Ten words or less: "I don't use Linux because..."
This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Desktop
This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by daveo2000
to Kirk's description of Spock's white robe condition in the "Save the Whales" Star Trek movie? ;\
-----------
Warning: innocuous geeky reference enclosed.
by apotheon
Maybe just a little.
Ssshhh, don't tell anyone.
by apotheon
"[i]receive banana.[/i]"
Bestest installation metaphor EVAR.
by j.g.camp
by jmgarvin
- set the OS market back at least a decade
- created a strange sort of xenophobia towards non-MS products (although this is dying away)
- is schizophrenic
- Confused the home market
- make home users believe that there was no such thing as security no matter what
- kludged up heterogenious IT shops
- limited user choice to such an extent that users are afraid of choice now...
by rkuhn040172
MS hasn't set the market back.
Linux is advancing it in some ways, Microsoft in others. Competition is good.
Xenophobia towards non-Microsoft products? Maybe in the OS and office world, but that is but one slice of the pie.
I have dozens of non-Microsoft products on my PC and I'm a strong MS supporter...like you needed to know that :)
The home market has always been confused, MS didn't achieve that one.
Security is a myth to a large extent. It is a never ending battle with no winner on either side. The only winner will be the day the battle is over which will never happen.
Users aren't afraid of choice, they just prefer simplicity. Some call it ignorance, others just say they have better things to do.
by daveo2000
Let's see if JM's points can be toned back a bit...
[i]- set the OS market back at least a decade[/i]
I quite agree with Rickk that competition is good. I think what JM might be alluding to is the major push that MS has had to kill Linux and quash the Open Source sector. What has amazed me is the resilience that open source community has had in the face of this.
Here is a related question I would like answered: MS posted the SMB spec such that the SAMBA crew could create the de facto Linux/Windows file server. MS only implemented a small portion of the mammoth spec and the SMB folks had to poke around to find the bits that worked. The created a great product. Then MS went and changed what parts of the spec they implemented (like they did with Lotus and DOS 5) until they broke SAMBA. Does anyone know if MS had a valid technical reason to change their implementation? (BTW, killing competing products is not a technical reason, it is a predatory reason.)
[i]- created a strange sort of xenophobia towards non-MS products (although this is dying away)[/i]
There is some logic behind this on the MS part. Since so much of any application is based on bits that become integrated in the OS, they can rightly claim that "non-compliant products" are dangerous to the users computer. The bit that seems unfair is that MS created this environment and then won't publicize the interface so the products can be more effective and compliant. The make it hard to get on the field and then complain that the products haven't joined the field. Now, as I understand it, to get an XP certified rating, a company is contractually prevented from developing for any other OS. What is up with that?
[i]- is schizophrenic[/i]
You got me with this one. I could probably make something up but... ;)
[i]- Confused the home market[/i]
To add to Rickk's comment, there was no home market before MS entered the game... unless you want to consider Apple. I don't really see a reason to at this point. The real culprit there could be IBM (the former evil giant). Any standard that came along, IBM would find a way to break. I mean, EBCDIC? What was the point?
[i]- make home users believe that there was no such thing as security no matter what[/i]
I have to side with JM here. Security is analog (by degrees) not digital (you have it or you don't). Anytime MS comes out with anything they seem to market it as if it never existed before. Any old school Unix junkie (can you say PDP-11?) or earlier can probably point to any MS tool and tell you the Unix daemon it was patterned after. What MS did was to add wizards and GUIs on top of them. I'll admit that I still cling to vi and shun emacs.
So now that people are screaming about the daily/weekly MS security alerts MS markets it like nobody ever had security until MS decided it was important.
I loved the line that Gates said some time ago "We want to make the computer experience as reliable, resilient and secure as the electric, water and telephone companies." What I thought was so incredibly ironic was the pairing (by order) of security with the phone! since phone conversations are only slightly more secure than talking in the subway.
[i]- kludged up heterogeneous IT shops[/i]
You avoided this one Rickk...
I remember having DEC, IBM, CDC and other hardware sitting comfortably under the same cooling system. We got our jobs done.
BUT! much of our job was in getting the systems to cooperate and exchange data. Now, if you work in big-mother IT shops you will probably only see Unix clones (Solaris, Linux, etc) and Windows. That has been a step forward since interoperability is now a piece of cake in most cases. MS, not being happy with that, is now trying to force their hand in the server market making things so Windows interdependent that, unless you really know what you are doing, you will lock yourself into a Windows only (or mainly) shop in short order. (I will let others explain this in better detail)
[i]- limited user choice to such an extent that users are afraid of choice now...[/i]
This can get back to the [b]xenophobia[/b] bit above. Although, in many cases, they aren't afraid, MS just takes advantage of "ignorance breeds laziness". If it works, why change it? Who cares (besides us!) if there are technologies 10 times better to play our music or browse the web? If it is bundled, they will use it. To heck with "fair competition"...
Good points Rickk.
" ... xenophobia towards non-MS products ... "
What xenophobia? Most corporate Windows users have Office, and this creates a preference for Office, but that isn't the same thing as a fear of other products. Most home users may have Office or Works, and maybe Money if it came preloaded, but they spend more money on non-MS games, entertainment apps, and online game and media services.
" ... schizophrenic"
Please elaborate.
"Confused the home market"
Again, please elaborate. What confusion are you referring to?
"make home users believe that there was no such thing as security ... "
Odd, I thought all their marketing was aimed at making home users believe MS products offered great security. Everytime they release a new OS or service pack they push improved security as one of the reasons to adopt it. Please note I am not saying the marketing verbage is true.
"limited user choice ... "
How? The web and the big box shelves are full of non-MS products.
MS is only competitive in the OS and office suite arenas. Yes, those are two huge markets, but they regularly fail to cut it in other areas. Money is second to Quicken. Nobody takes FrontPage seriously. They're dropping PowerPoint from the next version of Office. There are software areas where they aren't even entered: CAD and graphic arts leap to mind. In the online arena, their search engine lags behing Google and Yahoo and their IM use is way behind AOL.
MS is also beginning to suffer from a condition that afflicts many large companies: an inability to exploit new technologies at a competitive speed.
by jmgarvin
by rkuhn040172
But no place for it on TR.
Go push your product somewhere else.
I missed the announcement by TR when they hired you to police the forums.
You'll like Louisville, although it's a shame you missed Derby Week. Do you plan on living in town or on the Indiana side of the river?
by daveo2000
When I first had to start using Windows at the office (years ago) I had been working with a Sparc 10 on my desktop (Those were the days :D ). One thing that caught me by surprise was this: I started up three desktop clocks and set the time zones (NY, London and Tokyo) and different colors and I was happy. Sometime later (for whatever reason) I rebooted. When it started back up, I had three clocks, all the same color and time zone as the last one I had set up :0 . Windows was designed and built on a conceptual island. There is only one of anything and the rest of the world doesn't exist. For many apps this works. For me it didn't. I ended up installing eXceed and X-displaying 3 clocks back to my Windows root window. :)
Let's take mcfreak's request a bit further. I want BOTH Apache 1.3 AND 2.0 because I have to upgrade my website and need to run both to verify functionality. Actually, you might be able to do that with Apache, I'm not sure. But how many Windows apps can you have more than one version of installed concurrently? [b]Easily[/b]? ;\
by daveo2000
many of these discussions come down to specific cases. And we can all provide anecdotal evidence for any position on just about any platform. (Although I have yet to hear anyone sticking up for CP/M for a production application.)
Once Linux has a standardized desktop (finally there has been an agreement :) ) and when vendors are free to provide the same software to both MS and Linux (without OS provider interference) we will have a chance to make real comparisons on a lot more choices.
For now, can somebody reply on installing OpenOffice 2.0 on multiple platforms?
by nighthawk808
I know, I know: Wine and/or Cedega. :)
This post is just a test to see if anyone ever scrolls down this far in a discussion.
by dawgit
by jmgarvin
by nighthawk808
I need those programs for work. I'm the official company idiot (actually, my proper job title is Sysadmin's Worst Nightmare), and it's my job to open up every attachment that ever comes in my inbox. Why is it that whenever I tell the IT guys that my employee number is id-10-t they laugh at me?
Times are tough, so I took a part-time job clicking on links in emails from PayPal and banks I don't have an account with and then filling in my Social Security Number, credit card number, and PIN.
I might be able to get out of this business altogether pretty soon. This nice foreign minister from Nigeria says that he's going to split $300 million with me just for helping him get the money out of the bank.
This post needs a disclaimer:
WARNING: The Surgeon General has declared this post unsafe for the humor-deficient and/or extremely gullible. Read at your own risk. The author disclaims all liability for aneurism, apoplexy, extreme bewilderment, or you looking like a fool after you took it seriously and responded with a semi-illiterate flame to said author. By reading the above post you have agreed to these terms. Have a good day.
by nighthawk808
by nighthawk808
And as a token of my appreciation, here's a little gift:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=195075&messageID=2019685
by jmgarvin
- set the OS market back at least a decade
I'm not saying their shouldn't be competion in the market. I'm saying the exact opposite. MS actively tries to kill any subsitute to their product(s). They take the stance of a Monopoly and to a large part succeed in this. What really bothers me is that they absorb superior technology and sit on it for YEARS.
- created a strange sort of xenophobia towards non-MS products (although this is dying away)
When I said this I was thinking of "signed" drivers. In essence MS won't sign a driver unless you only create MS drivers. Not only is this not fair, but it kills competition. Luckly the Open Source community has stood up to this, but at some point the vendors will HAVE to get on board.
- is schizophrenic
Here is my point. MS opens an Open Source lab, but continues to state that open source is secure and will destroy the world as we know it, maybe worse. They also don't know where they stand with security. They talk about fast 0 day patching and then they don't release the patch for IE until a month later. Which is it?
They also have some other huge issues in the way they "simplify" the market. So now I have 7 different Vista "flavors" to choose from, but there is no clear difference in 4 of them. This isn't simple, this is crazy!
- Confused the home market
I won't disagree that MS has driven the home market to where it is now, but recently they've started to make it...odd. With Windows XP Media, Windows XP Home, and Windows XP Pro, the home user doesn't understand where they need to be. They also have release things like Windows Defender with little explanation and little fanfair. Having delt with home users, they can't understand what they need and don't need from MS.
- make home users believe that there was no such thing as security no matter what
I think daveo2000 said it better than I could...so I'll leave you with this thought...Security, like an orge, is like an onion...lots of layers and tastes good on burgers.
- kludged up heterogeneous IT shops
No doubt in my mind this is clear. If you use multiple OSs, you know what I'm talking about. MS has not made it easy to intgrate your stuff together.
- limited user choice to such an extent that users are afraid of choice now...
daveo2000 hit the nail on the head. I guess users aren't so much afraid of choice, but are too lazy to find out that winamp is better than Windows Media Player. This is bothersome and a little on on MSs part. You'd think they'd want to push complements to their product....
by daveo2000
I work at a big freaking bank. I have worked at a couple of big freaking banks. I have also worked at some hedge funds and other money management firms. All of them have their persistent storage (database, source control, etc) on Solaris or Linux platforms. Most of them have transient functions (ETL, EII, web servers, etc) on Windows or Linux. Nearly all of the desk tops have Windows.
Persistent storage is boring so that runs on boring equipment... Solaris/Linux with no pretty GUI. All it does it work, no play. ;\
by nz_justice
by apotheon
. . . and dead freakin' easy.
On this system, all I'd have to do to install both is enter the following at the command line:
[i]apt-get install apache apache2[/i]
This installs both the apache package (for Apache 1.3.34) and the apache2 package (for Apache 2.0.55), along with all dependencies. The two packages do not conflict, and two separate http daemons can be run simultaneously.
by jaqui
it's the configurations that really make it hard with apache, you have to build it with version specific config locations to avoid conflicts.
the standard /etc/httpd/conf location will be a problem with multiple versions installed. You would have to pass a with-conf-dir= option to the config during the build process.
or, for simplicity sake, edit the init script for starting each version and use the -f option to specify the version specific config file.
you may also want to use the -d option to have a different default serverroot for the versions.
by editing the inittab for httpd, and making a version specific you can have both versions start at boot, without having to pass the -f or -d options through apachectl to start it.
by daveo2000
Thanks. That is good to know for future reference.
Can you do that with IIS, Word or many other MS packages too?
I will admit that I don't know the answer since I have never personally used a Windows system for serious development (other than as an X-terminal and mail manager). I [i]have[/i] heard some serious Windows developers lament the inability to have multiple versions of certain software on the system and definitely hate it when some new installs overwrite DLLs required for other software.
BTW, Jaqui, I have no problem with multiple packages in most cases on Unix-like platforms. A long time ago I wrote a run-time "package" manager that just uses environment variables to specify paths. That way you can use the modified command line to transparently load up the ENV vars you need. I patterned it after a couple of systems I had seen at places I have worked.
by apotheon
I've never tried to install a single piece of MS software (whether multiple versions or the same version) more than once simultaneously on the same system. I tend to suspect it's at least heinously difficult, if not effectively impossible, though.
I have tried installing multiple versions of non-MS closed source software on Windows in the past, though. Generally, the more commercial and closed it is, the more difficult it is to install multiple instances. That's part of the reason I suspect it's quite difficult to install multiple instances of IIS, for example, on the same Windows system. In fact, it's probably easier to install multiple instances of the same piece of MS software on the same system if you're using Wine than using Windows.
by apotheon
by daveo2000
Thanks! Useful info.
I ask not because I do this in my own work but because I don't like to be victim of incorrect information. I think part of what I am thinking of might be related to DLLs. I have worked with some serious MS-heads that have complained when developing DLLs that end up in the system32 directory. Either that or apps that required a certain version of a system32 DLL and the app stopped working when a new app installed an updated DLL.
This might be related to some header info in the file that many developers don't fill in so apps can't figure out which version to use (or something like that). Sound familar?
Edited to add "Thanks"
That's why I was careful to say "some programs" (or something like that). I was shocked it worked with Access, an application nortorious for backwards incompatability of data, but apparently not of .DLLs
All files required for an application should be kept in the same directory as the .EXE. I should post that on the "I wish Microsoft would ... " discussion.
by rkuhn040172
I would assume most people are running multiple versions for mostly testing purposes.
Ideal scenario for a virtual PC. VMware, MS Virtual PC, or the now free MS Virtual Server.
by daveo2000
If you need to test with multiple versions, that might require multiple versions of DLLs. Would the virtual server allow for different contents of a system32 directory without requiring multiple OS licenses?
If this seems like a dense question it may be because I didn't express it well enough.
by barrymiller
by apotheon
by jmgarvin
by dawgit
by rkuhn040172
That sounds enormous.
I wish I had that much $.
by daveo2000
by jmgarvin
There really ARE users like "you."
'Course it gave me the giggles anyway...
by rkuhn040172
They all used to cost $.
Then, various Linux flavors came out costing nothing.
Then VMware came out with a freebie.
Microsoft then followed.
That is how the market works. Has nothing to do with licenses as much as it does have to do with Microsoft facing the facts and reality that everyone else was starting to give it away for free.
by apotheon
by jmgarvin
It's a bag to carrry around variables and objects! What's even better is that for a slight increase in yearly fees you can get the "double bagger!"
REAL VALUE...ALWAYS!
by rkuhn040172
I thought the term "double bagger" was reserved for that ugly chick who was so ugly one bag wasn't enough. Double it up just in case.
I learn something new every day.
by rkuhn040172
I had it good.
My wife must be playing games with me. After years and years of marriage, I thought I had accomplished quite a bit when I finely filled that zip lock baggy.
There's something bigger?
Damn, and I've settled for a zip lock.
You have to admit that there is something sick and wrong when married and double your salary and you still have less...
I'm driving the 6 year old car and she has the brand new one.
by worm22
actually, I do but ... when I use winbloze:
"the cool games are for windows."
by arleenw
by jmgarvin
Man, how lucky you are! I can only wish to get an email like that!
I'd respond ASAP with my bank account number, routing number, PIN, and perhaps even my mother's maiden name! What a lucky guy you are...
*Disclaimer: For those not in the know, this is sarcasm. If you do any of this, you are not only an idiot, but you deserve what you get. Greed is one of the 7 deadly sins!
by apotheon
by deepsand
Or, am I thinking of Linus? I do get so confused at times.
Let's see now. Black & white beagle, black & white bird, ... Nope, that's not working.
Hey, how 'bout a little help here.
by rkuhn040172
You just can't refrain yourself can you?
My record is clear. Your comments don't hold water. Show me one system on my network, home or work, that have been attacked in the last xx number of years and you might have a point.
Case closed.
by hal 9000
[b]Successfully Attacked[/b] as honestly anytime that one of your AV Products picks up a Virus Trojan worm that is an [b]Attack[/b] just not a Successful one.
Also we would need access to every Log of any Mal Ware Programs that you run to make sure that you've never had a single case of one instance of Spy Ware/Mal Ware as if you have had just one that is a [b]Successful Attack.[/b]
Col ]:)
by rkuhn040172
Your definition of successful attack vs attack.
However, not all malware attacks are serious attacks.
By serious, I mean financial loss, intellectual property stolen, system compromised, etc.
Sure, we all get malware from time to time. Most of which isn't a serious, successful attack.
by apotheon
You keep trying to change the rules every time it looks like you're going to lose a point, rickk. Keep at it. It hasn't worked yet, but it might some day.
(insanity (n.): a state of mind whereby one keeps performing the same action in the same circumstances with an expectation of different results)
We haven't [b]all[/b] had malware infections. Some of us choose our software wisely.
by apotheon
Pretty much everyone here knows you're the canonical example of the Microsoft cultist.
Anyway, I think the word you sought was "restrain", not "refrain".
by pkr9
would be to know how many hits your firewall catches?
Mine at home - private - took one a second after we by mistake installed XP from a CD on a PC with a live ADSL connection.
Now, after switching IP adress a couple of times, we are down to a regular 5-6 a minute.
At work it is a lot more, several a second, and this takes care of what hits us from the outside. We are still - as every other Windows users - very vulnerable to what hits us from inside the firewall.
by rkuhn040172
But again, if my AV, anti-malware, or firewall catches something, I really didn't get it in the first place did I?
Windows is very insecure comparatively speaking. But with the proper infrastructure surrounding it, it can be quite secure...that was my point.
Any program or OS is insecure if not properly setup, maintained, monitored, etc.
Windows may take a bit more support to keep it secure, but it can be made secure. In my environment, the benefits of running MS outweigh the additional costs of making it secure.
For others, the benefits of MS don't outweigh the additional costs of making it secure. They use Linux or MAC or whatever.
by hal 9000
I can no longer play any Herby DVDs as I keep getting a Virus Alert and it stops the movie telling me that there is a [b]Love Bug[/b] Virus on the DVD. So if I want to watch any of my [b]Love Bug Herbie[/b] movies I have to use Nix to do it because it isn't affected by the Love Bug Virus. :^0
Col ]:)
by nighthawk808
In my profile, I've had the answer to question of the importance of access to the source for a while now. To Apotheontificate (IOW, to quote myself shamelessly :) ):
"An interesting piece of trivia: I am the only person I know who beat Rogue the first time they played it. Ask me how. Or, if you noticed the fact from above that I'm a C programmer, you have probably figured it out already. (Open Source isn't just a beautiful idea, it's a useful one, too!)"
Now, all you "I can't play any good games on Linux" people: let's see you do that with Sims 2/WoW/Oblivion/[insert favorite "Windows-only" game here]!
It's amazing what a difference one character can make. Out of thousands of lines of code, all it took was a change from "rogue.hp_current -= d;" to "rogue.hp_current += d;" and I started looking FORWARD to running into dragons. There's nothing like seeing a status line that contains "Hp: 147(42)". And there you have the power of OSS.
And that's also why I don't trust a closed-source Diebold voting machine any further than I can throw it. The same goes for Vista's new DRM "enhancements".
"Of course your vote counted!"
"Of course no information about the CD's you play is collected and sent to the RIAA!"
"What do you mean you want to see the source? We would never do anything unethical!* Trust us--we would never lie to you...."
*Offer not valid in the US, Canada, or countries whose names contain a vowel. See your participating dealer for details.
by ken coe
There are advantages for every OS. I have had many clients which I would not point to Linux. There are arguments against it in many cases, but software and equipment costs are solidly in Linux' corner.
Fair and realistic would be remembering that the OS installed in the box isn't free, and neither are the additional hardware requirements. It would also consider TCO.
A better point may have been the cost of re-training end users, or a learning curve example of sorts. Thankfully (for the people trying to train), that argument won't be around for long either.
With regards to the argument, there are a few points that are not really correct. Here are some specifics.
A manufacturer does not give you all of that software for free, and almost all of them will leave it out by request. That will cut the cost of the system by a fair margin.
There is also the issue of hardware cost. Linux needs much less resources available for equal performance. That obviously cuts the cost more.
There is the cost of maintenance time. I know that someone mentioned that Linux isn't good without broadband, but I do point out that any given XP system will spend just as much time doing downloads. Did you ever download SP2 with a dialup account? Linux does more frequent updates, but smaller ones. It is a fair balance between the two there.
There is also the cost of downtime, but that depends on the quality of software you pick, and your ability, so I won't brag about Linux there.
Finally, in a commercial (especially enterprise) setting, there is the consideration of Admin time, and Uptime. You need better Admins, but they can monitor and maintain more boxes in less time, with a much broader scope for customization. Uptime is amazing in Linux. I have servers that are only rebooted when upgrading Kernals, and my home systems are rebooted every six months when I clean and check them.
by craiglarry9
by craiglarry9
by apotheon
I avoid using Windows because, once I get something working, I prefer that it keep working instead of randomly crapping out on me at irregular intervals, or entirely blowing up in my face one day while in the midst of completing a huge project that will pay my rent for two months.
The only reason I ever use Windows these days is to get paid. Luckily, I get paid more for my Linux work -- and that's work I'd do for free, for myself, if nobody else wanted to pay me to do it for them.
by apotheon
by hal 9000
After what other platform would you claim that VB is a easier & More Powerful Programing Language. It's got to be Windows.
Col
by deesy58
by crake
I like malware.
by rkuhn040172
Business Opportunity:
1) Setup Windows PC exposed to the Internet for 5 minutes unprotected
2) Proceed to nearest gentlemen's club with Windows PC
3) Setup as kiosk and charge per minute for porn between dances, sell watches, Nigerian investments, and medicines such as Viagra.
4) Or, alternatively, don't charge per minute and charge per click...there will be plenty of popup windows to choose from
by hal 9000
The latest medicines that they are pushing [b]Cures Everything.[/b] :0
Well at least that's the headings that I see I don't bother with the rest of the junk I just delete it off customers computers and get paid to do it.
Male Ware is Great from a Techs point of view I get paid to remove it so why should I want something that doesn't attract so much of it. It's probably because I'm getting sick and tired of doing it on a weekly basis and feeling like nothing better than a [b]Trained Monkey.[/b] :(
Col ]:)
by terp66
by nighthawk808
Linux is the kernel. Everything else around it combines into the set of supporting applications that makes for an OS. I hope I didn't come off the wrong way by pointing that out to you, because I'm not trying to be a jerk about things. However, there are a whole lot of people--many Linux users included--that don't know that.
What applications can't you find? There are plenty of the kind that you mention that I know of that do exactly what you say can't be done. Let us know and we'll be happy to give you suggestions.
by apotheon
by deesy58
by nighthawk808
I have a liver. That doesn't make me a liver. Without it, I wouldn't be able to survive. Without everything else that combines to make me a human, the liver is useless.
You can use the Linux kernel without using a window manager or a web browser. Try doing that with Windows. That's a difference between an operating system and a kernel.
My SuSE uses a different version number of the Linux kernel than Debian does. Debian uses a different version than Ubuntu does. Red Hat uses a different version than... you get the point. They all combine their kernel with a bunch of other different programs to build an operating system.
by apotheon
by hal 9000
Being the only [b]True Programing Language[/b] because the people from MS Said So it must be the best and it doesn't play nice on a Nix Install because it's such a lousy language it doesn't work on a [b]Real[/b] OS. :^0
That just brought back memories of one MS Road Show where a old C Coder who had not touched C for about 12 years was expounding the massive benefits of VB because he picked it up in 20 minutes and was writing code for Macro's. Now that is Programing isn't it? But unfortunately because someone thinks that they can write a query in VB for Excel that makes them a [b]Programmer[/b] not a qualified end user. :0
Got the idea now? :D
Col ]:)
by ffjkgggdftdt
by apotheon
It's not as bad as the picture you paint, but it's true that intellectual protectionism (some people call it "intellectual property" for some reason) laws can get in the way of convenient enjoyment of the multimedia entertainment for which you paid your hard-earned money. While I, personally, am willing to go to the extra effort when necessary, I can understand someone wanting to maintain a Windows or Mac machine for purposes of multimedia entertainment.
I still think you'd be better off biting the bullet and learning something about your computer rather than relying on monopolists, though.
I need things to "just work" and got tired of wasting time getting things running and keeping them running. I first used Linux in 1993 when it was at version 0.99 and was a Linux evengelist inside Sybase, so I am neither a new user nor naive about linux. But as an independent developer with a laptop as my main development machine there simply is no comparison between Mac OS X as a Unix development environment and constantly fiddling with this that or the other ( read - sound, power managment, firewire ... ) on Linux laptops.
As Jamie Zawinsky said "Linux is free only if your time has no value".
I write open source software and suppor the cause so this is not a philosophical issue - Linux on the laptop is not agood enough value proposition for me.
For a server, I'd still use linux.
by andy
I have only clunker of an HP laptop, according to the little sticker I just ripped off the case it was "made for Windows Me" poor little bugger.
Anyways, it doesnt have wifi or even a built in NIC so one of the big factors of which distro I use is hardware recognition. Download a bunch of Live CD's, try em, and whichever one picks up most of your hardware, install.
To my surprise the best recognition to date hasn't been Ubuntu, or Red Hat or Fedora or even Suse but PCLinuxOS.
Linspire picked it up too but I found it a mite slow.
So just because one disty dont cut it, try another. Not only do you get to experience a whole bunch of new installs, GUI's and desktops but, in my case, I ended up with a laptop faster than the day it came off the production line.
Stick with it, there's nothing wrong with MS and I have nothing against their products but the times they are a changing. And being Linux savvy will never harm your career.
by skategeezer
Linux is behide the curve.
Windows dominates desktops allways will.........
by nighthawk808
We're still way behind on implementing easy-to-use rootkit API's. Until Linux is as easy to crack as Windows, it will never be as popular.
As for your second, err, sentence(?), say hello to my little friend cluebat:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=195075&messageID=2022533
by apotheon
Wow, I should run right out and spend $300 on a retail copy of Windows XP quick, and buy Vista the moment it comes out, based on that guy's recommendation! Linux is incomplete! Woah! There's no defense against such stunning logic.
I guess he figures that if he makes unsupported statements, he doesn't have to worry about someone pointing out how his logic is flawed. You won't get accused of using flawed logic if you don't use any logic at all, after all.
by notetaker
by jonjon1946
by deesy58
by apotheon
An OS needs at least the following:
hardware interface
application interface
human interface
filesystem
memory allocation
process management
The Linux kernel provides some hardware interface, and a way to link in more hardware interface. It provides an application interface. It provides memory allocation and process management. It does not provide a human interface or a filesystem. If you add these two things, you've got something approaching an operating system.
There's probably more that's needed to qualify as a proper OS, but nothing comes immediately to mind. In particular, you'd notice a lack of a human interface, because you [b]wouldn't be able to use the damned computer[/b]. The human interface does not necessarily need to be a window manager or other GUI environment, but it needs [b]something[/b]. For instance, old proprietary UNIX systems like the original AT&T UNIX, and OSes like OS/370 both had command shells, roughly equivalent in purpose to bash, the most commonly used shell on Linux -- bash is part of the human interface of many Linux-based OSes, but not part of Linux (the kernel) itself.
See? No analogies, and you're still wrong.
by deesy58
You're a little sensitive about analogies, aren't you? Especially since my comments weren't directed at you. Unless ... you've got multiple screen names you're posting under ...
So, a computer can't have an Operating System unless it has a human interface and a file system? What about embedded systems? How about the real-time operating systems used by the military, or to operate machines like automobiles? Have you never seen a microcomputer system with a real-time OS that had no file system and no human interface? I have. Whether or not a computer is usable is a function of its designed purpose, isn't it? No matter how broadly or narrowly we define an OS, it still isn't a programming language!
by robax
I don't use Linux
..because I don't need to.
..because I do my work with applications not Operating Systems
..because my OS choice is motivated by purpose and function, not ideology.
..because I don't buy into fud nor hype.
..because OSX would be the second choice.
..because I don't need Apache.
..because I have a job with performance measures.
..because my social conscience is where it belongs.. with real people in real need.
..because I can afford to choose my applications and not worry about their purchase price.
..because I don't have a 'box'.
..because my cpu is more powerful than a 386.
..because I need to learn another OS like I need to pick up z80 machine language.
..because I have better things to do with my life.
..because I have tasks, hobbies and interests other than playing with operating systems.
..and because I'd like to get on them them now.
On a side note.. I have thrice over 9 years attempted to install and use Linux. Each effort ended up in a wasted day and reaffirmed all of the above reasons.
Open source is a great method for creating software. It is not a method for creating great software. A narrow mind will confuse these things.
by apotheon
I don't use Windows . . .
because I don't need to.
because I don't want my work to vanish because of my Operating System.
because my OS choice is motivated by purpose and function, not marketing.
because I don't buy into fud or hype.
because OSX would be the second choice.
because I don't need IIS.
because I have a job where performance matters.
because my social conscience is where it belongs: with real people in real need.
because I can afford to choose my applications and not worry about their corporate acceptability.
because I don't have a "PC" -- I know what they're really called.
because my cpu is more powerful than a 386, and I don't want it to [i]act like[/i] a 386 under the weight of Redmond.
because I need to learn another OS every time Microsoft decides it wants more money like I need to pick up z80 machine language.
because I have better things to do with my life than fix mysterious magical Windows problems and chase malware.
because I have tasks, hobbies and interests other than keeping abreast of the latest bugs introduced by Windows Update.
(I decided to leave "and because I'd like to get on them them now" alone because it doesn't make any sense.)
by jamas
by jmgarvin
"..because I don't need to."
This is a poor reason not to use anything. Being a techy means you SHOULD want to explore new and exciting technology.
"..because I do my work with applications not Operating Systems"
WTF does this mean? Of course you do work with applications. Your OS should be hidden and you should NEVER see it. Windows breaks this rule constantly.
"..because my OS choice is motivated by purpose and function, not ideology."
You have a strange idea of purpose and function then.
"..because I don't buy into fud nor hype."
HA! Sure you don't...If you didn't you'd at least understand some of the basic concept of Linux.
"..because OSX would be the second choice."
Sure, why not...
"..because I don't need Apache."
Why not? No need for a web server? If you use IIS you have just introduced a serious attack vector.
"..because I have a job with performance measures."
They must not measure very well because *nix typically out performs Windows in almost all server tasks*
* I'd mention AD here, but honestly, we've been over this...
"..because my social conscience is where it belongs.. with real people in real need."
No it isn't. It is in MS's pocket. If you wanted to support need, you'd look into various technologies and not just one.
"..because I can afford to choose my applications and not worry about their purchase price."
Uh, ok...good for you...
"..because I don't have a 'box'."
Uh...ok....sure....
"..because my cpu is more powerful than a 386."
But grinds down to the performance of one when Windows "forgets" to release resources.
"..because I need to learn another OS like I need to pick up z80 machine language."
Uh..."another" OS. How many OSs do you have to maintain...sounds like just one. You don't want to double your knowledge?
"..because I have better things to do with my life."
Like looking into freaky Windows issues and fighting with malware?
"..because I have tasks, hobbies and interests other than playing with operating systems."
Welcome to my life...That's why I use Linux...So I don't have to mess with it...
"..and because I'd like to get on them them now."
HUH!!?? What the deuce does that mean?
"On a side note.. I have thrice over 9 years attempted to install and use Linux. Each effort ended up in a wasted day and reaffirmed all of the above reasons."
Then your technological compentencies suck. If you can't click next to install Linux, I'll be taking your job (or possibly even firing you) soon.
Honestly, why do people say it is hard to install Linux?
"Open source is a great method for creating software. It is not a method for creating great software. A narrow mind will confuse these things."
What are you going on about? Are you saying not all open source software is good? Well, DUH!! Just like not all closed source software is good...the difference is I can modify crappy open source stuff and make it good.
by rkuhn040172
Even I have to agree with you here.
People like that damage the credibility of both the Windows and Linux worlds.
by jmgarvin
No. An OS is USELESS without a file system and human interface. Even embedded system have this (to a very limited extent).
Real-time operating systems are nothing more than REAL TIME operating systems...They still have a user interface and a file system (although the defintion of file system can be loose here, depending on what kind of real-time system you are talking about)
If you saw an OS without a human interface, you saw a human interface. How do you modify, program, allocate resources, write drivers for, et al without a human interface? At some point there has to be an interface for the user....
I tend to think you think human interface = GUI...
Jeez, what is going on on TR? These posts from IT "managers" are so wanna be pendantic it's getting silly...
Sort by Trending