Discussion Locked

Unionize IT Now!

0 helpful
725 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post

725 replies

by cactus pete

The additional costs, back when unins merely fought for safe and reasonable working conditions, were passed on to the consumers back then, too.

But we don't consider that shooting one's self in the foot.

The difference is to what degree is reasonable for the company to use it's employees for profit before use becomes abuse.

At the moment, I lean towards companies are using employees (which is OK) and unions are looking for a way to rationalize their continued existence.

I beleive that, with current laws in place, MOST unions are no longer neccesary.

It's OK to disagree with me. It is not OK to make rude comments towards my position simply because of the disagreement. (Those of you to whom this comment was directed know who you are.)

by cactus pete

Not back when I bought mine. NOW, yes, you can buy american-made hybrids. The technology and parts might not all be from the US, but the workers who performed the final assembly might be here...

But that's my point.

(And the saddest part is, the technology isn't from here.)

by cactus pete

I just searched postings within the lat 30 days within 30 miles of Boise.

I see no LAN techs asked for for $12/hr. (I had my suspicions earlier...)

I do see some posts for positions around that wage rate, but they are for sales and data entry, etc.

So, let's all try to imagine a data entry clerk making $50/hr...

by cactus pete

Squaredge:

I'd like to see a reference for this want ad to which you refer.

Oh, and maybe a little feedback to the thread you started.

With other posts to other threads at this caliber:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11179-0.html?forumID=7&threadID=184209&messageID=1893436

and

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11189-0.html?forumID=3&threadID=183755&messageID=1893683

This person needs to calm down, and get a little better education himself. A college degree just to be promoted? Hell, I want the best person working for me, not just the one with the highest level of post graduate education.

And how does this guy think that ICQ is the standard for telecommuting?

I think you're lacking, that's why you're not getting the good jobs. Degree and certs or not - if you can't do the job, you won't get promoted and you won't get a better job elsewhere.

You think unionizing will help you? Then you think the poorest stereotype of unions is the best you can attain.

Sad.

by ontheropes

I generally don't agree with your particular position in this discussion but your remark, "this person needs to calm down, and get a little better education himself," is pretty good.

Having an education doesn't make people intelligent though. Being taught something doesn't mean you learn it.
I think it's sad too that most of the people writing responses in this discussion might not be able to write coherent, pertinent inter-office memos.

"What'd you say about my grammar? You haven't even met my grammar!"

by apotheon

I didn't see anything that said we can't do anything to help the situation. I just saw a pretty clear-headed explanantion for how/why unionizing isn't the answer. Stop putting words in people's mouths.

The mixed economy of the US is seriously broken. Corporate welfare, arbitrary regulation, and economy management are screwing up the efficiencies of the market economy.

by boogaloodude

I speak as one who is not a member of a union, but I have more then a few friends that are. You sound like someone who just warped back to the 30's when the unions were getting a bad rap out east, and in Chicago when the only negotiating tool they used was a Baseball Bat. Yeah the Unions have large Bank Accounts, but if you look at how it's spent I think you'll see that there are no Multi-Million dollar CEO's running off with the funds, there's no Insider trading of the funds, leaving the vested employees with no Retirement Funds, and unlike your Insurance Company and your local Church, they're not Building Outrageously Huge Buidings to impress the community at large, you will however find that all the retirees will have a healthy Retirement fund that is in no danger of running out like our Social Security systems funds are predicted to do in the not to distant future (because they have GOBS of money), and you'll see that they cover there members Health Insurance until the day they die. I have to hand it to (some of) them, they do take care of there own. Sure, you've got Major Corporations like GM and Ford who can hire the best of the best Attorney's and move there plants to Mexico to build Weapons of Mass Destruction, but for the most part, and Particularly in the Service Industry, the Unions have done a great job in looking out for the members and there Families, Just the way that Abraham Lincoln wanted it. Yeah, old Abe was a backer of the Unions, AND HE WAS A REPUBLICAN!! Read your history and I think you'll see that on paper Unions aren't as bad as they are made out to be, they just got a bad rap when the Mob decided to get involved, and that's like saying that all Harley Riders are Hells Angels, and we both know that's not true, but there are those who decide on thier own, without actually looking up the facts, and believe me I've been reading a lot of statements in this Thread by people who know nothing more about Unions then they do about rebuilding, from the ground up, a 426 HEMI, although if it came down to it, I'm sure that there are a couple of know-it-alls who will put thier 2 cents in about how that should be done, with no actual knowledge of Internal Combustion Engines. Point is, why even discuss this without someone involved that has an actual working knowledge of what benefits Unions Have or Don't Have to offer, Have any of you actually been involved in one? and if so for how long, in what position, and which Union?

by apotheon

I'm not going to read that entire post. It's one huge block of text, not broken up by subtopic, almost unreadable. I have better things to do than struggle through that alphabet soup.

Judging by the first few lines, though, I think I get the gist of it.

In the early days of unions, they were not businesses of their own. The people who ran them may have had some power, but that power arose because they were leading people who were part of the decision-making process. Nobody had to be in a union that didn't want to be. People didn't have to pay dues to be able to get a job in a given industry.

Things have changed. Unions are not what they once were, and the law ensures that they will never again be what they once were. Where once they were nearly spontaneous consolidations of individuals with common cause into organizations to solve their problems, now they're bureaucratic organizations whose administrators are concerned with their own lucrative careers as union bosses rather than with making life any better for union members.

You're the one stuck in the past.

by noyoki

> "Read your history and I think you'll see that on paper Unions aren't as bad as they are made out to be"

Communism works on paper too!

by ontheropes

You... assume too much. Have you ever heard of an expense account/contract/reimbursement?
What do YOU say is the median income and median satisfaction level of the IT employes in India in Rupees/USD in comparison to the US poverty levels?
What are your references? (Data/Surveys)
Have you ever been to India, are you from India or are you just "onbliss"?

by heml0ck

I'm afraid you can't use the auto industry's unions as the scapegoats for the fall of the big three.
Lack of foresight, corporate arrogance towards customer loyalty, a corporate culture which stifles change (read: improvement), these are the factors which led to the fall of GM, not the people actually amking the product.
Dollar for dollar, American and Japanese work make about the same, when you consider cost of living and benefits. The difference is that the Japanese auto makers have invested in their own companies by: 1)streamlined production processes which DON'T involve layoffs,2) demanding quality from their suppliers and helping them achieve their quality goals, 3)using a 'stop the line' mentality to empower the workers to take ownership of their processes and ensure quality is built into the car.
It isn't the UNIONS that won't allow that sort of corporate culture, it is the MANAGEMENT!

by ontheropes

The Big 3's problems began after US legislation began to favor foreign competition rather than the American worker. In theory, you could sell an American-made auto in Japan. If you were Japanese and bought one, the Japanese government performed a complete audit of all of your finances so they quit buying them. The Japanese were/are free to purchase American companies/real estate. Do you or anyone know of ANY American company that has bought and succeeded with the purchase of a Japanese company. The largest investment firms in America can barely afford to keep a Japanese golf club membership on Japanese soil.

In the 90's, Japan business leaders held weekly meetings on how to manage the American economy. They quit doing that because the trade defecit made it much easier for them to profit from buying American companies.
I have seen Japanese investment groups buy US patent rights (innovation) and then never attempt to produce the product simply to prevent competition by a US company.
The Japanese Keiritsu business model allows them to profit by "dumping" products in the US. (Sell them for less than what it costs to produce them.) "Dumping" is and has been illegal for American companies. American companies struggle to compete for product cost when US legislation makes it illegal and allows the vast trade deficits to continue unabated.

Corporations are responsible to their shareholders to produce profit. If an American owned manufacturing Corporation is still running profitably in the face of all the US legislation favoring foreign trade I think that management might just be doing the right things. I do wonder who the share-holders are though.

by peter warren

Thanks for your comments and thank heaven there are others who see the route cause of our economic decline. While so many are busy blaming unions and workers, and mindlessly repeating mantras about the sanctity of "free" markets, it's refreshing to see responsibility put where it belongs: on the same corporate shortsightedness that has ruined both steel and autos, and which now is destroying the information industry in the US.

The truth is, if our markets were truly free, we'd be able to build a sounder, saner, more socially responsible economy. But as long as corporate payoffs buy our legislators and presidents, we're destined to decline. Why can't more of you see this? We have the power to improve ourselves both individually and collectively.

by jamesrl

A few years back I was laid off, and I did some contracting work while looking for permanent work. One agency had got me a good interview but the job had been put on hold. They knew I had been contracting at $40 an hour - the market in our area was pretty soft.

I asked them for an update and it wasn't looking good. I aked them if they had anything else happening. They told me they had a short contract and needed people, but it probably wouldn't pay enough - $25 an hour. I told them that if it paid more than unemployment and since I didn't have anything else lined up, I would take it. They were happy, I was happy, I made new friends and contacts - it was a very positive experience.

Always better to be working than sitting at home.

James

by ontheropes

It's not just the IT industry. In the early 90's there were many jobs that paid more than what those same jobs pay today. Relatively speaking the early 60's were actually better times for the working man. One person working per household could afford to buy a house, a new car, raise and educate their children and invest for their retirement.
There aren't a lot of jobs today where one person is able to do all of that successfully. There are very few American companies that can afford to be loyal to their employees when they face such stiff competition from the work that is allowed to be offshored. Workers Unions aren't going to solve the problems that the US Legislators have allowed and, in fact, created.
I live in the heart of Union country and don't know of any American owned Union plant that isn't struggling to survive.
Business is war. When the US began to have a trade defecit with foreign countries, like Japan, it has allowed those countries to prosper at US expense. Japan received over $1B per day from the US in the early 80's. Japanese nationals now own 95% of the real estate in Hawaii.China gets much more than $1B today. Since NAFTA and Chinas elevated trade status foreign nationals have bought over $3T of US real estate. Unions aren't the answer. Education and immediate legislation are but it's probably too late. You want fries with that?

by absolutely

cut taxes, and the foolish pet projects in earmarks sent to every single district. Because some of those corrupt projects go to your district does not mean that your district [b]benefits[/b] from earmarks. The waste is spread across all 50 states, keeping taxes unnecessarily high across all 50 states, preventing more private, productive, [b]proven[/b] competent employers from employing more.

End all earmarks & support Senator Tom Coburn.

by scifiman

Certainly, some types of IT jobs can be outsourced, whether overseas or some other state. But I consider most of IT to be hardware related. When Betty in accounting can't print invoices, she isn't going to sit on the phone troubleshooting with India. She needs a onsite body to fix the problem. Can India swap out a bad video card. Swap drives in a server? Pull a cable? Go up on the roof and realign the Hughes VSAT dish? No, outsourcing sounds scary, but it doesn't bother me. But then, I'm not a maint. programer. Seems to me that half the companies that try outsourcing come back inhouse when the contract expires, if not sooner.

by absolutely

If free-market $12 wages are elevated to $50 by unions, the whole brick & mortar operation will go someplace where workers are reasonable.

by alexp023

Adding to that, do you think every small company is going overseas for their IT work. Consider that each small company needs IT work, but can't afford a full time "Consultant". How about a part-time consultant and the consultant finds a few small companies. Isn't that what Accountants and Lawyers do in the private sector.

You're working for one large company that has many Consultants and you're putting all your eggs in one basket.

It's what you make it. It you want it to be miserable, then it will.

Have a great day!!

by scifiman

I agree. For the most part, unions are evil. Except for certain safety areas such as mining, construction, etc. -or standards need to be followed such as electrical work, etc. sure keep unions. All the rest should be bannished. It certainly helps the wealth of the union leadership, but it mostly just another drain on union members paychecks. I for one would change jobs or careers before joining a union!

by apotheon

The only reason unemployment rates aren't even worse in union-dominated industries than they already are is that unemployed people in union industries can't afford to get back into, or stay in, the union. Thus, they change industries. Voila, unemployment rates in that industry drop.

by scifiman

Yes, they are really not much needed any more. Not that I wouldn't mind high pay for little work, but it's a different era, and raise your hand if you think the end of unions will bring back 8 year olds in sweat shops in the U.S. Decades ago in the industrial ear the were important, but no longer. Time to evolve.

Unionize, and if my son wants an IT job in the future, he'll need me to get him in. Then if he sucks at it or is just a slacker, no manager can fire him. Big benefits and pay, light work. Or my son will have to pay $5000 to start his "apprentiship" somewhere. Look at United Airlines, GM, etc. Unions are flushing this country down the tubes.

by scifiman

Get paid whatever you want. Remember the good old days in USSR and some other countries (maybe still?). You were given a test in 10th grade or whatever. The outcome determinied if you were allowed into college and what your career in life would be.

Also, I'm on the tail end of the baby boomers. All those older than me will be opening up slots in the coming years, making tons of opportunities for me and the youngsters. Plus, since the dot com crash, fewer folks when into IT so there will be some nice worker shortages in the future. I'm looking forward to it.

Read The Automatic Millionire, save a portion of every dollar you earn. If we aren't ignorant consumers that NEED piles of STUFF and live within our means, you're all set to retire early and live comfortably. There, now we don't need unions. Problem solved. My work here is done.

by scifiman

Because if my email server goes down for a week, nobody dies. Thus, most doctors make more than I do.

Oh no! The CEO's Blackberry isn't working. Dear lord, he might have to actually use his telephone and actually speak to a person. Nobody died.

Network crashed at store 87. Oh well, just send the JIT truck shipment across town anyway, and we do the paperwork later. More work, but nobody died.

by peter warren

I agree with your four suggestions. What too many of us fail to realize is that even when we more than earn our pay, we are still tossed out like yesterday's trash if the same job can be given to someone else at a fraction of the cost. Inevitable under our so-called free market system? I don't think so.

We who have contributed mightily to economic growth deserve better and we still have the power to improve our economy and our society. Unfortunately, simply working hard, honestly and efficiently is all too often not enough. We need to replace our so called leaders with people intelligent enough to get the big picture.

by ralford100

I feel that my point is correct, but that the quality mentality needs to be very widespread, as opposed to a minority of individuals "simply working hard, honestly and efficiently".

Quality w/quantity participation. Unfortunately, it may be too late. We have to ride his one out and wait for world economic balance; and of course, it'll never be the same.

by peter warren

I agree. I've been riding for a while and I hope that the future will be characterised by real concern for quality. I do think that without intelligent management of our economic resources, we're destined to repeat the same old mistakes over and over.

by absolutely

Why do you think the captains of industry are currently outsourcing (only 10% of call center jobs, by the way, you twit) as much as they are? Is it because India's communism is so wonderful and their workers are all just as knowledgeable, or is it because so many North American employees are not workers, but money pits?

I'm willing to [b]work[/b] for a living.

Get the hell out of my way!

by scifiman

Yes, some very small percentage of jobs (which sounds huge in the media) has/is going overseas. Some of that is also returning. Labor is lower there, but it's rising fast which may help slow down the job drain all by itself. India, of course, is the worlds largest democracy, and just like the U.S., has wealth, a middle class, and the poor. [The poor and middle class aren't getting any support in the US either, so don't cast fowl looks at other countries until we clean up our own mess!] India and China also have a big push on for math, science, etc. education and the population to take advantage of it. Education reform here is just so-so.

And your other point, yes, American's want big pay, more holiday's, etc. But the real problem is we want to live big- usually more than our paychecks allow. I suggest that everyone here that has posted so far as pro-union would find a lot of extra money in the bank if they didn't spend it all first. Some Euro nations have tons of holidays- now they're trying to get workers back to work and rebuild their stagnant economies.

by absolutely

are not my problem. The results may be, if they succeed in driving the price of their marginal competence too high.

by too old for it

because slave labor is cheaper to the bottom line. Supporting communism abroad is only a means to an end. End of corporate civics lesson.

"Shareholder value" is code for "destroy the middle class so that they live in poverty and realize that we the rich are their betters".

by scifiman

Sounds like you really are "Too Old For IT". The new jobs created in, for instance, India, is creating a new affluent class for 20-somethings over there. Often they have some experience with lifestyle from working in the US, and now fancy cars, night clubs, higher rents, etc. are taking off in the tech center areas. Outsourced jobs are not going to "slave labor". Before you go spouting off decades-old party lines, educate yourself about the new realities.

And there is nothing wrong with shareholder value. There is also nothing stopping YOU from being one of those shareholders getting the value. Do you have a 401K, mutual fund, stock? You ARE a shareholder. Do you want it's value to go up or down. You can't have it both ways. Nothing stopping you from being rich in this country, except you. Go read The Automatic Millionaire and other personal finance books. Learn, and fix your spending habits so you aren't in your envisioned impoverished middle class. Don't pretend to be a victim where everything is beyond your control.

by absolutely

Good point. Communism is slavery. Cutting all relations with all communist nations would be better, but taking that [b]moral[/b] position during this discussion about [b]competition[/b] being harmful to American employees is ironic, to say it kindly.

And bad point. Shareholder value is code for nothing. It means the dollar value, per share, of the shareholder's property.

I wonder about the poor who act so certain that the rich have "rigged the game": if you know it's rigged, why can't you use the rigging to your advantage? No, I'm not falling for your hard luck stories.

by absolutely

But in the context of this discussion, hell no. When wages exceed what the market will bear, jobs go to countries where the price of labor is reasonable, or the jobs disappear altogether.

In all seriousness, to anybody who truly wants to inflate their pay via collectivism instead of by improving themselves in order to [b]deserve[/b] more money according to the [b]free[/b] market: get the hell out of my way, you pathetic trash!

by scifiman

Yeah, and now nobody will even look at my 24 plus years in the industry resume, because it doesn't mention a certification. To bad companies don't invest in employee training anymore. It's, "hey, spend the $10K yourself and we'll keep you on, or else we'll hire a kid that cramed for an exam but can't troubleshoot." To bad I can't memorize things or I'd have a pretty piece of paper too.

by too old for it

I'm helping a data center / disaster recovery center get going. And a lawyer I know, while may be not needing something so grand certainly needs something better than his server sitting in the middle of a loft-space office.

First words out of his mouth were: "Good idea, but I need a discount."

Well, there is s discount schedule after the first piece of rack-mounted equipment. And there is a further discount if you lease an entire rack. Anything over 3 racks and we can get the boys in accounting to sharpen up their pencil.

But there is not nor will there be a discount simply because the only thing you know how to do is spout off "I need a discount" before even seeing if the idea of putting a rack server offsite to back up your in house server makes sense.

Back when I still did independent break/fix for people, I had a universal answer for "Can you sharpen up your pencil, and get me a better price?" I said "No." Then I closed my portfolio, and left. Funny, about 50% of the time after the guy with the sharp pencil balled up the works, I'd get a call back, and it would cost more than if I had been fired the first time. The usually whimpered, but they always paid.

I pretty much defer lawyers elsewhere, tho some of my better competitors no longer take lawyers either. One firm was installing a new PC, and the lawyer kept bumping into the tech with his electric wheelchair, finally running up on the guy?s foot, sending him to the hospital. Of course, he wanted a discount, because the work was not completed to his satisfaction.

by too old for it

CEO's in Outsource Nation never move their trophy shopaholic wife or Muffy & Buffy, the fashion conscious teenage daughters over to Bangalore to live.

Before the fall of the Taliban, I always wanted to be there to watch the reaction of the local social vanguards to a couple of stuck up mall rats who were pissed that they had to be "in ocuntry" with daddy, the CxO of OutsourceCo.

by too old for it

CEO's in Outsource Nation never move their trophy shopaholic wife or Muffy & Buffy, the fashion conscious teenage daughters over to Bangalore to live.

Before the fall of the Taliban, I always wanted to be there to watch the reaction of the local social vanguards to a couple of stuck up mall rats who were pissed that they had to be "in country" with daddy, the CxO of OutsourceCo.

by peter warren

Maybe I missed it, but all I read were examples of industry failures being blamed on workers. Do you really believe that our corrupt government officials and their myopic corporate paymasters have nothing to do with it?

And I don't know, but somehow "just dealing with it" strikes me as surrender to the status quo, no matter how miserable it gets. It's too bad that while "just dealing with it" is necessary, it is not sufficient to bring about progress.
Frankly, in light of the growing seriousness of our economic situation, just dealing with our individual situations is tantamount to economic suicide.

As you stated, our economy is broken largely due to corporate welfare and other market inefficiencies. I believe these inefficiencies are typically introduced to benefit the powerful and connected. And to paraphrase Maire Antoinette, let the rest of eat crap. What was once envisioned as a society of laws, fairness and equality, is becoming as corrupt and nepotistic as your garden variety bananna republic. I say we can restore our economy and our society by using the power we have. That's what I am taking about.

by apotheon

"[i]Maybe I missed it, but all I read were examples of industry failures being blamed on workers. Do you really believe that our corrupt government officials and their myopic corporate paymasters have nothing to do with it?[/i]"
You must have missed the part where I said, at the very end of my previous post: "Corporate welfare, arbitrary regulation, and economy management are screwing up the efficiencies of the market economy." What does that have to do with blaming workers and leaving government officials and "myopic corporate paymasters" blameless? I did the complete opposite of what you're trying to say I did.

Again, you're putting words in someone else's mouth -- this time, mine.

What needs to be done is simple. Corporate law needs to be torn down, brick by brick, and replaced with a solid foundation for protection from force and fraud without granting special privileges to anyone. Since government isn't likely to do so on its own, especially with major corporations like Microsoft lobbying for more of the same rather than a reduction in their own power, we have to monkeywrench the system somehow -- which is exactly what open source software is starting to do in the software industry.

by peter warren

With all due respect, my first post was in response to comments by another contributor, in which he equated industry failure with the high cost of labor in the US.

"Where is the US steel industry? Where is the US automotive industry? Answer, both of these formerly very powerful US industries are now very much struggling. In both cases, they were unionized and, ultimately, the cost of jobs forced the "exportation" of many of the jobs."

Those are his words. You responded by saying I was putting words in his mouth and that all he?d done was lay out a clear explanation of why unions don?t work. I don?t see any explanation here; just citing examples of failure and, by inference, an indictment of unions and labor.

True, my response was critical and perhaps overly harsh, but again, here are his words: "Go ahead, unionize. But when you do, US IT workers will ALL be unemployed. You should have saved more money when an MCSE was a rare commodity. Today, an MCSE is a dime-a-dozen and you just are not going to get high $$. Deal with it." This seems highhanded and arrogant to me. It?s as if he?s saying ?I?ve got mine, so the rest of you can go to hell.? Maybe I?m wrong, but I wonder why he is unable to point to the other important factors that you and I, in our own ways, are concerned about.

"As you stated, our economy is broken largely due to corporate welfare and other market inefficiencies. I believe these inefficiencies are typically introduced to benefit the powerful and connected."

This is part of my second post where I acknowledged your comments about corporate welfare, arbitrary regulation and economic management. The fact is, you and I agree on a very important idea ? that corporate law needs to be torn down and rebuilt without granting special privileges to anyone. When I asked -- "Do you really believe that our corrupt government officials and their myopic corporate paymasters have nothing to do with it?" ? I meant to emphasize not your comments, but the oversights referred to in my first post.

In any case, the blurring of lines between the US government and corporate America is a mistake that?s costing all of us more and more each day. I think reversing this trend is both possible and absolutely necessary if our society is to succeed in the modern world.

by too old for it

Ok, so other than drop the minimum wage to zero, meet India and China slum for slum, and have our kids eating out of trash cans because dad can't make enough to feed a family of 3, any suggestion on the future of the American middle class? Retrain and redeploy into knowledge jobs sure was a bust.

by tonythetiger

are unionized because of the widespread practice of hiring according to the applicant's political affiliation rather than their abilities. It was actually a greater expense to the taxpayer to have to train thousands of people every 4 years.

by delaaguilerae

Open competitive exams and the Merit System were implemented at the Federal, State, County and City level to help correct those problems also the quality of a political appointee was rather poor.
There are other factors; at the County and City level there are residency requirements. Applicants must reside in or move to the County or City within 6 Months of accepting the job. This is done to benefit the "political subdivision" by making them spend a good portion wages inside the area.
Also a "well run" public employee enterprise can provide higher quality services for a lower price when compared with a private subcontractor. The reason for it is that the Public Sector does not have to show a profit to enrich the owner. It can simply break even, using higher quality material or processes to benefit the taxpayer.

by 50kilroy

Oh, they will fill the position all right enough. some "hi skooler" with a giant golden book of networking will take it at substandard wages and drive wages into the dirt for everyone.
UNIONIZE NOW!

by cactus pete

Then someone willing to work at that wage, who is worth exactly that wage, has a job.

You probably wouldn't want to work there anyway.

by scifiman

You could probably do it. Did you buy more house than you need, in an expensive (high tax) neighborhood? Got a 20mpg $30K car when a 30mpg $17K car will get you to the same places? Have premium cable TV you hardly ever watch, big cell phone bill, dinners out often, etc? Bottled water that costs $20 a gallon? $4 coffee every morning?

Personnally, I made aprox $60K last year but spent more. Just gave myself a big raise starting last month simply by automating all of my bill payments, and cleaned up my wasteful spending. No more huge bank fees, bounced checks, and underused services. Now I can fund my retirement and the family can eat out and see a movie without the water getting shut off.

Took me 44 years to figure out it wasn't my paycheck that was the problem, it was me. I don't need a union taking more of my income- just some reasonable self-control. Sure, I'll take future pay raises and better jobs, but suddenly I have plenty of money.

by 50kilroy

Unions do often cooperate with each other. For instance, should a large IC manufacturer not be paying a decent wage, that company might find itself without any raw materials due to the Teamster freight haulers not crossing a picket line. Should they hire non-union haulers, other companies might find that Teamsters have initiated a 'sympathy' strike. So, as you can see, a union can have wide ranging effect. The problem is that companies are so forceful in quelling union talk that folks are afraid to organize.
Could a strike affect Microsoft? You bet it could.

by apotheon

Why would employees of Microsoft ever strike? They're well-paid, with plenty of vacation time and benefits. They have no interest in joining any unions.

by mikeetemple

AFSCME.ORG is a UNION of public employees that was started in the "30s by a group of REPUBLICAN Auditors that worked for the State of Wisconson. When the newly elected Democratic Governor announced that he would "spoil" existing employees for a "patronige" system of rewarding campaign workers/contributors.

There is no way that you can make a "profit" from certain mandated public concerns such as children protective service, corections and even HOMELAND SECURITY or IT security.

IT now and the future will have the greatest impact on our society as we know it today.

If we do not collectivly learn how to control our destiny, it will control us.

by delaaguilerae

You can make profits in corrections it has been tried by Republicans who want to privatize everything, including corrections. On some States, for profit companies have been allowed to hire and guards and run corrections facilities. The results have been unsafe and dangerous.
Also Florida's Jeb Bush has been trying to privatize Florida Schools with a voucher program and there have been some talk of doing that with children protective services.
I am aware of the Republican origins of AFSCME however its just about all Democratic now. I am allmost sure that we don't want anything to do with Homeland Security, AFSCME doesn't represent federal employees. American Federation of State County and Municipal Employees = AFSCME.

I agree with you on the impact of IT. I remember reading when I was a child a Science Fiction story where the people where so advanced that didn't have to leave their homes to talk or communicate anybody in the world. The future is here and also Telecommuting specially on IT. What do you think about the help desks overseas?

by absolutely

to exercise enough discipline to acquire enough skill to compete on a level playing field with the rest of the world. And unions stifle the greed that fuels healthy competition even more.

by ralford100

Greed is when you join a union, then think you're better than
everybody else, so you should get better benefits and better pay
and when the corporation (AND THE ECONOMY) don't agree with
you, perform acts of sabotage, violence, and other unethical
actions. Greed is when you will say and do ANYTHING to get
those benefits, regardless of truth.

Yes, I realize that it's a stereotype of unions, but that has been
my experience.

by luther49

Have you done your research on the Unions yet? Yes, you can make great money belonging to a Union, but it will even become more difficult to work for companies or firms. You cannot force the companies or firms to accept Union labor. Most of the gifted individuals, which consist of .0005 percent of the earth's population do not want the constrains of being part of Union labor. Unions are basically to help the non bargaining employees. Since the labor laws have changed many of the things that are offered by the union is offered by Federal and State governments. It's it funny that the similar scenario can be observed by watching the differences between the Microsoft Corporation (Microsoft Windows Vs. SuSe or Red Hat (Linux). Open source verse propitiatory source. Yes, there are many things that I have learned because of the open source code. I hope you find the answers and share it with us on the Net.

by aaron a baker

Unions thrive on the bottom line. That being the there is never enough money,or the hours are too long, or the Maternity leave isn't what it was, there's always some excuse.
Funny how there always seems to be a strike at the most inconvenient times for the innocents, "Us" who by the way, pay the Unions, but the Unions make damned sure that they nail us everytime.
What are they really doing?. What is their end Goal? That THEY will remain needed by the people who they are supposed to be serving.
Look around you, The Teamsters,The Lumber Industry, The Government Unions, are ANY of them broke? I wonder why. When they call a strike, do they care that it might devastate you financially, hurt your family, wipe you out? Not the Unions.
So now we're talking about allowing this Rat Pack into the IT business. Sure let's do it and then watch as everything we've ever worked for is whittled away and taken from us with little or no help fro the God Almighty Unions.
Oh they would put on the usual "Show" but the result would be the same.
Man, Don't talk to me about Unions.They are not about People, they are avarice, greed and their own self interests.
So by all means open the door and invite the Bloodsuckers in, then watch the IT industry die a slow and painful Death
Good Luck, especially if THEY get in.
Aaron :)

by absolutely

Since self-respect is so often disparaged as "greed", I defend acquisitiveness, ignoring the negative connotations of the word "greed" that are assumed by imbeciles who consider self-respect a personal affront, simply because they have earned none and experience envy when in the presence of another person's self-respect, instead of admiration.

by absolutely

only if the people "in charge" are completely honest. I know I don't believe that they all are, and I believe that coercive wage controls are irrational because "value" of all goods and services are determined by the phenomenon competition, which only exists in systems where there is freedom of choice. Without economic competition and choice, the term value itself is meaningless. So, without knowing the history of labor unions in as much detail as you seem to have, I can say that all seems very plausible.

by apotheon

A free market economy isn't possible when government looks for every possible excuse to screw with it.

by tony hopkinson

Unions were at least in the UK brought in to combat the truly atrocious conditions that workers had to deal with. Only one of those conditions was remuneration, there were far more important ones , such as not being maimed or dead, terminated without reason or redress etc. One of the things unions got us was legislation to force employers to a minimum standard of conditions. In fact good employers exceed those standards now, because they've seen that it helps them.
Unfortunately as unions gained power they became political, politicians invaded them. Unions lost their purpose and became vehicles for the self agrandisemnent of a tiny minority.
So I'm afraid before you could recapture their original purpose things would have to become much worse. In my opinion we are heading towards this situation but we are not there yet. At the monent if you join a union you are simply changing which asshole is in charge. Union leadership aren't us they are those who want to steal the mantle of them.

Your wage demand said everything, it's not realistic, it would damage the membership (IT employees). You are only looking at yourself, and that's not what unions were meant to be about, they were us not me.

I'd be happy to join a union, but not one where you are at the top, because you don't have my interests at heart because you don't feel that my interests are in your interests.

If you did, you'd have suggested a rate that kept us both employed on a living wage that kept the industry we are engaged in alive. Your $50 an hour would put me on welfare and you don't f'ing care. So don't ask me to pay you to put me out of a job and give you a salary increase.

Socialism run by asocialists is capitalism in disguise.

Footnote
As I understand it, employment conditions in the US are far worse than those I enjoy in europe, personally I put that down to the fact that as nation you think it's perfectly OK to have every freedom you fight for abrogated as soon as you step on your employer's premises.

That's how it looks from the outside anyway.

So come back when you're argument is to safeguard your colleague's employment on a long term basis. ie until retirement. I don't expect you to achieve it, but I do expect you to try. If you don't and aren't, you don't want a union, you want a personal sinecure.

by richard

It is a sad thing that such and accurate discripton has to come from outside our own conutry.
Tony, you seem to see the picture clearly, the problem to me is I don't know how to show it tho those who do not know the hardship and don't even know they are charging at high speed down a dark tunnel. There is know light in the near future bacause that tunnel has a wall in it.
I wish there it were not so, but working conditions ans freedoms will probably need to be so bad before the majority will wake up.

Yes, I have worked 15 years without a union, after working 19 years with one. I am doing fine, but I know it is a result of the progress made by the Unions and I see it eroding, at this point in time employeers pay and treat my generation a little better then the younger ones. What will happen in 20 more years? I think I know, Lucky me, I will be out of the work force by then and enjoy the deflated economy with my earned assets that I got from the union years. I will be forced to take advantage of those who don't listen now. They will stay at the bottom and the bottom will get lower.
It seems to be a new world. Less of us will move up.

by tony hopkinson

get terrible press over here. They always seem to involve corruption, the mafia etc.
Ours generally get labelled as communists. Whatever the truth, unless the membership is prepared to make personal sacrifices for the good of the whole, it isn't a union.

While the workfore is at the beck and call of capital nothing will ever change. Flipping the relationship on it's head and have labour hire capital would redress the situation, but the people who have capital now are in control and it's as sure as my **** is brown they aren't going to allow that to happen. On top of that we would all end up with less personal wealth as essentially everything would be co-operative/community based, so how do you sell that to a bunch of people who's prime goal is unenlightened self interest.

by absolutely

Which has worsened terribly, steadily, since Lyndon Johnson's "Great Society" swindle began. So the question to you is, are you willing to get the government out of people's way and allow them to [b]earn[/b] a living in a free, productive economy (you cannot have one without the other), or do you want to keep socializing this already mixed economy, until there is no way for anybody to earn their living?

by Member 25348569

on your new tag-line "Get the hell..." which I've seen a couple of times, not on your thoughts about unions. Nothing unfriendly about it, merely a comment on what happens when you meet yourself - or a close approximation - coming the other way. But then, that rarely - if ever - happens with rational beings?

:D

by absolutely

Although I'm not exactly sure what you mean by "when you meet yourself - or a close approximation - coming the other way", I didn't think [b]you[/b] were being unfriendly. I was just being careful that the serious message did not become confused with your humor. Theft is not something that amuses me. Neilb does amuse me, frequently!

by apotheon

I guess that answers the question of whether you consider yourself an Objectivist, then. I take issue with some of the details of Objectivism, but I definitely sympathize with the basic principles of Objectivist economics.

by tony hopkinson

I'm alive because of my union, I did 19 years in heavy industry, without my union management would have found it cheaper to risk my life. Without unions there would be no legislation safeguarding employees rights as pitiful as they are. Without unions my kid's would be sweeping up under the machines I worked on. Without unions I'd be letting my boss shag my duaghter in order to keep food on the table. Now the legislation to force employers to acceed to some basic human rightsm is in place and it would be politically inadvisable to hamstring it too much we simply don't need them as much as we used to.

by tony hopkinson

die in the UK. Three forces pulled it apart. None of them could have done it on their own.

Personal wealth creation.
Cheaper labour overseas.
Union leaders who believed in the former and refused to recognise the latter.

by tony hopkinson

US set the standards for human rights in the workplace, are you having a laugh? You're slave labour compared to us commie europeans. Our employment costs are much higher than yours. In the netherlands for instance there is a statutary four month notice period and if you get laid off you get your average wage as welfare for the first six months. Now do you want to pay the necessary taxes to get those rights. No do you f***.

I'll go with a level playing field anytime you want, US standards would have to increase dramatically to get to where western europe is. That would make us more competive not you.

A country that believes in the goals of free market capitalism, but wants to impose controls, tariffs, etc on others so it can compete. Hypocrite.

by tony hopkinson

If that's true why did the union membership feel it was a good idea to help wreck the industries in which they worked. Mis-informed by a leadership with it's own agenda perhaps?
Don't tell me it has n't happened. I was born in a yorkshire mining village and then worked in the british steel industry for nineteen years. So either you are wrong or I and thousands of others simultaneously shot ourselves in the foot.

What's next governments don't have power, voters do !
You are either very naive, or you think we are all extremely naive.

by tony hopkinson

if your home market will support your economy, other wise those you raise them against will simply go tit for tat.
My ?2 * 0.67s worth.

by absolutely

Trade barriers violate the rights of "the market" -- people -- to decide for themselves what is in their self-interest. Most people, when their rights are violated, tend to retaliate. Unfortunately, the most intelligent and productive tend to be the most patient and tolerant, otherwise there would be much less dead weight in the gene pool.

by gimpy0509

I live in an area where Unions are/were dominant. My father is a union representative. I've listened to these "Highly trained, productive union people" around where I live talk. "Less Related Injuries" -- Yeah, most are not doing their job or sleeping. "Better Trained" -- Most love training -- for the food, free coffee and sleep time. I am a self taught programmer. I held 1 of the 2 top Technical Positions at the Worlds Largest Options Exchange. I ran circles around those with degrees and certificates. It was always the one's who could not perform that wanted a Union -- so that they would be protected. "Economics" -- Do your job well. You will get recognised and paid accordingly. If not there are a lot of IT jobs out there and I have never had any problem getting a job and getting paid based on "MY" perfromance. If you can't cut it, find a new line of work -- drive a truck or something.

by absolutely

Here are the answers.

Peter Kelley: "If your skills are in high demand then you get high pay. Is that fair?"

Absolutely: Yes, because "high demand" means that the value of my skills is high as defined by [b]the market[/b], which means people who are free to choose what is best for them. At least, that is what "the market" means in a free, "market economy". In a command economy, which is the only alternative -- "mixed" economies only have some free industries and others controlled by the government, and are no "third way", but a mongrel -- "the market" is determined by the Fuhrer, commissar, party chairman, or whatever the most vicious thug chooses to call itself, until it's stabbed in the back and replaced by the next thug.

The individual or collective that employs me does so because it chooses, rationally, that the value it receives from my work is sufficient to validate the expense incurred. That is [b]exactly[/b] the logic employed by rational employees, and that's what dealing fairly with other people means -- pursuing self-interest rationally, and giving those with whom I deal the same choice, to decide whether dealing with me is beneficial. If it is not [b]mutually[/b] beneficial, neither of us has the right to compel the other to interact at all.

Peter Kelley: "Is it fair that production jobs have dried up or that 55 year old metal worker is no longer employable, because his trained for a job no longer exists?"

Absolutely: Not so fast, pal. Is it fair that production jobs have dried up? Of course. The market is demanding something different than it did before those jobs "dried up". The market is composed of all of us. So, rephrase your question in the literal terms of the [b]cause[/b] of the phenomenon of "dried up" jobs. "Is it fair to allow you and everybody you love to spend their money on what they judge is best [b]for themselves, and those they love[/b]?" I hold this truth to be self-evident: yes, you are free to choose to spend your money on things that benefit [b]you[/b], as long as you leave everybody else free to do likewise for ourselves.

It's a lot of little people who compose the market, but it's always the superlative achievers who are expected to pull the weight of the little people who are trained only for the demands of yesterday's market, which means the desires of yesterday's little people. Is [b]that[/b] fair?

Separate question: "Is it fair that ... 55 year old metal worker is no longer employable, because his trained for a job no longer exists?"

Again, of course. When she trained for that job, he did so because the market did demand it. The desires of the market changed. That's the way free markets work, and free markets are perfectly fair [b]because[/b] they allow each individual to decide her own standards of happiness and pursue them to the best of her ability. The 55 year old metal worker has the right to pursue happiness, not to stagnate the world economy so that her happiness can be given to her.

Artists take this risk all the time, and most of them work in menial jobs while they hone their art, or move forward through effort and talent in a profession that isn't what they love, but they do their jobs well because they are motivated by the pursuit of something they do love.

They pay their bills, so can a 55 year old metal worker, unless she has made unalterable financial commitments based on an assumption related to her employment, which is alterable. Employment at will [b]is[/b] fair. Slavery is not. Laborers are not their employers' masters, they are their employees, and doing your job well is only half your responsibility. The other half is maintaining your own ability to do work whose worth [b]to the market[/b] is what you want to be paid. I'm still working on that myself, but I'll never ask somebody else to pay me more than my productive ability is worth in the free market.

by tony hopkinson

Trade barriers are stupid. They are a reaction to a global economic condition and simultaneously a denial that the economy is global.
Theoretically, they could be a short term measure to spread out the social consequences of an ecomonic change, more usually they simply build up the pressure resulting in an economic upheaval.

Not a tariff as such, but I watched my local industry get de-nationalised. It was overmanned vastly unprofitable and unable to compete on the world market. One set of dogmatic idiots kept the situation going for a long while, so when the idiots suffering under the opposite dogma came in to power, we had 10k direct job losses in a very short period in town with a population of 75k. You may be able to imagine the consequences socially.

Maintaining an ecomonic imbalance is not a long term proposition, therefore stupid, eventually the restraint snaps and shit goes everywhere.

by tony hopkinson

At their worst a union will try to get a sinecure for it's membership, whether their employers can support it or not. Always a long term losing proposition.
At their worst a company will seek to reduce it's salary overhead, whether the workforce is either capable of doing the work or the salary is capable of supporting them individually. Also a losing proposition.

One put's off being unemployed until the firm goes bust, the other put's off employing until the firm goes bust. So they are both imbecilic positions.

The only reason employers get away with it is because some individuals with capital milk as much profit out of the situation as they can and then bog off without facing the consequences of their withdrawal of capital.
When either side goes for us and them whichever gets the upper hand is damaging someone else, can't really expect them to like it can you ?

On a personal note, my concerns do get heard by the market, if remuneration and conditions are inadequate I go elsewhere. This is a privilege I worked my ass off to get. I aren't giving it up so some twit with money can buy my ability cheaper and I aren't giving it up for some twit without my ability or his money can get part of my money.

Anybody who want's a piece of the cake should pay me for mine, learn to cook, or ask politely.
If the latter, don't presume on my generosity too often.

by richard kirk

Look at what the idealist folls did to the British car industry! Unions are just another puss filled boil in the side of progress.

by midwestcio

I strongly believe that unions play an important role in this country for certain industries. IT is not one of them. I recently hired an employee away from a unionized IT shop. When asked why he wanted to leave his old position he stated that his scope for growth and access to new technologies were limited by the "union classification" of his position. For example, he was very interested in receiving his CCNA to help further his career goals. His union classification did not allow him access to CCNA training or the ability to work on routers. How sad. If your staff is not being properly conpensated, trained or motivated look inward not outward to unionization. I want the maximum flexibility for my staff. I am responsible to enusre that my staff is properly trained, fairly compensated and has options for growth. the last thing I would want is to be told that "that's not in my job classification". I can certainly sympathize with the author of the original post. My point wounld be that we need better management overseeing IT and unionization will place a barrier between management and staff.

by fooser dan the network man

whether or not to join an IT union is the day I decide to change career fields. I don't need no stinkin' union to go to bat for me. If my boss is being an a-hole, I look for another job instead of whining to the union. If I don't feel as though I am being paid enough, I either convince management that I deserve a raise or I look for another job instead of crying to the union. This country was founded on rugged individualism - that's what I do, that's who I am. Leave the unions to those who can't hold down a job or work hard/smart enough to get a raise on their own.

by evisscerator

I'm with you on this one. An IT Union would suck as bad a being on Welfare. Besides, don't we pay Microsoft - Novell - Sun and other IT whoremongers enough without having to dish out more to IT Wannabe's who wouldn't, couldn't manage our interests but instead look for raking in more funds out of our pockets to feed their endless GREEDY lives ?

by techiemikee

Personally I'd like to promote my career on my experience alone, but the reality is that if I supplement my experience and references with Certifications it makes closing the sale easier. It is my job to give the client what they want and charge accordingly. If they want to pay extra for the peace of mind they get from seeing a Cert, why leave money on the table? I take pride in knowing what I know but if 80 hours of study and testing time gets me $5 more an hour that addition $10K (5x 2080) a year will go further than arguing whether employers are rightfully requesting it.

It is a pain going to test lab, even a bigger pain studying examples of not-so realistic labs, and of course wasting time reading all the marketing propaganda vendors throw in the courseware to brainwash you into thinking their product is the better than the competition (even if it is different than accepted industry standards).

There are companies out there that could care less whether you have a degree or a certification, but I?ve never heard of a company excluding you from consideration for having them.

by 50kilroy

Microsoft employees would not have to strike for MS to feel the heat.
Teamsters move their product.
Postal workers move their product.
Cafeteria workers cater their onsite food provision.
Electrical workers provide power.
Union members do not cross picket lines.

MS product sitting in a truck, undelivered, on the outside of a picket line, makes 0 dollars for MS.
0 dollars for MS makes for fewer workers at MS with wage cuts.
An electrical failure at the MS complex could halt production if IBEW were on sympathy strike.

Get the picture now?

IT WORKERS, UNITE NOW!

by apotheon

There's no reason for IT workers to unionize because the only IT workers who could benefit don't need it. Strikes only make any difference the strikers consider positive when the employer is a major corporation, and the major IT corporations pay their IT employees well, give them good benefits, and so on.

Get the picture?

by 50kilroy

You hit it on the head. I have just finished reading in another thread some MSCE flaming me because I know DOS but don't have MS toilet paper. He evidently could'nt read or perhaps understand the part of my post in which I said that I have been troubleshooting and repairing Windows since Ver 2 through XP, including the server versions.
Several times, I have had one of the MS "engineers" tell me that I would be unable to attach to a MS network using DOS. I have always taken great pleasure in booting to my FDD and attaching to the network for them.
Evidently, the certification process begins with a pre-frontal lobotomy.
UNIONIZE NOW!

by boogaloodude

Why aren't you mentioning the Salaries of the CEO's, CFO's, Presidents, Vice Presidents, Marketing, etc...., Don't you think that figures into the Equation?, Don't you think that's gotten More then a Little out of Hand? Who's there to put a Cap on thier Salaries?