Discussion Locked

2004 - Year of the Commonwealth

0 helpful
88 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

It?s a new year, and time to turn our focus away from American issues and towards a greater understanding of the Commonwealth.

The recent revelations regarding the reckless introduction of nuclear weapons into the Falkland Islands area during the British war with Argentina really got me wondering. What could possibly justify such risk to an otherwise risk adverse and civilized nation? This made me think that perhaps I have missed key cultural elements of Commonwealth countries, an unhappy thought given that they make up around a third of all people.

In many of the posts on world issues during 2003, Americans found themselves at odds with those from the Commonwealth. At times, the discussions resemble the Old West feuds between cowboys and sheep herders! With little regard to logic or facts, these feuds had all the maturity of nursery school battles.

I began with some of the past discussions. Clearly, the Commonwealth faction perception is that all American actions are driven by oil or money, and that the American public follows along like a nation of sheep. If true, would there be a similar source behind the actions of other nations? Could there be a prime driver for the actions of the Commonwealth nations? A thread that binds those 54, excuse me, 53 nations of the former British Empire? Some single issue that would cause the tweed suits in London, the descendents of kilted clansmen, the Indian, the Pakistani, the shepherds in North Africa, the ranchers of New Zealand, and the stockmen of Australia to flock together? And if so, how would that effect a war in the Falklands, a place noted mostly for its 2,200 residents and their sheep? What link could there possibly be between that and a fascist Argentine government heading a country best known at that time for harboring former Nazis and being a major sheep producer?

I have to tell you, this was leaving me feeling a bit mutton headed. This poor old US public school educated brain of mine was just gathering wool, but somehow I was hopeful I could lift the blanket of confusion off if I just kept at it.

I started doing a bit of research. Along the way I became side tracked with the long term unrest over Kashmir. I started thinking of my high school days, when a slow dance with a cheer leader in a tight cashmere sweater was the height of? well never mind. At my age, such thoughts could cause a coronary. Besides, India and Pakistan are making progress in resolving their differences including the issue of Kashmir. Then I moved over to the Middle East. Those Afghan and Persian rugs are really something. Carefully woven designs in woolen yarn, creating not only wonderful patterns but stories. Still, the common thread eluded me.

And how did Canada fit into all of this? Sure, I have lived along our common border for half my life. Sure, I have spent many summers enjoying the fishing north of Toronto and in Quebec, and autumns on the Canadian side of the great lake they call Gitche Gumee. Yes, I have enjoyed lunches at the Polish Hall in Windsor, and Friday nights at the Canadian ballet. But what did I know of Canada? Of its western provinces like Saskatchewan where sheep production is growing while cattle production declines. My answers weren?t to be found in the hockey on CBC that I watched, nor with Captain Jolly or Bozo?s Big Top or the Windsor studios where they were produced. Perhaps more recent events would help me find that thread, like NAFTA. NAFTA which opens trade from Canada to Mexico, another major sheep producer.

Sometimes answers are to be found in the everyday. The language, the literature, the humor. On to some of those well loved BBC comedy shows. Take MPFC. There were the lumberjack songs, all in their woolen shirts, but I saw no clues. The skits about the businessman having an affair with a sheep. Hmm. Between Clinton and Bush, it seems everything is driven by sex or money here in the US. Still, to lead the world into a nuclear holocaust like lambs to slaughter, there must be some major underlying factor. Besides, Thatcher was in power at the time, and I don?t recall any skits involving rams.

Taking a break, I read some articles about green house gasses. Seems methane is becoming a real issue in global warming. A natural gas, it is a byproduct of livestock, and sheep in particular.

While I pondered this, word of a new outbreak of mad cow disease, this time in the US, grabbed my attention. What a bizarre world! Cows eating sheep parts and developing in effect Alzheimer?s, and the ability to pass it on to people who eat the cows. I see the USDA has traced those cattle back to our Canadian friends. Was Reagan a victim of conspiracy?

Reviewing what I learned: the richest members of the Commonwealth all are involved in sheep production; Commonwealth nations among the top 10 world sheep producers include Pakistan, India, New Zealand, Australia, and South Africa; how there is a strong movement within the Commonwealth to expand ovine production in their developing member nations; how world hot spots involved with sheep production include Syria, Iran, Algeria, Egypt, Sri Lanka, and Iraq; how the UK (England, Scotland, Northern Ireland, Wales) have significant sheep production; how Canada is expanding its own sheep production while cattle and other livestock production declines; and how Argentina, another of the top 10 world leaders in sheep production, was considered worth risking a nuclear holocaust over the Falkland Islands.

Feeling a bit sheepish I began to wonder if it is possible we have had the wool pulled over our eyes all this time? Could there be a previously unrecognized conspiracy on a level greater than the alleged Illuminati working ever so slowly to take over the world? Will methane, in the form of ovine flatulence, be the source of energy and so the source of power in the current century? Is mutton, rather than money, the fuel of globalization?

As an American I can only say ?Naa-a-aa-aa, can?t be? and keep seeking understanding.

88 replies

by oz_media

Hi Ken, how are ewe? (Sorry, that was baaaaaaad!)In my security years at the PNE I worked many long nights in the livestock barns during the summer fair. The Clydsedales and Belgians were really cool to work with (however they often threatened my manhood). The barnyard jokes were baaad and aplenty so I'm a shoe-in for baaad barnyard humor.

Wow, you've had some time on your hands to ponder lately !

From first read, all I can say in contrast to your statements is that although the USDA has pointed the finger to Candian cattle, Canadian sources show no links and agree that it will be some time, if at all, before the origin is discovered. Originally the main point that separated that cow from Canada's exports is that it was a Dairy cow, thus a completely different and isolated breed in comparisson to the last problems, but that's to be decided over time.

Your analogy does spark a slight interest in that one could assume that GWB had KNOWN of 'the great methane infiltration' coming from the commonwealth and that's why he needed to get control of Middle Eastern Oil deposits, hmmmmmmmmm

Mind you, for those in Northern Canada, the sheep are warmer than the women.

by oldefar

And I always thought that situation had led to the one, two, and three dog night solution!

Perhaps global warming is an American plot to counter the value of sheep???

by hal 9000

Next you be telling us all obout you're lattest sex aid Velcro Gloves so the sheep can't excape.

by jardinier

but a widely held view is that the citizens of the USA (some, most, all -- take your pick) strongly feel that the USA believes itself to be the mightiest (and I could probably add "most righteous") nation on earth.

Thus is projected this arrogant view: "We don't need anyone else."

Perhaps if the USA was able to outgrow this stupid and childish view, and join the Commonwealth of Nations, you would immediately belong to a group which comprises one third of the world's population.

by w2ktechman

I think that this View is only partially True. Most people that I talk to think that we (USA Citizens) are in a great country, but unlike the ones in power, think that we shouldnt meddle too much in other nations affairs, especially if it does not directly concern us.
This "American Ego" is usually associated with those in power, or the rich people who "beleive" that they are much more important in the world than they are.
As far as not "needing" anyone else, we could get along just fine if no-one else was around, but I think the same about a great many other nations.
But as things are, and others are around, it is far easier to utilize resources from others as well. But in my opinion, the UN should have more power over governing nations, than any individual nation trying to be the worlds police (what a joke, it will always fail)

by maxwell edison

.
At least not under the circumstances and expectations of the current time and current nations. Moreover, social and political changes of such a drastic nature and huge scale would, most likely, have to take place over many generations, and the probability of it happening in our life-time would fall somewhere between slim and none. (And Slim left town.)

But what exactly do you mean by the "commonwealth of nations"? The suggestion of such, especially when facilitated under the "guidance" of the United Nations, gives an image of a world-wide consortium consisting of every nation on earth. But on the other hand, you indicated that the "commonwealth of nations", as it currently exists, consists of only one-third of the world's population. One-third of the world's population plus the population of the USA would leave about 60% or more of the world's population excluded, left out in the cold, so to speak. What about them? In your view, would this "commonwealth of nations" involve every nation on earth, or only a select few? And who gets to decide who those fortunate few are?

I think that most countries, including the USA, put up a facade of cooperation with regards to joining the "commonwealth of nations", with the United Nations being the organization to facilitate such a collaboration. But to have a realistic expectation of the success of such an endeavor is, I think, being unrealistic at best, naive' at worst. It just can't happen unless all these nations have common goals and shared values, which we know they don't.

Common goals and shared values are the key, and they are necessary in just about any partnership, e.g. a "commonwealth of nations". What about the nations that believe in the superiority of men over women versus the ones who believe in equality of the genders? What about the monarchies versus the democracies? What about the totalitarian states versus the ones who value individual liberty? What about nations who are extremely pacifist versus those who are less apt to stand by and watch injustice in the world go unchecked? What about the religious states versus the secular ones? What about the nations that believe in and implement a strong socialistic environment complete with a high tax rate (Sweden, for instance, at around 90%) versus a nation who believes in more individualism and lower tax rates (New Zealand, for instance, at around 30%)? What about the differences in the visions and views for the future? How can people (or nations) with vastly different (and possible contrasting) goals possibly work together to achieve them? How can such partnerships exist when the participants' values and goals are so different? How can (or could have) the United States, for example, reconcile the differences such as the ones seen recently with France and Germany? (And don't think all involved didn't have self-serving motives.) Perhaps one nation should change their values and goals to comply with the majority, if there is such a thing as a majority in this context?

Some slams on the USA:

Slam number 1: The USA acts as though it's the world's police force. Okay, maybe it does, maybe it doesn't, but therefore what? For argument's sake, I'll concede the point; the USA does, at times, act as the world's police force. If this is bad, then therefore what? Which is a better option? Should the world's police force be the United Nations? (Great job they've done over the last 50 years, right? - NOT.) Should another nation act as the world's police force? Which one should it be? And who gets to decide who it is? Should there be no world's police force at all? Should this commonwealth of nations (whatever that is) be the world's police force? Why? It's great to criticize, but therefore what? What's a better, and more practical, option?

Slam number 2: A widely held view is that the citizens of the USA (some, most, all -- take your pick) strongly feel that the USA believes itself to be the mightiest (and I could probably add "most righteous") nation on earth. Okay, I'll bite on this one. Yes, I'll admit it. This American citizen believes his country is the mightiest nation on earth. I think we are the mightiest militarily and economically. So what? And therefore what? Is this view wrong? Says who? And why? Are we not the mightiest nation on earth? If not us (U.S.), who is - and who should be? Again, therefore what? My second bite: This American citizen does indeed believe we are the most righteous nation on earth. Is this wrong? Who says? And by whose values? And who should decide what is right (righteous) and what is wrong? Why should they decide what is right? Sure, I'm a self-righteous person. But not because I think I'm "better", but because I believe I'm "right". And make no mistake about it, this is not unlike many other self-righteous (and pompous) non-Americans. Why is an American being self-righteous considered wrong, while an Australian's or Canadian's (or others') self-righteousness is considered right? Isn't it being "self-righteous" to be so judgmental of others? Quite frankly, I'm amazed at all the self-righteous non-Americans in the world.

Slam number 3: It was suggested that the USA, "projected this arrogant view". Well again, maybe we do, maybe we don't. But what is "arrogance"? Many people (individuals) who generally lack confidence in themselves are the ones who see confidence in others as arrogant. What's the difference between confidence and arrogance? Who gets to decide when the line from one to the other is crossed? Are you suggesting that confidence and/or arrogance should somehow be measured and/or limited? By whose measure? Yes, I'm a confident person living in what I think to be a confidant nation. If someone else sees this as arrogant, why is it my problem and not his?

Slam number 4: It was suggested that, "Perhaps if the USA was able to outgrow this stupid and childish view, and join the Commonwealth of Nations, you (the USA) would immediately belong to a group which comprises one third of the world's population. First of all, I won't repeat my questions about the Commonwealth of Nations, but consider them asked again. Secondly, what if two people (or two nations) have a different view of what constitutes stupid and childish. Who gets to define "stupid and childish", and why? Is it not "stupid and childish", in and of itself, for a person to charge the mightiest and most self-righteous nation in the world of being "stupid and childish"? Moreover, how do these charges help facilitate the "common goal" of living in a peaceful co-existence in a Commonwealth of Nations where everyone is always happy and everything is always right?

Slam number 5: The USA is the "self-appointed" leader of the free-world. Quite frankly, I'm rather happy with our position as the leader of the free-world. I like being the leader, not the follower. As I've said before, the world needs to follow OUR lead, not the other way around.

Last question(s): Would the world have been better able to face the challenges and the problems of the twentieth century with or without the United States? Would the world be better off today with or without the United States, even with all her flaws? Poof - the USA has simply vanished. Now what will happen?

by hal 9000

And quite rightly so as I got a great laugh out of it and am currently trying tpo think of a way to phrase a reply about just how stupid the sheep in Australia are.

We have mainly Merinos here and there are some who claim that Govenor Phillip imported these as they where the only sheep that where willing to get on the boats and make the crossing here all the rest had more sence and prefered being slaughtered on the docks rather than being transported to New South Wales as they believed that they had committed no crime so thay should not be placed in a position of being transported with the rest of the convicts.

But we treat our sheep very wel as we give them crusies to no particular destination and when they arrive the "Locals" are told that the majority of the ships crew are Kiwi and have been molesting the sheep all the way there so the Local Muslim leaders not wanting corrupted sheep find a way to prevent them being offloaded. We then send them out into the ocean and send them around in circles until they all fall over from getting giddy and are feed up with the attentions of tyhe Kiwi crew.

Then offer tham to some other unsuspecting Muslim country who quite rightly reject them once they find out what has happened to them and then there is the fact that as they can no longer stand up they are imediatly considered as suspicious. Eventually we managed to give them away after out Foregin Minister Mr Go-Down tried very hard to give the bloody things away and when he eventually succedded some great funny people then claimed that they had feed the next load of sheep some pig so they where not considered as suitable for the Muslim countries after all who would want a carniverious molested sheep?

But think of it this way if the USA was to appoligise to Elizy 2 and say we are very sorry for fighting you all those years ago she just might allow you back into the Commonwealth and then you can compete in our games every 4 years instead of just the Olypmics so you're sports people will have a major compition every two years instead of the current 4 year intivals. Then of course all the Americians who travel to the UK would have a valid reason to go there instead of the current curiosity value.

by oz_media

Just break down the word, COMMON WEALTH. that would never happen in a capitalist country.

If the USA became a commonwealth country, the Commonwealth would reject it like a bad organ that just doesn't fit with the rest.

Where would we be without America? Who cares, at least we wouldn't have to hear about the USA all day and night. At least we wouldn't be banished for not liking thier obscure system of government and then banished again for not joining in thier little invasions. At least music would be real. At least people would be humble. At least....

I could write an entire novel on why I wouldn't want to be American, with a second novel about how anally blind to reality American society is.

by john_wills

"commonwealth", or "commonweal", is the English claque of the Latin "res publica", from which we derive also the word "republic". "commonwealth" and "republic" do not mean exactly the same, but they are related words. "Commonwealth of Pennsylvania" means approximately "Republic of Pennsylvania".

by maxwell edison

It was suggested in the past that the USA become (well, remain) part of the British Commonwealth. The notion was soundly rejected. Why bring it up again? What's different now?

by oz_media

It seems that the line between independance and isolation is getting thinner and thinner.

Independance, an American could explain MUCH better than me because your country is built upon independance and you lives are surrounded by reminders of your independance.

What you feel is independance may often be seen as isolation by others?

You (US society) are very vocal about being unique and better than the rest of the world. The US has a better form of government, better social rules, better companies, better resources, better ideas, better military, better foods, better cars, better music, more money etc.

Now that vocal 'we are the best' attitude is often seen as a way of separating yourselves from others, therefore your indpendance becomes isolation.

You have a right to feel that your government, country and lifestyle is better than mine, but not a right to suggest that your way should be followed. I know Canada is better than the USA because I have spent time in both countries and prefer Canada. I am VERY split between canada and England. Socially England is light years ahead of Canada and the USA, but the scenery in Canada cannot be topped. I also LOVE France, it is absolutelu gorgeous and a very pleasant and welcoming place for a Canadian to visit. Germany has a history and freindliness about it that I haven't seen in other countries.

Therefore, how can I say the Canada is the best? I can't. Canada, England, Germany, France etc. all have thier beauties and values. I live in Canada therefore, I feel this is the best place to be RIGHT NOW as I am happy here. I wouldn't be stuck up enough to say it was BETTER than the USA, or that England should learn from Canada's example. I respect each country for what it offers. For this reason, I am neither arrogant nor unpatriotic. I support my country of origin, I support the country I live in and I support other countries that welcome me.
The fact that I admit Canada has political problems makes me unpatriotic? No.
Should the fact that Canada doesn't have a massive military make me feel my country is inadequate? No.

I don't have to lie to the rest of the world about how much better my country is in order to justify my living here, THAT is excepted by all others who realize no country is perfect or a paradigm of how a country should be, everyone has fault even politicians.

What reason do you have for saying that America is better than any other country, other than the fact that you live there and are proud of it?

What reason do you have to deem others inadequate and say that they should adopt your American ways?

NONE. And THAT's why people resent Americans.

by oldefar

Hope everyone enjoyed a chuckle, but as this post takes on its own life (as they all do) I wonder if it is possible to discuss the Commonwealth or any other organization without reference to the US.

Does anyone out there have a perspective on their country or affiliation that does not have to link to the US to be told?

by hereinoz

Don't say too much Jules - our own fair Prime Minister and his mates are looking a little internationally & domestically arrogant at the moment too.

It makes me feel a little sheepish at being an Australian. And after all the nuts and pretzels that I ate over Christmas, it isn't just ovine flatulence that is causing me distress!

See Ya

Alan

by dc_guy

Maxwell asks, "Would the world have been better able to face the challenges and the problems of the twentieth century with or without the United States?" Start at the beginning of that century. Without Wilson manipulating us into entering WWI on the side of England (which at that time was NOT beloved by Americans), Germany might have won the war. Or at least it would not have been humiliated by the Treaty of Versailles. Hitler could never have come to power. No Third Reich. Stalin would have no reason to squander the USSR's GDP, turning it into a military superpower with no hot water in its hospitals. Communism could have had a fair chance to prove itself once and for all. WWII, the Holocaust, the occupation of Eastern Europe, and the Cold War might well not have happened. The Chinese could not have overthrown Japanese rule, and as sad as that sounds they could hardly be worse off than they are. Perhaps France could not have hung onto Indochina, which would then have no cause for a paradigm-shattering revolution. The Brits might have been forced to dismantle their empire more quickly; the angry, fictitious "nations" of Africa and the Mideast, cobbled out of fragmented ethnic groups with nothing in common except hatred, might not exist to spread poverty and terrorism around the globe. On the downside, operettas and skittle might be all we'd have for music. And computers might not have been invented yet. Wait, which column does that go in?

by oz_media

You can SEE fault in your government.
You can see fault in those that run te country.

You can openly admit that your government is far from perfect but has good AND bad.
This isn't arrogance, is open eyed viewing of government actions.

MOST US citizens, see NO fault in thier government.
See NO fault in thier leaders, and if they do, they will STILL support him/her and refuse to ADMIT faults.

This is closed eyed view of the government as being superior to any other. However this is seen as normal and expected behavior, any doubt or displeasure with Government activity or Presidential statements is plainly UNpatriotic and intolerable.

Personally I think Canada's government, despite all it's mistakes is FAR better than the US government. I don't make a daily point of telling the world that they should learn from our examples and that OUR government is the one to be followed though.

by maxwell edison

The sheep reference to the British Commonwealth nations was indeed humorous. But it's not likely that some of our foreign friends will be able to see past their spite for the U.S. long enough to do much of anything else. It's incredible how often the subject gets diverted to blast America for this or for that. And then when you ask them reasonable questions about the reasons and logic for that spite, they go unanswered. (Because accurate answers would nullify that spite, I suppose. And they couldn't have that.)

America is the blame all scapegoat for everything. We've certainly learned that, haven't we? It's almost like a disease.

by hal 9000

You're begining to sound bitter and it doesn't look appealing.

If you want to quite rightly get upset by the way the USA is treated by some countries then have a go at Iran who are only too willing to accept humanitrian aid for their recent earthquake from the USA bit at the very same time say this aid will in no way affect if/how they chose to deal with the USA.

It all seems a bit wrong to me but I do understand just why the USA is involved in attempts to save lives in that part of the world I just find it introlable they way that you're country is treated when they supply this aid without any hitches seems to me that you are constantly getting kicked in the guts for doing the right thing. But you must be held in a higher opinion than Israil as Iran wuill just refuse and assistance from that country.

Just goes to show how concerned they are about their civilian population dosen't it?

by maxwell edison

.
Motives and feelings can often get misunderstood, misinterpreted or miscommunicated in these threads, as indicated by your perception.

No, I'm not bitter or pissed or anything like that at all. I do, however, find it frustrating that some people seem to be so obsessed with their dislike of the United States that they can't resist taking another jab, then another, then another. Moreover, even though I believe everyone is entitled to their opinion, I find it in extremely poor taste to continually badger someone over differences of opinion and/or differences in perspective. It seems that the practice of respectfully agreeing to disagree has long since gone by the wayside.

True, this is an International forum. However, I don't think that anyone would argue with the fact that it's a site primarily visited by Americans, and it's a site hosted by an American company. So in a way, it's kinda' like me going to Australia (or to an Australian site) and continually bombard you nice folks with insults about you, your leaders, your businesses, your country, your past, your present, your future, your everything. Before too long, you might want to punch this bloke right in the nose, saying to him, enough already.

It's just like Oldefar said. Geesh, he started a thread about one thing, but someone always finds a way to slip in a bash America statement. (Isn't there even a bash America or bash Bush in your Australia/RIAA thread?) No, the USA isn't perfect, and it may not even be the best. (Since that's all a matter of values and/or perspective, isn't it?) But it ain't all that bad either, as others continually attempt to make it out to be.

It just gets old, Colin. It's too bad these folks just can't get over it, already.

by hal 9000

And here I thought I had heard all the Kiwi Jokes as a friend who is a Kiwi constantly tells me all the newest ones and yes she does have an "All Black" car.

by hal 9000

About the sheep.

I actually quite enjoyed the original posting and have spent a bit of time attempting to make some form of comeback related to sheep.

by maxwell edison

...that Ken was having a fun dig at the British Commonwealth. But the message to which I replied was the off-topic, and take yet another poke at America message posted by someone else.

by oldefar

To think that I had considered a vacation on the Coral Trekker where guests are invited to "join the crew in the rigging (they'll show you the ropes)". The promise of an adventure like none other I have ever had takes on a whole new meaning!

;-D

by oz_media

Everything has to be picked apart.

I was only using a play on the word to suggest that the name goes AGAINST American theories.

I was not implying the origin of the word at all.

by oz_media

But that would be unAmerican as the world has it's Axis driven from Idaho to Texas, or so I've been told. How could ANY world topic NOT include the USA, the USA IS the world.

by mrbill-

Oz, is it any wonder why "some" people jump on you for "trash talking" the US. Every chance you get you turn a yanks comments into a tirade about how everyone in the States thinks we are better... everyone else is... yada yada yada. Give us a break for once ok. No one was intentionally slamming the Commonwealth countries until you started slamming Max who did what every human would do, go on the defensive. It appears to me that Max was talking about the universal "Commonwealth of Nations" not the ex-UK states. You tried to inject some humor with the "Common - Wealth" and capitalist system which was good. But then you went into a rant about how the US was a bad organ and should be rejected from the world body. Yes you could right a novel about why you would not want to be a yank, so what. Hitler wrote a book once too.

Then you attacked our Independence, one of the things that has made us, I hate to say this, the world leader we are. We are independent and proud of it. Instead of sending our resources back to Europe for their use we got to keep them and build our Nation as WE saw fit. If that upsets your British side I'm sorry. Britain was the biggest Imperialistic Nation in the last thousand years, but they over reached and lost what they had, they are still a great people. In that post you attacked us for our National Pride. To which I say go ahead at least we have one.

When Max was making a reply to Colin's post he made a thinly veiled mentioned of someone's constant attacks on the US, as his right. Then you take him to the wood shed for stating his opinions all the while trashing him the same way.

I know I have sided with you in the past on issues and probably will in the future but not on the constant trashing of the US. I love her and am proud to say I am an American, though I will cheer on other nationalities for saying the same about their homelands.

We are not ?the world? but we are a world leader so get over it. Sorry for the harshness I can get carried away when I get defensive.

Awaiting the storm.

by oz_media

You only say you respect other nations for what they are and 'I love her and am proud to say I am an American, though I will cheer on other nationalities for saying the same about their homelands' as you are VERY right to do so.

You and some others here are an exception to the rule, you also represent a smaller demographic of the country. My shots aren't aimed at those who are proud of thier country. My complaint is against those that incessantly wave the flag in everyone face while putting down other countries and thier inhabitants. Those who feel EVERYONE wants to be American and is just jealous of the USA, I think you remember those threads. THESE are the people who speak loudest in your country and show a different representation than some want to have portrayed. THESE are the people the rest of the world sees. With THAT face on, how do you expect others to back extreme poilitical movements that are supported for the wrong reasons?

I was born after the British Imperial Army, after WWII. I lived in a VERY peaceful country, visit Germany and absolutely adore it and the people of Germany. They have been through a lot and are humbled and happy to simly BE. I now live in CANADA, everyone is happy, laid back and the government just let's us simply BE. I have no reason to follow an Imperialistic frame of mind, that was then, this is now, then will be later.

Am I unpatriotic or a disgrace to my country for just wanting to live instead of conquer?

I just find America and American's too loud, much like my mum used to say about my music, "What a lot of racket!"

I am surrounded by serenity and have seen the powerful yet humbled victors of history. Why would I support any form of agression from such a young child of a nation?

As for Max, well he just likes to piss me off, just ignore it.

by oz_media

I have to disagree with you there.

You FEEL as if you are the world leader. Now go tell Tony Blair that, or Osama, or Saddam or Guy Verhofstadt, Simeon Sakskoburggotski, Paul Martin, the list goes on. Bottom line YOU feel as if YOU are the world leader. Nobody else does.

Everyone knows you WANT to be the world leader, everynoe knows you THINK you are the world leaders but nobody is convinced you are the world leaders.

Now on a different perspective, you definitley have the LARGEST military, you definitely spend more of your taxpayers money on military than others do. You definitely are NOT a world leader.
You MAY have a more powerful military out of sheer size and value of technology and arms, but not on a basis of knowledge or ability.

You Do have a great country, you DO have great people. You do NOT have a better government, other than it serves YOU best. in MY eyes MY government is better.

What I don't like is the look-down-your-nose attitude that you have toward other countries abilities, military and government.

What works for you, works for you. If you are content with your government, that is your right.

Do NOT assume that everyone else sees it that way though. I've NEVER met someone who wants to become American, I've NEVER met someone who is envious of the US military, I've NEVER met someone who thinks you have a better way of life, NEVER. Not in Canada, not in Germany, not in France, not in England and not in Brazil. Nobody talks about you other than yourselves.

What irritates me beyond belief is not someone who is proud of thier country but one who feels the world OWES the US for all thier efforts. That people only WISH they could be American, that people are jealous of America and worst of all, someone who feels that everyone would benefit from living like an American. American politics in Canada would destroy the country as it is and simply create a new America. American politics in England would have the entire country up at arms and trying to overthrow the government.

What then makes you feel justified in implying your political and social beliefs on ANY other country other than your own? Arrogance?

by oz_media

'Others' may see this as two faced, "Moreover, even though I believe everyone is entitled to their opinion, I find it in extremely poor taste to continually badger someone over differences of opinion and/or differences in perspective. It seems that the practice of respectfully agreeing to disagree has long since gone by the wayside."

Practice what you preach.

You do NOT accept 'ONE's' opinion as is, and you don't agree to disagree, as 'ONE' has to get you to do before with the resllt being your implying that 'ONE' had run out of defenses and was looking to avoid answering your circular questions.

Even when 'ONE' has outright agreed with you you STILL find a way to take it defensively. So get off your high sheep and look inward for once. You are a very clever person when it comes to seeing others faults but quite stupid when it comes to seeing your own.

Practice what you preach and you MAY gain some credibility as a voice.

I came to this forum with an open mind toward America even though I had seen the reality of America first hand and didn't like it, within one week of being here, I heard people satying the typical America saved your ass, America is the best, Canada should be grateful of the USA, EVERYONE in the world is jealous because they don't live in America. (admittedly, NONE of this was from yourself) What it does do is make someone with ANY doubt about America feel certain in thier dislikes for the USA. I had doubts about the citizens of America but was open to all comments, the Pro-America and F-K the rest of you mentality gets SO tiring because it is so uninformed and anal.

You have admitted here that america has its problems and also isn't perfect. This is the FIRST time I have EVER read anything even remotely close to this frame of mind on TR.

"America has NO faults, the reast of the world should follow" is the general frame of mind.

When I said, I didn't support all the things the Canadian PM did, I was called a traitor and told that I shouldn't be a part of this country and that I am unpatriotic. I stated that this is crap and that I don't have to agree with EVERYTHING my country does and that I won't just follow blindly. That my country should be ashamed of me and that I should be cast out for disloyalty to Canada or England as I didn't support all government actions.

You say that America isn't perfect but you're always being picked on. This is the same hypocritical attitude that causes you to be attacked and terrorized. What's best for America is best. You can slam Canada, slam the UK, slam France, SLAM Iraq, slam ... But when it comes back at you, people are picking on the good ole USA.

What a heaping, steaming pile of ....

by oz_media

The statement"You do NOT accept 'ONE's' opinion as is, and you don't agree to disagree, as 'ONE' has to get you to do before with the resllt being your implying that 'ONE' had run out of defenses and was looking to avoid answering your circular questions."

Should have read "You do not accept 'ONE's' opinion as is and you don't agree to disagree, as 'ONE' has TRIED to get you to do before, but with the result being your implying that 'ONE' was unable to answer your circular questions"

YOU CANNOT AGREE TO DISAGREE. YOU ARE INCAPABLE OF SUCH AN OPEN RESOLVE WITHOUT FEELING VICTORIOUS, I'VE ASKED, I'VE TRIED, YOU DON'T ACCEPT.

What a 'kin whiny old bitch!

by oz_media

I can accept your THEORIES or ASSUMPTIONS, but that is all you have given.

If, IF, IF, but no fact. All of your statement is based purely on speculation. In the same sense.

If Canada had joined in the Iraq invasion, you may have lost less lives due to proper recon. You would have lost less lives as a ersult of having less troops needed. You would have spent less of the taxpayers money.

If you had been born in France, you might have a better acceptance of the rest of the world, you may be able to make better wine.

If I had been born as Elvis Presley, the name MAY not have been so famous.

What's your point other than the fact that you don't have one.

by msamson

I quite enjoyed the read of the initial post on this thread... I also caught a few references where other questions were being asked about what it was that made it so hard to keep this thread going without mentionning the US...

Being canadian, it's not very hard for me to seperate Commonwealth from US... On one side, we have remnants of the British empire strewn every which way across our landscape... Figures on our money, statues everywhere, and constitutional issues which aren't likely to leave us anytime soon... On the other side, we have, and I have to be honest, a rather overbearing neighbor who just loves to try to push us around and make fun in a almost malicious way... Yes, I'm generalising... I know some amazing US citizens but I also know some pretty stupid ones too... My point is this: It just seems to me that whenever someting important happens in the world, the US always has a knee jerk reaction when it comes to its own involvement in the affairs of others whether it be justified or not... The self proclaimed greatest nation on earth is ever trying to dictate when and how things should be done elsewhere... And unfortunately (IMHO) the prime seat of the Commonwealth (Great Britain) has joined its "just" cause in the middle east.
It might then just be a sign of the times and of things to come that, like Canada, many countries who were once staunchly aligned with both these powerfull entities are now speaking their own minds in matters that truly do not concern either.

Maybe it is time to start looking at problems within instead of trying to always meddle with the problems of others...

Just a thought!

M.

by oz_media

I haven't changed my alias, msamson is just another Canadian with similar vierws to mine.

By posting here, you can see my alias is the same throughout the thread and wasn't changed for the above post.

by mrbill-

So you are saying that of the 10 people in Canada two of them are posting here, a likely story. `:]

by maxwell edison

Just because your alias hasn't changed, it doesn't mean that you can't post under multiple aliases. Not that I'm suggesting you have multiple aliases, but it's sure possible.

I remember a while back, probably a couple of years now, TechRepublic used to have an indicator of how many members it had. It was like the billions of burgers served on the McDonalds signs. The membership number just kept growing and growing until it finally reached a totally unbelievable number, into the tens of millions if I remember correctly. There were even several threads started questioning the number and making fun of it. TR removed that feature, and probably for good reason.

It was a pretty universal assumption that one person, for example, would create more than one account, perhaps even dozens of accounts. Why would a person do this, you might ask? Well, a person might do it in his or her quest to accumulate the most valuable, yet worthless, TechPoints. It was even proven by several members that one of the top techpoint earners would post answers to his/her own questions, thereby assigning tens of thousands of techpoints to him or her self.

If you're wondering who it was, by the way, I won't say exactly who. But I've never seen that person, that particular alias, ever post a message in the discussion forum. (And it wasn't dklippert, who I haven't seen post here; it wasn't Chas; it wasn't Joseph; and it wasn't me.)

Therefore, it is certainly within the realm of possibility for one person to have multiple aliases. Some might do it to reinforce themselves with points (techpoints) in the Q&A, while others might do it to reinforce themselves with points (talking points) in the discussion forum.

But you wouldn't do that, would you Oz? No, I didn't think so.

by msamson

Just so I can confirm...
OZ and I are separate carbon based entities...

Let there be no mistake... we few canadians always stand together!!!

eh!!

by dc_guy

Oz: Maxwell asked for speculations, so I gave him some. Alternative history is nothing more than science fiction. But yes indeed, our country seems to have rotted from the bottom up. People who grew up getting away with drunken driving and cheating on their income tax are now in charge of government, business, academia, church, and press. To me personally one of the worst aspects of that is that I'm starting to sound like my parents railing against Elvis Presley and the Trilateral Commission. Samson: Perhaps this is what is meant by "paradigm shift." Not only are we marching blindly into the Post-Industrial Age, but we've emerged from the bloodiest era in recorded history -- centuries of nearly constant warfare among the "Christian" nations -- into one which so far (media- and Homeland Security-hyped hysteria notwithstanding) is statistically the least bloody. Everything really is different now. The U.S. may appear to be the new dominant empire, but it does not have the political, business, or cultural leadership to sustain that position for even two more generations. And this is not Rome against the barbarians; the rest of you can stand up to us militarily if you need to. We will soon join the Soviets, British, Ottomans (and the myriad previous incarnations of the busy Mongols), Indians, Spaniards, Incas, Aztecs, Romans, Greeks, Persians, Chinese, Egyptians, and Babylonians in the Former World Powers Gentlemen's Club. Who will take our place? You Antipodeans, perhaps joined by a liberated Commonwealth? A miraculously united Europe or Latin America? An Islamic Enlightenment? If the Three Gorges Dam really works, will China be the first former world power to have a second chance? We really are doomed to "live during interesting times."

by maxwell edison

...probably more rhetorical in nature, as one could, most likely, surmise that the USA has been more of a positive force in the world than a negative one.

The way you "speculated" was really rather absurd, not to be taken seriously.

But I'll rephrase my question. Has the USA been more a positive force in the world, or more of a negative one?

by john_wills

which means that it has tremedous influence, which gives it an extra responsiblity to do things right, at home and abroad, a responsibility it is not holding to.

by oz_media

I know you don't care, but I think you have walked the razors edge.

Although your INTENTS may seem positive, many see them as negative.

I don't think anyone has actually started out with a negative intent on behalf of the USA, but there SEEMS to be very little resistance by the American people to political actions, whether positive or negative.

As I've said, America is not a BAD place, nor are the people within it. What I do see is a massive and powerful nation full of citizens who are scared to stad up for themselves after voting in a given administration. Once the vote is in, everything else is simply accepted whether right or wrong. As one person has said here, it is his duty to support his vote even if he disagrees with the president's actions, he voted for him and now MUST support him. Ludicrous.

by mrbill-

DC_GUY. Your assumption that Germany could have won WWI if we had not entered the war is stretching it. The US contributed to only a small part of the overall victory. Yes there were a few notable actions, the Marne for one. But not enough to drastically change the outcome, the war might have gone on longer but the Germany would have lost. The war reparations would still have crippled Germany resulting in the eventual rise of Hitler. The USSR would still have created a military jugernaught. Stalin craved power. WWII would still have happened, but without the Washington Naval Treaties of the 20s Germany would have had a larger Navy as would Japan. Britain would have been sweep aside, sorry chaps but it?s true. The Holocaust would have been worse, the Soviets had not love for the Jews. Germany would still have lost but it would have been because of the USSR, and then we could have seen how well Communism worked as it swept all of Europe and Afrika under its belt. Then the USSR would head east to deal with the other major power, Japan who would have had a hold on all of the Pacific and Asia. Ask China and Korea how fun it was to be under Imperialist Japanese rule. Imagine that arm reaching to Sydney, the ?rape of Bribane? may have been in the world news alongside Nanking, Seoul, Singapore, Delhi and anywhere the Japanese Army could reach.

But then all this is based on America not existing at all, including her resources and manpower, not very feasible. If anything it would still be under British rule then everything would be worse. GB might not have fallen and everyone would be sending tribute to London. Now that is something I shudder to think about.

by oz_media

I like your realization that the USA never WON WWII but definitely helped reverse the German advances. I have never claimed you weren't needed, wanted or appreciated for your efforts and actually my absolute FAVORITE DVD in my collection is the Band Of Brothers series. These brave men were depicted so well and events accurately told. I have spoken with several members of the 506th infantry who were depicted in BOB, via email, and they are TRULY heros although they would never see themselves as the heros before those who never returned.

As for your analogy of WHAT IF things had been different, although I accept you theories, they are simply that...THEORIES. I have heard completely different and just as believable theories as well as seeing a what if scenario on the History channel that showed Hitlers inability to succeed in conwuering England (as you noted) but the Russian events wer entirely different also.

Nice post but again, purely theoretical or speculative and not to be mistaken as fact.

by mrbill-

You are correct, I never said it was fact. As it never happened or never could have happened it is just the rambelings of an idiot. As are many post on here besides mine, and not just this one.

by cactus pete

We've split off a bit, haven't we?

For the record, the login creation scheme wasn't me. However, I have admitted before to being part of the reason why you don't get techpoints for reading articles anymore. I figured they would simply create another DB entry for articles you've read so you don't get point sthe second time you read it, but they just did away with this feature all together.

I currently have more than 4.2 million techpoints to spend. The only question I've ever asked was worth 50k, and I think all of the aliases mentioned in the above Maxwell post got a share... Unfortunately, the answers were few, and not from personal experience, so I didn't gain much that I didn't already know. But the points went out anyway. I can't believe more people didn't try!

by maxwell edison

.
WOW! All you have to do is create a second alias, ask yourself a question with a value of a million points, answer it yourself and poof, you leapfrog Chas, me, and everybody else to get to the top of the list. (Not that I'm suggesting anyone actually do it. That's not "the right thing to do", you know.)

By the way, I too have spent a bunch of my techpoints asking questions. A 50k question will indeed attract some attention, and I think I've asked a couple of dozen such high point questions. Some were real questions, some were fun questions. Actually, one of my high points questions generated so much attention that it compelled TechRepublic to reverse a site design decision they made.

(Yes, as usual, the thread has split into a couple of different directions.)

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "Although your intents may seem positive, many see them as negative."

Well, I sure can't disagree with that. However, I think that, for the most part, and I'm primarily talking about foreign policy affairs, the leaders of the USA do what they believe to be the right thing. (Regardless of their party, I might add. It used to be said, although this is less true today, that politics stops at the country's shores, and internationally we need to put up a united front.)

But it is said that you can't please all of the people all of the time. As an individual, I try to do what I consider to be the right thing, and I just let the chips fall where they may. Subsequently, as a nation, we should just do the right thing and let those chips fall where they may, and hopefully we make more good decisions than bad. (With domestic issues, it's a different story. Politicians often put the "right thing" on the back burner, far behind getting votes and campaign contributions.)

Are Americans blind followers of their leaders, as you've suggested? Well, yes and no, and some to a lesser or greater degree than others. I think domestically, the answer is an obvious and resounding no. (Even with foreign policy to some degree and in some cases.) To believe otherwise is naive'. We've removed our elected officials from office. We've changed their policy positions through the applying of pressure. We stopped the war in Vietnam. We've not reelected people. We've put our dishonest representatives in jail. We write letters to the editors. We write letters to our representatives. We go to town meetings. We protest in the streets.....shall I go on? (Of course this doesn't apply to ALL Americans, as only about half of us even bother to vote.)

When it comes to foreign policy, however, I'll admit that, with some obvious exceptions, you may be right. In fact, I've even mentioned more times than I can count, that I "hired" GWB to work for me and make decisions for me in areas in which I really have no knowledge - foreign affairs. I don't know what goes on behind the scenes in foreign embassies, nor do you, nor do most people. I don't know how to deal with the Chinese or the Russians or the Iraqis. And like any other good boss or business owner, if I'm lacking in such expertise, I hire someone to do it for me. If I wanted to have heart surgery, I sure wouldn't tell the surgeon how to do his or her job. So yep, when it comes to foreign affairs, I trust GWB to do the right thing. But that doesn't mean that I don't try to monitor things and educate myself on issues. What I really find amusing, however, is other people who are as equally ignorant as I am, go on and on and on, detailing what should be done with matters about which they have absolutely no clue as to what's really going on. (However, as I consider myself pretty savvy with domestic issues, I've found myself disagreeing with several of the president's domestic policy decisions. The latest one was just yesterday.)

So don't lump all Americans into a neat little description. Not only is it not true, but it pretty much invalidates your whole argument.

By the way, that last paragraph of yours seems like a direct contradiction to many of your previous claims that all Americans are obsessed with politics. Do you care to clarify this apparent contradiction?

by oz_media

I don't see it as a DIRECT contradiction to what I've said, if you're referring to my saying that American's vote and then support the vote no matter what, which may be out of embarrssment. I don't think this contradicts a statement regarding American citizens focusing thier lives on politics at all. You can still be focused on poiltics without voicing distaste for your decision. If that's what you meant.

I think if anything it SUPPORTS my statements. If one is focused only on his political preferences and stands for only a particular party at voting time, then that person would be even more intent on proving it was the right decision and would discount any errors made even though he/she knew better in the back of his/her mind.

I think that due to the importance of politics in the day to day lives of Americans, one would not admit to fault in political choices or would be too embarrassed to say they voted for BUSH not knowing what his aims were. A Democrat would eat these people alive!

In contrast, in Canada, we take politics very lightly, I think more people line up for the ice cream truck than to see Cretien (or more recently) Martin speak.

If I voted for a Canadian PM (I can't, but if I COULD)I wouldn't feel responsible for his actions at all. If he said he was going to lower taxes (and that was my reason for voting) but when in office, RAISED taxes, I'd admit to voting for and being deceived by the idiot, while humting him down. I wouldn't stand by him regardless of his actions if I thought he was wrong in his ways.
We don't hold much pride in voting or choosing the right candidate, they're all F-d up scammers, in Canada they are held one notch above a crack dealer in the MacDonalds Playground.

I think this is because it doesn't matter and nobody cares. We all know that politicians will BS their way into office and then the true colors are shown, it's been done since the dawn of the elective process I'm sure, however for all Cretien's faults, we were never at war and he is the only PM to balance our budget for years in a row (I don't want to know how), the biggest mistake was NAFTA but it is well kown he was practically bullied into the decision and was a spineless defender against American Way (but he spoke funny and smiled a lot so he was OK). We may not be so lucky with our latest joker though, we'll see I guess.

If I vote for someone (provincially I can vote), nobody cares, they don't even ask WHO I voted for because it doesn't matter to anyone.

In contrast to Canada or England I see America as being VERY politically charged and driven, the peolpe are politically focused and politics IS the American way. Now that's neither bad nor good but at least, as I've always said, keep it in your OWN backyard. Not much to ask, nobody else cares or wants to hear it, do your thing and we'll do ours. If people need to be removed from power, they ned to be removed from power. Don't expect the world to supoprt you based on fear of attack. If the USA had a reputation of only wanting what's best for those they interfere with, it would be different. With the USA seen as a war mongering, pushy and loud nation, it repels those whom you wish to side with.

Sorry to be lengthy or to ramble but that's me, thoughts flow, they don't get pondered.

OM

by mrbill-

I thought that in Canada, as in England, you don't vote for the PM. You vote for a party and if that party has majority, or can forge aliences giving majority, it gets to place the PM. In the States we directly, well sorta with the electorial college, select our prez. We have a more direct involvment than you so have more attachment.

by maxwell edison

.
...you've still got it all wrong.

Not all Americans focus their lives on politics, as you suggest. To the contrary, most do not. Like I mentioned, half of them don't even vote.

Just because there are some very vocal political animals around here, myself included, it doesn't mean it's representative of all Americans. So don't judge all Americans based on a couple of dozen people around here. (How many American TR members avoid these kinds of discussions like the plague? Lordinfidel, for instance.) And sure, the American news media certainly has a focus on politics and world affairs, but how many Americans choose to watch the Simpsons or Oprah Winfrey instead of the evening news? How many people read the sports page and the comics, and see the front page only at the bottom of their bird cage? Quite a few, I would suspect, on both counts. I would say that there are more sports enthusiasts in America than those interested in politics. (Of course, some, such as yours truly, are both.)

Your "embarrassment" comment - not even close. However, there are those die-in-the-wool partisans who will support their guy come hell or high water no matter what the issue. But that's really a rather small percentage of the voters. There are more swing voters in the middle that could negate anything those people do.

And you're mistaken about everyone supporting their guy regardless of the issue. Take me, for example. I don't support everything President Bush does, but yet you've accused me of "blindly following" him like a sheep. You are so way off base in that regard that it's silly.

As far as supporting a political party, i.e. being a partisan Democrat or Republican, there's a good reason for it considering the political system and process in place in the USA. The people who vote for the person, not the party, simply don't fully understand the process. And that's the majority of voters, in my observation. But that's not necessarily all bad either. Just like a pendulum of a clock that sways back and forth, the transfer of power from one party to another ensures that the extremists on either side don't get too strong a foothold. If one party takes something too far, the other party will, most likely, eventually gain enough control to bring it back in line.

And hey, I'd be happy to keep all this "political discussion" in my own backyard. But I just can't get you to go play someplace else. If you don't want to be exposed to it, just go away and don't get involved.

by oz_media

we are all just rambling idiots, that's how we talked ourselves into IT jobs. If we were actually a capable bunch, we'd have REAL jobs instead of certed roles in a field that's a complete mysetery to even the most knowledgeable staff. I think that our ability to find resources (like TR) is what makes us valuable, not knowledge, common sense or logic.

If those were requirements for IT, I'd still be laying under cars in someone else's shop!

I got good at finding free porn, then I had to get good at removing the viruses, startup programs, hijacks and ads.

Then I had to get free porn throughout my home, I learned networking. I then used my pronographically obtained skills to help some people out, then a company or two, then built websites for them and finally certed in Novell.

ANYONE here, including yourself, knows I'm just a snot nosed puke with an attitude. The thing is, at least I admit it, IT isn't brain surgery, most people never took the time that's all so people like us have laid back BS jobs with good pay.

But then again, so do the high school drop outs who landed union work or city jobs through parents or associates.

It's not what you know, it's who you know. as for IT, it's just a metter of finding out HWO knows the answer.

Like Eric Idle says, "How sweet to be an idiot, as harmless as a clown."

OM

by hal 9000

Is he the onew who appears in the Bundy Rum comeriacls over here in Australia?

I always thought he had a funny accent but now I understand.

by oz_media

I'm sure there's some good smiles there but I' haven't heard nor seen the Bundy Rum commercials.
They don't advertise alcohol in Canada, pretty much just Labatts, Kokanee and Molson Canadian beer, which I suppose SOME may classify as alcohol, but not a Brit.

In fact the running joke here, locally anyhow when you don't like someone, you just offer them a CAN of Kokanee. First of all it's CANNED beer, secondly it's our bottom feeder's brew.

"Hey can I offer you a beer" (stifled laugh).
"sure man THANKS!"
"Here you go" hand 'em a can of Kokanee
"Hey you A&%$&#E !! What the hell is this??"

by oz_media

A while back someone acused another post as being mine with a changed alias. I pointed out that CHANGING your alias, changes ALL your previous posts too.

I was just pointing out (either from relief or slight humor if you will)that someone else other than myself sees similar viewpoints. With the amount of US citizens I'm often up against with my views it is no wonder that I would really be happy to see a fellow Canadian with the opinion I have said many Canadians have towards US policies.

Especially after being told that people haven't heard another Canadian with my views.

Not a big deal Max, just a little over excitement on my part. :-)

by oldefar

Some interesting threads here.

When I was younger we all brought our own lunches to work. Every day at noon, we'd all sit in the back of the pickup trucks and eat our lunches. One guy, George, always griped as he opened his lunch pail. "Peanut butter and jelly again. Damn! I HATE peanut butter and jelly!"

After several weeks of this, the foreman finally had enough. "Hey George. Why don't you ask your wife to make you something else for lunch?"

"Aw, it wouldn't do any good" replied George.

"Why not?" asked the foreman.

George responded "I make my own lunch."

As I read all the threads that have drifted so far from the original post, I can't help but note that we all pack our own lunches here.

Oh, and for those of the Commonwealth persuasion, feel free to change peanut butter and jelly to whatever the most boring but most easily prepared common fare for lunch applies. Mutton and cheese, tinned meat, bangers and mash, or whatever.

Velcro gloves and leggings. I am still laughing over that, and may never take another cruise.

by hal 9000

Will Mutton and Mutton surfice.

But then again a lot of wat is called Lamb over here is actually Ram tough full of grisle and as hard as nails. It seems that what we kill here the best is sent overseas and we only get the rubbish.

Unless of course you want to take into account the Carniverious Molested sheep that have just been sent on the lattest cruse. The current Government has come up with a lot of proposals to prevent the same thing happening again but the main one is no more live sheep exports to Saudi Arabia but the Kiwi crew can remain. It seems that if the Prime Minister prevented Kiwis from crewing these ships he would be called "Racist." Now there is a case of PC gone mad.

by oz_media

"It seems that if the Prime Minister prevented Kiwis from crewing these ships he would be called Racist."

Well, I am an extremely Liberal and open person who is not offended by ANYTHING (other than my fat women in Spandex fears, 9 down and 3 more steps to go!), but if I was an Aussie who saw a sign reading "Now Hiring able bodied men to crew a ship no experienc eneccessary, must be able to sorta read and write, ability to speak is a definite asset. NO KIWIS NEED APPLY!" I may see it as a little bit racist. :-)

by oldefar

You got me, Colin. Of all the directions I thought this post could go or would go, the direction you have pushed it was last on my list.

I had a ton responses ready for almost everything else, obscure and useless facts prepared, even links if needed. But no, you and Oz had to keep coming back to the love of sheep!

Had I known the extent the Commonwealth has taken animal husbandry, or at least as it applies to sheep, I never would have tossed down the gauntlet!

by oz_media

You are right in that we vote in a party. The representatives of that party are still the reason for selection, not the party itself.

From what you imply, we would vote for a specific party that we suport without considering WHO will be in power. Is this how American's chose GWB? Those that are Republican in 1998 for example, would then stand by the party regardless of the representatives? I'm not being fecicous, I am asking an honest question.

by mrbill-

I?m not sure where you are coming from. Do you mean do we vote for a party regardless of who is the candidate for rep or senate so we get the prez? Then no, we vote for each individually along how we agree or not with their platform. Sometimes we cross parties to get the representation we want, this could cause a problem later as the prez and the house or senate may not see things along the same lines, then compromises between the ideological points of view would have to be made. If someone voted republican in 98 they do not have to agree with everything the party does, but they usually don?t have a problem because they voted that way based on the platforms, as long as the elected stays near enough to the platform. That does not mean the platform is set in stone, it can change due to events and such.

by oz_media

That statement can mean one of two things,
1) If you don't want to hear about politics, don't use TR.

2) If you don't want to hear about politics, don't participate in political discussions.

The first would be completely absurd to imply on anyone, I am sure that's not what you meant. If it is the second, you have a good point but that doesn't mean US politics aren't in my face every day. The people in these discussions have actually been some of the most 'normal', for lack of a better word, views I've heard. What I see, erad and hear on the street is completely different, pro-American, propaganda.

This started here a long time back, with me it was when discussing the Iraq war BEFORE it started, I believe even the Iran conflict first.

When I mentioned I was from England and didn't support GWB, I was jumped on immediately and told that I was lucky the US saved my ass. That's where it all began. I expressed PERSONAL dislike for GWB to which I was told I was unqualified as a non-American to voice my opinion, that's pretty dumb. If it's involving me and those around me, what I see, read and hear, then YES I am able to voice an opinion.

The reason YOU have come this far with me is because you adamantly support GWB for political reasons. You are unable to agree that my reasons for disliking him are valid, my opinions though adimttedly self formed are invalid and any information I find that supports MY veiws is also invalid or discounted as Democratic US hatred.

How do I voice an opinion without conflict if you are closed to accepting anothers views?

You are not wrong, I am FAR from wrong.

I believe what I've read, and seen is valid. the US report to congress speaks my mind quite well. It also iterates my point that the focus is on capital gains not Liberation. If the face has now turned to Liberation, I still don't buy it, as so many here were defending your actions as neccessary due to the impending attack from Saddam's WMD. I'm sure these people didn't create these ideas themselves and have learned them from presidential or related cabinet members speeches.
I then feel that people are blindly following BUSH because there is so much contrary opinion that show his motives otherwise. Those who thought the war was due to WMD, then STILL stood behind the effort as a Liberation war and never even started to wonder or contest WHY they were mislead by the politicians who deceived them into believing WMD were the target.

Now, without further debate, I know you don't feel this way, won't feel this way (even if GWB plants a flag and an AMOCO sogn in the Iraqi oil fields)and can't feel this way as you are admittedly firm with your convictions.

Therefore, you needlessly continue to argue the point that I am unqualified to speak on the subject, discount all of my opinions and my character as an unpatriotic and ANTI-american protester.

It doesn't matter which thread, there is almost always someone saying that the US should do this becuase... The US is better because.... the US should be followed because.... The US should have control because....Others should thank the US because.... etc.

The slightest HINT of this behaviour and I defend my beliefs that the US needs to humble herself and her people and just learn to become a country indstead of a den mother. Your drug, police, political, consumer, corporate problems and deficiencies are shown everywhere, but you (Americans in general) seem to feel America does no wrong, and has no wrong so it should be followed. You are the first to point out historical mistakes by other countries, yet the last to see your own current problems.

People, and I'm sure I speak for the MAJORITY (yet not all) of Canadians and Brit's here, are sick and tired of hearing about the US and president BUSH. You have chosen him, he has chosen the world as his stage, then it is in everyone's right to express thier views of him, not just America's views.

Like I said, if you were humble, nobody would care. Because you are so inexperienced as a nation and built from every other nation in the world, peolpe don't want to hear that you THINK you're better. If you do, that's fine, you're allowed pride in your country. Just wave your flag IN your country, or at the Olympics.

by hereinoz

Thanks for that Oz, I don't feel as sheepish now.

It's a good point. I have always said that what we need is a good bulls**t detector. Maybe that is something that us Commonwealthians have in common - dealing with Britain for so long we get a heightened level of Bulls**t detection and realise that our governments may not be gods, but they surely have feet of clay!!

Cheers,

Alan

by oldefar

Not sheep, but at least cows with feet of clay!
http://tinyurl.com/3ffmp

Here in Texas we also have a traditional folk dance to teach BS detection called the Texas Two-Step, done to the music "Cotton-eye Joe".

by maxwell edison

* Yep, it's door number two that I meant.

* If you're bombarded with pro-American propaganda every day in the streets of Vancouver (or wherever), just spend some time in a major American city, and you'll be exposed to plenty of anti-American propaganda. The "blame America first" crowd is, in my opinion, made up of enough Americans to make me sick.

* Where it all began - I remember all too well how your entrance to TechRepublic began. You and I may remember things a bit differently, but there's no point in discussing water that's well under the bridge. But you're not alone in your lack of support for GWB, and I've never held that against anyone if, of course, it was well reasoned and accurate in its assessment. But one of my pet peeves in these discussions is when someone states a false premise and subsequently builds an argument on that false premise. (Kinda' like the "fact" there's no heaven or hell in that other thread. An opinion built on a false premise, or at best, an inaccurate choice of words.) Maybe I'm naive' enough to think that I can change someone's mind if I can point out some flaws in their reasoning. Bit more often than not, too many people work backwards from a desired and predetermined conclusion, and they look for things that might support that desired conclusion. (Bass ackwards from how I form my opinions.) But you're as qualified as anyone to not support or to dislike GWB, just like I'm not crazy about that idiot Frenchman, Jacques "the crock" Chirac.

* You suggested that I support GWB for political reasons. Well, I suppose you're right. But I also support him, in some cases, for reasons of principle. However, I'm in disagreement with him on several of his issues. I disagree with his immigration plan released yesterday. I disagree with his prescription drug plan that was added to our already overburdened and fraud-infested Medicare system. He let Senator Kennedy write too much of the recent education bill. However, I believe he's acting on principle and convictions. But I don't think it's possible to agree with everything any individual office holder might do. And the people who are just dead wrong about GWB are the ones who question his intelligence and honesty. He's extremely smart, very savvy, and one of the most honest presidents we've had in a long time. (The WMD thing may have been a misstep, but it was a genuine concern.)

* You mentioned the validity of your reasons for disliking him were challenged by me. Well, I think this may be a case of seeing the same thing, but seeing something different from it. Again, using the WMD thing, many people, you included I suppose, would call him a liar over that, and discount anything and everything he says because of it. Whereas I, on the other hand, would say it was an unfortunate misstep that should be kept within the context of the entire Iraq issue. That was one reason out of a dozen or more, not the only reason, nor was it the primary reason. But that horse has long been flogged to death.

* On the information you find to support your views: See above statement on false premise equals flawed conclusion. Moreover, I don't "look for information to support my views". I do it in reverse order. I gather and study information, consider my values and principles, and then form an opinion accordingly. (Who does it bass ackwards, you or me?)

* You asked, "How do I voice an opinion without conflict if you are closed to accepting another's views?" Well, TheChas and I have disagreed on several issues, and we've never had such conflicts. I suppose it's the reason I stated above that leads to it. If I can point out where you may be mistaken about something, you won't reevaluate your position, but rather deny you made an error. (Here's an example, but one turning the tables, if I did what you've done. Discussion topic: What was the best muscle car ever made? I might say, since a 1969 Charger has a 500 hp, 525 c.i. V-12 engine, it's the best muscle car ever made. You might say, but Maxwell, it doesn't have a 500 hp V-12, it has a 375 hp 440 V-8 engine. I might then say that I have a right to my opinion. At which point you might just say, ooooooookay, or something much worse.) An opinion based on incorrect facts is, in my opinion, worthless. To make my point, president Bush never suggested that there was an "impending attack" (your exact words), as you have suggested. He never said it. He never said it. He never said it. He never said it. However, you're opinion is formed as though he did.

* I think this whole Iraq thing is bigger than you might want to see. Is it about oil? Yes. Is it about liberating the Iraqi people? Yes. Is it about making the world a safer place? Yes. Is it about finally doing something about rogue and dangerous regimes in the world? Yes. Is it part of the war on terrorism? Yes. Is it about transforming the war-plagued middle-east into a stable region similar to the transformation made in Europe? Yes. Is it about selfish United States' motives? A resounding no.

* I've never called you unpatriotic. Moreover, I think it would be strange if you were patriotic towards the USA. But you certainly have expressed your dislike for America and/or many things American. Surely you're not going to deny that.

* You said, "It doesn't matter which thread, there is almost always someone saying that the US should......". Well hold the phone there, bucko. Look at this Commonwealth thread and see who started the American (or anti-American) diversion. I've got news for you. It was the other way around. The blast-America came first. (I think Julian was the first, and you continued it.)

* You think I feel America does no wrong? Well, you've missed many many references to my complaints about various things. I think I might start a thread titled, what's wrong with America. (Okay, no one steal my thunder here. But give me time to gather some thoughts.) But yes, I do think the direction of world events needs to be changed. If you look at how things have progressed over the last thousand years, and look at them in only ten 100-year frames, we've only begun to turn the corner into creating a more harmonious world. I think that the USA has been more instrumental in achieving that desired end than any other major power in the last thousand years. And we've only been trying for a little over 50 years. Do I think the USA should follow a world that's been screwing it up for a thousand years, or do I think the world should follow a different kind of idea for a while? I think the latter is a better choice. Actually, I think isolationism is the better choice, but not practical in today's world economy.

* If your sick and tired about hearing about President Bush and the USA, go gripe to whatever Canadian media outlets bombards you with it. There's nothing I can do about it.

* Actually, President Bush didn't choose the world as his stage, as you suggested. He actually ran his campaign on domestic issues, while foreign policy was considered his weak point and something on which he didn't place much emphasis. But when some fanatics decided to steal our planes and crash them into our buildings killing our people, they are the ones who forced him onto the world stage. They brought this fight to us, not the other way around. And I'm grateful that President Bush has the onions to step-up and finally do something about it, where a half-dozen or more of his predecessors failed to respond.

* Yep, the USA was built by people from all over the world. We are indeed a nation of immigrants. But did these people come to America because things were better where they were? Of course not. America was built by people fleeing oppression and lack of opportunity. And because of those people, we now have the values that you, for some reason, despise. But get over it already. Or, just turn off the news and watch The Simpsons.

by oz_media

Ok Max, I have a hopeful feeling that we MAY actually be breaking new ground here and advancing in our discussion relationship.
Let's see if I can get this al together (similar format to keep it simple):

* Yep, it's door number two that I meant.
-I assumed so but had to confirm your intent

*If you're bobarded with pro_American propaganda...just spend some time in a major American city
-You should know I have spent a LOT of time in American cities. Even outside my business I have traveled America (not to what I consider extensively)more than MANY Americans have. Perhaps my focus was not in such a public way as paying attention to people's livelihoods but I have employed and worked with many Americans and have only ever seen a mutual view. For the most part, even with differing political views as to which party to support, the common "we are the leader, follow us" attitude was rampant.
This tells me, even though you say only half the population votes, that society in the USA is more 'comcerned' about politics than any other I've encountered.

NOTE: This may be entirely reletive to our daily lives. What you see as minimal or normal involvement may seem like infatuation to citizens of other countries.

* Where it all began -...
-If you're referring to my who is Max thread. I chose you selectively as you were one of the most prominent members and I was proving a point unrelated to TR. That wasn't where this all began though, I'd been around for a few months I think. As you say, it's irrelevant now and I again say it was a poor choice on my behalf and you were not being targeted in the manner you feel you were.

* You suggested...

by maxwell edison

.
Oz, you said, "Society in the USA is more concerned about politics than any other I've encountered."

Great - we agree. And while you consider it a bad thing, I consider it a good thing. No, I consider that a GREAT thing.

It's working! The great experiment is working!

As our greatest president, Abraham Lincoln, said, "that this nation under God shall have a new birth of freedom, and that government of the people, by the people, for the people shall
not perish from the earth."

Of the people, by the people, for the people. We in the USA run our own government, and that is the way we want it; while those in other countries are run by their government, which is, I suppose, the way they (and you) want it. No wonder we have such a different perspective on this.

Thank you Mr. Lincoln. Thank you Mr. Jefferson. Thank you Mr. Madison. Thank you Mr. Washington. I wouldn't want it any other way.

by oz_media

I guess I can't pat my head and rub my tummy at the same time anymore. I was paying attention to my post but not the fact that I hit submit. In case space runs short, I'll just continue here.

* You suggested... most honest presidents we've had in a long time. (The WMD thing may have been a misstep, but it was a genuine concern.)
-I've never heard you agree to the 'mistep'of WMD, I've only heard you deny it was said (which it may not have been). Although you've been quite evasive when I say it was implied. I don't think I said GWV 'lied' about it, I remember someone else had, but I have said he 'mislead' American citizens and was surprised at the inbending support he was still receiving. I feel US/IRAQ history points to this conflict being to gain American control of US oil and petroleum companies rallying against him also supports my suspicions. To see such political conviction supporting GWB, without questioning him, blows my mind, especially after the WMD dispute. This I believe was one of my original disagreements here.

*You mentioned the validity ...
-see above

* On the information you find to support your views:...
-I am a person of feeling and personal awareness(inner faith), a touchy-feely guy (probably what has made me mechanically capable). If I see or feel something, I am then 'qualified' to comment on my thoughts, this is not stating fact it is stating 'qualified' opinion. If that opinion is wrongly challenged, I am usually pushed to provide 'evidence' of my thoughts. It usually doesn't take long to find several like minded opinions in response, which incidentally are quickly disregarded by the reader as biased or left-wing BUSH haters. Obviously someone who doesn't support Bush could be seen as a Bush hater. Why would that also make them unqualified opinions?

* You asked...However, you're opinion is formed as though he did.
-I have agreed that he may not have said this himself, however it wasimplied or stated by members of the presidential administartion. These members represent GWB and the Republican Administration, I'm sure they don't speak freely without prewritten and approved speeches. It seems so long ago now, yet I ot that impression from the presidential speeches as did so many millions of Americans. One peer was defending the WMD threat here by saying I would let my children suffer "help it burns it burns". This wa also a member current member of the US military in a southern state. How could such a person who is directly involved with the miitary not have been under the understanding of a WMD threat unless told so?

* I think this whole Iraq thing ...A resounding no.
-I agree almost completely yet you have never admitted this was about or even slightly related to oil before, no matter how much I've said it is an underlying reason it has been denied or evaded.
I understand there were many reasons and have said myself that Saddam needed to be removed. I just disagreed with the 'reasons' used to support the decision (WMD)and expediting the invasion, against allied wishes by which may have lead to more lives lost. This is a GLOBAL war on terrorism, not just America's.

* I've never called you unpatriotic.
-Firstly, I can't see where I said YOU considered me unpatriotic but you are well aware that there are those who have.

* You said, "It doesn't matter which thread,
-maybe I've faced offense for so long that I read too much into the discussion. I may have seen it as an American's clever shot at the British Commonwealth as a way to retaliate at anti-American sentiments and prove America's independance as superiority.
My response was somewhat passive though, as I was thinking of a Monty Python sketch where one guy says "I hear Nixon had an asshole transplant, the asshole rejected him". Thinking that the Commwealth being chuckled at, so was the US.
I can laugh at anything, as long as others can too.

* You think I feel America does no wrong?
-You've been very open about your distaste for some policies. I was referring to those who, as above, stand TOO proud.

* If your sick and tired about hearing about ...there's nothing I can do about it.
-I know and wouldn't expect you to. You wonder where my distaste stems from. I think America is too loud and needs to lower the volume, no other country dominates world news as you do, even during peace time.

* Actually, President Bush didn't choose...while foreign policy was considered his weak point.... (NO KIDDING)
...But when some fanatics decided to steal our planes and crash them into our buildings killing our people,...And I'm grateful that President Bush has the onions to step-up and finally do something about it, where a half-dozen or more of his predecessors failed to respond.

-I'm almost positive you've said that the WTC and Iraqi invasion are not related, if not others have. It was voiced as WMD and then changed to Liberation. As for the past presidents not acting on terrorism that's is true. Something SHOULD have been done long ago but it wasn't. In fact reports noo say that good ole Ronnie sat idly by and supprted the Iraq Iran conflict with full knowledge that Saddam was using WMD. I still don't see this as an excuse for the reasoning used to justify an immediate and greatly unsupported invasion.

* Yep, the USA was built by people from all over the world....watch The Simpsons.
-It is often implied that the US is so independant and peers are constantly downplaying the other countries from which they originated. A little respect for your origins would be kind, especially when expecting unquestioned support from these countries. To slag others and then expect them to join forces with you or face further slagging is uncalled for. As for watching the Simpsons, I've followed Matt Groening since the Life In Hell cartoons done for the Georgia Straight (Independant Vancouver music and events rag), the Simpsons used to be Two Bunnies, then two little guys with a fez on and then The Simpsons.
BUT NOW IT'S AN AMERICAN TV SHOW!!! ARRRRRRRRRRRRRGH! Just jooking, I usually don't get too much TV time, when I do get to chuckle at cartoons, The Family Guy is my most recent fav. but I still download those OLD Looney Tunes and Tom&Jerry toons. In fact I just found some banned WWII propaganda cartoons, where the US was campaiging for paople to happily save to pay taxes and buy war bonds. These of course were not intended for children but were aired in those long Saturdays at the pictures. Another shows how NAZI's train children to become NAZI's from birth and how thay are the terror to be destroyed. Amusing now, but I'm sure very scary at the time.

So..where are we. I guess at the point where all the laundry is aired and it's time to agree to disagree. Maybe we should come up with a secret 'safe' word for furture discussions, like dominatrix's do before a torture session so they know when to stop. (No I haven't, don't ask)

by oz_media

other than the fact I said my spelling would be a new years resolution, I've made several, but this is purely a grammar mistake.

In my last post, I said: "I feel US/IRAQ history points to this conflict being to gain American control of US oil and petroleum companies rallying against him also supports my suspicions."

I should have explained that in greater detail: I feel that the history between the US & IRAQ points toward this conflict being to gain American control of Iraqi's vast wealth of oil which is restricted from direct sale to the US.

I was unaware of this until seeing local petroleum companies protesting GWB for witholding millions they felt they were owed from the Oil-for-food program.

I then researched the topic and found proof in the U.S.Embassy's report to Congress. As all of this was brought to my attention, WMD were still unproven (as doubted by many since before the invasion)and my original beliefs were strengthened as events unfolded.

Everyone knows that America, just like almost any country, is highly motivated by monetary gain, wealth and power. With all of the other reasons that support the action of removing this tyrant, it is almost impossible not to seize the opportunity.

Go ahead and tell the world that we are going to invade and remove this horrible man and in return will gain billions in oil. This will drop gas prices (well could and should, but WILL it?), Liberate Iraq and create a sound Democratic government, a respectable school system (not that they'rs uneducated), modern hospitals and at the same time destroy a terrorist cell,

Now you have everyone on your side, the gas alone would be enough for most, the worlds resources could be fairly distributed, Iraq would become a first world country (they could even plant fake grass and build a golf couse with a waterfell).

I would be behind the operation without any questionand with full support.

Taking a questionable intelligence into a world forum and asking for support due to unconfirmed but expected WMD is not being straight up at all. It's not lies, you're right, it's deception.

When IMMEDIATE support was denied and further evidence needed, the wishes were ignored, public was warned of WMD and then lead to believe they could be unleashed in an attack on the USA. Although I saw many reports question Saddams ability to launch this far with his arms, it was still not discounted. America was under attack (as the WTC had already shown) and America launched Attack on Iraq.

Like I said, this is a completely fine, understandable and justified cause and result, everyone wins except Saddam and his fellow terrorists. It sets an example that actions will be taken to stop terrorism, many other groups are much smaller than Saddam's, they will soon be removed too, then Bin Laden (hopefully before more terrorism).

It also sets the example that despite pacts and promises of alliance and world unity, despite the fact that the war on terrorism is a global issue with a team of allied forces, that the USA will do as it wishes without hesitation. England wasn't much better but at least TB came out and expressed he may be misinformed of WMD, he was going to support the war to liberate the people of Iraq and support the 350,000 Iraqi exiles who pleadedwith him to remove Saddam's regime and help to free Iraq.

I've said over and over again, it's not the action it was the premature-action. Some say the UN wasn't effective in inspections, the last actions by the UN in Iraq turnesd up unused warheads, how is that ineffective?

Had there been further findings, or resistance from Saddam at this point, I'm sure allied support would have been stronger as any denial would then be seen as favoritism for Saddam.

Like I said, that's my take Max. I had ideas, I heard reports and found opinions that confirmed my iedas. To that extent, why would I take notice YOUR findings, you wouldn't agree to mine.

My sources are as credible to me as your are to you. Yours state mine are incorrect, mine state yours are incorrect.

Are you to say you are privvy to the truth, even if more politically savvy? (There isn't two V's in Privy is there?) That looks wierd with the savvy after it. I wonder how many two V'd words we could put together in another thread if every sentence needed a double-V word but words could be repeated?

I say this after pleading my sanity in my beliefs!

by maxwell edison

.
As I said earlier, it's about a lot of things, not just one. And as I've mentioned on more than one occasion, yes, oil is certainly part of the equation.

But when the naysayers say "it's all about oil", they like to suggest that the USA is stealing Iraqi oil and putting it under our Texas mattresses, I suppose. But they're wrong. The oil variable is for the benefit of the Iraqis, not the Texans.

Maintaining the free flow of oil from the middle east benefits not only the Iraqi people, but the rest of the world as well.

But it's Iraqi oil, not American oil, and instead of using the proceeds of the sale of that oil to line the pockets of the thugs, help finance terrorism, build more palaces for Saddam, and so on, it will be used to help bring the Iraqi people some prosperity and stability.

Oil is one part of the equation, not the only one. So don't take our "agreement" out of context or assume I'm suggesting something that I'm not. There's nothing sinister about it at all. To suggest that America is somehow stealing Iraqi oil is ridiculous.

by oz_media

I don't think America is stealing anything, even I would doubt that was an objective of GWB's. I don't think he's a bad person, just a bad leader. I'm sure he is MUCH more qualified for his position than any one of us as he well should be. I just don't agree with his methods, not neccesarily his motives.

Here's MY take and again, only MY views. American petroleum companies would be pretty excited to get a hold on oil development, research and control of distribution of Iraqi oil. This nobody can deny. They would gain massive benefits by eliminating third party trading and the whole oil-for-food program that they feel has let them down. From what I understand as a result of local petroleum protests is that they have invested millions if not bilions of dollars into the O-F-F program and seen no return on investment. Now this isn't from a websites, a democratic underground, Fox, CNN etc. This is my neighbours and local business owners who have been prompted into action by thier suppliers such as Petro Canada and Texaco/Chevron Oil. Talking with a friend at PC Oil, I was told that the company hd invested millions with a promised return that was yet to be seen. Stock holders were furious and market prices were on a rollercoaster ride.

Not speculation, in front of my eyes. To me, if I touch it, feel it an/or see it, it is more realistic than mere words on a website or a carefuly and profesionally written public address fro a politician whos MAIN goal is to keep the support of his people. Now, an important note: The oilf for food program s a UN program not a US program. I believe it was put into effect as Saddam had cut off US ability to purchase large amounts of oil and to keep the USA out of the oil picture. It was then agreed that Iraq would provide smaller countries with oil in return for much needed goods and supplies entering Iraq.
The USA was in charge of inspecting these goods in case they could be classified as dual purpose goods. The US was not inspecting goods in a timely fashion which in turn starved Iraqi's of much needed food and medical supplies, now it is also said that even WITH these supplies being let through, Saddam was not distributing them effectively, but that's neither here nor there if the supplies were held by the USA to begin with.

Saddam felt (probably rightfully so) that he was being controlled by the USA and refused to let an entirely US led UN inspectors in his country. After a little back and forth, he allowed te UN to inspect where they successfully found empty and unused war heads that COULD have been used to send a chemical payload against Iraq's enemy. More recent news says this was known during Reagan's term but ignored as he was supporting Iraq's fight on Iran.

It is in Corporate America's best interests to gain control of Iraq's oil distribution, no doubt much of the wealth will be seen in Iraq yet much will also be for US petroleum corporations that have been unable to aquire oil directly from Iraq in large quantity.

This removes the need for third party trading, removes the suspected dual-purpose imports to Iraq, removes a tyrant and frees the people.

All in all it is a fantastic and long overdue idea. This is capitol gain that ANY country with any common sense would take interest in. Everyone wins, especially the US corporations. This isn't WRONG, this isn't unjust, this isn't stealing anything. You liberate a country and benefit from it's resouces while sharing those benefits with the country you've saved, good for you! The US will rightly receive a great return on it's WAR investment and will recover the costs of the invasion, it is only logic.

The war was not sold on this premise, people would see capitol gain as wrong. You've said yourself that most people don't agree with right-wing or capitalistic actions and most lean to the left.

America is the biggest consumer of fear that I've even encountered. Whether in movies, ghetto's or anywhere else, fear sells. Instilling fear into American citizens sells them on a political move of such magnitude, with the effects on US citizens from 911, this is all the more feasible.

If GWB had openly stated that it was in America's best interests to remove saddam from power, free the peolpe of Iraq and gain much needed control of Iraqi oil deposits and exploration, they may not fully support the effort once the cost to taxpayers is aired. Having them FEAR Iraq, will justify the cause.

This is common sense, not stories, not a what if, not American hatred, not Anti-Bush sentiment.

I fully support action to remove Saddam and liberate Iraqi peolpe. It is a daunting and important task, not to mention extramely humane.

The justification is not. I see it as a weak yet effective way to deceive or mislead people into seeing ONE side and not all side of he ultimate goal.

You disagree, I agree. You're stibborn as hell when it comes to changing your beliefs or views, so am I until PROVEN otherwise.

We will have to just agree to disagree and see where things land in the next tow or three years. Perhaps the Iraq conflict will be somewhat reduced in the next year or so and we will start to see positive change. As of yet, even though action is being taken, little POSITIVE has come out of this other than the removal of Saddam and the repression, yet not removal, of the terrorists that followed his cause.

by oz_media

Martin, if they find out you're my neighbour, there's noo doot aboot it that all hell will break loose!

On another note, do you really think that Starbucks even holds a candle to Tim Hortons?

In Seattle last weekend, I was forced to go to Starbucks, who I despise up here, but the lack of a good Timmy's had me choking back the black slop from the imposters. ACK!

by oldefar

A northwest invention intended for those who do not like coffee. Having tried it once, I couldn't help but wonder if the beans were those picked by civet cats and collected and processed after passing through their digestive tracks (and you thought your job was bad).

Horton's coffee is a close approximation of the excellent Dunkin Donut brew, something we've had here in the states since back in 1950 when Tim was still learning about the boards in Boston Gardens and the squid at the Red Barn. However, I do like his donuts better.

by oz_media

If you're referring to the Coffee at Dunkin Doghnuts, I don't like it either.

Actually, I had to give up caffeine last year. I now am a decaf mocha guy (I sneakin the odd French Roast here and there).

I was having severe anxiety atacks, after owning a high end ezpresso machine, and found out that I had actually developed an allergic reaction to caffeine. Decaf these days is OK though, I had horrible fears of drinking SANKA for a while but then realized that coffe has come a long way since the Sanka days.

Tim Horton's is off my list now, I just can't drink a regular decaf. My friends owns an espresso and caterong business, I built him a very simple website and now my daily decaf mocha's are on the house, I've had friends say they couldn't tell the difference between that and a regular mocha.
Cheers to In A Rush Cartering!

Maybe if Canada put ALL of thier forces together, we could invade Starbucks in Seattle and liberate Americans with a little Tim Horton's. Nah, there's WAY too many Starbucks for the Canadian army to take on and we'd never find GWB in HIS underground hidey-hole, Texas is a BIIIIIIIG place!

by hal 9000

You have stoped a perfectly good tangent being pursued that had absolutely ne bearing on the original topic.

Naughty boy now get ready to have you're wrists slapped for doing this.

by oz_media

We know all aboot slaps on the wrist, eh.
They call it our judicial system. :-)

OM

by oldefar

It wasn't done in Texas until the big migration of firms from the rust belt to the south.

Line dancing was a good way to get a fight started with the cowboys and goat ropers at the Dunbar in West Texas (although just being a Yankee was usually enough for the fights to break out).

By the way, Forest got it wrong. Life is like a jar of jalepinos, you never know which one is going to burn your arse.

by oz_media

Well I see line dancing as originating with Hitler's goose step.

Either that or Donnie and Marie, it's a little bit country, a little bit rock n roll. Just as Shania's music is, it has no real place. Shania is great don't get me wrong. Mutt Lang's influence has put her OUT of rock n roll and also OUT of country. It's country music with Mutt's trademark drum sound found throughout all the Def Leopard tunes.

I see line dancing as a way of letting white people dance without looking dumb, or so they think. If you do as I do, nobody will look at you, better still, why don't we ALL stand beside one another then we can't see each others mistakes and awkward attempts at white rhythm?

Pink Floyd describes it best in the album Animals with thier mulitple versions of SHEEP and DOGS that covers thier ideas of clones (SHEEP) and government officials (DOGS).
SHEEP
"Meek and obedient you follow the leader
Down well trodden corridors into the valley of steel
What a surprise!
A look of terminal shock in your eyes
Now things are really what they seem
No, this is no bad dream."

-Roger Waters

DOGS

"And after a while, you can work on points for style
Like the club tie, and the firm handshake
A certain look in the eye and an easy smile
You have to be trusted by the people that you lie to
So that when they turn their backs on you
You'll get the chance to put the knife in

You gotta keep one eye looking over your shoulder
You know it's going to get harder and harder and
harder as you get older
And in the end you'll pack up and fly down south
Hide your head in the sand
Just another old man
All alone and dying of cancer ...

...Deaf dumb and blind, you just keep on pretending
That everyone's expendable and no one has a real
friend
And it seems to you the thing to do
Would be to isolate the winner
And everything's done under the sun
And you believe at heart, everyone's a killer"

by hal 9000

It was good for a laugh wasn't it?

I have a Kiwi friend who tells me a lot of these things like what do you call a bunch of Kiwi's sitting around a TV watching "Football." The All Blacks NZ's national football team.

Or then there is the one where the All Blacks came out and played the worst game of football ever possible and some bright spark anounced that they had been driven past a "Shinnies Hideout" {this croud makes sheep skin seat covers and the like} and they where told this is what we did to sheep here in Australia. Apparently they where so upset that they couldn't play football that night or for the rest of the tour and required massive councilling to cure them of their fears of the Aussie Team.

Col

by hal 9000

Australia than in NZ.

It is all because of their National Anthem whos chorus goes something like this "God Loves New Zealand he gave us boiling mud etc."

The there is the final verse which says something similar to this "God Loves New Zealand he gave us Australia because you can't live in bloody boiling mud!"

But on a more serrious note there are a lot of Kiwi's over here as untill recently you didn't need a pasport to travel between the two countries and there was no travel restrictions on Kiwi's or any records held on those who just stayed on so with cheaper cars and a better standard of living most of them just stay.

On the other hand the New Zealand Prime Minister was subject to a search recently when she came to Australia to visit and apparently the Custom's Officers didn't know who she was. She took it all well with no complaint but it is rumoutred that when she returned home she imediatly placed the entire Australian Government on Newe Zelands "Most Wanted" list and it is interesating that no current Australian polly has been there since. It seems that they are affraid of "Body Cavity" searches and detintion for 7 days until they completly empty the contents of their bodies into buckets so they can be inspected not to mention the "Laxatives" in all the food that they are provided with." This was after an "Official Appoligy" I don't know what would have happened if that had not been forth comming as our Prime Minister has some trouble saying "I'm Sorry!"

Perhaps they would have done a French style thing and sent in NZ opperatives to "Kidnapp" all the Aussie pollies but then again we being a nation very interested in politics nobody would have noticed until it came time for the pollies to vote themselves another pay rise and when no one showed up to vote on this it would have come to our attention but we wouldn't have worried about it knowing that "Bad Pennies" always return.

by hal 9000

Laidley in the country to "Fit a Scanner" a somewhat easy job that ended up requiring a total reload of a Rual Fire Services computer so I was there for quite some time and they shouted me dinner at a local pub whose specialty was "Roast Lamb" that was grown by Kiwi's slaughtered by Kiwi's and cooked by Kiwi's or so I was told.

When the meal was served they asked did I want to know what the brown stuff all over the meat was and when I declined the girl said "Good and I will not tell you what that clear jelly like stuff is with bits of green in it!" Still it tasted OK so I'm not complaining.

by oldefar

Always a good policy for pub fare.

So the secret Commonwealth plan is to what? Convert Americans to eating McMutton sandwiches, and once we're hooked disclose what's in the new "special" sauce and starve us right out?

I am already avoiding the mixed juice drinks that include Kiwi now! And I sticking with 100% cotton and petroleum based synthetics for all my clothes! Virgin wool sweaters? Not in my closets!!

by hal 9000

Answer to McDonalds watch out for the new fast food take away store opening soon selling only Kiwi bred or looked after sheep.

Did you hear the one about the little fenced off area in a field? When the Kiwi owner was asked about it he replied that is the first place I ever had sex. The person then looked around and saw another fenced off area and asked what that was all about and the reply came straight back that is where her mother was standing. Shocked the person asked what did her mother have to say about this happening right in front of her and thew Kiwi replied Baaaa!

Then there is the true one about what was considered suitable punishment for breaking some Catholic rules. The first one was 7 years penence for raping a Nun. But if you had sex with an animal you had to serve 25 years penence so I guess that goes a long way to explain just why there are so few good Catholics in New Zeland.

by hal 9000

Not Commonwealth Plot as at the recent Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting or as it ids known within the Commonwealth countries "CHOG" they find very little to agree about and they even spent 2 weeks attempting to decide if Zimbarbai was to be expelled from the Commonwealth or just slapped on the wrists again with no conclusion reached.

Mc Mutton will come from New Zeland as a payback for not telling them if US Navy ships have any "Specials" on them as New Zeland isn't happy enough with only refusing docking privileges to American War Ships they want to go on the offensive to prove their point and keep New Zeland a Nuclear Free Zone, remember that have already had a bad experience with France sinking the Rainbow Warrior while it was in a NZ harbour.

by oz_media

Several US ships were intown last year, one was a neuclear powered sub. Now there are TWO reasons it didn't enter Vancouver harbour.

1) Tides under the lions gate bridge were too high and when they were low, large tankers have the first docking priveledges.

2) Vancouver is a meuclear free zone. This isn't the first time, US naval vessels have been disallowed from entering Vancouvers harbour.

The Constellation (destroyer?) (I think that's what the name was) docked here for a few days. Canadians are so against military vessels in he harbour, the tours went unattended for several days, with exception of Vancouver's ladies of the night who were welcomed with open arms as they filled thier pocketboooks. I've heard US sailors say they just don't make women like they do in Vancouver. (Now that could mean a bunch of things but I supose he was talking about them being just fine. He had two in tow as he stumbled out of Mugs and Jugs).

This discussion is closed to new replies.