Discussion Locked

27" Snowfall. . .Heaviest on Record. . .Global Warming Out Of Control

0 helpful
238 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

238 replies

by jaqui

who Jacqui is.

what for do you think I have designed fusion bombs for?
they cross the line, I turn most of the US of A into radioactive crater. ]:)

by absolutely

"The time from start of snowfall to end wasn't measured in 1947."

The rest of your message was clear, but this sentence is suspicious. You didn't really mean that the "time from start of snowfall to end wasn't measured in 1947." Do you mean that the 1947 "record" was for all snow that fell in 1947, because they didn't measure the time from start of snowfall to end -- at all?

"Just change the facts to fit your opinions... "

Do you assert that stating facts vaguely is a valid method of proving a premise? That is what you did.

by tonythetiger

They can by choice be artificially terminated for someone's convenience; or artificially kept alive to make sure their weak genes propagate so we can keep the medical profession in business.

by jdclyde

it is something in their DNA that is having them intentionally put themselves at risk? If you stand in the middle of a busy road and then get hit by a car, is it really an "accident"?

Not long ago someone (don't remember who) proposed that MAYBE homosexuality is INTENTIONAL in nature as a way to control the population of the herd. I had never heard that before, and have not seen anything even REMOTELY resembling a reputable study on this.

Would it all fit?

That "little voice" inside us DOES influence us. MOST of the times criminals get caught, isn't because of GREAT detective work but because they BRAG about it to other people who snitch them out. A subconsious desire to be caught and punished?

Sure, the stronger of the human race can try to protect the weaker, but can you really save people from themselves?

Do you have a better explanation for people building their homes in a place that they know WILL be flooded, they just don't know WHEN. Sounds like a major mental flaw to me.

by tonythetiger

"What is the relationship between the two groups? I don't see one."

It's a common politic.

"Anyway, at which point do you decide that it's not worth keeping a baby alive? Two heads? Thalidomide baby? Spina Bifida? Learning difficulties? Hare lip? Squint? Black?"

I don't 'decide'. I just get to question the motives of those who do.

How can it be ethical to be against the killing of a cold-blooded murderer but for the killing of an innocent child? Slippery slope? ... we're already on it!

by jdclyde

MANY that came to the US were the scum of the land because it was cheaper and easier to ship prisoners to "the new land" than it was to jail them. The prisioners liked this option better than sitting in a prision as well.

There has NEVER been anything in the start of our history to show that the SETTLERS were brights. Many wanted a chance to own land because they had NO chance in Europe, but that is self-interest, not brightness.

Over the last century on the other hand, many of the brightest DID come here because it was better than being stuck in a Communist state where they and their families would and could disapear if they didn't do as they were told.

by x-marcap

Enlightened self interest is very intelligent.

The settlers that I am referring to were the people who moved West from the East coast of the US. They had to be a bit brighter than the average bear to survive. Most people today couldn't survive in the wildernes much less make a life there.

They were either blessed with greater intelligence or greater courage. They all wanted a better life for their children and themselves.

Look the average IQ is much higher in Australia than London. The criminal class isn't always stupid...

Greed will only get you so far.

Stupidity is usually its own reward.

I have read the history of the US, and the rest of the world... Fairly consistantly, the top college graduates from the 1800's moved to the interior. This was parodied in movies like Paleface and Son of Paleface. Arguably, the greatest hospitals are in the interior of the US. Mayo, Cleveland Clinic, etc...

Now, there is a brain drain in the US to the southwest, and west coast. These bright people are complimented by some of the stupidest people that have ever been allowed to procreate on God's Earth just to balance them out.

by jamesrl

Many of first large scale settlements from England had a very high proportion of religious zealots. These were the people who supported radical church reform - they thought the Church of England was not strict enough and that English society was too permissive. Many of their like minded peers who stayed in England became supporters of Cromwell.

The first French settlers, about the same time as the Pilgrims, were either poor peasant farmers or aristocrats - the early French settlements were modelled on the same feudal system that was still prevelant in France at the time.

Funny my ancestors came here under threat of jail too - in the Clearances in Scotland, if the Laird(often english) wanted you to quit the land you rented without worrying about any signed agreements or prepaid rents, he would have the local magistrate(often english) talk to the local authorities and have someone come round the house to tell you that you stood accused of being a horse thief. There didn't have to be any basis in fact. He would tell you that he would be by the next day to take you in front of the magistrate. Most families packed up, sold their posessesions and bought passage out of Scotland.

James

by Member 25348569

But I might as well give you my views.

It's not "killing a defenceless child". It's an embyo. It might - just - be a foetus.

Unless you believe in some "divine spark at conception" or that the "immortal soul" is present at 12 weeks gestation then your comment is worthless cant. If you [b]do[/b] believe then good for you. If you're not a Christian and have the ethical viewpoint that abortion is wrong then you still have no right to subject another to your will. If you are a Christian and this is a moral viewpoint then you especially have no right to subject another to the will derived from the flawed interpretation of the words of an imaginary being.

The problem with the death penalty is not really moral. It just doesn't work at all. It [b]is[/b] economically sound to execute murderers but you can't even get that right in the US because you let the lawyers feed off it to bursting point.

by jdclyde

things would be different if the US and Candian oil would STAY in the US and Canada.

It is inexcusable for Canadian gas prices to be adversly affected by the world market like it is. They must have greedy oil men up in Canada too?

We do always hear about Bush and his oil buddies, but as we are small potatos in the oil industry, maybe it is time the very very far left took a look at who the REAL corrupt oil men of the world are?

by jaqui

there is but one Canadian owned oil company, the rest are international companies..SHELL, Chevron, Esso, Texaco, ARCO

all but one of which are US OWNED.

Canadian Gas prices are dictated by greedy us oilmen.

and the one Canadian owned company?
Pierre Eliott Treudeau Rips Off CANada = PETROCAN
so naturally they follow the gouging by the greedy oil barons.

by jdclyde

if you LET them.

The FIRST thing they teach you in safety training for around water is that protect yourself FIRST or you will both die.

If someone climbs on you or wraps you up, you DIVE down and they will let go to get back to the surface.

It looks like nature threw them in the deep end and we could only save so many from themselves.

Just last week, people living off the Government because of this are now starting to get the free meal ticket to expire and they will HAVE to start fending for themselves.

They expect US to pay for EVERYTHING, from the rebuilding to completely supporting them while they are here.

The unemployment rate in N.O. is UNDER 3%. There IS work, they just need to go do it. Or is it out fault that living in the great welfare state created by the Demcorats that completely controlled that state, they have NO SKILLS?

by tonythetiger

"...you still have no right to subject another to your will."

I don't 'decide'. I just get to question the motives of those who do.

by jdclyde

Not Sally the HUTT! :O

[i]
"do you want some cheezy poofs dear?"
"Yes, I want some cheesy poofs!"

"sweet!"

by montgomery gator

We could take the liberals and throw them into the vats with all the other organic waste and convert them to biodiesel fuels. Supposedly there is technology that will take any organic matter and convert it into Diesel fuel. I am making the assumption that liberals are carbon-based organic life forms, and therefore could be convertible to biodiesel fuel. We could probably get enough biodiesel from the biomass that make up Ted Kennedy and Michael Moore to fuel a 18-wheeler on a cross-country trip from the Atlantic to the Pacific coasts.

by absolutely

on conservatives.

Did you know that the chief executive of the company waging war on Iraq doesn't know the [b]first thing[/b] about wielding a gun? He shot his own hunting companion, and he runs Halliburton.

c - o - r - r - u - p - t - i - o - n

Last person able to tell what that spells is Dan Quayle.

by Member 25348569

I would like to think that we're all just logical, cool, calculating silicon-based lifeforms with none of the human failings of you emotional religious type.

I suppose, though, that History - especially Christian History - has long since proven that we're not so and, in fact, heretics and witches burn rather well.

Be warned, though - http://tinyurl.com/c5xuw

by Member 25348569

How is killing people - supporting the death penalty - and anti-abortion - forcing women to go to term against their will - [b]not[/b] forcing your will on someone else.

How is not killing people - against the death penalty - and pro-choice - not forcing women one way or the other - forcing your will on someone else.

Do you not have it a bit backwards?

by tonythetiger

forcing anyone to do or not do anything? Nobody is subject to my will. If they decide on a particular action or inaction based on my opinion, that's them doing (or not doing) it, not my will!

You may have that power, but I don't.

by Member 25348569

You said - "I just get to question the motives of those who do".

My question is "do what?". As far as I can see, at least from the abortion/death penalty issue that you rather puzzlingly raised, the people whose motives you appear to question are those that [b]don't[/b] want to force people.

From the point of view of Global Warming, yes, I could see where you might be coming from but as I don't link the two groups in the same way that you do, I don't.

Walks away, scratching head...

by jardinier

I regard it as contraception after the event.

What the idiot misguided pro-lifers don't take into account is what kind of life these unwanted children might expect when they are born to parents who do not have the wherewithal to provide for them.

As far as I am concerned the potential social nightmare that would result if ALL ABORTIONS ceased, would far outweigh any moral or ethical considerations.

If there are any anti-Bush fans listening, please also remember that it was the pro-lifers (predominantly evangelical Christians) who voted this disaster of a "president" in for a second term.

And let's not forget Mother Teresa who cares for the dying while at the same time being strongly against contraception (except for the Billings Method which is far too complicated to be practised by uneducated people), thus producing more potentially "dying" people for her and her nuns to care for.

by jardinier

what you have failed to address is that the weather worldwide has become EXTREMELY erratic in just the last few years.

by x-marcap

Weather is what you actually get.

As a Pilot I can tell you that the late 70's- early 80s were really the most bizarre here in the Midwest. The great ice storm of 77. the winter of '78. The Browns in the AFC Championship. I tell you really wierd stuff was happening.

by tonythetiger

But how much of that is actually due to changes in the weather, and how much due to our increased ability to observe?

by tryten

Over the past million years weather patterns have been even more erratic than we have ever seen. For example, we all know that the moon was at one point 15 times closer to the Earth that it is today. During those times storms a small thunderstorm would have been like a hurricane only one that would have been measured as a 8 or 9 if the scale were to go that far. Keep in mind that would be a small storm. Large storms are far beyond what we could imagine.

The point I am makeing here is that what we view as EXTREME weather is FAR from what the Earth is capable of producing.

And it was also very common of the weather patterns to become erratic within a few years then become more powerful as time goes on when a major global temperature change happens.

All weather patterns come in cycles currently we are said to have started another 50 year cycle of extreme weather. Which is true. The rotation of Earth on a tilted axis has produced a pendulum effect with the planets weather. And what happens is just like a clock, the pendulum swings and its arc gets shorter and shorter until its has no more momentum.

Like the pendulum the weather cycles will shorten and increase with intensity until we get put into another ice age or the ice caps melt and the oceans become stagnant and deprived of oxygen because there are no more ice caps to help with the oceanic currents. Either way it spells unhappy times for us.

Its happened before and was one of the major factors in the "Great Dying" when 90% of all marine life and 80% of all land animals became extinct.

The cycle has always been there and always will be our interfence will only bring more harm that good. If we get in the way of nature it just might fight back and we already stand no change against nature.

by rob mekel

And let it go down with a mudslide :O

We, dutch, just bild dikes. :)

But don't think that will do on the long run. :O

Rob

edited, emoticons didn't turn out right, now they do :)

by jardinier

I am sidestepping the topic here to point out some irreversible damage that humans have done.

We have been directly responsible for the extinction of countless species of both flora and fauna.

Now if I were a rational Christian (oxymoron) I would be far more concerned at the irreversible destruction of these myriad wonders of God's creation, than the abortion of humans of which there are far too many on the planet already.

by tonythetiger

So was the lion who ate the last dodo responsible for its extinction?

Adapt or die. Them's da rules.

by rob mekel

Actually, the dodo lived on Madagascar. Unfortunately for the Lion, as it didn't have a boat, they only live in Africa, mainland that is. (As Madagascar is considered of being part of Africa) So they never had to opportunity too taste a Dodo :D:D

But get your meaning. Through the ages many species have been extinct, dino's, dodo, homo erectus, etc. Being their own doings or nature doings.

Rob

by tryten

Extinction is a process that keeps rolling along with or without human intervention.

The fact is that humans may be responsible for the extinction of many species, i understand that. But by reasoning that we are the problem is poor logic. We were not responsible for the death of the trilobites, dinosaurs or about a billion other species that existed before us.

We as humans somehow think that we in our infinite wisdom can fix EVERYTHING, and that makes us responsible for EVERYTHING. BS, we had nothing to do with 99.999% of the extinctions that took place over the lifetime of the Earth.

You know who was responsible, nature. Survival of the fittest, evolutions and cosmic and geograpghical events are the major causes of extinction. Even humans hunting a species to their extinction fall under the law of survival of the fittest.

by maxwell edison

I think you probably realize this, Julian, but I'll state it again in case you've missed it (or in case anyone else is wondering).

I'm an admitted environmentalist, but in "my" sense of the word, not the "political" sense. I absolutely abhor a dirty environment, pollution, litter, and whatever else might muck up our home. I've actually called the mayor of my city and discussed graffiti. I've actually cleaned it up myself. I've donated my time and my dollars to clean up our environment. I'm a dang boy scout leader; I teach "leave no trace"; I hike in the mountains; I sail in the oceans. No one, absolutely no one, loves a cleaner Earth than me.

I support and espouse the development of alternative energy sources, as I realize that fossil fuels pollute the environment. Moreover, in my opinion, the United States should make it our first priority to become energy independent. As you well know, I'm a very vocal proponent of taking personal responsibility as an individual; and that also translates into taking personal responsibility as a nation. The fact that we are dependent on other nations to meet our energy needs is just as appalling to me as an individual content on relying on other individuals to meet his personal needs, especially considering that both the nation and the individual are equally capable of meeting those respective needs.

I know how many coral reefs have been damaged. I know how some irreplaceable redwoods have been felled. I see the smog above our cities; and I know how it affects the health of many people. But "protecting the environment at all costs", per se, is not only unrealistic, but a Polly-Anna attitude. In today's reality, a balance must be found. For example, those who espouse the elimination of "urban sprawl" don't take into consideration every thing else. Balance is the key, especially today. Extremism, one way or the other, is not possible.

Moreover, I truly do believe that the "environmentalist movement" in the United States (and in the world) is not what it appears to be, and is not what it would like the population to believe it is. Yes, I do believe that mankind is capable of polluting the land, the air, and the water on our planet. But no, I don't believe for a second that we are capable of initiating its destruction. The Earth is such an insignificant planet in the universe; and mankind is such an insignificant presence on the Earth. One single fluke of nature could literally wipe-out every man, woman, and child on the face of the Earth; but no, it just can't happen in reverse.

Having said that, I believe that the global warming scare is the biggest scam ever perpetrated in the entire history of mankind. There is no conclusive evidence to prove that mankind is causing the Earth's climate to change, yet so many people buy into it. And since I've seen the gullibility of so many people in so many areas, its easy for me to understand why so many have been duped in this case. But the sad thing is this. This particular scam not only affects the duped, but the skeptical as well.

I don't like to be duped. And I dislike it even more being affected by others who choose to be duped and want to drag me, kicking and screaming, along with them.

by jardinier

Actually Max, in a hypothetical setting (such as a James Bond movie) I think we could shake the planet up quite a bit by inserting numerous nuclear devices along the fault lines.

But apart from this, a nuclear war could certainly wipe out all organic life and make the planet uninhabitable for many, many years.

As you are so good at finding statistics I invite you to ascertain how many nuclear devices are stockpiled in the world, with their total destructive power, and how many of these would be sufficient to destroy all organic life. I strongly suspect that the weapons stockpiled would be sufficient to destroy all life on the planet several times over.

by maxwell edison

I think that I can honestly say that I have NEVER heard even one scientist warn about man-made global warming. Sure, there have been articles written in scientific journals and such, but for the most part, government grants pay for them to study the issue. And sure, other people "cite" such scientists, but it can be observed, without question, that the "scientific community" is not, en masse, shouting warnings to the rest of the population.

The people leading the charge are: left-leaning politicians, the left-leaning media, and the left-leaning environmental groups. If there was ever an assembled group of people to not believe, there you have it.

Under the circumstances, and considering those leading the charge, absolute proof will be required for me to even give them the time of day. Otherwise, it's just more of their usual lies and scare tactics.

by alexh19740110

Hi Max,

I haven't joined any of these discussions before, but I'm rather puzzled by all of this.

The evidence for global warming is incontrovertible. Whether it's "man-made" or not is, I suppose, another matter--but it's happening!

Have a look at the following graph:

http://www.ecobridge.org/content/g_evd.htm

Data is from the Hadley Centre for Climate Prediction and Research of the UK Meteorological Office.

So one sunny day doesn't make a summer; one snowstorm doens't make an ice age; the articles you've posted--evidence of one of the most extreme snowfalls in history--is entirely predicted by the theory of global warming, and stands, indeed, as corroborating evidence for it.

I'm obviously missing something here!

Regards,
Alex Harvey
UNIX System Sdministrator

by x-marcap

The US has been reduced by the environmentalists to the third in productivity. We could reopen Alaska, the offshore rigs, etc.

The problem isn't as much technical as political for us.

Shale oil is currently expensive. In fact it will become a great resource when someone comes up with products made from shale. Then the oil is a waste product. Goodbye high oil prices...

Then it is just a small engineering problem.

by tonythetiger

"I regard it as contraception after the event."

So did Scott Peterson, but 12 people called it murder (2 counts).

"What the idiot misguided pro-lifers don't take into account is what kind of life these unwanted children might expect when they are born to parents who do not have the wherewithal to provide for them."

Sure, or maybe there was a genetic reason, or a rape. On the other hand, that abortion doctor might have just cut up the next Pastuer or Einstein.
Either way, doesn't that imply the kind of labeling and presupposing that you liberals claim to be victim of all the time? (Neil, pay attention, I'm starting to figure out how to explain what I mean.)

None of us knows ahead of time what kind of life we might expect, and I don't know why anyone would want it any different.

by Member 25348569

I'll watch that one with interest! If anyone can create such products then, as you say, the supply problems are over. Then the "small engineering" problems begin.

Let's assume that self-igniting ashtrays is the best that you can make out of what is not - otherwise - a very useful rock. They burn it directly as a high-ash, low-yield fuel in Estonia but that's all they've found to do with it. Most oil shale is marl which, if I remember my geology, is a sedimentary mixture of clay and limestone. Deep-buried shale - and most of the US's best shale is deep buried - would be extracted by fracturing in-situ and heating to obtain gases and liquids by wells. The technology to do this on any large scale is probably by the explosion of low-yied, low radioactivity nuclear bombs! Near-surface shale can be extracted by mining, transporting, and heating the shale to about 450C, adding hydrogen to the resulting product, and disposing of and stabilising the waste. It's worth noting that oil shale does not contain oil. The organic material is chiefly kerogen which can be converted into a substance somewhat similar to petroleum by heating to a high temperature. Further processing - with current technology - can produce an oil which is said to be better than the lowest grade of conventional oil, but of lower quality than the upper grades of conventional oil.

Oil price is still the driver for shale extraction and I don't think that the cutoff is too far away! So, you don't invade Canada - much the easiest solution - and you start extracting surface shale bigtime just to save your balance of payments from going interstellar. I believe that, with current techniques, extracting the kerogen from surface oil shale turns it into "rock popcorn" so you stand absolutely no chance of stuffing it back into the hole it came out of. If you do the math for, say, 20% of current oil usage then you get some very big numbers for size of hole and even bigger numbers for size of spoil dump and even bigger numbers again for the dollars to restore the environment of Colorado back to even tolerably livable when the shale or the need for it is gone.

Or you could just reduce consumption. :p

by absolutely

His wife didn't ask for an abortion.

Any unwanted growth in a woman's body is a parasite. She has the right to remove & destroy it. You have no right to determine for her whether the circumstances of her life "justify" her choice to abort. No justification is necessary. The definition of a right means that nobody else's permission is required.

by tonythetiger

A murder charge requires a live human victim, thus a fetus is a live human. All men have the right to life, liberty, etc.

Hmmm....

by absolutely

1. tjsanko: "The US has been reduced by the environmentalists to the third in productivity. We could reopen Alaska, the offshore rigs, etc."

The truth: Harry Truman, not environmentalists, allowed the Arab nations to steal the private property of US citizens who owned the petroleum mines and/or had contracts granting the right to operate mines for their own profit, not for the profit of Arab dictators. Truman supposedly believed it was impossible to defend simultaneously defend petroleum from Arab dictators and defend the entire Earth from the red menace.

2. tjsanko: "The problem isn't as much technical as political for us."

The truth: The United States contains far less petroleum per square mile than the Arab region. Even if ANWR and every other sq in of land in North America were available for petroleum mining, the laws of economics would make it cheaper to import the majority of the oil, at the levels we currently use it.

tjsanko: "Shale oil is currently expensive. In fact it will become a great resource when someone comes up with products made from shale. Then the oil is a waste product. Goodbye high oil prices..."

The truth: Like opening protected wildlife refuges all over the continent, new & improved mining methods can be a stopgap measure at best. Do you look for workarounds or for solutions, IT pro?

tjsanko: "Then it is just a small engineering problem."

The premise of that statement is a falsehood, as I just explained above. The conclusion is therefore equally false.

by rob mekel

sloppy sloppy, very sloppy of me. :(

Then again billing in advance to building the dikes, is not a bad idea :D

And yeb they do(the dikes that is, the dutch however... well I hope you know that one. :)). As New Orleans found out, bit late too but .... well better late then never. lol
(if it only were fun to get the place destroyed like that, think not)

Rob

by jardinier

You have "conveniently" failed to address the strongest point I made:

"As far as I am concerned the potential social nightmare that would result if ALL ABORTIONS ceased, would far outweigh any moral or ethical considerations."

Could you please give your opinion on this hypothetical scenario, which would be the result if pro-lifers won the day?

It's all very well to say an Einstien may have been aborted, but could society possibly deal with the chaos that would arise if ALL abortions were ceased NOW?

It so happens I have a friend in Ethiopia who is a 19-year-old orphan. She thanks the parents that she never knew for giving her life by NOT having an abortion. I have "adopted" her. Sure I am glad she is alive -- she is a real blessing in my life.

But that does not alter the fact that if ALL abortions ceased, there would be social chaos.

by maxwell edison

You said, "I strongly suspect that the weapons stockpiled would be sufficient to destroy all life on the planet several times over."

I agree. And I never said we didn't have the power to destroy ourselves, once, twice, or several times over.

What I said is that we don't have the power to destroy the planet. There's a huge difference.

Even if all 26,000 nuclear devices were to be detonated, the good old earth would fix itself in a very short time, cosmically speaking, of course, and live on and on without us. (And actually, some semblance of human life might even find a way to survive with it.)

In a round-about way, you're actually making my point. If we were to actually listen to the global warming alarmists, you'd think that the destruction of the planet was already a forgone conclusion. And even if we tried to destroy the planet by detonating all 26,000 nuclear devices, that wouldn't even do it. We'd only succeed in killing ourselves by trying to kill the planet.

We just can't destroy the planet!

But speaking of nuclear power, isn't it strange that the same American wacko environmentalists who spout off about using fossil fuels for power generation are also the ones who block efforts to switch to the cleaner nuclear generated power plants? And you guys in Australia aren't doing anything with nuclear power, as far as I can see. In the USA, only 20 percent of our electricity is generated by nuclear means. In France, by contrast it's almost 100 percent. And in many European nations, it's well over 50 percent. (Australia is not even on the list.)

The whole global warming issue in anything but environmental. It's political -- 100 percent political. That's my point.

by mjwx

Any species that would detonate that many nuclear devices has earned their extintion.

For the record Australia has one nuclear reactor (I don?t know off hand what percentage of national power it generates). It is protested regally. Once they came dressed as nuclear waste barrels, would of made it easy to roll them down the hill.

by jardinier

You would have to be referring to the reactor at Lucas Heights, situated at the southern edge of the Sydney metropolitan area.

It has only ever been intended to be used for scientific study and to produce radioactive isotopes for medical applications.

Because we have such a small population (20 million) on such a large continent -- most of which is desert or swampland -- I can see no reason to go nuclear.

While nuclear is clean energy, its byproducts remain toxic for thousands of years and no-one has yet come up with a guaranteed stable, safe way of storing the spent rods etc.

We know from the Chernobyl incident of the potential hazards associated with this form of "clean" energy. Yes clean, unless something goes wrong.

So I would vote for fossil fuel and its known emissions against nuclear and it potentially horrendous consequences.

by maxwell edison

You replied to my message with, "Any species that would detonate that many nuclear devices." I wonder what your point was?

As far as the number of nuclear reactors in Australia, I'll just take your word for it. However, here's the source for my comment:

http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/reactors.htm

I guess that chart needs to be updated. It is, after all, more than a month old.

by tonythetiger

I don't know if there would be social chaos or not. Maybe it would instead renew interest in a thing called personal responsibility.

Most of us were "oops" babies, and we are fine.

by sleepin'dawg

on most of this material. The most recent date I saw, although I might have missed something more recent, was 2002, a few items from 2001 and 2000 but the vast majority is dated between 1999 back to 1995-6 and it is heavily weighted on that end of the time line. '95-'96 was the ramping up of all the hype for Global Warming. You will note that serious scientific sources are not particularly cited with much prominence but a documntary by Meryl Streep and Roy Scheider, two prominent actors but a tad sketchy on scientific qualifications, is given a degree of prominence. Most of the "serious" evidence dates from '95-'96 but science has not been standing still. Yes the study of the Global Warming phenomenon has continued but rather than confirming the earlier evidence, new questions have arisen which has cast serious doubts upon the earlier conclusions. In fact the current conclusion is that it is too early to draw any conclusions based upon the current available data.

[b]The year 1999 was the fifth-warmest year on record since the mid-1800's[/b]

And that is the very point under consideration at the moment. Weather data only dates from that period and the earliest data is far from being quantitative and accurate; especially considering that archaeological evidence shows that the earth has moved through similar warming and cooling periods before.

[b]So one sunny day doesn't make a summer; one snowstorm doens't make an ice age; the articles you've posted--evidence of one of the most extreme snowfalls in history--[i]is entirely predicted by the theory of global warming, and stands, indeed, as corroborating evidence for it.[/b][/i]

That's just it; it isn't, wasn't and can't be predicted by any theory of Global Warming any more than The Farmer's Almanac can predict that we are going to have 4"of rain or 20" of snow, two Thursdays from now. With only 130+ years of data how can we measure conditions comparably on a phenomonon that appears to be working in cycles ranging between 400 to 1500 years. I won't say you are wrong but you cannot say that the current evidence you have presented makes you definitively right.

I can remember about 35 years ago, at the height of the "Cold War" there were scientists claiming the Soviets had discovered a method of controlling the weather and were using it as a weapon aginst the west. Well it's fairly safe to say that wasn't so, because if they had that capability then, think of what a marketable product it would be today. Yet there are people who will swear somebody has this capability even now and that is the explanation for the current erratic weather patterns.

I frankly think, something is going on with the weather but I'm more inclined to believe it is a nature rather than man made problem and until I see more solid evidence to the contrary, that is what I choose to believe, for now. I would say if you are missing something that would be it. Are you right??? Maybe! Am I right??? I think so but I am keeping an open mind for any evidence, either pro or con.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by Member 25348569

One of the references is to an ice study covering 680,000 years. Is that over a long enough period for you?

http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/n/a/2005/11/24/national/w135801S21.DTL

"Carbon dioxide levels have climbed from 280 parts per million two centuries ago to 380 ppm today. (...) Skeptics sometimes dismiss the rise in greenhouse gases as part of a naturally fluctuating cycle. The new study provides ever-more definitive evidence countering that view, however.

Deep Antarctic ice encases tiny air bubbles formed when snowflakes fell over hundreds of thousands of years. Extracting the air allows a direct measurement of the atmosphere at past points in time, to determine the naturally fluctuating range.

(...) Today's still rising level of carbon dioxide already is 27 percent higher than its peak during all those millennia, said lead researcher Thomas Stocker of the University of Bern, Switzerland.

"We are out of that natural range today," he said.

Moreover, that rise is occurring at a speed that "is over a factor of a hundred faster than anything we are seeing in the natural cycles," Stocker added. "It puts the present changes in context."

by sleepin'dawg

[i]The bottom line: "There's no natural condition that we know about in a really long time where the greenhouse gas levels were anywhere near what they are now. And these studies tell us that there's a strong relationship between temperature and greenhouse gases," said Oregon State's Brook. "Which logically leads you to the conclusion that [b]maybe[/b] we should worry about temperature change in the future."[/i]

Okay let's follow some of it up. I do not deny one item in the article but I do note that at no point does it mention the global population increases of the past 50 - 60 years. If I remember correctly, shortly after WW II the world population stood around 2.5 billion. Now it's pushing 6 billion, maybe even surpassing that.

About a year ago I read an article, somewhere, that cattle were a major source of CO2 and methane gases. How could this be??? The article explained that bovine flatulence was a large contributor to the problem of Green House gases. Silly me; I thought that chloroflurocarbons used in aerosols and other industrial processes were a major contributor but according to the article that while they were, bovine and human flatulence contributed almost as much. Now with the concerted push that has been and is still being made to eliminate or restrict chlorofluorocarbons and things like the Kyota Accord coming into force, am I to assume that after we have eliminated all the other sources of air pollution that the only remaining sources will be animal and human flatulence??? After all the human population continues to grow as I imagine, so does the animal population to provide a food source for that increasing human population. Will humanity fart itself into extinction???

Yes there has been an increase in greenhouse gases. What would you expect with three times the population level and I am not talking about flatulence here. The question that nobody seems to want to ask is; how much can the worlds environment absorb before we are going to have to take serious steps to limit the growth of population both in animals and humans because like it or not, even if we turned the clocks back to pre-industrial technology (forget flatulence which I brought up only as a facetious item) people have a nasty habit of breathing. For each breath taken in over 50% is expelled as CO and CO2 and all other things aside that will continue to grow as the population grows.

[b]Now[/b] add in the greenhouse gases being produced by industry, that provides employment so people can earn the wherewithall so they can afford to feed and cloth themselves and you will see that no matter to what level we restrict these gases as long as we continue on a geometric scale of population increase the problem is going to stay with us. That is and will remain a constant; as long as populations are permitted to grow unchecked.

As far as I know, China is the only nation making serious efforts to limit population growth by limiting couples to one child and penalizing any and all who produce in excess of that number. Does any nation in the western world make that kind of effort??? [b]NO[/b] and as long as we continue to give additional tax benefits for every child produced, we will continue to add fuel to the fire. How about other nations such as India, Malaysia and Indonesia. In these nations it is not unusual to see couples producing anywhere from 4 - 10 offspring, so not much hope from that quarter. Even Africa with all its genocidal tribal strife, is increasing in population. In fact every nation that has an agricultural based economy is reproducing at rates far in excess of the first world economies. So unless and until you can repress the natural instinct of people to fvck, the world's population will continue to grow along with the pollution of the air and the increasing thinning of the ozone layer. Maybe the increasing instances of cancer, especially the dermatological varieties. Is natures way of fighting back.

I have another article c/w data I would like to cite that, put in context with poulation growth, will curl your hair, that is, if you have any left. Unfortunately I don't have it readily at hand but I'll either post it or pm you with it later.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

all the talk of about natural ranges of carbon dioxide et al, maybe the level has increased but nobody is definitively sticking there neck out saying that humanity is the definite cause and I say that in light of, [b][i]the present changes in context.[/i][/b] I would be more impressed if it was stated as an increase per capita than just a sweeping statement that it [b][i]is over a factor of a hundred than anything we are seeing in the natural cycles[/i][/b] We're out of the natural range today??? Who says so??? Especially if it is rated on a per capita basis. On tha per capita basis it might even be lower because the population levels have increased by factors in excess of that. C'mon Neil, you have a science background and you are accepting statements like that without question??? Reduce the numbers to a per capita basis and then tell me what the natural range should be because as long as the population keeps growing so will the production of these gases. We don't have any idea yet, just what the environment can or can't absorb. Note: I am not saying we should ignore this but I loathe shoddy and incomplete science.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by rob mekel

Should have been. :D

But the chemical facturies that time weren't that clean so they were stopped producing. :(

But then we as Homo sapiens sapiens took over and did a very nice job. (mmm, getting slippery)

As for the viagra, don't think it's needed for the keeping off the species. (@ least not to my knowledge :O :O)

Rob

by maxwell edison

This is my entire point, and I always qualify my comments to reflect as much. (If I don't state it on each and every message, it's only because I forgot and/or have already established that premise.)

If the Earth is undergoing another one if its warming/cooling trends, there's not a dang thing we can do about it, except deal with it. If it's not, there's nothing we can do about that, except wipe the mud off our collective faces for being wrong.

My position is two fold: First of all, if it is happaning, there is no proof that mankind is CAUSING it. And no, the "just in case" argument won't fly. Second, the group of people who are advancing that silly notion have proven themselves to not be worthy of my trust.

Therefore, it's just a non issue.

by thechas

There can be no argument that human activity can and does have a negative impact on the environment. You can argue how significant that impact is, but not whether or not man has a negative impact on the environment.

Further, I doubt you can find a credible scientist who will argue that the Earth has an unlimited capacity to absorb the pollution that human activity spews about the planet.

Notching this up a step further, I contend that your stand against taking action to reduce man's impact on the climate goes against one of your core beliefs. To rally against working to reduce man's impact on the climate and environment is telling people that they do not need to take responsibility for the impact of their actions!

Even if you were silent on the global warming debate, and did all that you could to reduce your personal impact on the environment, you would still be negligent in your quest to have people take responsibility for their actions.

Doing what is best for yourself in the short term (even your lifetime) is not showing personal responsibility if your actions have a lasting negative impact on the environment.

As a Christian, a Scout, and a human, your personal responsibility does NOT end at your own actions. You MUST call on others to forsake their wasteful negligent ways. Even IF doing so raises their costs or lowers their profit.

Do the right thing! Take people and companies to task for wasting resources and polluting more than is necessary.

If America would simply reduce our energy waste by a minimum of 50 percent, we would be taking a giant step in reducing both greenhouse emissions, and our oil addiction.

Chas

by maxwell edison

Would that be as defined by you or me?

By the way, if you read and understand ALL my messages on this issue (environmental concerns), you'll realize that the only problem I have with it is the lies and deceptions on which it's based.

And how does that reconcile with doing "the right thing"?

by tonythetiger

All creatures, and all groups of creatures (including families, herds, and governments) do it to one extent or other. It is each creature's (or group's) responsibility to continue to survive (adapting as necessary).

Attempting to put guilt-trips on other creatures does not change the fact. It really is quite simple and the truth is the same whether you're a flower in a meadow, a bear in the woods, a bible-thumper, or an environmentalist whacko. If you (or your group) do not adapt and survive, then you (or your group) are not worthy of survival.

by sleepin'dawg

why do the leftist liberals always seem to support the tree hugging, animal rights variety and heap abuse and scorn on the rightest conservatives who want to preserve the environment just as much but for purposes of sustainable exploitation.

After many years of seeing the overall effects of organizations such as Green Peace and PETA, I have come to the conclusion that they exist solely for the purpose of activism for its own sake and have no real interest in true environmental concerns. Juxtaposed against them is an Organisation such as Ducks Unlimited who go quietly about their business in there efforts to preserve wetlands with the supposed ostensible reason of providing habitat for waterfowl to the benefit of bird hunters and the gun nuts of the NRA.

First, let me say this, in the eyes of the leftist crowd, I am probably considered a gun nut. I own weapons; both shoulder operated and hand varieties and am a member of and supporter of the NRA. I am also a member of Ducks Unlimited and yes, what hunting I do it is invariably for fowl both landed and water.

The thing I find curious is, this week I've been in receipt of four different package from each of the above organisations. The package from the NRA is a small trifold 8 1/2 X 11 piece printed on laquered stock, stating the benefits of membership etc and a business letter reminding me that my membership is due for renewal all tucked neatly inside a standard business envelope which has the organisations logo printed on the upper left corner. The package from Ducks Unlimited is somewhat similar all though it is all done on recycled paper and their letter is asking for donations to a specific project. I have a lifetime membership in DU and am never reminded of membership renewal.

There is a glaring contrast to the other two organizations. The Green Peace package consists of multiple pages (8)of four colour process, all printed on coated stock, not laquered and trumpeting their achievement in areas such as saving whales and arresting Canada's seal hunt. The PETA package is similar except they only sent five pages and they are against the evils of animal testing for either cosmetic or pharmaceutical purposes. I imagine they prefer testing being done on humans. Both of their packages are in large 9 X 12 envelopes with all sorts of thing printed on the outside.

I find it interesting that these supposed lovers of nature and animals find it necessary to promote themselves in a manner so wasteful of resources and so potentialy polluting, while the other two, which if you listen to the first two, are mere lackeys of the industrial/ military complex. If this were all true, wouldn't you expect the format of the approaches for membership and/or funds for these different organizations to be reversed???

Although a member of the NRA, I am not in total agreement with them but I do appreciate their efforts in promoting the safe and secure handling of firearems. Likewise DU; which wants to preserve wetlands, which does provide habitat for my chosen prey but also contributes something to the environment in purifying waters polluted from the inevitable industrial runoff, which BTW they want to see efforts being made to minimize this.

Green Peace, on the other hand has been successful in limiting the seal hunt. No more killing of those cute cuddly little white seal pups. What they fail to mentionis their efforts were largely responsible for devastating the economies of hundreds of aboriginal people who had been hunting seals for centuries, not only for their pelts but also for sustenance. Without the seal hunt the herds have been growing unchecked, which to a large extent can account for the depletion of the Atlantic cod fishery and again has seriously harmed the economies of the many inhabitants of the eastern sea board. I won't even dignify PETA by acknowledging their idiocies.

I just found it interesting to see the differnt approaches made by these different and differing organizations. I would say that Green Peace and PETA have the more effective publicists, also the more polluting. I wrote two checks. Guess to which organizations I sent them??? I hope poor old GP and PETA aren't holding their breathe waiting for mail from me.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by alexh19740110

Hi Max,

I feel this response is quite as emotive as the extreme leftists whom you criticise.

There are some facts here and although neither the left NOR the right can demonstrate to the n-th degree the veracity of their claims, it is nice to take a step back and see that those facts really are there and they are FACTS:

Here are some facts:

i. carbon-dioxide, methane, etc. REALLY DO trap in heat.

ii. ***human beings REALLY ARE generating carbon, methane etc. to a degree that is UNPRECEDENTED in millions of years of BIOLOGICAL HISTORY.*** The idea that we haven't the power to influence our environment in a significant way is just plainly silly. Obviously, we have nuclear weapons that can destroy all life--or near enough to it. If we cut down every single tree on the face of the earth--something we certainly have the power to do--WE WILL ALL DIE. That's another simple, cold, hard fact (although admittedly tangential to point ii.:-))

iii. over the last hundred years or more the temperatures HAVE risen (sure: there's evidence of climate changes like this in ancient times, the regular freezing of the Rhine stopped happening well before humans could be fairly blamed for it). Agreed, point iii. is deceptive and should be taken very cautiously.

iv. ***We do not understand the forces that drive climate change.*** We don't know why the last ice age ended. We don't know why the dinosaurs died out. We don't know a lot of things.

v. THEREFORE (and I feel I have justification for using this word): the POSSIBILITY that our production of carbon, methane, etc. STANDS IN A CAUSAL RELATION with the temperature changes which we have MEASURED is **REAL**. I don't care about the statistics; if some leftists are fudging their figures, it has no bearing on what I'm saying. The extreme left (& the extreme right) will always be...well...extreme.:-)

You dismiss the "just in case" argument as though it was advanced by a person who wouldn't leave his houses "just in case" there was a bogey men outside. There may be no demonstrative proof for the moderate environmentalists' position but to say they're claims are entirely without foundation is an extreme rightist position and simply ignores a lot of facts. It's one thing to say there's no proof; it's quite another to say there's no evidence.

You go on: "Second, the group of people who are advancing that silly notion have proven themselves to not be worthy of my trust."

This is just an ad hominem fallacy: "The people who are saying the things I don't agree with are bad people, THEREFORE, they're wrong."

"Therefore it's a non-issue"???

I'd like to know what the issue is then? I'd have to agree with the other responders: this is a call for collective irresponsibility.

My view FWIW.:-)

Best,
Alex

by montgomery gator

Jamestown, the first English settlement in North America, was not Puritan. They were loyal to the Church of England. It was the Puritans that settled the New England colonies that went for the radical stuff. For the most part, cooler heads prevailed religious-wise in the southern colonies, and they were more tolerant of other religions and denominations, compared to the New England colonies. Pennsylvania was even more tolerant, under William Penn and the Quakers. Jews and Catholics were able to find safe havens in both Pennsylvania and the southern colonies.

Some of my ancestors were from Scotland, also, and settled in Virginia. However, they did not leave Scotland due to being forced to leave by the magistrates. They were younger sons of the lowland Scots nobility who left to gain land grants in the New World, since they would not inherit titles and lands that the older sons got.

French Huguenots (fleeing religious persecution from the Catholics in France) also settled in the English colonies, particularly South Carolina, and some of my ancestors came from them.

by Member 25348569

I'll research more and do the maths next week and get back to you. I'm off to visit my old Mum and she won't let me fire up the laptop - "You've come up here to see me".

However, do I really think that I'll convince you? What I think is that for something as crucial as this, you should do the maths yourself. "Shoddy and incomplete science"? I've done the maths before.

Per capita doesn't really matter and I'm not sure of the point that you're making. It's meaningless if the CO2 rise is not down to us. If the rise [b]is[/b] due to us then per capita [b]still[/b] doesn't have any real value except as a figure that we even more seriously need to reduce.

http://www.eia.doe.gov/iea/carbon.html

Read for youself - at least over the last twenty five years. Per capita consumption bouncing around at around 4 Tons per person per annum. We have to reduce that.

The average human produces around 300Kg of CO2 by respiration per annum. A significant quantity but rather less than that produced by fossil fuel combustion.

Add in the huge amount by deforestation and slash and burn agriculture and you see where it's all coming from.

Per capita in 1900, was around 0.3 in 1900 from fossil fuels and, obviously, another 0.3 due to respiration. The value peaked around 1970 and has been roughly static ever since.

So, in the last fifty years, many more of us have been producing much more CO2 each. Brown stuff and fan on collision course.

Chloroflourocarbons were screwing up the ozone layer, by the way and aren't really linked to GW.

by jamesg

No, it just does no good to attempt reason with self-righteous limp dick fucks like yourself. Too bad yo momma didn't bother to abort another conservative puke like yourself. Now start sneering again. Oh, and if you don;'t like abortion, DONT GET ONE - but don't tell my wife what she can do with her body, it ain't NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS.

by jdclyde

I can think of all kinds of thing you could be dying OF....

A self-centered, imature loser like you wouldn't CARE about anything enough to really die for it.

by puppybreath

While he was sitting at the kid's table during the family gatherings, some of his peers must have told him he was a wit. Well, at least they were half right......

by jdclyde

because Fake James, you haven't tried once since you started splashing your troll posts around TR.

Is there any wonder there is a whole discussion talking about what a complete loser you are? No, it is no wonder at all.

With the way you make your posts here, it is easy to see why you would want to be a liberal. When you can't hold a job you will need a good safety net to support your worthless hide.

- edit to acknowledge puppy post -
wit, half right , half wit? BAWAAAHAAHAHAHAAAAAAHAAHAAA! :^O

by sleepin'dawg

[b][i]What I think is that for something as crucial as this, you should do the maths yourself. "Shoddy and incomplete science"? I've done the maths before.

Per capita doesn't really matter and I'm not sure of the point that you're making. It's meaningless if the CO2 rise is not down to us. If the rise is due to us then per capita still doesn't have any real value except as a figure that we even more seriously need to reduce.

Read for youself - at least over the last twenty five years. Per capita consumption bouncing around at around 4 Tons per person per annum. We have to reduce that.

The average human produces around 300Kg of CO2 by respiration per annum. A significant quantity but rather less than that produced by fossil fuel combustion.[/i][/b]

Cool!!! I actually think you already know what I'm saying and I'm not necessarily trying to prove anything but I am stating an opinion, which you seem to be in disagreement with. I accept that but feel that in all the number crunching done by the "possibly biased" source you provided with your link, two things have been or are being overlooked. (a): Human nature (b): A population that is at least 3 times larger than it was 60 years ago, in 1945.

Since I'm too busy to really devote much time to this, I'm about to shock you and will stipulate to the numbers you quoted above. Nice of me, isn't it. I will also further stipulate that it matters little whether you are talking about metric tons versus avoirdupois tons or long tons versus short tons although the metric tons are 10%
heavier. I will also stipulate to the 300Kg figure for CO2 produced by respiration by the average human. However you do not state any figures for the bovine population or other domestic ungulants on the planet. For the sake of simplicity, I think we'll ignore that for now but it may come up later.

One thing you do mention is the "average" human. What figure from what year are you using to define average? The 1945 figure, the 1975 figure or the 2005 figure? I ask this because the average is a moving target that has been increasing with time. Again, for the sake of simplicity, lets say we are talking the 2005 average human.

Would you disagree with me that the average 1945 human was in all probability slightly smaller in stature than the average 2005 human? Would you accept the claim that respiratory output from one of smaller stature would in all probability be slightly less than the output of one of larger stature. When I say slightly, I am not talking large numbers, in fact I have no corroberating data available to prove this but I am thinking in terms of 1.5% - 3% at the absolute maximum. Figures which are, more or less, inconsequential to this discussion. But lets look at the population numbers of 1945 and 2005. The 2005 figure is almost 3 times greater than the 1945 figure; so isn't it safe to assume, using your 300Kg, that 3 times the amount of CO2 is being pumped out by humans in 2005 than was pumped out in 1945? Again the same would apply to your your 4 Ton consumption number. The total consumption would have to be at least 3 times higher today than it was 60 years ago.

Okay now you say we have to reduce that. Okay that is probably an excellent idea and if I'm not mistaken the Kyota Accord hopes for an overall reduction of 20% by the year 2020. But nobody seems to be taking human nature into account. Almost every individual in every third world nation aspires to raise himself to the levels of conspicious consumption of Americans and I might add Canadians as well, in that. In fact I will go further in that statement; Canadians, perhaps because of climate are slightly more conspicious consumers on a [b]per capita[/b] basis than our American counterparts.

When you bash away at Americans, for being conspicious consumers, you probably didn't realize you were bashing away at us as well and further more you might be right in doing so, since our standards of living are so similar. We just have to deal with a slightly harsher climate. So, if I'm understanding your argument correctly, you think we should reduce our consumption by 20% complete with the reduced standard of living that, that would entail. BTW, for what it's worth I can understand your argument. I just don't agree with it.

I lived in England for the better part of 1972 and one of the first things I took note of upon arrival was the lower standard of living in the UK at that time, [b]in terms of consumer items[/b]. Smaller cars, quaint little refrigerators, smaller living accomodations without central heating and plumbing that almost brought tears of frustration to my eyes. I'm not saying it was an inferior standard of living but it was substantially different from what I was used to. One of the first things I did was to bring over one of our standard sized refrigerators because the idea of running to the shops every second day was something I had a difficult time wrapping my mind around. I conceded defeat by bringing over a larger refrigerator and was finally able to get back to my normal habit of eating most of my meals at home. All my friends were envious of my 'fridge and when I left they were all clamoring to buy it from me. Not that there weren't large fridges in the UK it was just that they were hellishly expensive at that time. At no time did I ever have the idea that Englishmen wanted to become Americans or Canadians but I did feel you envied us our consumer goods and the fact we had such easy and inexpensive access to them.

My English friends could never understand how casually I would drive 3-400 miles and back in a day but in Canada that isn't anything particularly unusual. I can leave Montreal at 5AM be in Toronto, approx 365 miles or 585 kilometres, by 10AM, work all day, leave at 6PM and be back home shortly after 11PM. I don't do it every day but I can and will if the occasion demands it; and yes, I do speed. Again I'm not suggesting any superiority, just that our mentalities are different, especially as regards driving distances and shunning public transport. Look at Jd, I think he mentioned drivng, daily, 60 miles or 100 kilometres to work and that is one way. he repeats that trip in reverse going home and I'll bet he doesn't consider that unusual.

Now for the kick in the head. I'm in the UK at least twice a year and I've noticed something you may have missed for being so close to it. You people have been catching up to us in many ways. Your houses are getting bigger as are your appliances, you are getting central heating, after a fashion, now if you would only do something about the plumbing but even that has shown signs of improvement. So if we are to cut our consumption by 20% you too will probably have to cut yours by a similar amount. Oh yes our cars are still bigger and gas guzzlers but again I've been seeing larger cars around the UK in the past few years; so even there you are catching up. You may not have our quantity of SUVs but you seem to have a lot of minivans and the UK produces one of the worst SUVs in terms of mieage, the Range Rover.

Now it gets interesting because what comes next will probably startle you a bit.

[b][u]Starving for Oil[/u][/b]

We already know oil is the lifeblood of modern industrial society.
Today almost every human endeavor from transportation, to manufacturing,
to electricity, to plastics is inextricably connected to this finite
resource.

It's not as widely known or realized, however, that food is now nourished by oil.
Next to transportation and heating, the industrial food supply system is
one of the biggest consumers of fossil fuels on the planet.

Oil and natural gas are crucial at every step of modern agriculture --
from making fertilizers to sowing, cultivating and shipping crops.

But with peak oil production looming, the future of food security is
grim.

[b][u]Eating Oil[/u][/b]

From farm to plate, the contemporary food system is inherently
unsustainable.

Vast amounts of fossil fuels are used as raw materials and energy in the
food system.

Oil refined for gasoline and diesel is critical to run the tractors,
combines and other farm equipment that plant, spray the herbicides and
pesticides, and harvest/transport food and seed.

Gasoline and diesel are also required to deliver the finished food
products. Everyday, countless food shipments are delivered to grocery
stores, restaurants, hospitals, schools. On top of all this, customers
use oil when they drive to grocery stores to purchase these supplies.

It seems simple enough. But think about it for a moment..............

Food processors also rely on oil for the production and delivery of food
additives, including vitamins and minerals, emulsifiers, preservatives,
coloring agents, as well as boxes, metal cans, printed paper labels,
plastic trays, cellophane, glass jars, plastic and metal lids with
sealing compounds. Many of these are essentially oil-based.

In addition, fossil fuels are essential in the construction and the
repair of equipment and infrastructure needed to facilitate this
industry, including farm machinery, processing facilities, storage,
ships, trucks and roads.

In the U.S. and Canada, the area and markets I'm most familiar with,
agriculture is directly responsible for over 10% of all national energy
consumption but I see no reason to believe that similar statistics do not
apply to Europe and the UK as well.

The food system uses over 10 quadrillion BTUs of energy each year.
In fact, over 400 gallons of oil equivalent are expended to feed each
individual American or Canadian annually, in fact the figure for
Canada is quite possibly slightly in excess of that.

To put that in perspective, the amount of energy used by the U.S.
agriculture industry is equivalent to the total annual energy
consumption of France and when the Canadian figures are added,
exceeds it.

Growing the food accounts for only one fifth of the energy expenditure.
The other four fifths is used to move, process, package, sell, and store
food after it leaves the farm.

Some 28% of energy used in agriculture goes to fertilizer manufacturing,
and 7% goes to irrigation. And 34% is consumed as diesel and gasoline by
farm vehicles used to plant, till, and harvest crops. In fact, the
average distance food travels between the farm and the dinner table on
this continent is 1650 miles-an incredible journey indeed.

The rest goes to pesticide production, grain drying, and facility
operations.

Food is energy. And it takes energy to get food. These two facts, taken
together, have always established the biological limits to the human
population and always will.

The same is true for every other species on the planet. Food must yield
more energy to the consumer than is needed in order to acquire the food.

We can call this the energy in/energy out ratio.

Consider a lion who spends more energy chasing zebras than he can get
from eating the zebras he catches.

If this energy balance remains in the negative for too long, the result is
death.

For an entire species, the outcome is a die-off event, which could
eventually lead to extinction.

Today we are spending more energy planting, irrigating, harvesting,
processing, packaging, distributing and transporting food than the
energy we can acquire from eating the food.

The world's food system inefficiency can be summed up in a Swedish study
on the production of ketchup.

Researchers at the Swedish Institute for Food and Biotechnology analyzed
the production of ketchup.

The study considered the production of inputs to agriculture, tomato
cultivation and conversion to tomato paste, the processing and packaging
of the paste and other ingredients into ketchup as well as the retail
and storage of the final product.

All this involved more than 52 transport and process stages.

The aseptic bags used to package the tomato paste were produced in the
Netherlands and transported to Italy to be filled, placed in steel
barrels, and then moved to Sweden.

The bottles for the ketchup were either produced in the UK or Sweden
with materials form Japan, Italy, Belgium, the USA and Denmark.

The polypropylene screw-cap of the bottle and plug, made from low
density polyethylene, was produced in Denmark and transported to Sweden.

Additionally, polyethylene shrink-film and corrugated cardboard were
used to distribute the final product.

Who knew so much went into making ketchup?

Over all, including energy costs for farm machinery, transportation, and
processing, and oil and natural gas used as feedstocks for agricultural
chemicals -- the modern food system consumes roughly ten calories of
fossil fuel energy for every calorie of food energy produced.

How long can we sustain this???

[b][u]The Cuban Example[/u][/b]

In the late 1980s, farmers in Cuba were highly reliant on cheap fuels
and petrochemicals imported from the Soviet Union, using more
agrochemicals per acre than their American counterparts.

In 1990, as the Soviet empire collapsed, Cuba lost those imports and
faced an agricultural crisis.

The population lost 20 pounds on average and malnutrition was nearly
universal, especially among young children.

The Cuban GDP fell by 85% and inhabitants of the island nation
experienced a substantial decline in their material standard of living.

Cuban authorities responded by breaking up large state-owned farms,
offering land to farming families, and encouraging the formation of
small agricultural co-ops.

Cuban farmers began employing oxen as a replacement for the tractors
they could no longer afford to fuel.

Could this happen in the US and Canada? Who knows for sure???

For too long we've put a blind faith in technology, believing naively
that [b]"they'll think of something".[/b]

Maybe [b]"they"[/b] will. But for now oil is hard-wired into our culture.

Many people cling to a belief that higher oil prices will spur more oil
discoveries. But they ignore what earth scientists have been saying for
years: there aren't many more big discoveries to make.

It took 500 million years to produce these hydrocarbon deposits and we
are using them at a rate in excess of 1 million times their natural rate
of production.

On the time scale of centuries, we certainly cannot expect to continue
using oil as freely and ubiquitously as we do today.

Something is going to have to change.

Despite the appearance of an endless cornucopia of food, it is a fragile
bounty, dependent upon the integrity of the global oil production,
refining and delivery system.

Now consider the economics that trying for a 20% reduction is going to entail. In the winter months muchof our fresh produce comes from Mexico and while Mexicans might disagree they are a third world country. If we reduce our consumption by 20%, what happens to their already unstable and fragile economy. How about those in other nations who aspire to coming here. Sure maybe they'll have to stay at but do you think it will stop them from aspiring to our levels of consumerism??? For the answer to that just look at the massive increase in consumerismm that has taken place in Russia and all the other eastern block countries, since the cold war ended in 1989.

You say the western nations should set a good example by reducing our consumption as an inspiration to these nations. I can just see your reaction now when gas increases by another 50P in the UK. Your idea is a nice little fairy tale but after some time when these nations have not responded to your nice little inspirational gesture, in fact will probably ignore it, you will probably be at the forefront of those demanding a return to the old standards. Either that or be prepared for a return to the labour strife of the 70s as your unions will be leading the way for higher wages and the accompanying inflation rates you used to have. Getting us to cripple our economies by any reductions in consumption would just be playing into the hands of third world leaders. If necessary we will have to put these nations under some form of trade embargo before they will do anything in the way of restricting emissions.

So what can be done in the mean time. Let's say oil is a finite resource but with the reserves available we are probably good for another couple of hundred years at least. We should start looking at alternative sources of energy now but currently there is one thing we do know and that is we have know idea whatsoever what the global environment can absorb or what the global poulation can tolerate.

All the alarms being sounded about carcinogens, thinning ozone layers etc are just that alarms. When you say the thinning ozone layer has no impact well as temperatures rise the need for heating will be reduced but there will be a cooresponding demand for air conditioning.

The one thing I am currently and acutely aware of is the lack of standards for air quality in the third world just as I know your Noble gesture will be ignored. The only way we are going to get them to acquire comparable standards to the west is by stopping the importation of goods from these nations until they clean up. I do not mean start to clean up but actually do it.

Again that will mean increases in consumer prices. I do not know what the air pollution levels are in third world countries but I do know it is far in excess of anything in the west, especially the US and Canada.

BTW one other item; global population is increasing geometrically. So there will be more people pumping out 300Kg of CO2 and consuming 4 Tons annually. China is the only nation I know of that is trying to stabilize its birth rate; while in the west the birth rate has been declining naturally, the further we move away from dependance on an agricultural economy.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by Member 25348569

WARNING. ANTI-AMERICAN SENTIMENTS EXPRESSED BELOW. ONLY READ ON IF YOU'VE PUT YOUR GUNS SAFELY AWAY. REMEMBER, I'M A LEFT-WINGNUT COMMIE SO YOU CAN JUST INVADE IF YOU DON'T LIKE WHAT I'M SAYING.

Well, I haven't got much time for a reply but I'll try and give a few answers. Straight off the top of my head so if I get incoherent, ramble, don't make sense...

Per capita consumption of fossil fuels is 20Tpa for you lot over there and less than half of that for us. A third for the pestilential Froggies but then they have lots of nuclear. They might be right.

It helps that we have a climate that really doesn't (yet) warrant a/c more than a few days a year so putting a/c in a UK house is really a waste of money.

This probably sums up my surface attitude - most of our cars have got a/c now and, again, that's really quite dumb if we're trying to limit energy consumption. Open the f*cking windows!

Back to YOU. Leaving aside global warming, for once, lets talk about the price and availability.

I refer you back to my "Anti-American rant" a few dozen posts ago. All I will say - in slightly less hysterical tones - is reduce consumption or don't - the choice is simple. The consequences of not doing so are obvious. Canada has its own oil - for now - so they're probably OK until things get really bad and the US tramp over your borders and take what they need.

Anyway, whatever reason the US give for not doing it - Resisting the International Conspiracy of the Left, The Constitutional Requirement To Do Anything You Want And F*ck Everyone Else, Capitalism Is The Only Way, Don't You Dare Tell Us What To Do (I could go on but you get the point) - the balance of payments issues and the insecurity inherent in relying on OPEC not to throw a wobbly is so obvious that even GWB has finally picked up on it in his recent SOU speech. He still turned it into an anti-Arab point though - will he ever learn?

Of course, American Ingenuity will triumph.

For an example, I refer you to the Moon Landings. On the surface, a triumph of that same American Ingenuity that a number of peers believe will overcome any problems in future energy and resource needs. In reality, a political triumph that has set space exploration back twenty years at the waste of around $150bn.

It is ironic, in a way, that we could all probably have got some of the energy from space had we gone about the exploration in a cooperative and scientifically sensible fashion and... Sorry, I nearly went into a recursive rant there.

Back to the plot. SDI. What the hell happened to that. Did anything ever come of it? Another political triumph which was a major impetus to the breakup of the soviet Bloc. But materially? Scientifically? Has the US public seen any benefits?

On that basis, do we expect "Third Time Lucky" for what needs to be a major political, social, economic and scientific push to reduce the USA's reliance on imported energy? I hope so. An unstable American economy is not good for any of us.

Sorry, got to stop. More Monday.

by maxwell edison

You guys have a way of stretching the truth so far out of proportion that it's almost laughable. You shouldn't be surprised that everything you guys say is taken with the preverbal grain if salt. You get on your soapbox and proclaim that the planet is being destroyed, but how can we possibly take you seriously?

Here's an example of what I mean.

A headline in your publication, The Independent, online edition:

[b][i]Climate change: On the edge.[/b] Greenland ice cap breaking up at twice the rate it was five years ago, says scientist Bush tried to gag[/i]

Oh my God (I mean god), one might say! That dastardly President Bush actually gagged a scientist? That's awful. Even taken figuratively, not literally, we now know that President Bush, personally, kept this scientist from talking. He undoubtedly threatened him with a hunting trip with Dick Cheney!

Deeper in the story is the following: [i]"...the NASA public affairs team - staffed by political appointees from the Bush administration - tried to stop me doing so."[/i]

Would you like to make a wager? I would bet a dollar to a pound of dirt that the "NASA public affairs team" in question is not only staffed by people who weren't appointed by President Bush, but they had their jobs when President Bush was still counting balls and strikes from the owners box at a Texas Rangers Baseball game. (Presidents come and go, but government employees go on and on milking the taxpayers for all they can get.)

There ya' have it. That's the Brits' version of reality. Now remind me again of why we should heed your dire warnings instead of just dismissing them as yet another example of gross exaggerations? After all, the story established, from the very beginning, a firm foundation in absurd exaggeration. (Something that's quite common, I've noticed.) Why shouldn't we expect more to follow?

By the way, nice rant. Those things always crack me up.

by jdclyde

if you go into the hills in the south to find people that live in the wild, tell me just what kind of intelligence you find. Don't confuse rugged with intelligent.

Lots of people are tough, hard workers. This is not dependent on intelligence.

The people on the coast, they are going through the brian drain because they FEEL instead of THINK. They have political power because they take money away from people that actually WORK for a living and give it away, creating a peasent class that will do anything they say to keep the gravy train rolling. Look up "gift society" as a means to get and keep power. Has Democrat written all over it.

Oh yeah, they like to scare old people too.

It is the same people that have people today so leach like that they actually think someone should be just GIVING them their health care free. The great intitlements push. pathetic.

by jdclyde

[i]"It helps that we have a climate that really doesn't (yet) warrant a/c more than a few days a year so putting a/c in a UK house is really a waste of money.

This probably sums up my surface attitude - most of our cars have got a/c now and, again, that's really quite dumb if we're trying to limit energy consumption. Open the f*cking windows!"[/i]

Don't NEED A/C yet? It should be unbareable by NOW? :D

[b]Conservation FACT for Neil.[/b] It has been proven that it uses more energy to drive over 45 mph with the windows open (air drag) than it uses to have the air conditioning on. The opposite is true for UNDER 45 mph. :p

Now roll that window UP!!! B-)
[i]
(I crack myself up!)

by tonythetiger

the break-even point differs with the vehicle, but it just makes sense ... as speed increases, so does drag ... while cooling requirements remain the same.

by tonythetiger

If it's zero degrees tonight and it's supposed to be twice as cold tomorrow night, how cold's it going to be?

by jdclyde

"there is no such thing as COLD, there is only an absence of heat!"

You measure how much heat is in an object, and even at zero, there is still heat.

now from there, do we measuer from ABSOLUTE zero as our starting point?

:D

by maxwell edison

You asked, "If it's zero degrees tonight and it's supposed to be twice as cold tomorrow night, how cold's it going to be?"

Well, it will be half as cold as it would be if it was four times as cold as it is tonight.

by jdclyde

I think your just jealous that I got that post in before you did! :D

ok, "at ABOUT 45 mph".

Is that better? ;\

Either way, Neil is STILL wrong, so happy dance continues! (no, not on my desk, and yes, I still have my cloths on)

by sleepin'dawg

I wouldn't hesitate putting that one on my truck.
Joke: Dick's reply to what his excuse was for the accident,"Excuse??? I hit him, didn't I???"

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

Are you trying to imply you can still put all that into motion??? :^O Ah yes, now I remember. Disney's Fantasia; the hippos did dance.< sorry Jd but I couldn't resist>

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jamesrl

I may be biased on the issue. I worked for the firm that designed your Australian reactor (a slowpoke reserach reactor, similar to ones I have visited at McMaster University in Hamilton).

Chernobyl was a situation where operating standards had fallen so low, that an accident was a good possibility. I would tell you that we have similar situations with chemical plants (Dow in India - does no one remember). But with a good bit of care, such as being exercised in Europe, Canada and US since Three Mile Island, nuclear can be a decent alternative.

The ironic thing about toxicity and half lifes is that the most toxic materials have the shortest half lifes. Canada's Candus do not use enriched Uranium, and while they are very toxic for the first 5 years (stored in water), after that they are able to be trasnferred to dry storage. There have been many studies involving moving dry storage to deep undergound caverns, but its the political consequences not the technical ones that keep this from going forward. Most of the issues in the US around storage are from the by products of the nuclear weapons making industry, not power reactors.

On the other hand, people in North American cities are dying because of the effects of burning fossil fuels for power. We have recently had smog days in communities 200 miles from a major urban centre or source of air pollution.

We have a responsibility that when we are affecting the health of millions NOW that we investigate every potential avenue including nuclear. We may be able to reduce emissions from coal and natural gas. But we can implement emission free nuclear power today. Canada's reactors are very safe, and cannot have a Chernobyl type accident. Others can come up with similar technologies or license ours.

James

by tonythetiger

just imparting a little knowledge (I was a mechanic before I got into IT).

PS. Feel free to continue dancing, but be careful at that edge.

by pjws

... is that people in New York noticed !!!

HA...Just kidding.. now don't go all nutty with the I don't know anything about the New York Second.. etc.. I was just fooling about... perhaps I am just SnowMad.. yeah that's it.. snowmad... backs out of the room slowly and makes a quiet exit ...

by absolutely

I've made a lot of derogatory comments, but only because I hate the man for his actions in office. In the accidental shotgun incident, he made an unfortunate, honest, error.

It's a travesty of journalists' real responsibility to inform the populace that Cheney is even asked for an "excuse". He may owe his hunting partner an [b]explanation[/b], to everybody else on Earth, he owes not a damn thing for that particular mistake.

His error on Windows Media Drivers, however, deserve some careful inquiry.

by puppybreath

I'm beginning to see your point. I think that you should go public with your views regarding abortion. In fact, let's make you the poster child for abortions. I think everyone will agree that in your case, an abortion would have been best for everyone involved.

by jdclyde

and was right about the dance.

Being right all the time is a burden, but I am used to it! :D

Back to the dance!