Discussion Locked

88,399,953 is a VERY big number

0 helpful
22 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

PrivacyRights.org has put together a site to track every single identity theft incident since February, 2005. As of today, there have been over 210 separate incidents reported and 88,399,953 people affected. Yes, in the past 18 months nearly 90 MILLION (may I emphasize the MILLION) people in this country alone have been affected by identity theft. 90 MILLION is nearly 1/3 the population of this country. Many types of personal information lost has included:

* Names
* Phone numbers
* Addresses
* SSN?s
* Credit card numbers
* Checking account numbers
* Mortgage information
* Payroll information
* Photos
* Dates of birth
* Fingerprints
* Medical histories

The site is
http://www.privacyrights.org/ar/ChronDataBreaches.htm#CP

Seriously, how long are we going to wait until we really take it upon us to protect ourselves with maximum effort. Once again...90 MILLION affected...

22 replies

by mickster269

"Seriously, how long are we going to wait until we really take it upon us to protect ourselves with maximum effort. Once again...90 MILLION affected..."

You make the claim that 90 Million people have been "affected". Please define "affected".

For example, I am a Veteran of the US Army. Recently, as you might have heard, some of my personal information collected by the Veterans Administration may have been compromised.

I recieved a letter from the VA informing me of the incident, and what steps (if I didn't already know) I should take as a precaution.

Now, have I been "affected"?

by nathank9

Good question...what does "affected" really mean.

In my case, affected means someone has breached security systems one way or another and whereabouts of the data are unknown. In your case, it is likely that your data is on that laptop, but it is unlikely that the person will be able to use/sell all 26.5 identities on there.

Of course 90 million people have not had their identities stolen and people are charging thousands of dollars to their credit cards, but the data has been lost on 90 million people and something could potentialy come about from it.

To summarize, yes, you have been "affected" because your information was stolen and CAN be used for identity fraud. I hope of course that nothing has happened yet and that nothing will come about from this but we can not be 100% sure.

by mickster269

I have been affected, because now I have reason to pay attention to my bank accounts and such for reasons not of my own making.

It's one thing to pro-active about the release of your personal information (online banking/purchases, getting a credit card, etc). It's another to be re-active because of something you had no control over.

My next question would be, how many specific individuals have been affected? Is that 90 million individuals, or 90 million instances of data theft.

I imagine, from reading that list, it really must suck to have been in the Navy right now.

by tonythetiger

"people are charging thousands of dollars to their credit cards"

Get about 50 credit cards and max them out. Then nobody will WANT your identity :)

by tryten

I recieved the same papers from the VA. The papers also stated that some of the stolen data included spouses information. This could easily bring the 26 million up by several MILLION. Do these reported numbers include the VA and their spouses. This is important information that should be passed along with these results.

by tig2

This count only goes back to Feb 2005. I would be interested in seeing a count since 2002 when it was MUCH more difficult to report and there was little to no protection in place.

Teaching the average end user to protect themselves is difficult at best. You might understand the need in your workplace but can't translate the need to your home computer. Since your bank, creditors, and just about everyone else is encouraging you to pay on line, the average user is really unaware of how much of their personal, non-public info is really stored on a hard drive.

From a business perspective, it runs hot and cold. Sure, there are requirements to manage to but not enough buy-in for the spend to get robust projects off the ground. Living in the violation zone is often referred to as "the cost of doing business" even though it may generate a reportable event.

I don't know what the answer is. I do know that it must be mandated that the individual is responsible for protecting their information when it is in their possession. Equally, business must be held responsible if the breach occurs while they are in possession of an individual's data.

by ontheropes

you didn't want to though.

Blog it all Max. What was that I said? Blog it all? Yup! That's what I thought I said. I'm not telling you to, uh uh, I'm asking you to. I don't mean blog here at TR either. Come here to cool down. Blog on the Web to heat things up. Use your TR alias if need be.

I'll predict that you'll have a rather large web page hit count in no time. You can safely play against the Class A varsity big boys, you aren't a second string player, so get in the big game and whoop on 'em!

Hut 1, Hut 2, Hut 3...

edit clarity

by rfink

Identify theft will be profitable until the penalites are severe enough to curtail it. Let's make identify theft a capital offense or better yet have Bush create the Department of Identify Security, throw billions of dollars at it and that should solve all of our problems. After all he is only trying to help.

by oldbag

My husband is a complete luddite when it comes to using computers. He never banks or shops on-line, goes to a bank teller for deposits and uses his debit card infrequently.

A couple of months ago,one of our bank accounts was mysteriously cleared out. Luckily for us, the account was at a low point and not much was actually taken. After I double checked the transactions, we determined that neither of us had made the withdrawal so we reported it to the bank immediately. They did an investigation and determined that the transaction was made with my husband's card and PIN and that the source of the transaction was Romania.

Here in Canada, the banks have insurance to cover losses such as this so we had our money back in a couple of weeks. My husband had to replace his debit card and change his PIN.

We are both more careful now.

by ontheropes

Some identities have to be negative assets. ?There he is boys! Finally caught the sumbeech!?

That would be too funny. I'm waiting for that kind of thing to show up at fark.com.

by marileev9

Thanks for the information Nathan and starting this very important discussion. More than a month later, the White House as reported by CNET has published a Risk Memo addressing government organization's responsibility to data security and the laptop theft - http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/memoranda/fy2006/m06-16.pdf

Tools already exist in the commercial sector to do many of the required items on the memo like authentication checks, encrypting data and restricting usage http://www.essentialsecurity.com/howitworks_laptop.htm

I hope that the government looks to already available solutions "out of the box," rather than starting from the ground up. Utilizing public sector technology could save them additional embarrassment and time.

by tig2

The laptop with data on 26.5 million veterans, active duty and spouses has been recovered. See http://news.com.com/2061-10789_3-6089461.html. I didn't see anything that helps to understand if the data was accessed or copied to another source.

Unfortunately, for those impacted, the recovery doesn't mean that you are now safe. It only means that the source data has been recovered.

Too little, too late if you ask me.

by j.lupo

the indicated that the data was intact and had not been accessed or copied elsewhere. Sorry I don't have the link to the story, but it appeared on Yahoo about an hour ago.

by ontheropes

June 29, 2006
Google Aims to Speed the Online Checkout Line
By SAUL HANSELL

In its quest to "organize the world's information," Google now wants to keep track of your credit card number and where you live.

The company is introducing Google Checkout today, a service that will allow users to make purchases from online stores using payment and shipping information they keep on file with Google.

Google's aim, said Eric E. Schmidt, the chief executive, is to make it easier and faster for people to buy products advertised on Google ? thus attracting more advertisers.

"The goal here is to make it be one nanosecond from the time the customer decides to buy to the time the transaction is complete and the product is on the way," Mr. Schmidt said.

For consumers, this sort of service, often referred to as an online wallet, is hardly new. Microsoft, AOL and Yahoo have offered similar wallets, which proved to have limited appeal. While the PayPal service of eBay has attracted widespread use, it offers additional features like the ability to transfer money from checking accounts.

But for merchants, the service comes with a twist: Google will waive some or all of the transaction fees for companies that buy advertising from it. That may give the service a leg up on competitors like PayPal and several smaller companies that help online merchants accept credit cards.

It will also add another entry to the list of businesses that have been shaken up by Google's innovations, a list that already includes publishing, advertising and desktop software.

Google is charging merchants 20 cents plus 2 percent of the purchase price to process card transactions, less than most businesses pay for credit card processing. Banking industry executives say that credit card processors typically pay MasterCard and Visa a fee of 30 cents and 1.95 percent for every purchase, so Google will be subsidizing many transactions.

What is more, for every $1 a company spends on search advertising, Google will waive the fees on $10 worth of purchases. Factoring in the 2 percent fee, that represents a rebate of at least 20 percent of advertising spending.

Mr. Schmidt said the company was willing to lose money on transaction fees because it felt the package would increase advertising spending.

"The math works because we can have lower prices and higher volume," he said.

Google's decision to give free transaction processing to advertisers has the potential to disrupt its carefully cultivated electronic auction for ad placement. Google has worked hard to ensure that the auction treats all advertisers equally, sometimes to the dismay of big companies that are used to discounts for major purchases. It has not offered commissions to advertising agencies, as most media companies do.

Online merchants that do not want to use Google Checkout "might be a little peeved," said Kevin Lee, chief executive of Did-it.com, a search advertising agency. "They might say if you give that credit to some people for credit card processing, give it to me for something else."

Mr. Schmidt said Google had not considered this issue.

While Google's tactics may be seen as aggressive competition, the company is unlikely to run afoul of antitrust laws because it does not have a monopoly in the market.

Yahoo, the other main seller of advertising on search results, recently announced an alliance with eBay that among other things will encourage Yahoo advertisers to use PayPal for payment processing. PayPal will also be promoted as the online wallet for use on Yahoo services. Both companies declined to give financial details of the deal.

Google expects that most sites that use Google Checkout will also continue to use their existing method of processing credit cards and may accept PayPal as well.

Advertisements on Google.com from companies that accept Google Checkout will display a small image of a shopping cart. Clicking on the ad will take customers to the advertiser's Web site, as it does now. When customers decide to buy something, they will be offered the option to sign into Google Checkout and use the credit card and address information on file there. Customers that do not have accounts with Google will be encouraged to set them up.

Google may get several additional benefits from the checkout service. It will encourage more users to register and give it personal data, allowing Google to display advertising based on specific attributes of the viewer. More broadly, the data the company gets from transactions could help it improve the way it chooses which advertising to show to which users. Google says it does not currently plan to use transaction data in this way.

For merchants, one concern is whether Google's system, which is unfamiliar to users, will reduce the number of people who complete purchases on their sites, a measure known as the conversion rate.

"You have people in your most valuable area and suddenly you are switching them off your site to something no one has ever done before," said John Bresee, the president of Backcountry.com, an online seller of sporting goods that has been testing Google Checkout. "The cost will be stunningly high, if they are not great at what they do."

Mr. Bresee said Backcountry would have people watching the performance of Google Checkout around the clock.

"If they convert at the same rate, and the fees are lower, we will put up the biggest Google Checkout button you have ever seen," he said.

by tig2

Until I can read and understand a privacy statement and data safeguard statement with traceable examples, I will not use this service. If I cannot use a "rechargable" credit card- one that is pay-as-you-go, I will not use this service- and I will tell everyone I can get the ear of to not use this service.

Too many businesses have a laissez-faire attittude about my personal information and little will to help when they foster a crisis. Access to a credit report is insufficent. You are ENTITLED to one from each credit reporting agency per year anyway. Three agencies, 12 months in a calendar year. Every trimester. Free. Just ask.

The problems start when someone HAS stolen your identity and you have to pick up the pieces. You may be asked to PROVE that it wasn't you who charged all that merchandise. If the shops were local or online, good luck with that. You might try "habits and spending" as a defense. Good luck with that, too. I can almost guarentee that if you don't have a definitive police report, you will get no traction.

Bottom line- banks are insured AGAINST you, not FOR you.

I have been there, done that, and frankly will never have credit or a bank account again because of it.

Google is possibly making a big mistake here.

by tig2

But I have to try.

I still won't use the service- but then I have never been big on on-line purchases and I pay my bills in cash- thus ticking off many who would like to NEVER handle cash. They especially don't like me to point out that each bill is imprinted with the words "This note is legal tender for all debts, public and private."

The theory is that the credit reporting agencies have to fix errors that you find on your report if you bring them to attention. Good luck with that.

I have gotten to do the ID theft thing. See https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196739&messageID=2051512
for the gorey details. The problem is that once it has happened, you are never free of it. So I do my best.

I know that my information is out there- some of it deliberately mis-stated by me. Wherever possible and where it makes no difference, I don't use actual information. Does this mean that I will dodge further ID theft? Probably not. But at least I am trying.

You're right- Life is great! The little stuff BITES

Edited for the heck of it

This discussion is closed to new replies.