Discussion Locked

A Catch-22 proposition on oil dependence

0 helpful
141 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

141 replies

by x-marcap

The biggest poluter in the world would be exempt from the treaty. China is exempt. Third World countries are exempt.

Kyoto is only implemented in the places where there is no, or very little industry. Russia signed but polutes as desired. The treaty is useless, and was designed to handcuff US industry.

by x-marcap

Most of the rest of the world believes they cannot rise so they try to lower all others.

They should know a rising tide lifts all boats.

by dr dij

wind power is already competitive,
solar power needs price reductions
which are likely to come with mass production

brazil produces 25% of its transportation fuel from ethanol
biodiesel from waste is only a miniscule portion of need
biodiesel from agriculture (oil palms) is being done in malaysia. it has the air pollution problems of diesel. in addition, forest fires are caused by clearing land and yearly burn off of cane, causing vast air pollution in same areas.
the plantations are wiping out vast areas of wildlife habitat

by mjwx

By viable I meant a solution that can be implemented now. Implementation would initially require both systems to be in place but then have the fossil fuel system phased out.

Wind power relies on wind being present. A 10 Km2 (square) patch of solar panels in the desert of Australia could power the entire country but we don?t know what the effect of a 10 Km2 heat sink would have on the environment. Good idea?s yes, but unfortunately not viable.

Nuclear is viable, but then you have the waste, fallout and weapons issues so while it is viable for nations like Australia, the US and Brittan, it isn?t viable for all.

by Member 25348569

I have to believe it's deliberate ignorance!

Kyoto is not about pollution. It's about carbon dioxide emissions - and other greenhouse gases, but they're nowhere near as critical. It's about the amount of energy from non-nuclear, non-renewable sources that you use. All your gas-fired, scrubbed waste gas, clean, sulphur-free gasoline don't cause a jot of reduction in the quantity of carbon dioxide that America puts out.

Yes, China's industry pumps out a load of sulphurous black smog but it's only the invisible, odourless carbon dioxide that Kyoto was dealing with.

So. What have you done without Kyoto? Bush talked a good lot but what have you [b]done[/b]?

Fcuk all. That's what!

by maxwell edison

.
And I think it's because of [i]deliberate ignorance.[/i]

Kyoto IS NOT about pollution.

Kyoto IS NOT about carbon dioxide emissions.

Kyoto IS NOT about greenhouse gases.

Kyoto IS NOT about global warming (real or perceived).

Kyoto IS NOT about man-caused global warming (real or perceived).

Kyoto IS NOT about the amount of energy from non-nuclear sources.

Kyoto IS NOT about the amount of energy from non-renewable sources.

Kyoto IS NOT about the amount of energy from non-renewable sources.

Kyoto IS NOT about saving the Earth.

[b]Kyoto IS NOT about ANYTHING except extorting money from the United States and/or exercising control over the United States.[/b]

What about that do [b]YOU[/b] not understand?

by maxwell edison

.
Original Source:

http://news.independent.co.uk/world/politics/article341967.ece

By Philip Thornton
January 30, 2006
The Independent (UK)

The most potent threats to life on earth - global warming, health pandemics, poverty and armed conflict - could be ended by moves that would unlock $7 trillion - $7,000,000,000,000 (?3.9trn) - of previously untapped wealth, the United Nations claims today....

The price? An admission that the nation-state is an old-fashioned concept that has no role to play in a modern globalised world where financial markets have to be harnessed rather than simply condemned....

Solving the environmental crisis tops the UN's $7trn wish-list. It calls for an international market to trade pollution permits that would encourage rich countries to cut pollution and hit their targets under the Kyoto protocol....

But - and the UN admits it is a big "but" - the US would have to sign up to Kyoto and carbon trading to achieve the $3.64trn that it believes the system would deliver over time.

----------

NO, Neil. It's NOT about ANYTHING you claim.

IT'S ALL ABOUT THE MONEY!

http://www.eyeontheun.org/assets/attachments/articles/2494%20UN%20unveils%20plan%20to%20release%20untapped%20wealth%20of.doc

by Member 25348569

I'll try and come back with some proper arguments when I get some time...

In the mean time, keep the anger down, it's not good for the environment.

Money, money, money...
It's a rich man's world...

by Member 25348569

Here's an example of when it all works. I accept that the the hole in the Ozone Layer was an observable fact and you couldn't say it wasn't an issue. However, it was the US who led efforts to address this problem which culminated in the 1987 Montreal Protocol which imposed a ban on many deoderants, refrigerants and propellants for aerosols. Later, the US brokered amendments to the protocol allowing India and China to join and, subsequently, almost every country in the world. The hole in the ozone layer is closing. Started in the Reagan years and continued under Clinton.

I do believe that we have to address fossil fuel consumption for many reasons - some of them beneficial even if Global Warming is either imaginary or not capable of being affected by our efforts. I accept that you, personally, do not agree with Global Warming and your implacable resistance to anyone "telling you what to do" will make you resist any international treaty that isn't US-inspired so I'll just limit myself to telling you why environmentalists don't like the US. Make of it whatever you want. Ignore it if you will.

This is [b]my[/b] take, by the way, and that of the governments of most of the rest of the world. You see it as a conspiracy to wreck the US economy despite the self-evident fact that if the US economy suffers, the whole world goes into recession with you. We see it as commercialism and greed overcoming all common sense.

The Kyoto Protocol has been accepted by nearly every other country. The USA is by a massive margin the world's biggest polluter and very disproportionately so. President bush has repeatedly stated that he will not adopt such protocols if they harm American economy.

Here's the facts from around the time of the Kyoto negociations of the Carbon Dioxide emissions of the three biggest polluters:

The USA has 4.6% of the Worlds population and around 30% of the World's economic wealth and produces 24% of the total World carbon dioxide emissions. The EU, with 5.3% of the World's population and 23% of the world economy emits 14% of the carbon dioxide. China, with 32% of the poulation and 3.2% of the economic wealth produces 13% of the carbon dioxide emissions.

China and the EU combined are both lesser polluters than the US and have one thing in common which is that they are both reducing and committed to further reducing their rate of emissions. The odd one out is the USA. Immensely richer than China, but with less population than Europe, it emits more greenhouse gasses than both of them. The US has so far stubbornly refused to do anything other than talk big and has failed to endorse any international protocols designed to reduce such emissions.

We all look on totally flabbergasted.

The Kyoto Protocol is not perfect but no compromise between countries ever is. It doesn't go far enough but it is at least a first step. In September 2004, Russia accepted Kyoto, making the protocol legally binding internationally and now in total over 55% of all greenhouse gases are accounted for internationally. This was its original aim.

You go ahead and do your own thing.

by rob mekel

a lot of things.

And yes, Kyoto is about "rich" country's contributing more to the environment then "poor" country's. Whether this is right or wrong I won't discus.

As our, now a day's, most used energy sources are very polluting there has to be taken action to protect our environment. This and the fact that on the long run we know we will run out of, as you put it nicely, non-renewable (re)sources, next to our dependency on not very relaible suppliers we have to take actions. So that on the long run, but who of the policitians is interested on a long run gain, we will have enough resources to provide the needed energy.

Some think that Kyoto is a contribute to this, as it makes community more eager to invest in discovering new energy, less polluting, sources to avoid paying for the pollution.
That is where Kyoto is not a bad thing.

And as I stated before I won't discus whether who has to pay what or when, this is a matter of politicians/negotiations, whom we, as voters, can judge on every voting day.

But sure do find that the polluter has to pay, whether they're rich or poor.

Rob

@life is too short to not enjoy it :x

by jck

they'd probably also start funding more North Sea oil exploration with all that money they'd take from the Arabs, as well as probably funding it anywhere else to try and find something to try and compensate what they were getting from the Middle East.

Wonder if the Russians would sell us Siberia like they did Alaska? :^O

by x-marcap

Extortion, because the US and it's citizen's own the rights and the property that will be converted to UN control...

Look at our National Parks that are now UN Heritage Zones... What did the UN have to do with our National Parks? Nothing, but they are now in the ownership and control position. Thank ($*%#) you Bill Clinton...

by x-marcap

If the Oil lease has a known reserve. (located Oil and/or Gas) it is worth far more to a company who merely takes possession of the rig and pumps the oil out and refines it to sell and make profit. The cash from the oil and gas lease sales helps fund:
General budget items, Further exploration, Government lease process, and education...

Most of the problem is that the ugly truth is we aren't actually opening up new wells this way to a great extent. That is what happens with 6% of the income generated from oil leases. 94% goes to attorney fees. Yes, I said attorney fees. From the environmentalist challenges in court, to the writing of contracts to keep the oil companies from just pumping and running, the fees are horrendous. Shakespeare said it best... The first against the wall....

by x-marcap

Then we would get the efficiency of the Bureau (Frog for Desk) with the Hierarchy of a Religion fron the left. (Maybe with the bureaucratic liberal efficiency, accused murderers would die of old age before their trials, but that is another issue.)

A bureaucracy exists to perpetuate itself.

We need the Government to get out of the way.

by maxwell edison

Neil will never concede that this whole Kyoto business is ONLY about extorting money from the United States. He has bought into the global warming scare lock, stock, and oil barrel.

And I will never concede that this whole global warming scare is about anything BUT extorting money from the United States and/or United States companies (either directly or indirectly).

We are both literally and figuratively oceans apart on this one.

I's not about the environment, Neil. It's about money and control.

by cactus pete

So, how many 10m by 10m rooftops dor you need to achieve the same coverage?

How much of downtown Sydney is covered by rooftops? Add in all your other major buildings... Getting my point yet?

by mjwx

where there is an uninteruped source of sunlight year round. (the sun in the aussie desert can fry an egg on a paint tin). the problem with this is as I mentioned, that the enviromental effect of a 10 by 10 KM heat sink in is not known.

The rooftops of homes (which is what occupies most of sydney's footprint) in australia are placed at angles (not flat like in the US) making the only half the rooftop useful for half the day.

also theres the logistical nightmare of linking them together.

re-reading posts dpetrak, its a good idea in theory, but i take it you dont live in australia. you really have to live here to fully understand the climate and geography.

by cactus pete

And I responded, knowing that altering the landscape of the desert is a bad idea, that perhaps a better solution is then to change the tops of buildings in your DOWNTOWN locations. I did not refer to your residential houses.

I fact, I have proposed the same thing be done ANYWHERE. If you have a roof, have solar panels. Particularly on large government and business structures.

Add to that, particularly in DOWNTOWN areas, wind turbines on the sides of buildings. Winds become concentrated between these buildings and effectively speed up there, making it more profitable in these types of locations.

by sleepin'dawg

from where I'm sitting I can't see the ground from my hotel room window. (15th floor) The worst smog and quality of air I've seen from anywhere other than in eastern Germany and the Czech Republic and even they weren't as bad as this. It's nearly 6AM here and the morning rush has started but I can't see a soul because I can't see the ground. This is normal here at this time of the year but it is only marginally better during the rest of the year. The same applys to Mumbai(Bombay), Delhi, Bangkok, Manila, Mexico City, Djakarta and Guangzhou. I've never seen so much smog any place else like they have it in these places. People wear surgical masks, it is that bad. You don't step outdoors without slipping a mask on.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by Member 25348569

This is the classic misinformation as posted by a number of the US peers.

We all need to grasp the difference between pollution and greenhouse emissions. The US might have the cleanest power stations and cars on God's Green Earth but they produce by far and away the largest quantity of greenhouse gases.

Sorry, Dawg, you'll just have to keep coughing.

:D

by maxwell edison

.
....will you PLEASE spare me the usual and silly "Money, money, money...It's a rich man's world" type rhetoric. You know damn well what I meant by my comments, and for you (or anyone) to turn it into something it's not, only shows disingenuousness and/or the inability to confront a real concern with a real answer.

by Member 25348569

Not in any meaning of the word.

It is about the money - just as you said. American money and the rest of the world can go fu*k themselves. Face it, as we disagree on the need for any reduction in carbon emissions then we don't really have a basis for any discussion on Kyoto.

Kyoto is either an International Conspiract Funded by the Treacherous United Nations to Control the Freedoms of the American Citizens Won by Your Forefathers from Perfidious Britain or it isn't.

It isn't.

by maxwell edison

"The hole in the ozone layer above Antarctica has grown to near record size this year, suggesting 20 years of pollution controls have so far had little effect, the United Nations said on Friday."

http://www.int.iol.co.za/index.php?set_id=1&click_id=31&art_id=qw1126879021640B251

"The hole in the ozone layer this year will probably be slightly smaller than the all-time largest of 2003, in line with the general trend of a gradual healing of the ozone layer's depletion, a U.N. agency said Friday."

http://www.livescience.com/environment/ap_050916_ozone_hole.html

"The ozone hole over Antarctica appears to have shrunk about 20 per cent from last year's record size, scientists said Friday."

http://www.cbc.ca/story/science/national/2004/10/01/ozone_hole0401001.html

"The ozone hole over the Antarctic this year has reached the record size of 10.8 million square miles set three years ago, the United Nations' weather organization said Wednesday. Measurements over and near Antarctica show that ozone decreased more rapidly this year than in previous years and that the size of the ozone hole is now as large as it was in September 2000, the World Meteorological Organization said. The hole could continue to grow to its largest size ever in the next couple of weeks, the WMO said, but it also could suddenly decrease. It's impossible to predict...."

http://www.usatoday.com/weather/climate/2003-09-17-ozone-hole_x.htm

-----------------------------------

The ozone hole - Just another elaborate hoax.

The "ozone hole" was discovered a mere 30 years ago -- COMPARED TO WHAT? Who's to say it hasn't ALWAYS been there, shrinking, growing, and doing whatever mother nature decides it will do.

Well, people are gullible enough to believe that we caused the ozone hole, so I shouldn't be surprised that they're also gullible enough to believe we're warming the planet.

by maxwell edison

ALL cut-and-pasted from article - link to follow.

Europe is the citadel of hypocrisy. Considering Europeans' contempt for the United States and George Bush for not embracing the Kyoto Protocol, you'd expect that they would have made major reductions in greenhouse gas emissions -- the purpose of Kyoto. Well, not exactly. From 1990 (Kyoto's base year for measuring changes) to 2002, global emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2), the main greenhouse gas, increased 16.4 percent, reports the International Energy Agency. The U.S. increase was 16.7 percent, and most of Europe hasn't done much better.

Here are some IEA estimates of the increases: France, 6.9 percent; Italy, 8.3 percent; Greece, 28.2 percent; Ireland, 40.3 percent; the Netherlands, 13.2 percent; Portugal, 59 percent; Spain, 46.9 percent. It's true that Germany (down 13.3 percent) and Britain (a 5.5 percent decline) have made big reductions. But their cuts had nothing to do with Kyoto. After reunification in 1990, Germany closed many inefficient coal-fired plants in eastern Germany; that was a huge one-time saving. In Britain, the government had earlier decided to shift electric utilities from coal (high CO2 emissions) to plentiful natural gas (lower CO2 emissions).

On their present courses, many European countries will miss their Kyoto targets for 2008-2012. To reduce emissions significantly, Europeans would have to suppress driving and electricity use; that would depress economic growth and fan popular discontent. It won't happen. Political leaders everywhere deplore global warming -- and then do little. Except for Eastern European nations, where dirty factories have been shuttered, few countries have cut emissions. Since 1990 Canada's emissions are up 23.6 percent; Japan's, 18.9 percent.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/06/28/AR2005062801248.html

by Member 25348569

You know what I meant and I'm so fed up with explaining the difference between pollution and carbon emissions to the deliberately obtuse that I give up. I just don't give a sh:t about what the good ol' US of f*cking A does about reducing emissions because I know you'll do absolutely f*ck all. You all carry on driving your gas-guzzling crap and whining about your balance of payments and the Arabs holding you to ransom until another of your cities is washed away like New Orleans.

Gah.

by maxwell edison

You said, "Kyoto is either an International Conspiract Funded by the Treacherous United Nations to Control the Freedoms of the American Citizens Won by Your Forefathers from Perfidious Britain or it isn't."

Yes, it is.

By the way, is this the same United Nations that swore up and down (before 2004) that they, or any of their people, were not involved in the Iraq oil for food scandal?

Yea, right!

by Member 25348569

that we are really arguing about different things.

It is my belief that global warming is a real issue. I am, as yet, unsure as to whether it is anthropogenic or - even if it is - that it's not too late to do anything about it. It is certainly a waste of time trying to do anything about it if the government of the US is going to ignore the possibility that it is real.

The fact that the governments of most countries - my own included - are more dishonest, though perhaps not as venal, as yours merely serves to fuel (p.i.) my frustration with the whole issue.

Given that, we - you and me - are hardly going to progress from my earlier contention that the US would benefit from adopting some of the goals of the Kyoto agreement. For you to extrapolate from Kyoto through some blue sky globalisation scheme to reach the conclusion that by doing anything against global warming you would be out $7 trillion isn't something that I really care about. I'll believe that when it happens.

Nonetheless, if ythe US had signed up for some part of emissions reduction; if the US scientific and engineering community had seriously addressed the alternative energy question starting ten or more years ago rather than the unspecified future date in Bush's SOU speech then we would probably all be further along the road towards reducing emissions, balance of payments and reliance on mad Arabs.

Sorry about the last post by the way. I am sitting here at 11:30pm local time trying to fix our Exchange backup and it hasn't put me in the best - or most logical - of moods. Shouting "reattach, you bastard volume" doesn't make it run any faster, either.

68%

by Member 25348569

Yes, they'd like you to contribute. If there is a problem - you believe there isn't and they either believe or say there is - then you are the major cause of the problem.

If the problem is real then the main cost of the solution would paid by the main polluter - you.

As you don't believe in the problem then - obviously - you see it as a conspiracy.

by maxwell edison

.
It shows genuine passion, even though I disagree on the particular issue. I don't think you'll ever get me upset or mad, per se, nor could you ever offend me, but I think I've shown such "passion" in the past as well.

Yea, that's the ticket -- it's passion! It's not name-calling, not flaming, not yelling, but passion. Has a nice ring to it, don't you think?

by Member 25348569

and I do like a good rant now and again.

Nobody can get hurt unless they really are wimps. I don't like to lose it too much though but tonight I could unload some of my frustration with another US icon - Bill Gates - onto you, the US and everything.

The Exchange volume has now reattached and I can go home. Alas, tomorrow you are in for an in-depth Ozone Layer Hole dissertation if nothing breaks in my SAN.

Unless, of course, I find you were right...:p

by Member 25348569

With the combination of rising oil prices, low energy taxes and adequate - for the moment - supply, there is no incentive for any organisation to move towards alternative energy. Serious investment won't come until the price of oil products reaches a level far above what it is now. By then it will be too late and the effect on your economy will be major.

Carrot or stick. the government has to do one or the other.

You (and we) should have started seriously years ago.

Just my 2 barrels worth.

by Member 25348569

Are you a mate of Maxwells? Methinks I recognise the sentiments...

You Libertarians ganging up on us lefty econuts, are you?

by mjwx

Our urban centers are in temperate, tropical or cyclonic zones. each making them unsuitable for large scale solar colection.

by absolutely

make a couple megawatts!

Nuclear energy is the only rational solution. It happens to be the safest source of large quantities of energy. Food, of course, is good for a few thousand calories per day per person, but for the thousands of Watts we each use each day, nuclear energy is really the safest. John Stossel did the math for us, and I admit that I haven't checked it. But his claim is that "Chernobyl, the worst nuclear power disaster ever, killed only 30 people. Some say the radiation may eventually kill others, but even if that's true, natural gas kills more people every year." ([i]Give Me A Break[/i], page 80)

In another chapter, he uses a more rigorous, in fact brilliant, proof that poverty is more lethal than cigarette smoke: he correlates both factors, and many others, to life span, and the numbers show conclusively that the average life span of smokers (of any income) is greater than the average life span of the shamefully poor (regardless of whether they smoke or not). The same should be done with the total effect of proximity to nuclear plants on lifespans compared to people not close to nuclear plants. Anybody got a large pile of grant money? I wonder if the Nuclear Regulatory Commission has even done a single study.

by absolutely

I'll vote for the first Presidential candidate to commit to commission such a study, to see that it's widely publicized and conducted thoroughly, objectively, and using academically correct statistical methods.

This discussion is closed to new replies.