Discussion Locked

A man walks into a bar...

0 helpful
82 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The classic start to many a good joke.

Based on the discourses in some of the lengthy discussions on here, which three 'peers' would you most like to have a beer with and 'put the world to rights' - person to person?

This isn't a popularity contest! Just be interesting to see who you'd choose to have a beer or three with. Would you choose like-minded TR 'citizens' with similar opinions? Would you prefer an 'interesting' evening with the chance of a damn good 'punch-up' before last call?!!

Just to kick off...

I'd choose the following company for starters...

'The Duck' (MallardtooXX), Jules (Jul646) and LordInfidel.

And then maybe a night out with 'The Chas', 'Admin'(@l33tcentral) and dpetrak.

Should prove to be a 'lively' drink either way! Mine's a Guinness...first one in, set 'em up!

82 replies

by cactus pete

I gave up alcohol when I was 15. Then I tried it on my 22nd birthday, and let's just say it's a good thing I gave it up.

But perhaps I'll kill my taste buds on an IronBru with you the next time I'm over your way.

Hmm, who would I pick?

Youknow, I'm not sure. I suppose I'd rather sit back and watch the whole lot of the core posters 'discuss' things - with periodic interjections on my part to help the tone of the night, or the direction of the conversation.

A gun to my head? I'd snap up LordInfidel, the Duck, and probably Colin.

That would surely lead to an entertaining evening.

Most of the others I would want to see in one on one at first.

by oz_media

I'd welcome ANY member of TR out for beers. Like minded company is boring to say the least. I think with all the different countries and opinions that are represented here, it would be a blast to have a TR night out. Hey lets get them to give us beers for our points, I guess instead of "Bang Bang Maxwell's Silver Hammer" it would be "Bang Bang let's see Maxwell Hammered".

I don't think the opinions shared here would be as amusing if it didn't include all opinions the way discussions do, so I won't take sides and pick a few. You're all good for a drink in my books.

by admin

I'm game.... I'll start up in the Q&A again when that happens!!! Of course, they better have Guinness!!!

Well, it's really difficult....

I'd like to drink with (even if it's Root Beer- no worries!)

Generalist
Oldefar
Max
TomSal
Jim Phelps
Jules
Guru of DOS
Duck
OZ
Lord
dpetrek
Colin
The Locksmith
JimHM
Chas
MR Afrohead
and epepke

That was off the top of my head.... so check back! :)

Maybe we need a 2 week convention instead of a night out though!!!!! *smile*

by maxwell edison

This is a tough question because, as mentioned earlier, it would be a hoot to have a beer with many - or most - of the folks who post here.

For a stimulating and intelligent discussion on many political issues with people I both agree and disagree with on various issues, I'd choose TheChas, TheDuck, TheDpetrak, TheAdmin, TheTomSal, and TheDonald. (Okay, I just threw in TheDonald - and the other The's)

To get "hammered" (great line, oz) around a pool table with the possibility of getting into a tiff with some renegade locals, it would definitely be LordInfidel. (And as a bonus he could answer any networking questions I have.)

To discuss how much we have in common, it would be oldefar. (He's revealed more than I have, so he wouldn'thave known this. For example, same early scenario plus USAF 1972-1978 plus more.)

On the golf course (even though I usually refrain from drinking on the links), since he's the only one that I remember mentioning that he plays golf as well, I'd walk down the yellow brick cart path with the OZ man. (But he'd have to leave his choice of music at home)

(continued...)

by maxwell edison

For some laughs over some crude jokes and for an explanation of why every Brit I've ever met looks down their nose at all Americans - while, at the same time, they're working in America - it would be GuruOfDOS.

To enlighten him about how politicsreally works, it would be MrAfroHead.

To learn a thing or two or three or more about MS Office and/or any other Microsoft product, it would be DKlippert and Joseph Moore.

Because of the incredibly nice things she's said about me, it would be dbgirl. (If, of course, she's really a girl. I wouldn't want to drink a beer with a guy who calls himself girl.)

To prove I'm not what he thinks I am (even though he'll say he was intentionally trying to just push me over the "brink"), and to proveto him that he can't believe everything he reads in the Sydney Morning Herald newspaper, it would be Julian - but he owes me, so he'll have to buy.

To see if he really does have three dozen PhDs, has scaled the highest mountains, has swam the deepest seas, has done all and knows all that there is to do and know, it would be Colin.

by oz_media

"Because of the incredibly nice things she's said about me, it would be dbgirl. (If, of course, she's really a girl. I wouldn't want to drink a beer with a guy who calls himself girl.)"

Depends on the order though, beer first and you never know?

As for my taste in music, I don't really have one, people assume METAL because I think Ozzy is the next best thing to GOD (who is really Rob Halford formerly of Judas Priest) and manage Metal bands.
My first wife was the Principal Cellist for the Vancouver Symphony Orchestra (many nights spent there), I love reggae and old jazz, I'm into all that North American Beer Rock (Sprignsteen, Cochrane, CCR etc.) and often listen to the Retro 80's stuff, Men at Work, Prince, Dexy and the Midnight Runners, et al.
About the ONLY "sound" I can't bear is RAP, or HipHop due to the lack of musicianship and ease of production, this simplicity doesn't gain credit for being an ARTIST in my books.

I-Loo, a place for everyone,whether mega-bits or mega-*^%Ts.
(It's getting worse, somebody help me.)

by maxwell edison

As far as the music goes, bring a copy of - what else - Abbey Road.

.... as for the "beer first" comment. Okay, whatever rows your boat. But if I don't show up for our tee time, just go ahead and start without me.

by guruofdos

Can't explain that....the only time I look down MY nose at an American, is when my wife is bl**ing me...but that's not for discussion here....oooo-er!!! As for the viewpoint of 'Brits working in the US'...I haven't lived or worked there so I can't help on that one...I visit often enough because the wife's family are all over there, but I'm not! Mind you, if working for the US Army in Germany and Kosovo count's as working there (all their bases are 'Little America') then that's as close as I get!!

Of course...YOU'D be on my list of people to go for a beer with as you have a great perspective on Life, The Universe and Everything....but we'd still be in the bar a month later and THAT doesn't count as a 'night out'!

by oz_media

I actually have two US offices (California and Oregon) and work back and forth.
I know I've said in past rants that American's are seen as arrogant by MY friends, aquaintances and family in England (OK, I confess, me too)but that was only after having a real love for the USA and then having my "useless" nationality thrown down my throat anytime I mentioned England or Canada.

Maybe that's why the English burned down the Whitehouse (oooooh, cheap shot). That was well before MY time though.

by maxwell edison

I saw his post below and realized I forgot about Road Dog.

Maybe TheChas was right about not posting any names. I, like him, would enjoy it with just about anyone.

by thechas

Sounds like it's time for Tech Republic to sponsor a convention of the peers.

Actually, there are very few regulars here that I would not want to sit down and share a good birch beer with.
(My Uncle used to bring a case when they came to visit from New Jersey.)

I hope that someday I can get a chance for a face to face with most of you.

So as to not forget anyone, I will not post a specific list.

As to the 'best' group to gather with, that would depend on my mood at the time.

Chas

by oldefar

My grandfather used to make his own down in the basement - until a batch went ballistic and blew apart most of his bottles!

Only place I found it on a store shelf was in Sudsbury Ontario. Of course, by the time I hit New Jersey my tastes had changed to something a bit harder.

An ice cold birch beer, the call of the loon, and the tug of a rainbow on the line. Now that is a bit of heaven!

by mallardtooxx

<>

We all know it was because you Brits were jelous of Dolly Madison and her huge...uh snack cakes!

=)
-duck

by mallardtooxx

I think it is an opportunity for all of us to get s!@t faced and duke it out in person for a change.

I can say without reservation though that there are several people that I would want to tip a pint or ten with just because.

Colin: I wanna see if he is as big as paul bunion

Max: Together we could find a way to take over the world.

MrAfrohead: Everyone needs a fresh perspective, afro always seems to have one.

Guru: I am curious how a Brit ever got himself in the situation he has (American Women are difficult aren't they Guru?)

Jules: We are both writers and believers in Karma, it could be interesting.

OZ: Wouldn't you like to see Oz Afro and myself sitting at a table?

TheChas: I would need a voice of reason after ten pints of anything.

the list goes on and on but The space does not.

Lemme sleep on it and I am sure there will be more to come!

-duck

by jellimonsta

***Guru: I am curious how a Brit ever got himself in the situation he has (American Women are difficult aren't they Guru?)****
Duck, I am a brit living in the mid west, with an American wife. You are correct in the statement that American women canbe trying :)

by mallardtooxx

And to top it all off you are stuck in wisconsin!
I would say I feel for ya but being that I am stuck in Indiana it prolly wouldn't be much condolence =) You my friend need a beer! Shots of windex on me!

-duck

by oldefar

I have been looking at the world map, and it seems the most central point would be the Yucatan penninsyla in Mexico.

Now if we can get TR to spring for a one week all inclusive package at some resort there.

by road-dog

getting this crew together would be like herding cats. Besides, does anyone think the world's economy could stand the absence of all of us at one time?

As for the "one on one" beer scenario, I'd open a bottle and throw away the cap with just about everybody. Agreement with me on any issue is not a prerequisite. The world's events have polarized us to some degree, and nothing unites us all better than a shared hangover.

by jardinier

OzMedia: because he shoots from the hip and doesn't care if his honest opinions upset people;
Guru: because his jokes are so cryptic that I might have a chance of understanding them through body language;
Mallard: because he chooses good discussion topics, and because his real name is so different to his alias;
Admin; Generalist; OldeFar and TheChas; to add some maturity to the gathering;
Maxwell: subject to a duel with rapiers or pistols to determine who should pay for the drinks;
Colin; so that any skeptics could find out what a really great guy he is;
Andrew Parken: no, you don't know him, but he's a really interesting guy to talk to, lives in my suburb, and is a TR member;
Anyone else who thinks they have the slightest chance ofout-talking me.

by jellimonsta

***Anyone else who thinks they have the slightest chance of out-talking me.*****

Jules, that would be an excercise in futility :)
At least you actually have something to say though.

by maxwell edison

For a United States meeting (Since everything revolves around the U.S. anyway):

The geographical center of the lower 48 states lies outside of Lebanon, Kansas, in the middle of a hog farm.

What would happen if we all met in Lebanon, Kansas, you might ask? Well, see the link to find out.

http://tinyurl.com/eu0m

The geographical center of all 50 states is located 17 miles west of Castle Rock, South Dakota.

(Nothing there - not even a hog farm.)

The geodetic center of the U.S. is found approximately 42 miles south of Lebanon, Kansas. (Note: A geodetic survey makes corrections to account for the curvature of the Earth.)

For an international meeting:

The geographical center of the planet's landmass:

The Great Pyramids in Egypt.

http://tinyurl.com/eu08

by thechas

Julian, I believe that this is the first time ANYONE has refereed to me as mature.

I don't know whether to take it as a compliment, an insult, or a sign I'm getting old.

(I know that you meant it as a compliment.)

Perhaps I work to hard at keeping things 'proper' when I post in the forums.

I do hold my keys a bit, and do not respond right away when a comment gets to me.

For the record, I am MUCH less reserved in person.

While the only mind altering substance I imbibe is chocolate, I have been described as being 'high on life'.

I do hope to get a chance to meet you, Maxwell, Guru, OzMedia, Lordinfidel, Oldfar to name but a few.

Chas

by jardinier

of chocolate with you any time. Definitely the best mind-altering substance available. Glad to learn that you are a groovy, cool cat, but with a sense of responsibility to go with it.

Speaking of at least one other susbstance that DOES prove Godmeant us to be happy, I once had a dog who followed in her master's footsteps and tried to use emotional blackmail (in the way that only dogs can) to become a chocaholic.

by admin

Oh I never should have done it!

Man. I missed Road Dog. and JellaMonsta.

I feel horrible now :|

by maxwell edison

For a United States meeting (Since everything revolves around the U.S. anyway):

The geographical center of the lower 48 states lies outside of Lebanon, Kansas, in the middle of a hog farm.

What would happen if we all met in Lebanon, Kansas, you might ask? Well, see the link to find out.

http://tinyurl.com/eu0m

The geographical center of all 50 states is located 17 miles west of Castle Rock, South Dakota.

(Nothing there - not even a hog farm.)

The geodetic center of the U.S. is found approximately 42 miles south of Lebanon, Kansas. (Note: A geodetic survey makes corrections to account for the curvature of the Earth.)

For an international meeting:

The geographical center of the planet's landmass:

The GreatPyramids in Egypt.

http://tinyurl.com/eu08

by jardinier

Now if one of you geniuses could invent digital beer, we could have the gabfest each sitting at our own computers, using mike and webcam.

by oldefar

Digitise my music, my pictures, my meetings, my sex life, but leave my beer alone! For pity's sake, show some compassion!!

Give me my beer in a frosty mug, a tall glass, a brown bottle, an aluminum can, a steel can, a plastic cup, a peanut bowl, a ceramic flower vase, but leave it in its natural form as our creator intended.

In the whole of this world there is so little you can count on. Beer, in all its variations, in all its colors, whether icy cold or warm as soup, beer will never betray you. The local water may kill you or clean you, the local girls may love you or leave you, the hard liquer can blind you or kill you, but the beer is safe wherever you go.

Some religious leaders have assured me that there will be no beer in heaven. I am encouraged that they have also assured me I am bound for hell.

by oz_media

The day that beer and bars come to the living room is the day I have enough on this blue ball.
Just think, taking the most social activity, one of the last, and making it an at home behind the computer event. It makes me gag just thinking about it. I guess at that point, we would evolve into ghost white people with BIG eyes like aliens, and have absolutely NO social skills at all, other than social engineering.

Sorry Jules, I know it was just humor but that is just plain f-in sick in the head. A gross conecept to say the least. What's next, Ozzy live at Yahoo?

eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeewwwwww, yuck, yuck, yucky !!!
OM

by jardinier

thought I would encounter a group of people more passionately involved with the amber fluid outside of the Newspaper Industry. Journalists are notoriously keen drinkers, but you lot take the cake.
Whilst I am fully aware that it provides a great relief from tension and inhibitions, it's a bit of a worry to think that so many people apparently cannot conceive of life without alcohol. This is in no way to be interpreted as critical or judgemental, it's just that I don't need the stuff to unwind;feel good; or lose my inhibitions. In fact I'm not aware of having any inhibitions: I am the extrovert's extrovert, to the point of frequently alarming people with what pops spontaneously out of my mouth.
[But the way, should the occasion arise, Iam rather partial to Hahn beer].

by generalist

The idea of a digital bar would work well without digital beer. You can always have your own stash of the consumable of your choice to be used by the physical 'you' while the VR 'you' has what best fits your VR personality.

by tomsal

I'm actually not one who calls myself a "drinker" (in fact there has been a time when for an entire year I drank probably the equivalent of a single six pack), but I love good debates on all things IT and beyond, so long as they are at least somewhat intelligent and their is at least a shred of mutual respect between all debaters. And since talking makes you thirsty its a good excuse to tilt back some black and tan as well. Btw, who's buying? ;)

Also...
Admin@133tcentral.com, OzMedia, maxwell edison, GuruofDos, LordInfidel, Mallardtooxx, TheChas, Oldefar, RoadKill, Jul646, dpetrak....

folks I deem the "regular guru's of TR"... very smart group with many good insights....

So how well can each of you design a lan, troubleshoot a circuit board problem, etc... -- with about 10 beers in you? lol

by road-dog

of networking while intoxicated. I once got called back to the office for a bughunt from the Friday night "choir practice". The problem was an omitted wr mem on a router that occurred while stone sober....

I have done lots of designs on cocktail napkins. actually, I'm extra careful to review designs as I create the schematics in Visio. Never been a problem.

by oz_media

I dunno, but I bet it will be a good looking one!
In fact, enough beers and I'll try to F-k the LAN.

by mallardtooxx

I just don't think after ten beers I am going to be able to get up the gumption to remember where I parked the office.

-duck

by oz_media

I designed my last LAN while playing darts and being incredibly Fit Shaced at my favorite pub.
It was hard deciphering the napkin and smoke pack hyroglyphics but it worked out OK.

by oz_media

Hopefully you know, or at least assume, that I was joking, it aint my gig either, but I've woken up beside more than one horror show in my days of backstage partying and often wondered if she shaved daily (or maybe she should).

As for the Abbey Road, I've got a Mint, Sealed, master copy if you got the dough. I've had it up for auction twice at Ritchie Brothers but didn't let it go.

P.S. Short my first 68 on an executive course today, woohooo !!!!! Especially at $4 a hole.

by maxwell edison

Many people use the term "master copy" in rather general terms. I might be interested if the price is right and depending on the label. (I assume you're talking about a 33-1/3 LP.)

Is it an Apple label master copy or MFSL? (Or perhaps it's something else, but it couldn't be a "master recording" if it's on the Capitol label - at least I don't think it could.)

Is it Apple No. 383

Is it MFSL No. 023

Something else?

How much do you want for it?

(And yes, I assumed you were joking.)

A 68 huh? Was that on the front or back nine?

by oz_media

I haven't looked at it in while and definitely don't want to unseal it, so I'm not sure about the label. Its' in my "sister studio" in St. Albans UK, along with a couple of thousand other wierd collectible LP's like bootleg ACDC cuts, unreleased Suzie Quatro, mipressed Sex Pistols etc. I know that it has a plain black cover with a two inch white stripe across the top that just says "Beatles, Abbey Road - Original Mastering Copy" if that helps. I had the collection appraised in the mid 80's for 3900 pound but I don't know a real value of the Abbey Road by itself, I used to pertner a small record trading shop and collected a bunch of stuff to hang onto. I think it is more of a keeper because I don't think it will sell for enough to make it worth my while (thus my case of LP's is still stashed away for a rainy day).

As for the 68, I figured with a score like that why play the second hole?

Actually, it's not a great score, was a par 3 course with four 4's.So I was still over par. That's good for me though, I just got new Top-Flite clubs and score has dropped by almost 8 strokes a game so I'm just being happy.

by jardinier

Regarding your comment further down this thread to the effect that "some audiophiles might consider that some vinyls might give better reproduction than CDs," I am flabbergasted. In my part of the world (and bearing in mind that building Hi-Fi audioamplifiers was my hobby in my teens and early 20s) EVERYBODY knows that vinyls sound better than CDs, and I have even had an audio engineer explain to me why it is technically impossible for a digital disc to match the sound quality of an analog disc. It has to do with cut-off frequencies and the ability to reproduce subtle harmonics.

[By the way I also play guitar and organ, and compose music, so I think that my ear is pretty sensitive.]

by admin

in both religion and science and must be accepted on faith. We cannot prove nor disprove existence in general and also the existence of God one whit unless we cheat and work it in a priori with tricks of linguistics.

However, once you get past the current limitations of our language and quit focusing on existence, I would have to agree, based on experience, with Benjamin Franklin when he said: "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy." :)

by jardinier

a warm beer with you in hell. I certainly hope that I end up there, as I'm sure all the most interesting people will be there to welcome us.
The only catch is that the beer might vaporise and you'd have to breathe it in.

Regarding digital sex, well that's been around for a long time, hasn't it: the only option for those who don't have a partner.

by mallardtooxx

I will admit to being addicted to chocolate, But I must say it is not near as good a high as windex. Of course that is just one mans opinion! =)

-duck

by hal 9000

Sorry guys but I've been in the unfortuante position of having to work the last few days so most things are well and trully behind here.

Now I'd like to have a drink with all of you that gather here and I would enjoy the evening/month/year without a moments hesitation.

My only problem is in convinicing my wife that I'm not going over to the US to buy VeeDub parts in CA again. After my last trip she tore up my passport. But fortuantly she hasn't worked out just yet that I can still order these things over the NET so for the time being I'm safe.

But this sounds like a VERY GOOD IDEA to me!

by admin

It's not our silver and gold. Plenty of places have more than we in all likelihood. It's not alchohol, that likely can be either exported or exists other places as well.

It's chocolate.

Think about it. What an extremely narrow range of circumstances that must come together to have cows and cocoa beans..... They might not even want to waste the precious space of a production facility here... moving that offshore to the moon or a space station perhaps and filling the earth with cows andcocoa groves..... mmmmmmmmm.... if Guinness didn't exist, I may prefer chocolate over beer as well.... but then Guinness is often described as "Chocolatey"

:)

by jellimonsta

I could just imagine Ozzy in digital format. I could also imagine glitches in the encryption and data compression actually making some of his ramblings intelligible.
What ever would the prince of darkness think about being broadcast in lightspeed? :p
Hey Oz, I actually have a question for you if you would be so kind as to Email me through TR?

by jellimonsta

I could just imagine Ozzy in digital format. I could also imagine glitches in the encryption and data compression actually making some of his ramblings intelligible.
What ever would the prince of darkness think about being broadcast in lightspeed? :p
Hey Oz, I actually have a question for you if you would be so kind as to Email me through TR?

by maxwell edison

What I believe you have is the (Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab) MFSL-1-023 pressing, which was released in 1980. (And I believe it's a yellow stripe, not white.) With the exception of the very rare Beatles albums (like the butcher cover, ATCO label, someVee Jay labels, early Capitol labels, and some others), the MFSL pressings are, perhaps, the most sought after Beatles albums. Not because of the rarity of them (and some are rather hard to come by), but rather for the audio quality. MFSL used the original Capitol stereo master tapes to create them, and used half-speed mastering recording techniques to capture the clearest and crispest of sound. The packaging was better as well, which aided in maintaining flatness and prevent warping. Some audiophiles will claim that these particular vinyl records (better than 100% virgin vinyl) are a better quality than even the newer CD technology. (I might dispute that, but they do produce an excellent sound.)

There was one MFSL pressing for every major Beatles album - not the "best of" or compilation type albums, but the original releases, such as Abbey Road, Help, Rubber Soul, The White Album, etc. The most valuable (and hardest to find) is Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, which is valued at around $300 in mint condition. Let it Be and With The Beatles are valued around $200. Most of them fetch $50 - $100, and Abbey Road is in that category. They'll fetch the higher end (maybe a bit higher) if you have one that is still sealed.(continued...)

by maxwell edison

MFSL didn't just release Beatles music, but a wide variety of artists, but mostly jazz and rock and Roll, such as Fleetwood Mac, George Benson, Jackson Browne, Gordon Lightfoot (the Canadian troubadour), Eric Clapton, Moody Blues, Quincy Jones, and on and on. They are getting more collectible since MFSL went out of business in 1999. The only one I have (out of my collection of around 7000 LPs) is "I Robot" by Alan Parsons Project - the best sounding record I have.

You could possibly get close to $100 for your Abbey Road, since it's still sealed, but if you want to sell it, I'd offer you $50 right now.

by oldefar

An interesting arguement. Digital or analog recording, which is a more accurate reproduction?

The first limitation is the receptor - the listener's ear. Mine went to hell flying and no longer have a high level of sensitivity across the audio spectrum. Most people suffer some degree of loss from exposure to noise in their lives. Accuracy greater than the listener ear is a mute point.

Next is the speaker system. The fidelity of the audio output varies significantly across brands, and most popular brands are not capable of reproducing the full subtleties of the artist's work even if it has been recorded perfectly.

Backing up we have the amplification elements. Component selection, aging, temperature, placement, and purity of power are all working at distorting the input signal before passing it on.

Now we reach the recording playback. With vinyl the speed of the turntable, both accuracy and consistency, the balance of the turntable, the weight and balance of the arm, and the mechanical sensitivity of the needle are factors.

Finally, we hear the recording. They both were so nice, the audio so inspiring or soothing or exciting. Let's play it again, and again, and again.

Think I will stick to CD.

by road-dog

During my short but intense involvement with Napster, I did find that my unsophisticated tastes really could not discriminate between 128 and 256 bit sampling in MP-3 format.

I suspect that for most consumers, this is probably representative. For the average music consumer buying a Btitney Spears album, I think that their taste in artist disqualifies their opinion as relates to delivery.

I guess there are folks who's hearing is so practiced that they can be put off by the digitization flattening. I'm not in that group.

There are similar debates in the arena of voice, relating to PCM and ADPCM sampling. For most voices, the sampling rate and bit representation are sufficient to get the point across. This is a "good enough" representation for the masses.

by maxwell edison

In an absolutely perfect environment with equally perfect media played on the finest equipment available, vinyl recordings will produce, at least in my opinion, a better sound than CDs or DVDs. Since sound is originally analog, and vinyl records areanalog while CDs are digital, some sounds may get lost in the conversion from analog to digital. However, the differences are usually so miniscule as to escape detection under normal listening conditions. Moreover, vinyl recordings are susceptible to damage, such as nicks and scratches, and dust can accumulate in the grooves, both of which can negatively affect the sound by transmitting those annoying snaps, crackles and pops - especially during a "quiet" pause in a recording.

However, as the size of my collection might indicate, I prefer the vinyl. (But not in my car.) I do play my records quite often, especially when friends and family get together. It's fun to pull out a 30 to 50 year old record (or older) upon request, and the albumcovers (especially the gatefolds) and inserts are interesting to look at as well - something that's lost with the CDs. In addition, I've run across a number of people who collect the older albums for the cover art. Joni Mitchell, for instance, did some of the cover art for Crosby Stills Nash and Young, as well as a self portrait (for one of her own) which was modeled after Vincent Van Gogh's self portrait. Alberto Vargas who created "The Vargas Girls", Andy Warhol and others have done the art for album covers as well. (Not to mention some of the impressive picture disks.)

So in an absolutely perfect world, vinyl is much better. And in an absolutely perfect world, I would have the entire MFSL collection. But then again, nothing is perfect, is it?

by maxwell edison

I might also add that people (like me) who collect the old vinyl records, don't usually do so for the "quality" of the recording. As mentioned earlier, under normal listening conditions CDs are, in most cases, much better quality, easier to use and store, and I've yet to find a suitable 5 disk turntable that shuffles the music while protecting the disk.

by admin

As my distinguished peers have pointed out, there are many ways to say which is "better" but really I think it boils down to: "If it sounds good it is good" for me. I hear this argument at least weekly, and have realized that IMO the argument revolves more about ones likes are than what is a faithful reproduction.

To go back in music history, it is obvious that, (pick any era- 50's, 60's, 70's, Baroque, Medieval, Classical) that people heard music differently than they do now. Classical music is a good indicator of this. If you listen carefully to the same piece arranged, performed and recorded in say, the 40's, then the 50's and then each decade to the present you will find that it is approached somewhat differently. Sometimes in factI get a kick out of listening to pieces that attempt to be faithful to a composers era, especially Bach is good for this, because it can be a difficult listen for the modern. The same is true of reproduction equipment through the ages IMO.

All recording and reproduction equipment to date colors the sound. Not just Tubes vs. Solid State, but op-amps and power transitors of different eras both pre and post and speaker design, microphone design, and the list gets huge really fast. We get used to differing sounds and declare them best either by the defining high end equipment of an era or because we just like a particular sound.

by admin

Now, any recording engineer will talk about faithful reproduction and a flat response. This is not really because everyone uses this for general playback, but rather for producing a recording that will play acceptably in many systems. I will developlistening fatigue quite a bit quicker with a clean amp, an adjusted room and flat speakers compared to classical records running on a tube, which I can listen to all day. Alternately, Nine Inch Nails sound better IMO on CD with my Hafler and a big Subwoofer. Why? Different Color. And the Beatles, what do I listen to them on? Of course, My big old school Pioneer silver face from vinyl. Why? because I have fond memories of listening to them on systems like this at the older kids houses when I wasyoung. This all assumes your ear can distinguish of course, and it's not bad if you can't, in fact it may be a blessing not being frustrated and a perfectionist in listening experiences! Anyway, even the particular mixing board colors the sound one way or another on every recording...it's all a matter of whether it is a color people like at the time. :)

by oz_media

Thanks for all the information, you really seem to know your vinyl. I guess that's the reason that I haven't sold it, I just feel it is worth more to me than $100.00 (even in that real American money that even looks like money). I'll probably passthen on to my grandkids when and if they arrive, (my son would just sell it and get pissed).
I do really appreciate the info though and you are probably right, it is a yellow bar, I dunno because it's been a while since I dug through them.

If I'm ever really hard up for a few bucks, I'll let you know though and you can make me an offer.

Thanks again,
OM

by oz_media

"Anyway, even the particular mixing board colors the sound one way or another on every recording...it's all a matter of whether it is a color people like at the time"

Hit the nail on the head. My parents used to tell me that the music I listenedto was tinny, they had grown up listening to colored nusic (no, not hip hop)and hed become accustomed to bottom end. Same with the radio, "more bass!".

I prefer vinyl for older recordings. I have a Harman Kardon AMP/PreAMP cpmbo with Mission speakers and a Mission cartridge on my HK turntable. I have yet to hear a better sounding Louis Armstrong on CD. The record was produced and mixed to sound best on vinyl, had it been recorded this year, it would be mixed and produced to sound best onCD.

I think that MOST analog music sounds better in analog playback but when converted to digital, even the filters can't reproduce that same warm woody sound of the clarinet. My ex was the principal cellist for the Vancouver Symphony so I listen to a LOT of classical. Older peices sound better on vinyl, the new peices better on CD. Again, due to engineering and production changes over time to have equipment adapt to the music.

CD's yay for today, vinyl for the way it was supposed to be.
OM

by ghstinshll

There are so many I've had godo conversations with though... those are three names that come fondly (and quickly) to mind...

by admin

at least you could fire up Carmeggedon, Twisted Metal Black or Grand Theft Auto and have MORE fun drivng around even MORE irresponsibly.

It's still been my experience that games are a safety valve for most of our society and when we violent typesget to act it out online we can have quite peaceful non-violent real lives most of the time. I wish everyone who was ever tempted to drink and drive in the real world would only be able to hop in a driving simulator instead and keep the rest of us safe.

by oz_media

I agree, if only people got their jollies in a simulator then drove home safely it would be safer for all of us. BUT.

Unfortunately, kids who use arcade simulators are also then jumping in their cars and trying out the real thing around town. Unfortunately, the crashes actually kill people and don't simply place your car back on the track.

I think many kids also turn to violence as a result of games. NO I'm not going to say Rock and Roll is devils music, games are for the devil and so on but many kids are too easily influenced by the world around them and have no individual ideas or thought process to teach them right from wrong. Too many kids feel influenced by games, movies and music and the parents have absolutely NO idea whatis going on in their heads.

MORE TO COME

by oz_media

A lady and her husband were sitting in The Cactus Club restaurant on Sunday with their 4 or 5 year old son, who was playing his Game boy. The boy's meal was served yet the parents completely ignored him and let him play with his Game Boy.
About 15minutes went by before the boy said he didn't want his meal. The parents called the waitress over and told her that the food was cold and they weren't going to pay for it. The waitress apologized and offered to reheat or remake thmeal but the parents were adamant about just not paying for it.
The manager had a few words before the parents just got up and walked out with their kid.

When I was a boy, I ate what was put in front of me and I liked it or else. I remember sitting at the table for hours after my family had finished because I wasn't allowed to turn my nose up at dinner, that also meant no going out to play with my friends.

I know that most kids these days don't even realize that there IS an outside and simply play games,watch TV, sit at the PC or whatever.

This kid at the restaurant let his food go cold, he was playing GameBoy and nobody took it from him and told him to eat! What has happened to parents teaching responsibility and manners to children? The waitress lost a tip and probably some patience trying to resolve the problem, th erestaurant lost income for the unwanted meal they prepared and the parents just walked away with their kid behind them playing GameBoy.

It stuns me to see the lack of parenting and the number of irresponsible kids due to poor parenting. Sorry for the segue, but it just gets me pissed to see somone suggesting playing games as opposed to accepting responsibility, no matter what the end result may be. I know this wasn't your intention for your post but it got me steaming as I remembered that bratty little bastard that should have been bitch slapped and tld to eat hs dinner like a human being an

by generalist

I think that the non-parents of that kid should also be punished given the fact that they don't appear to have any control over him. And given the fact that they ordered the meal, they need to be arrested for the restaurant equivalent of stealing.
If the kid is this bad at age four or five, he's going to get a lot worse. And if the non-parents are that incompetent at teaching their child proper behavior, I hope that they don't have any more children.

by admin

I used to think it was all bits vs.analog, but in the last 10 years recording and sampling devices have progressed greatly. A CD isn't really all that high of quality by todays standards. A recording on a DigiDesign or MOTU device is far superior tothe final CD product. As sampling rates increase there are fewer and fewer people who can truly tell the difference.

Interestingly enough, these days putting analog in some way into the mix is quite popular with engineers here, not as a superior recording device though- they refer to a tape unit as a "Sound Processor" quite frequently these days. Are they doing the same in your neck of the woods Oz?

by oz_media

Your point is interesting.

I have used a 24 track analog board to mix into a DAT just because I like the analog mix. I SOMETIMES but not always record certain passages (bass line, some guitar solos)via Cakewalk or Protools for tempo adjustments or cut and pasting of overdubs.
The studio in Southampton where MOST of the recent songs are bed tracked is completely digital, heavy metal is a little more forgiving than Woodwinds, strings or reeds though so it is OK.
Generally the only changesthat I've seen, keep in mind I don't work for Capitol records, is the storage onto DAT making it possible to use ProTools, Cakewalk or Cubase.

I generally create bed tracks or demos using a XOOM but prefer to use a Yamaha Pm3524 for on the fly mixing, even though it is digital it still emulates an analog board well.

by oz_media

WOW you agree!!
I was having a few drinks with a friend who thought it was quite acceptable for a kid to be playing GameBoy while in the restaurant. I found it REALLY annoting just knowing what would have happened to me if I did that as a kid, mind you it was Electronic Quarterback then. Blip, Blip, Blip, I SCORED!!!!

It just really pissed me off and I told the waitress so, to which she said, "nothing new."

I think parents suck as a whole. They have No right raising kids anymore, there should be a mandatory How to Give a Crap course.

I know some of you as am I are parents so I don't want to get your feathers ruffled if you feel you are doing the right thing with your kids, it's ultimately up to you who and what they become. Stupidity and rudeness just piss me off though, PLEASE at least talk to your kids once in a while and don't let them be ignored that way this little kid was. It is a sad, sad day when parents rely on Nintendo as a babysitter and mentor for their children.

Dismayed,
OM

by jardinier

Thanks for all the informative postings, which cover very thoroughly the subject of "what the ear can distinguish."
However I would like to add/vindicate a few points. Audio design has been based on the premise that the maxium range of frequencieswhich the human ear can register is 20 - 20,000 Hz. In reality, however, probably 12 - 15KHz would be the maximum perceptible on the upper end, and this falls off naturally with age.
Originally I owned an Australian produced MBH magnetic pick-up with a flat response from 20 - 20,000 Hz. Similarly this is the standard frequency range for a true Hi-Fi amplifier. The weakest link is the speaker/s in which the response curve is quite irregular, and drops sharply below, say, 50Hz. The lowest note on a piano, however, is less than 30 Hz, and if you have the space for it, an organ pipe can go even lower.
The human ear has some 3,000 fibres, each of which responds only to a single sound. This allows for differentiation of about 30 frequencies in a semi-tone. So the human ear can register the most minute variations in pitch.
And this is partly why, I am assuming, that no electronic device can come even close to reproducing the sound of an actual musical instrument.

by admin

My kid loves his Gameboy, but not as much as me or Cub Scouts, camping, eating or playing outside. I agree with you, many of the parents I see scare me. But also, I know a lot of good parents and kids in the neighborhood and although they love to play games, they all make it to the dinner table and don't watch their parents be obnoxious theifs. I really think the chief problem is ignorance. I must admit I did not really know how to Father and grew up with my own Father absent a great deal of the time. I love my Father dearly and understand him, him dearly, but I didn't know how to parent and it took a lot of reading, asking questions and taking classes to figure it out.

I was trying to figure it out as I went in real time as a single Father of a 6 mos. old! Wow. he's almost 8 now, and a great kid doing well in school and the community, but it took a lot of work and change within myself to get there. I'm not the best equipped Dad, even today I work at it constantly.

What I am getting at here, is a lot of people grew up with absent parents for the most part, and they really don't know how to do it themselves, and unless they are really motivated to do this, they are lost. It's really really sad. All I can say, is like Maxwell, become a Scout Leader or start some LAN parties for youth in your community, be a Big Brother or Sister or at least let your kid drag other kids home and feed them and give them some rules and hold them accountable. It's amazing how many kids my son drags home from school that have no meals or people waiting for them, much less any tasks or payment for the tasks. I swear, just letting a kid rake your leaves for a few bucks, giving them some good feedback and helping them understand they CAN do something useful and make a buck themselves at a young age goes a LONG way towards their development as citizens.

by admin

>>The human ear has some 3,000 fibres, each of >>which responds only to a single sound. This >>allows for differentiation of about 30 >>frequencies in a semi-tone. So the human ear >>can register the most minute variations in >>pitch.

There is another factor which results in an incredible increase in distinction here Jules...every single one of us individual human beings has a different set of the 3000 fibers resonding in slightly different ways to the 30 frequencies in a semi-tone. Actually, I like to think of sound as more dimensional than Western theory anyway. Beyond tonal quality there are many other factors and combinations that result in what we hear IMO. It is mind boggling how amazing it is that so many people can enjoy listening to the same thing sometimes really...

>>And this is partly why, I am assuming, that no >>electronic device can come even close to >>reproducing the sound of an actual musical >>instrument.

No sound can ever be reproduced really. Isn't thatbeautiful! Every performance and every playback is uniquely beautiful and only happens once in the linear scale of time. MAn, I love and relish each time I hear a sound I like :)
Sure, it is important to try and reproduce faithfully (and to remix and experiment as well) but in the end, it is unique and different every time! :)

by oz_media

Hats off to you sir!! You saty that you were not really prepared to be a father and that you never really saw much of your father as a youngster yourself.NOBODY is really prepared to be a parent. Sometimes we fool ourselves with parenting classes,books and buying all the gadgets. In the long run, the second the mother gives birth, everything you knew is out the window. NOTHING can prepare you for that!

You say your son is in Cubs, that makes me so happy to see that people still believe in scouting. I spent 12 years as a Cub, Scout, Venturer then on to being a cub and scout leader for a few years. Passing down the information I had learned as a Scout was so erwarding it blew my mind. We had kids who's parents had to scrounge to gather weekly dues, their kids were simply these huge information seekers that listen and absorb everything they were shown, the rewards to me were tremendous. Scouting here just isn't COOL anymore, kids want to stay home and compute or game. If not, they are ususally up to no good due to the lack of youth programs and the ineveitable "there's nothing to do".

Hats off to you for doing what you feel is best in your heart and helping your son become an upstanding and well respected citizen. Too bad everyone isn't that way.

P.S. The parents I was referring to are VERY wealthy Asian immigrants in an Asian dominated suburb of Vancouver. It's hard to not sound like a racist but it certainly is a common sight in that area, obviously the result of the perents upbringing being different than mine.
OM

by generalist

I can see where a waitress would consider the Nintendo Nut behavior to be something that happens frequently enough not to be a surprize.

In fact, seeing kids behaving well seems to be more of a surprize. A little over eight years ago, when my kids were 13, 9 and 4 (or younger) we were at a Claim Jumper restaurant in the Greater LA area. It took a while to get in and get served because the restaurant is very popular. But the kids were on their normal behavior, sitting quietly and enjoying the conversation and the decor.

Out of the blue, one of the waitresses complimented my wife and I on how well behaved the kids were. My wife and I were pleased with the compliment and occasionally mention the event when people talk about how wellbehaved the kids are.

It does require a certain amount of work early on. Teaching a two year old the meaning of the word 'No' is a start. Explaining why something is a 'No' seems to be an essential element of the training process.

by generalist

Chocolate would be a good choice of mind altering substance, at least in limited doses of the high quality stuff.

Favorite flavors of ice cream would also work. For me, the equivalent of Baskin Robbin's Pralines and Cream would be nirvana.

But if you wanted to get me higher than a kite, a good conversation about science, technology, history, science fiction or fantasy would be the best deal. And if you can add some puns to the mix, it would be even better.

I might need some time to wind down before I drive home after the party. I once got pulled over for driving erratically when my wife and I got into a really fun conversation on our way home from a class.

by jardinier

All it takes to get me started is the presence of another human being who responds to my initial remark with anything other than "Ugh." I am incorrigibly flippant, which sometimes confuses or offends people who take me literally.
I don't know the ice creams to which you refer, but I am more than a little partial to chocolates made in Swizerland and Germany.

Now here is something that I found most interesting. I don't smoke at present, but when I used to, as soon as some trigger word like "God" was mentioned, I would instinctively reach for a cigarette. Sometime later I learnt that nicotine is a brain stimulant.

by hal 9000

Swiss choclate is the best in the world bar none. You should have been with me the last time I went to Switerland the company who took me over there decided to give me a break from work for a few hours and they made the mistake of taking me to a choclate factory and we where given a tour with a little plastic spoon to have samples. Well needless to say I made a pig of myself {a hopeless addiction here} and you should have seen the looks of dismay on the faces of the tour guide and some of the others they all took small tastes while I attempted to eat the lot. But at the end of the tour they showed us a shop where we could if we liked buy some of their product now all the others bought 1 or 2 bars of a few different choclates and when my turn came I asked how many to a box? and bought several boxes of everything that I liked. After that I was invited back whenever I was over there, but it was funny as I asked for lets say 4 boxes and the shop assistant came out with 4 bars/boxes it took quite a bit of time to get the message across and aparently no one had ever bought as much choclate after a tour as I did.

But I'm told choclate is a mind altering drug as it makes you feel happy or good after eating it well my opinion BRING IT ON!

by computopia

Did you ever notice that the monolith in 2001 looks like a big 'Ole dark chocolate bar. Perhaps Arthur C C was a secret chocoholic ?
Worth flying to Jupiter for ... or at least Sri Lanka ?

Any way I look forward to joining you all for a dinner with Julian in Sydney at Doyles Seafood on Watson's Bay, Sydney Harbour ( the one in the Visa ad where the fish is always fresh and so are the chocolate mousse desserts.mmmmmm.... btw they really don't take Amex) if your ever downunder this way. Together in the real world I am sure we could silence him (Jules) at least long enough to try the dessert.

Cheers Andrew Parken

by hal 9000

About shuting him up.

But more to the point could we stop him {Jules} from eating all the chocolate moousse so there where some left for the rest of us?

by jardinier

I think it is universally accepted now that chocolate creates the same feeling as being in love. It is also a good food as it (especially milk chocolate) contains the basic dietary elements including protein.
I discovered Swiss chocolate when a certain girlfriend of mine (who had been married to a German) used to bring me a bar each time she visited me.
I don't usually buy it for myself because of the cost. However the variety I found most addictive was the German Milka Mocca.

by thechas

I have to start keeping my eye on more discussions.

Because of design compromises made at the time the audio CD was developed, the format is flawed. It CANNOT accurately reproduce music!

The encoding was chosen based on the cost of D/A converter ICs in 1982.

The sampling frequency was chosen based on the compromise of size (to fit a dashboard radio slot) and single side length of 1 hour.

On the technical side, the sampling frequency of 44.1 KHz is 'capable' of properly encoding a 22KHz SINE wave. This is based on the Nyquist Theorem.

The Nyquist Theorem ONLY applies to sinusoidal waveforms. Music has many non-sinusoidal components. The initial crash of a symbol or the beat of a drum is a sharp high speed transient.
The only pure sine waves are from the voice, and wind and bowed string instruments.

The last time I reviewed sampling theory, you had to sample non-sinusoids at a minimum of 10 times the fundamental frequency.

So, the audio CD format only provides accurate reproduction for signals with fundamental frequencies of 4400 hertz or below.

Now, much like the compact cassette, the CD is performing beyond textbook limitations.

The primary area of improvement has been to reduce the jitter (variations over time) in the oscillators for the A/D and D/A converters.

Chas

by jkaras

First I havent been here in a while and the last time I saw a posting from the Guru he was expecting a baby, so the first would be to him and his new luck. Boy or girl? There are many people I would tip with especially to see if I could hold my own with the two Aussies. I would love to see Admin and Max go at it fully plastered in a debate, that would be classic. I would like to see if Mr. Afro actually has an afro or not, tip a beer on Road Dogs porch while watching his neighbor mow the lawn. The list goes on and on and maybe someday....

This discussion is closed to new replies.