Discussion Locked

A Poem for my French Friends!

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Eleven thousand soldiers lay beneath the dirt and stone, all buried on a distant land so far away from home.
For just a strip of dismal beach they paid a hero's price, to save a foreign nation they all made the sacrifice.
And now the shores of Normandy are lined with blocks of white: Americans who didn't turn from someone else's plight.
Eleven thousand reasons for the French to take our side, but in the moment of our need, they chose to run and hide.
Chirac said every war means loss, perhaps for France that's true, for they've lost every battle since the days of Waterloo.

Without a soldier worth a damn to be found within the region, the French became the only land to need a Foreign Legion.

You French all say we're arrogant. Well hell, we've earned the right-- We saved your sorry nation when you lacked the guts to fight.

But now you've made a big mistake, and one that you'll regret; you took sides with our enemies, and that we won't forget.

It wasn't just our citizens you spit on when you turned, but every one of yours who fell the day the towers burned.
You spit upon our soldiers, on our pilots and Marines, and now you'll get a little sense of just what payback means.
So keep your Paris fashions and your wine and your champagne, and find some other market that will buy your aeroplanes.

And try to find somebody else to wear your French cologne, for you're about to find out what it means to stand alone.
You see, you need us far more than we ever needed you, America has better friends who know how to be true.
I'd rather stand with warriors who have the will and might, than huddle in the dark with those whose only flag is white.

I'll take the Brits, the Aussies, the Israelis and the rest, for when it comes to valor we have seen that they're the best.

We'll count on one another as we face a moment dire, while you sit on the sideline with a sign, "friendship for hire."
We'll win this war without you and we'll total up the cost, and take it from your foreign aid, and then you'll feel the loss.

And when your nation starts to fall, well Frenchie, you can spare us, just call the Germans for a hand, they know the way to Paris!

5 replies

by dc_guy

No one seems to remember (or maybe you neocons just aren't old enough to have been around) the popular advertising slogan right after your precious WWII:

Forty million Frenchmen can't be wrong.

It's still true.

Being a loyal friend doesn't mean that you have to support your friend when he's being an idiot.

by jamesrl

If you wonder where the phrase, "Ugly American(from a book written by an American author BTW)" comes from, its xenophobic rants like this. You are reaching Bucky like heights in your rhetoric.

Consider this for a moment. In WWI, France lost 1.4 million dead, 4.3 million wounded of which 1.5 million were permanently maimed. Six out of 10 Frenchmen between the age of 18 and 28. Think on that for a while. Think about the impact of 9/11 where 3000 Americans were killed. Think about the impact of losing 6 out of 10 on France. That impact lasts a generation.

The battle of France in 1940 was not lost because the French lacked valour - their generals had an outdated WWI way of thinking and despite the fact they had more tanks, and some better tanks, and some pretty good planes, they lost because the Germans had perfected the method of having air, artillery, tanks and infantry work together in combined arms. The US and the other allies learned that lesson from France's fall.

France did not lose WWI or WWII - they were allies, and many French people died protecting allied airman who fell on french soil. Many of them risked their lives during the occupation to spy and commit sabotage.

If you want to criticise France for losing in Vietnam, then be just as critical of the US - they had more troops, better equipment, an enormous budget, and still faced the same end.

I won't suggest I support everything that France has ever done. But they have been partners in NATO(they opted out formally but came back, even when they opted out they co-operated), participated in Afghanistan, the Balkans and other US missions.

You demand unconditional loyalty to the US and its causes. But the US doesn't treat its allies the same way. Be realistic.

James

by protiusx

This was a term used during the WWII by the British and referred to being betrayed. I wonder at its origins? Do you suppose it had merit or where the British just a little sore at the French for some other reason than being constantly betrayed by the French.
I will agree that there were many brave Frenchmen who fought tirelessly during WWII against the Nazi invaders. The resistance put their lives on the line and many of them died to see a free France. The point is that you and I both know that the French control the EU, the UN and conspired against us in Iraq to cover the fact that they illegally thwarted the UN sanctions against Saddam Hussein so they could make money while the people of Iraq lived under a brutal dictator whose own children murdered and raped and tortured at will.

by jamesrl

Its the French generals.

They made huge tactical blunders, put billions of dollars into the Maginot line. Built great tanks but couldn't figure out how to use them(used them piecemeal and without infantry support). Once the Germans bypassed the Maginot line, half the French force was immobile and cut off from resupply.

Regarding being Frenched as WWII slang, my understanding from my reading of history at the time has a different usage. Being Frenched from the perspective of the British and Americans, is suffering under the ego of someone like deGaulle, who was an arrogant SOB who did not co-operate when he had a chance not to.

The French have a big influence in the EU, but not as much as Germany or Britain. The UN - the US has as more influence than France - look at Rwanda as an example.

If France was some much in colusion with Iraq, and has so much influence, then why didnt they get sanctions overturned?

James

by olprof67

Let's not forget that, while many errors by the French have served to diminish their stature among nations, much of it can be traced to their having paid a disproportionate share of the freight in saving western democracy. French dead outstripped the British roughly 3 to 2 in World War I, and the struggle was fought largely on French soil.

During the years of democracy's flowering, the French contributed generously....Lafayette, Talleyrand, Tocqueville. Some of the finest arguments ever written for free trade were penned by Frederic Bastiat (1801-1850).

The great tragedy of the French, and one all Americans can learn from, is that that nation was never fully able to dismiss the destructive ethic of class-consciousness. The abuses of the French nobility are painfully documented. The revenge taken by the rabble during the Terror is sickening. Never forget that Lavosier died on the guillotine.

The full price of this cancer can then be traced through the embarrassments of the Franco-Prussian War, the Dreyfus scandal, and the slow descent into socialist economic stagantion. But the fact can't be overlooked that many of the brighter, more-foresighted minds that might have revived French society were lost at Ypres`, Verdun and the Somme.

It's doubtful that the French will ever regain even a shadow of their former stature. The nation survives on foreign, often Muslim, labor, sustains itself on the weakest work-ethic of any western democracy, and left many of its senior citizens to swelter and die in the cities while the kiddies went for their annual frolic at the Riviera two years ago.

If there is a lesson in this sad narrative, it's this; Left unchecked, socialism and collectivism will rot any great nation. Fortunately, on November 2, 60 million+ Americans demonstrated their knowledge of that bitter lesson.

This discussion is closed to new replies.