Discussion Locked

A question of Civil Liberties

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I just recieved this in my incoming E-Mail now and since it's from a US source I would like to hear the comments of those here at TR on the contents of the report which can be found at

http://enterprisesecurity.symantec.com/content.cfm?articleID=2139&PID=15348814&EID=392

I'm really interested in your thoughts.

Colin

6 replies

by oldefar

"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." http://tinyurl.com/aky9

The flip side to the coin of liberty is responsibility. When we give up our individual responsibility we give up an equal amount of liberty.

Speaking for myself, the aspect of terrorism I fear most is not the direct risk they pose to me but the risk to freedom in our effort to counter that risk. Is there any free person as safe the prisoner held in solitary confinement at a maximum security prison?

I also adhere to the idea, source forgotten, that all of our laws can be pretty much linked back to ten etched on stone tablets. These ten can be fairly well summarized by one that is known as the Golden rule. Of course, if we all applied these we would have all those government employees and lawyers out of work.

by theboomanchu

The hard truth of the matter is that we have gotten too far away from the genuine intent of the Constitution, including The Bill of Rights. It is not the Government's role to provide us with personal security, but that responsibility is supposed to fall back on us, hence the 2nd Amendment. Imagine all law abiding citizens (not unarmed subjects) still realizing the 2nd Amendment without restriction. First of all, the crime in this country would be very low in comparison to what it is today with all our restrictive gun laws. (Criminals just love these gun laws) Second and more to the point, is that if these terrorists had an idea that the average American citizen was armed, there is a good chance that Sept. 11 would never have happened. The reason I say that is that they are not afraid to die (they think they will be met by 10,000 virgins at heavens gate)but they are very afraid of failing in their mission. With armed people around, they would not have attacked us in the manner they did. I'm not saying that some sort of attack would not have happened, but my point is that the (false) security I am hearing about does nothing really but possibly compromising our liberties, which ultimately will make us more vulnerable. There is not enough room here or time for me to say all I have on the subject, but I hope you get the Jist of it.

by admin

hehehehe...

At any rate, I quite agree. Our gun laws are crazy. I should have the right to own any weapon I can afford or build. People would be a lot more polite if they knew I might take them or their entire lineage out at any minute.

We need more polite people in this country.

by thechas

Hi Colin,

The sad truth here is that the majority of US citizens are more than willing to give up a "FEW" liberties in exchange for a 'perceived' increase in security.

As a rule, US voters do not rise up against legislation unless it directly affects them.
Since the increased police powers are seen as only affecting terrorists and criminals, the average voter thinks it's a good idea.

I don't even want to get into how un-informed the US population is on political issues. Suffice it tosay, that most people AVOID hard news on any issue except professional sports.

The thing that really scares me are some of the rumored provisions of Patriot Act II.
Even George Orwell would be appalled.

Chas

by oldefar

Somewhere along the line, we lost sight of a simple fact in our Constitution. Government has powers - state or federal, executive, judicial, or legislative branch. People have rights.

Second Ammendment - the RIGHT to bear arms. Seems pretty simple to me. It isn't about the national guard or standing armies. It is about every citizen beginning with a right to own firearms.

This discussion is closed to new replies.