Discussion Locked

A question of ethics and principle

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm going to open this thread with a simple question, and as a result I'll probably open myself up for hoards of criticism. But that's okay, I can take it, so please be forthright and honest. I feel comfortable with what I did, and the worst case scenario would be my realization that I made an error (but I doubt it) or that I will simply agree to disagree with some people. And since I can live with either one of those outcomes (or any other outcome, for that matter), here goes.

First, the premise of the question:

In the context of a different thread, I posted a message that contained the full and unedited contents of an email sent to me by another TechRepublic member. This particular email was not sent to me through the "contact peer" function, but rather directly, as this other member and I have conversed via email on quite a number of occasions. I'll admit that I posted the email in the midst of a verbal feud with this member, he sent this email to me in the heat of that verbal feud, and it was, in part, an attempt to partake in a little "get even with him-ism". But I had a bigger reason as well. (And depending on how this thread develops, I may or may not elaborate on that bigger reason. But if you want to know, just ask, and I'll email a reply to you - and do whatever you want with my email.) But suffice it to say that the email was very disturbing, and the thought did cross my mind that other TechRepublic members may be setting themselves up for a similar experience.

(continued...)

13 replies

by maxwell edison

The question is this:

When is it alright to make public an email you received? Whose property is an email sitting in your own inbox? Is there (should there be) any assumed sense of privacy when you send an email? Is it never alright? Is it sometimes alright? Is it always alright? Do the rules for email differ than those for snail mail? What if a person admitted to a crime in an email to you? Would you be obligated to report it or keep it private? What if it was an admission of cheating on anexam? Would you be obligated to the school or the person? Sure, the circumstances and/or infraction would have some bearing on the decision, and sometimes the line that separates one from the other may be blurred. But when and how does a person makesuch decisions? (Okay, that's a lot of questions, not only one, but they're all in the context of a single issue.)

So there ya' go. Have at it (or me).

by mallardtooxx

I believe any email unless marked private or classified is at the receivers? discretion. Therefore anything that is sent to your inbox is yours unless otherwise marked. As long as it is unedited and not otherwise altered then I see no harm in posting it anywhere. If it is altered then it still falls under the domain of libel and that is not good.

More to come

-duck

by admin

>>When is it alright to make public an email you received?

When you have the senders permission.

>>Whose property is an email sitting in your own inbox?

In effect, it is a communication with shared ownership in this case. Some e-mail is meant to be distributed publically, and is usually noted as such. This sort of sharing with the consent of both parties is expected.

>>Is there (should there be) any assumed sense of privacy when you send an email?

Yes. It is the honor system, not the legal system- but it still is important. How much would we write to anybody, our loved ones, our spouses, our confidants if we had the knowledge that it would be shared publically? Kant asked that we apply the scenario to be universally willed before we decided whether or not to do it. Would anyone want their e-mail posted on a public board? Julian could have posted publically. Obviously he trusted you to keep it private by the act of a private message.

>>Is it never alright?

It'snever alright.

>>Is it sometimes alright?

No.

>>Is it always alright?

No.

by admin

>>Do the rules for email differ than those for snail mail?

No. The technology does differ, but if TechRepublic was an industry journal, the only difference would have been an editor would not have allowed the printing, even in a letter to the editor.

>>What if a person admitted to a crime in an email to you?

You can notify the authorities without going public. In fact, going public would make it better, not worse for the criminal and thwart the authorities ability to properly deal with the situation. If you were a Marine and another Marine committed a crime, would you go to the MP or send the story to the New York Times?

>>Would you be obligated to report it or keep it private?

Report it privately.

>>What if it was an admission of cheating on an exam?

Go to the proper authority. Perhaps the Headmaster.

>>Would you be obligated to the school or the person?

No, but you should choose going to these people before going public.

by cactus pete

Well, as you even said to me in an email [I'll paraphrase], I wouldn't send anything in an email I wouldn't mind seeing posted for the public. I consider myself to be honest, and honestly trying. Sure, I guess I could regret having said a few things, once in a while [especially if it makes me look like a dunce], but it'll wash over. I would have honestly been ignorant, and that embarrassment is only ever temporary.

Now, I contacted Max about the post [through an email], and said that I was a bit surprised, though empathetic. I'm not judging, and I am sure I don't [and will not] know the whole story, but I asked for an explanation. I'm not troubled by what I was told. When someone has earned my respect, I ask them for an explanation, since I expect there was a good reason for the apparent indescetion. [I don't just assume it, though, as I do not subscribe to blind faith.]

So when is it OK to divulge? I think that when there is a harm, the proper autorities should be notified - if the explanation does not suffice. Barring some governing authority, the public and one's peers should be able to sift through the facts for themselves.

by admin

Although now that I read your letter... it seems that if we are getting it in e-mail, he must not believe it should be publically posted. There must be a good reason for it though.

by armylanman

Initial Question: Is it OK to make an Email public?

When I send an Email, or leave a voice-mail, I always assume that my message may be read, or heard by someone other than the intended person. Whether that is the case or not, and whether that issimply a single unintended viewer or the whole world. I do not have an expectation of privacy.

The words I write or say are attributable to me and I must be able and willing to face whatever response my action (writing the Email or leaving a message)may bring. Unless there is some understood privilege between us (as in attorney-client communications) I can not assume my remarks are private. I may be upset that you published my comments but there is no implied privacy.

That covers what you do with the communication itself.

As to what you do regarding the substance of the Email is a different matter entirely. IF I told you that I was going to kill the president or bomb the capitol building, it would likely criminally implicate youif you withheld that information. Now that is an extreme example.

If I told you I had the answers to the Final Exam that we are taking tomorrow. The risk to you on how you handled that information would be minimal. If you turned me in, I might want to run you over with my car (or some other such badness).. If you did nothing, you might feel cheated when you got a "C" instead of the "A" I got.

Once you move out of the Legal-Illegal (those acts that society has actually enumerated as being"naughty") area, you are at the point where how you act is a complex equation of what you think is right and wrong, and what the perceived cost of "doing the right thing" would be.

ALM

by guruofdos

And that's a fact! Where to begin?!

All commercial e-mail is normally marked with 'Commercial in confidence' or some other disclaimer and forwarding or disclosing contents without authority is a breach of trust and a BAD THING.

Private email...this comes down to personal ethics...and whether the intention is revenge or any other reason, should IMHO remain private between the parties concerned. However, the subject matter and the context of the particular email, and the circumstances in which it is then 'used' may dictate a person's reaction or 'right' to distribute the content.

I believe there was an example of a private internal email (Pixar Inc...makers of Toy-Story) that became public knowledge (and headline news) and concerned executives salaries. In this case, there were possible criminal charges attached to incident, I recall.

Public posting of private emails could lead to accusations of defamation, slander or libel and in the UK there have been several newsworthy cases where court action has resulted...mostly involving investigative reporters and national newspapers!

As the other party concerned in this has a journalistic background...he must be aware that certain 'private' information has a tendency to be made public. What may be 'off the record' usually becomes 'public domain' as far as the tabloid press are concerned! This happens often enough in the 'traditional' media but in this day and age, the Net is the most accessible and readily available forum. You and I (and most of our colleagues on TR) know that a 'heated discussion' can all-too-easily turn into all-out-war and a good 'flaming' is often the result.

>>The best way to publicise information is to share it with others as a 'secret'
>>If you aren't prepared to 'tell it to my face' (or tell me in public)...don't tell me at all!

Mike :-)

by oldefar

I think we all subscribe to some basic rules for social behavior. This includes round table talks at the local watering hole, back porch discussions at work, and public post forums. The rules include limiting attacks on comments rather than individuals, backing off when personal offense is taken, and generally putting group cohesion above maintaining a position. In short, we shut up before ?reaching the brink? when we want see a group continue. A public argument between 2 people will kill a party, a smoke break, a beer session, and a topic on a discussion board. Recurring fights will stop the parties, the common breaks, the beer sessions, and the regular group of posters.

We avoid this in our social groups by taking personal issues up outside of the group. The regular posters have become a social group as well, and we can take our issues with a member off line via email. This is a courtesy to all of us, and keeps us from having to pick sides on individuals instead of positions.Lately many of us have become a bit personal in our comments. Friendly banter is good, it strengthens the sense of fellowship. We all use it to acknowledge that we read each others posts and respect each others contributions. Sometimes that friendlybanter gets misread and an email to clear things up is good. Some of us may dislike each other on a personal basis. That can remain out of the public postings and we can all continue to gain from the diversity of perspectives and wealth of unique experiences we bring.

Could such a spectrum of individuals exist outside of an online forum? Could we all ever sit down together and discuss such a range of issues? Would such a meeting become the stuff of legends with the local police?

by oldefar

In regard to your more general questions regarding email.

I have to agree that when someone records something, it should be done with an expectation that it now has an infinite lifespan. The longest I have seen is 14 years, when an email I had sent a manager came back to me via an employee. When that record is passed on it becomes the property of whoever received it and you should assume it may go public for any reason or no reason.

Now as to what I would do with information I have, that is a personal matter. My first allegiance is to myself, to my principals and values. This determines for me the order of allegiance. Every situation gets run through this matrix as part of the decision process. The gray area becomes more black and white when I stay true to myself.

It is really a question of expected results. In other words, what is the motive behind the action? If the motive is petty, vindictive, or simply self serving, I hope I would not take the action.

For the record, law is way down the list of justification. Every participant in the American Revolution was guilty of treason first, after all.

by guruofdos

and how very true...

hence my post re going for a beer...would we choose 'like minded individuals' or start a riot?!

by oz_media

Max, your topic has my head racing with examples and what ifs.

I agree with the focus that if an email discolses the intention to do harm or commit a crime, it is in your best judgement to report it to the correct authorities.

Outside of the criminal, email is to be considered a personal ciommunication between TWO parties and therefore should not be shared, disclaimer or not. This is more of a morality issue though. However, if a person send ANY other person an email, he/she must understand that the email CAN be shared and MAY be shared (in the case of revenge etc.), so ensure that anything you include in the email should be carefully thought out as to any negative effects that public viewing would have.

I myself have sent PEER mail to Maxwell in an attempt to keep peace as a result of a previous post that seemed to be and was found to be quite scathing, for this I apologize again Max.

I assume that Max has the ettiquette to keep this to himself, however I wouldn't be too upset if he chose to share it.

I manage several bands, yet I refuse to disclose their names because of this exact issue. If I really piss off a member here, they in turn could attempt to defame the artist or post comments on their bulletin boards etc. in an attempt to get revenge on myself. (Plus it's in our contract.)

If someone REALLY pissed me off and then sent me an email that infuriated me further, would I disclose the info?
1) If the person was misrepresenting themselves to others and told me differently, I may, but I usually don't care enough to bother.

2) If the person had defamed me and the email detracted from that, I probably would but onlybetween the relevant parties or those that would respect my privacy requirements (I wouldn't just send it to someone who inturn would publish it.

WOW MAX, lots of grey areas. Based on the ethical issues, will this become the next neverending story??

This discussion is closed to new replies.