Discussion Locked

A Travesty of Rock and Roll Justice

0 helpful
71 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

.
Another year of inductees into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, and another year where the Moody Blues are overlooked.

http://entertainment.tv.yahoo.com/entnews/ap/20051128/113320422000.html

http://www.rockhall.com/hof/allinductees.asp

Is there any band or performer more deserving, but more overlooked, than the Moody Blues? I certainly can't think of one.

71 replies

by jamesrl

I do have a Moody Blues greatest hits CD which I enjoy. And I loved the SNL parody. I did not go see them at the local casino though I had the chance.

But I did scan the list and did a few searches, and everyone I thought might be borderline would appear to be in. If Del Shannon is in (yes I am familiar with his works) then, Moody Blues should be in.

James

by antuck

Since Prince made it in 2004, the Moddy Blues most certainly should have been on the list. I would have placed the Moddy Blues much higher then the Sex Pistols.

I wonder why they haven't been inducted?

by mirrormirror

I'm gonna show my true head banger rocker self...

DEF LEPPARD should be in there if Prince already made it. Def Leppard is still making great music today and had influenced many other bands.

ROCK ON!!!!

by jck

so many years in the business...like 25 or 30 years?

Def Leppard might just be reaching that. I think On Through The Night came out about 1980.

They are a good band and do still put out some good stuff.

by johno

How about jethro tull, The Clash, Warren Zevon, it seems that no more than 7 a year, queen only made it in the 200?, they have benn going since 1973 before the police etc.

how about Dire Straits. bad Company, Free, Argent thin Lizzy. Golden earing.

i have to say though that it seems that USA, as usual, makes it before Europe or England. RnR is not an american invention, if you follow the inductees you will see they are Blues players, and therefore Black and therefore African. i dont seen any african bands there.

But as usual we have to bow down to the great american god.

just a thought

johno

by gregjahn

I imagine the Hall of Fame has certian set of rules or criterias for inductions.

by johno

off the subject, why are the moody blues not in the hall of fame, look at the name, Moody BLUES, dont sound like a Rnr band to me. Good band but TOO clasical, in my opinion, like procul harem(sic).

If 25 years is a critria then we should have bach, Beethoven and Mozart, as influences. the afore mentioned procul harem's whiter shade of pale is based on a bach piece, cant remember which now.

What i find intruging is the induction of the sex pistols, they were influential, but they were crap, sorry to say that i cannot remember a radio station taking a reqest for a sex pistols number. Okay Africa is a bit limited, but Good music is just that, and you will always get someone who will remind you of the good old days. I have yet to find someone who says "put on the sex pistols, we just love there three chord limitations and there rubbish harmonies, and I really get blown away by their vulgarity".

johno

by johno

the ventures good stuff, but then we should have the shadows, i must be honest though I have not paid too much attention to the list. i belive that there are criteria we are not privvy to, ie how many groupies were laid etc, you know real significant stuff. Jokingly though, the stones were/are great, but technically speaking, eric Clapton, has got to be one of the best guitarist that ever existed. he makes Keith richards look like Milli Vanilli.

johno

by 76guitars

You're right. The Shadows deserve the honor, too. Much more so,
IMHO, than groups such as Frankie Lymon & The Teenagers.

by johno

Truth be told until i heard they did "why do fools fall in love" and nothing else, I was clueless.

i have gone to the RnR hall of fame and have gleaned a plethora of knowledge i did not know.

what i find strange though is the definition of Rock n roll, i can apprecate Michael Jacksons brilliance i would not make him a RnR legend, Pop yes.

too each his own.

johno

by beads

I just caught a Jethro Tull concert here in Chicago a couple of weeks ago. Safe to say that Ian still knocks 'em out. Great show and agree that if nothing else Ian should be in the Hall of Fame.

I had forgotten that Jethro Tull used to be the opening act for Led Zepplin back in the early 70s to boot!

- beads

by middleagednewbie

I always thought of the Moody Blues as standing very much alone among musical groups. Nobody really preceded or followed them; Genesis might be the most similar band I can name. I never really thought they fit under any particular genre, and did have some detractors who thought rock music shouldn't be quite that elegant. I definitely don't agree with that last point, and think they deserve such an honor (or maybe that should be spelled "honour") as induction.

by bluron

Stevie Ray Vaughn not only as a performer, but a major influence to some quite respectful and talented performers. I would have thought both the Moody Blues and SRV would have been inducted.

by johno

Obviously there is some criteria, we are not privy too, SRV is brilliant, but a little bluesy maybe, but having said that given the likes of BB king etc, maybe it should be called the Rnr Blues and pop hall of fame.

I doubt though if our little discussion here would influence them, but it has been loads of fun, learnt something, spoke with kindred spirits, drank some beer, got go and ride the harley now.

johno

by nicknielsen

The Stones, the Beatles, and many more got their start covering songs by Robert Johnson, Muddy Waters, Bo Diddley, Howlin' Wolf, Elmore James, BB King, and many others.

We wouldn't have rock & roll _without_ the blues.

by sleepin'dawg

And don't get me wrong but I've never been one to get my shorts in a knot over any kind of entertaiment and/or the practioners of same. I enjoyed and still enjoy the Moody Blues when I hear them but as far as I'm concerned I don't care whether they are in a hall of fame. In fact I had to stretch my memory that there was such a thing as a Rock 'n Roll Hall of fame but then I have to stretch my mind to remember there is such a place as Cleveland which I only remember as the mistake on the lake. I've just never understood how people get so wrapped up in things like this. My loss I suppose.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by soundchaser

the mistake on the lake was a term from the early 70's. Cleveland has changed considerably in the 30 years since. To follow that logic, I could insist on calling all my friends down here in Florida as Johnny Reb. It does not sit well. Hahaha... if you get a chance, check the city out. It may surprise you.

by doug m.

I was in Cleveland a few years back; I liked it. Being from Chicago, it sort of had the look and feel of my hometown. I found out that some of the same architects who designed buildings in Chitown also built a few in Cleveland.

by sleepin'dawg

of being there was leaving there. I stand by my opinion of the mistake on the lake. BTW it's a term dating as far back as the fifties and possibly further. If Cleveland is so wonderful why don't you go live there??? It is most definitely not high on the list of places people willingly choose to live. I only go there when I have no choice and my last trip there was March/03 and my mind is still seared by the memory. What does it have going for it other than the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Cleveland, the elephants grave yard of the trailer trash set. It is one of the misfortunes of my life that I have relatives there and have to attend family functions such as funerals, weddings and christenings. Trust me as soon as they're hatched, matched or dispatched I'm out of there via the fastest means possible.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by les.eaglestone

If longevity is a criterion to be used, then the Moody Blues should make the Hall of Fame as they've been around since the sixties! Looking at the list of inductees to date, it is a travesty that they're not there in my opinion (there are far less deserving inductees already in the Hall of Fame)

by nicknielsen

Just like many other bands, Procol Harum has been classified based on their single big hit. Anybody who listened to a complete album (any of them) knows they were much more than "Whiter Shade of Pale."

Give it time, it'll happen. Although I must agree with you on one count. If the Sex Pistols are there, something is definitely wrong with the system.

by sawyerch

There is a war in Iraq and our boys are dying. Let's get to what's real in life. Besides, what on earth does this have to do with IT?

by dmambo

"There is a war in Iraq and our boys are dying."
There are people suffering here and abroad and we still go on vacations. There are people homeless, and we still order out for pizza. Don't you think it's OK to have a mild diversion once in a while?

"Let's get to what's real in life."
There are lot of people for whom music, even Rock and Roll, is a very important factor in their lives. It's conceivable that for them, this is a significant discussion.

"Besides, what on earth does this have to do with IT?"
This is the Miscellaneous board. The post's title was about as descriptive as possible. There was no way anyone should confuse this thread with a technology discussion, and it's right where it belongs.

If you don't like the non-IT discussions, perhaps it would better suit your preferences if you did not participate in them.

by mickster269

Maybe that's why this thread is in the "Miscellaneous" section?

And real in life? Are you implying that rock and roll isn't real? Haven't you ever listened to music while performing some IT task? Have you seen a computer commercial on the Television that DOESN'T have a music sound track?

We can't be focused on the trials and tribulations of just the critical issues of the world. Everyone needs to relax at one point, and where better than here?

by soundchaser

The board fo the RnR Hall of Fame decided on Cleveland as its home, it was because of Alan Freed and his coining of the term and his influence on American radio based in Cleveland. I will not recognize the hall until the actual announcements, and the induction ceremonies take place in that town.If they wanted a oard based in New York and a figure head museum in Cleveland, it should have been presented to the public as such, but it wasn't.

Some of the inductees have been valid, but I agree with this writer that more inflential groups have been overlooked, like the Moodies, Yes, Emerson, Lake and Palmer, Genesis, Tangerine Dream....all European blockbuster groups. This board is a sham.

by johno

I tend to think, having viewed the actual list, that the RnR Hall is Parochial with a tenedency towards bands from the US. before i get shot down, I dont have a problem with the Music per se' it is just that the hall only looks outside the borders when forced too. ELP, Definatly genesis, They also dont listen to everything the band plays again I go back to the Sex pistols, 3 Chords crap Vocals No harmoines and no real music talent whatsoever, unless you call spitting on the crowd.

Cheers.

johno

by soundchaser

As a teenager in the "British Invasion" of the 60's, I was glad that there were new rock sounds being injected. These guys had different outlooks on life and culture than we Americans did and it expanded our experience. Groups like Cream, The Who, The Yardbirds, contributed as much to the rock experience as any other group. Unfortunately, who knows what goes through the minds of those nominating and voting on selection for admission???

by doug m.

And let's not forget Dick Dale. The surfer rock sound in the early 60's was cool. Dick is still out there playing at some smaller venues occasionally.

by johno

his music is used in Tarantino movies, so yeah good guitarists. Dont know about his influence, live far away in Sunny RSA, not someone who is going to tour here.

johno

by geezah

Ditto!

I am also shocked that The Moody Blues are not in the the R&R Hall of.. well Shame now. Remember thier 1st LP, with Go Now? Much different than the rest but one of my all time favorite LPs.

And what about Jeffery Fredericks and the Clamtones???

by doug m.

why don't you tell us how you really feel? LOL
I have no desire to live there. But I'm not opposed to visiting there, just like NYC and L.A.
Nice places to visit but you really don't want to live there. I'm not trying to convince anyone to live there, just saying I didn't find the city all that bad, but then again I was only there for a couple of days.

by sleepin'dawg

queer. It might feel kind of nice but would you really want your friends to see you doing that??? Well you did ask how I felt!!!:^O Do note I did say might; I really have no standard of comparison in that area but what the hell, you say you found the city not that bad. You trying to tell us something???:p

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by soundchaser

I guess obvious cultural pastimes were not on your agenda. World class Art and History Museums, a World class orchestra, one of the finest Urban park systems in the country. Hospital systems that rival any other city in the world, professional sports teams. I lived in the Cleveland market for 28 years and only recently left.

And I thought IT was reserved for the intelligent folks......

by doug m.

you won't get me to bite on that bait my friend. All I'm saying is I like the way the city was laid out and it seemed pretty friendly and halfway clean. There are parts of all large cities you really don't want to go in. My opinion of NYC, for example, was formed back in 1978 and they appeared to be on a garbage strike and the city was just awful at that time. I hear tell they've cleaned it all up, including Times Square where I was handed hand-bills promoting all sorts of lurid adult shows. (much like Las Vegas)Not that there's anything wrong with adult shows if you're so inclined.

by tony hopkinson

Jackson Five, The Supremes ?
Not the top of my list when listening to Rock, Roll or Blues.
Not going to confuse them with AC-DC or Robert Cray are you ?
Never been a great fan of the Moody Blues myself, but I'd much rather listen to them than either of the above, in fact I'd rather listen to my mother-in-law complain than either of them.

Next year they'll realise they've left out europeans and add Shakin' Stevens, Rick Astley or Steps I should think.

by johno

AC/DC and Robert Cray, I suppose you should have Tina Turner then. But yes the jackson 5 et al dont fall into my record selection. On the subject of really rubbish, how about Boney M. Milli Vanilli, and most of the Euro Disco rubbish you get nowadays.

On the good side from Australia, Midnight Oil, JO Jo zep and the falcons, from NZ Crowed House, but this is degenerating into a Hand bag slapping scenario, My band is better than yours. RnR is like Sex, it is always good, but when it is brilliant it is fantastic

johno

by tony hopkinson

Disco, that's dead thank various deities, most of it was american anyway.
If you like the jacksons and the supremes be my guest, I like lots of music myself, just not them. I'm sure they deserve to be in a top 20 in some genre, just not rock and roll.

by nicknielsen

The Strawbs.

I mean, let's get real, if the Sex Pistols are there, every other band ever recorded deserves a place.

by johno

The strawbs, now there is a blast from the past, they were excellent, tight, different with an outstanding lead vocalist (cant remember name), I have another one, if we are on the Sex pistols, Supertramp.

In fact we should petition the hall to remove the bloddy sex pistols, 3 chord rubbish, whilst been high on drugs, really makes for good music.

johno

by tony hopkinson

of very popular music entertainers who aren't musically gifted. I wouldn't put the pistols in Top 20 Rock and Roll either. Top 20 punk rock definitely.
Should Sid and the pistols have been up there with Frank in top 20 crooners for My Way do you think ?
Tee Hee
This site is obviously some sort of popularity contest, nothing to do with the style or quality of the music.
SuperTramp Ugh, you'll be mentioning REO Speedwagon next.
AOR, can't stand it. Rock for eunuchs.

by soundchaser

I can remember WALKING the streets of NYC at midnight - 2AM even down around Times Square with no one bothering me. That was some time ago. It did get pretty bad, but I, too, have heard it has improved.

by maxwell edison

.
They were, after all, according to Frank Zappa, better than the Beatles. And since the Beatles are in, and Zappa is in, there ya go. Where are the Shaggs?

by Member 25348569

Zappa was not as good a music critic as he was a musician.

I must admit that, once heard, you can't take a middle ground with the Shaggs, though. I'd probably leave 'em out.

by johno

Who? maybe coming from Sunny RSA has limited my listening options, but I have not heard of them, I will check in at my local store though, nothing like a new experience. I like zappa though, but find at times he tends to be a little esoteric, or mocking, i dont know which. When he is good he is really good.

johno

by maxwell edison

.
Well, you might. Their stuff has been released again on CD.

However, be advised, my message was dripping with sarcasm.

The Shaggs, an all-girl band who recorded their first (and only?) record in 1969 (it was re-released in 1980), hold the distinction, in many circles, of being the absolutely worst group to ever make a record. They were SO bad, that no recording company, reputable of otherwise, would record their "music" (and I use the term "music" with extreme caution); their father actually had to PAY a recording studio to do it, and he had to buy 1,000 records himself.

I've been offered $50 for my 1980 re-released record, The Shaggs, Philosophy of the World, but I've turned it down. I've never seen an original 1969 record; it's one of the most rare records of all time, only 100 out of the original 1000 survived, and it's worth multi-mega-$$$.

Listen to some samples:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0000003MZ/104-6028039-7443942?v=glance&n=5174

Read all about them:

http://www.aurealm.com/shaggs.htm

http://www.missioncreep.com/tilt/shaggs.html

http://www.susanorlean.com/articles/meet_shaggs.html

But if the Sex Pistols made the R&R Hall of Fame, and the Moody Blues don't, well, The Shaggs should certainly be a shoe-in. (More sarcasm!)

Personally, I think the R&R HoF is a joke.

by nicknielsen

Definitely mocking. Zappa had a very low opinion of most mainstream rock.

I miss him and Captain Beefheart both!

by maecuff

Rock and Roll came from a blues song. No, the DJ in Cleveland didn't coin that phrase, he borrowed it.

by johno

Cant agree more, I think the problem lies with the title Rock and Roll hall of fame. Maybe the pures blues artists should fall into the infulence section. Whatever they do I am just happy RnR exists along with Pretty women Beer and Harley-Davidson. Oh yes and rugby, but the yanks wont know about that.

johno

by Member 25348569

I saw them live a few times. To think that Rick Wakeman - of 'Yes' fame - started with them and Sandy Denny of Fairport Convention and then Pentangle - who tragically died at age 31 of a brain tumour.

Oooops! Showing my age and early musical tastes here!

by gadgetgirl

I remember Pentangle!

And Fairport Convention!

I actually bought a Fairport Convention LP when I was.......ooops......

:p

GG

by Member 25348569

I went and Googled up a sample of their work after your first post about them.

I'm afraid, as always, I missed the irony. It does, after all, take all sorts to make world and you just [b]might[/b] have been a fan.

by dmambo

I was never a Zappa fan, but a roommate I had had an LP called "Shut Up And Play Yer Guitar" in which Frank really showed off his chops. To me, it was much better than the "normal" Zappa stuff

by nicknielsen

A live album in which FZ also shows his chops AND we learn to yodel for vegetables.

Actually, if you know where to listen, you can hear FZ show off his chops in every one of his songs.

by dmambo

are evident throughout, but I sometimes have a hard time getting past the loopiness integrated into much of his art. To each his own.

by jdclyde

If you look, on many of the albums is Steve Vai, listed as "Stat Abuse".

If you like guitar, you HAVE to LOVE Vai.

by jdclyde

If you look, on many of the albums is Steve Vai, listed as "Stat Abuse".

If you like guitar, you HAVE to LOVE Vai.

Oh yeah, don't eat the yellow snow!

by doug m.

of Frank Zappa either but I can appreciate what he did. I think he and the band could have been serious performers but then they might have just been lumped together with all the other bands of the time and would not have gotten the recognition they did. They stood out from the crowd.

by johno

Yep, I dont have any of there stuff either, maybe they should have a Pop hall of fame, then they can have their deities and normal folk can listen to decent RnR. I must be honest though I have danced to the Staying alive soundtrack, Wouldnt mention it in polite company though could offend some people.

johno

This discussion is closed to new replies.