Discussion Locked

Am I alone on this, Opinion and question

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a Thinkpad r31, great machine, 640Megs RAM, 32Meg Graphics. IBM provides a 1 year Hardware support warranty. I have called support about 6 times in the last year (I had an R30 that died)and not once have they escalated my problem to level 2or level 3 support, even after 2 or 3 1st level guys can't resolve the issue!
Support techs there are really pathetic and all have different answers. ie: My Thinkpad restarts when I disconnect the network cable (standby or not), this happened afterthe latest IBM BIOS update installation.
1st guy said "it's not supposed to work after disconnecting the network" ?!?!? what the....
2nd guy said "it is software related, sorry, is there anything else I can help you with?" what the...
If I hadn'tinstalled the latest BIOS, support would have asked me to update my software before they can resolve the issue. Now they say, because I updated software(off their site) that it is software related and they can't help.
I am a net admin that has HP's, Compaq's and IBM's in house. IBM has, by far, the most incompetent and useless support techs in the industry. Is it just me or has your support sucked too?!?
Q2: Does anyone know why a Thinkpad would get a blue screen (real quick flash with some kind of Mode Exception Error) and restarts when the network is unplugged?

10 replies

by samlowrey

I don't have an answer, but just a thought. I know that when the network is disconnected in 2000, it seems to "alert" the user with an icon in the systray. I guess that means it is aware when you unplug it (through some sort of polling, maybe?) I'm guessing there is something faulty with the circuitry in the NIC, and when the OS accesses it in a particular way, it goes haywire. I imagine all NICs have some cache - perhaps it is faulty in this instance. I can just imagine this as being flakey hardware.

(This is my first reply, btw. Hope I'm not speaking out of line.)

by lordinfidel

The only 2 things that would come to mind would be 1: memory (which probably isn't the case)

or 2: the latest bios upgrade.
Especially if it started happening after the upgrade.

I would downgrade the bios at this point.

As far as tech support goes, IBM is not the only ones. Dell's desktop support sucks also. (Not to be confused with server support which rocks)

I had a drive on a friends machine that died, you can hear the actuator arm thrashing around in there. I call them, (told them who I was and was nice about it), told them what was going on. And they still made me run diagnostics on the system just so it can get a screen that said, Device unrepairable.

This actually happened to me twice in one week. A clients machine also died, called again, This time told them that I ran the diagnostic and got the error message (I did not feel like playing around). This time though they decided not only to send me a drive but to send a tech out also.

I politely told themthat it was not necessary I can install the drive myself. And they got nasty with me.

After arguing with them I told them point blank that I will not allow their tech to install the drive in the machine. It's their dime, I could care less how they spend it, but it is still my clients machine and therefor my responsibility.

I even had to throw out there my qual's, which I really dispise doing.

In answer to your question, it's not just you. Tech support for the big companies blows. They are generally just people reading from a manual/screen and can only do what they are prompted.

by support#netropole.com

i would have to agree with LordInfidel. you need to downgrade your bios. if the older bios is not on the website and you dont have a backup. your only option is to talk with techsupport. this time dont tell them you know anything about computers. tell them in a duh voice that you upgraded your bios and now when you unplug your network thingy your pretty laptop gives this cool blue looking screen and reboots. then help them to come up with giving you the ftp site for the previous bios version. i've talk to phone support alot in the past and i found you get more information and upgraded to tier2 if you make the tech feel like he/she is the smarter one :-)

and thats my 3.5 cents

by oz_media

Well you have all posted valid points and yes, I am trying to get the previos BIOS update.
Sorry for not mentioning that I use W2KPro !!
All in all, I have never been an IBM fan ( I also hate Sony after working in the audio industry) but this Thinkpad really kicks butt! By far the fastest and most stable notebook I have ever used (with this minor exception of course).
Thank you everyone for your valued answers, it's nice to get positive support from somewhere even if it isn't my vendor. :-)

by lordinfidel

At least certain models.

I've had the same 390x now for almost 3 years.
Although I have had the keyboard and screen replaced twice, but they were really good about their turnaround time.

(it does'nt hurt that I have 2 identical models, just in case 1 dies I still have another to use, but that's the price to pay when you are in a mission critical type of position)

But the 390e's i'm not a big fan off. Or the i1400/1500 series. I did'nt like that you can't get to the hdd easily.

by thechas

I to have experianced poor or bad tech support at numerous companies.

Generally, I feel that I know more than the person at the other end of the line, they just have the script of details for the hardware or software that they are supporting.

Because of cost pressures, most firms have farmed out the tech support / help desk function.
Often, the person you are talking to or e-mailing is in a 3rd world country!

My best advice, is to make friends with a good local independant PC retailer.
If you throw a little business to most of these shops, they will go out of their way to assist you.

Chas

by ώ.ữ.ẃ.ϫ.м.ς ® ,

I think i agree with you that IBM is just a load of CRAP!!!! i have about 30 300Gl's and the service is *&*((@&(@(.

I think these systems belong to the trash BIN!!!!!!

by ώ.ữ.ẃ.ϫ.м.ς ® ,

I think i agree with you that IBM is just a load of CRAP!!!! i have about 30 300Gl's and the service is *&*((@&(@(.

I think these IBM systems belong to the trash BIN!!!!!!

by radiic

I have not had the pleasure in dealing with the fine people of IBM tech support. But I am sure they are as bad as the other tech support departments I have had the pleasure in dealing with. I agree with Lord on the DELL server support...THEY ROCK. Also I had good luck with their desktop support, only because we had the phone number to their department that supported IT people. We never had to do the run around, we told them what we had diagnosed and they would send us the part next day to repair. Gateway well enough said their. And their server people suck too. I was setting up a sco unix server and needed the boot string for the cd rom and they told me that the one guy in their company that supports unix is on vacation and wont be back for 2 weeks. ARGGGGGGG

About the only tech support people I enjoy calling is the guys at Cisco TAC. NOW THEY ROCK.
Not that I enjoy calling tech support because you know when your calling them somebody in your company is complaining about not being able to work because their computer or the network is down.

IT is a vicous cycle, but IT is job security. ;)

Rad
Theres my 4.5 cents

by kate.perez

A few years ago, I was a warranty administrator in Houston. I called IBM asking for a part. The next day, I did not have it, and I called, the 2nd day, asking where my part was. They told me quite clearly that they only had one of that part left on the shelf, and they were not going to send it out until they got more in their stock. What good was it doing on their shelf, while I had someone down at my location? It is a good thing IBM does have pretty reliable equipment, or they'd be out ofbusiness, due to their lack of customer service/support.

This discussion is closed to new replies.