Discussion Locked

American IT Consultant vs H1B IT Con

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Are companies selecting younger H1B applicants over American applicants because they can pay the H1B applicants less? Also, are there more IT applicants than job openings, especially in Northern California, to include H1B applicants?

5 replies

by timwalsh

One of the myths surrounding H1B workers is that they can be paid "slave wages". This is not true.

Employers petitioning to hire an H1B worker must certify that they will pay an "appropriate wage" for the specific job they are hiring for. The Department of Labor keeps statistics of median wages for a given labor category for each state. Therefore, while the employer has some leeway in determining wages offered, they cannot be too far from the median without justification.
This certification to pay an appropriate wage is a protection put in place to protect American workers from being replaced by slave labor imported from outside the country.

A perceived advantage for hiring an H1B worker over an American worker is that given similar qualifications and experience, an H1B worker may accept lower wages than an American worker who has to support a big mortgage, a wife, 2 kids getting ready to go to college, 3 cars, etc., etc. While the H1B worker is still getting an "appropriate wage" for a given job category, it may be at the lower end of the spectrum for that category. His living expenses are lower. Although he IS also supporting a family, where he is from, the money he is making will probably go a lot further. Long winded answer for your first question.

Most of us see the reported stats that XXX thousand IT jobs will go unfilled in the US this year. These stats don't do us any good if the jobs aren't where we are looking and aren't in fields where we have expertise. So your second question is really hard to answer with any degree of accuracy. The economy in general is on a slippery slope. Many industries are laying off workers. IT budgets are getting smaller. This obviously makes it much harder for anyone trying to find specific types of work in a specific area. I cant be any more specific than to say that for some skill sets, the answer is yes, and for others it is no.

by parkerjj01

I think most of us are trying hard to be political correct especially if we are currently working on an IT assignment or still have our permanent IT job. I have talked to many H1B workers who were looking to change jobs in order to try and raise their pay to the rates most of us American workers were getting. They were just waiting to get the papers in order, and they had no plans of ever returning to their country of origin. They have actually started their own communities here. It is as simple as the nose own your face (economics), when the supply is greater than the demand first the price goes down, and then the demand for services goes down, as all the positions are filled.

by saguarojt

My company uses a lot of H1B technical staff. At first glance, or in the short-term, they may be a little cheaper, but that's not a long-term reality. Ultimately, people are going to be paid what they're worth; and most of our H1B staff end up beingworth the competitive wages we pay them.

It's a winning equation for us because they are, by in large, well-trained and educated, hard workers with (for us) a great track record. And, India (where our H1B workers come from) is replete with individuals who are talented and trained in technology we're looking for. Most are with us long-term (many years), and many go on to earn permanent residence status, and most of them stay with us after that. As a project manager, I'm extremely pleased withour work force, which is comprised of both H1B and "domestic" staff.

While there are "domestic" hires available (particularly now), what I've found is that the crop of talented local consultants are not the ones who are looking for work at any given time. The pickings for truly valuable technical staff are really marginal even now, and H1B provides a source that's unequaled through any other channel I have access to.

I'm not sure if this is what you're looking for, but I hope it helps.

by ramsdell_kevin

From an employer's, capitalistic, point of view, the answer is as simple as Supply and Demand. You need something done, where can you obtain the most cost effective (same quality) resources. If there's an inefficiency in the US labor market then you would exploit it until it levels out. In this case, there are three ways that it would naturally level out, 1) H1B applicants demand higher wages, 2) non H1B will work for less or 3) employers reevaluate the interchangeability of the two resource pools.

Ask yourself, if someone could do your job for cheaper then what right do you have to that position? That was then this is now. IT staffers have gone from a misunderstood group of coding machines that supposedly had poor interpersonal skills, to mid to senior level managers that understand key business objectives, processes and goals. This migration has moved many out of the resource pool previously discusseed and transitioned them into an asset as opposed to an expense. If you can see the income that you add to an employer you're all set. You understand the big picture and that's what will get you the extra cah these days. However, grunt work IS still getting shipped to cheaper countries so don't be a grunt. Challenge your higher ups!

This discussion is closed to new replies.