Discussion Locked

Appreciation of peers

0 helpful
33 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In recent discussions, a lot of people have stood up to be counted and offered support for my post while slandering another peer who was objective.

As much as I appreciate people going to bat for me or supporting my ideas, I never expect such resopnses and would feel terrible if someone lost thier TR privaleges for stepping over the line.

Please don't jeopardize your good name at TR to support me, I can always find a new sandbox if I go over the line but would not be able to accept someone else losing out on the TR forums and support due to some idiot takig pot shots at me.

If you agree with me that's great, if you supoprt my arguments, thank you, but please don't cross the line on my behalf.

Thanks all,
OM

33 replies

by passwordchanged

this is copied from the discussions entrance page.

Express your opinion
Join conversations with other TechRepublic members about anything from desktop application support to shopping for an ASP. You can start a conversation about any subject. Questions? Check
out our Discussions FAQ.

Now, which part of "conversation about anysubject" do you NOT understand? Any subject - which by my read kmeans sex, politics, R&R, and technical, too.

by oz_media

Don't see where you are going with this. I assume you are going to say that this means technical questions should be allowed in the discussion forums.

If you had stated this along with your above comments in your ORIGINAL response, I would have happily pointed out where you are mislead. Instead you choose to abandon logic and slam my character instead.

"CONVERSATION ABOUT ANY SUBJECT" Does NOT mean ask a techical question. A question is a question, a conversation is NOT a request for help.

If I said, HOW do I get my graphics card working, this is a question, NOT a discussion topic or as you have pointed out, a CONVERSATION. It is a request for information.

If I said, my grphics card doesn't work, I found all GeForce cards have this buggy problem, how do you feel about GeForce cards? or What cards do you like? THIS is a CONVERSATION or DISCUSSION topic.

You should read some of the posting guidelines too, before you preach, learn about the issue yourself.

by passwordchanged

"The Discussion Center is where you can discuss relevant IT topics, such as technology, career, and management, with other IT professionals. No TechPoints are needed to participate in these discussions, and there are no right or wrong answers. Think of this as an online team meeting with other IT professionals participating."

my issue with you, mr. canadian bacon, is that instead of encouraging other active people in these forums to help newbies find their way to techq&A, you suggested giving them sarcasm and abuse. that's not helping either the people who post in the "wrong" place and it isn't helping build this community either. So do you wish to build or destroy goodwill? By your incessant flames and abuse of otherposters, must be the latter

by oz_media

But you still resorted to name calling, another few years and you'll be adult enough to converse.

Now, we have for several months TRIED to get the Q&A topics reduced in the Discussion forum. SOme have completely ignored them, some have had a pre written redirect that can be pasted and points the user to the correct forum, we have also formally requested to the TR staff for change.

The number of questions has increased, not decreased. When someone posts a question, they don't see all the other posts being told that they will get better help in Q&A, they just see other questions and post, thinking it is the right place. This needs to be resolved by site navigation updating.

Mu suggestion was tongue in cheek as most people would have read it. It was a frustrated post with a last resort of BRIDGING discussions, not being sarcastic or abusive. Can you point to where in the thread I suggested sarcasm orabuse as a resolution? I didn't think so.

So, if you disagree you may offer an alternative resolution if you have a better idea OR you may simly say you don't like the idea and feel it is unjust.

Simply calling someone names is not a resolution, it is antagonistic and your insults will be returned, as should be expected.

Now, you've said you disagree, I can accept that. Do you have a better idea or will you just disagree and be on your way?

OM

by oz_media

I am not really Canadian, as you may remember.
I LIVE in Canada, I LOVE Canada but I'm NOT Canadian. Your slams at Canada are unjust as they are targeted at me being Canadian, I don't think too many Canadians would agree with your point of view and would probably just jump on the hate USA bandwagon, as you are a poor example of your country and your country's beliefs.

People with such an attitude are the reason people dislike America, not the few such as yourself that give the USA a bad name. Do your fellow citizens a favour, don't use your being American as a way to put down others, it isn't well received.

by passwordchanged

dude you have lost your shiite. I never bashed Canada. You on the other hand take every occasion you can to slam the u.s. Sounds like your guilty conscience is catching up with you.

by fluxit

What ever happened to the days of hippy love and wearing flowers in your hair? IT guys used to have the Jesus look with long hair and beard at one time. The played a guitar and sang about the new economic order!

by oz_media

As much as I'd love the ideal planet too, unfortunately those days didn't stick.

What was originally a good idea (except the lazy bastards wouldn't work for a living) turned into AIDS (Hippie love), Drug Addiction (Hippie love)and Turf Wars (economic order).

Guitars are stil played, 140 decibels, songs are still sung, or lip synch'd.

It's the same place only the names have been changed to protect the guilty.

by jardinier

During the hippie era, I was living in Kings Cross, Sydney, through which all truth-seekers passed, and hippies were everywhere, practising their free love, smoking pot and grooving on Bob Dylan.

I grew long hair, and a red beard, and I swear I looked just like the classic image of Jesus. When I was busted for vagrancy (being out of work but not on the dole) the nice, sarcastic policeman actually called me Jesus.

As virtually every person played the guitar, my mother bought me my first guitar, which gradually led to my composing spiritual songs (as mentioned in an earlier discussion).

by hal 9000

I haven't seen you around here much lately but I suspose that the little one is keeping you away right?

Incidently how is she going and more impartantly how and you and Mrs GOD going?

In relation to you're post I think most of us still do after all if we didn't TR wouldn't be here would it?

Cheers

Col

by oz_media

You are being seomwhat refined but your message is clear.

mr. Canadian bacon you may deny but it is clearly a shot at me being from canada, therefore you are associating your disagreement with me as being a disagreement with me as a Canadian, not a person.

I learned to be this PC picky right here on TR, not bad huh?

My concience is clear, I speak my mind and therefore retain no hatred or doubt in my thoughts, things in the open don't become dirty laundry.

You seem to have nto recovered from last year's rants and still have a little bit of a sting in your bum. I have not slammed America or her people in a while, I have also seen VERY little Pro-American charing lately. Funny how arrogance is met with such conflict. You take away the 'Holier than thou' attitude and the resistance mellows too, hmmmm. Is there perhaps some psychology behind all this?

by hal 9000

In the Discussion Forums and for that matter I haven't seen much activity from you at all around TR.

So what exactly are you trying to say when you critise OZ instead of doing this shouldn't you as the mature adult that you say you are have forgoten about the original post and jumped right in and attempted to answer all the questions that where listed instead of attempting to attack the person who brought this up?

If you do not like a topic there is no need for you to join in but you could very easly have gone to all the listed questions and tried to help there as you claim that is what you want to see being done here at TR.

But if you had even bothered to have a look at any of these questions you would have seen my responces to most of the listed questions and the suggestion that they give more detail and post in the Q & A section as they would get a faster responce and more likely someone from their time zone to help them as well. Now one of those questions was titeled "I need help" and went on to say that my new P4 that I've just built will not work and gives no video display and then something about a 9 pin male to 15 pin male connector. I asked for a lot more detail like what exactly was happening and made a few suggestions about how he could fix his problem or at least start some basic trouble shooting.

I notice that since then no one else has made any coment or the original person has not attempted to reply with more information I even offered to attempt to help him if he wanted to contact me through the Peer Listings which he has not availed himself of either.

Now exactly what have you done in any form of attempt to help any of these people?

I was taught manners when I was young and if you can not say something nice about someone then just don't say anything at all.

You claim that TR is here to help people then get to it and offer the help that you are so adimant about and stop interfering with others who want a little peace and quite away from the daily grind of work in the IT industry!

If you do not like what I've posted here you can contact me through the Peer listings with a complaint as well but I notice you do not make you're self available for this kind of action so aren't you the Pot calling the Kettle BLACK?

Col

by hal 9000

Since you appear to be so adiment about helping people here on the TR discussion threads here is a new posting that I'll leave for you to answer you will find it at https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=145755&start=0

Of course you will need to remove any spaces that where inserted when uploaded that is a normal thing since the change.

But go for it as it is a simple answer I'm sure that you'll make short work of it and have the complete answer in no time at all after all you did deride a Peer for his thoughts on this matter so fess up and put you're money where you're mouth is.

Col

by hal 9000

I'll check up in a few days time and see how you went with an answer to this persons problem.

I'm sure you'll be able to answer it in no time at all and without exerting any mental effort either.

by oz_media

I am a short haired well dressed and professional IT guy. I listen to the news, not music, I think "Sex is boring ugly hippie shit, boring, boring, boring" (Johnny Rotten circa '69.).

On weekends Santa and the Easter Bunny come over for non achoholic cocktails and Yahtzee.

It would be funny/cool to see a picture page or even a private picture forum we could offer links to. I know the peer listing does that but that's not really the same.

by hal 9000

As when someone tries to take a picture of me the camera breaks always.

But I can use the same camera to take photos it must be my "Magnetic Personality" that causes digital cameras not to work when pointed at me.

Now I've just seen that very nice person posting directly to me so I suspose I'd better go see what he/she wants. I wonder what I've done to upset him/her after all it is "Bash OZ week this week isn't it?"

Col

by oz_media

Yes you are a very sociable type aren't you.

I think I just like the fact that you make as many typos as I do, well that and the fact that you guys brew a FAIRLY decent beer there. :-)

I actually have a photo of your fingertip that is quite revealing, do you always go gloveless?

by passwordchanged

yo i looked at that question - and if i could help answer it, i would. But you miss thepoint - that person (if it is a REAL post) probably genuinely hopes to get some help from this forum. My point was and STILL IS that people like you and Oz should let 'em be. You are not the friggin GODS of the discussions and tech qa center, and you don't have to post answers to enjoy reading the thredas and learning from them. But when you and O-Z flame on people for no apparent reason, you make this forum un-enjoyable. I flame on O-Z because he is a real prick and deserves some of his own medicine - tho i have to admit he has chilled out some lately. you on the other hand maybe ought to go back to a wired mouse. wireless you're out of control

by maxwell edison

You said that Oz is a real %$@!&. Well, I suppose I've thought the same thing, but I've also decided that he is one because he wants to be one. I've also decided that he enjoys the role, as he likes the light shining brightly on himself. (Not psychoanalyzing, just sharing my "opinion".) There are a number of people who regularly "flame" and "name-call", and incite others into the same behavior. Both you and Oz are in that category, Oz is probably the leader of the flame pack, and if the folks at TR ever decided to enforce their "rules", both of your accounts would be the target of a laser guided cyber bomb.

That's just my opinion, mind you, which probably isn't worth a tinker's damn. (By the way, what's a "tinker"?)

by oz_media

A Tinkers Dam, this is REALLY cool as I spent a bunch of time rsearching OLD sayings one year.

A tinker was a tinman. He would, for example, solder the handles onto the old tin cups at wartime.

Solder in that day was mainly silver and VERY expensive to waste during recession. He would use an angled board under his work to catch the dripping solder and it would run down the board into a little puddle of tin/silver.

TO keep the puddle from becoming a flat pool, he would pile up a little dam of sand so that the drippings would pool into a blob by the end of the day so he could resuse it.

Now SILVER was worth money, but this little puddle of tin/silver (tinkers dam) was prectically worthless in trade as it was mixed with dirt and was not pure, but worth saving for reuse if you were a tinker.

When something is worthless, we say it isn't worth a tinker's dam.

I don't have a link to my resources as I said it was a while ago and I don't even think it was the net I was searching, probably old books at the library. But nobody really gives a tinker's dam anyway.

by thechas

A tinker is a metal-smith.

The term tinker comes from the gentle 'tink' sound produced when his small hammer delicately formed the metal into shape.

Chas

by hal 9000

You will see that I have offered a possible answer and not as you claimed "Flamed" him but at the same time I have also pointed out that while I am willing to offer him any help that he may require I am in a completely different time zone to him and there will be a time delay that may not be the case if he was to post his question in the Q & A section.

At least I appear to know a little more about IT than you do and I am willing to offer assistance.

Now what is you're excuse?

And don't come up with M$ is the only OS worth looking at because this just is incorrect and only a fool would believe this or a person who works for M$.

Unix and its deritivies have been around for a long time before Microsucks was ever thought about but if you like I can point you to M$ only questions!

Col

by oz_media

Need-a-raise: Now I've read your thought AND thought about your points only to find that there is no point.

No you have accused ME of flaming those who post Questions in the Discusion forum. I will accept that, if you can show me where. You can't because Ialways help people or at least point them POLITELY to where they can get help.

Now you have a point in saying that we don't HAVE to address the questions in the Q&A forum, you are correct, we don't. Unfortunately,I like to help people and therefore feel compelled to at least steer people in the right direction before adding that they would receive more responses from the Q&A forum.

ALSO, my post was that the number of Questions in the Discussion forum has removed all need of the Tech Q&A section, it is not adhered to so why have it at all? Some people (even newbies) will figure out that questions are for Q&A, why should they register and try to help others while accumulating points to help themselves in the future, if others wont play by the rules.

Its not fair on those that play by the rules, it's not fair on those who want to help but need a break.

Have you ever been at a bus stop where everyone is lined up waiting, and then some knob walks up to the bus stop pole to read the schedule, the bus pulls up and he gets on first? It's anal, it's unthoughtful and it pisses people off, if WE play by the rules, sorry but you'll have to as well.

NOW, sorting through Discussions and only reading NON questions is fine. When there are TEN new discussions and not a single one is actually a discussion topic, is that also fair? NO.

As for Colin, he contibutes SO much in the Q&A forum, he deserves a break from questions when in the discussion group. He has done NO wrong here, he contributes a thousand fold more than yourself and is always sincere and helpful to all.

Recently I had a confusig hardware issue that I was at my wits end with, I chose to email two peers that I kNOW contribute exceptionally to the hardware problems here. Both came back with the most helpful responses and Colin pegged it late one night and ofered me his thoughts, which turned out to be the problem.
I bow to these men for thier helpful behavior, I knew this was where to get help and these were the people who offer it.

Colin, as many of the group here are, is 100% justified in complaint about the site layout, changes he would recommend etc. Earn your stripes before you hand out the orders my friend.
One day your opinion may count too.

by oz_media

Well the last message didn't fit the title as I strayed from my intent somewhat, as usual.
In short, there is a local park in London HYDE PARK, where anyone with a big mouth and something to say can stand on his soapbox and do so with hundreds if not thousands of people to listen.

You don't need any qualifications, you are not told you are unpatriotic for speaking out against the government, you can just spew about anything you please and people will listen. You may get into a debate with other soapboxers but that's because it is an open and very puvlic forum. (I guess you would consider it free speech), you don't need a point, you don't need a reason, just stand up and start yapping.

Perhaps you need to travel a little and get this out of your system. At least someone would listen and your point MAY get heard.

by maxwell edison

.
You said, that you don't "flame" those who post Questions in the Discusion forum. You went on and said that you always "help" people or "at least point them POLITELY to where they can get help."

You said those things, right? I didn't take them out of context, did I?

Okay, so far we are in agreement.

If I can show you where you flamed someone who asked a simple question, not in the discussion forum, but in the Q&A forum, if I can show that you flamed this person in the most mean-spirited way, what will you agree to do in return?

(Be careful how you answer, because I can indeed prove it.)

by hal 9000

A some what harder one that will test you a bit.

You will find it at

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=145763&start=0

Again please remember to remove any spaces that may get inserted on the upload.

It is a Win 98 SE question and if you are unable to answer it instead of trying to deride me you might ask for some more detail as it will be required and shock horror you could even offer for that person who needs a answer to comunicate directly with you so that you can help him out as you seem so interested in helping people who can not place thier questions in the correct area. I just get peeved when I take the time to ask for more info so that I can help them and never hear from them again so I guess that they are not at all really interested in any answers.

However if you are unwilling to offer direct contact with you're self you should point this person to the Q & A site for the help that he/she needs.

Col

by hal 9000

5.10 AM on the 22-1-04 and I'm calling it quits so instead of giving that poor person who asked the question a hard time about me going to attack him. Do the right thing and either offer what help you can, ask for what things you think you need or point him to the Q & A section so he at the very least will get a responce from someone who is willing to help him. As I have to work for the food that I eat and the fuel that goes into the car that I drive and all the rest I will not be able to get back for at least 20 hours and that is just too long to leave someone waiting if they are geninue.

Col

by oz_media

Stull laughing out loud Max, I had to actually stop and think whatthe hell you meant (defensive radar engage!). Without viewing the titles I was looking through my post, quites confused.
VERY witty squire!

Talk about brain dead, I can't believe I didn't catch it right away, yet again, I'm not really used to humor between us so I look straight for the pot shot (I'll get better, I promise).

Reminds me of a guy who worked for me in the early 90's, when faced with a problem, the heavy brow was shown.

I asked him jokingly one day if he was slow. He replied "what do you mean?"

I said , "you know, a little slow to the draw, not quite up to speed, a little backward, not the sharpest tool in the shed?"

He looked at me with the heavy brow for a minute then his eyes lit up and the lighbulb went on, "OH SLOW! I get it...no I'm not slow."

:-)

by oz_media

I make a concious attempt to help people in the Q&A forum. Recently had a bit of fristration with a guy in Q&A but others have agreed with my response when I questioned it.

By all means, have a go, I nkow you like to spend time wading through the heaps of crap here in order to prove others wrong, but the point is. I DO help more people here than I hurt. I offer sincere responses when not poked, I go out of my way to research topics that somepople are simply too lazy to lok up themselves. I post links to help people, I return to see if they have further questions and have received MANY personal thank you's in my email from these people.

Needs-a-raise and A-drunk-at-the-wheel haave contributed nothing, nil. Big vacancy sign. Yet they feel justified in speaking out on how the support is handled? Like I say, Hyde Park, or get off the soapbox and practice what you preach.

For the most patr, you are eloquent and well spoken, you also say that you lose it sometimes, which we all do. Does this then mean you are NOT helpful or that MOST of your answers are flaming someone? No.

But I would be interested in which post your are referring to, somehow I suspect it is regarding a TV out issue, but may be wrong.

by oz_media

Ahhh, that's it. I knew it was someone who formed and soldered tin but your metal-smith sounds a little more acceptable than tin-man.

I just couldn't get my tongue around the word when needed, pretty sad for a third year machinist! (Got bored of my dad before I got journeyman status).

by hal 9000

And even now because of the heat I've stoped wearing them as well because even a short trip of 1 K gets them soaking wet and almost impossible to put back on.

Add to that that you have to put on a wet crash helmet and well I'm just not interested if I was to travel any further I would wear gloves but for those short trips I just can not be bothered.

By the way who sent you the photo?

This discussion is closed to new replies.