Discussion Locked

Are you a conspiracy theorist?

0 helpful
131 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

131 replies

by tonythetiger

[i]This from one who has repeatedly demonstrated little to no grasp of Science in general, and Physics in particular?[/i]

I'm not a fireman either, but I can tell when a house is burning! I have enough of a "grasp" to realize that there is still a lot that science doesn't know/can't explain, and that anyone who claims otherwise is a snake oil salesman.

[i]it is an indictment of all who insist that their limited knowledge and understanding is sufficient for arriving at any and all correct conclusions.[/i]

Which is EXACTLY why I've not reached a "conclusion". I'm smart enough to know that I don't know everything... are you?

by charliespencer

Although it probably took you more time than is deserved by a list of questions that begins with, "According to Wikipedia..."

by deepsand

that being to ignore that the effects of spectral absorption, and the resulting radiative forcing, are independent of the past, but are determined by universal Physical Laws, to persist on insisting that the presence or absence of some other cause(s) might somehow render these Laws impotent.

In short, you have reached a conclusion based of the logical fallacy of "argument from ignorance." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance

by tonythetiger

[i]"argument from ignorance."[/i]

That would require that I assert that your claim is false. I don't. I am simply not joining you in claiming that it is the entire truth.

I am not convinced that there are not other factors, clues of which may be found by further examining the past.

By the way, why did you insert the adverb "necessarily" in the phrase "the Past is not necessarily prologue"?

by nicknielsen

It was kind of fun doing a little research on that issue. I was amazed at some of the absolutely wacko crap that's out there about 9/11; the Kennedy theorists have nothing on the 9/11 crowd.

I even found a site that blames the whole thing on magicians and mass hypnosis. http://www.thesleaze.co.uk/magic.html ;\
;)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

are 'they' out to get me, 'they' are out to get you, too.
You'll be amazed at who 'they' are if you ever get to meet 'them'!

:0 ;) :D

by deepsand

I've been to the dark bellies of more beasts than I long ago could have imagined.

What now amazes me is that, despite such, mankind continues to survive.

by deepsand

[b][u]1) [i]Argumentum ad Ignorantium[/i], Argument from Ignorance, or Appeal to Ignorance.[/u][/b]

See http://www.fallacyfiles.org/ignorant.html , and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance , among others.

Your position is that, as other possible causes for global warming, known from the past and/or unknown, have not be [b]disproven[/b] to here be in play, it cannot be concluded that anthropologically produced atmospheric compounds are a cause of such.

[b]Fact[/b] The Science of Spectral Absorption is long & well understood.

[b]Fact[/b] It is long & well understood that, under certain conditions, said absorption results in Radiative Forcing.

[b]Fact[/b] It is well understood that the system consisting of Sol, Earth, and Earth's atmosphere is that type of system susceptible to radiative forcing.

[b]Fact[/b] It is long & well understood that certain compounds serve to facilitate radiative forcing.

[b]Fact[/b] It is well understood that mankind's endeavors release large quantities of said compounds into Earth's atmosphere.

[b]Therefore[/b], there exists a substantial body of evidence to conclude that anthropologically produced atmospheric compounds are a cause of global warming.

To argue otherwise is to hold that other causes must first be eliminated prior to reaching said conclusion. That is, it is to hold that such conclusion cannot be reached owing to a lack of evidence against its being false.

This precisely fits the definition of said fallacy.

[b][u]2) Past & Prologue[/u][/b]

Past may or may not be prologue.

If a given phenomenon has but one possible genesis, that that genesis cannot [b]not[/b] yield said phenomenon, then the presence of such phenomenon must, by deductive logic, herald the presence of said genesis. Here, Past [b]must[/b] be Prologue.

However, if a given phenomenon allows of multiple causes, then the mere presence of such phenomenon is silent with regards to its current genesis.

Similarly, if a particular set of conditions need not necessarily give rise to said phenomenon, we can deduce naught of of the genesis of its present occurrence.

Here, in both cases, Past is [b]not[/b] Prologue.

[b][u]Conclusion[/u][/b]

Global warming allows of various possible & [b]independent[/b] causes.

None of the conditions known to have been possible causes of such warming are presently observed.

The necessary conditions for a particular cause of systemic warming, radiative forcing, as defined by Theoretical Physics, rather than as deduced by observational data, is known to currently exist.

None of the conditions known to have been possible causes of such past warming can serve to nullify the latter & present cause.

Therefore, it must be concluded that, regardless of any other possible causes, anthropologically produced atmospheric compounds are indeed a cause of such.

by nicknielsen

Too carefully. A few additional facts:

[b]Fact[/b] "Global warming" started 18,000 years ago. Both atmospheric CO2 and temperature have been rising steadily since then. http://www.geocraft.com/WVFossils/temp_vs_CO2.html

[b]Fact[/b] The Holocene Maximum, the hottest period in human history, occurred approximately 7000 to 4500 years before present, long before the advent of industrial pollution.

[b]Fact[/b] Atmospheric temperature and CO2 concentration show a strong correlation over the past 425,000 years. This chart also shows strong periodicity in atmospheric temperature variation, with long, cooler periods separated by shorter warm periods and clearly shows that we are approaching the peak of one of those warm periods. http://www.seed.slb.com/en/scictr/watch/climate_change/images/carbon_dioxide.jpg

[b]Fact[/b] Over the past 140 years, atmospheric temperature and CO2 correlate directly with the sun's intensity, where the strength of the solar wind is used as a measure of that intensity. http://www.geocraft.com/WVFossils/tempCO2_vs_solwind.html

Given these facts, your assertion that past is not prologue is suspect at best and possibly fallacious.

In all the writing and discussion on climate change, I have noticed that those most zealously advocating action to alleviate "anthropologically produced atmospheric compounds" will not consider any other possible causes outside those that can be blamed on humanity and choose their facts accordingly. Your conclusion follows this trend. Although it utilizes proper scientific phrasing such as "The necessary conditions for a particular cause..." and "...are indeed a cause...", it rejects the possibilities that (a) there may be other, currently-unknown, causes; and (b) the current warming trend may be part of a larger climate cycle. By doing so, you are now able to conclude that past is not prologue and promote your hypothesis that "anthropologically produced atmospheric compounds" are the [u]only[/u] possible cause of global warming.

[b]Fact[/b] Natural causes account for 99.72% of the greenhouse effect, reducing the possible human contribution to about 0.28%, an essentially negligible amount. Water vapor alone accounts for about 95% of the greenhouse effect. http://www.geocraft.com/WVFossils/greenhouse_data.html

We have no control over more than 99% of the known contributors to the greenhouse effect. How, then, are our actions to eliminate or reduce our contribution to greenhouse gases going to affect the outcome?

Edit: found some missing years...

by tonythetiger

[i]it cannot be concluded that anthropologically produced atmospheric compounds are a cause of such.[/i]

but that's not what I said. What I WOULD have said is: "it cannot be concluded that anthropologically produced atmospheric compounds are THE ONLY POSSIBLE cause of such".

Do you see the difference?

by Member 25348569

in this case, anyway.

What intrigues me about the discussion of the cause of the change in the earth's climate is why you all persist in using past measurements in an attempt to "disprove" or, for that matter, "prove" climate change.

The current situation is unique. In the Earth's entire history there has never been a time when the rate of change of CO2 has been so fast without there being an incident of catastrophic volcanism. That is always accompanied by the cooling effects of SO2 aerosols and ash.

Given "normal" changes in the Earth's temperature, the CO2 [b]follows[/b] the rise in temperature. This time, it's leading because it's totally anomalous in its origin.

The CO2 is in the atmosphere. Undeniable. Ignore it at your peril.

Neil :)

Nick, I'm puzzled about the solar Wind graph - what is it meant to show? It only goes up to 1990 and the SW dips while the temperature continues to rise (along with the CO2).

The Holocene Maximum was just another manifestation of the Milankovitch Cycles but of course no climate scientists has ever heard of them.

I could go on but my forehead is starting to make a dent in the wall...

by nicknielsen

[i]The current situation is unique. In the Earth's entire history there has never been a time when the rate of change of CO2 has been so fast without there being an incident of catastrophic volcanism. That is always accompanied by the cooling effects of SO2 aerosols and ash.[/i]

What evidence is there that this situation is unique? Although CO2-bearing strata can be related to a period of time, there is no daily record of CO2 levels from centuries or millennia past. It's no stretch to speculate that CO2 levels spike at the end of each warming cycle, but we just haven't found the evidence for it.

Call it misdirection, call it argument from ignorance, call it what you like. I've not been shown convincing evidence that global warming is solely anthropogenic and continue to find evidence that the warming is simply part of a recurring cycle. The only convincing evidence associated with this subject that I've seen is that there are zealots on both sides.

by Member 25348569

I would have thought that it's pretty obvious. We have found no fossil record of any comparable civilisation of, say, intelligent dinosaurs. There is no other way to get the quantities of CO2 at the rate that it is being released without the sort of targeted extraction and burning that Man is doing.

As for "I've not been shown convincing evidence", a couple of questions. Firstly, what would be "convincing evidence"? What do you want? A smoking gun? Secondly, isn't this important enough for everyone to put some real effort into finding out for themselves? Maybe you believe that you have but the quality of your posted links unfortunately suggest to me that this isn't so.

by nicknielsen

The arrogance that knows humanity is the sole cause of global warming is matched only by the arrogance of the Christian who knows he is saved. Until opposing viewpoints are calmly debated and not shouted down as heresy, I will continue to view this entire flap as no more than a religious exercise for zealots with no other cause. (Not accusing you, Neil, but there are others...)

As I have said before: Is mankind contributing? Of course he is, he's part of the ecosystem? Is mankind the sole contributor? Given the cyclic nature of climate change, the most likely answer is "No." Can we stop or even slow our contribution? Probably not without eliminating significant parts of modern civilization and/or the human race.

by santeewelding

Nick has just raised you.

You do a good conceptual job of staking out planetary status quo -- sin humanity. Now, what do we do about humanity?

by deepsand

None of what you state in any way affects the validity of that set forth by me.

That which happened in the past cannot serve to change that which now occurs.

You, like Toni, appeal to ignorance.

by deepsand

To say that you cannot arrive at a conclusion re. the existence of AGW because "[i]it cannot be concluded that anthropologically produced atmospheric compounds are THE ONLY POSSIBLE cause of such[/i]" is the very esssence of an appeal to ignorance.

One need not [b]disprove[/b] the existence of other possible causes in order to prove that a particular cause is at work; and, the latter has been done.

by deepsand

Again, this is an appeal to ignorance.

Unique or not, such does not suffice to alter the Physics of Spectral Absorption, etal..

That other sources of CO2 may in the past have made significant contributions to Radiative Forcing is wholly irrelevant to the fact that mankind is now a major source of CO2, & immaterial with respect to present Radiative Forcing.

by deepsand

"[i]As I have said before: Is mankind contributing? Of course he is, he's part of the ecosystem? Is mankind the sole contributor?[/i]"

Does it matter? If he is not, his contributions most certainly contribute to the aggregate total. And, it is this total which serves as cause for the final effect.

"[i]Given the cyclic nature of climate change, the most likely answer is "No.""[/i]

This is pure speculation. There is no evidence to suggest that some past cause of such warming is here in play, one that we not only do not understand, but are wholly unaware of. If you are going to posit a repeat of some past cause, then step forth with a specific claim, one that has not already been discredited. Otherwise you continue to do naught but appeal to ignorance.

"[i]Can we stop or even slow our contribution? Probably not without eliminating significant parts of modern civilization and/or the human race.
[/i]"

So, since you believe it inconvenient, we should make no effort, but should simply plunge blindly forward & hope for the best. And, it that later proves unwise, it won't be you who suffers, but you descendants. But, hey, screw them; after all, what have they ever done for you.

by nicknielsen

[i]There is no evidence to suggest that some past cause of such warming is here in play, one that we not only do not understand, but are wholly unaware of. If you are going to posit a repeat of some past cause, then step forth with a specific claim, one that has not already been discredited.[/i]

Your position is that mankind is the sole cause of global warming. In my attempt to show that all such warming cannot be attributed to man, I provide a link to data showing that such warming began 18 millennia before present; you call it discredited and state that it has no bearing, yet provide no evidence of such. I believe your statement that it has no bearing results solely because the data simply does not fit your world view.

It becomes more and more obvious to me that I am once again wasting my time in a religious discussion.

by nicknielsen

[i]So, since you believe it inconvenient, we should make no effort, but should simply plunge blindly forward & hope for the best.[/i]

I don't believe it inconvenient. I believe it impossible absent a return to a hunter-gatherer society and/or massive loss of life.

Now there's an idea. Why don't those so committed to reducing human-caused CO2 take action by ceasing respiration for the remainder of their existence? Just imagine the reduction in CO2 emissions...

by tonythetiger

[i]One need not disprove the existence of other possible causes in order to prove that a particular cause is at work; and, the latter has been done. [/i]

You have to prove other possible causes don't exist before you can claim that yours is the only one!

by tonythetiger

[i]Now there's an idea. Why don't those so committed to reducing human-caused CO2 take action by ceasing respiration for the remainder of their existence? Just imagine the reduction in CO2 emissions... [/i]

I'll bet getting rid of Algore would usher in a new ice age :)

This discussion is closed to new replies.