Discussion Locked

Are you better off now than you were 5 years ago?

0 helpful
301 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

301 replies

by judger48193

I graduated from college in 1966 with honors in Math. I had companies I never talked to offering me jobs by telegram (dated, but just substitute "email"). I had 3 offers to pursue a masters degree while either working full-time and getting full paid or as a teaching assistant. All of the work I did for 20+ years was original and very interesting and of course extremely demanding. I have run projects with budgets in the millions as both a technical contributor or as a technical and/or project manager.

Sounds like I should be all set, right? Wrong! Since 1992 the IT market has gotten terrible and companies very selfish. Yeah, there was a reprieve for year 2000 and the dot-com mess where I too worked for one for an instant. Every company I have worked for since 1993 has been mean-spirited, selfish and frequently financially shacky, even though I worked for some of the largest technical, insurance and hosital companies in Chicago. Many of them just about totally cleared out their IT staffs of sometimes 1000's or dumbed down their highly creative staff.

I still love creative IT work whether it be technical, technical management or project management. But IT ain't fun or lucrative any more. In my eyes, my experience and that of many people I know should be to kill for. Ain't so! Most IT jobs only consider which cert or technology you have and companies do not train. Many IT jobs left in the US resemble technician jobs, sophisticated but still repetitive, configuration-oriented or operational in nature. I am not putting down this needed expertise, however, I wouldn't enter the IT field today if this is what lay ahead. I have seen few of the young, in-demand IT types trained in the latest technologies that have had full life-cycle experience on large challenging projects. The companies where I worked on projects like these have not retained any of the IT staff, used consultants for all of the interesting work or just about went out of business.

I would be cautious if I were advising my family or friends about sticking with IT in the future. This is sad and terrible for the US and our financial welfare.

For years I have been doing many types of low paying, mostly uninteresting jobs. I moved out of the Chicago area where I lived and worked for over 30 years to a much cheaper area of the country. I am fortunate that I may be able to retire, whether I want to or not. This is not an option I would have if I was in the beginning or middle of my IT career with all of the family and financial responsibilities implied. I would be in dispair and financial trouble if I relied on the "new", current IT environment.

by pmanjunk

I have been in the IT field for 28 years. Since Oct. 1976, when I first worked for Honeywell Info. Systems here in downtown Chicago.
Since then I held a few more jobs, each time increasing my pay substantially and climbing in position and responsibility.
I was 'downsized' from a well-paid tech support position in 1990 and suffered difficult times shortly thereafter. Once I was on my feet again I found I would never make the same kind of money again.
My wife and I ran our own retail computer store here in the south suburbs of Chicago. The 'big box' stores limited our sales and pretty much put the writing on the wall. At least we got out and sold the business for a profit.
In 1997 I was hired on as an IT manager for a local non-profit, but here in 2004 was 'downsized' again due to budget woes.
I've sent out hundreds of resumes and networked with groups as well as worked with an outplacement firm to try to find suitable work, but so far haven't.
At 53, I feel that age discrimination has a bit to do with it. Outsourcing to other countries has a bit to do with it. And the economy has a bit to do with it.
It's late and I'm tired. You said it well.
At this time I discourage anyone who asks from seeking a job in the IT field unless they have a clear understanding of what is likely to happen to them.
Regards,
Pete
p.s. Please don't crab about 'keeping up your skillset', etc. I am an MCSE+I and A+ for years, I've read more technical manuals than I ever care to remember, and I have been going to evening classes for most of the past 28+ years. (Including this last semester.)
Sorry if I sound crabby myself. It's late and this subject is a sore one with me. :)

by salamander

I would say better. Financially, I am doing better than five years ago, and that has given me a degree of freedom. There are negatives and tradeoffs, to be sure. I just wish I had learned how to mentally partition the negative stuff off years earlier.

Fortunately, I have been blessed with a supportive boss, decent income, and a great deal of latitude in the performance of my duties. So, I can't but smile when I come home at the end of the day and enjoy the roof over my head.

I have some good friends who have been unemployed for more than a year. I know that the market's tough out there, and I'm very grateful to have what I have. I hope that things pick up again soon for those who are searching.

by judger48193

Sure training is very valuable, but IT has gotten to the stage where only experience in the most current whatever is looked at. Seems like you will never get off of the cert-go-round if that is your strategy for IT success.

Technical knowledge, as refelected by a long list of certs, shouldn't be the only measure of the value of an employee. If a company wants specific technical knowledge, capable IT staff should be trained. You cannot train for things like people-skills, performance under fire and the big picture view gained by years of experience and challenging projects.

Companies are placing the responsibility and cost for acquiring technical skills on the employees. Employees shouldn't have to guess at what technical direction will be needed and of value to a company. Frequently we have to make these choices before we are even considered for hire. Technologies are changing very rapidly. I always believed that a mutual respect and everybody with skin in the game is needed to have a productive and mutually beneficial employer/employee environment.

by apotheon

You don't even have anything credible to say. Why are you here? Do you just like flame wars?

The fact that you're scamming people when you tell them you're an IT professional doesn't make the entire field a scam.

by apotheon

"no one was born an IT expert"

. . . except me. Heh. I'm a third-generation computer geek.

by zyphlar

the only thing a+ and mcsa have done for me (at age 19) have been to put an eye-catching abbreviation to the skills i've gained myself.

then again, for anyone who doesn't have the time to pick up skills by themselves, certification programs are pretty good ways to learn the basics.

by markguer9

5 years ago (with 3 years of experience then) I was a sole admin of a network. 5 years later After layoff 2 years I've moved to larger shop, with more responsibility and a 45% pay increase.

I'd say times are better.

by f22

I worked for a small software company for six years as desktop support. Have a BS degree and got my cert MCSA/MCSE 2000 and it made no difference. Realizing that I was going nowhere in the company, I started seriously looking for a new job for over 2 years more in the system administrator position.

Through a recruiter I was able to land a job within a large company but doing 3rd shift system operations.

This has provided me a large pay raise and benefits, it has caused havoc within my family life and not to mention my sleep schedule.

Although, I went into this thing with my eyes wide open, I have found that working nights is not what it's cracked up to be (at least for me).

However, I have been told that the company wants to do 24 X 7 schedule and I have been offered 2nd shift, but as of yet it has been well over 3 months, and the company has yet to interview any replacements. Something always comes up with them having no time to do the interviews.

Although I am greatful for the opportunity, my desire is to increase my skill set by getting my hands dirty doing real admin work rather than the "same thing" different day.

Bottom line is, continue to study, prove yourself where you can and either go for it, or move on.

by (nor) it-consultant

5 years ago I worked as an IT-Supervisor up in the north of my country, making my pupils pass MCSE. I had about $40k then (higher expenses, higher salaries).
Quitted the job and moved to the Capitol and worked as an IT-Consultant and earned $50k (even higher expenses). This was just after Y2k and most companies didn't need so much IT-services as before Y2k, so I moved within a year. Now I'm working in a hospital as an IT-Consultant, we're 2 workers which replace and move computer equipment, maintain network and servers and helps user in a helpdesk. We have 400 computers and approx 1000 users. And now I earn $43k again. It's twice the amount of work as when I earned $50k. And the salaries have in general raised with $4k since 1999. With all the work and responsibility in this work, making systems go 24/7, I rather be a janitor and earn $34k

by robdew

Maybe if you learned how to speak/spell in a professional manner things would go easier for you.

I see way to many people in the IT business with this lack of "basic" skills.

Or

Is English your second language?

by strikeleader

Age discrimination my be illegal, but is very hard to prove. I think the sad thing is most employers would hire older more experienced people, but the cost of healthcare insurance keeps them from it.

by vltiii

I agree that age discrimination is hard to prove just as any other type of discrimination, bar blatant acts. The previous poster indicated that he was told (in private) that his age was an issue. In that case they have basically admitted the discrimination. I also agree that most employers would prefer older experienced people. I don't know about the healthcare issue, but then again, being retired military I only pay $230 yr and don't use the coverage offered by the company I work for. Actually, my company offers a supplement to my military coverage at no cost to me which is really nice. The only coverage I accepted from my company is dental and vision care and as I post this I realize I can probably drop the vision care since it's covered under my military benefits. Of course I realize that I'm in a special category compared to civilians that have no military benefits.

by givemeabreak

I worked in Textiles as a Network/Systems Engineer before I had the MBA. The reason for the MBA was because company management required it before they would promote up to the executive level (I was offered the Director of I.T. position (a fast-track position, the VP of IT was ready to retire)but I HAD to have the MBA). Unless you have been living in a barrel (or cave, take your pick)you know that the American Textile industry is DEAD. With it went my future. I had alot of good executive-level contacts in the textile industry and with the MBA I became a rather hot property in the industry. The MBA helped me to judge when to get out of the textile business, I left the company and two months later the entire company (2000+ employees) ceased operations. I took a position with a local governmental utility as the Mgr. of IT because I THOUGHT it would be stable and secure (I have small children). I planned to stay long enough to find a better position and the pay was not but a few bucks less than I was making. Well, that was 6 years ago. I have applied for Director and Manager level positions while keeping my skills as sharp as possible. In the meantime, I and the rest of the entity where I work have been under a wage freeze for the past 5 years. People I used to manage at my old company are making more than I am. Most companies in my area promote from within. But the reason for the MCSE is because the Director and Manager positions have all stated that a MCSE is required and a CCNA is preferred. Forget networking here. I tried to start a monthly IT conference to allow the local IT people to network here and maybe make some good contacts. The first meeting there were 12 people out of the 100+ invited. The next meeting there was 20, the next there were 10. PeopCompetition is very tough in this geographical area and you have to have a leg up on the competition to even get an interview.

by vltiii

I think competition is tough industry wide. This in my opinion is why networking is so critical, but even networking will only get us noticed. Remaining marketable is an ongoing process that doesn't stop once we're hired into a position. Being proficient in one position does not mean that we're good candidates to be promoted into positions of higher responsibility. Politics as much as I don't like them play a critical role in our career successes.

by vltiii

I've noticed a trend in the threads that I follow, whenever things don't go the way the poster wants them to, it's the Republicans fault. What ever happened to personal responsibility? I think this instant gratification society we live in now gives some a false sense of self worth. There are jobs out there, some high paying if you're motivated by profit, but we need to ensure that we're marketable. If you think because you have a certain skill you should have a job you're doomed to continue blaming the Republicans. The free market will decide what skills are required and employers resond by hiring who they think will yield the best bottom line for their organization.

by momtojustin

You said it very well. It is easy to blame the other guy or some big nameless entity, such as a politcial party.

The free market system (with all its flaws, still the best system in the world), depends upon a workforce that will take the PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY to see that they are marketable.

There will ALWAYS be highs and lows in a free market economy, people. It's the nature of the beast. It is up to us, the workers, to stop whining and work. Don't look to the gov't for help!!! It is up to YOU. It's NOT the gov't's job to help you! Nowhere in the Constitution are there guarantees of a job or any job security.

Renee, a committed Libertarian (who is currently unemployed)

by thedanc

I did a paper on H1-B during my MSCS program since my industry is so full of this. While this is largely a Republican led idea, the Democrats are hardly blameless. Here's an excerpt, based on the congressional record/Library of Congress:

Senate Bill S.2045, the "American Competitiveness in the Twenty-First Century Act," combined with House of Representatives Bill H.R.5362, an Act to increase the fees charged to employers who petition to employ H-1B nonimmigrant workers was signed into law by President Bill Clinton on October 17, 2000. Senate Bill S.2045 officially increased the H1-B cap to 195,000 each (up from 60,000) for fiscal years 2001, 2002, and 2003. Senate Bill S.2045 was sponsored by Senator Orrin G. Hatch [R,UT] (introduced 2/9/2000) and was cosponsored by 24 other senators. Of the 24 senators, all were Republican with the exception of three Democrats: Senator Joseph I. Lieberman [D-CT], Senator Dianne Feinstein [D-CA], and, former 2005 Vice-Presidential hopeful, Senator John Edwards [D-NC]

The three Dems are from strong IT communities. As immigrants go, these Indians are hard not to like. They are here legally, they come with degrees, and most of the ones I know work very hard and contribute greatly to the economy. If we don't hire them, other nations will and we as a country will no longer be a technical superpower.

I too have been in the computer biz since the 1980's and was quite spoiled by the lack of competitition for my job. So far, I remain competitive and my salary keeps climbing, but I keep saving and investing knowing that as good as I think I am I can always be laid off. That keeps me working hard and staying competitive through new degree programs and certs. You have to love IT as a lifestyle, otherwise you will be miserable, your work will suffer, and you will be quickly replaced.

by givemeabreak

I work for a governmental body. They never have layoffs and it is hard to get fired. What we do is make crap up to get people to resign when we have too many people. Our HR department is the Secret Police for management. I have seen it happen to two good people and heard about it happening to scores of others. The first was accused of having porn on his PC. The purported porn was a picture of a hopeful girlfriend in a sheer shirt that he received in an email and a humorous picture that didn't really show anything. He was allowed to resign but not without a stern warning not to discuss the matter with anyone.
The second guy was accused of slacking off. His job involved doing work that others in his area were incapable of doing. He was very good. They built a huge file on this guy that would never have held up in court. Most of it was built on estimates of how long it should have taken him to do the work by people who did'nt know how to do the work or what was involved. They also accused him of staying gone too long on lunch (they had pictures of him coming and going, we don't use time clocks) on at least 3 occasions. He also was allowed to resign, but given a strong warning not to discuss the matter with anyone.

None of these positions have ever been filled.

Did I also mention that for 5 years we were and continue to be under a wage and hiring freeze? Yet the head of our division got a great BIG fat Bonus and RAISE every one of those 5 years. His bonus was more than I make and I'm a middle manager!

Stable? Secure? Not really.

by vltiii

Job hopping is one option, but the more technologically savvy you are, the better equipped you are to sell the company you work for on technology. Historically, companies that resist advances in technology end up playing catchup which can be costly if not terminal.

by robdew

If it's not too late for you to go back to school get out of IT. It's a losing proposition. The promise is gone. Unless you live in India.

Find a job you love doing or that you would do (for free) in your spare time and you'll never work a day in your life. It may not pay the best (or it might) but you'll always be happy. What are your hobbies?

by bospgmr

While laid-off for 6 months last year I took the severance education $ and prepaired for and obtained My USCG 50GT Masters/Captain license. If I eventually start driving a tug boat or cummuter ferry around Boston harbor I'll have a few less bucks to spend but I'll have a smile on my face. I'm much more proud of being called "Captain" than "Systems Analyst" or "Sr. P/A" ..

Happy Sailing !!

by vltiii

I think one of the fatal errors that are made is that a lot of people count on their experience to carry them. There is much more to being able to get and hold a job than experience. In fact I would say that experience is probably not even the strongest factor is some hiring. These days there are plenty of employers that are willing to allow a new hire grow into their position (gain experience on the job). This I believe is true in any industry, not just IT.

by vltiii

It's never too late to go back to school. I understand in your current situation you probably can't afford it, but I recommend you do a little research. The government for starters has many not very well known programs that can be put to good use. Since you have internet access do some searching. You may be able to find something within the government (or elsewhere) to ease your family's discomfort/worries, even if only a little.

by packratt

Indeed, I would go back to college if it were an option... Not just because this career choice is no longer sufficient to support my family, but also because I'm having trouble seeing the worth or value of doing what I do in the larger scheme of things.

The problem is not just the cost of tuition itself but the cost in terms of time away from work while retraining and that since my wife has health problems she relies on me to help her when I'm "home". (I keep resisting calling the hotel room "home, sorry).

For right now, going into a different line of work just isn't an option unfortunately. Thank you for the suggestion though.

by bospgmr

While laid-off for 6 months last year I took the severance education $ and prepaired for and obtained My USCG 50GT Masters/Captain license. If I eventually start driving a tug boat or cummuter ferry around Boston harbor I'll have a few less bucks to spend but I'll have a smile on my face. I'm much more proud of being called "Captain" than "Systems Analyst" or "Sr. P/A" ..

Happy Sailing !!

by jamesrl

Was a government agency.

They laid off 25% of the IT department. I had done some layoffs of some of my staff the previous year. Oh and firings were not uncommon - for cause.

In Canada in the 90s, there were massive layoffs in the Federal Public Service. It was reduced by about 15%.

So its not so simple.

James

by jennyn

Yes, it was a total bubble - when young kids with nothing behind them at all except they were a bit nifty with a computer, could be in 40hr/wk contracts at $40 an hour and call themselves "Engineers". (Sorry all you PC Support "Engineers" out there but that never really flew... ask an engineer!)

I was earning about 120k then in financial sector in 2000 and 34k now in the nonprofit sector - so apples & oranges to compare it. ...but I did know the good times wouldn't last and left of my own accord just before the bubble burst.

I made the most of the money while it was on offer, invested it in my future, then took time off to travel, but never upgraded my lifestyle.

So now at 40 I have a very rewarding job, and some security put aside for when the youngsters boot me off the field.

To be honest, I had my first wakeup call in the first months of my first IT job in '88. I was lowly 23yr old PC support person, and I watched a team of 30 high paid experienced mainframe techs & cobol programmers, (mainly in their 40's & 50's with mortgages etc) get "outsourced" and within two months made redundant (the outsourcing step was a way to reduce their benefits from the company).

I knew then to never get too cosy or too dependent on this career, and have always had a fall back position for when I want to get out or am forced out of IT.

It's a bubble bath.

by worm22

I went from about $60k/year (no degree) to broke. now I can (barely) make ends meet most of the time with independant contracts. I happen to have more certs than most ppl in their right mind would even try for (at least 12 field related).

better than 2000? only slightly.

by sabbie

You ask if I am better off? In 2000 I graduated with my BS in IT and could not find an IT job and decided to do MSc in 2001. In 2002 I landed my first IT job, Technology Director. I was brought in to technically enable two catholic schools that were up for re-accreditation and needed to have the schools wired. In 18 months, I built two computer labs with wireless technology, and Ethernet cabling (of course), wired classrooms with four to five computers, researched and wrote for grants, participated in government programs that gave away old computers on which I installed windows 2000, through another government program I got a Dell Advantage server and installed windows server 2000. Also, I built two libraries; catalogued the old books (using Microsoft Access and Excel), discarded the really old books, participated in government programs to acquire books, coordinated a small network of librarians who donated books, worked with the oblates missionaries to received books nationwide from other catholic schools and created vendor relationships with Follet (who finally gave me a 40% discount on its automated circulation system for the school) and installed computers in both libraries. By the time January 2004 came around, both schools were ready and passed its re-accreditation visits receiving high marks for its technology and libraries. This I did for two middle schools. (All this was accomplished because I had three fulltime workers and a eight student workers from the local Catholic University).

February 2004, the school laid off my technician, said they were having budget problems, believe me, the only costs the schools incurred were the salaries of myself and the three workers.

[All of the software came from various vendors like, Microsoft?s fresh start program, and other government programs. Hardware came from government programs and other private sources.]

Mid February 2004, while checking an email sent to me from my undergrad school regarding their upcoming job fair, I found the schools I worked for had posted my job. When I asked why, I was told that they could not continue to pay my salary. Having completed my MSc in IT in 2003, they felt that I would want more money than they could pay Also, since, now that the labs and library is set up they would only need someone part time to maintain the network. I said okay and left the next month on a contract job.

So now I am looking and no one is hiring me. I made a decision to go back and get a second Masters, this time in Accounting. I know that I will always have a job and I think that my IT experience would compliment the Accounting degree.

Am I better off? I don?t know?I never had a chance?..

by 33prism33

They're offshoring accounting jobs, too. Rajji will work for about 10% that you will and has a MBA.

by 33prism33

Why the hell should I believe this stuff from those asshats now? Every month they lie about so called "job creation" and it's my belief that unemployment. Feh. May Pakistan and India nuke each other.

by tony hopkinson

In a couple of years time some management type will decide, that if they distributed the centralized IT function, it will be a lot more pro-active and they'll be able to cut the numbers. They usually leave it just long enough, so the rest of this business has just started coping with the previous round.
Logical conclusion is the MD's nephew who once did a wonderful spreadsheet, a mobile and a cheap car.

by tony hopkinson

Not that much better over here I'm afraid. More than a few graduates (though mainly in media studies for some reason) scratching about in the UK. I'm in work, though not contentedly, enormous amount of esperience but no qualifications, may be we should amalgamate our cv's. One last point if you become succcessful in law you'll be earning so much money you'd only come back to IT if you developed a serious case of morals.

by hardknocks

Believing the "liberal left" is behind a policy that benefits, to quote you: "The ONLY person who benefit from Off-Shoring are the corporate Sr. executives and financers who get huge bonuses for improving their bottom lines.", is a HUGE MISTAKE.
This "stinking thinking" is why the resistance to these trends is failing. According to your own statement you understand the perpetrators of the "global economy" movement are the top execs of the fortune 500. These people are certainly REPUBLICANS.
Think about this, I really don't mean to anger you. I hope more people begin to understand the problem.
The "liberal left" is the only hope we workers have but we have to get their attention and make them understand they are making a mistake by trying to be "more like Republicans" in order to get the votes.
I too, am totally disgusted by the way we have been sold out but don't misplace the blame. Admit it when your party has sold you out. Both parties have sold us all out, help to change that.
We need to support a new "American" party that TELLS THE TRUTH.
THE TRUTH WILL MAKE US FREE AGAIN, but it's not pretty and hard for people to admit they have been fooled.
H. Ross Perot tried to tell us but no one would listen.

Reality bytes,

John Coleman

by vltiii

We can't expect any party to tell the truth when we don't want to know the truth, especially when it would mean that we would have to abandon our own beliefs of what the real source of the problem(s) are. To say that top executives are "certainly Republicans" is clearly an outright false statement. There are just as many Democrats that are senior executives (if not more) as there are Republican. Don't confuse financial success with party affiliation, there is no direct correlation between the two doesn't. If your premise were true that would make hollywood a Republican safe haven and anyone that is capable of breathing on their own know that is no true. The truth will set us free, but we have to be willing to accept the truth for what it is and not what we want it to be.

by pmanjunk

Really, now. Since at least early last century the republican party has been known as the party of the rich, by the rich, and for the rich. And yes, there are many more republicans at the heads of companies than democrats.

Of course, there are many democrats in those positions, too, but your reference to 'Hollywood' is almost ludicrous. Hollywood is a drop in the bucket when it comes to corporate wealth.

On another note, I do not support NAFTA. I have written my senator (Durbin) requesting a repeal of NAFTA.

Many thought it was a grand idea at the time. Although many objected and warned us of problems, it passed under the Clinton administration.
Now many believe it has shown not to work and it is time to repeal it.

I also believe H1b visa's are an enormous problem for our country and need to be curbed dramatically.

I'm trying to do my part.
Regards,
Pete

by vltiii

Don't give up on this. Continue to press the issue with the emergency rooms, doctors, media if appropriate, your elected representatives, etc. I actually thought that emergency rooms were required by law to treat anyone that comes in. Perhaps that's only here in California. In any case there must be a solution, especially if your wife's condition is as serious as you indicated.

by packratt

First, like I said, a lot of the issue isn't even the problems with being uninsured and the loopholes involved there but the fact that we're on financial thin ice and any interuption to the paychecks will be devastating. There were days my family didn't eat when I was in between contracts last year, I don't want to see that happen again.

But, as far as what happens... ER rooms are required to examine and treat anyone who seeks treatment, but that treatment is at the doctor's discretion as to whether or not it's something that is sufficiently critical to require admittance to the hospital or can be defered to a GP or family doctor for further tests and treatment instead.

The crack in the net is thus, if the condition is not critical enough to require immediate attention all they have to do is look at you, advise you to make an appointment with your doctor, and send you on your way with a perscription or whatever have you.

Eventually we'll figure something out, either that or eventually it will be critical and the issue will be forced.. It's just frustrating that she has to endure treatable pain needlessly in the interim.

*added after post:
Oh, and yes, I have been in contact with several people including the media, was in a few papers and a televised interview with an international news org.

I'm not one to lay down and play dead.

by piratetoolz

I agree. Too bad the folks that run the business units don't feel the same way. As for trade journals, they certianly help, but there is no substitute for actually working with the technology.

by vltiii

I'm not sure I agree with your assessment of nursing not having to continuously chase certs. Nurses are licensed professionals that must remain proficient in their trade to keep their license. They may not have to do so as often as an IT professional, but it does have to be done. There are advances in medicine as well as medical procedures all the time. There also are varying levels within the nurses profession, LVN, RN, emergency room nurse, surgical nurse, specialty nurses, etc, just to name a few.

by sdhanraj

Nursing is a field with diminishing returns in terms of salary with regards to educational effort.

Advancing in anything medically related takes time in education (years) to advance. IT was just as long as eg. MCSE cert.. Definite advantage for IT. So market was innundated with paper certs. Now you get a handle on that by demanding a certain years of experience. So IT was commoditized.

Nursing for STARTERS with an ASSOCIATE (2yrs) (yes bar was lowered from RN degress 4yrs due to shortage) will command 50-60k. That's the hook to get you in the profession. Continue your education and the pay increase is less per effort. Nurses don't have to assimilate NEARLY as much information as IT professionals because the field is handicapped by legalities/restrictions. In other words, just be a medical waitress and do your procedural and legal tasks and you can keep your job. There is no pressure to constantly upgrade your knowledge base or specialize.

KNOW your function and you are paid for that. That's your proficiency.

You've mentioned specialities and you never have to venture into specialities to keep a nursing job. Also with anything that commands more money, there is more to learn. That is an option in nursing but the norm in IT. In IT, you don't know, then bye, bye.

Hint for nursing - Get basic licensing ASSOCIATE and then do loads of overtime and I guarantee that you will make more than the specialities with less worries than they do.

There is no modesty in medicine and the pathogens, body fluids, pew de toilette are the trade offs. Big trade off.

I work with nurses and I am just amazed at the state of deficiency in proficiency that commands that type of salary.

I know loads of nurses (work alongside them) that don't really know anything about medicine, just their function, and making 50-60k. While my knowledge is more expansive and always cutting edge in regards to the next new treatment. (Hmm sounds like the IT attidude in medicine..hmmm)

Also nursing has had the stability during a downturn in the economy. IT got killed. Stability, you can't put a price on that.

I care too much for people to just do a job for money especially medicine. I work with nurses and they tell me "don't do it". But I know that most people that are going into nursing are doing it for the money.

You don't have to specialize to make the big bucks, just do the overtime. The knowledge base is more legacy based than cutting edge.

What so you say to Phd's and physicists making less than nurses?? I guess it is the same as people complaining that NBA players make so much.

by jdclyde

Your shop can't do jobs fixing warrenty work if you aren't certified for that hardware.

It means a lot on a shop sign to say they have Certified Technicians.

Means a lot more to non-techs to know you had some formal acknowledgement of your abilities as well.

Yes, I know people that benefit greatly from Certs.

I also got a big increase in my last raise because of getting Certs.

I am also working on my next Cert.

by jdclyde

When you have a government that is taxing companies heavily, you have a government that is chasing away jobs.

Look at Virginia, high tech is booming because the state isn't leaching them dry, compaired to other states.

When a company does half it's business overseas but is based in the US, it pays taxes on ALL earnings. If that same business sets up a small office off shore and calls it the home office they only pay taxes on the revenue made in the US.

Some people will whine that they aren't paying their fair share if they aren't paying taxes on every dollar earned. They pay wages to people who live in towns. They need to buy stuff to live so the town thrives because there is someone with a job spending their money there.

When other countries aren't paying as high a wage and don't have to meet the same eco standards (not talking about you Canada) they can produce for much less.

by tony hopkinson

When other countries aren't paying as high a wage and don't have to meet the same eco standards they can produce for much less.

Are you saying as soon as America signs up to some world eco standards things are going to be even worse. ? Or has some massive reversal in US policy skipped my attention.

Last I heard the policy on this was "You can keep the environment clean if you want, we are going to make a bigger profit when you do.". Saw Dick Chaney say that on CNN so it must be true.

The argument against global warming was even better. "If there is such a thing it would cost us a lot of money, so there isn't".

I'll admit the chap who provided the paraphrase of the argument against global warming was firmly in the other camp, but he was there at the time.

I have some vague memory of the anti camp's presentation, but their position is stupid.

If there isn't such a thing and everybody acts as though there is we get a cleaner world and no warming if we happen to be wrong.

If there is such a thing and we act as if there isn't, we exacerbate the problem, end up with a world wide ecological disaster that will cost billions. And we still haven't stopped adding to the problem, unless of course this industry is now under water.

Right risk asessment time.

by momhodge

I am currently working at a job that I enjoy. So I consider myself fortunate in that respect.
But I am doing so at 25% less pay than I was making during the boom years.
The job opportunities of the past are gone and with them so has the $.

by g.m.bakker (cne, self employed)

5 years ago I was helpdesk guy and network admin for Dutch government full time. I started working part time and started my own IT company. I fill in the gap that the box movers leave, doing support on various computer configs for companies and privately owned systems. Dell sells computers, but caters crappy support, so that's my field. I also sell computers built to customer specs and also do turn key projects. It's a niche market that can go everywhere, and currently it's climbing. Thanks to all the box movers. Selling hardware is profitless, selling support, that's something thats going somewhere!
So to be more on the subject side, a change in trade keeps you humming and in business!

by rrainsbe

.. is my reaction when I hear IT types look to accounting as a good career move. As an accountant I will grant that the two areas are extremely compatible. However, whose jobs do you think those were that were being replaced by productivity gains due to tech advances of the last 6-8 years? And now they are just as likely to be outsourced overseas as IT jobs. Salaries have fallen, jobs are harder to come by without very specific skills such as SarBox or IT auditing. Claims you see in the press to the contrary are, I suspect, largely due to press releases from the AICPA.

by rocky5689

I dont think that we are better of then 5 years ago. salaries are dropping for It JOBS . In my case I am going backwards , used to to be network admin and now I am doing help desk.

by holg555

From reading all the replies about Certs I was wondering which Certs are the most desired and sought after? I know of many people who have gotten CISCO certifications MCSE's etc. and were having trouble landing a job for lack of experience within that specialisation? I too want to keep up with times but with so many certification available which one to choose?

by vltiii

What you've described here is someone whose motivation, ambitions, etc, can't possibly get any lower. Of course they may be able to get by with the least effort. I personally think that is also true in the IT industry. I also can't imagine that anyone who has so little interest in bettering themselves would be interested in putting in overtime. I'll agree that advancing oneself doesn't guarantee professional advancement, but it certainly puts you in a better position. If the only concern is whether big bucks can be made, then I think that mindset is probably part of the problem.

by vltiii

I agree, and as a result you're probably better prepared to set yourself up for success. I think too many that were around during the dot com boom are expecting those days to return. It's unlikely they will. Career planning is the key and there is more to that than getting a cert, completing a degree program, etc.

by j-lepore

5 years ago I was laid off as IT Manager for a small manufacturing company. After 18 months of unemployment I took a retail sales job with a nationwide electronic retailer. I'm still there earning min. wage plus commission. My earnings have dropped more than 85% and I see little hope of ever getting back to IT unless I return for an advanced degree or move to Bangalore. Past age 55 I see no payback to more schooling.

by j-lepore

5 years ago I was laid off as IT Manager for a small manufacturing company. After 18 months of unemployment I took a retail sales job with a nationwide electronic retailer. I'm still there earning min. wage plus commission. My earnings have dropped more than 85% and I see little hope of ever getting back to IT unless I return for an advanced degree or move to Bangalore. Past age 55 I see no payback to more schooling. Had I to do it all over again, I'd have selected a different career than IT.

by yelesom

I share the view of most of you in that IT isn't lucrative as it once was. 5 yrs ago I was now finishing my BSc, blinded by the hope of a successfully career in IT I pursued a graduate degree in the same field. Now I find my self in a Jack of all job (which is a good thing as that is prob how you will have to be if you are to succeed in IT now) but making a rather lousey salary. So yes if i had to do it again I would choose another career.

by vltiii

I think that mindset plays a part in someone not being desirable after age 50. Intentional or not those individuals send a mesaage about themselves. There are plenty of people that maintain professional careers and retire when they choose as opposed to being forced to do so. Clearly, being unhirable is a falacy created most likely by those that can't effectively market themselves.

by Member 19753669

Let's see... about a 68% increase in the past 5 years, to answer you question. I've scanned through this discussion, and found it similar to many others on this topic in the past; it sounds like a lot of people expect too much in very little time and think book-learning in itself qualifies them for great things.

I have been in IT for about 18 years, after receiving a PC repair cert at 30, which was fairly worthless. I took the A+ cert exam and passed with 98% in the late 90's, then I went back to school and earned an AA (Business Admin) in my mid-40's. I have no other certifications, but what I do have is hands-on experience, superior troubleshooting skills, and common sense. These things you cannot learn in school.

That is why I have been with the same company nearly 10 years, enjoy a position as a global Windows network administrator, and earn a salary in the upper 60's.

One should never stop learning, but concentrate on things that will actually be of benefit, rather than simply chasing after certifications, half of which you may never use. I struggled early on, just like many of you, but intelligence and persistence will lead to the real experience necessary to succeed.

by cloudedyoda

I would rate you situation as one of the success stories. There are many other areas of IT that cannot offer the same success that you get, in terms of money and promotion posibilities. Some, like development is oversaturated and we can't deny that the software development scene move faster than any other areas. Before one can respond, there are new programming languages around and certification is the only way to re-skill.

by magic-g

Yep, you got it right. I just got done reading all this whining about big salaries lost. if you look at history, the steel workers, the rubber workers, some auto workers, shoemakers, TV manufacturers, etc., and the list goes on all went through this job pain and/or loss. IT workers were taking businesses to the cleaners in many areas and now things are finding their proper levels... It's called life. Get over it..

by wendyb_09

I lost my IT job as in desktop support/training over three years ago. I'm battling rampent overseas outsourcing and the cert requirements. If you don't have a cert, very few are willing to sponsor you, although one scam offered to find me financing for $12K of training in certs I'd never heard of.

I've run through most of my financial resources and have been working as a paralegal or admin assistant part time trying to string together enough to keep a roof over my head. One of the admin jobs offered full time last week a fraction of what I had hoped to get. But at least I have a job. Probably will not be able to afford to get back into IT this late in life, and will never be able to recoup my lost savings.

good luck to everyone out there!

by vltiii

Amen! I couldn't have said it better, even though I do find myself falling into the same arrogant traps you speak of from time to time.

by etan

I'm not in healthcare anymore but do keep my nose in it because my neighbor is a charge nurse for a hospital.

Here are some articles on nursing shortage:
http://tinyurl.com/4hnu4
http://www.mc.vanderbilt.edu/reporter/?ID=2121
http://tinyurl.com6om3n
http://www.acn.nche.edu/media/Backgrounders/shortagefacts.htm
http://bhpr.hrsa.gov/nursing/shortage.htm

Somewhere I read that NY city was short 10,000 nurses while Florida was similar or higher.

I'm now a network admin and have taken a 60% pay cut in the past 5 years. We were on full time but now on 90% time. At one time we were at 80% time. So now I work 50 hours a week to keep the network up but cannot complain. Lucky to have the job that I love. We barely make ends meet, sometimes borrowing money from bank's LOC to pay for wife's re-education. She's going into dentistry. Can't wait until we start paying $30,000 a year in tuition! That's almost what I take home now. Wonder how we can afford that? Sell the house, I guess.

I know a network admin who moved to a small retirement town in Arizona, setup shop as ISP and does computer repairs for retirees. He's making a killing. Wish I had the same fortitude but at 48 I now tend to be more cautious.

So am I better off than 5 years ago? Definitely not.

by vanight

Highschool degree, MCP 2000 and A+, about 10 years in the industry experience. Was laid off for about a year and now working for a much smaller company for 10K less a year (mid 40s) than I was 5 years ago. Money is tight but I am by no means any less "happy" because money has NOTHING to do with happiness. That I have tested, retested, seen by example and am convinced of.

Later!

David

by oliverllc

At the height of the dot-com boom I was making 175K/year as an IT contractor. Subsequently, my hourly rate took a 40% drop, then the contract market in my area totally dried up. My only option was making a 60-70K/yr salary with an hour+ commute each way and a lot of free overtime. I did some soul searching as far as my interests/abilities/etc. and ended up taking a job as a County property tax appraiser 3 years ago. I love it! It will take me about 2-3 more years to get to the 60K salary I passed up BUT I have job security, a pension, no commute, no free overtime, and I like the work more that I liked IT work. The downside is that my wife now has to work, which she did not before. We don't spend money like we used to but that's OK too. There's a lot to be said for peace of mind. One of the things I like about my new field is that your skills don't become outdated overnight. Aaaaaaaaah; this is what a normal work-life feels like. I'm loving it!

by oliverllc

I'm in Southern California and I've witnessed a huge drop in IT contract rates as well as job opportunities. It seems that the most active sector in the IT job market is government contract work. I don't think our area took quite the hit that some areas did due to the large military presence and the government contract work.

by jdclyde

What skills are wanted in your area? Did you check at all or did someone come up to you and tell you if you get certified through them you make X amount of money?

Need to have the right Cert for the right job.

Your Cert would not get you hired where I am because there is NO NEED for that skill here.

Don't blame the Certs because you didn't have someone hand you a job.

There are many cases where the Cert makes a big difference.

by vltiii

The fact that the Republican party has been known as the party of the rich doesn't change anything I said in my post. As I stated in my response it's easy to accept that position if not doing so challenges your own beliefs.

by donweinstein

In my case things are much worse. I've been laid off from my network postion at IBM for 8 months now, still unable to find work. IBM was in mood to get pinpoint experts in tiny fields to do consulting work. I'm very embittered. The entire IT industry is tanking, with outsourcing, consulting, long Dilbert hours, and exhaustion, I'm fed up with it.

by sysengineer

I am relativly new to the I.T. field (only about 4 months) and more than once I have found myself already re-thinking my career decision. But then I can not think of anything else that I would rather be doing then working with computers, networks and electronics. I think the place we work has alot to do with the impact on our attitude about the career choice we have chosen. I have friends in different fields that are sometimes equally unhappy, not with their skill set but where they work wether it be Architecture, Accounting or Finance. Everyones situation is different but in the end, our work and what we love to do is what really matters. Hopefully I still feel like this in 5 years.

by zyphlar

You're a 4 month old IT Consultant? Wow, I wish I was that good.

I've been in IT-related jobs for the past 3 years, and I recommend that you keep your options open for at least 2-4 years. Actually, keep your options open for ever. IT isn't for everyone, especially in this global marketplace. Formal experience and training helps. Don't settle for anything less than a bachelor's degree, or you'll be on your ass in a few years.

Also, good luck.

by tx1cajun

The downturn in the economy is directly based on selling out your brother. It doesn't matter what country or what human or inhuman rights that are at stake. Can you talk to your corporate heads and executives and place responsibility at the right place. We as Americans, can compete, but as long as we have both Democratic and Republicans on the big kick back in this country , we will fail.

Our government is for sale for the right bidder and the influence from anywhere other than the US is on the bidding block from both parties, bar none. How can you make a difference, taxes , that is it. Tax the heck out of what comes in and make it more beneficial to do it "here" than there. Make your friendly unaccountable Washington rep on either side of the house...accountable. We at the technical side of the issue, need to broadcast wrong doing, and become accountable ourselves at what levels we are participating in the sell out and stop.

As dangerous as our sell out is, we have to accountable that we are compromising our existence as a free and democratic society. We are leveraging debt into the hands of countries such as China, and as friendly as they might be , the payback is on the horizon.

Free Trade, competition, I believe in it all. But selling out your brother has been bad back into biblical times. The whole country suffers, want to make a difference, stand up and be counted, don't buy into the whole global bit until the globe start cooperating with taxes coming in not tax breaks.

We could begin to educate the next generation for world wide competition, but giving tax breaks to sell our country out used to be treacherous, some levels it is thought to be treason.

Cooperate and gain by business cooperatives but also tax the other countries so that we are even ground and help our own economy and our own children to prosper.

Can I hear from the believers?

by frehen

I am not going to spend more than a few words on this one. At the end of 2001 I suffered some shoulder injury for which I had to have surgery.
The damn IT boss at that time wanted to fire me with a no-good reason, just because he was afraid it would cost him too much. As mentioned by roybrew in this discussion, the dollar (or euro) is more important than the people in this line of business.
So, had surgery in march 2002 and in april i was unemployed. Still am unemployed. With 46 one is to old for this they assume. Still, experience is more valuable than the fresh recrutes they get from high-school nowadays, for they cannot do a simple task... which is not meant to judge the young recrutes, for they have learned more theory than I ever will, but when it comes to practical matters, I think experience is more in place.
From what I've heard IT-compangnies are getting that picture too now. Still I don't believe I ever will be working for a boss in the IT again.
So, as a last resort I am going to start my own business now and hope that that will work out.
Good luck to all!

by zyphlar

i would stay in IT, but continue to expand your abilities and remain flexible.

remain flexible. that's the biggest thing to remember in the open market. don't lock yourself in with an associate technician degree, don't lock your perspective by looking in a certain field in a certain place.

maybe years from now, IT will totally disintegrate. who knows? in the meantime, gain general skills that will help you in any job, and constantly keep your finger on the pulse of the workforce.

don't think there's a magic job out there that you can land and stay secure until retirement. those days are over.

you can whine all you want when your sector gets eliminated, but it's not the government's fault that you don't want to pick yourself up and try something else. (ever thought of becoming a consultant? what about moving to india? some of the best experiences of our lives are the result of something distasteful.)

by zyphlar

at a certain point, sure you're too old for something. it might not be ageism, but something related (like compatibility with the current team). i helped hire a tech support position under me, and we turned down a highly qualified, confident 26 year old for a qualified and eager 18 year old. Why? The position was too small for the guy-- he should be leading teams, not following orders.

I don't want to tell my elders what to do, but i would consider alternatives, like the comment about hiring yourself. Your years of experience could be worth gold in other places, like teaching, training, consulting, etc.

You're definitely more knowledgeable and experienced than me. I believe you can leverage that to your advantage and, with some creativity, come out for the better.

by zyphlar

your consipracy theory regarding training is pretty ignorant. trainers, and by extension training companies, only seek to offer education to those who want it.

it's your own fault if you seek an education for a skill you'll never use. it's only their fault if they offer something and don't fulfill it. no training company will guarantee a skill's relevance in 5 years

IT has become a cutthroat industry because of Moore's law and outsourcing, to be sure. if you can't handle that, it may not be the place for you. but don't cook up a paranoid theory like we're all helpless rats in a maze-- the winners in the industry aren't enemies, they're just flexible, goal-oriented rats like the rest of us.

by nobby57

It still happens. I am not in IT although I tried to enter the field a few years ago. After meeting a lot of fellow graduates and certification holders who were trying to do the same thing -- change careers in midlife by going into IT -- it became painfully obvious that middle aged career changers almost always need not apply.

And not just middle aged entry level people -- one experienced sysadmin I know very well lost his job with a defense contractor five years ago when their gov't contract ran out (he is 50+) and has been unemployed since. This in the DC area where there are a fair number of jobs.

Of course, it's not only IT. Many fields suffer from age discrimination. Nobody talks about it, and never will they say "you're too old" just like they will never say "we don't hire your kind." But it happens every day.

OVERT age discrimination is illegal all right, but there are more subtle methods.

by 69552901-69552901

Younger staff experience the same kind of age discrimination. In my experience, a 20 year old network tech can know her stuff inside and out will probably still not be able to find a job. Of course, if you'll notice I said *her*. I'm in my mid-twenties now and a girl still has troubles finding an IT job in Canada...

by trav62

I'm 43, have no college, and have been in IT since 1999; started part-time as a computer tech building new personal pc systems. (Took about 6k hit to change careers from food-service to IT.) By end of '99 was full-time, in charge of sales, and had A+. 2 years later, changed employers and got about 8k raise (to low 30's) still doing tech work. Obtained network+ earlier this year. This spring got promoted to a network admin with same company and got over $5/hour raise. Now I'm in the process of buying a new house and I can't imagine that things could look much better.

by thestonez

I am about the same financially as 5 years ago, maybe even a little less. My benefits however are superior at my current position, and I work for one of the, if not the most powerful Firm in the world. Couple that with the fact that the market is still tight, and that I was laid off for 8 months prior to this position and I can tell you I am grateful for the opportunities I have had throughout my IT career. That said, I do not regret the move to IT because I came from construction of all things. If I had to do it again, I wouldn't hesitate. Just my $.02

by thedanc

I work for a major software company. The job is ridiculously complex and I work no less than 50 hours per week. My pay has increased over the years, despite the constant export of jobs to India and the influx of H1-B employees. The key to survival starts with a bachelors degree and to that you must add certifications to stay current and most importantly do work within whatever company you work in that distinguishes you favorably. The competition in this field is so harsh that I get migraines now.

Am I better off than I was a year ago? Well, I do make more money. I put at least 30% of it into investments and savings though because so many really good IT jobs (like drago762 found) can disappear even without the fault of the employee and he winds up doing some other IT job for less. It's feast and famine at the same time.

by bg6638

For myself the last 5 years have gone from bad to worse. I was a programmer/sys admin making 50k+/yr working with COBOL on an as400, Foxpro, plus Win2k & Win2k3, Exchange, SQL, ISA Server. That was before my employer went bankrupt. Now, even trying to get an interview is next to impossible!! The state job services and other recruiters just shrug their shoulders. A gal working at the state job services dept had the guts to suggest that I retire!! I'm only in my early fifties (most people think I'm 45). I need to work another 10 years at least!
Would I have chosen IT if I had it to do again? Yes, however I would have gone to a 4yr school instead of a 2yr, plus dual-majored in MIS/Accting. Today, it seems that employers regard an AAB degree as merely an extension of HS, in other words totally useless!! I wish that the 2yr colleges would realise this, and point out to anyone planning to get an AAB degree, *must* continue their education at a 4yr school.
The recruiters seem to be looking for people in their late 20's, bachelor's in IT/MIS, five years exp. working for a mid-sized company, MCSE 2k & 2k3 with messaging & security, CCNA, CCDP, CCVP, CCIE, CISSP, RHCT, RHCE, etc., etc. Plus at least 2-3 well defined job progressions.

by coopster

So, why did we choose the it field? Some of us can't relate to humans, and thats cool.

Most of us did because we're gearheads at heart. We like the challenge of putting things together and make them work, that aren't "supposed to". bg6638 was talking about life in general.

I have an MSEE, am closer to 50 than most think. This in a field where 40 is ancient. What am I doing? I'm actually working on an MBA. I think old age and treachery will win out over youth and skill; But I hedge my bet by keeping abreast, and keeping myself "valuable". Sure, some of you grew up gamers, and have learned that inherent "this is how it works' -not why". But I think those of us that've been around have an understanding of what makes business work. There's your advantage.

My advice for those starting; Learn to be comfortable making presentations. Learn to have a command of the language, and ensure you can comm effectively in writting. True, a BS today is like hi-screwal degree was 20 yrs ago. But look who's in grad school these days. Then we turn an gripe about who gets hired, and where the jobs are going?! These events are not unrelated.

by pickle_316

In the last 5 years I have changed jobs 3 times and none of them by choice. I am currently working as a contract employee without few benefits and no job security. Apparently like everyone else has stated having 9 years experience and a bachelors degree doesn't mean much because everyone want people with certifications and 10 years experience in something that has only been around for 5!

I am working towards my MCSE certification that will hopefully get me past the initial screening of HR at most places and get to talk to the techs that know I can do the job now (even without certifications.)
I am interviewing for the second time at the contract place I am at now even though the techs I work with know I am doing the job, the people doing the hiring are looking for something else!

Definately not better than 5 years ago except that my family has grown.

by glastron

I certainly agree that a BS is not a bad thing but AS degree has great value. I know people who have a BS in IT and can barly turn on their PC. A BS and masters are a great tool for management advancment but to say AS degrees are useless is plain wrong. I would take someone with a 2 year degree that actually worked on real systems instead of 4 year "theory" degree. By the way I have 2 AS degrees and am working towards my BS. Merry Christmas everyone.

by bg6638

I read Glastron's post, and my immediate thought was when I went to a Robert Half agency to speak with one of their recruiters. I thought that 30+ years in IT with an AAB degree would be worth something! According to them, an AAB degree in Accting or Computer Science "is not worth the paper that it is printed on"! In fact, they told me that employers are now regarding a BS as a secondary degree, and that a Master's will be required by more employers within the next several years.

by thedanc

A lot of IT jobs nowadays use scanners and parsers to sift through the huge piles of resumes. These sifters are getting better, but most will toss away any resume without the letters BS. I was working as an engineer with three AS degrees but could not be given the engineering title or salary until I finished my BS degree. Ironically I had been working the engineering job for two years, had been with the company for 7 years, and only had three courses left in my BS degree: Art&Music Apprec, World History, Colorado History. Technologically speaking my BS degree was done, but I couldn't even leave the company and get a new job until I had the BS diploma in hand! I ripped through these last three classes in one semester, while working full time, got my salary promotion and then a job with a real company!

Someone mentioned MS ... has anyone found a program that is technically relevant? So many certs these days are just so more relevant than MS degrees from stale universities.

by quiet_type

You're putting the blame in the wrong place. It's not the liberal left that benefits most from off-shoring. It's the rich, conservative, Republican aristocracy in this country, with its insatiable greed for more and more money, at any cost to everyone else. They're the ones talking about a world economy. This year, Microsoft, Intel, and Cisco will be pouring a combined $3.8 billion into developing their interests in India. It's the rich in the U.S. that benefit most from illegal aliens and cheap labor. There used to be strong organizations of the liberal left. They were called "unions," and they helped to make sure the rich shared some of the wealth. The gains they made were passed on to everyone, in some ways, as even non-union shops benefitted from better wages, insurance, and other benefits. Now look at us. The unions are dead, the Republicans are in power, and our workers are being laid off by the 10s of thousands, and still our jobs are being off-shored. It's people who think like you do that make this possible. By the way, I hope you're not driving an import car. What's happening to the American IT worker is the same thing that's been happening to other American workers for years!

by daydo

I got my A.A.S degree a little over a year ago and started of as helpdesl/infrastrucre support now I pretty much am doing the same thing (A little more SysAdmin and responsibilites, different comanpany) but I am making about 40% percent more than a year ago. I see my self acheiving another increase like that in the next 2 years. I can see good things in 5 years. I just think you should work harder at climning the ladder, There is no reason you can't accomplish the same. Leave to another company if needed. Dont give up on IT, there is growth and a lot of money there.

by mdigiuseppe

I can't believe some of the comments! The dilemma of lackluster employment and insufficient rewards in the IT industry aren't the results of partisan politics; it has to do with our captains of industry courting our National leadership in order to significantly lower the cost of skilled labor!

If it were merely market demand, everyone with an IT need would be outsourcing to American professionals because we're the ones who have spent tens of thousands of dollars on our own education and training and we're the ones who launched these ridiculous certification programs which have now gotten completely out of hand. I mean, look guys, a CCIE Cert can run upwards of $22,000 by the time you complete the required labs.

Many of the outsourced service and support providers that run their business overseas don't even have certified employees in their shops! I know, I've asked when I've been blown off to a help desk in India or Pakistan by a manufacturer and have had to indulge the poor man or woman struggling to communicate with me in English!

To compensate for the poor performance of the outsourced labor, American industry has spent millions of dollars in advertising and marketing to drive down the expectations of consumers who continue to struggle with information technology in their day-to-day routine.

We're not going to resolve our employment issues at the ballot box voting individually because it won't matter who we elect on an individual basis.

We'll only resolve our dilemma when the entire labor component of the IT industry realizes that we need to take back control by organizing our political will around sound, well-thought-out action! One of the first things we'd need to do is accelerate the current trend among our elected representatives to close immigration and fortify our boarders. You can't believe how much that would affect our prosperity. Another thing that we could do is organize around a National initiative to promote telecommuting--getting industry to accept the notion that it's just getting too damn costly to drive a $22,000 automobile to work at $2.50 per gallon of gas. We could all work for a little less if we didn't have to underwrite Detroit's speculation all of the time.

Our focus should be on organizing and networking to produce effective political, economic, and social change. We won't get anywhere making this serious change in the paradigm of our careers a fault of any political party. We have to hammer the political sector every bit as hard as any other special interest group.

But, I know that all of you will just sit back and say that I'm crazy. You let this gigantic sleeping dog lie there undisturbed and continue the petulant grousing until the next major layoff.

Eventually, we'll all be stocking shelves for WalMart on W-2 Contract earning $6.75 an hour and trying to determine how we'll pay for our utility bill or agonizing over the fact that we can't provide our families with adequate health care. And while we suffer, we'll hear our politicians continue to say: "Overseas outsourcing, guest worker programs, and unrestricted trade is good for America.

Come on people! Which America are these Yahoos talking about?

by thechas

So, you want to have unionized IT workers?

It is hard to get enough money into trade organizations to fund effective political action.

In order for IT to gain the type of clout that you are looking for, the majority of IT workers would need to join a common union.

While I don't see unions as the problem that some members do. I don't think it is practicle to expect IT workers to join together anytime soon.

Chas

by mdigiuseppe

I should have been more specific: No, Chas, I was talking about a Professional Association expressed as a movement. Sort of like the IEEE.

by foothillscg.com

A good friend of mine got downsized twice. His wife is working full time while he goes to school full time and pulls double-shifts on the weekends at an old folks' home.

Can't outsource cleaning up vomit. After he graduates and gets about a year of experience, he'll be able to work anywhere.

I met two nurses who specialtize in surgery, and hospitals paid for their room and board, too. They were touring the country by going from hospital to hospital. I met them outside their marina-side apartment in Marina del Rey, CA, where those places were going for $2300/month, minimum.

I don't remember if it's 45% or 55% of the nursing profession is nearing retirement age in the next 5 years...

Also, more and more computing is being integrated into the medical professions.

I also have another friend who used to implement computer-controlled medical equipment in a large HMO. He was one of the few people doctors there treated with something close to respect. He knew how to use the equipment better than they did, and they needed him to do their jobs!

by jamesg

Off-shoring, is of course, a Republican fueled phenomenon in that it is just another give away to mega corps looking to dodge taxes, and health care costs, another thing the far right fasctist wing of the Republican party has foisted off on us in the interest of enriching their corporate masters. So don't blame liberals, blame money hungry republican wolves in sheeps clothing claiming they give a damn what happens to you.

by glastron

Hello, What type of job were you looking for? As I said in my post any kind of management postion would almost always require a BS. The market is tight now but for hands on jobs I still think 2 year degree has value. It is a buyers market right now so employers are tighting up the qualifcations. 5 years ago you didn't need any degree. If you where breathing and could spell PC you had a job. I agree the higher the degree the better but to say you need a masters to run cable and setup users is just not true. Head hunters tend to look at just catch phrases such as certs and degrees. I would take your 30 years of relevant real world experience and "worthless" degree over someone who has a masters and never worked in the field. Sorry you had that experience but I don't know if that is the thought everywhere. Happy New Year!

by spbonus

5 years ago i was a software developer with 1 year of experience and a BS in computer science. i was with a small start up and it was a 60k salary job.

2 laid off in between

now i am still a software developer for a larger company with still getting in the low 60k.

by spbonus

5 years ago i was a software developer with 1 year of experience and a BS in computer science. i was with a small start up and it was a 60k salary job.

2 laid off in between

now i am still a software developer for a larger company with still getting in the low 60k.

by oz_media

I would never stay put if I wasn't constantly moving forward in pay, duties, responsibilities and mroe than anything, interests.

Pigeon-holing myself into a career corner has never been my cup of tea (speaking of which, time to put the kettle on). If the bottom falls out of IT, I fall out of IT.

When I got tired of my last gig, I bailed out and did something different, I couldn't see IT as a future that was growing fast enough anymore. Wages crawled up the scale and work was a complete snooze. So I found something else to do (I always keep irons in the fire) that pays more, is more exciting and has a much better future, for now anyway.

Why pick a career, spend your life in school trying to earn more at that career and then realize it isn't what you 'want' to do anymore? No thanks.