Discussion Locked

Aussie woman a pot dealer?

0 helpful
182 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Has the world gone daft? An Australian woman is getting 20 years in prison from an Indonesian court for bringing pot into the country. She says the stuff was planted in her luggage.

http://www.cnn.com/2005/WORLD/asiapcf/05/27/corby.appeal/index.html

182 replies

by oz_media

A fiew views.

1) If she actually did try to smuggle the drugs in, that's a pretty steep sentence even for 9 pounds of marijuana with a pathetic street value that is not much higher then the minimal fine she got too.

2) In most countries, such a 'set-up' complaint is easily dismissed via security cameras etc. I don't think they have quite the same security there so it is very likely as it would be very effective (as shown in this specific case) Posession is 9 tenths of the law.

But I don't get the part about some prisoner vouching for her, that doesn't really make sense, why would they try and use THAT? I would be interested in finding out more abou THIS story than hers, what exactly WAS dismissed?

Still....20 YEARS? Nasty!

Perhaps another one of those people that spends 20 years in jail (and in this case a rotten one at that)for a crime they didn't commit. Just like the hundreds of convicted killers that have been released after more than a dozen years behind bars due to a mistake or crooked detective.

This is the main reason I oppose the death sentence, until we can be 100% positive and not just proven beyond a REASONABLE doubt, what a loose term that is.

by stress junkie

I don't understand why they didn't just deport her and tell her not to return. Maybe they want to make an example of her to deter others from bringing drugs into the country. I'd like to know more facts in the case. She certainly doesn't look like a drug smuggler.

by oz_media

What does a drug smuggler look like?

Remember we are talking about one trying to move drugs to another country and not just a local street dealer. Do you think they would EVER "look the type?"

Coming from a city of blue suited executives that smoke pot in public during lunch and in the bars after work, leads to the realization that you just never know.

It does sound quite possible she is being a scape goat on this one though.

by black panther

Lock ALL of your luggage... and think twice before going to such countries.

**What is the maximum sentance the American judicial system has for drug smuggling**

by sleepin'dawg

If you were behind a drug smuggling ring wouldn't you use the mules who least looked like a drug smuggler???

Most travel advisory books warn people to never let their luggage out of their sight and control.

All travelers should be aware that when you enter a foreign country you are under that countries laws, not those of your own. These laws may be much stricter and reactionary than your own.
There are still countries in the world whose laws advocate chopping off the hands of petty thieves.

9 pounds of grass seems like a lot of grass to be unaware of. I could understand a pound or two but 9 is a bit over the top. I don't know about her but I would have noticed that excess weight immediately; it would be like someone added a 10 pound bag of potatoes to my bags. Not to mention the space that it takes up. 9 pounds of grass would require more space than 10 pounds of spuds.

These were the questions I asked when I first read the story. The girl might be innocent but she'll never win any awards for being observant or intelligent.

Dawg ]:)

by oz_media

I got the sense that perhapse customs had stopped her bag at the airport in Bali after coming off a flight from Australia. She has accused baggage handlers of planting it (bad pun).

I got the impression that someone (a baggage handler) had planted it during or prior to loading the baggage on the aircraft and it was found by Bali customs.

In this case, the guys at the airport could be shipping tonnes with a lower risk of it coming back on them if it is stopped because it is 'technically' someone elses and Bali customs will just immediately charge the person who it is associated with.

Or was it explained otherwise and I just missed it? :p

by hal 9000

It was in one of those space bags where the air is sucked out of the bag after closing and then inserted into a boggy board bag so it effectively only was a bit wider/thicker and after several hours of flying all your baggage seems heaver than when you got on the plane.

The main problem here is that no finger printing of the bag was done to see who had handled it. If this had of happened it would have been evidence one way or the other of who was responsible for inserting it into the bag.

Also what you have to know is that the girl in question didn't pick up the bag her brother did and took it to customs where she claimed it was hers. She was traveling with several members of her family so she needn't of even handled the bag before it was handed in at the check in counter.

Col ]:)

by stress junkie

I've watched a lot of trials on Court TV. It's amazing how the dynamics of a trial work. I remember some years ago when that guy from the Kennedy clan was on trial for raping a woman in Floriday. I was very biased against this guy and thought that he would beat the charges based on his family association. When I watched the trial I found that I agreed with the defense. If I were on the jury I would have voted to acquit. So trials can be very complicated. If we could see the trial we would get a better understanding of the case.

by av .

I just saw this on CNN and I can't believe it. What happened to her could happen to anyone with luggage being that it is unlocked for security purposes.

What kind of justice is that? 20 years for pot? She could have gotten the death penalty!! Her attorney wasn't too smart to call another prisoner as a witness though. She needs a much better lawyer.

The Australian government should insist that she be returned to her country immediately. This poor woman didn't get a fair trial. If I was an Australian I would be outraged. I would definitely strike Bali and Indonesia off my vacation list FOREVER and boycott their products. I'm sure they depend heavily on Australia to buy their products and for tourism.

The unfortunate truth is that when you are in a foreign country, you are subject to its laws. I for one am going to ship my luggage so I only have a carry-on bag in the future. This could happen anywhere to anybody. I never thought about it before, but it might be a good idea to read a bit about the legal system in the country you are going to. From now on,I will.

How do you like that "justice" system? Isn't it Indonesia that let the suspected leader of the terrorist organization responsible for the Bali nightclub bombing go because they didn't have enough evidence a couple of years ago?

by hal 9000

As they charged him with a terror crime that was in breach of laws that where not at the time on the books effectively he was not guilty of the crime as his defense quite rightly argued you can not be held responsible for something that isn't law at the point in time that the offense accrues. IN that case the prosecution slipped up big time not the legal system.

In that case it is exactly the same as a change in speed laws being made and then applied retrospectively so you get a speeding ticked from 3 years ago because you where doing the speed limit at the time but when the law was changed you suddenly where speeding so you should be prosecuted.

That is a very simplistic view but it was how the systems works and both the prosecution and Government wanted to show just how effective their new anti terror laws where but they chose the wrong target as a test case.

Col ]:)

by black panther

The verdict was telecast live - 3 hours long - with tranlaters on TV translating it for us.

It was one of the most emotional things I have ever watched.

There has been a lot of speculation that she was the victim of a Baggage Handling Drug Ring.

In some Asian Countries like Indonesia, Thailand etc the judicial system is lot stricter and she could have easily got the 'death' penalty.

**People get less for Murder!***

I could go on and on and on...a lesson is lock your luggage and think before going to some of these countries.

And what sentance did the Bali Bomber get who killed many people ***2 years***

**as a side issue did you know Australia donated 1 Billion dollars to Indonesia for the Tsumani Appeal** ;)

by mrafrohead

Well I'm sold. After the crap those assmonkeys in Indonesia pulled on the US after they were hit by the waves, then this, I will NEVER go there and spend any of my hard earned pennies.

That's a crock.

20 years for 9 pounds of pot. Maybe the judges need to go and smoke some of that and mellow out a bit.

I've seen murderers get less of a sentence.

Maybe with enough luck another wave will hit there and get those corrupt judges...

I feel very bad for the poor woman suffering through this political nonsense.

by oz_media

I did a shout-out a while back trying to track you down. I am going to be down your way in July and wanted to ask you for some help.

Your peer link shows as active but when you send teh mail it says that the peer has requested to not be contacted.

Can you email me at 'ozmedia AT excite.com' when you get a chance?

Cheers,
OM

by hal 9000

In this case Bali has a ZERO TOLERANCE for Drugs and by bring in this amount she should have received the Death Penalty.

The Judges did nothing wrong as they could only preside on the evidence presented before them and act within the laws of the land. So you've seen a murderer get a lighter sentence was it in Bali?

You can not judge your legal system against another's country as the laws are different. For instance if your sister was not a virgin on her wedding day would you feel shame and would it bring down your family? Most likely not but in other parts of the world it would. If you want to visit these places with a Zero Tolerance for any thing you have to expect their laws to be applied equally to you as well as others or there is no law to speak of.

You can not blame the Judges in this case for following their laws you can only blame those involved for not offering a better defense as they offered one based on appealing the the AU sympathies and not one that was in accordance to Indonesian Law to give them another person who was responsible. Did the girl claim the bag at the Bali Airport Yes! Did it contain Grass Yes! Did she offer them another person as being responsible for it being there No! Did she suspect that the bag had been tampered with and report it to customs NO!

What other verdict could they come up with?

Col ]:)

by oz_media

They have a zero tolranc epolicy too, yet they have different penalties applied.

In SOME states, you will do time for even minor amounts but in others it's a little more lax.

They did say that because this was Bali and not some other country that she did get off pretty easy. The number of US cameras and reporters also helped reduce the possibility, but they also showed the prison she may serve time in and there is little hope of her surviving 20 years there anyway, most die from disease, it is NOTHING like one of our prisons at all.

It's still pretty absurd that such an extensive sentence is placed on such a crime.

by dafe2

Particularly liked the third paragraph......humans judge things based on their own experiences rather than seeing the bigger picture sometimes.

In Canada, she would've got a fine and a couple of years....................but she wasn't in Canada.

by hal 9000

First the young Corby claimed that as she flew from Brisbane to Sydney someone inserted 4 KG of Grass into one of her bags and it was supposed to have been removed in Sydney by baggage handlers. This happened on the same day that a lot of coke was imported and removed by baggage handlers in Sydney and this was only made public within the last few weeks when some of those involved where arrested.

Qantas has been wearing egg all over its face on this matter and has continued to insist that their staff are perfect and nothing like this could happen. Even when presented with video of one of the baggage handlers stealing a camel suit from luggage and wearing it around the work areas of the airport they claimed it didn't happen. Although it was a bit of a joke and very had to miss on the video.

My Corby arrived in Bali which has very strict Anti Drug Laws with a quantie that should have brought a Death Sentence and while the defense claimed that it was planted which most likely it was they failed to produce a single person or name a person who was responsible so she was found guilty. The prosecution asked for a Life Sentence rather than the death Penalty and only got a 20 year sentence which is very light in Indonesia so the prosecution will be appealing the sentence to get a longer sentence.

The prisoner who testified in the court case was an inmate in a Melbourne jail who is awaiting trial for rape and claims to have overheard two other prisoners speaking of the stuff up that had occurred as the grass had not been removed but he failed to mention any names in fear of his life or so he claimed so it didn't hold any weight with the Court as again no person responsible was named. The fact that he was stabbed just after being returned to the Melbourne jail tends to imply that he just might have had something to be scared of and while his evidence was ruled as inadmissible by the Indonesian Court because he didn't offer a person responsible and even if he had of as it happened in a different country it was not important to the Court and was the responsibility of the other country the court was only looking at the facts did the girl arrived with 4 KG of grass in their country? The simple answer was yes! The AU government didn't make any representations about possible problems and breaches of security at the airports here so any thing brought before the Indonesian Courts was nothing more than Here-say and ruled inadmissible.

However as quite a few Australian citizens are a bit worked up by what has happened since her arrest which initially got no coverage here because of an election the AU Government is now trying to make amends and get her out of there as they quite obviously know what has happened but are unwilling to share the information with another country and risk an ongoing investigation. When this started to become an issue here the Federal Government at first said it was none of their business and would allow justice to take its course but as public sediment rose higher they seemed to get more worked up probably by the fact that it was adversely affecting them in the polls so they had to look as if they where doing something which of course they are not but if they look busy that is all that is important to them as people have a short memory.

But after the verdict was handed down the Government realized it had a problem as there are people wanting to attack the Indonesian Consulates and literally close them down and show those involved a bit of rough justice so the Government has had to provide extra protection for these places and the Foreign Affairs Minister Alexander go down has come out on National TV saying this would be counter productive as it would affect the Governments ability to talk to and deal with the Indonesian Government which it would but the AU Government is attempting to shut the door after the horse has bolted and are wondering why things are not going their way.

Personally I think that the AU Government must have done something behind the scenes as a 20 year jail term is very little there where anyone else would have got a death sentence and I really think that some pressure was applied to the judges in this case to impose a minor sentence and deal with the mess latter.

Col ]:)

by tony hopkinson

If you go to someone elses country and get found guilty of breaking their laws, and you suffer their sentencing. End of story. To say your citizen is more imporant than their laws is both crass and hyprocritical. When the reverse happens and someone comes into our countries and breaks our laws, do we all sit around saying well in his country it's OK to do this so we'll let him go ?

Our country, our law, their country, their law.

by hal 9000

With the Bali 9 who are currently awaiting trial for trying to smuggle herion out of Bali there is no public sympathy but in the Corby case it is a bit different as it has been accepted that the package was planted and her bag was used to transport the goods between different City airports. The fact that it was not removed shows that either the people concerned where very slack or more likely there where some security issues in Sydney which prevented them from removing the goods.

What has got a lot of people he upset is the fact that they can be charged and found guilty for something that they have no control over and actually for doing something that is supposed to be in their best interests by handing their baggage over to "Trusted" staff to hold and make sure that it not only arrive safely but do not contain any dangerous goods.

Did she do it well yes because she arrived in Bali with the grass but did she know about it is a different story and that is the sticking point here.

While I do not agree with this a lot of those who donated money for the relief effort after the Boxing Day incident now want a refund. Which they are not only not entitled to but for some reason seem to think that they should have the ability after the fact to decide where any money that they give away goes.

What is the real problem here is the Companies involved namely Qantas in this case refusing to even consider that some of their staff may be less than honest particularly after this has already been proved and there is an ongoing investigation into this matter by the Federal Police. What is making a lot of people here concerned is that this could just have easily happened to them and they would be in the same boat. Even if they had been traveling domestically they could collect their baggage and find that it has been tampered with and still be responsible for any illegal contents. There is currently a paranoid fear about this at the moment and the airlines are now providing plastic wrap rolls way out in front of the terminals to wrap up your baggage in before handing it in. Well not quite right in most of the airports this is correct and has been happening for a while after Corby was arrested but in the prime target Sydney as of Wednesday this option was still unavailable. But they where talking about introducing this there as well but the main problem was not with the airlines but the private airport owners who didn't want to sacrifice any more space to the airlines than was absolutely necessary because it meant a loss in rental space that they could not recover from either the airlines or shops in the facility.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

As locks are cut off the baggage. Currently if you even so much as suspect that your baggage has been tampered with you shouldn't even touch it but call an official over and ask them to get the proper authorities to examine you baggage to make sure that it hasn't been tampered with.

Once you pick it up you are responsible for the contents. Currently here all baggage is being plastic wrapped at the airports before being handed in at the baggage collection points but this only gives you a false sense of security as someone could unwrap it put something in or remove something and re wrap it after you have handed it in.

I remember on one occasion when I returned from Europe one of my bags came out looking as if it had been through a meat grinder with bits of clothing hanging out every where the locks and handles missing and 2 big cable ties holding it together, there was a note on it claiming that it had been damaged while in transit and to contact the airline for compensation. As it was a long time prior to 9-11 it wasn't an issue but today I would be leaving it on the conveyor belt and asking a customs official to inspect it prior to even handling it.

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

there has been a few stories lately about cameras, laptops and jewelry coming up missing out of luggage. As it is getting x-rayed, security knows what is in them and knows what bags to go through.

a bag of drugs would also show up at this time if it had already been there so this SHOULD not have been able to have happened as she would never had gotten ON the plane without an inspection!

Doesn't make sence that it gets found coming off the plane instead of going on with everyone looking for bombs.

by hal 9000

I believe that she boarded a plane in Brisbane and flew to Sydney where she transfered to an international flight to Bali.

Now effectively her luggage was out of her control from Brisbane as from what I understand it was transfered to the international flight direct from the domestic aircraft in Sydney but maybe she boarded an aircraft at Cooloongata flew to Brisbane and then onto Sydney. No matter what though she lost control of her baggage from at the very least Brisbane where the inspections are fairly strict and I just about have to get half undressed to even enter that airport. Last time I was there seeing someone off I had to empty my pockets remove my belt buckle and lighter holder from my belt along with the Zipo Lighter and then my shoes as that have some metal in them.

Now what the Government here would have you believe is that with this level of inspection here the baggage isn't inspected and the highly trained drug & bomb sniffing dogs must have been on holiday that day or at the very least on a meal break {N B L.} At the very least the baggage should have been checked at Brisbane and Sydney airports and even twice at the Sydney Airport when it was off loaded from the domestic flight and again prior to being loaded onto the international flight. Now even if this person was smuggling drugs she should have been picked up long before she even got near the International Aircraft and if she was prepared to carry this amount of drugs to Bali what would have happened if she had other intentions?

At the very least it makes a total joke of airport security.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Baggage handlers in AU had inserted it from Brisbane and it was supposed to have been removed in Sydney prior to it getting transfered to the international terminal but for some reason it wasn't removed.

On the same day that she left AU for this trip several KG's of Heroin where picked up coming into the country and being removed by baggage handlers prior to it going through customs. But charges where not brought against some of the people concerned until about 6 months latter as there is an ongoing investigation running.

Col ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

(actually not a bad pun)It was found in the bag for her boogie board. I don't know how they do it in Bali but I assume it is somewhat like here, where you and your bags step up to the customs agent who then asks if you have anything to declare. 9 extra pounds in a boogie board bag??? How stunned or unobservant can you be??? She had an opportunity right then and there to declare that there was something wrong with her bag and that she had no knowledge of what it could be. She is not a 17 year old kid but a 27 year old woman. She should have been more aware that something was wrong with the bag and started declaring that before she ever got to customs. She was stupid and to compound it her defence was definitely not of the best quality. The Aussie consul should have been called in immediately and a lot of her problems would have disappeared on the spot. But that's just my opinion.

Dawg ]:)

by hal 9000

Her brother took it to customs and she claimed it as hers but that was where the real problems began as she is saying that she was trying to tell the customs agent {who doesn't speak English} that something was wrong and the customs agent is saying that she tried to prevent him from opening the bag.

As they took a video directly after the arrest where the Indonesian officials where all handling the contraband and generally showing off to the camera they lost the ability to finger print the bag with the drugs in it.

When it is all said and done the Judges took the word of their fellow country man aver the foreigner who they do not know. The fact that you could have walked 100 yards in any direction from the front of the court building and buy some grass is neither here nor there. They already knew of its existence before it was collected and where just waiting for the owner to claim it.

Col ]:)

by tony hopkinson

trial according to the legal rules in Bali, you can argue. Whether 20 years, life or even the death penalty is fair for smuggling pot, you cannot. The only reason this story is new is because she's a foreigner, if she was from Bali, it wouldn't have got a mention off the island. As for whether she was a knowing mule, who knows. Her family, government etc need to pursue that. If they want her off the hook, they are going to have to find someone else to put on it. Arguing whether the sentence is fair is effectively an admission of guilt. One day in jail wouldn't be fair if you are innocent.

by hal 9000

But we have been hearing about it for a very long time now. As to the fairness or not of the sentence I do not think that I addressed the issue all I was trying to do here was provide information as those posting prior who seemed to have no real knowledge of what was going on. I was only attempting to supply some background information in an impartial manner "other than bashing the Government here for their lack of action" but what you are very unlikely to have heard of is that within the last month or so there have been 9 Australians arrested in Bali for attempting to smuggle drugs out of Bali and they knew what they where doing there is no sympathy for these people who got there for free and knew what they where getting into but the Corby case is a bit different and has been misrepresented by the media from the start. It started out claiming that she was going over to Bali to visit her sister {correct} who owned a surf shop in Bali {incorrect} and other rubbish like this since that point in time the media has been forced to lift its game and actually start reporting facts rather than the rumor that they generally rely upon and this has what has been the result as I posted above.

There is no question that this girl entered Bali with the drugs but there is a big question as to how they did get there and several airport baggage handlers in Sydney have been arrested for smuggling cocaine into the country and removing it from bags before it reached customs. That is fact and only came to light a few weeks ago when several people where arrested and there is an ongoing investigation. The Qantas Management is playing dumb and defending their workers even when it has been proved that not all of them are as honest as Qantas claims and when the Chairman was shown the video of the camel suit incident he could only say it wasn't one of my staff members so the inference could only be that the place is so open that anyone can walk in and do as they please unchecked which is very unlikely.

To see these people trying to defend their actions and the actions of their staff is like looking at Dumb and Dumber on TV as they have constantly been shown to be at best stupid or criminally responsible for what is happening. It has been this mostly that has caused many Australians to become unhappy with what has happened in the Corby cases security breaches have been shown to exist in airport security and no one is willing to take responsibility for these security breach's.

I've heard it said a lot if it had of been John Howard's daughter involved the AU Government would have behaved a lot differently. But this comes from the same Government who arrested a foreign national for attempting to leave the country on a false passport so instead of letting her go they have arrested her held her in Mandatory Detention for over 3 years and are waiting to deport her to where she was attempting to go when arrested. Since that time however she has had another child here and now the Howard Government has allowed her and the child free and seem very unlikely to deport her and the child now, talk about Government stupidity. That comes on top of locking up AU citizens in demotion centers for protracted periods of time believing that they are foreign nationals who have entered the country illegally without doing the proper investigations to find out who they actually are and at least one case of deporting an AU citizen to the Philippines and then loosing her and 4 years latter trying to find her and bring her back. The Federal Government spent several Million $ in an attempt to find her and it was only when the media became involved that a priest saw the media report and rang up the media and said I've got that woman here under my care. Since that time another 201 cases of wrongful actions by the Immigration Department have come to light and are being investigated by a Royal Commission.

Currently the Federal Government is keeping stum over the allegations raised by the Corby defense under the pretext that they do not comment on ongoing investigations that are being run by the Federal Police and they have previously been justifying this by claiming that they do not become involved in legal matters in other countries which would be perfectly all right unless they are withholding vital evidence that could prove that the woman in this case was not involved. This the impression that many Australians have come to after watching the Governments Actions and the hasty way in which they are now attempting to arrange a prisoner exchange scheme with Indonesia and particularly a one off exchange in the Corby case, it appears to many that the Government knows far more than it is letting on and has been prepared to allow Corby to be scarified to allow their investigations to continue. Of course if they had of steeped in at the very beginning knowing that there was a problem and had direct talks with the Indonesian Government the whole thing would have just gone away with out question or the media getting involved but as they where still celebrating their Election Win they seemed to forget about the business of Government and allowed this case to reach this stage where that had they be seen to act but at the same time not to adversely impact upon the ongoing investigation which daily owing to leaks to the press is getting harder for those involved to pursue.

Col ]:)

by bfilmfan

Having been to several different countries in the course of my military and civilian career, I can tell you that I NEVER EVER check baggage for EXACTLY that reason.

I pack what I absolutely need and buy more clothes when I get there. Always makes it more fun to shop in the local markets and look like a resident anyway. And trust me in some places, you do seriously want to blend in...

Frankly, the best way to show Indonesia how upset Australians are at their antics is to absolutely boycott any travel destination in the area, strip search all baggage, cargo containers, ships, and anything else coming from Indonesia. After a couple of weeks, the government will quickly get the idea that Ozians (My new and totally created word for the folks down under) are really upset, call the woman back into court and quickly remand her sentence to time served and deport her home.

If that Indonesian minister keeps running his mouth about how evil the US government and British government are, he might have other issues to worry about anyway, as it is pretty obvious that President Bush won't lose a minute of sleep declaring them a "nation of terror" and dispatching those fun boys in the Pacific fleet to pay them a nice "Hey There You Damned Fureigners!" call.

Please note that last paragraph was said with my tongue in my cheek so far I look like Dizzy Gillespie before the hate mail and flames start! Oy!

by linc137

I can't see this woman being guilty. Simple as that. A person REALLY interested in bringing dope across certainly wouldnt have stashed it openly in an unlocked bag.

by tony hopkinson

Looking furtive and secret, or even worried is the fastest way you can find to get pulled in customs. Unwitting mules are the best way in for 'small' amounts. This thing I can't understand is why dope, it's a very bulky item and it's not as if it would be hard to grow your own in that climate.

by jdclyde

Then instead of looking like her life is over, she would have had plenty of happy people around her to give her a light when needed.

Lesson learned. Learn the penalties before going to that other country on a trip.

Again the obvious question, how did she check this bag in without the pot being found in the first place if she really did take it on?

by av .

I haven't heard anything about that. It looked like a pretty big package to miss.

by hal 9000

One of those space bags where you suck all the air out after closing it up. This was then inserted into a Boogie Board Bag along with the boogie board.

Where the real problems arose was after the arrest the customs officers where video taped showing the bag off to the camera and thus loosing any real evidence along the lines of finger prints which may have answered the question one way or the other. To this day the bag has never been fingerprinted and in all likely hood it would now prove useless as the evidence has either been lost or tainted.

Col ]:)

by oz_media

People don't smuggle pot INTO Canada.

That's like taking a bucket of manure to a farm.

by av .

A slap on the hand? A look the other way? A wink and a nod? No biggie?

In the US there would be jail time. Maybe like up to 5 years but not 20 years, and definitely not the death penalty.

by av .

I wanted to respond to your later post, but maximum message level was reached (don't you just hate that?).

My mother-in-law recently returned from vacation in Canada. She had lots of pictures that she took in Montreal and one of them was a Cannabis Cafe of some type. Of course, she didn't know what it was; she thought it was just a cute place. If pot isn't totally legal, how is it ok to operate a business like that?

One thing I have to agree with in Canadian law is not filling the jails with people that use marijuana. In the US, I think only Oregon has decriminalized pot and made it a misdemeanor. Otherwise, you will have a criminal record of some type.

by av .

In reply to your last post, it almost sounds like the US in the 60's and 70's, before it was restricted.

They used to have "head shops" that sold various paraphernalia, bongs, papers, no hemp clothing though. It was, sort of, accepted back then. Today you don't see any shops like that. It was all closed down over the years.

There was never any official cannabis cafe establishments though that I can recall, it was all underground.

by garion11

Very similar in story and I think it was Hong Kong or some other spot near south east Asia. Very strict drug laws and corrupt government officials. Interestingly enough, the 2 girls in the movie who were accused of drug smuggling had their stuff planted also or did they? The movie is eerily similar.

by hal 9000

Was feeds from AU Media as there where no US media at the Court for the sentence. Over here ever TV channel showed the final day of the court proceedings and every one of them commented on the total lack of any other media attention that was present. The Bali media only had minimal representation and even then only because there where so many AU media there.

I think you'll find that most of the coverage that you saw was from a direct feed by the AU media or archive footage.

But in Indonesia there are only two possible sentences for this type of crime one being Death and the other being Life but the judges are allowed a bit of lea way on the last one and in this case only imposed a 20 year sentence which incensed the prosecution who are currently in the process of appealing the sentence to make it longer.

There have been occasions in Indonesia where on appeal a life sentence has been changed to a Death Sentence and this is the risk that is run on making appeal. On the other hand there are two courts to appeal to and if the appeal process is pursued generally speaking the appeals are heard in both courts within 6 months so it is very quick by our standards but it is this quickness which may very well work against this girl as the ongoing investigations by the Federal Police here are unlikely to be finished prior to the appeal process being finished. After the appeal process has been finished there is only one other course of action and that is to ask for a pardon from the Leader of Indonesia but you normally have to have served at least 5 years of your sentence and admit guilt and beg for mercy.

Somehow unless she is facing a Death Sentence I can not see her admitting guilt so she effectively would not be capable of receiving a pardon as she is showing no remorse for her crime.

Col ]:)

by oz_media

In Canada the issue would have been investigated properly, perhaps resulting in someone else's arrest.

The myth is that weed is legal in Canada whereas it isn't at all. Before now, posession of up to a quarter pound would never result in a conviction, too many loopholes, too many small busts, too many people getting off while the city pays immense costs for police overtime, and court costs.

They have in essence tightened the law further, not eased it as most seem to think. Now, it is not a criminal offense to posess up to 15 grams (hair over a half ounce), up to 14 grams is now a fine instead (up to $400.00 for minor amounts), thus the city gets paid without the legal fees, but people can still fight that ticket and in most cases they won't stick, again due to loopholes.

I have yet to know someone who has been given a ticket, so really, nothing's been done. They played a little lip service to slow down the legalize pot crowd, though now they are fighting for full legaliztion. They line city pockets instead of draining them and everything carry's on as normal.

The city says it's not fair to give someone a criminal record for marijuana posession, but that's just because more than half the country would be unemployable.

[u]The following, is the educational portion of the post:[/u]

[i]"Kurtis Lee Masse stands charged on information 62876-1, that on or about the 21st day of February, 2003 at or near the City of New Westminster, he did unlawfully possess a controlled substance, to wit:...In the case at bar the issue before me is whether the information charging Mr. Masse discloses an offence known to law...It follows therefore, that there is no offence known to law at this time for simple possession of marihuana. The application is allowed."[/i]
http://www.provincialcourt.bc.ca/judgments/pc/2003/03/p03_0328.htm

Judge Chen has stringly opposed posession as unlawful in this and many other cases by explaining that to apply criminal charges for marijuana posession is unconstitutional and that there is no written law prohibiting the posession of marijuana.

[i]"Two men, who were stopped by police and charged with possessing a narcotic for the purpose of trafficking after 22 pounds of marijuana was found in their car, were acquitted by the court. The court found that the men's Charter right against arbitrary detention had been violated since the police had no reasonable basis to suspect the men were involved in criminal activity, other than relying on supposed indicators learned at a training course."[/i]
http://www.ontariocourts.on.ca/decisions/2004/august/C38499.pdf

Another one walks.

This issue in Australia is not a first though, nearly 10 years ago, a Canadian narrowly escaped the death sentence (by gallows) in Singapore for drug smuggling.

So some people take it quite seriously I suppose.

by deepsand

The following is an extract from a review of a book, written by a American lawyer enrolled as a student at the Universitas Padjadjaran?s Masters of Law Program.

==================================================

The rule of law in Indonesia is in the process of major reform. Corruption is a major hindrance to this process but an even more formidable impediment is access and clear understanding of Indonesia?s regulatory promulgations.

Outside Jakarta, individuals, offices and courts often experience significant inconvenience in attempting to access the tens of thousands of laws, regulations and decrees that are in effect governing Indonesian lives. Judges and lawyers are even prevented from making legal decisions and analysis regarding business, social and criminal cases simply they can?t even find the relevant law that should be applied. However, with a bit of effort the existing written body of law is capable of serving its intended function if read and applied in good faith.

The construction of law libraries throughout the entire archipelago is beyond the budgetary ability of the government. There is also a dearth of law reference works written by legal experts because the long hours of selfless labor and the printing costs, often carried solely by the author, is most often a money losing proposition.

Efforts have been made to develop websites representing various governmental departments containing an ever growing quantity of downloadable laws and regulations. Unfortunately, both the density of telephones and insufficient band width service across the nation reduces the government?s efforts to disseminate the law via the Web.

by garion11

With a sex slave trade, corruption up the wazoo, tsunami destruction, it seems their main priority is sentencing a woman who just happened to be a citizen of a country that donated the largest amount of Tsunami aid. I say the Australians should go in and teach these Indonasian muslims a lesson...before more pack rapists and bali like bombers invade Sydney.

by oz_media

Certainly a rash action would be to pour Indonesian wine in the gutter and stop eating at Indonesian restaurants while claiming all citizens of Indonesia are a bunch of scum. I don't think that addresses the problem at hand though.

This is a law, if that was the law in the USA and it was a Canadan charged with it, you would be freaking out about Canada's lack of dreg laws and ease on smugglers, how WE let these smugglers pass through US customs etc. The blame woud VERY QUICKLY be passed on to us, and America would be correct in sending the guy to the chair.

Yet in a country somewhere else, it is extreme and is backstabbing a country that is helping them recover from the tsunami.

There is no and can be no correlation between global relations and a country's law. If so, then ANY law with a foreign land can be twisted bent or ignored due to some favour someone did down the line.

It is simply notpractical at all, though I do agree with the knee jerk reaction to slap them right back in the face, well the judge and the prosecution anyway. Not exactlly a problem with the people of Indonesia, they still deserve a right to life even though they have stiff penalties for drug trafficing.

Mind you, that's exactly how most Canadians feel about the US when it comes to drugs too, the US needs to get a grip and realize how futile such an effort is and how expensive to it's citizens it is when there are real issues that need addressing.

by deepsand

It's an ancient tactic, used when those in power seem to be impotent to adequately deal with internal problems, to create the appearance of, and vigorously defend against, an external threat so as to redirect the public attention away from the many other failures.

by deepsand

For the view of some of those with expertise in Asian law, see

[v]http://www.smh.com.au/news/Opinion/Justice-system-not-getting-a-fair-hearing-in-highprofile-drugscases/2005/05/02/1114886314945.html?oneclick=true[/v]

by garion11

its how this whole thing is played out...It appears to be a classic setup for this lady. Lots of things don't make sense in this whole thing...suppression of evidence, corruption, etc...I guess I am not arguing that there shouldn't be a law at all, but the way its all carried out. I smell a rat thats all.

by av .

You're right on about the airlines culpability. Their procedures should be investigated thoroughly and the results presented to the Indonesian judges on her behalf. Its extremely important to understand how this happened to a seemingly innocent person. It could happen to anybody.

If I look at Bali justice, I'd say you don't have a chance if you are perceived to have committed a crime. You are guilty, period, OFF WITH YOUR HEAD! What is that? It surely isn't justice. I know, its their country and they have their laws, but the possibility that someone along the way planted this in her luggage casts enough reasonable doubt to me that she may not have committed the crime. If there is any message that is clear as a result of this incident, its DON'T travel to places like that.

The AU government should insist that Ms. Corby be returned to AU for the appeals process. There is always the prisoner swap option too. She shouldn't have to be a political scapegoat. We didn't see anything in the US of the trial, just the actual moment when she was sentenced. I felt such horror to see the shock and disbelief in her face, I can only imagine how bad the trial must have been. She doesn't look like the drug dealer type to me.

I think all of us can relate to this woman. This could happen anywhere to anybody. There needs to be legal protection for people that travel if their luggage can be tampered with.

by hal 9000

About her not getting a fair trial in Bali her defense wasn't any help either as they where just not up to the job of doing it properly. The reality is that in any country a defense like that would have resulted in a conviction is unquestioned and even accepted by the media here.

Where the real problems lie is firstly with Qantas who's Closed Circuit Coverage of the check in counter was not working on the day, the fact that instead of weighing each persons luggage individually they just accepted a group weigh in for all of the families luggage who where traveling to Bali and the AU Government who failed to provide the defense with Surveillance footage of the baggage check in area.

This left the defense with absolutely no way to prove that the pot was not in the bag before it was handed over for transport as freight. But also the family can nor absolve themselves of responsibility either as they where handed a list of Lawyers in Indonesia and just went through the list until they found someone who spoke English to defend their daughter/sister now this particular company looks like they where not up to the job in hand as really they appealed for sympathy rather than addressing matters of LAW and didn't address any of the Legal Issues that where not admitted by the Court.

Considering just how bad the defense was I'm surprised she only got 20 years! But on the up side I think that the lead Judge felt the same way as most others and while he had his hands tied to a certain extent as there was no question that the pot was in this girls bag and she admitted to owning the bag but the Lead Judge did speak to the Media during the trial which is in directly not allowed under Indonesian Law and is grounds for a Dismissal of the Verdict in itself.

But of course some far better Lawyers should handle the case to get the original conviction thrown out and possibly the trial dispensed with and just deport her out of the country back to her home land. But if the family stick with the current Law Firm to defend her in the appeals process she will most likely receive the Death Penalty they really are that inept.

Col ]:)

by av .

It never helps to present a prisoner's testimony on anyone's behalf. She needs an attorney thats more experienced in international law. Particularly, Indonesian law.

I hope that all of the media attention she gets will get her out of Indonesia. What an absolutely horrible situation to be in.

Its amazing to me that I haven't seen any coverage of this in the US aside from the courtroom conviction. Its something that could happen to anyone, anywhere.

by levannah44

The Schapelle Corby case has generated an almighty emotional reaction in this country simply because Oz law, in any similar case, would be much less harsh.

However, what everybody seems to be missing is the fact that Corby actually got a very lenient trial by Indonesian standards. The fact that it was also a media circus probably wouldn't have helped, but, by and large, given that this lass was plucked from her anonimity to have her case in particular held up for scrutiny by the world's media (there are plenty of other Aussies in Indon prisons convicted of the same of similar crimes we never even hear about) meant that so was the Indon justice system.

Indonesia has very harsh penalties for drug trafficking -- usually death, often life in prison. Ms Corby has been extremely lucky to date to only have scored 20 years.

Now, I believe this girl is innocent. That, of course, is beside the point at the moment. Indon law clearly states that anyone caught with drugs on them (more than for personal use I expect) will face the death penalty or life.

The first odd thing about this case was why would anyone, Ms Corby included, want to bring a drug from Oz to Indon in the first place? Usually, it's the other way round!

Nevertheless, she was caught with drugs on her at Denpasar airport, and this was all the Indons looked at. That was the EVIDENCE.

All other so-called "evidence" to date, as far as I can make out, is either only heresay or circumstantial. None of it can be PROVED.

It wasn't that the Indon judges disbelieved what Corby said about baggage-handlers planting the stuff in her bag, it was simply that there was no evidence for this.

It's now well-known that there are some pretty crooked baggage-handlers here in Oz, especially at Qantus, Australia'a big international airline. Well, that's as maybe, but until one of them comes forward and says: "I put the stuff in Corby's bag!", the Indon judges have NO EVIDENCE that what Corby has told them is true.

The fact that the day Corby flew out for Bali was quite a big day for the to-ing and fro-ing of large amounts of drugs into the country is really neither here nor there, other than to point out that these crooked baggage-handlers were obviously so busy they didn't have time to stop and think what was coming in and still had to go on to Sydney, so stuffed the drugs in an outgoing bag rather than an incoming one!

However, whatever may have been the "rush" and the "mixup" is still only heresay. It can't be proved that this is what happened, and it's highly unlikely that any baggage-handler is going to come forward and own up, since such an action would immediately lose him his job. The fact that Corby is paying for this mixup with twenty years of her life would mean nothing to such a bounder.

I wish everyone, Aussies included, would stop and look rationally at this case first before sounding off about it being a miscarriage of justice and all the rest.

It is a miscarriage of justice only in the fact that Corby was the innocent guinea-pig in this hodge-podge of a mess. Everything else has been based on solid evidence, and the Indon judges, in spite of all the tears and emotion, have stuck quite solidly to their guns and convicted her ONLY ON THE EVIDENCE.

This must be remembered at all times. What happens from now on in remains an unknown. If a roster at Qantus is able to pin the baggage-handler more acurately, then be sure the Indon judges would acknowledge that.

They are not monsters, in spite of what's been said about them. They are only carrying out the law -- their law -- in what they have done so far. Wouldn't our own system have done just the same?

Gret

by jdclyde

If she truely didn't get to present ALL evidence she did NOT get a fair trial and the judges did NOT rule on only the evidence.

Drugs were in her bag, off with her head is not quite what I would call justice, no matter what the law about drugs is.

by av .

Her evidence was not thoroughly investigated. The fact that drugs could be planted because bags are open for security reasons in AU should be enough reasonable doubt that the person could be innocent.

It seems to me that the Indonesians have rushed to judgement. Are they monsters? Yes. They sent an innocent woman to their third-world prison and the real culprits are free. That isn't justice. Thats harsh and unfair law based on circumstantial evidence as perceived by small minds. Why didn't they apply their strict law to the terrorists that they harbor that bombed the nightclub in Bali? Didn't the cleric only get something like 5 years in prison after a lengthy investigation? How is that just punishment for a person who may have masterminded the killing of 200 innocent people?

Maybe you think its ok because its their country, their law; I would agree if the trial was fair. It wasn't thorough enough. I think the AU government should investigate the airlines and bring Ms. Corby home for the appeals process so she can get a fair trial. I hope her family will file a complaint against the airlines, their handling of baggage and possible involvement.

The real criminals are still out there and will do it again. The AU government has to investigate so this doesn't happen again to anyone. It could be you next time. People in AU should continue to be totally outraged until the truth is uncovered. It is a miscarriage of justice. I'm outraged and I'm in the US. It could happen here too.

by hal 9000

It is the defense who failed miserable to produce a credible defense at all. From what they produced which was more a sympathy approach rather than addressing the legal issues themselves they effectively caused the sentence to be brought down. Although I believe it to be very lenient for that country the real fact is that in any country with that defense they would have lost without a second thought.

The real problems here are more administrative ones by Qantas they did a group weigh in of all the family's baggage their Closed Circuit Video was not working on the day and the AU Government has failed to produce any surveillance video of the initial check in at Brisbane Airport. Beside thew fact that Qantas and the AU Government have consistently failed their client and in the case of the AU Government their citizen in this case they left the defense with virtually nothing at all to work with and it is the Indonesian people who are wearing the blame by many Australians.

The reality is that there is very little else that they could do and maybe even the Head Judge has given the defense a way out of this by talking to the Media which breaches the Indonesian Constitution and is grounds for a dismissal of the conviction itself. While he had to follow the law he may have deliberately breached the rules to get her another trial with a better defense team who could really provide something better in the way of Legal Arguments and maybe even have the whole thing dismissed on a legal technically.

The real people who should be found guilty here are Qantas The AU Government and the Defense team but of course none of them where standing at the dock they where all happy to stand back and leave Corby to her own devices. The Corby family was given a list of defenders and they just rang through the list until they found a company who could understand English which while good for them may not have been the best defense council available and by what was presented as a defense looks very much like they weren't the best available for the job in hand.

The Indonesian people do not deserve any of this rubbish and knee jerk reactions that have come about after the verdict and sentence where announced. The bulk of the people complaining are accepting what they have been told by the media without understanding the Legal system in Indonesia and want to hurt the Indonesians for this outcome when really they are just as much caught in the middle as Corby is.

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

I thought that a large part of what they wanted to submit as part of the defense was thrown out before they even got to court?

How do you get a "fair" trial if the prosocution decides what you can and can't use to defend yourself?

But like most here in the US, this discussion was the first time I had even heard about this case.

by garion11

How do you get a "fair" trial if the prosocution decides what you can and can't use to defend yourself?

You don't. Its a Muslim country whadya expect?

by oz_media

That has been happening for years, all over the world. Both sides have a discovery where each side shows all of the evidence it has gathered to support it's case, this makes it fair for both sides and no secret witness is brought ot light at the last minute (unlike the movies).

At that point they have enough time before the trial to start reducing thevalidity of others evidence, the main goal is to have it deemed in admissible.
Key evidence is found irrelevant, unsubatantial and inadmissable for hundreds of reaons all the time. This is what makes a god attorney, being able to find those miniscule issue to leave the other side with nothing to go on.

For the most part, it's very effective for removing BS evidence and evidence that will unafairly influence a jury, heresay, incredible witnesses etc.

The rest of the time, it see people wrongly convicted or aquitted for heinous crimes, look to OJ for that example. It was a case of evidence credibility, there was SO much evidence, they only hope his defense had was to make as much of it in admissible as possible and therefore leave SOME reasonable doubt before in the verdict.

It's just when these issues obviously effect the wrong person that we pay attention, but I can promise you, this goes on dozens of times daily in teh US alone.

It's just yet another example of a very flawed legal system that we all live within, yet in another country it seems preposterous.

by hal 9000

Finger printing the bag that the stuff was in not the actual boogie board bag but the bag of pot which was not done.

The Corby Legal team never questioned the facts which where the Drugs where in the Bag and Corby claimed the bag.

That is a Prima Facie case there and all the prosecution requires to go to court.

It is the same in most parts of the world as well as an example for those X Files buffs here the episode where Mulder wakes up in a hotel room with blood on his shirt and the keys to a car that he doesn't own. Sculley drags him out of the place and eventually they find a dead couple shot at point blank range in an execution style murder. That was enough for the Local Police to build a Prima Facie case against Mulder and if Sculley had not of stepped in and investigated the murders he would have gone to trial and been convicted of the murders even though he claimed to have no knowledge of them. That wouldn't have washed in court anywhere as there was enough physical evidence to not only place him with those murdered but it showed that he was there at the very least shortly after the murders. Case closed end of story and conviction recorded.

That is how the Legal Service works they weigh up the evidence and then bring charges against the person they think is responsible I believe in the US it is called the DA over here it is called the Public Prosecution Service and different things in different parts of the world but effectively it all does the same thing. What was wanted to be used by the defense was the fact that a large amount of cocaine was brought into AU on the same day that Corby left but because it was not a matter that directly affected Bali or Indonesia as it was a crime in another country it was not admissible in the Bali Court and without other evidence provided it shouldn't have been either. If a direct link could have been provided to the importation of cocaine and the bag of pot it would have been a different story but everything offered by the defense was nothing more than Here say and was quite rightly ruled as inadmissible.

Now if I flew over to the US and was caught standing over Maxwell's still twitching body with a bloody knife in my hand it would be reasonable to expect that I had at the very least stabbed him just how do you think it would be construed if I just claimed that I only wanted to hold the murder weapon?

"No Max it will not happen but it was a good example" That would be more than enough evidence to construct a Prima Facie case to bring me before the Courts and be charged with the murder the fact that I have in the past disagreed with Max would be considered as a motive. Now can you see just how easy it is to get into problems that are not of your making and then having people like you turn up at court and give evidence that you read here that I was going to visit Maxwell and have a drink with him would not be evidence as there is no direct connection with the persons involved it would be Here say which it is and as such can not be accepted as evidence of no ill intent on my part against Maxwell. The DA would make out that I was so incensed with some of Maxwell's postings that I deliberately planed the flight over to the US and them set about systematically murdering Maxwell because of something that he posted that I not only disagreed with but was violently apposed to.

What should have happened in this case was the AU Government Representatives had a meeting with the Indonesian Government Representatives within a few days of the incident happening and told them officially that they where experiencing security problems at a certain airport and it was believed by the AU Government that the seized drugs had been planted and the necessary Affidavits handed over. If that had of happened there would have been no court case no 7 months imprisonment for the girl and no trial both Governments would just have made the problem go away. The Indonesians would have accepted the explanation and not wanting to start an International Incident that could harm themselves would have dropped the charges and most likely told the Corby Girl that it would be a good idea to leave the Country NOW!

Instead the AU Government failed to do anything and even after promising any surveillance Footage failed to deliver, what could have been soughed over a cup of coffee in a pleasant meeting has been allowed to blow out of all proportion by the stupidity of the AU Government Officials who thought that they knew best. Only after pressure was applied to the AU Government was the Star Witness allowed out of Melbourne jail to attend the court hearing and even then all he could say is that he "Overhears" two others prisoners talking, that is not evidence and the Court's quite rightly ruled it as Here say as there was no direct connection to the case at hand. From what I could see the "Rules Of Evidence" where strictly applied in this case and other than failing to finger print the bag with the drugs in everything that the prosecution did was correct and the same thing would be done in any other country and is done every day of the week.

What makes no sense in this case is taking that amount of pot to Bali as it is freely available there and in every other reported case the people have been picked up trying to leave the country rather than on arrival. That is what is wrong here, and something that could have been easily soughed out behind closed doors by the Governments talking to each other like adults instead of the AU Government behaving like a child and attempting to bury its head in the sand hoping that the problem would just go away. Now that it hasn't they are trying to clean up the mess after it not only has been dropped on the floor but trodden into the floor and spread about by all and sundry.

It is not something that is possible to clean up quietly behind closed doors what ever now happens now will be very public and the Authorities will be unable to hide form the results of this and it will adversely impact on their ongoing investigations maybe so much so that any further investigation will be so severely flawed that there will be no chance of achieving a conviction.

Col ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

and it is left to the individual to prove there innocense. The assumption is that you must be guilty otherwise, why have you been arrested and brought to court. You are not assumed to be innocent and the court must prove you guilty. You start off with the assumption you are guilty and you must establish your innocense backed up with corroberated evidence. This is very much like the courts of France, Italy and Spain as well as a lot of other nations. Procedurally it is different from the common law type of jurisprudence but who are we to say it is wrong???

The woman may or may not be guilty of smuggling but she is guilty of arrogance and stupidity and being stupidly unobservant. If she had any sort of sense at all, she would never have touched that bag if she suspected that it had been tampered with. Her arrogance and that of her ignorant family has landed her in this trouble; after all who are these funny little men to dare interfere with a nice white Australian girl and her family. On the basis of the defence that was presented she got what she deserved and is lucky she didn't lose her life. She will probably only serve about 3-4 years at most and the Indonesians under a diplomatic gesture of magnaminity will probably release and deport her. She and her stupid family literally shot her in the foot. The evidence that was presented was non-corroborated and/or contaminated. Under those terms she did as well as could be expected. Arrogance coupled with intense stupidity will do you in almost every time. Sure it's a tough sentence but the bleeding heart liberals are now going to damage the case further because there continued meddling will prevent the Indonesians from backing down so as not to lose face. Get real people would you want another nation meddling in our judicial system; well neither do the Indonesians. Don't forget the laws against double jeopardy don't exist there. If the prosecution believes the sentence is too lenient he has the right to appeal for a stiffer term and she could still be given a death sentence. Whether or not she will admit her responsibility, as soon as she picked up that bag she was responsible for it. Even here she would have been held responsible for it but she really screwed herself over royally by treating the officials with a contempt they did not deserve. Her and her family's reaction were what started the problem and the rest played out as we have seen. She and her family are what people with more brains and class would refer to here, as trailer trash. A little humility on her and her families part might have gone a long way to save her from this. I'm having a hard time really feeling sorry for her. I think her problem has been largely self inflicted.

Dawg ]:)

by deepsand

In fact, Indonesian law uses the "presumption of innocence" concept.

Where it [b]does[/b] differ form US law is that Indonesian law uses the European model of trial by Tribunal, as opposed to trial by Jury.

by black panther

This is all very true Col -

I also wonder what would have happened if Corby was not attractive or emotional ie What would have happened if the media did not take up the story ( as they did in this case )

There have been hundreds of Ozzies convicted ( some which have also pleaded they are guilty ) for 'Drug Smuggling' in Thailand and Indonesia but why have we heard only about this one in 'mammoth' proportions?

Apparently if she was 'aquitted' a lot of people would have made a lot of money!

I am not sure if she is guilty or innocent ( just as with the case for Azaria Chamberlain ) but whatever happens -

do we all deserve the same media attention given to Corby? :)

by hal 9000

However it will not happen and other than the Bali 9 who have been picked up since the Corby incident there is next to no news being broadcast when things like this happen. Even with those 9 people in Bali now the media has screwed up their defense by getting them to admit to knowingly being there to smuggle things out of Bali and have brought off their families with "Exclusive" contracts for their stories.

But the Media started out by getting it wrong and then in an attempt to make things right they started throwing money at the problem. The Mother is over there at the expense of a Media outlet and her stay is being paid for by the same company. Of course it was great press to have her in the court when the conviction was read out which I very much suspect was the desired result by the TV networks, why settle for a live coverage of the final court appearance when you can have the mother and the bulk of the family there to lash out at the surrounding people? A script writer couldn't have done a better job of it.

Personally I don't know if she is innocent or guilty either but the fact that she was picked up entering Bali and not leaving AU tends to make me think that something isn't quite so right in this case. Also the fact that she was picked up entering Bali with pot doesn't make any sense either it just wouldn't be worth the effort taking pot to Bali where it is as cheap as chips and freely available. It would be like taking opium to Afghanistan where the stuff is grown makes absolutely no sense what so ever.

The amount was far too much for personal use even if she was caring for several people and the money derived from selling that amount of pot on the streets of Bali just wouldn't have been worth the risk and most likely if the intention was to make money to pay for the trip she would have lost out. At best she could only hope to cover her hotel bills if that with the proceeds of the sale of that amount of pot.

The last time I visited Indonesia or the Philippines I can't remember which it was the customs guy hit the person in front of me to see some AU money and them kept it as a pay off not to go through his bags with a fine tooth comb when I was asked the same question I just held up a bit of plastic and said I only use this I don't carry money. But everyone is so poor over there that have to make money where ever possible so bribes are the name of the game and if you just accept this you will not have any problems.

Col ]:)

by garion11

http://talkleft.com/new_archives/010678.html

And the latest: A police report yesterday shows that a slew of baggage handlers were arrested in a cocaine smuggling scheme at the same Australian airport she departed from on the same day...but the Indonesian Court won't hear about it because the trial is over. Here's more on the baggage handler's use of unsuspecting fliers' luggage to smuggle drugs.

Stuff like this...

Another thing that doesn't make sense is the price of pot in Bali. Noone imports pot into Bali, its the other way around. Again things just don't add up...I agree that there were some incredible mishaps by Qantas, AU government etc but the Indonesian justice system is not even hearing about whatever evidence there is out there. In their eyes she is guilty before being proven otherwise.

by hal 9000

Look at the OJ trial he was considered as guilty and walked away a free man. But at the civil action brought against him where the rules of evidence do not apply he got convicted and had to pay up.

The problem here is not the Indonesian Legal System or the Government but the inability of the AU Government to step in and explain things to the Indonesian Government and then just allow things to go away. In the case of the imported cocaine it was actually brought into AU on the same day that Corby left and at the same airport Sydney.

However the defense did raise this point about the imported cocaine but because they could provide no direct link between the cocaine and the pot it was ruled as inadmissible as firstly the crime did not happen in Indonesia and even more importantly there was nothing to link the cocaine importation with the pot exportation to Bali.

However I do agree with your last paragraph the importing of that small amount of pot to Bali just makes absolutely no sense. The chairman of Qantas was on National TV claiming that his staff where all honest that that nothing like ferrying drugs between cities in passengers baggage could happen he was shown the now famous case of one of the baggage handlers stealing a camel suit from baggage and wearing it around the runway side of the airport, his response was that wouldn't be one of my staff and the implication is that security is so lax that anyone can walk in do as they please and them walk out without getting caught. Two days latter the now ex Qantas baggage handler appeared in court for stealing the Camel suit.

Col ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

Otherwise why would you have been arrested and brought to court. BTW this is the way most legal systems around the world work. This is the way it is in France, Italy and Spain just for openers. It is only in countries that work under the common law system like Britain, Canada, the USA, Australia and New Zealand, as the primary examples, where you are presumed innocent before being proved guilty. There is seldom, if ever, a jury of your peers. The evidence that was presented was tainted and would have been rejected here under our rules of evidence. Her team put up a very poor defence and her arrogance didn't help her situation. She probably did not understand that the honus was on her to prove her innocense not the prosecution to prove her guilty.
The prosecution assumed that she was guilty; why else was she in court???

Dawg ]:)

by deepsand

In fact, Indonesian law uses the "presumption of innocence" concept.

Where it does differ form US law is that Indonesian law uses the European model of trial by Tribunal, as opposed to trial by Jury.

by maxwell edison

.
I'm curious about that. What's the general consensus down there. Was it really planted or is she just claiming it was planted. The US prisons, as you probably could guess, are full of "innocent" people.

by black panther

or "20 year" question:-

This is the 'crux' of the matter. If it can be proved who planted it then 'Case Closed'!.

The real issue is that the Defence Team ( Indonesian ) did not do ALL that could be done, but on the other hand why would they spend any extra budget on trying to prove her as innocent as against guilty??

There was no finger-printing done on the drug
!

There was no research done on where it may have come from ie grown!

I think the matter has become 'highly emotional' due to the extensive media coverage as well.

On the other side ( recent post )

also wonder what would have happened if Corby was not attractive or emotional ie What would have happened if the media did not take up the story ( as they did in this case )

There have been hundreds of Ozzies convicted ( some which have also pleaded they are guilty ) for 'Drug Smuggling' in Thailand and Indonesia but why have we heard only about this one in 'mammoth' proportions?

Apparently if she was 'aquitted' a lot of people would have made a lot of money!

I am not sure if she is guilty or innocent ( just as with the case for Azaria Chamberlain ) but whatever happens -

do we all deserve the same media attention given to Corby?

by hal 9000

I don't know Maxwell but what I can say for certain is that it makes absolutely no sense taking that amount of pot to Bali.

You can buy pot or harder drugs on just about every street corner or so I've been told as I've never actually been there as it is considered as a Yuppy Place to holiday at.

But what I do know is that there have been major security breaches at Sydney airport and it is not inconceivable that it was planted if you pardon the pun. :D Of course a lot of our jails here are filled with self proclaimed innocent people as well. ;)

Col ]:)

by jck

Send her to me...I'll spank her and tell her she's a bad girl ]:)

by maxwell edison

.
The American "war on drugs" is no more than an effort to raise an ENORMOUS amount of revenue (confiscated money and property) for law enforcement agencies. Not only that, as I am totally consistent with my principles of individual liberty, it's the epitome of infringement to tell a person he can't drink a beer, smoke some tobacco, smoke some weed, or whatever else he may select to indulge himself.

by oz_media

Funny how we agree on more than I originally realized.

WIth the laws on drugs though, you did state it quite simply and I agree about letting people do as they choose, but we do need stiff regulations enforced when it comes to drinking in public, driving drunk etc. Really, as I am sure you also agree, alcohol is FAR more dangerous to the user AND anyone around the user than smoking marijuana.

You can drive stoned, read, walk talk, etc. You don't lose the ability to control your basic motor skills, some people slow down quite a bit, but in regular smokers you wouldn't know if they were stoned or not and they function in the day to day world and workforce just as anyone else would.

I remember at age 16 going to science class high on LSD (kids huh?) where we grew pot plants in the unaware, teacher's window planters. I was called up to the front of the class to explain light refraction and did a bang up job of it too! I was asked to not use power tools in metal shop but that was fair be me.

For the most part, whensmoking dope, people never knew I was high unless I wanted them to.

You CAN'T do things under the influence of alcohol though, the impairment is far too uncontrollable. Lifting the prohibition and taxing alcohol and tobacco has resulted in BILLIONS and BILLIONS sunk into our economies,it feeds our nations.

I am quite convinced that IF the government could control distribution and tax it, marijuana would be completely legal in the USA and Canada, as it once was. But they have NO HOPE on controlling cultivation, you don't need a farm to grow a crop (a closet will do), and they can't control distribution.

So they are left with one solution, making it illegal. If they don't benefit from it, they will be damned if someone else does (and scams welfare at the same time). They must remove that liberty, we are not earning or paying for that liberty, therefore it is not ours to enjoy.

by oz_media

First of all, the Cannabis Cafe in BC, operated by Marc Emery of the BC Marijuana Party, had been raided and shut down several times, before it was finally closed permanently. The BC Hemp stores are everywhere, but they don't sell pot over the counter. they sell HEMP seeds, no THC value, they sell herbal oils, pipes, papers etc. as hese are all legal items. They sell books on cultivation, hemp clothing (VERY expensive but definitely the most durable and comfortable clothing around) and that kid of ZEN type stuff, the idea is to promote the wide spead uses for hemp products and the number of people interested in that culture.

The Hemp Cafe (in Vancouver) originally had vaporizer bongs on the table, whee you could smoke your own stash if you chose, but that was ousted pretty damn quick and has been rattlingaround in courts for years now.

There was a see and book shop in East Vancouver that was shut down, reopened and shuty down again recently, They were selling POUNDS of BC Bud each day and actually had a full business licence and permit to sell pot.

THere was some argument over whether they had lied to obtain it or whether the clerk had simply not been paying attention, but they're gone too.

The issue is such a fine line, you can't stop someone from selling HERBS or HERBAL oils and incences, thus they need the tools to do so, enter bongs papers and pipes, there is no criminal charge for posession of small amounts, and there aren't enough trees here to make enough paper for the tickets. So for the most part, they don't care if you're not in their face about it. DO your thing and they do there's. They do attend teh annual marihuana smoke ins in Vancouver without arrests though, again, people are all together doing their thing, unless they create a disturbance it's left be, they even supply traffic police for the parade where band and floats parade to the beach.

It's like being treated like adults I suppose. Act responsibly and as long as nobody is harmed, there is no harm done.

by garion11

Now that is something I would have never thought of.

And I agree, Amsterdam is one fine place.;).

Its a shame that America doesn't have a city like that...or Canada. How much tourism is North America losing to Amsterdam?

by hal 9000

Because it was a slow news day or the AU Media had engineered a dramatic Court Room Scene by having the Mother there.

Did you get to see the mother tear into the Judges? Or the sister tear into people outside the court?

We have been hearing about this case ever since the media mucked it up by claiming that she was going over to Bali to visit her Sister that owns a Surf Shop there with the inference that she was guilty because she didn't need to take a boogie board with her as her sister had hundreds to chose from. From that point on when they where proved wrong they started trying to make amends by reporting the facts instead of unsubstituted rumor.

But what you will not have heard is that today after a lengthy investigation one of AU biggest airports has major security issues that range from cleaners to pilots all being responsible for importing drugs and stealing things. Of course they will not mention the name of the airport "yet anyway" but it has to be Sydney as that is the largest International Airport on the Eastern Seaboard. Along with Qantas being the largest carrier of people out of AU you are left with a major problem of not flying Qantas and attempting one of the smaller carriers who all have reciprocal agreements with each other so even if you where to book and pay one of the other airlines you still might find yourself on a Qantas aircraft on the way out or on the way back in.

After all the dealings that I've had with Qantas I try not to get on their aircraft but that is a personal thing. :D

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

The only thing that could have been done that was not was to finger print the bag with the drugs in it. This was not done and is grounds for the appeal process as it was refused by the court. But by the same token by that stage so many people had handled it it is doubtful that anything useful could have been gleaned and it is even possible that Corby herself was handed the bag.

What the Judges ruled on was two simple facts one there where drugs in a bag and two Corby admitted owning the bag.

There are several things wrong with this however and they all amount to the actions of Corby's brother who picked up the bag and took it to customs. If it had of been left to Corby herself she may have seen something wrong and failed to claim it or call customs over and claim that the bag had been tampered with. Now if this had of happened there would not be a problem. The brother didn't help one little bit in this case.

If you look at the whole trip from the start in Brisbane to finish in Bali it was a stuff up by all the parties concerned. And there is enough blame to go around to all the parties involved. No one in this particular case is beyond reproach for allowing this to happen but the Judges are being made the scape goats for the whole mess.

Today a report was released that Sydney airport had a multitude of security breaches from cleaners to pilots and everyone in between but again even this doesn't prove that Corby did not pack the pot and attempt to carry it Internationally it only makes it less likely and if things are as bad as they have been made out to be at Sydney Airport they will not be much better at other airports either here in AU.

What is really counter productive in this case is the Headlines in todays Bali Newspaper claiming that Australians who donated money for the relief effort after the Boxing Day disaster want their money refunded as a result of the Corby verdict. Currently most of the people in Bali think that she is guilty and this type of Headline doesn't help her at all as it makes it look as if the Australians think that they can do as they please and the poor people in Bali just have to accept what they do without question.

Now the AU Government knew what was going on when Corby was arrested and have done absolutely nothing about it they could and should have approached the Indonesian Government and told them of their suspicions and the whole mess would have been soughed out then and there and the public would not have become involved. Of course Ms Corby would have been asked to leave Bali on the next aircraft and have been held in "Protective Custody" until the aircraft was available and if that had of happened it would have been a far better outcome than what has since happened.

Now the Indonesian Government can not appear to back down to a request by the AU Government as it will look as if they are bowing to pressure and they would loose face and at the same time make people world wide think that it was open season for drug smuggling from there as all that would be required is pressure being placed on the Government by your Countries Government to get you off.

Now that the mess has been made it is going to take a lot of very Diplomatic work to get around and it will all be behind the scenes but if she is released by any other means than a Court action it will appear that Indonesia has bowed to outside pressure and the Local AU Media Services will all be claiming that they where responsible while those in Indonesia will be saying that they have a weak Government who caves in at the first sign of outside pressure being applied.

The best option now is for the Corby family to accept the AU Governments offer of 2 QC's to work on the appeal and with a bit of luck they will place enough evidence before the higher courts to quash the conviction and deport the girl from their country, but we will have to wait and see what the family is prepared to do now.

Col ]:)

by oz_media

I already got tangled up in the sex,drugs, rock n roll thing. Kicked a coke habit that would have seen me dead within a year, quit all the other stuff (pills, acid etc.).

SOMETIMES, and I mean once in a blue moon, I'll have a quick puff if one's going around (say while drinking with friends on a Friday night), but not normally though.

But I don't inhale. Though now I have the time, nature and solitude to actually sit back and enjoy it, I find I get just as awed by this place without it.

by itgirli

There are "head shops" all over the fine state of Delaware (my home away from home). Glass items and hemp clothing. About one on every corner in Rehoboth.

by oz_media

I would have no roof over my head, or would be dead. I would be in debt with some of the WRONG people, dealers I met in the music industry don't usually come from street corners or stoner friends, they are serious businessmen, with bikes.

I was spending thousands as if they were $5 bills, it is NOT a good idead and quitting was my only way out and what a saviour that was!

My best friend, and business partner at that time was about 6'4" built like a birck s**thouse, healthy as can be, very active and health concious but he had a coke problem too. We were basing a ball one night and he dropped and hard a massive heart attack right in front of me. He is now paralyzed down one side, will be on medication for the rest of his life (to strengthen and help his heart) etc. No thanks, not interested.

But being in teh Bud capital of the world, I do partake in the odd puff or two if out on the bikes, boating etc. as most people I know smoke and there's always one going around it seems. I find I don't really get baked anymore though, too many yeas of smoking, it just mellows me out a bit and lightens the mood enhances a few beers etc.

But yeah, as far as the Cid, Coke, Shrooms, Bennies etc. I'm proud to be a quitter, bailed before it got the better of me and killed me too.

Now I can actually focus and help people achieve thier goalsin the industry, the bands that are heavy drug users have less and less chance of makin git nowdays, the business is too busy and you simply can't be screwed up and survive it now.

by itgirli

I would be to scared to try that hard stuff in the first place. I'm a sissy.

by deepsand

See
[v]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=175104&messageID=1781268[/v]

by oz_media

Fly her tro my place, will split the profits 50/50 and she'll be home by the morning.

by deepsand

Article 8 of the Indonesian Judiciary Law and Article 18 of the Indonesian Human Rights Law state that every person who is arrested, detained, charged or brought before a court has the right to be considered innocent until proven guilty.

Article 66 of the Indonesian Code of Criminal Procedure likewise provides that "the obligation of proof is not to be imposed upon the accused or defendant".

by black panther

In the same article:-

Indonesian law places the burden of proof on the prosecution and provides for a presumption of innocence similar to that which applies in Australia.

and in saying so -- all the proof they needed was:--

The drug was in her bag!

by black panther

In the same article:-

Indonesian law places the burden of proof on the prosecution and provides for a presumption of innocence similar to that which applies in Australia.

and in saying so -- all the proof they needed was:--

The drug was in her bag!

by deepsand

I myself held the same belief as you.

The difference is that I've lived long enough to have put my foot into it too many times to risk repeating that mistake in public.

So, I researched the matter, and saved myself the embarrassment.

by black panther

Too err is human.. to forgive divine!

We all make mistakes but how many of us actually admit it!

I don't see too many on this site!