Australian soldiers are so good
that in order to suffer casualities in Iraq, they have to do it themselves.
Community archive
that in order to suffer casualities in Iraq, they have to do it themselves.
by hal 9000
Have told me are similar but it's extremely hard to understand them as they tend to only talk about their experiences in Nan when [b]Severely Drunk and are LEGLESS at the time that they let things Slip.[/b] :^0
One of the Gulf War Vets will not speak about his experiences there either unless well and truly under the influence of the [b]Daemon Drink[/b] I learn far more about his time spent in the Gulf by cleaning out his computer that what I ever hear from him and he was a Surgeon. So instead of Beer He's into the Expensive Scotch particularly on the [b]DRY[/b] US Navy Ships.
If he wasn't such a funny guy I would never put up with his [b]Blackmail[/b] but as I can't help but laugh when he's standing over me with a Scalpel and insists that he's so worried about some computer that his hand might slip of course by this time he's already made the first cut so I just accept things and do the work. :p
But what really gets me worried is when I get a phone call from him telling me that I have an appointment to see him then I know that something really nasty has happened and he wants it fixed but is unwilling to ask me unless I'm at a severe disadvantage. :_|
Col ]:)
by dawgit
by hal 9000
I find this story hard to believe as I know what these people are taught about the firearms that they carry and use.
More likely it's one of the [b]Substandard Brendon Nelson's[/b] supplied Rifles that has caused this to happen. I just can not imagine any possibility where a Regular Army person could do such a thing accidentally and if they wanted to do it they wouldn't have made such a mess of it they would have killed them self immediately.
I would put it down to the WW1 ammo that is supplied to them that doesn't fit the weapons that the AU Army supplies.
Col
by jardinier
He's my local Federal Representative.
We used to be great buddies until the article below was published in a local free magazine. The next time I walked into his office, everybody looked at me as if I had horns and a tail. ]:)
[b]The Story Of Bradfield Electorate
By Julian Hancock[/b]
Liberal and Labour allegiances are enigmatically entwined in the Federal seat of Bradfield. Created after a redistribution in 1948, the first election for the new seat was held in 1949. While this election led to the establishment of the first Liberal Government under Sir Robert Menzies, it also introduced as the first representative for Bradfield, William Morris Hughes ? ?The little digger? ? who had been Prime Minister of Australia under a Labour-led coalition from 1915 to 1917. After a party split over the conscription of Australian men for World War I, Billy Hughes formed a coalition with the conservatives. He served as Prime Minister in the Conservative Government until 1923 when he resigned.
Earlier in his career, in 1894, he was elected to the New South Wales Parliament, representing the Lang district of Sydney as a member of the Labour Party. In the beginning of last century, he was involved in the creation of the current Labor Party. (Please note the new spelling of Labor).
Our incumbent representative, Dr Brendan Nelson, came from a strong Labour background and was for many years a member of the Labour Party. In 1995 he stood down from his position as Federal President of the Australian Medical Association to become the endorsed Liberal Party Candidate for the seat of Bradfield.
Between these two Labour-turned-Liberal representatives, the seat has been held by Henry Turner (1952 ? 1974) and David Connolly (1974 ? 1996). For more than half a century since its inception, Bradfield has been a safe Liberal Seat.
The primary vote in Bradfield at the 1998 election was distributed as follows: Nelson (LP) 64.37%; Kailainathan (ALP) 18.80%; Morris (DEM) 7.81%; Webeck (HAN) 3.82%; Allas (GRN); 2.99%; Informal 2.85%; Ratcliffe (CDP) 1.66%; Kiely (NLP) 0.56%. On a two-party preferred basis, the result was: Nelson (LP) 73.20%; Kailainathan (ALP) 26.80%. Bradfield is still a VERY safe Liberal seat.
However, nothing lasts forever. Taking into consideration the widespread criticism of the current Federal administration, both from the general public and from within Mr Howard?s own Government, it would seem inevitable that the already declining Liberal primary vote in Bradfield (down from 70% in 1993 to 64% in 1998) will slip back even further in this year?s election.
The new Labor candidate for Bradfield, Mrs Kathie Blunt, who was profiled in the July edition of the KO, is determined to spread the Labor ?gospel? as far and widely as possible. I do not carry a banner for any particular party or candidate, but I am concerned that such an imbalance of representation as we have in this electorate may not be a healthy situation. I suspect it could, or probably already has led to apathy on the part of traditional Liberal voters, and a feeling of impotence or futility on the part of Labor and would-be Labor voters.
Our electorate is named after Dr John Job Crew Bradfield who, as a highly qualified engineer built, among other things, the Sydney Harbour Bridge. Perhaps we could use this as a symbol to work towards bridging the gap between people of differing political persuasions, so that we can all work together to build a better Australia.
by hal 9000
If I attempt to get my Great Uncles name pulled from that Electorate who it was named after do you think it would help?
It might not make any difference to the [b]Squatting Member[/b] but at least my Family's name wouldn't be involved with someone responsible for providing substandard equipment to our Military Personal.
Col ]:)
by sleepin'dawg
by hal 9000
There is either something wrong or missing here as this [b]Can Not Happen![/b]
Currently I'm putting it down to the substandard equipment that the Aussie Diggers are issued until I can be proved wrong.
Col
by sleepin'dawg
this is one discussion that should be dropped because the potential of a personal human tragedy should be beyond anyone trying to score any kind of point off. Maybe it's an accident; maybe it isn't but to continue in this vein is in poor taste to an extreme. Anyone who knows anything about firearms and specifically the shoulder operated variety, knows what I am talking about. All things considered, this should be left alone on the grounds of common decency or human compassion. Further pursuit is tastless.
Just my two cents, for what they're worth.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by jardinier
by sleepin'dawg
Maybe you aren't trying to make a point; just the same if you have any sense of decency, you will drop this.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by mjwx
And this was the third of my countrymen to die in Iraq. It's a pointless and senseless waste of life.
OK, the way Jules put this article across was IMO a bit tasteless but it's tragic none the less.
Col, the styer is an underpowered rifle anyway (regardless of its manufactured quality). We should replace them with a decent rifle like the SA80.
by hal 9000
I still find this hard to understand how it happened. These guys can strip down clean and reassemble their weapons blindfolded and under 20 feet of water with out a single problem and then somehow someone accidentally shoots them self in the head. NAW this just doesn't sound right to me anyway.
But I do agree the sooner that those firearms are replaced with decent weapons the better!
Col
by gilsbugs
by hal 9000
I'm not going to climb up on that SOAP BOX as I'll never get off. It's better never to ask questions like that because the answers are not at all nice and are defiantly not something to be discussed in a [b]PUBLIC FORUM![/b]
Col
by gilsbugs
Sorry to be late-but as we all most likely do-"work 27/8"-and then the stuff at home.......
Anywaaaay..........Some things are better left unsaid. I believe that it's a rather,Extremely serious question that does not belong in this forum, nor this site..........
by stand fast
If you speak to any experienced Veteren you'll find they hold the Australian armed forces in the highest respect. Well heck they have fought along side the US in every war we have started. With war history Gallipoli and the countless battle with the Japs in WWII has shown they are a formidable force. The Aussie SAS where in Iraq doing recon even before this current conflict.
As for the cause of the accident we will have to see what the report brings. My condolences go out to the soldier's family as it does to all the families of the US forces who have lost a family member. My son is a US Marine, this deal isn't nice but regardless of what you think about it politically we need to show 100% support for theese guys.
by jardinier
The most recent news I have read said that he was a sniper and accidentally shot himself while cleaning his rifle.
And yes, I and I am sure all other Australians support our troops despite what we may think about becoming involved in the first place.
Incidentally here is something for you to think about. Australian Vietnam vets were not scorned on their return home, and they march proudly with all the other vets of various wars on our national day of remembrance, ANZAC day (Australia and New Zealand Army Corps) on April 25.
The day starts with a dawn service in the centre of the city, which a great many people attend.
by hal 9000
Of what the Vets do after the ANZAC Day March whatever you do. :^0
Col
by jardinier
[Yes I know you hate being addressed correctly]
]:) I am most honoured to know that my electorate was named after a relative of yours.
I am sure you would know that Bradfield was a real visionary who planned for infrastructure well into the future.
There are in existence certain railway tunnels that were started under his advice but never completed. Now -- 70 years or so more later -- there is chaos in Sydney as these oversights are being recognised and belatedly attended to.
by hal 9000
John Bradfield wanted to turn all the coastal rivers inland and dam them so we would have a ready supply of water. I don't think I need to tell you what we don't have now do I? :p
He was also responsible for starting the Engineers Society as well as being a head Lecturer at the Sydney University he got his way there and [b]Warped Young Minds to His Way of Thinking.[/b] :^0
A throughly nice guy who knew what was required even if those in Power at the time lacked the ability to see further than the end of their noses. :(
Col ]:)
[i]PS This time I'll let you get away with the [b]DR[/b] rubbish but I'm not responsible or punishable for Hijacking any threads right![/i]
by jardinier
Well here's the latest news on this unfortunate incident, but it beats the hell out of me how "one of Australia's most highly trained and respected snipers" could accidentally shoot himself in the head with a hand gun.
http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/dead-digger-was-elite-sniper/2006/04/23/1145730796376.html
by dave.clarke
Why you would make some form of cynical reference to an Australian soldier being killed in this manner? What purpose does it serve?
You are a disgrace.
I hope you think of your appalling sense of humour when you [hopefully] think of those who gave their lives in war tomorrow (ANZAC day).
I'm sure the only dawn service you'd see tomorrow is breakfast in bed.
by jardinier
It wasn't meant to be cynical. It was meant as a compliment to Australian soldiers who have not suffered a single casualty in Iraq at the hands of the enemy.
But how would you have phrased it?
"The first casualty among Australian troops in Iraq was a soldier who accidentally shot himself."
Does that sound any more respectful?
Whatever way you look at it the situation is ironical.
by mjwx
Sorry but I don?t have the links off hand
The first stepped on a landmine
The second was run over in a training accident
And the third is this poor bloke we're talking about.
by stand fast
I think they call it a s--t stirrer.... Smile
Aussie definition for someone who likes to create controversy.
Seriously jardinier your Ok..... Just having some fun.
by jardinier
avoided making any reference to whatever it is your are referring to. :)
And once again I apologise for my tacky way of presenting this unfortunate incident.
by stand fast
by hal 9000
I went out with a couple of Vets yesterday for the March and a few drinks afterwards. The [b]Evil SODS[/b] promised that I'd be home no latter than 2.00 PM. I've still got the headache and whats worse no one would accept my wife as a wager as I tried so hard to lose her on the turn of a couple of pennies. :^0
They stole my mobile phone and turned it off and I didn't arrive home till well after 11.00 PM well and truly re-hydrated. Then I found out that I had a urgent Service Call to do again a put up by one of those [b]SOB's![/b] :_|
I hate [b]RUM & Milk[/b] and after several gallons of the stuff felt throughly sick only then to be greeted by the sounds of a Gun Ship from Nam being played at Audio Assault levels. I'm way toooooo Old for this and [b]Never Again[/b] No matter what is promised will I accompany that lot of crazy Barstewards ever again! :D
No not next year and no matter how much they beg or threaten me will I ever consider it. Oh my head still hurts. :_|
Col ]:)
by mjwx
I was told by someone who was in the army (some time ago but it shouldn?t matter) that when you are handling your weapon you keep it pointed away from you. He told me that under no circumstances should a weapon be held towards one's person, especially whilst loaded.
Using my limited knowledge of forensics (one semester in year 12 science) and my equally limited knowledge of firearms I also cannot determine how this soldier could have done it...
by accident. Even if the weapon malfunctioned why was a trained soldier looking into the barrel of a loaded weapon, is it not procedure to unload a weapon before performing maintenance. If this was a deliberate act the army for several reasons (not the least of which is the guys family) why the army would deliberately misreport it. My question is what could have bought him to do it after one month.
This could have been the result of enemy action in an ongoing operation and the army was forced to reveal the soldiers death whilst withholding operational details.
Now I'm in full conspiracy theory mode.
We need better weapons (the 80's) but our govt. is too frugal. The yanks need better weapons also, M16?s are still being dropped for AK?s.
by hal 9000
I can not understand how an accident like this could happen particularly with someone who's supposedly so highly trained.
More to the point I've spoken to a couple of people who will be marching tomorrow [25-4-06] and they can't understand it either. If the reports are accurate No One that I've spoken to can understand how it happened. I've been told that to clean this particular weapon the breach has to be locked open and empty so for fairly obvious reasons there can be no chance of a misfire occurring. The only thing that someone has suggested as this was a [b]Side Arm[/b] that the person involved may have just pulled it out of the holster and taken a look down the barrel to see if it needed cleaning and it had a faulty Safety which allowed the misfire but they all insist that he would have to be well and truly under the weather for something like this to happen but it's possible that the safety was not working and as he laid the unit on a table prior to starting to begin dismantling to clean it misfired and it was a Ricochet that got him.
Unlucky but [b]S_H_I_T Happens![/b]
Col
by jardinier
by jardinier
A web search revealed only two, including the current victim:
http://icasualties.org/oif/Country.aspx?hndRef=AUS
And yet the story I posted lists a pilot:
[i]In January last year Flight Lieutenant Paul Pardoel, a RAAF-trained C-130 navigator on contract to the RAF, died when his aircraft was shot down north of Baghdad.[/i]
There have also been two Australian journalists killed:
Paul Moran, freelance cameraman for the Australian Broadcasting Corporation, March 22, northern Iraq.
Australian sound engineer for NBC News, died July 6 at military hospital in Germany from wounds suffered June 29 in a grenade attack on a military vehicle in Fallujah.
Well one death is one too many. Thank you Messrs Bush, Blair and HOWARD.
by jardinier
As I drive past Brendan Nelson's office every day, I shall endeavour to obtain precise details.
There was a long period (after THAT article was published) when I could not get any replies to my emails to him. It turned out that a member of his staff was apparently intercepting the emails so that they never reached the good doctor.
When that particular staff member left, everything changed. As the former Federal President of the Australian Medical Association AND a practising Roman Catholic, I asked for his opinion on stem cell research.
I received a form letter with some handwritten comments added. And then I received a phone call from his secretary apologising profusely for accidentally sending me the draft of the letter instead of a retyped letter.
So I guess I will get straight answers in future.
by mjwx
So they may not be entirely accurate but all three incidences happened. You kind of remember individual deaths when you can count them on one hand.
Like Stalin said "the death of one is a tragedy, the death of a million is a statistic".
by stand fast
by hal 9000
I don't know where it started but most likely it took off during WW1 where their Rum Ration had to be stretched out so they used powered Milk. :)
Anyway now days they start the day off with a little rum and a lot of milk and eventually end up with a bottle of milk to show the full tumbler of Rum so they can still make out that they are drinking Rum & Milk. :^0
According to my now Dead Father in Law the milk was to put a coating on the stomach so they could drink more of that terrible mess and as the day wore on the amount of milk dropped off. :D
Anyway it's terrible and what's worse they expect you to drive even though you are only 15 times over the [b]Legal Limit[/b] and unable to stand let alone walk. I could have handled this as I was under [b]Medical Supervision[/b] as one or several of those I was with where Quacks from different conflicts ranging up to the Peace Keeping Efforts in Rwanda. They where the worst of the offenders as well I might add. :_|
It's just not going to happen again no matter how much they try to threaten me to accompany them I knew better previously but this time I must have been [b]Drunk[/b] when I agreed to go with them for [b]Immoral Support.[/b] :p
The whole lot of them are [b]Totally Insane & Proud of It![/b] ;\
Col ]:)
Something to help for next time...
by jardinier
if the topic is NOT controversial?
I would say it is a pretty general rule here that any discussion which does NOT lend itself to controversy, immediately degrades into an endless exchange of light-hearted repartee. This appeals to some people who use the discussions to unwind from the stress of work.
Here is an example of a discussion which is entirely playful banter and as such of NO interest to me personally:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=189216&start=0
I have plenty of opportunity for repartee with REAL (as distinct from cyber) people each day, and so I am only interested in discussions which provoke thought.
I am considered a sh*t stirrer by some people here simply because I am not: PRO America; PRO George Bush; PRO war and violence; PRO multiple personal firearms; ANTI global warming (myth); ANTI alleged left-wing commie media; and so the list goes on.
Thanks for the kudos though.
by stand fast
I see you like to liven the discussion, that cool. As I said I was just having some fun with you jardinier. Your ok.
I feel the same way about the issues you spoke of at the end of your post too.
Have you seen Loose Change 2 yet? If not Goggle it and you may be another dicussion starter for you.
Thanks
by jardinier
I have been accused several times of poor taste in starting this thread.
I have apologised for the way I worded the post.
Please DO NOT demonstrate MUCH WORSE TASTE by turning it into a comedy routine.
by stand fast
The truth is a rare things and it appears it the same here. Makes you wonder if the body swap deal may be trying to buy some time for someone ha.
Keep us up to date.
by hal 9000
I'm never ever going out with that lot again no matter what! :(
I don't even plan on attending Parties at any of their houses again! :p
I've seen the light and been cured. :^0
But on a side note getting back to the original intent of this thread not a single one of the people that I was drinking with or any of the other people there believed the [b]Official Lie[/b] for a single second. To these guys the so called explanation doesn't make any sense and they are all talking about [b]Another Army Cover UP again.[/b]
Col ]:)
by jardinier
I stopped following this story when it started turning into a media circus. [It was pushed from number one story when two men were trapped in a mine in Sydney. They are OK ].
However today I called into Brendan Nelson's office and spoke to his secretary, Lee Hall. [I am not exactly her favourite person after THAT article and some derogatory letters by myself about Howard and Nelson in the local free newspaper. She is happy however to talk endlessly about how her husband, Tony Hall, a member of the local council, has been mistreated, misjudged and so forth].
Anyhow she did have the courtesy to answer my question, and explained that an enquiry was taking place and even the Minister for Defence would not have anything to say until the results of the enquiry are released.
And a little side note to Col and other Aussies. I knew Nelson before he became a cabinet minister. HOWEVER, upon being upgraded to the status of Minister for Education and Science, the glass outer wall of the reception area of his office is kept locked and can only be unlocked (to outsiders) from within by his secretary or other staff member. Now what the hell is he afraid of?
Additionally Col, I could see through the glass a large portrait that quite likely is of your uncle. But in order to check, I will have to wait until I have another excuse to confront the dragon lady.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending