Discussion Locked

Beat me up and steal my lunch money...

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What is the deal with the respondents in the TR forums lately? I have noticed a steady progression (or should I say regression) of individuals resorting to name calling and whining about another contributors comments (usually directed @ Oz for his harsh reply :)... but now even G.O.D and other members are receiving the same treatment.
Is this now the mentality of the technology sector?... are we no longer perceived as geeks but instead whiny babies who complain when things do not go their way, or "call other kids names"?
Well, sticks and stones....

23 replies

by onbliss

that we are Humans and then geeks :-))) There must be something fishing during the inheritance from huamns to geeks, for the Super Class takes the control.

by jkaras

Whoops I forgot someone already copyrighted that, I hope Michael Buffer is not a member. Life gets in the way at times and its refreshing to get some frustrations out every now and again. Hey its better than physically taking it out on someone, so flame on. Maybe a new phyla is created, grumpus erectus.

by guruofdos

may break my bones but whips and chains excite me.

Ooops, that should have been 'names can never hurt me'.

I'm thick skinned. I can take it. All I can say is that if someone wants me to call me something on here then let them. It doesn't change my opinion of myself or that of others who know or respect (or even barely tolerate!) me.

If somebody wishes to slag me off, defame me, slander me or libel me then fine. One word of warning! Defamatory, libelous or slanderous comments posted on a web-site available to public view are exactly the same as such remarks made in the press or on the media, and as such COULD be the grounds to commence legal action should I or anyone else desire so to do. Here in the UK, many internet users who have published defamatory remarks on web-sites HAVE been taken to court and successfully prosecuted. Not just in the UK either...it happens in other places too and I'm sure the USA with it's mentality of 'litigate, not mediate' has had similar cases. Libel and slander cases have attracted large sums in damages where it has been proven that such remarks have had a material effect on the health, reputation or well-being of an individual!

Me...I don't actually give a damn...you can call me what you like people. As I said, sticks and stones....

BUT...should any remarks, comments or opinions end up materially affecting my health or earning potential or upset my wife and children, then watch out.

Most of you on here who partake in debate with me on a regular basis know that I'm generally an easy going soul and enjoy some ribald banter as much as the next man (or woman). Just don't take it too far....I may bite!

by jellimonsta

I too do not take any offense at peoples slander. Everybody has opinion and it is just that, I do not really give a rats a$$ what they think.
I am just surprised at the mentality of the personal attacks by posters in these forums as of late. It seems people cannot take a little criticism and a difference of opinion and get defensive straight away.

by guruofdos

I referred to Oz an asshole once...but in the context in which I posted the comment I'm sure he didn't take it personally. He and I have developed something of a 'rapport' on here and we both know how far we can push a joke with each other without either of us throwing our toys out of the pram...well, usually. We may actually even meet in person for a beer in the next year or three!

I may pass comments on what I think, but I certainly wouldn't make a deliberately offensive remark to anybody or at least not knowingly. I appreciate some people may take offence at some things I say. No offence intended but my sense of humour does tend to be a little 'off the wall' at times.

There are many fine people on here who I respect and hold their opinions in high esteem. I may not always agree with them, and I may argue a point with them if I feel there is valid debate to be had. TheChas and Maxwell to name two often participate actively in discussions with myself (and many of the other regulars). We are agreed on many issues and yet we probably clash on as many others but usually we manage to remain polite, courteous and respectful even if we will never agree in a million years. If it all gets too much, we are happy to just let it drop and 'walk away'.

One or two members seem to like provocation. Not subtly or cleverly, but just downright obnoxious! In a recent posting regarding Kazaa I gave a 'harsh' answer, but I was polite and explained my answer fully. I was 'attacked' and for those who missed it, I quote:

>>So go pick on someone who has the time and patience to argue with you instead of venting all your built up frustration from your pitiful life out on me. By the way, thanks for your "stupid" reply.<<

I defended this 'attack' and was gratified to note that other members, while agreeing that I was perhaps a little 'out of character' in my post, rallied to my defence. I will be the first to jump in and defend another member if I see them maliciously targeted in discussions, but it's getting to the point where I can see it happening so often that it will just end up another forum for disruption and abuse and all the value of healthy debate will be lost in the flames.

As 'G.O.D' I am a benevolent kinda guy most of the time but when angered, I can get a head of steam up of truly Biblical proportions. Fortunately it is in my nature to be reasonably forgiving but some on here are truly 'unforgiveable'. They KNOW who they are. One member in particular, I know, has ruffled more than a few feathers...as yet they are not on my 'fire and brimstone' list but I'm sure it's only a matter of time. I'm not going to provoke them into it but when it does happen, the whole of TR will know about it because there are at least six others who will 'flash' before I do!

jkaras@ocpafl.org has already (in the same discussion I quoted) mentioned 'The slap that was heard around the world'. When the inevitable happens, you won't hear one slap...you'll hear a virtual round of applause. I'd rather this didn't happen....it might even spell the end of TR as we know it, but this person is spoiling for a real scrap and will probably end up starting one!

by jackofalltech

When I first joined TR, almost every member was a senior-level professional with many years of experience and most of the questions were hair-pullers that had been thoroughly researched before being posted here.

Now, I think most of the members are newbies and script-kiddies who ask stupid questions without even trying to do basic research and have not learned manners or graciousness in the college of life.

I'm seriously considering removing TR from my daily to-do list.

Ralph

by mrbill-

Ralph, Try to weather the storm out. Don?t let the ?newbies and script-kiddies? chase you away from a wonderful discussion forum. If you and the other veterans of the forum leave then the ?punks? win and that would be a shame. Maybe if we all ignored them they will go away on their own. It will be hard because they will try to incite you into a response but we are more mature than they are. They will get bored and leave because we can outlast them.

by guruofdos

I often 'flash' at the little turds! Perhaps the regulars should gang up on them, but in a co-ordinated manner and not just flying off the handle. If all of us 'old hands' spot a 'weener', we should all post identical replies. Whether that reply would be 'FUCK OFF!' or 'Why not ask your parents this stupid question?' or 'Sorry, it's past your bedtime!' is something we'd all have to agree on. But imagine a 'weeners' post, followed by thirty-seven replies all with the same put-down. Naturally it would make the Hot Topics list, and a very quick look would tell a regular that it's such a post....and then another identical reply could be posted.

This may or may not 'cure' the problem...but it would be an interesting excersise!

by guruofdos

The problem is... I have a TR problem! I used to just do TR once or twice a week. I thought 'I can control this...it isn't doing any harm'.

I used to just do the occasional debate, you know how it is....I was a 'social' debater. Now with the benefit of 20-20 hindsight I can see that I have become 'hooked'. I'm now doing TR two or three times a day and it's getting out of control. A couple of hours without catching up with Chas, Maxwell, Ralph and Lord Infidel and I start shaking, getting the jitters and wondering how long till my next 'fix'.

Unfortunately, organised 'whine' has taken over the site and the quality stuff is getting 'cut' with all kinds of nasty stuff. The 'weeners' are muscling in on the racket and the turf just ain't safe any more.

Seriously, it's nearly as bad as the newsgroups and internet chat rooms. Part of the problem is that internet access is so cheap and anyone can get on. In the good old days, you had to pay ?10 a month, or whatever, plus per minute connection charges for internet use at home. Kiddies only got on for ten minutes or so every few days to research their homework or visit the Disney site under supervision of their parents. You needed a credit card to set up a dial-up account and that kept the majority of the 'under 18s' off most of the time. I started my online life with AOL back in the very first days. Chat rooms just didn't have kids in them and you never got a/s/l'd every five minutes. You could meet other like minded adults and actually have a conversation! Of course, you came across the odd twat here and there. Nowadays, it's wall to wall with flying mobile phone numbers and 'hit 555 if you want to chat 2 me' every ten seconds. I long ago stopped using AOL chat and in fact I don't participate in any on-line chatting anymore (ok, I DO use AOL IM's to message the wife...she's an AOL user).

This discussion area as you said, used to be a forum for erudite conversation, sharing of knowledge and a chance to exchange ideas. Now it's turning to rat-shit like everything else in life that kids get hold of. I'd give it up in a heartbeat... but I'm addicted and I'd miss my 'friends'.

by jardinier

When I have no emails to answer, and when my three websites are sufficiently up to date, I head straight for TR. I have made some excellent friends here, none of whom I have actually met.

I don't find it a problem to ignore the crap and have stimulating interactions with the regular members who have a wide general knowledge and a great sense of humour.

I wouldn't dream of entering a chat room: icq or ur4me2 -- yuk !!!!!

I, for one, will keep coming back while there are intelligent, knowledgeable, sincere, witty people with whom to exchange information, ideas, and and repartee.

by generalist

All of the advertising about getting into the exciting world of Information Technology has dredged up a population of 'make it rich quick' types who tend to be rude and crude when they don't get their way.

Add to that various search engines and wide spread Internet access, and you have an even larger population of people who have problems with a civil conversation.

by dnvrtechgrrl

Not all young people are interested in spamming, scripting and flaming. That is a promise. Yes, it's true that most under the age of 30 grew up with some form of ingrained "chat behavior" that makes the rest of us want to curl up and die a quick and painless social death, I dred the day when people like that are in power.

I come here to read more than post though. I'm trapped in some small podunk town in Texas and the nearest half-brain is at least six hours away. There is no one to talk to, no one to call, no one to bail me out should a problem arise. Thankfully, I can usually get back on track by reading the forums. I also benefit from the experience of the older posters and the mistakes they've made in the past. Usually when a "no-no" is posted, the solution isn't far behind.

Not all young people are out for an AOL chatroom experience. Some of us, hard to believe, actually acknowlege the awesome power of mass communication and use it wisely. Should we all take on that responsibility, we'd all achieve greater things, age aside.

by jackofalltech

I believe most of us would welcome talking to a mature, polite person, even if said person was only in their teens. It's not the age that bothers us, it's the rudeness and laziness.

Ralph

by dnvrtechgrrl

That is not at all what I'm hearing the last few days. I come here to participate in the only intelligent conversation I'm going to receive in my day. I choose not to answer questions in the Q&A because I'm smart enough to know that there are people out there who can answer them much better and have more experience than I. I choose not to participate in many debates because I know on the age spectrum I'm on the lower rungs, though not a teen or young adult having problems with Kazaa or some hideous chat client, I am still young and inexperienced in this field. I've only been supporting networks and users for about five years. I still need to benefit from the more refined members. I'd also like to think at some point I can offer a valuable contribution.

What I am hearing is that newbies and weeners and young people should no longer be allowed to post questions, partake of discussion or engage in debate. That's rediculous. Age or time in the field should have nothing to do with the ability to learn from each other. Putting yourself out in the open as an experienced member of the community is going to follow a natural progression where more inexperienced people seek you out for help and advice.

Granted, this brings about the redundant and irritating questions of home users that don't understand that this is a technical forum for people in the field. But a "forum wide" lockout on those who are young, inexperienced or those who don't accrue a mass amount of points is only going to defeat the original purpose of this site.

Education. Community. Knowlege.

Creating a sepratist community is only going to diminish the value that this place holds.

by hal 9000

I'm taking my bucket and spade away from the sandpit so you lot here can't play with it while we are here at preschool.

Now lets get back to what our Geek Score actually was!

by hal 9000

Escape while you still can.

If you've only been working IT for somewhere around 5 years you still have the chance to get a REAL JOB well at least one that will not drive you nuts within a very short time.

But at 5 years you are quickly reaching the point of no return and if you don't manage to escape very soon you will be hooked for life with no chance of a cure. But worse still you will not be acknolledged as having an addiction by most people and you will never get any real treatment by proper medical people as they are under the mistaken impression that your job is useful, demanding, and the worst one yet forfilling.

None of this is true and in fact you will end up as sinicial and sarcastic as most of the so called Oldies here. Like me for one and do you want to even think about sounding like me all within a few years?

Take the advice of someone that has long since forgoten what the point of no return even looked like and get out while you still can and before you get hooked on the smell of Silicon and the horrible habits of Microsoft Products.

by guruofdos

TR Anonymous?

MrsGuru occasionally comments that she's a TR Widow and that GuruJr is a TR Orphan! I do spend a little too much time on here than is good for me but like you, I enjoy it!

That's my excuse, and I'm sticking to it!

Cheers!

by jardinier

It's MY addiction, and I like it, and I will "beat up and steal the lunch money" of anyone who tries to wean me from it.

By the way, a close female friend of mine, who lets me use her basement as a storeroom/workshop, astutely said: "Julian, you should take your computer to bed with you."

I replied: "It would probably get pregnant, and then I would have even more computers."

by jardinier

Well for a start, I guess I must be a newbie because I've been a member for less than a year. But I agree that the proportion of silly or trivial discussions has increased in that time.

As for name-calling, well if you don't happen to be a pro-Bush American Republican, then it seems you're fair game.

However, as this is a website for IT Pros, it's a wonder the management can't get someone to build a decent website for TechRepublic.

The only positive thing I can find about the new layout is that we are freed from the rigid limit to the length of postings.

On the other hand, they have removed photos from Peer Listings (fortunately I can still recall the image of Guru at least); nowhere can I find my tech points; and the information about my participation in Technical Q & A's is incorrect. I am listed as having asked NO questions, which is quite incorrect as I have asked at least two that I can remember.

There are other non-technical websites to which I belong which have MASSIVE databases about members' activities, and they NEVER make an error.

by guruofdos

>>fortunately I can still recall the image of Guru at least<<

Don't you mean 'unfortunately'?!!!! Reminds me of a little ditty from way back:-

I wish I had your picture,
It would be very nice.
I'd keep it in the cellar,
To scare away the mice!

Actually, I still have YOUR mugshot on file somewhere. I like to match names to faces!!

by jardinier

When asked by anyone: "Do you have a match?" the reply was: "Yes, your face and my bum." Well I've seen your face, but you haven't seen my bum; so on that note I will leave you hoping that I have a beautiful bum.

This discussion is closed to new replies.