Discussion Locked

BEST BUY... staff ignorance or unethical cheats?

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Please bear with me because I am new to owning a laptop.

I bought a Gateway 6510GZ notebook from Best Buy in Oakville (Ontario, Canada) in the summer of 2005 under the most expensive and comprehensive extended (3 year) service plan. From the first day I bought it, the included power supply kept getting so hot that it gave me a severe burn when it touched my leg, and the battery would start and stop charging for unknown reasons. This continued till the battery refused to charge at all.

Best Buy tried out the laptop/charger ensemble in the store, sent out the charger (which was also covered), and eventually replaced it. They replaced the charger two more that year after recurrent charging failures, after which time they suspected a problem with the DC Power Jack.

By then a permanent vertical line had also appeared on my screen, and Best Buy sent the laptop to shop for repair. The power jack was fixed, and though here were a few worrisome pixel outs, the replacement motherboard had eliminated the vertical line.

I had no more problems with the unit until April 2008, when my opening of the notebook caused THE WHOLE PLASTIC to RIP AWAY FROM around THE KEYBOARD, geez Louise!. When I took it into the store, a geek squad member pried out a screw from some damaged plastic around the hinge, and explained that the loose hinge screw had caused the problem by jamming into the plastic below the hinge, causing trauma to the connecting plastic when the lap was opened (which makes me wonder WHY laptop hinges would be constructed interconnecting with the plastic?)

After he sent it out for repair, I got a disturbing call from the shop saying they would not repair the notebook unless I paid $300 extra, because the only thing that causes hinge failure is the dropping of the unit, which voids the terms of warranty. I declined on a matter of principle, as my friend could fix it for free, which ? guess what ? also voids a warranty.

The laptop was returned to the store with a different explanation ? that ?normal wear and tear? was not covered under warranty.

Since when is dropping a product considered ?normal? wear and tear? And does anyone know something that has worked to get them to honor their warranty?independent appraiser ? court ? newspaper ? anything? If it is just a mistake resulting from ignorant staff, I am willing to remove this post as not to defame them, but otherwise I am not rich enough to accept being cheated on something I so desperately need.

Cheers,
Charlie

2 replies

by older mycroft

There is every likelihood, and indeed every possibility to prove, that replacement of the motherboard would have required the removal/reinsertion of all the relevant chassis screws including the errant hinge screw.

I suspect that when the screw was put back in, it was not treated with Blue Loctite first. ALL screws that frequently come under flex pressure due to where they are located should have this glue process before being screwed into the socket.

Secondly, on a couple of occasions now, I have found that a polite email mentioning your intention to submit the details of the case to the computer trade press and the biggest circulation computer consumer magazines (which is your right) generally has the desired effect.

Nothing hurts more than bad publicity - preferably on a grand scale. :)

by highlander718

What IS covered in a full, most expensive 3 year warranty if not regular tear&wear ? After a while all defects can be labeled tear & wear, no ?

I say, if you know you did not drop or do anything funny with the laptop, go up a level, I presume the 3 year warranty being close to end they might also try to prolongue the process until just after the expiration.

good luck,

This discussion is closed to new replies.