Discussion Locked

Bill to Ban Smoking In Your Car...(No I'm Not Kidding)

0 helpful
34 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is amazing to me. Granted I'm not a smoker and I detest the habit as I think its disgusting, but this is just wrong....And people wonder why NJ is the *butt* end of so many jokes. (Let's see most crowded state per sq. mile, insane property taxes, one of the highest car insurance rates in the country....and let's add more moronic legislation like this to the list of turn off's to my home state...)

July 24, 2005, 11:11 AM EDT

TRENTON, N.J. -- Ashtrays have been disappearing in cars like fins on Cadillacs, and so could smoking while driving in New Jersey, under a measure introduced in the Legislature.

Although the measure faces long odds, it still has smokers incensed and tearing into the idea as a Big Brother intrusion that threatens to take away one of the few places they can enjoy their habit.

Assemblyman John McKeon, a tobacco opponent whose father died of emphysema, sponsored the legislation. He cites a AAA-sponsored study on driver distractions in which the automobile association found that of 32,000 accidents linked to distraction, one percent were related to smoking.

Insane isn't it?

34 replies

by dc guy

To paraphrase that wise old lament. By the time "they" came after him, there wasn't anyone left to help.

People who think the War on Drugs is just great will eventually discover that by sacrificing someone else's freedom you're just getting an already bloated and overzealous government into a really bad habit.

Mark my words, we'll live to see doughnuts rationed and timers limiting our maximum TV per day to two hours.

Health, fitness, safety, and sobriety at any cost. Welcome to the Nanny State.

by tomsal

I guess we should be prepared to be assimilated into the borg that is big government.

heh...makes you wonder though -- would such controls be an exception the government employees who impose them?

Oh wait what am I thinking there is no hypocrisy in politics right? LOL

by stress junkie

I've said before in TR posts that I believe that there are always some people in government that want to take away one liberty of another. When I was in elementary school I was taught that the theory of freedoms in the United States was that people should be allowed to do something unless there is a compelling reason to prevent it. Each generation has had to deal with some self righteous element in society that wants to prevent people from doing one thing or another just because they don't like allowing others to do that. Their idea of a compelling reason to restrict some behavior is that they just don't like it. Directing their own life isn't enough. They want everyone to do what they do, think what they think, et. al.

Massachusetts has restricted tobacco smoking in public to some degree for a decade or so. There is a town in Massachusetts named Sharon where it is illegal to smoke on a public street if you are near a school or a public park. Smoking in restaurants was banned state wide several years ago. Admittedly many restaurants didn't implement their smoking section rationally. Many times the fresh air from the vents went into the restaurant in the smoking section and was exhausted in the nonsmoking section; exactly the opposite of what it should have been. Now you can't even smoke in a bar. There has been an effort in Boston to create smoking clubs where members could go and have an alchoholic drink and smoke cigarettes or cigars but the nonsmoking contingent complains that these places should be public places of business and then that they should ban smoking on their premises.

I also agree with your implied criticism of the restriction of (some) recreational drugs. Currently I only favor making marijuana and hashish legal. Hey if Amsterdam can do it and maintain social order then why can't we? It's just because some self righteous jackass down the street doesn't want anyone to be able to use these things.

People are a$$holes.

by absolutely

([i]and hashish[/i], although that's just what falls from drip-dried marijuana!)

Ethically and morally: your "right" to prohibit the use of emthamphetamine and heroin to somebody else is [i]exactly[/i] equivalent to somebody else's right to prohibit to you the stress that gives you your rush. Both are unhealthy, and in both cases it is up to the individual to decide whether that cost is less or greater than the benefit of the more healthy alternative.

"But drugs are [i]more[/i] unhealthy" some might say. But [i]how much[/i] more unhealthy? Can you prove it? Can you quantify it? If so, quantify "how unhealthy" a drug must be to be "justly" prohibited. The primary issue is that we all have the right to pursue our own happiness, as wisely or foolishly as we are able. When a crackhead robs you to support his habit, then your rights are violated, but only then. Without prohibition raising the price of drugs, such drug-related crime was unknown. Anybody who remembers the 1950's knows that I'm right.

Pragmatically: the effects of addiction are widely known, though exaggeration and confusion of one drug's effects with another are common. Even so, do you really believe that a LAW will deter somebody who so easily forgets or ignores the physiological damage known to result from extended use? Do you really want to put the law between that guy and his decay? I'd rather let the police protect the [i]innocent[/i]. Drug laws mainly protect addicts from themselves, a service they [i]do not deserve[/i].

by Member 25348569

Watch the number of live addicts drop along with their affect on the rest of us.

Think of it as evolution in action.

by tony hopkinson

The main reason heavily addicted users survive so long is because they have to put some effort in to get their next fix.
It's cruel to make them strain like that in their condition, give them a government sized bag.

by hal 9000

Currently she is in Kent but will be moving to London within a few weeks so when you run into her can you say hello to her from me? Her name is Janice and she's working as a nurse at one of the bigger Meat-works OOPS that should have read Hospitals in London.

Sorry but I couldn't resist after all I know just how small the UK actually is! :D

Col ]:)

by stress junkie

I just didn't want to confuse the issues by including other drugs. As I mentioned we have a model of a society that allows marijuana and a few other recreational drugs in Amsterdam, Holland. The kinds of things that people generally use to justify making drugs illegal include crime, ill health, automobile safety, job performance, etc. Statistics are available for how these issues affect society in Holland so it is easier to discuss whether their drug policies cause problems in their society.

American history shows that there is a compelling reason to outlaw the recreational use of other drugs such as cocaine, opium, and other addictive narcotics. These substances were once widely available. Their widespread use actually did cause problems which grew to dramatic proportions. In the case of these drugs the government was faced with a clear and present danger of widespread health problems due to their recreational use.

The people who want to stop all recreational drug use, including the use of alchohol, took advantage of the movement to stop the recreational use of opium, heroine, et. al. to include all recreational drugs. This happened at the beginning of the 20th century. We all know how the prohibition of alchohol fared. Eventually the U.S. government had to permit the free use of alchohol but they maintained restrictions on all other drugs. Most of these restrictions are justified. The restriction on marijuana is not justified.

Marijuana was not actually illegal until President Nixon passed the drug control act in the early 1970s. Up to that time the government stopped the trafficing of marijuana by requiring a tax stamp. Cleverly the government didn't print any of these required stamps so it was impossible to comply with the requirement. Catch 22 applied to substance control. Funny stuff if it weren't a back door means to restricting our liberties.

In summary I agree with the government controlling access to many drugs. History justifies this restriction. I just don't agree with making marijuana illegal.

by absolutely

stress: I just didn't want to confuse the issues by including other drugs. As I mentioned we have a model of a society that allows marijuana and a few other recreational drugs in Amsterdam, Holland. The kinds of things that people generally use to justify making drugs illegal include crime, ill health, automobile safety, job performance, etc. Statistics are available for how these issues affect society in Holland so it is easier to discuss whether their drug policies cause problems in their society."

Abs: Actually, in Amsterdam, there are green stickers on the front windows of coffee shops and red stickers on the front windows of coffee shops that also sell hard drugs. Statistics about Holland often overlook the magnet effect, but in fact people travel there from all over the world to get high, so accurate, meaningful statistical studies should include the birth places of the problematic people, but rarely do.

stress: American history shows that there is a compelling reason to outlaw the recreational use of other drugs such as cocaine, opium, and other addictive narcotics. These substances were once widely available. Their widespread use actually did cause problems which grew to dramatic proportions. In the case of these drugs the government was faced with a clear and present danger of widespread health problems due to their recreational use.

Abs: American history shows no such mother-loving thing! When those substances were "widely available" their addictive character was not advertised, but their pleasant intoxicating effects were. People have the right to pertinent information, then to make their own choices and live with the consequences -- of [i]their own[/i] actions.

Coca-Cola used to contain coca and cola, now it contains neither, but other elixirs containing opium, cocaine, methamphetamine or any other psychoactive substance should be governed by the laws that exist for honest advertising. No other regulation is justified, nor legal according to the Constitution.

stress: Most of these restrictions are justified.

Abs: By whom? Or, according to whom? By what right?

stress: The restriction on marijuana is not justified.

Abs: True, but since you claim a similar restriction on other drugs [i]is[/i] justified, why not for weed? What's the difference? Your subtle discernment, some medical definition of addictive potential? There is no legal basis for that, regardless of any pragmatic arguments. There is no provision in the constitution to limit [i]how[/i] individuals may pursue their happiness unless such pursuit [i]directly[/i] violates anothers' rights. The Constitution was written to limit the power of government, not to describe how it would grow. Drug-related crime may legally be prosecuted for its criminal character, not persecuted for being drug-related. The existence of the DEA violates the Constitution, particularly Amendment 10 which does not assign such a power to the federal government.

by av .

I guess you don't live in NJ, but I do. Our politicians here apparently have nothing constructive to do so they came up with yet another way to impose more restrictions on us.

I smoke, even though I think its disgusting too, but it gives me something to do while sitting in the horrendous traffic jams we have here. Why don't they work on fixing that?

Even if I didn't smoke, its my car, I pay for it, I work for it and its none of their business what I do in it if I'm not affecting anyone else but me. There are no studies to support that smoking causes more accidents. If they want to know whats really happening on the roads, they should get out there and commute everyday like I do.

If they pass that bill, they can come and get me because I will continue doing what I want in MY car. Its like the cell phone laws that they passed. Everyone I see is still yakking away anyway.

by tomsal

Its the first reason the article drew my attention -- because I live here.

But you are right -- its your car, your money, and to put it in terms politicians can understand its your time spent in the car going to work so the politicians can get TAX DOLLARS to spend. lol.

One of my brother's is a big smoker, so is his wife and his wife's entire family. (On a side note: more evidence that smoking is a physical addiction -- my brother that smokes was caught smoking for the first time when he was 11 years old...lol...my dad made him eat, yes *eat* the rest of the cigarette.....and he stopped for about 2 years..but it didn't take....he's gonna be 40 soon and still smokes like a chimney.).

One of the citizen's interviewed for comment in the article that reported this bill's proposal (paraphrase) said "yeah well they can tell me what to do in my car when they pay my lease payments."..lol

As far as distractions for accidents -- I think that is bunk.

You mean as distracting as...

--- people using cell phones while they drive (eegats but that's against the law in NJ right? LOL)

--- women applying makeup while they drive

--- people eating while they drive (though I am a little guilty of this one from time to time..lol)

--- people drinking while they drive (yes I mean the non-alcoholic beverages...I hope you don't drink alcohol while driving!!)

--- And my all time favorite one because people always overlook it -- but arguing with others in the car while you try to drive.

by stress junkie

An example of your last item: screaming children. Yeah. I think they're distracting. :-)

I just saw a report on television of a study that stated that of all accidents caused by distrations cigarettes only accounted for 1%. That suggests to me that cigarettes in the car are not a real safety issue. Not that I'm all that confident in the validity of statistical studies. You can change your data set to show almost any result that you want to see.

by anarchocapitalist

More government = less freedom.

Government should stick to the few functions that the Constitution says it should perform--and that's it (until we can get to a point in society where we no longer need governments, at all)! Nowhere will you find any provision in the Constitution for government to be a nanny or vice patrol. Even so, both Democrats and Republicans want to regulate and control us, whether it has to do with our money or our lifestyles.

Saudi Arabia has the "mutaween" police force that flogs people for violating vice codes. We don't want, or need, that in the United States of America.

It really amazes me that so many clueless people in this country actually believe that they are truly free.

If you think you're really free, try building a permanent structure without getting a permit (permission and pay-off) and inspection. If you don't get the necessary permissions, and pay off the government, they will tear your structure down, fine you, and possibly imprison you.

Try starting a business without getting a business license (permission and pay-off).

Think you can move freely, without government interference? Try driving down the street without a driver's license (permission and pay-off).

Want to keep your property, make sure you pay the government's yearly extortion fee (protection money and permanent lien on your property), or you may lose it--even though you've already paid the mortgage, in full. As long as you pay a property tax, you do not own your property; you simply lease it from the government every year.

In some areas, due to zoning ordinances (America's communism) if grass remains uncut, you fail to upkeep the paint up on your house, or your fence is too high, you can be taken before a "Livability Court," where they can tear your house/fence down or condemn your house and take it from you.

In some states, insurance is mandated (forced socialism), so you are forced to pay for the bills of others (health care costs, accident costs, etc.). Then, when those costs skyrocket, government bureaucrats use that as an excuse to raise taxes--all because of something they forced on you, and then they try to blame it on the people who are driving up the costs. (Hint: If you really want to bring down costs, and get people to think about what they do, reintroduce personal responsibility, instead of spreading the burden around to everyone else.)

I could go on, but I think you get the picture.

Just remember one thing: You are free, or you are not free; there is no such thing as "somewhat free" or "mostly free." If you must answer to, and obey, someone else, you are not free.

by mrcwalker

NEW JERSY! Get a rope. one rope....this man is insane check his blood he must be on something.

That's my one cents....I would even call it 2.

by maxwell edison

.
Very well said. I agree 100 percent. And the sad thing is, people keep voting themselves more and more into submission. What an utterly ignorant and stupid lot we are.

And the Republican Party is not much better than the Democrat Party. The Republican Party of today would be similar to the Democrat Party of 1960; and the Democrat Party of today would be similar to the American Socialist Party of 1932.

Is it too late to turn the tide? If not, we will soon be overcome by a tsunami of socialism -- all of our own making and caused by our own insecurities, resentfulness of others, and greed.

I use the plural only to be polite. There are a few of us who can see this for what it really is. But there are so many stupid and ignorant Americans that it's truly sad. They have no idea what "America" was, and is, supposed to be. They are slaves at worst, indentured servants at best. Property rights are a thing of the past; the stupid and ignorant gave up those rights decades ago. I challenge anyone to name one aspect of his or her life over which the government doesn't have control -- just one.

We are a nation of figurative frogs. And we voluntarily jumped into a slowly cooking pot of water. It used to be cool, then tepid, now it's getting quite warm. How long will it be before we cannot jump out, only to find ourselves totally cooked?

by av .

We're not free here and its getting worse. There are so many laws in NJ, you don't have a chance. There is too much government(that does nothing but collect money from our tax dollars), pay to play, nepotism, and other extreme corruption. The crooks are running this state.

I'm surprised we don't have religious police here too. Thats probably next. The local governments are scary with the amount of power they have over your life. If you don't play by their rules or rub them the wrong way you might as well leave town. On the other hand, people that kiss up to the local government (translation: people that paid them off) can do whatever they want. You can't win here. Its pretty brutal.

I have heard that other states are much more lenient and they don't have the oppressive laws of NJ. Is that true or is it bull? I recently went to VA and the people there told me they don't have all of the restrictions we have here. They do what they want.

As a whole, I think all Americans have to wake up to the fact that we aren't free anymore. Its awful to me, but most people seem to be so wrapped up in their own lives they don't seem to care. Sheep. Baaaaa.

by tomsal

Just general comments as a result of reading your post:

-As much as we hate the "big bad government" taxes some are needed and make sense. For instance, I don't want to manage my own sewage -- I'm fine with paying the local municipality to do that for me. Likewise, yes insurance sucks -- because the concept is odd to take. You are paying monthly for years and years for something that you see no direct benefit back so that part pisses you (me/us) off. Yet if we didn't have insurance and something happened and we had to pay everything out of pocket that would piss us off even more so.
Bottomline here: Yeah insurance costs suck the big one, but insurance does make sense. And its not gonna be free.

-Also of course we have to answer to someone -- if you are defining freedom as truly no responsibility for your actions to society at all and you just do whatever the hell you want no matter what -- good luck living alone, in the uncivilized remote parts of the planet -- no hospitals, no grocery stores, no entertainment (though I suppose you could talk to the bears, or spell your name in the sand when you pee). There HAS to be someone we answer to -- cops as the most common example. An orderly civilization has to have some rules, and if there is no one to enforce the rules -- what are the points of the rules. Surely you don't think we can do this whole "honor system thing" to a nation of hundreds of millions?
So I don't mind having to always answer to someone.

What I *DO* mind...

--the enforcers (aka cops, judges) can't abuse their authorities and they themselves should be subject to the same rules I am and kept in check by other cops and judges.

--You are right on pretty much everything else you posted. And yeah its really stupid we need permits to add to our own homes that we already paid for. Safety inspections I can see -- but if its truly for the interest of safety and if "they" really cared -- why do they charge for it? LOL

by anarchocapitalist

QUOTE: "-As much as we hate the "big bad government" taxes some are needed and make sense. For instance, I don't want to manage my own sewage -- I'm fine with paying the local municipality to do that for me."

No one said that you can't enter into a contract with them to do it for you--if that's what you choose. Just don't ask me to help pay for it (taxes). I'll take care of mine, and you take care of yours. Easy solution.

QUOTE: "Likewise, yes insurance sucks -- because the concept is odd to take. You are paying monthly for years and years for something that you see no direct benefit back so that part pisses you (me/us) off. Yet if we didn't have insurance and something happened and we had to pay everything out of pocket that would piss us off even more so.
Bottomline here: Yeah insurance costs suck the big one, but insurance does make sense. And its not gonna be free."

No, insurance doesn't make since, when it's mandated (forced on you). What sense does it make for me (a careful driver, non-smoker, non-drinker, healthy diet, etc.) to have to pay sky-high insurance rates, because other people don't take personal responsibility for their actions/vices? Should I be forced to subsidize them? Hell no! It makes no sense at all, and is extremely unfair--especially when government then uses the rising costs as an excuse to forcefully remove even more money from my wallet.

QUOTE: "-Also of course we have to answer to someone"

Whoa, wait a second! Why should I have to answer to anyone else? You make it sound as though humanity needs to be controlled and regulated (government officials love people like you). That's a totally different mindset than what the Founders had in mind for this country. I shouldn't have to answer to anyone, unless I violate their rights in some way. Unless that happens, what I do is no one else's business--including the government.

QUOTE: "-- if you are defining freedom as truly no responsibility for your actions to society at all and you just do whatever the hell you want no matter what -- good luck living alone, in the uncivilized remote parts of the planet"

I believe in the Jeffersonian concept of "rightful liberty": "Of liberty I would say that, in the whole plenitude of its extent, it is unobstructed action according to our will. But rightful liberty is unobstructed action according to our will within limits drawn around us by the equal rights of others. I do not add 'within the limits of the law,' because law is often but the tyrant's will, and always so when it violates the right of an individual. -- Thomas Jefferson." Do you support that? If not, you cannot claim to support freedom.

QUOTE: "-- no hospitals, no grocery stores, no entertainment (though I suppose you could talk to the bears, or spell your name in the sand when you pee)."

You don't seem to have a firm grasp on economics. Sorry to burst your bubble, but that's the job of entrepreneurs, not government. Government should not be in the business of competing with the private sector. Additionally, government isn't responsible for the entertainment and possessions you have been fortunate enough to acquire. In fact, government--due to regulations, rules, bans and controls--has put a lot of things out of your reach. For instance, be sure to thank the government busybodies for causing the price of cars to nearly double (taxes on production and parts, compliance costs, etc.).

QUOTE: "There HAS to be someone we answer to -- cops as the most common example."

Is that what they taught you in government-run schools? You aren't capable of controlling yourself and running your own life? That's pretty pathetic. Ben Franklin and the original colonists set up a night watchman operation (and the first fire department), and they took turns taking watch in the evenings, to protect their properties. Did they need a government to do that for them? No, they entered into private agreements between themselves, and it worked out just fine. I would like to see free people go back to that kind of thing, in the same way that communities hire their own security forces to patrol their private neighborhoods. It's being done successfully, right now, all across the country.

QUOTE: "An orderly civilization has to have some rules, and if there is no one to enforce the rules -- what are the points of the rules. Surely you don't think we can do this whole "honor system thing" to a nation of hundreds of millions? So I don't mind having to always answer to someone."

The only rule should be this: Don't violate anyone else's rights. If you want to answer to someone else, that's your business; you should be free to contract with whomever you wish--just don't try to force your contract on me. Thanks, but I'll opt-out--and take my freedom with me. You can have your rulers, along with their totally un-American asset forfeiture and eminent domain laws.

QUOTE: "What I *DO* mind...

"--the enforcers (aka cops, judges) can't abuse their authorities and they themselves should be subject to the same rules I am and kept in check by other cops and judges."

Thank you for pointing out typical problems that come about when certain humans are allowed to rule over other humans. With that in mind, why should I submit to them? They are just as corrupt and evil as the people they are claiming to protect us from--and they certainly don't keep each other in check.

Still want your rulers?

by jbaker

Is the incongruity of these laws that are supposed to "protect" us. For example: Here is Texas, it is illegal to drive or ride in a car without your seatbelt on. Obviously to protect "me" in the event of an accident. However, it is completely legal for me to ride a motorcycle in shorts, flip-flops and no helmet. In which situation am I more likely to be injusred in an accident? Completely encased in the metal box of an automobile, or sitting on top of the seat of a (relatively) small motorcycle?

by jck

more accidents were caused by people picking their nose than smoking.

That's insane...next thing you know, they'll tell you it's illegal to push the brake too hard.

by jaqui

when they put anti-lock brakes in as a requirement for safety.

after all that kid that ran out in front of you only 18 inches away doesn't deserve to live, the car ain't gonna get that quick slowdown that gives the kid a chance to survive with antilock brakes.

by jaqui

that the twit that introduced the bill wants the state economy to get sh|tcanned.
kill all tourist trade.
nail torists with fines for smoking in a car, watch how fast the tourism moneys leave the state.

dumba$$ politico... perfect example of why they should kill stupid people.

by tomsal

I agree with ya Jaqui!

So many stupid things about this state I can't stand, but my job is here, my family is here, my gf is here (and she firmly insists she wants to stay in NJ)...damn my dad for moving us here when I was 12! lol.

Anyway the other stupid law they have is you need to buy a beach tag to go on most (though some select ones you don't -- or so I've "heard") beaches here. And you get heavy fines if you are caught without one on the beach.

What BS.

Anyway, yep if only it were legal to kill some folks on pure ultra stupidity.

by hal 9000

Many Years ago the Government insisted that Gold Miners here near Ballarat had to have mining licenses on them at all times. The Police naturally abused this and it lead to the Revolt that is commonly known as the Eureka Stockade where the citizens rose up against the Government of the day and fought them. Naturally they did lose but their action did make the Government take notice and eventually relax the Laws pertaining to Mining Licenses.

Col ]:)

by jaqui

hashish, as originally sold was the leftovers from pressing opium from poppys.
for making morphine and heroin.

what is being called hashish now, the pressings of pot stems is nothing but garbage.
if it wasn't for the oils they poor onto it you couldn't catch a buzz of the pot stem hash if your life depended on it.

by hal 9000

And then the incidence of "Road Rage" will increase so most likely more will either die or be horribly injured but it will have saved the lives of those few right? :D

Col ]:)

by av .

I certainly don't want to see the day that an 18-wheel tractor trailer driver is having a nicotine fit.

Yeah, they probably will pass it but it will be a secondary offense. Then, if you get stopped for something else they can tack on smoking in the car and make a quick $250.

They're not interested in saving anyone, they just want the revenue for the state coffers. I don't think anyone will obey the law even if they pass it. They don't obey the cell phone laws either.

I unfortunately smoke. Until I quit, I want some respect for my rights too. I'm tired of being persecuted "for my own good" and treated like a second class citizen. It doesn't seem to me that the government should be involved in my personal choices. I'm not bothering anyone.

Besides that, the car is the last place I can smoke where someone isn't offended.

by tomsal

Your thoughts and views are somewhat admirable -- you basically picture a free society where everyone is fully responsible for their ownselves and no one else. This is great, in theory or written in a internet forum, but once reality strikes...it falls apart.

I expect you to do the normal "you are brainwashed by government" routine -- people with your viewpoint would actually shock me if you didn't do that brainwashed routine. (Kind of like an atheist would shock me if they actually respected someone believing in God and just leaving it at that.)

I don't know if I can hit all the topics, as it would be a huge post and time right now is a little tight for me. But I can come back later and re-address any issues you want to make.

-Cops, yes they are needed. Nightwatch/town watches -- are *YOU* kidding ME! They hardly have the resources and specialized training to deal with anything more complex or dangerous than someone playing mailbox baseball. Are these night watchmen paid/do they health/death benefits - are they dedicated to the job or is this some weekend warrior type who is an accountant by day and then at night (depending if its his turn on the schedule) he is a super defender of 114 North Broad Street? What happens for judging the sentence for a crime..they toss in all these punishment ideas into a hat and go "pick one". Or do you just kill everyone no matter if they are defacing your property, keying your car or shooting at your house?

Then of course what do you do with very dangerous and large numbers of criminals -- aka gangs...organized crime. You think Joe Smith, the Hardware owner by day, is gonna scare a hardened criminal just because he has a walkie talkie and a shotgun?

Then of course your nightwatchmen would have full resources to expert crime labs, supercomputers used to do ballistics and forensics research.

Oh wait you said you could privately contract someone for that stuff right...oh great...so how strict are the credentials needed for earning such a contract with a forenics lab -- or could any schmoe off the street hire such services? I don't suppose they are free either...so there is a payment issue too.

-The sewer thing....HAHAHA! you go right ahead with your idea of contract separate people...tell you what present that to the masses and see how that goes...What standards for disease control will you have where all contractors meet too -- because if they reported to a central body isn't that breaking your rule of "no government/no rulers"? Yet without centralized management -- how would it be maintained? The market could control prices -- if one guy is too high he won't get business. But you need safety measures, sewage contains bacteria, possibly carries of disease,also how complex do you think it would be if everyone could hire their own company to do the sewage treatment...it simply doesn't work that way...physically, I mean how the sewer lines and treatment plants are set up right now.

--You said thanks for the fact that I addressed corruption and abuse exists in law enforcment.

Let me tell you something, corruption and abuse will exist for as long as humans are in existence. If the country went to your system -- corruption would be in your nightwatch groups too.!!!

**Here is the fundamental wrong in your idea**

Aside from everything else...under your view of non-government/no one to report too/full responsibility for yourself (which I agree with the part of people need to be held accountable for their own actions) ... that means we as private citizens would have so much more stress dumped on us than we already do, we would have to effectively work more than we already do and since we would be involved in more "organizations" -- like the nightwatch idea , when is the part that we can relax? When can I ease my mind and be left alone? When do I have "play time" to enjoy life instead of worrying about who is posted on watch tonight so no one steals my car? etc.

People forget...hey I love the idea of LESS government, truth is you are absolutely correct with your general underlying theme -- but I'm sorry to upset the apple cart -- a form of government is needed.

Not all government employees/law enforcement officers are bad/evil/corrupt people. Some really are good folks who honestly work for US.

(I can personally vouch for cops -- there are MANY in my family).

And like I said before...you are very misguided if you think your way would make everyone honest people who are always fair to each other.

People are people -- what they are is what they are.

by anarchocapitalist

You sure ask a lot of questions, for someone who is attempting to show me how incorrect I am. I gave you alternatives--alternatives that have proven successful--and all you can do is ask more questions and say that they won't work, so prove me wrong with facts and figures. I don't really care for your opinions and speculations.

Basically, you're saying "Sorry, but your freedoms are going to have to suffer, because people are too lazy to do things for themselves. They want government to do everything for them." That is completely unacceptable. Wake up, man!

I want you to read an excellent book, titled "The Voluntary City." Also, visit this Web site: http://www.libertarianism.com/visions.htm.

I know how YOUR side thinks. Educate yourself on alternatives (MY side) and then come back so we can have a meaningful, fully-informed discussion.

by tomsal

The questions are real, note you didn't provide responses for them? hmmmm..and maybe you think I was throwing in sarcasm on purpose just a tad. ;)

You don't care for my opinions and speculations? Why because you can't answer the logic in some of the questions?

I was answerimg back to your alternatives -- what the heck you think the questions were based out of ?

and as to your "I know how YOUR side thinks"...my side is MY OWN.

And finally,

If your spin is I'm for no freedoms, if I'm for government doing everything...you couldn't be more wrong and if that's the leg you are gonna stand on throughout whatever lengths this little debate of ours goes -- you are making it up yourself.

I never said I love government, I never said I want big government. I even agreed with your general theory -- I happen to think self-responsibility is something that SHOULD be persued.

I'm merely being logical in saying that you need structure in a modern society, let along one with hundreds of millions of people.

And btw our founding fathers certainly did believe in laws that govern its citizens and they certainly did believe in such things as jail time for breaking laws.

So how is that not having rulers?

As for your original statement examples that I countered (some intentionally smart arsed I'll admit) to render a real answer --- MONEY (ie paying for things is a real issue buddy...that was one of my points).

You think for example with the sewage think it would cost you just $32 a quarter (what I pay) if you elected to say "screw it I don't need local government for that..I'll pay my own guy" -- ok but get ready to pay HUNDREDS of dollars for the same service (you see the reason its cheaper IS because others are paying in too with you...oh but that's a bad thing because its related to government.)

I'm awake man....if you are you should stop day dreaming.

(I'd ask you more questions but then I'd upset you more...questions like how is it speculation saying that chaos would run rampant if the citizens left enforcement of laws to themselves? You keep saying many places do this...well provide me information about these places..don't just say "many places run this way"....what part of some people are evil to the core regardless of the rules (or no rules) society puts on them don't you understand? Your system requires a "watch my back I watch yours" mentality -- which, again...is admirable...but apply that to the whole society of millions there will be those that instead of watching your back will stab you in the back.)

by montgomery gator

..and don't like it when people do so around me, people smoking in their own cars should not be a government issue. However, when they throw their cigarette butts out the window, that is a totally different matter. It seems the littering laws are not enforced in that case, and many smokers think the world is their ashtray. Go ahead and smoke in your own car, but keep the butts inside until you can find a trash can in which to put them.

by av .

I don't like littering period. It isn't only cigarettes, its soda cans, bottles, bags, you name it. People are slobs.

This law isn't just aimed at cigarette smokers either. What about cigars?

by anarchocapitalist

QUOTE: "And btw our founding fathers certainly did believe in laws that govern its citizens and they certainly did believe in such things as jail time for breaking laws."

Actually, it's a well-known fact that the Founders were firm proponents of self-government, and power decentralization. Did you happen to skip over the Jefferson quote that I provided in a previous post?

As for the "escape route," I don't use escape routes; I simply tire of dealing with certain people--especially when I have more important things to take care of.

I do this for a living (I am a political talk radio show host), and I know when to say, "Okay, I'm not going to change your mind, and you certainly aren't going to change mine, so we'll just have to agree to disagree."

Please, just take a read through the book, and visit the site that I mentioned, and let's discuss this another day.

by tomsal

Yep one thing I must say I agree on..neither of us are gonna change either person's minds.

I know they (they being founding fathers) were not into big government, a book called "American History" I have at home is pretty good and that's one source I know this from (and assorted documentaries I watched just because I find it interesting).

As for being a talk show host that's great -- good luck on your success. However being a talk show host doesn't mean you are always right (but hold on...it doesn't mean you are always wrong either. It means you are highly opinionated and extremely passionate about your viewpoint --- and you get paid for it.

Good job if you ask me :)

best of luck!

This discussion is closed to new replies.