Discussion Locked

Building my own PC -- Any opinions or comments are welcome

0 helpful
86 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Case -- Aero Cool -- $63.50
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc....-196-001&depa=0

Powersupply -- Aspire -- $55.50
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc....-148-005&depa=1

Motherboard -- Intel D925XCVLK -- $192.00
http://www.newegg.com/app/viewProductDesc....-121-226&depa=1

Processor -- Intel P4 2.8 Ghz -- 158.00
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc....-116-185&depa=1
Intel P4 3.0 Ghz -- $179.00
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc....-116-184&depa=1

Leaning towards the 3.0 Ghz at this point.

Memory -- DDR2 PC4200 (512 MB) -- $137.99
http://www.crucial.com/store/MPartspecs.As...SPN=CT6464AA53E

Hard Drive -- Western Digital (80 Gb) -- $66.00
http://www.gogocity.com/searchresults.asp?...1&parent%5Fid=3

Optical Drives -- DVDRW/CDRW -- $67.00
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc....-151-055&depa=1

Sound Card -- Not buying right now but will purchase Sound Blaster Audigy 2

Video Card -- XFX Nvidia GeForce 6600 -- $140.50
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc....-150-077&depa=1

Cables
Serial ATA -- $2.50
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProduct.asp?...=0&Order=rating

IDE -- $15.00
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc....-105-010&depa=0

Fans -- Aero Cool -- $14.00 (x2)
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc....-129-232&depa=0

Operating System - Windows XP Professional ($100.00) (But I have the Acadamic licence version so it might not cost me anything at all)

What do you guys think?

86 replies

by willcomp

I believe you get more "bang for the buck" with an Athlon 64 3200+ or higher. The 3200 is sitting on the sweet spot at present. Will also save some on mobo.

Also consider an Antec Sonata case. They are elegant, quiet, and fairly easy to work in. Also come with a top quality Antec True 380 power supply. Add a front 120mm fan to cool drives if you install Raptors or multiple drives.

If speed is your objective, invest in a WD Raptor (either single or in RAID array) as primary drive and add a larger drive for data drive. It's amazing the difference those 10K RPM drives make and they have a 5 year warranty.

Dalton

by apotheon

A 64-bit processor is probably a good idea if you need very high performance, but generally only if you're using a true 64-bit OS (such as Debian "pure 64" GNU/Linux). The only way a Windows-based system would be worth running on a 64-bit processor, at least until Microsoft gets its act together in regards to properly supporting the hardware, is if you're willing to spend the increased money to have the very bleeding edge top-end incremental performance boost for a gaming system because you simply Must Have The Best.

by callupchuck

Where would I find out or compare the different processor types? I too am looking at a new system, but have always been a strict Pentium user. Why would one choose an Athlon over a Pentium? Don't you run into compatibilty issues with some software if you're not using a true Pentium?

by aceskaraoke

I've had a processor from each generation whenever I get a new PC, upgrade or build I try out the next generation. Got my eyes set on building an AMD64 system next year if money allows.

Consistent reliability, great performance, and low cost. What's not to like?

Some AMD64 motherboards have FSB speeds that rival and surpass P4 motherboards. It doesn't look like price has been a concern for you though.

If you're looking to really put a gorgeous system though, treat yourself to a whole gig of memory, your computer will thank you (especially if you want to run Win XP Pro).

by dafe2

Just a thought:

You could get a bare Dell, HP or IBM WORKSTATION and build up and out from there? I only added up your expenses & rounded off but I think your in range.

I'm curious as to why you would build?

by garion11

I would love to get a link from you on where I can find a barebones Dell system with Dell parts and Dell warranty. When I priced out similar features on a Dell machine, I am getting $1500 to $2000 (unless it has been changed recently) range and that is beyond what I am willing to spend on a PC.

by apotheon

I think dafe2 was talking about getting a cheaper, lower-performance Dell and upgrading it with parts purchased separately. While I'm skeptical about the likelihood of being able to get the same performance for the same money, I suppose it is possible if you happen on a good deal. At the very least, though, you'd avoid some of the initial gruntwork of assembling the system.

Of course, there are other reasons to avoid getting a Dell, Gateway, HP, IBM, et cetera when you have the option of building it yourself. For one thing, when you buy a complete system from one of those vendors, you don't get as much control over what parts are in the system. For another, many such systems are intentionally designed to be difficult for a home user to open up and muck about in. For many years, for instance, the only way to more quickly dismay a computer tech than to ask him to support an Apple was to ask him to support a Compaq, beause of the highly proprietary, idiosyncratic, generally aggravating design features of the things. I'm not sure whether that's still the case, now that HP has owned the Compaq brand for a while, though.

In any case, I get exactly what I want when I build my system myself or go through a high quality "white box" computer vendor. I get it at a good price, too. I'll stick with building my own, generally, when I'm not dealing with high-volume corporate accounts.

by mrafrohead

The prefab boxes are awful. You can take a computer that you bought from a prefab. Then I will make the exact same computer (spec wise), for a cheaper price that will outperform the prefab. By a long shot.

These shoddy little prefabs are horrible. We have to use them at work, and I can tell you the system I have at my desk, is technically a third faster than my main box at home. My main box at home will run circles around these little sissy prefab POS machines...

Personally if I was Dell, I would have been embarassed to put my little sticker on it...

But that's just my 2 cents.

If you would really like to see the difference, I would be more than happy to build you a box so you can see the difference for yourself.

Mrafrohead

by dafe2

My response was nothing more than to suggest that he get his facts straight (and) refrain from using words like sissy & POS when he should be talking about tech specs.

The person - that's me - was asking valid question....I expected an answer and received this rhetoric from mrafrohead.

Incidently. I am a resseller & have been for over 15 years. I have also built systems for the same ammount of time. And once again, for many DIFFERENT reasons.

As far as the five hundred bucks, I wasn't necessarily referring to myself........but WAS referring to motivation in general.

No, I don't make big bucks either BUT there may be something else that I could be doing instead of building a machine that is worth $500.00 to me. A CUSTOMER may feel the same way - and we should give them ALL the options that are available this includes SOUND technical advice.

That was my point & this thread is what I responded to.

So to answer your question, no, I didn't expect much.

Make no mistake - I do have a LOT of respect for system builders and re-sellers - I am one.

I have very little tolerance for the kind of ***it this guy wrote to me is all.

Also, I was only suggesting that this workstation COULD cost $500.00 more...........it could cost $500.00 less too.

I thought my question was a good one. My suggestion that garion11 CONSIDER a tier 1 WORKSTATION (Not PC) was backed with reasoning, not rhetoric or uh....opinion.

Maybe the guy was joking.......who knows but putting down others to lift yourself up really doesn't bode well with me. I am NOT referring to me here, just that his approach in this case, well, "really blows".

by jdclyde

First, all low end systems have intigrated video and sound which is a huge hit on performance. About half of these don't even have an AGP slot to allow you to upgrade the video.

Drivers. Vendors are real good at not giving you a disk with the drivers you need for the system. If you buy it off the shelf and it goes bad just get another off the shelf. If the driver pukes, load from disk or get from the manufactures website.

Warranty. How many changes can you make before the warranty is voided? Used to be just by opening the box, but now they give you more wiggle room on that. But if you have a problem they will make you go back to original config before even looking to see if it is their system causing the problems or the add-ons you did.

Performance will be hit because you are not getting as good of a motherboard with a low end system.

White Box all the way, unless your making for someone else. Then get the dell and let dell fix it when they break it or get a virus.

by dafe2

I was referring to brand named WORKSTATIONS not PC's.

I was (not) referring to low end anything.

by theantimike

Well for starters the pride and satisfaction of doing something that I enjoy and do well.
And...more importantly-QUALITY! I am responsible for front end at a successful top 10 growth company. I purchase and maintain all the desktops and, in what little spare time I have, build custom systems.
I used to buy Dell computers for the company but started having them custom built by a local company.
WHY?
I found that with Dell there was a name brand on the outside of the case and that was it, with some exceptions of course.
When I had them built locally, to my specs, I got much more for less money. I am saving, on average, 400.00 per desktop.
Here are the specs of the current systems I am building.

Case-Antec SX635B11 Black MID 350W
Mainboard- ASUS P4P800-E DLX i865PE
HD - dual Seagate SATA 80GB
Video adapter - Nvidia FX5200 AGP
CPU - Intel P4 3 Ghz
CDRW- Samsung 52x32x52x16 black combo
Memory - kingston 256 MB pc3200 DDR
Speakers - ALTEC 120
Monitor - Acer 17 inch flat panel

For a comparible system from Dell I would pay at least 400.00 more. Most of the people that I meet don't have a system this nice at work.

All the major computer companies are profit driven which means that they will always find ways to cut corners for savings--to boost their profits and save the consumer money. When I am building a custom system for myself or a customer---that is unacceptable. I want top quality starting with the mainboard and power supply all the way up to the mouse.

by trockii

What is the charge for the computers? How many are you buying? What kind of warranty do you get?

by imagictech

If I was building a PC, I would strongly consider purchasing a mainline system such as an HP as one of the other respondants stated. There are real issues concerning warranty if you purchase your parts all over the internet rather than one or two main suppliers. You may get a good deal on a board but are you going to have a hassle getting an exchange of the board proves to be bad? With a major name brand to start all of your "core" parts are warranted. I would stick with a mid range and up system. All low end systems regardless of make are trouble.

Dells, except for the high end systems, are also trouble. I do warranty service for them and they have an uncomforatbly high failure rate. Mostly mainboards.

Start with a quality base and then add in the frills. Also get a board with an AGP slot instead of on board video. I personally have a leaning toward Intel boards, chipsets and processors. We have deployed literally hundreds of HP D220's which are relatively low end business class desktops and rarely see any come back but I cant tell you how many systems we have had issues with with a particular customer that insists we build it from scratch with ASUS boards, VIA chipsets and AMD processors. out of a run of 15 we will have probably have 5 blue screen on us.

Robert

by garion11

The reason I am building this thing is the price. The same features on a Dell machine are running at around $1500 to $2000. Although the warranty on their systems is great, these parts all come with 3 year manufacturer warranty in addition to the website warranties.

The motherboard I chose has PCI Express slot (better than AGP) but thanks for the info.

by house

The only HP I like is "sauce". Don't buy an HP if you want to start swapping hardware. You'll end up beating it down with a baseball bat.

I don't know what their cases are like nowadays, but I had a Pavilion about 2-3 years ago that went out the window. It had the proprietary Rubik's Cube inside. Piece of crap. It even had a modem/sound combo card. "Who are the wizards that came up with this one?"

by dafe2

I agree with your assessment....however, 2 or three years ago I'm sure I was still building my own boxes too (All due respect here). Incidently, if I'd worked on a Pavilion I'd still be bitter too.....it would also be part of the driveway.

Workstation Offerings from Tier 1 vendors offer great value for money.

Other than the low end desktops from these vendors nothing is proprietary - with the exeption of the power supplies....these can be had for about 70 - 100 dollars IF necessary.

All I'm saying is check them out...the workstations....you may find a lot of machine for your money.

by maxwell edison

.
The only HP I like includes printer or plotter in its name.

I'd never buy an HP computer, but I buy nothing but HP printing products.

by house

Everything looks good. I wouldn't invest in 64 bit cpu's right now either. Don't listen to them.

The only thing wrong is that you've chosen Nvidia. Joke. :) They're ok I guess, but I have an affinity for ATI.

house

by garion11

$ 830.00 (before tax)

I upgraded to 3.0 Ghz, added a different DVD player (alread ordered the memory), and even managed to buy a few extended warranties on some of the components. Similar system at Dell went for $1600.00.

by dafe2

I'm only (half) joking here:

I'd be concerned about the caliber of system board being offered at that price (and) if your getting yourself into one of those chassis's that "flex" when you sneeze, sound like an air conditioner and rip two layers of skin off your hand when you reposition a cable.

Things to consider is all.

by house

Did you forget to switch the Nvidia card for an ATI? Joke. You might actually be better off with the Nvidia, although I prefer ATI.

From my observation, it seems that ATI is usually about one month ahead of Nvidia. ATI will release a card, and Nvidia will counter with it's own. This being said, there is a good chance that Nvidia has that extra month to produce a better product for the same price. I've not compared the two in a proper 3d mark test myself, but I've read numerous reviews that claim Canadian based ATI on top every single time for every new release over the past year or so.

My preference for ATI is in no way scientific... it is just one of those things.

You should keep us up to speed after you have completed the project.

house

by dafe2

Actually, I was suggesting a "workstation" class system.....my original post wasn't clear on that point.

Lately, at least from HP & DELL, they offer a nice "Base" to work from, solid performance, lots of expansion. The chassis is designed for tooless entry and is easy to work in and arround.

Apotheon says it all....entry level boxes from these guys usually offer no expansion, old firmware, built in video, slow FSB, inadequate power supplies, poorly developed riser cards etc..

I bought the HP XW 4200 Workstation for about 900.00ca and some change, then built from there. I use it primarily as a "server" at the house. Don't know your intended use for your system.......

I think we'd agree that many of us have ended up with FRANKENPUTERS at one time other too.

Building your own continues to have many advantages.....not the least of which could include some personal satisfaction. I think the cost of building today plays a much smaller role than it did say even 5 years ago. My take on it anyway.

Currently, I view value for money as getting a base from a tier 1 vendor, HOWEVER, I'd still build my own in a heartbeat given the right circumstances.

Good luck to you!

by maxwell edison

.
I'm with you in that I, too, prefer to build my own and stay away from the Dell and HP stuff. The advertised and off-the-shelf brand names are certainly more inexpensive, but they're "cheap" in absolutely every sense of the word -- or P.O.S. comes to mind. If you call Dell and specify exactly what you want, the cost is usually 1.5 times (maybe 2 times) what you'd spend to build a similar unit. Besides, when I put my own together, I think I'm better able to deal with any problems it might have -- I really do know the computer inside and out, so to speak.

As far as the specifications of yours, it all looks pretty good to me, and I think all you'll get is a difference of preferences. So here are mine.

Someone mentioned the Antec Sonata case, and I agree. It's a great case; it looks good; it has all the quiet features including a case fan that you really can't hear, and vibration isolation for the drives; and it has plenty of room to work in. Antec tech support is very good as well. Out of the dozen or so Sonata cases I've purchased, one of them had a case fan that didn't fit my definition of "quiet", and they replaced it with no questions and no problems. I also once broke the hinge on a door, and they replaced that as well -- free of charge. The only downside to the case would be if you prefer one without a door that conceals the drives. Some people may not want to fool with a door, and if you were to remove it, the case would not be the good looking unit it was designed to be.

Motherboards are changing all the time. Unless you work with them on a daily basis, it's hard to know which one is the best. I've tried a number of manufacturers, and have pretty much decided, rightly or wrongly, that either Intel or ASUS provides the best value and performance all around. I've had problems with ABit and a couple of others, even though other people haven't, while I've had great luck and performance with Intel and ASUS. So I just look for the latest and greatest Intel or ASUS board, and pick the one that will provide the best basis for the rest of my specifications.

Someone else recommended ATI instead of NVidia, and I concur. I've had both, and although I haven't had any significant problems with NVidia, I've just come to prefer ATI. It's a great card for my primarily CAD environment, and I've run the gamut by buying the higher end cards, or the more mainstream. (I've not used the PCI Express, so I just don't know.)

I seem to change preferences for manufacturers of hard drives as often as I change my radio listening habits (from classic rock and roll to country to jazz to conservative talk to liberal talk, etc.); and I don't really have a reason for it. For the longest time I was buying the IBM DeskStar; then it was the Western Digital; and now I seem to drift to the Maxtor flavor of the day. I've been buying the Maxtor DiamondMax 7200 RPM, Ultra ATA/133 drive with the 8MB cache -- anywhere from 30GB up to 160GB, and I haven't had one fail yet. Moreover, they are built with a very quiet motor, and it seems to be a good fit with my "quiet" goals that led me to the Antec Sonata case.

I've bought a lot of RAM from Crucial, and as long as the specifications fit the board, it's as good as any.

Intel versus AMD will continue to be the debate of the day. I tried the AMD processors back in the K6-300 / K6-333 days when I bought either that or the Intel Pentium. Personally speaking, I had more trouble with the AMD chips back then, so that probably formed my preference for Intel. Those particular processors just seemed to crash and freeze up more often. They ran hotter, so I had to beef up the cooling capacity by adding additional case fans (which made them more noisy) or liquid cooling coils (just kidding). But from what I've read, the AMDs of today are more reliable, and they are the preferred processor for heavy-duty gamers because they can be more easily overclocked, at least that's what I've heard. But I still prefer the Intel processor. And especially if I buy the Intel board, it just makes sense to me that, most likely, that particular board was designed around the Intel processor and might perform better.

You didn't mention a monitor, and that certainly depends on your budget and applications. But I've bought a few of the ViewSonic flat panels and I'm very impressed with them. The 19" gets a little pricey, but you can get a 17" VA721 for around $350, maybe a little less.

And don't forget the cool keyboard and mouse. I buy the Microsoft optical mouse and Microsoft keyboard with all the bells and whistles. A nice finishing touch for not a lot of money. (And my users feel special when we spend the extra bucks.)

Good luck with your computer.

by willcomp

Have you had any experience with LGA775 motherboards? I have not had to tackle one yet, but understand they are quite tricky.

As you may have noticed, I'm a fan of Athlon 64's due to my experience with them. However, would not chastise anyone for selecting an Intel motherboard (most reliable ones) and a P4.

Also prefer ATI since drivers are more stable. nVidia may be tweaking performance at expense of stability. I prefer stable.

Maxtor drives are fine. Use them and WD. However, no Maxtor drive can compete with WD Raptor drives. They are simply much faster and also much more expensive per GB.

I'm the other Sonata case fan also. A real bargain considering power supply is included.

Dalton

by maxwell edison

.
I've not used the ASUS LGA755.

The board on my current "specification" list is the ASUS P4P800-E. I've purchased about 8 over the past year, and they are performing great with the Intel 2.8 GHz processor.

Perhaps my next drive will be one of your recommended WD Raptor drives. It never hurts to give a different one a "test drive".

And you're right about the Sonata case "bargain" because of that ultra-quiet power supply. That's a $50 dollar value by itself, which puts the rest of the case in the $50 range.

Later...

by willcomp

I build custom systems including small office servers (basically a desktop in a bigger box with mirrored RAID). Having seen P4's and Athlon 64's in very similar systems, the Athlon 64 is superior in almost all respects when running Windows. It really shines on a small server running Windows 2000. The difference is noticable without running benchmarks.

Also Athlon 64's are less expensive and motherboards are very reasonable.

His selected mobo has an LGA775 socket which I am hesitant to tackle until absolutely necessary.

The 10,000 RPM Raptors also make a significant difference.

Dalton

by tomsal

I don't know what the intentions of this system are (business/recreation?) and perhaps I should of read more to learn the answer to that..lol..

Anyway.. as an avid pc gamer (aside from pc geek) I've built more custom game boxes (for me and others) than the amount of years I am old.

Right now you simply will not find a better performance value than the AMD 64 - period.

If you do happen to be into building a box for game and your budget is limited...you can shave down the drives a little and devote more money into the video card...theoretically either of the latest line from ATI or Nvidia are great...but on a personal note I'm a Nvidia guy. I have an Over Clocked 6800 I picked up for just around $300, plays every game (includes Far Cry, Doom 3 and Half Life 2) I can throw at it and very high res with respectable frame rates.

Definitely go for the dual channel memory too if you *do* want a game box...you want atleast 1 gb ram.

Sound cards...still the best bang for the buck .. the Santa Cruz (Turtle Beach Systems).

Even supports surround sound.

Now for a business box...do the reverse...crank down the video card and get the best hard drives you can afford...the 10k drives as talked about earlier in this thread are good ideas.

Either way the AMD64 is an excellent choice (what even more power and you got the bucks...look into a socket 939 motherboard and the AMD FX-55, we all know how fast technology changes but as of 1 month ago the FX was deemed the world's fastest processor (for consumer PCs). The testing was done by Anandtech, if you know about those guys they test pretty strict.)

by house

I've got a Lexmark S 1855 laser at home. I've had an Epson ink jet, which was a piece of garbage, and a Sharp about 10 years ago which lasted me quite a while.

I've had experience with networked HP printers in a corporate environment... enough to turn my stomach.

I am all for the Lexmark Lasers, and will buy another one if mine ever decides to take a trip.

by maxwell edison

.
This is especially true for the large format plotters. I have 3 HP1050c plotters in my office, and they are all very reliable work-horses. The HP4si printers are still going strong after a lot of years and many hundreds of thousands of printed sheets, and I just recently got rid of a couple of LaserJet IIIs that were close to 10 years old.

Sure, the low end DeskJets aren't as reliable, but I have a lot of those still going strong as well. And personally, I've never had any bad network issues with them.

by willcomp

Dammit Max, I hate to have to agree with you again.

HP Laserjet printers generally cannot be beat. My first one was a Laserjet+ and have been sold on them since with a few exceptions. The 5L, 6L, and 1100 series personal/small office printers were problem children primarily due to paper feed issues.

I consider HP, Canon, and Epson inkjets of about equal quality across the product lines.

Lexmark lasers are OK, but their inkjets leave a lot to be desired.

Another big plus for HP is wide availability of consumables. Last time I checked, you could still buy toner cartridges for every laser printer ever manufactured by HP.

Dalton

by mrafrohead

The links aren't working, so I can't verify everything... BUT - this is what I have...

The case, dunno without seeing it. But as long as it has adequate ventilation, you'll be okay, that's really the most important part. Though, I really think that functionality is a very nice addition too. So if you have those two things, you have a winner.

I'm not familiar with Aspire for power supplies. I like Antec, and I have a Thermaltake that I'm using right now in a box that is working well. Though I don't generally care for Thermaltake products and I think they're poorly made. I learned the hard way... Main thing on your power supply. I'd keep it at at least 450watts. And make sure it's from a good manufacturer. Your system will have enough stuff in it that it can drain the power quickly. Also, if you plan on ever upgrading or expanding, you'll want the extra room on your PS...

Motherboard looks nice. I like the four SATA connects. Very good. May I recommend when you get the SATA HD's. Go with the Western Digital Raptor... http://tinyurl.com/63hem I have a pair of the 36.7G drives running Raid0. All I have to say is hold onto your seats. These things are FAST!!! I can do a full format of the 70G in under 30 seconds... I use them for video encoding and they're nice. I can definately say that my HD's are not the bottleneck of my system...

For the processor, you will get much better performance if you go with the AMD. Though the AMD has "Palladium" built into it. (google it if you don't know what it is, it's scary and enough to where I no longer buy from AMD, and they're all I have bought from). I would try the Via C3 chip. That's my next purchase... ;p

I can't see the dvd drive you have listed. I will recommend the Pioneer DVR-108 burner. It's a 16X DVD burner with 4X DL burning... The thing that makes this drive so special, is if you use it with the Ritek G05 8X DVD-/+ disks, you can burn at 12X. It's kinda nice. And cost effective.

Cables, should be round to help with better air flow. Can't see them. Though the SATA should be fine no matter what.

The video card, I have heard good things about, though I prefer ATI myself... But those that I know that use Nvidia are VERY happy with their **00 cards...

Overall, sounds great. I hope that you enjoy it!!! :)

Mrafrohead

by cactus pete

If done right, cabling with flat rather than round is just as airflow efficient. Aesthetically, well, that's all up to whomever, but there is a possible signal loss due to the bundled wires in a rounded cable. I recommend flat - just like my world.

by jdclyde

The equates to a wall right down the middle of your computer.

If you are going with a high end system you have to improve air flow as much as possible.

If you have a slower system, it doesn't generate the same amount of heat so the flat is just fine.

Just my humble opinion and why I have it.

by maxwell edison

.
Some of the motherboards I've purchased recently came with the round cables. If the flat ones allow for better air flow, should I have taken a hammer and flattened those suckers out a little bit?

And I heard that the orange colored round cables allow better air flow than the green ones. And I could swear I detected a slight citrus aroma. I'm sure glad I got the orange ones.

by mrafrohead

Another aspect I forgot to post in my last one a few above.

When people see your boxes and they ask, Dude, is that a Dell???

And you can say, HELL NO, that's a MRAFROHEAD!!! ;o)

I love the fact that all of my computers are my creations and not off of some assembly line where they were just put together, instead of being carefully made with love and sweat and heart... Okay, just kidding there, but I think you get my drift.

There's a lot of pride in building your own musclehouse box that just kicks you know what... And you can sit back and say, "I did that."

Mrafrohead

by dafe2

I think you need more Fiber in your diet.

Building systems for many, comes down to simple satisfaction. For others it's cost. Today if you build a "killer box"......it can be more expensive (or very close) to the cost of a WORKSTATION. It depends whose definition of "killer box" you use.

Sometimes, a WORKSTATION of equivalent performance to your "MRAFROHEAD" may even cost $500.00 MORE.

Now, here's the secret.....Pay attention...I don't want to loose you now......are you ready?.........ok:

For some people, myself being one of them, IT'S NOT WORTH the savings to spend the day building a system to save 500 bucks for the sake of a couple of CPU cycles. I'd bet that 500 bucks that some of the guys reading this have probably built more systems in a week, than the years you've been alive. I didn't say awake.

Hope I didn't loose you there......that was the important part.

Now, if I thought you could tell me the difference between a WORKSTATION and a Personal Computer.......I'd be more inclined to believe that your MRAFROHEAD wasn't a FRANKENPUTER.

Garion11 was looking for opinions and options.....to answer the question, it's good to understand motivation & goal..................damn it, I lostya again didn't I....sorry about that.

by mrafrohead

Maybe you should pay attention. If you would have read what I stated earlier...

You will get a better computer for the same amount of money.

Easy enough?

I'd lay off of the "whitty rhetoric", as it's quite lacking, and almost... *yawn* put me to sleep...

In regards to this:
"Now, if I thought you could tell me the difference between a WORKSTATION and a Personal Computer.......I'd be more inclined to believe that your MRAFROHEAD wasn't a FRANKENPUTER."

I can tell you your mistake was the third and fourth words. You should refrain from that type of thing. Dangerous consequences can result...

Mrafrohead

by house

What about the proprietary network ports? I think that this is an issue when we talk about standards.

I'm not saying that HP makes bad printers.

by trockii

He's a reseller. If people don't buy prebuilt machines from him he is out of a job. Why is saving $500 NOT worth spending ONE day building a computer? Do you mean to tell everyone here you make over $500/day equaling over $175K/year? I know I sure as **** I don't make that much and the satisfaction I get from building my own computer is worth the day or two for me specially when it takes me a week to make $500. I work hard for what little money I make as well as everyone else here.

by garion11

I didn't follow the past comments so I am going to assume your post refers to me.

After looking at several options and in considering how old my PC is (Dell Celeron 466, lol, 4 years old) I decided go ahead with the project. The bonus of this is the lesson learned, money saved, and to finish a PC from end to end. We have all worked on PCs probably from replacing components, but I figured this would teach me a few things and fill in some of the knowledge gaps.

the final cost with extended warranty, shipping, came to roughly $900 and I was ecstatic and just can't wait for the parts to get here, lol.

The links I was told weren't working but here is a link for the PC case. It looks like a rocket, lol.

http://www.aerocool.us/case/jetmaster/jetmaster%20bk-photo.htm

Thank you all for your comments and suggestions. I will keep posting updates on the project. Can anyone else display their PC pictures??? I think it would be kind of fun to see your creations...lol. :)

by trockii

This was only my second personal built pc. I have had it for just about 2 years now, with no hard ware problems. I have built 4 more since then for friends and family. Each time I learn something new. All said and done it only cost me around $600. I got the video card used (2 months old) for $250 from a friend. Retail is still over $350.

Specs:
Case: Ahanix Platinum XP
MOBO: Asus A7N8X-X
CPU: AMD Athlon XP 2200+
Memory: Crucial Technologies 512MB DDR PC3200
HDD: Western Digital 80GB 7200RPM
Video Card: Prolink GeForce FX 5900 256MB Ram
Sound: on board

http://www.overclockersclub.com/reviews/platinumxpcase.php

by garion11

Explored that option, but I didn't trust it. A sound card (Audigy), raid, memory are the future upgrades for this guy at this point. :).

by mrafrohead

You want to talk about a plane taking off...

Man, I got this Thermaltake box, that has pretty poor airflow... So I figured I would upgrade the fans to these fans you would typically see in a server. They move so much air, it's quite impressive. But they're L O U D!!!! Which wasn't a big deal, because I bought this really cool fan controller. So I could turn them down when I wasn't encoding movies... Great idea in theory, at least I thought.

But in practise...

Man, these things are so loud, and I have seven of them, that when they are turned all of the way up, you can't talk to the person standing next to you without almost yelling. When they're turned down, they sound like a hair dryer running full bore... Not what I was expecting. Worse part is that the fans at their low setting moving probably twice the air as the original fans, keep the box running warmer than the original ones... If turned up they work like a dream, but it's so loud it's just gross... But I don't want to put the other fans back in because I spent a hundred bucks on the "upgrade" that was just bogus... ;p wocka wocka

Moral is, my next cooling solution, will be with liquid cooling.

Mrafrohead

by trockii

Glad I can learn from other's mistakes. LOL J/K I guess bigger isn't always better.

by jdclyde

I have seen systems where people tried to "improve" airflow by adding more fans. Not in this lifetime.

The only thing worse is a cheap power supply that whines or whistles. Lets talk nails on a chalk board!

My next project will be mounting all the parts on a piece of plywood and hanging it on the wall as my computer. Maybe a fan blowing across it.

Why you ask? Because it looks cool. Like you need a better reason.

by mrafrohead

"I have also built systems for the same ammount of time."

Then you would know that there is no prefab machine that will run better than a home built computer.

Hands down, that's all that there is to it.

The ONLY perk to a prefab is that you get the outstanding outsourced tech support that you can't understand because they don't speak English... But then again, I'm sure you already know that and that's why you were so offended. The truth hurts sometimes...

YOU asked a ? and I answered it with an honest and factual answer. If you are too good to see that then that is your own loss...

My post was to save Garion11 the hassle of buying some POS prefab when he is attempting to build himself a real computer.

It's a pretty simple concept...

And originally, my tone was meant in a jovial joking manner. But you're a jerk, so I take that back.

Mrafrohead

by dafe2

Now, once again my point:

THERE IS A BIG TECHNICAL DIFERENCE BETWEEN A "WORKSTATION" AND A "PERSONAL COMPUTER"

It does NOT matter if it's whitebox, home made or factory made - I wasn't referring to an entry level box.

I kept the words at a minimum and kept my caps on. I understand I tend to put you to sleep.

For the last time:

W O R K S T A T I O N

Also, (since) you got personal this time:

I was simply offended by your lack of technical knowledge. (You said you where concerned about offending me personally, so I thought I should clear that up)

I'll keep this short and sweet too:

F-O....afrohead.......notice I didn't say Mr or even please?

Fill your boots with any replies, your now just a waste........**it, I new you where sleeping.

by mrafrohead

First off...

Read this, this is the title of the thread that was started:

"Building my own PC -- Any opinions or comments are welcome"

Where do you see workstation??? You invented that part all by your self... It was NEVER a part of the freaking thread you moron!!! So explain to me, where did workstation came from? It was never brought up until you started with it...

Second...

"Fill your boots with any replies, your now just a waste........**it, I new you where sleeping."

I think that you should have spelled it "knew" not new.

MY ignorance is showing???

Mrafrohead... ;p Wait, that might be too much for you, how about this:

Fro...

"It does NOT matter if it's whitebox, home made or factory made - I wasn't referring to an entry level box."

Who was talking about making an entry level box??? No one was. Garion11 was talking about building a computer. You mentioned prefab garbage. I gave my advice about your prefab garbage that you have been peddling for the last 15 years... Prefab shit sucks, flat out, no lies. It just sucks! There is no prefab ANYTHING that you can supply that I can't build a better piece, for the same price or cheaper. So get over it. I know, the truth hurts, but accept it. That's all there is to it. You are no more superior than anyone in this thread, so stop trying to act like it.

You put me to sleep because you think you're some kind of computer god, but you are more of a joke than anything. I'll bet you're one of those schmucks that sits around with like twenty certs thinking he's the shit, when you don't know jack and only have them because you went to some crash course class that "guarentee's a pass". And I'll bet you have them all labeled on your little pretty business cards with your own personal font too huh??? YOU probably wouldn't know a workstation if it came up and bit you in the ass.

by dwdino

If you fold the ribbons correctly, they can be flush against the back/motherboard. 100% out of the airflow path.

by mrafrohead

If you just had the rounded cables to begin with, you wouldn't have to fold it up. That is, if you are talking about what I think you are. You mean folding them into like fourfold piece of skinny cable??? That's ultimately all a rounded cable is, just in a prepacked form, that is a little easier to work with, IMHO.

As for the part from a previous post of the cables being together to reduce signal noise, the folding of the cable would ultimately do the same thing as having the rounded cables.

In all seriousness though. The rounded cables are done right out of the package. They will reduce the airflow. You won't have to fold up your flat ribbons to make them less intrusive (which does work very well, but I am horrible at doing ;p). And in regards to the signal interferance, I can say that I've been using round cables for about three years and I have noticed no performance issues. Although sitting here thinking about it, I think it would be okay as your power connections are seperate from your data connection. I think that the power is what would cause the interference. Reason I say this is: when you wire a car stereo, you wire your audio connections down one side of the car, and you wire your power connections down the other side. The reason you do this is the power flowing through the power cables can bleed into the audio cables and cause interference. Since the data and power cables are seperate on a computer, you should be okay from that type of problem. I think...

by maxwell edison

.
That way the air can just flow through them. And I use one of those single hole-punchers so the size of the holes are consistent.

by mrafrohead

I don't understand how you do that. There isn't enough room between wires to poke a hole without cutting a wire or two...

Are you serious or just kidding?

Mrafrohead

by willcomp

Believe your data transfer rate will be about 0 KB/sec with that method.

Max, we discussed Antec cases earlier. This is a link to info for a non-door Antec case with 120 mm fan. It is quiet, drives are exposed, and is fairly easy to work in. Power supply is 350 watt SmartPower instead of 380 watt TruePower in Sonata case. Side panels remove vertically. Remove 2 thumbscrews from top rear and slide top off. Then lift up side panel(s). It's strange, but rather easy when one gets used to it.

I have used several and am quite pleased with them.

Would not use for multiple high speed HDDs though due to concern about drive cooling with no front fan.

http://www.directron.com/csslk1650b.html

Dalton

by mrafrohead

I get what you're saying. That is what I used to do to keep them out of the way.

But in all seriousness, I found that the rounds were the way to go. You don't have to mess around with all of that jazz, and they work very well.

But again, this is just my opinion, and we all know what's said about those... ;p

Mrafrohead

by mrafrohead

I'll throw up a few pics of my main box. The rest of my boxes aren't very spectacular, but my main one is kinda neat to look at with the lights off... ;p

Specially when my new lights show up. I'm upgrading the lights in the box from blue to U/V to match the U/V sensitive cables I just upgraded to. Had plain silver with clear coating in there, but changed to blue cables that glow with the black light... They're kinda neat... ;p

Mrafrohead

by dafe2

I hope you don't mind, but considering you tend to fall asleep & stuff I copied your post here so you could follow along while I answer all your questions for you. Your some curious guy aren't you?

"Building my own PC -- Any opinions or comments are welcome"

Answer - Yes I read it, I gave my comment & opinion ? A workstation from IBM or HP, now that you've gotten personal I'll add: but not from a scumbag, like yourself

Where do you see workstation??? You invented that part all by your self... It was NEVER a part of the freaking thread you moron!!! So explain to me, where did workstation came from? It was never brought up until you started with it...

Answer - Yes I read it, I gave my comment & opinion ? A workstation from IBM or HP. now that you've gotten personal I'll add: but not from a scumbag, like yourself

"Fill your boots with any replies, your now just a waste........**it, I new you where sleeping."

I think that you should have spelled it "knew" not new.

Answer - Yes I did make that mistake, glad you where awake, thanks!

Mrafrohead... ;p Wait, that might be too much for you, how about this:

Answer - Yes that was too much?especially the Mr part, May I call you fro?

"It does NOT matter if it's whitebox, home made or factory made - I wasn't referring to an entry level box."

Answer - You may want to go back to school, that means that "I" wasn?t talking about an entry level box, I was talking about a workstation

Who was talking about making an entry level box??? No one was. Garion11 was talking about building a computer. You mentioned prefab garbage. I gave my advice about your prefab garbage that you have been peddling for the last 15 years... Prefab **** sucks, flat out, no lies. It just sucks! There is no prefab ANYTHING that you can supply that I can't build a better piece, for the same price or cheaper. So get over it. I know, the truth hurts, but accept it. That's all there is to it. You are no more superior than anyone in this thread, so stop trying to act like it.

Answer - WAIT! I didn?t say anything about you being a liar. Let's be clear, I was suggesting, but am now convinced, your an as**hole. The only thing I peddle (Pedal)is a bike.
Never said I was superior, nor do I act. Yes, I know what I?m talking about. I think your pissed because you know your full of sh**t

You put me to sleep because you think you're some kind of computer god, but you are more of a joke than anything. I'll bet you're one of those schmucks that sits around with like twenty certs thinking he's the ****, when you don't know jack and only have them because you went to some crash course class that "guarentee's a pass". And I'll bet you have them all labeled on your little pretty business cards with your own personal font too huh??? YOU probably wouldn't know a workstation if it came up and bit you in the ass

Answer - I?ll keep this one short, I?m still concerned about your sleep so: If I was a computer god, then you?d be the devil? No I?m not a joke because you don?t seem to think I?m funny. No I?m not a shmuck with twenty certs?But I did work hard for the 12 I have?.Not sure what those stars say, but it can?t be good. No I never met Jack but I did screw his sister Jill...and your wife too. I failed that crash course even though they gave me that guaranty.

No I don?t have a little business card. Your wife did say yours was little.

Oh yes - If that workstation does ever bite my ass I?ll be sure and shove it up yours so you can appreciate the technology "behind" it.

By now.

by trockii

He HAS to be joking. Like you said there's NO WAY you can punch holes in an IDE cable to let air flow through. LOL he got you hook line and sinker on that one. What is the price difference between the flat IDE cables and round? I know all the motherboards I buy come with the flat floppy drive and flat IDE cables, so round cables would be an additional cost.

by maxwell edison

.
It depends on the size of the holes. Mine are only about one-eigth inch diameter, so the worst thing that happens is a little fragmented data. But we should all have a good disk defragmenter in our bag of tricks, so it's something I can deal with. After all, maintaining good air-flow is worth the additional effort.

by maxwell edison

.
And it can be a good indicator of proper installation. If you have orange cables, for example, but detect the lime-citrus aroma, then you probably have the primary and secondary cables installed backwards. The same would apply, of course, with the green cables emitting the orange-citrus aroma.

A mixture of yellow and green cables -- a lemon-lime combination -- can get rather confusing.

Your jumpers might enter into the equation as well, since it can determine when it's time to jump off this silly tangent.

Besides, it's time for lunch...............

Chinese...............

Orange Chicken, of course.

Later...

by jkaras

The only important part of the computer that you should seriously consider is not going cheap on the power supply. This is the heart of the computer and if you got a cheapo then you could either have random lock up issues or major damage to the other expensive parts. I reccommend Antec, if you question my reccommendation then do comparitive research on the net, there are many articles written.
As for online buying, always trust Newegg (my opinion). I trusted other sites only to get burned on their warrantee stalling to replace with new giving me refurbished and long waits when getting bunk parts. If you save a couple of dollars, it may cost you much more in the long run.

Invest in better cooling, but you will suffer from more noise, there is no great answer.

Clarify what your intention for the pc is for. Gaming? Video editing? Or just surfing?

Dont go for the top of the line because the price will drop saving you money. (exception Power Supply)

Video card, I prefer ATI over Nvidia, better support, but a bit more pricy at times, rather on the fence.

Some people love Xp, me I'm not really impressed and 2000 pro has always been stable enough with all that's necessary. Is there any advantage to XP? Only future support because it is a newer OS.

Intel or AMD? personal preference AMD because its cheaper and at times easier to over clock or upgrade but not always.

If mobo comes with integrated sound save money on sound card unless editing music, never use integrated video.

Memory, Crucial is good, Kingston, the same, the technology is the same so its preference. Stick with 512, not a gig, its just a waste. PC3200 is fine for just about anything, higher is great, but you wont really see much difference, its all good now for anything.

by mrafrohead

well now that I see where this one is going, i'm done.

you see, you're taking it to a place that only works when you are face to face. this can't be done online. so unless you live in the pacific northwest, this conversation is over. you've crossed the line, and I no longer am wasting my time and energy on something that can not be finished online.

enjoy yourself. i think that you're attempting to overcompensate for something, and there is no arguement for that.

Mrafrohead

by mrafrohead

They're about 3-8 bucks (US) depending where you by them and what you are buying. Just a plain cable that's about 24" long will get you about 3-5 bucks. But if you get anything that's "tricked out" it can cost a little more up to the 8 bucks...

Mrafrohead

by mrafrohead

I don't know man, they serve their purpose, but when in down time, they're SO not worth it. Knowing now, what I know versus what I thought, I would rather just have cracked the case and left a side panel off while encoding instead of listening to them loud all of the time and then even louder when needed... ;p

by johnrthomas30

I just got to my email after being locked up with work for several days straight, so I apologise for coming late to the party.

My comments are based on 30 years of hardware experience (yes, that goes back to before they invented the "PC", but we still had computers back then, they were just BIGGER ....lol), anyway....

I recently built a system for myself, and I used the AMD64 platform, which is the only processor I would recomend for a 'personal' system right now. The Code Execution Prevention thing is a big plus. For the corporate environment where all design work is based on the Intel/Microsoft source, then the compatability issue lists higher than extreme performance, but today even that old excuse is losing most of it's validity, as the AMD processors will run anything that Intel can run (and usually faster -at the same price point).

The AMD64 is the most advanced processor on the market that is available at consumer-level prices.

Video cards: The nVidia 6600 is good, but I would say get the 6600 GT, or the equivelent ATI card. They will both provide excellent performance for the money (I run the ATI 9600 XT for example, and it's great. Not bleeding edge, but it will run FarCry and Half-Life 2 beautifully).

The other areas to watch for performance enhancements are the RAM (more is better of course, and 512 MB is an absolute minimum these days, for example I run 2 GB), and the hard drives. For HDD's, I would go Serial ATA only, and the 10k rpm WD Raptors are amazing, but the regular WD SATA drives (or similar) are fine for everyday performance. I use twin 76GB Raptors, and they are lightning fast.

So, I hope that this helps (perhaps it's all a bit late, but one never knows....)

cheers
jrt

by mjd420nova

I have built over 500 pc's and have found that sticking to common or de-facto standard hardware will give you the best performance and ease of service down the road when something fails(it always does) Th elocalFRY's hates me. I buy two of each and return the unused one, that's beacuse i've gotten numerous failures in factory boxes.
Creative is the audio standard and Nvidia the video standard. Other cards will rquire patches and that will slow down the machine. The INTEL P-4
will run most any cards out there where AMD types either aren't recognized by the system or need patches. Atlons and Celerons present their own group of problems with patches and complete incompatabilies with some vieo cards and most audio cards. The system board should be devoid of on board video, audio or NIC's. This saves you from having to replace the whole system board should a function fail. Good Luck

by garion11

Thank you all for the great suggestions and comments. I got the parts shipped and they arrived yesterday (the memory is coming today). So I proceeded to go ahead and do what I can and finish the project today when the memory comes in.

I put the MB in, processor, fan, powersupply, HD, and DVD burner. I have yet to install the Chassis fans, the memory, USB/Firewire front interface and back plate (these came with the MB btw), and Video card. The case looks amazing...looks like a Jet engine (hopefully it won't be as noisy):) and is much bigger than I thought. The powersupply looks very cool and very organized and the reason I chose this case and powersupply (seperate) was because this guy was a 500W as opossed to the other powesupplies that came with the cases were going for 380 to 420W. Any how, I will be finishing it up tonight and thank you all for your posts.

by mrafrohead

did you end up going with exactly what you had above, or did you change anything?

Glad to hear you got it all together, almost, :)

by chris

Bottlenecks at the moment are above, I would get SATA HDD and at least 333Mhz System Bus.
As much Ram as possible with room to upgrade helps also

by dafe2

Considering this is a BUSINESS I have a few questions too....and some comment:

In some Business Environments guys will come up and ask the unavoidable question: Why are you paying XXX ammount of dollars and buying "junk" when I can build one for XXX. Your nuts!!!!

To those I can only answer this:

Usually a business is more interested in:

1- Reliability
2- Manageability
3- Warranty
4- Serviceability
5- Value for money

In that order.

No business owner cares about performance on (most) desktops. Most care about price & Total Cost Of Ownership.....value for money.

What's curious here is that the bottom line is speaking. No value, it seems, is placed on TCO in this case. It's been my experience that when you get 40,50 or even 200 "build your own boxes" out in the field, you usually end up with a whole lot of different components out there. Usually from different suppliers. Anyway, it generally turns in to an asset management nightmare and that's just the start of it. The total cost of ownership studies I've seen are usually TEN TIMES MORE using this model. Of course, it may work for this company I don't know.

I think "branded" business class desktop PC's DO put value in business and lower TCO for the following reasons (To name a few):

Reliability:

Usually a business desktop (as a unit) offers greater MTBF stats. In many cases, 17000 power on hours more than an "entry level" PC. (no stats where available for a "build your own" in this study of course.) Consistant manufacturing techniques and quality control methods ensure against premature component failures.

Manageability:

Usually a business desktop offers a DMI compliant BIOS and a WEB based interface to HP Openview or Insight Manager. Alerts, such as impending faillures of any sort can be routed to pagers, e-mail and blackberry etc...This advantage alone makes an Admins life a whole lot easier. Asset management reports can be produced from here as well.

Warranty:

Most vendors like DELL, HP or IBM will overnight anything......give them the serial number and it's there. No cost, no grief. Of course, a consistent desktop environment from one vendor makes life a whole lot easier for in house spares as well.

Serviceability:

Usually a business desktop offers a chassis (Case) that offers a tool free entry and even hot swappable PCI buses. MTTR (Mean time to repair) is usually 10 times faster - No longer is technician held up running arround looking for his phillips or torx drivers when failures do occur. Also included on theses cases is Solenoid lock controlled by BIOS (Password protected of course). No more "curious" users opening cases.

It's all well and good to build a PC and I usually use this analogy with those questioning souls I refer to above:

A "gearheads" PC is like a race car......it's a high performance machine that breaks down a lot (or) is "tweaked" in some way allmost daily.
The next time you look at a true gearheads case, you'll see that most of them have the "side pannel" open.........just waiting for that next "tweak". These owners live and breath performance, The "average" Corporate worker just wants his/her work to get done.

(Most) business PC's are like a Volvo.....usually putt arround, but they're reliable as hell and quick to service when broken.
(We're not talking about the Business Power User or Political crowd here. They demand Workstations, which offer all of the above advantages -plus- Big Time Performance, for a price).

Sounds like tHEaNTImIKE has had great success with his approach, and is saving money.......any ohers doing this out there? Am I missing out? I don't see this as "savings".

by garion11

Finally got the parts in and put it all together. PC was up and running on the first try, although I am still tweaking it here and there. The baby has 8 fans (including the Power supply) powering it, lol (2 rear fans, one large front fan, 1 side fan, a blower fan, a video card fan, and the processor fan). Nothing really changed except for the processor speed which I upped to 3.0 ghz.

So the final cost

Parts (+S/H) = $930.00
Memory (+S/H)= $150.00
Labor = a couple of hours
Satisfaction, confidence, and knowledge gained from building this from end to end = priceless.

This isn't a knock against anyone that suggested otherwise but after this experience I don't think I will ever buy a PC for myself ever again, only build. Thank you all for your input. Now onto Servers :P ;)

by mrafrohead

It really is worth it isn't it??? It just feels good putting one together and then watching it run.

by hal 9000

But over all I never consider buying off the shelf so to speak the ones that I build are just better.

But I did love one error message that I got with a new unit that I'd just built Windows told me this "Error Device 6 Missing" well after much searching around I eventually gave in and rang MS "well I'm a "Certified" Partner" so there should be some benefits but eventually after well over 1 hour on the tech support line I was told that I had not fitted the CPU as that was what "Device 6" was.

I never really understood that one and when I asked how I could get a error message telling me that I had not fitted the CPU without a CPU it also left the MS senior support guy speechless as well.

I pulled it all apart refitted everything again and it worked perfectly now all I want to know is how I loaded Windows with something not seated properly?

It's one that I've given up upon and just drag it out every now and then out of curiosity.

Col

by hal 9000

Use the Tyan Dual/Quad Processor M'Boards and forget about the AMD ones they just are not as good.

Col

by jdclyde

Many of your work systems still have the on-board video and sound as many working professionals do not need high end video at work. Just for publishing, video editing, CAD, or playing games.

If someone wants a system to use as a computer, your way is the way to go.

If someone is building a toy (like in this case) you save a lot by putting it together yourself.

Of course you would save even more by just getting an Xbox, but oh well.

This discussion is closed to new replies.