Discussion Locked

Bush tries to dictate Australian policy ...

0 helpful
41 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I don't know what kind of coverage the American media gave to John Howard's visit to America, but in reply to a question from a reporter from the Australian newspaper regarding Mark Latham's promise to withdraw Australian troops from Iraq by Christmas, if he is elected as Prime Minister before then, Bush gave a straightforward and honest answer which amounted to dictating what Australia's policy should be on this issue.

Not that Mark Latham will take any notice of this, but I think Bush should have said something like: "I cannot comment on Australia's foreign policy." or: "It would not be appropriate for me to comment on the foreign policy of another country."

Currently 63 per cent of Australians think Australia should never have gone to Iraq in the first place.

I don't think that Bush's comment will endear him to Australians.

Whilst Mark Latham has criticised Bush, he has not done so on a live telecast to the whole nation, and certainly not in a way that would be readily picked up by all Americans.

41 replies

by thechas

Julian,

Whether or not Bush is trying to influence Australian policy should not be the question.

Until Iraq has a functioning government and security forces it is short-sighted for ANY government to remove their troops from Iraq.

If all the foreign troops left Iraq tomorrow, the world would be at it's least secure point since the days just prior to World War 2.

Whether we should have invaded Iraq or not, now that we are there, EVERY citizen of the world has a vested interest in seeing the mission through to completion.

Iraq needs to be aided in developing a strong legitimate government. If we leave Iraq without a strong government, the entire Mideast region is at risk for civil unrest.

The best way to shorten the length of time needed to finish the job in Iraq is for EVERY nation to join in the effort.

The bulk of the "heavy lifting" is done. What we need now is the slow gentle work of forming a solid legitimate government.

To allow a new government to sprout and take hold will take a strong united show of force to stop the terrorists.

Every country that pulls out of Iraq strengthens the terrorists and places the world at higher risk.

Yes, we can still protest the war. We need to remind our leaders that going into Iraq was a mistake.

That said, we CANNOT compound that mistake by leaving before the task is complete.

Chas

by hal 9000

I couldn't agree more with your sediments we have to finish what we started even if it is an unpopular choice. Iraq is now the most unstable it has ever been with different factions attempting to gain power and there would be a wholesale Civil War if all the troops where to leave tomorrow.

We started this mess off and MUST FINISH it as well or we would be worse than Saddam Husein who at least had a form of control over the country even though it was not to our taste but it was under control which now it isn't. We can not leave until there is some form of established Government in place and I have no doubt that it will take many years for this to be a stable government as this kind of Democracy just has never existed in that area previously so they will need a lot of support for it to function and for many years as well.

Col

by chameleon186

Where is the other super power LOL. Nazi germany was a powerful force. Iraq your talking about damn near 3rd world there. Arab state nukes would never make the distance needed. Germany had massive forces air naval and ground and if you remember was trying to pioneer nuclear technology jsut never got off the ground. Nazi's was more than capable of reaching U.S. with it's forces. especially if they managed to biuld up again after europe. I think is what the problem is relates to lack of counter measures. there is still security holes in many systems. It's just a matter of time before one is breached. counter measures world wide will be the only ultimate solution. terrorist live everywhere they do not all come from iraq. They could be your nieghbors for that matter. You need a reality check

by thechas

I don't know what you read.

The point of my post is that to reduce the ability of the terrorist groups to continue their attacks, we need a solid unified showing of force.

Not active fighting necessarily, but enough troops in open view that the cowards have no place to act.

The other point is that if terrorist leaders even believe that their attacks are convincing ANY country to leave Iraq, the number and ferocity of the attacks will escalate.

And yes, we are not going to prevent another terrorist attack against the US simply from making Iraq a free nation.

To intercept and capture the terrorists, we do need EVERY nation to be vigilant and share their intelligence information.

Chas

by oz_media

Well at this point I must agree that pulling out for any reason would be almost as stupid as the war in the first place.

This was exactly what I foresaw when it started and one of the main reasons I didn't feel that SUPPOSED WMD were justification of such a massive and complicated campaign. We STILL have troops in Afghanistan, this was premature.

What's done is done, we've all been dragged into this next chapter in GWB's life whether we like it or not. Let's see it through and see him out the door so he can go bankrupt another oil company.

Only YOU can prevent re-election. (is that supposed to be hyphenated?)

OM

by jardinier

finish what the US started. A labor government would never have sent Australian troops to Iraq, and Mark Latham at the time seemed mostly concerned at the possibly thousands of children who were likely to die.

Howard felt obliged to kowtow to Bush because talks on free trade were also on the agenda.

What may also not have been reported in the American media was Howard's visit to California, where he met Governor Arnie, and has struck a lucrative deal (for Australia) to supply a massive amount of fuel gas.

I will have to disagree strongly with you on this one Chas. The US invaded Iraq prematurely, based on false information and without the sanction of the UN Security Council. Now it wants all these other countries to try and fix the mess they made.

Let America send more of its own personnel to Iraq, and not leave the job of tidying up to countries who considered the invasion ill-advised in the first place.

Everyone to whom I have spoken today agreed that Bush should not have made those comments about Latham.

You had better start getting used to Latham, as currently he has a far greater chance of becoming prime minister, than it appears Bush has of being re-elected.

by sbi-limited

What America needs is for all of those who are ardent Patriots who have NOT had the opportunitty to serve in the Armed Forces (but feverously believe we should stay the course in Iraq), to immediately sign up and volunteer to go to Iraq until the course is complete. There are 4 branches to choose from. I'm told there's no waiting. I am a Vietnam combat veteran and I learned all about the politics behind Vietnam and I understand the politics behind the Invasion of Iraq. Back up your rhetoric. Go!

by oz_media

NObody in the world has been able to provide proof of the politics behind Iraq. MANY have offered proof surrounding SOME points behind Iraq, such as the Oil for Food program, WMD etc. even the president of the United States has not given a clear description of the politics or even the basic resons behiond the Iraq invasion as the focus and intent of the action has changed several times sice the initial invasion.

Perhaps you can enlighten myself as well as other TR peers here who have debated and shon proof behind MANY different reasons for the Iraq invasion. You seem to know more than GWB himself as he has never given a clear reason for this invasion either, not one that is justified and doesn't change a week later anyway..

by garion11

....Bush gave a straightforward and honest answer which amounted to dictating what Australia's policy should be on this issue.....

Can you post it please??

by oz_media

++++++++++++++++++++++++
From ABC Radio Australia
http://tinyurl.com/2esq5
++++++++++++++++++++++++

Australian PM ends US visit

The Prime Minister John Howard has wound up his fifth visit to Washington by defending the President George W.Bush against claims that he had intervened in Australian domestic politics.

John Shovelan reports from Washington Prime Minister Howard defended President Bush's stinging criticism of Mr Latham.

At a press conference yesterday President Bush said Mr Latham's proposal to withdraw troops would be "disasterous".

Mr Howard says his answer was consistent with the stance that he's taken.

Mr Howard is on his way to France's Normandy coast to mark the 60th anniversary of the D-Day landing.

He says Europe, should remember the sacrifice America had made in liberating Europe and the debt they owe the United States

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
From Ireland Online
http://tinyurl.com/yvf5n
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Iraq pullout would be disastrous - Bush

US president George Bush, facing tough talks with America?s allies, has said it would be disastrous if they pulled their troops out of Iraq.

Pulling out, Bush said, would send the wrong signals to the Iraqi people and to terrorists. ?It would dispirit those who love freedom in Iraq,? he said.

Bush, standing alongside Australian prime minister John Howard, a strong ally on Iraq, made his comments at the White House before leaving Washington for Rome on the first leg of a three-day European trip.

Howard renewed his intention to keep Australia?s 850 troops in Iraq, despite political criticism in his own country.

?It is the worst time imaginable for allies to be showing any weakness in relation to the pursuit of our goals in Iraq,? he said.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Pacific Rim Bureau (CNSNews.com)
http://tinyurl.com/2qnvp
Bush, Howard Agree Allies Shouldn't Pull Troops From Iraq

An Australian decision to withdrew its troops from Iraq by Christmas, as promised by the official opposition Labor Party, would be "disastrous," President Bush said Thursday.

"It would be a disastrous decision for the leader of a great country like Australia to say that 'we're pulling out,' " Bush said in response to a question during a joint appearance with visiting Prime Minister John Howard.

"It would embolden the enemy [and] it would dispirit those who love freedom in Iraq," he added.

A few minutes earlier, Howard -- whom Bush praised as a personal friend and U.S. ally -- said it was "the worst time imaginable for allies to be showing any weakness in relation to the pursuit of our goals in Iraq..."
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

You're welcome.

Remember, you have never actually shown ANY links or valid proof of ANY of your prior statements here when you have been asked to. Make sure you are willing to do the same in future when you start to rant.

by garion11

So Bush stating his opinion (which I think is a fact, but thats debatable) about a pull out of Australian troops from Iraq... How does that equal to Bush "dictating Australian policy?"

by jimhm

Right or Wrong - once you start you need to finish it. Otherwise it is worse than when you started.

Kind of like making love - once you start - you finish - or do you stop in the middle and say - sorry not in the mood tonight dear...

by jardinier

I would describe the invasion of Iraq as a TOTAL FUCK UP !

If current voting trends continue, come November Australia will have a new prime minister who, unlike Howard, has integrity (you wouldn't understand this as you would not be familiar with Australian domestic issues).

America, on the other hand, will quite likely have John Kerry as its president. And who will you have to thank for this? Yes, your blundering bull-in-a-china-shop GW Bush.

No doubt if this occurs you will blame the media and other leftie weanies. But the outcome, if this is the case, can be readily attributed to your constitution which permits freedom of the press.

You often cite the benefits of the freedoms given to you by your constitution. However these very same freedoms may just come back to bite you on the backside.

by garion11

If Bush wins, I get a cookie....no wait, make it a beer. Ice cold Fosters.

If Kerry wins, you get a hotdog with Heinz ketchup. lol

by jardinier

This discussion is NOT about Mark Latham's Iraq policy, but about Bush publicly criticising the policy of a contender for the leadership of another country.

Australia has had a strong alliance with the US since 1916, when this alliance was established under a war-time LABOR prime minister, John Curtin.

This alliance DOES NOT require Australia to be subservient or sycophantic to America, as Howard has been.

In an earlier discussion when I referred to Howard's subservience to the US, one answer was: "Well that's your problem. Vote him out if you don't like him."

We intend to do just that.

A man I spoke to this morning suggested that if Howard had been any kind of a decent leader, he would not have permitted Bush to make these remarks.

So please, start again and address the topic of the discussion, or SHUT UP!

by oz_media

When defending American politics, it is common for those who support it (either Dem or Repub) to sinply side step and evade to a different issue when they are cornered.

The presidents and prime ministers have made it such an art that people do it without relizing it.

by hal 9000

They just don't know any better and think that they have a "God Given Right" to comment on other countries political agendas.

Col

by oz_media

Australian policy is a decision that is completely up to Australia and it is politically incorrect for another leader to be so vocal against another politicians views unless they are running against each other directly. It's poor form, crass, arrogant, it's.....typically American.

If Mark Lathham had visited Bush and said that the invasion was "disasterous", this forum would be FILLED with pissed off Americans, probably responding to YOUR post on how DARE Latham show such disrespect to your president and his policies. You would be SCREAMING blue murder and crying yourself to sleep at night.

Don't even go there, we all know how YOU react to 'foreigners' speaking on YOUR government policies.

GWN doesn't LIVE in Australia how the hell does he know what's best? Isn't that YOUR analigy of people's comments from outside America when you are single handedly conducting a global effort?

by garion11

Yes we reacted. But the statement by Bush, there is no way it "dictates Australian policy" The headline for this thread should be, Bush was arrogant or something to that effect. Bush didn't tell Australians how to run their country. He simply stated the effect of a cause.

by garion11

He simply stated the effect of a choice. Yes it would be disastrous for Australia to pull out. But by all means, please do if you must.

The difference between that statement and what other countries' leaders and people said and did to America was huge. Bush was called a Nazi, America was called the Great Satan, American people were called blind, French went behind our backs to African leaders to try to influence their vote in the UN, etc etc.

I just hope you Australians realize the only reason Latham?? is saying he will pull out Australia is to GET ELECTED. Not the other way around. I am sure he will do it, but there have to be other important issues in Australia besides your alliance with US, Where does he stand on those issues? or Is Iraq #1 issue??

by thechas

Okay Julian, I guess I did kind of side-step the primary issue.

Yes, the US should not be dictating policy for any other sovereign nation.

Of course, since before WWI, the US has been doing just that through foreign aid and economic policy.

George W. Bush does not have the diplomatic skills that his father, or the late Ronald Reagan have.

Combine poor diplomatic skills, election year politics, and growing frustration with the situation in Iraq, and you get a politician talking to his core supporters, not the rest of the world.

I believe that President Bush knows that he cannot dictate policy for other countries. It just plays to the core Republican supporters to talk tough and take the lead by telling other countries what they should do.

The core conservative voters in the US DO believe that the rest of the free world should follow the US into whatever battles are deemed necessary to protect freedom.

Chas

by hal 9000

It was Ronald Reagan who called Australia a "State of America" when he was President.

Admittedly he was not a well man and it may have been nothing more than a simple mistake as Australia has been so closely aligned with the US ever since WW11.

I really do not wish to speak ill of the recently deceased but that was a bad analogy that you used there.

Col

by thechas

Colin,

All I meant by the analogy is that Ronald Reagan had the skills and ability to make you feel that you were doing yourself a favor by following his advice.

George H.W. Bush had the knowledge to work behind the scenes to accomplish diplomatic objectives without having to make overt statements.

George W. Bush has neither of those skills.
Of course, it is his bluntness that endears him to many right wingers in the US.

As you have seen from some of the right wing supporters who post in this forum, there is a growing belief in the US that the US SHOULD be telling the rest of the world what to do. And, they better well do what we tell them to, or they are no longer our friends.

Chas

by hal 9000

The Leader of a country like France, Germany, Russia or any number of others say that GWB was wrong and ahead of himself in invading Iraq in the first place?

That is similar to them attempting to tell the US how to run its Foreign Policy but right now Australia has an upcoming Election in which Mr Howard may very well be out of office and here you have the President of the US saying that the current Opposition Policy is wrong.

You can scratch your head all you like but what GWB did is just plain wrong and I do not think you'll ever understand that!

by hal 9000

GWB made a comment on a foreign countries Opposition Policy coming up to an election which appears to show support for the existing Prime Minister and a lack of respect for the other sides views.

And no Iraq isn't the number 1 subject here but then again Mark Latham hasn't been caught lieing to the country either for cheep political gain like at the last election where John Howard was caught out well and truely with his pants down but only after the election when the damage had been done> He has a habit of doing things like this so is it any wonder that Aussies get a bit upset when they see this type of thing that just isn't cricket mate?

Col

by jimhm

So you don't like it when another leader critizes your elected leader hum - doesn't sit will in your chew hum - so mate - whats you going to do.

Lets see GWB had Germany, France, Russa and a few other critize him going into Iraq you didn't any post whimy about it ... But gee GWB makes a nice comment about your leader and all hell breaks loose.

AS WE SAY IN THE STATES - TO BAD SO SAD -

by oz_media

When others were saying they didn't want to fight with America and thought it was premature, YOU GUYS WENT CRAZY!!!

Spain are a bunch of whimps, France is full of whiny wimps that must be FOR Saddam, CANADA never wants to get involved but you all cry to us when you need help/ ETC.

SO YES JIM, you DID all go nuts when other countries wouldn't jump on your political bandwagon.

Now when it comes back on you, all of a sudden you are being picked on, POOR OLD AMERICA. Get F*****d Jim, you two faced clown.

You only see what others do to you but NEVER what you do yourselves. Innocent America who just wants the best for everyone and everynoe is just on thier case. Damn Left wing Commie, socialists, they never look at both sides, yet when left wing enws is reported your FIRST utterance is that it does not stand up because it is left wing commie biased crap, while at the same time bitching the left wingers don't listen to both sides and simply write it off as Republican garbage.

Would you pick a side and stick to it for Christs sake! You are all over the place, you have NO idea what you stand for, no idea what anyone is saying to you, no idea what people mean in their comments, no idea at all.

You should read back on your comments, there are MANY MANY where you say one thing then either criticize someone else for doing the same or simply change your mind by posting a contrary opinion.

Stand up and let your brain get some air or something, you make NO sense at all yet go on and on about the most ridiculous and irrelevant garbage.

Figure it out and get a grip, you're losing your mind. Isn't there some form of support you can get for Nam srewing with your head like this?

by jimhm

Spain support the Iraq invasion until they were attacked - then they went soft. France was doing back door deals with Saddam - for oil and didn't want to kill the deals...

Lets see I have a French assult rifle - never fired and only dropped once....

Spain - is cool -

You sir / madam are just a little bit off center - and need some help.. Why bring in the curse words - I didn't ..

by hal 9000

What actually happened was the GWB criticized an alternative Leader of another country it is exactly the same as if John Howard {although he is irreverent} stood up and said that he would only support the US if GWB was elected and would cut all ties {if who is it now Kerry?} was elected at the next election.

This is quite a bit more than a bit of building up a supporter it is actually interfering in "DUE PROCESS" in another country and possibly being seen as attempting to swing an election for a supporter and deny all help if the other is elected.

I know you're better than this posting and I can only think that you want someone to point out exactly what GWB did wrong and how he should correct the mistake.

When Germany, France, Russia criticized GWB they where criticizing an elected leaders policy not attempting to swing an election in favor of a certain party after all there was no mention of the apposing potential leader being refused any support if required only a criticism of the current US Policies that is the difference and even the Ugliest American could spot the difference from a hundred miles away and know better than to go anywhere near that one as they are walking into a SHIT FIGHT that just is unwinable. In WW11 Field Marshall Rommel could never understand why the Aussie troops held Trobook when they where vastly outnumbered out gunned and no resupply they should have surrounded which was the reasonable thing to do but what he never understood was that the Germans had got the Aussies backs up by sinking their booze supply while letting in supplies of food and ammo. Now if only the rum had been allowed in there may very well have been a different outcome in Africa. But it all boils down to a very old adage "Never Piss Off an Aussie because it isn't worth the grief that will follow" the Japanese learn't this in New Genia and it was actually Australian Troops who inflicted the first defeat on the Japanese and that was what made them come to understand that they where not unbeatable and in all likelihood was the beginning of the end of the Japanese Conquests of WW11. A hand full of untried Aussies stood up against the best that the Japs could place and beat them back into the sea but only after caring their equipment through the worst possible conditions for 10 days and then standing and fighting a slow rear guard action that decimated the Imperial Japanese Army.

This is something that is unthinkable now days as even the best can only cross that track in a longer time with less weight on their backs let alone dragging heavy artillery behind them. That was something that even Mac Arthur though was impossible and he was beaten out of the Philippines by the Japs so he understood just how effective they really where.

Col

by jardinier

through the wrong orifice.

As Mark Latham (before he took on the responsibility of leadership) used to personally answer some of my emails, and send as attachments copies of speeches which he had made for publication on my website, I can assure you that he was totally against the invasion of Iraq even before it started.

He is NOT promising a pull-out just to win the election -- in fact he is jeopardizing his chances with this policy because, while 63 per cent of Australians now consider that Australia should not have sent troops to Iraq in the first place, they are also wary that Latham's stand on Iraq may sour America's attitude to Australia on other issues like free trade agreements.

As I have said, the alliance with the US was formed under a LABOR Government in Australia, and it is something that all Australians, including Mark Latham, value greatly.

However this alliance DOES NOT require Australia to agree with the US on all matters of foreign policy.

by oz_media

Perhaps I didn't need to spout off with the profanity and for that Jim I do apologize.
Every post from you seems to eiether be calling the messenger an idiot, calling people political names as if in insult etc. You are the first person to discount someone's opinion if it is in any way different than yours. A fellow Republican would even be told he was a commie if he didn't agree with you. You cannot, will not and simply don't want to hear anything other than Jim's thought's, why not buy a diary and play solitaire?

I'm off center? Why because I don't like Bush, then I must be an extreme left winger or a commie socialist or something (as if that is some form of an insult to someone like myself who favour no party).

As for WHO I mentioned it is entirely irrelevant, the point is you wondered why people were so pissed that YOUR president had commented on another country's political practices before an election? Why the hell do you think Jim?

Now once again, MANY countries, in fact all but GB, were strongly opposed to the decision to attack as early as you did. UN unspectors were being successful and were properly inspecting AS THEY WERE SUPOSED TO, but this wasn't quite good enough for Bush as he just doesn't understand how people operate, as he has proven all his life.

So you elect a guy with no idea whoat he's doing and no world knowldge or skills then back him when he goes against the decisions of all his alies that actually do have experience in world affairs and have developed their countries over several thousand years. These countries that OPPOSED your decisions were slammed daily on this forum, were called every name under the sun and were practically spat upon for not jumping the gun with you.

You say "Lets see GWB had Germany, France, Russa and a few other critize him going into Iraq you didn't any post whimy about it ... "

I suppose you are saying that Americans didn't get pissed off when other countries criticized Bush?

You guys raised such a stir and slandered everyone for commenting on how YOU have a right to do whatever you want and others are just a bunch of wimps for not backing you.

Now you have the audacity to think your president can comment on anyone else's political affairs?

You already told the rest of the world they suck and will come crying when they need your help. How can you then expect to have YOUR political opinions accepted by another country?

You already told everyone to F-O and that they are a bunch of losers who don't care about their country.

Somewhere along the line you now feel that your president deserves respect?

Who is HE to turn around and comment on a upcoming elections candidates or their intentions?

If it was an Australian PM that was saying Kerry's policies were disasterour, do you not think that more than half of Americans would be fuming? I'd be watching it three or four times a day on six channels about how inappropriate the cmments were.

No Jim, look in for a change, it workd both ways.

Perhaps you will one day realize that people don't actually look to the US for answers as many have said here, we don't look up ot the US as you are just another country among many, the one that's always at war.

by oz_media

"And, they better well do what we tell them to, or they are no longer our friends."

Well after so many hard years building strategic alliances with your 'friends', such a process would be wasted as the tides turn.

The common reply when someone says they don't want to be your friend anymore, "Who needs friends like that anyway?"

To work so hard at building free trade agreements (which are not really in Canadians favour as you definitely got the better end of the stick, watch out Autralia)and then have your allies turn on you because you have turned on them is just schoolyard politics.

Many Canadians already resent the US for imposing themselves on others in an attempt to seem as if they are helping. The general concesus I've seen is that you should kep your country IN your country.

Of course by having all of your 'friends' operate similar governments you will have much greater ease at making America a more prosperous place even if at the expense of others. They will acept YOUR policies and ultimately become American.

While this may not seem so bad for an American, to others it appears monopolistic, greedy, sly, underhanded and completely arrogant and self centered. Some don't see this as looking out for Iraq's best interests as much as it is wrong to impose your government upon another.

Now, ridding Saddam's regime and allowing the country to tend to itself with Saudi support would have been OK, if well planned and globally supported. To just take matters into your own hands with some absurd justification just isn't sitting well with most. To then impose your government upon them is just going too far. Had these people requested global help in obtaining a democray well that would be a while different story, if globally supported of course.

by hal 9000

In a news report today 11-6-04 it was reveled that the US would not continue the free interchange of intelligence if the Australian Labor Party was elected at the next Federal Election latter this year.

It has just ben stated on a TV News report that AUstralia can not pick and chose what they want to do if they want the exchange of intelligence to continue {Sounds a lot like do as I say and do not question} is now the guiding philosophy that is coming out of Capitol Hill. Well with fiends like that who needs enemies.

Australia and America have literally been joined at the hip since WW11 when an alliance was formed between the US and an Australian Labor Prime Minister but now it seems that the current US Administration will only deal with a Australian Collation Government now days and that if the Australian People dare elect a different Party to power they will no longer pay nice with Australia. Just like back in the 1970 when after 20 years it was reveled that the CIA had a hand in the downfall of the then current Australian Labor Government under Mr Whitlam.

Well those nasty Americans just may have bitten off more than they can chew this time as Aussies tend to get a bit pissed off when told how to act.

What the current American Administration HAS TO LEARN that it is better to entice with a carrot rather than use a bloody big stick to beat you into submission, if a new government is elected into power at our next election I for one hope that they tell the current US Administration when they can jump off and get the hell out of Australia and that includes the proposed joint training facility at Shoal Water Bay for the troops and by all means Pine Gap as well as any involvement in any other US procedures like using Radio Telescopes for any NASA projects. Remember it was the Parks Radio Telescope that was the one that carried pictures of man first walking on the moon and they where prepared to wreck the thing in the attempt to get those pictures. If that telescope had been under American control at the time it would have been locked down to protect the investment and the TV pictures would never have been seen.

Now some here have claimed that I'm Anti American but I am constantly defending America from stupid statements that I run across daily about America being a great threat to the current World Order and other such rubbish touted by those who are really Anti American like the Confederate Action Party over here who are really Anti American but funnily enough take their name from the Deep South of America.

ANyway I've ranted on long enough about this but I am more than a bit pissed off by the current showing of the US Administration and the very poor manner in which they are attempting to influence Australian Politics. At the very least the Leader needs to understand that when he snaps his fingers we are not only required to jump but ask "HOW HIGH & HOW LONG?"

Col

by garion11

Europe debt to US, says Howard
By Michael Harvey in Washington
June 06, 2004

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/common/story_page/0,5744,9761652^401,00.html

JOHN HOWARD has issued a blunt message to European nations opposed to the Iraq war - never forget you owe your freedom to the United States.

As the US seeks European support for a fresh United Nations resolution guiding Iraq's post-war transition to democracy, the Prime Minister delivered a pointed reminder yesterday of the bleak future Europe would have faced without American help in World War II.

"Without the decisive intervention of the United States, the future of those liberated countries in Europe would have been very different," Mr Howard said.

"I think it's a lesson that should never be forgotten."

The PM's rallying call came in a speech to the National Press Club in Washington and was warmly received by the largely American audience.

It came as Mr Howard prepared to join world leaders - including US President George Bush, British PM Tony Blair, the Queen and French President Jacques Chirac - in Normandy for 60th anniversary commemorations of the D-Day landing that changed the course of World War II.

Although Mr Howard mentioned no specific European nations, France - the host of this weekend's ceremonies - has been a staunch opponent of the military campaign in Iraq.

"It (the D-Day commemoration) is an event that ought to remind the nations of Europe of the enormous debt that they owe to the United States," he said.

Mr Howard said he spoke as the leader of a nation that was one of few to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with Britain during the dark early days of World War II in 1939 and 1940.

The PM used his speech, which concluded the US leg of his three-nation official visit, to mount an emphatic defence of Australia's military role in Iraq.

Asked about the failure to find weapons of mass destruction, Mr Howard said he still would not change anything about Australia's decision to commit troops.

He defended Australia's relationship with the US, saying it did not come at the expense of other relationships with nations in our immediate region.

by oz_media

I can't believe that ANY leader whether right or left would make such an inaccurate statement.

"...never forget you owe your freedom to the United States."

This is the type of mentality you would expect from some kid who's dad has been feeding him overpatriotic crap. not a leader of an allied country.

Australia was at war in WWII before the US, as he has aknowledged. Does that mean Europeans owe thier freedoms to Canada too? Canada was the first country to land IN France on D-Day, before the beach landings, specialists in gliders landed behind the beaches to capture a bridge and hold it so that German troops were not backed up by armour. They were also the first to land on the beaches of France in Juno beach, met the strongest resistance and made it farther into France than any other landing on D-day.

Australia and Canada wer ein WWi for several years (nearlt 4) before the uS entered the war. The US provided NUMBERS of troops that helped change the balance of the war. Thier men fought hard and strong after they were bombed in Pearl Harbour, they came, they helped, they celebrated an ALLIED victory. But the world owes nothing to America that we don't owe ALL the allied countries for thier efforts. I praise the men and women of America who fought in the final year of WWII, I also praise Canada's efforts, Australian efforts and lets not forget the people WHO REALLY defeated Hitler, the Russians. Russia stopped Hitler dead, he was spread thin, his armies were unprepared for war in Russian climates, his ego got in the way and he lost his futile attempts to take Russia, thus having no recourse but to give up, he was backed into a corner by the Allies and Russia saw to it he couldn't get out of that corner.

We owe our freedoms to MANY countries and hundreds of thousands of men, too many men for Hitlers troops to wipe out. We won by united numbers not by someone's single hand.

To single out America as the ones to be thanked is in itself thankless. What an idiotic statement from someone with political control.

by oz_media

I watched BOTH celebrations in Normandy over the weekend. The Queen attended both, Bush was at the Canadian/US tribute, Blair was at the UK's tribute, beither were in attendance together, whether for security reasons or simply political interests.

the display from France was one of undying thanks for the help the allied troops offered, they were in tears as they handed veterans flowers and greeted them with such warmth and affection, they certainly showed thier respects even though they have been shamed and verbally abused by the US for so many years. They were and are eternally grateful, what more can you ask them for?

I think BOTH celebrations were in excellent taste and paid respects to both the veterans and the modern society of the allies involved. It was very tasteful and respectful, do you now need blood from them in order for them to show appreciation?

by nd_it

Most of what I read about WWII, and I do read and watch a lot of documentaires on the war. Historians refer to D-Day as the ALLIED effort to liberate Europe, not the US effort. Could have the invasion been sucessfull without US help? That is debatable. More troops and supplies sure didn't hurt, especially since more casualties were predicted then what occured. I believe Omaha beach was where there was more resistance because of the bombers missing their targets. All the allied nations contributed to a great cause, let's not forget that. But I will say this about my country; The industrial strength of the US was a huge factor in winning the war. We could mass produce weapons, tanks, plans, ships, etc. faster than the Nazi's. Part of that is because of the continous bombing campaign by the ALLIES to destroy German factories.

by oz_media

From a report I watched on the weekend, Hitler was tipped off that Normandy would be hit but thought that the main landing point was Juno beach as the intercepted signals were regarding Canadian and British special forces landing on Juno. Nazi troops were pulled in to reinforce Juno as it was not heavily armed, what Hitler didn't catch onto was that Allies were planning on taking the main Nazi acces points, the Orne River/Caen Canal bridges, by use of nightime glider landings and not beach landings. The gliders landed in the darkness of late night before the D-Day invasion. Special forces quickly took the bridge and kept it while the troops landed in the morning, the only remaining glider pilot is a Canadian who was honored on the D-Day memorial weekend.

At this point more Canadian troops took Juno beach and worked thier way farther inland than any other allied force and held thier territory. The numbers of resistance troops were named but I didn't take any notes. They also said that Canada had met a greater opposition through these movements than any other allied force on D-Day as they were expected and Hitler had ordered troops to Juno, though they were stopped en route.

I believe the issue with the US forces on Omaha was that the beach was well fortified, and a smaller nimer of Nazis were able to create more destruction due to thier hilltop positions and several guns placed farther inland and prepared to protect the beach, which the US troops were unaware of.

Either way, it was an Allied effort not a US effort, numbers were the main reason Hitler was defeated, not greater ability.

I just found some details on the different beaches and the successes.
http://tinyurl.com/yrv3t

Even here it is stated that the Canadian troops had greater preparation as they had learned from the massacre at Dieppe (I watched a documentary on Dieppe where the cameras were rolling in anticipation of a major victory. They showed the lifeless bodies being carried aboard naval ships after finding out that Hitler had been tipped off and was waiting for the invasion at Dieppe, the hoped for propaganda film was never aired in Canada until last weekend.

Juno: "...in spite of heavy opposition at Courselles-sur-Mer, broke through and advanced nearly to their objective, the airfield at Carpiquet, west of Caen. The Canadians made the deepest penetration of any land forces on June 6th, again with moderate casualties."

Omaha: "One of the biggest problems was not only the restricted terrain and the dug in pillboxes, but the fact that allied intelligence had overlooked the 352nd Infantry Division, right behind the beaches. This unit, like the others in Normandy, was spread out but was an experienced unit that had served in Russia. It more than doubled the effectiveness of the coastal defences, thus resulting in excessive U.S. losses."

This coupled with a reluctance to use military engineers in place of the Sherman 'funnies' (modified Sherman tanks for mine sweeping and others with large rollers to flatten land for ease of movement was a major reason for the large numers of US casualties on Omaha beach.

I have also read that the US airmen were using British Spitfires as they were readily available in England and more effective for fighting off the Luftwaffe. Although the Luftwaffe had larger wing cannons and double the number on a British Spitfire, the Spitfire offered bette visibilty and maneuverability so the two were practically in a stalemate as to which was superior. Pilots who have since flown both planes have mixed opinions, many British pilots preferred the Luftwaffe's power where many German pilots say that the RAF Spitfires were way easier to fly and offered sight advantage.

by garion11

Yeah, thats what I thought. Surprise!! An American.

Casualties for WWII
http://www.hitler.org/ww2-deaths.html

The number that surprised me was the USSR information.

Country Military Civilian Deaths
USSR 13,600,000 7,700,000 21,300,000
China 1,324,000 10,000,000 11,324,000
Germany 3,250,000 3,810,000 7,060,000
Poland 850,000 6,000,000 6,850,000
Japan - - 2,000,000
Yugoslavia 300,000 1,400,000 1,706,000
Rumania 520,000 465,000 985,000
France 340,000 470,000 810,000
Hungary - - 750,000
Austria 380,000 145,000 525,000
Greece - - 520,000
United States 500,000 - 500,000
Italy 330,000 80,000 410,000
Czechoslovakia - - 400,000
Great Britain 326,000 62,000 388,000
Netherlands 198,000 12,000 210,000
Belgium 76,000 12,000 88,000
Finland - - 84,000
Canada 39,000 - 39,000
India 36,000 - 36,000
Australia 29,000 - 29,000
Albania - - 28,000
Spain 12,000 10,000 22,000
Bulgaria 19,000 2,000 21,000
New Zealand 12,000 - 12,000
Norway - - 10,262
South Africa 9,000 - 9,000
Luxembourg - - 5,000
Denmark 4,000 - 4,000
Total - - 56,125,262

Yeah, noone is disputing that the allies worked together to win WWII, but just don't forget America DID lead the way.

by jamesrl

You might want to tone down the Rah rah rhetoric Garion.

Yes the Americans did make massive contributions when they did enter the war. But on a per capita basis, the USSR, Canada and Russia spent more, contributed more troops and suffered more.

When you combine the British and Canadian forces on DDay, they outnumbered the US forces.

As to Omaha, Oz omits one of the crucial factors - the US swimming tanks that were released far beyond their operational limits in high seas - all but one sank, many crew were drowned. With those tanks(55 if I recall correctly) many of those pesky machine gun nests would have been eliminated. Another problem was the softening up with rockets. The rocket ships at Omaha attacked too far out and their rockets didnt come within hundreds of yards from shore. The landing forces were counting on some of those rockets making holes for cover.

Yes Ike was the Supreme Allied Commander in Europe. And for DDay and beyond, Monty was in command of all land forces, Tedder(British) was in charge of air forces, and a British Admiral was in Charge of the Navy.

But if we all focus on DDay, we ignore the fact that the Soviet Union suffered far worse that anyone in Europe - higher costs, higher casualties. Even without Normandy, the Soviets would have eventually defeated Hitler - though it might have taken years longer and would have caused even more frighteningly high casualties. They were at least as responsible for the defeat of Hitler as the US, and many historians, including American ones, would suggest they were more responsible.

James

by surrealx

In relation to this discussion, I thought you guys might find the below link interesting. It gives a general view of how the population of Australia regard the American alliance, in light of Richard Armitage latest comments. It may also help some of you see, or understand, why the way the US behave creates such an anti-american sentiment in other countries.

http://www.smh.com.au/yoursay/2004/06/11/index.html

This discussion is closed to new replies.