Discussion Locked

But Your Honor, he IS an idiot!

0 helpful
59 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I suppose this might be somewhat of an addendum discussion to that "freedom of anonymous speech" thread, but what do you think will and/or should come of this:

http://www.njleg.state.nj.us/2006/Bills/A1500/1327_I1.HTM

What if I call somebody an idiot in one of the occasional "flame sessions", and they want me to be arrested and/or be held libel for defamation. How can I prove that person really is an idiot? Or would that person have to prove he's not an idiot? Is there an idiot test that could be applied? Will I have to refrain from using my favorite idiot link? Will I be subjected to a cyber restraining order, and be forced to stay at least 100 Web pages away from the alleged idiot? Would this only apply to the idiots in New Jersey? Would I be the idiot extradited to New Jersey? Only an idiot would be in favor of a law like this. Or would only an idiot be opposed?

(Yes, I am being sarcastic, but with an obviously serious issue.)

And how about a libel suit for this:

http://www.thisislondon.com/showbiz/articles/21913422?source=PA

If Google can be held libel for that, where might it stop? I mean, really. What Yahoo would hold Google libel for that?

What about politicians? Would all those people have to PROVE that President Bush or John Kerry really is an idiot or a liar if they post a message stating as much on the Internet? And what about the international nature of the Internet? (There are international idiots, you know.)

Personally speaking, I'm getting sick and tired of people trying to make a new law to cover any little thing that bothers them; and people are obviously sue-happy. We already have too many stupid laws. Let's start repealing some of these laws, not make new ones. It used to be said that ignorance of the law is no excuse. In fact, it still is, I suppose. But there are so many laws that we ALL are ignorant, even if we tried not to be.

On a somewhat related note (related as it applies to too many laws), I was listening to a talk radio show some time ago, a show hosted by a lawyer. He takes calls answering legal questions and discusses the legal issues of the day. A caller relayed the following story.

This caller walked his young child to the bus stop to wait for the school bus. While he was waiting there with his daughter, a couple of other girls started fighting. The way he described it, a bigger girl was literally pummeling a younger and smaller girl with punches and kicks. He said that he just stood there watching, not wanting to get involved. Another parent (a mom) soon arrived at the same bus stop and saw the fighting, but this parent broke it up. She then went on to chastise the first parent (a guy) for not doing anything, and said that he should be arrested for allowing it to happen.

The gist of the call was to ask this lawyer if he could indeed be arrested for standing by and allowing a smaller child to get beat up be a bigger one. Absolutely, the lawyer answered. He then cited some law that covered that sort of thing. The caller went on to say that he thought about getting involved, and decided that if he did try to break it up, which might even take some physical contact to do so (and did take such contact for the "mom" to hold the bigger girl back), he might be accused of inappropriate touching, or some other thing like that, so he thought it best to NOT get involved. The lawyer went on to admit that if that bigger girl had indeed charged him with doing such a thing, he could have been arrested for that as well.

That sure sounded like a case of damned if you do and damned if you don't -- an example of TOO MANY friggin' laws.

So, tying-in my little story with the opening comments, would this guy have been an idiot to break-up that fight, or was he an idiot for not breaking it up? (We're obviously a nation of idiots, if this guy found himself being one regardless of what he did.)

I suppose my rambling caused a tangent to the original discussion intent without even creating a tangent thread. How idiotic is that? But don't call me an idiot. I'll sue!

59 replies

by old guy

is full of sarcasm (which is deserved) it is a sad commentary on humanity. Society has become so self-centered and selfish that your example of the fight would cause, particularly, a man to not know whether to stop it or stand back. The whole thing is stupid because so many people want what they want and forget anyone else.

Your comment, "people trying to make a new law to cover any little thing that bothers them; and people are obviously sue-happy" again spells it out. It's what "bothers" them. And too many times the "silent majority" has kept quite and allowed this to happen in the name of "tolerance" (Yeah, I know, I'm using a lot of quotation marks--so sue me!)

BTW, this type of idiocy is not just in America. I think it's spreading worldwide because there are a lot of idiots in other countries as well. And, if I have insulted anyone by calling them an idiot I will be glad to let them know who I am.

p.s. you asked how to prove if someone is an idiot. Some of them just have to open their mouths and they prove it for you.

by dr dij

problem of letting them know who you are, they may want to kill you.

Case in point (but not limited to) defaming Islam, or having an opinion other than 'Death to America'.

by old guy

that we continue to cower down and be afraid of everything including our own shadow. I certainly don't have a death wish and don't want to hurry it up but I agree with Max, I'm tired of these idiots and I'm tired of being politically correct and afraid of "offending" someone because I don't kowtow to them.

Besides I don't defame a country or even a whole people. I defame the idiots who are causing the trouble and are the only ones getting the press.

by jamesrl

There has been in common law an exception for politicians, movie stars and others who seek to be in the public eye, that they normally cannot sue for simple defamation.

There was a test case in BC a few decades ago. A political cartoonist drew a picture of a prominent politician grinning as he pulled the wings off of a fly - the fly represented something, not sure I remember what.

The court held that while normally satirists have a right to free expression, this one went over the boundaries(alledging he was sadistic)and therefore he could sue for damages.

So, if that is the latest precendent (and Britain, the US and Canada often site each others common law decisions) then there are limits to defamation.

James

by jamesrl

I did a little research on the Fly cartoon case.

"And nervous is what many editors are. Their concern is that cartoonists sometimes go too far and offend readers. And sometimes they do. There have been cases of libel suits being brought against Canadian editorial cartoonists, the most notorious occurring in British Columbia in 1978. Future provincial premier William Vander Zalm, then minister of human resources, sued the publisher, the editor and the cartoonist of the Victoria Times after the paper's cartoonist, Robert Bierman, depicted Vander Zalm gleefully pulling the wings off of a fly after a major shakeup took place at the ministry. The original court decision found that the cartoon went beyond fair comment because it implied that Vander Zalm enjoyed hurting people, instead of just showing that he had indirectly hurt people as a result of layoffs caused by his ministry. But the paper was acquitted on appeal. "

http://www.rrj.ca/issue/1999/summer/298/

James

by jarizonatech

There has been discussion of posting President Bush's picture next to the definition of IDIOT in the new American dictionary.

by mirrormirror

... being politically correct is offensive to you. It also sounds like you are suffering from a form of PTSD due to political correctness. I guess that would be PTPCSD. Sounds official, doesn't it?

Wow!! Now where is the lawyer who will take that one on?

;)

by bfilmfan

A better question the talk show host could have asked is why didn't the parent call the police when they observed an assault taking place, even if they didn't want to get involved physically?

I swear things haven't gotten any better since Kitty Genovese was murdered in '64. Ellison's Whimper of Whipped Dogs is even more relevant today.

by richtrini

I have read this thread and I am suprised there are no lawyers reading it. At common law, a person who witnesses a harm being done to someone else owes NO duty to aid or help the victim. Of course this can be changed by statute but this is the general rule. See Restatement 2d of Torts s. 314. Now there are exceptions but I see none based on the bare facts of the example given.

There is a difference between non-feasance and malfeasance. Non-feasance is just doing nothing and it is no crime to do nothing (unless state changes this by statute). Now if you do come to the aid of another and screw it up (malfeasance) you can be sued.

In the situation discussed, the father may have been in a state that has such a "yu must come to the aid of others" law. I did a quick search to find such a statute and found none. That doesn't mean there is none. I really didn't try that hard.

Disclaimer: This is not legal advice. Just legal information. Consult a licensed attorney in your state if you need advice.

by tony hopkinson

If I see a wrong, I'll make sure it is one, right it and then deal with the consequences. If the law chooses to punish me for this, just proves how how much of an ass it is.
I'd rather take my chance with a jury of my peers, than read on the news the following day that the kid I saw yesterday is dead.

by tonythetiger

qualifies as bona fide defamation. I think in order to qualify, the term has to accuse or imply that the subject performed a specific act of negative connotation. Calling someone a wife-beater or child molester would be examples. That's not to say that calling them an idiot couldn't be charged under harassment law however.

Per the second part. You are absolutely required to stop, try to stop, or report any crime you see taking place. If, through good faith effort to do so, you inadvertently break another law, you would most likely be acquitted.

by jdclyde

being ACCUSED of a sex crime, especially against a child, stays with you FOREVER.

This is NOT a case where "innocent until proven guilty". The hyper sensitive nature that is abound today will have you marked for LIFE, and even if you are found innocent you are an ACCUSED offender and will be watched. This also stays on your record which can and WILL hinder your future job searches.

There is no way I would have done more than "tut tut" the bigger girl, and then called the police. Also as a rule of thumb, NEVER be left alone so an angry child could LIE about abuse.

I have seen others burned on this, and don't need to stick my hand out to see if the fire is hot. I learn from other peoples misfortunes.

by Member 25348569

Anyone convicted of a "sex cime" in the UK goes on a register and is barred from a lot of jobs, working with children, etc. Seems highly worthwhile, doesn't it.

Then there is the poor chap who was caught short on his way home from the pub one night. No public toilets so he climbed over a wall, into some trees to have a pee. Unfortunately, he was spotted by the police, charged, accepts a "caution" and is now on the register for ten years. Or the youngster who got his girlfriend pregnant while she was just short of 16. Her parents were not very amused, took him to court and he, too, is on the register for ten years.

It's not only in the US that PC goes mad.

by bfilmfan

I was just watching the 3 Stooges famed slap at the Axis War Powers the other day and was struck what an apt commentary it is today on the world.

In the film, we have one set of morons making loud and fiery speeches and inane laws for another pack of morons who elected them.

Perhaps elections around the world should require politicians to watch this film, as well as several others that come to mind, and then write a 300 word essay before we allow them to take office. We could even get a stern teacher like Miss Shields, so she could give them a C+ if they try and bribe her with a fruit basket.

by cactus pete

Yes, there certainly are.

I remember, way back when I lived in VA, there was a "Good Samaritan" law. They basically put common sense on the books!

The gist was that if you saw a burning car next to the road, pulled an unconscious guy out of the vehicle to save him from burning alive, but in so doing you caused his injured back to worsen and he can never walk again - well, then you aren't at fault.

But these days, you're right, we sue too much.

The world, and I'd be happy if it started here at home, could use more common sense.

by jdclyde

as this is taking a good idea and destroying it.

Is there a reason to intentionally dillute the list, making it impossible to tell who the real threats are?

Is this an attempt by enforcement to get the list revoked so they don't have to maintain it?

by jdclyde

does not mean stupid.

It is called passive resistance. When you don't like an idea, you take it to an extreme to make it LOOK as stupid as you think it is hoping it will die.

There is NEVER a reason for a 17 year old boy having concentual sex with a 16 year old girl should EVER end up on the same list as a rapist or child molester. That is just stupid.

by tony hopkinson

the list of people not allowed to teach our kids didn't cover all sex offenders on the register, a separate list no less, after all you wouldn'twant any confusion in such a regard would you. Some people who were known to be on it were permitted to teach. Highlighted by the male teacher who was on the sex offenders register for bonking his underage student, but it was consenting so he wasn't a 'danger'.

by old guy

that I can jump on the band wagon and sue somebody, too? Wow, who can I sue? the government, the next person I see, Max (since he brought this up), how about Demolition Woman for characterizing/branding/diagnosing me?

Hey maybe I can get my name on the news too--just like these other idiots that just want to hear themselves rattling their mouths.

Note to Demo Woman: Hope I didn't offend you. I would hate for you to find out my true identity and then send the goon squad to kill me. B-)

by ontheropes

What?s even stranger is that some laws broken in the presence of a police officer aren?t crimes.
There was a case in Adrian, MI.
The officer on patrol heard loud music with offensive language coming from a parked car. The officer thought it was in violation of the city noise ordinance. He stepped up to the car, and asked them to turn the music down. The occupants of the car got out, began arguing with the officer and one made the mistake of shoving him and was arrested.

The court decided that since no citizen had reported the noise as being loud and offensive it wasn?t, even though the lyrics were pretty vulgar, to some folks anyway. The officer couldn?t be offended. If a citizen had complained, then an officer would be able to enforce the ordinance.

Crazy.

Legally?
?Would this guy have been an idiot to break-up that fight, or was he an idiot for not breaking it up? I?m going to ?cop out? on this one.

My attorney advises me that it?s in my best interests to say nothing about this issue that might look even remotely like legal advice.

If you were to call 911 or whoever handles your emergency services and report that a fight, as described, was taking place and then told the 911 operator that you were going to break it up, I?m pretty sure 911 would advise you to let the police handle it.

Seek out your attorney?s advice now that you?ve read the above statement. I take no responsibility and will forward a disclaimer if requested.

Morally? Let ?em fight and record the video on your cell phone for anonymous posting on the Internet, after blurring their faces of course.

by absolutely

The medium does not re-define the crime, nor necessitate re-iteration of a definition of crimes that are already well-defined by a combination of statute and precedent, nor warrant further discussion than I have just provided.

by absolutely

Who do you believe should get the press instead? Please start a new thread, because I agree, the media reports on stupid things. They won't know what to do differently if the market doesn't tell them. So, as "the market" use capitalism to your advantage, please.

by tonythetiger

The media reports what, and how, will make them the most money. Unfortunately, "Bad" news and "Stupid" news are perennial favorites.

by nicknielsen

I think the problem is that "the media" assume we are all idiots based on the ads. Just look at the recent past:

--A series of Hardees ads that assumed a single guy can't open a loaf of bread, open a box of cereal, use a toaster, etc., yet assumed the same moron could actually find Hardees.
--The new Verizon ad in which some cubicle clown brags in falsetto about his new phone being cool while calling the recipient of this treatment lame. I know who's lame in that ad, and it ain't the poor guy you can see! Makes me want to change cell carriers...can you hear me now?
--The Citicard series where the sucker has to go through a massive series of menus before he can talk to a human. The first time my bank asked if I wanted a shinier credit card, I'd be looking for a new bank.
--The "Miller Cowboy" ad. He dressed Western for a pool party? No effing wonder he's being laughed at!

In fact, very few radio or TV commercial compaigns in the past several years don't insult my intelligence. Makes me think, perhaps, that the idiots aren't out here, but in the ad agencies thinking that we'll buy products based on their puerile moronic output!

by mirrormirror

BFilmFan gets the prize for figuring out my acronym! What's the prize, you might ask?? Well, there is no better prize than the satisfaction of being correct. If that is not much of a prize, talk to Old Guy and sue me! ;)

Old Guy - I didn't want to leave you out of the sue happy culture that we have. And, if you sue me for sending Guido "The Shark" after you for offending me, let's make sure to go on all the TV talk shows and then write a book. It's only American to profit off all of our problems.

by oneamazingwriter

be true.
Name calling at any time and on any occassion creates controversy and reflects on the person doing the labling. Doing so in print before the public is not at all like muttering under one's breath. It resembles screaming, and is disruptive.
Time in grade does not necessarily bring with it maturity. Although life appears at times to be a cross between a day care center and a grade school play ground experience, those who choose to see "adult" as being responsible for one's actions and behavior relate more as teachers than as students on that play ground or in that day care.
Laws are simply a government's way of attempting to try to instruct or control the majority of immature people who make up the populace in any country. If the lawmakers themselves at times lack maturity, they simply reflect (in this country) what occurs in the majority.

When we, as individuals, decide within ourselves that it's time to grow up, we cease to lable those around us and seek to strengthen our own areas of weakness. We, thus, begin parenting ourselves and don't have to be overly concerned about breaking laws. We behave appropriately in most given circumstances, especially in print.

As for the question of whether or not to get involved in the children's battle, that's a matter of personal choice. Quite often a bully can be discouraged simply by hearing a firm adult tone. "Stop that...NOW!" tends to work well often. Calling attention to what is occurring will also cause other adults to enter in. In the case with the people fighting being female and the adult being male, I can appreciate a caution in getting physically involved. To children adults are still the "big people" and a deepened firm male tone can still shake the boots of a bullying girl.

by ontheropes

post BTW. I copied it to my HD as a keeper. I just checked and see you don't blog.
That's too bad. I'd read it.

by maxwell edison

And I might consider starting a blog. However, which one might generate more readers, these discussion threads or a blog?

by ontheropes

I look at a blog as a place to get something off your chest and speak your mind, comments be hanged. Of course folks comment on the blog too which might bring to mind more ideas for discussions by you and others. Circular reasoning I know but true, maybe.

by oz_media

MAx, GENERALLY, in the case of a public figure:
Oddly enough, politicians are not really protected for defamation of character. They hol da character that is ALWAYS questioned and that is part of their career, it is expected of them and the flames and slander is seen as fair.

In the case of a public figure where their reputation is tarnished and that leads to loss o fincome or ability to succeed, they have a LITTLE more protection than a politician but are still seen as fair game for the most part. Otherwise tabloids would lose far mroe lawsuits.

In the case of a businessman runnign a company, defanation of character is an EXTREMELY serious issue and those found responsible for such losses face serious penalties.

In the case of you and I, if your comments were to reduce my ability to earn income or my company to succeed, you woul dalso be found libel in most cases and would pay hefty fines, obviously depending on the losses.

So really, it all depends WHO you are and how much exposure you have to general public, how it effects your personal income and success etc.

With most PUBLIC figures, there is little they can do or say, other than whine and get their name on the front page for a few weeks.

With most private companies or people, the offender will often suffer great penalties. So it's okay to say Bush is a phag or a loser, but it's not okay to say Oz's XYZ company is for phags and losers. Then of course there is also the issue of where the ionformation is found, on a billboard outside the head office would obviously cause more damage than word of mouth at a bar. In which case the amount of loss would again be in direct relation to the penalty.

With respect to th eissue of the girls fighting, the gentleman who stood by can easily claimn that he felt he MAY have been accidentally or intentionally hit by the girl(s) if he was to intervene, therefore he has a right to not become involved in order to not incur bodily harm.

There are ways to prosecute, there are just as many ways to defend. Unfortunately, what wee see too often is people who are easily prosecuted because they can't afford reasonable defense.

I have a really interesting suit right now that I am taking upon a MAJOR North American corporation, it is in my favour so far , I can't mention names at this time. But here's hoping, BIG coin if it pans out for me!

by absolutely

Sorry, Oz, but unless you have your own NSA to command to eavesdrop without a warrant, you're an easier target for defamation than King George W.

by oz_media

As expected

If you were to have MY company name and were to publicly defame it, you would be found more liable for damages than if you were to fly a 'Bush is a phag' banner at the Stupid Bowl.

I have had a peer here before who decided to slander my company name, it took a couple of letters from my attorney but she soon go the hint.
TR has also been close to having issues until they took action and deleted a few posts also.

There is a far greater poosibility of me winning a slander of defamation suit that there is for a major public figure, like Cole and LOOOOONG before Bush.

by absolutely

I'm much more interested in what Maxwell Edison has to say about the topics that interest him than in any of the comments back to him. Oz_Media is funny sometimes, the rest of the anti-Maxwell noise doesn't even have humour to redeem it.

by too old for it

... at least that is what my notes say from civil litigation.

Of course, for 15 years I was just the paralegal ...

by wayne m.

I can't call up the first link, but I would like to comment on the Google story as it is one of many instances of companies denying responsibility purely on the gounds of their size.

Google's defense is largely that their search engine and coverage is far too large for them to provide reliable results. Their sole justification for making money is based on the presumption of the reliability of their searches. E-Bay uses the same argument; they are too big to be responsible for goods and services sold through them. The major credit reporting agencies take the same approach. They take no responsiblity for misreporting credit history of individuals, insisting that they are too big to get the information right. Again, however, their marketing approach is based on the accuracy of their reporting.

If companies shirk their responsibiity, then, like it or not, one of the few recourses that members of society have is legal action.

by jdclyde

We call that "child abuse" unless your a muslim in a middle eastern country. then it is perfectly legal and acceptable it seems.

But in a CIVILIZED society, we don't allow adults to have sex with children. That isn't even CLOSE to the 16/17 difference we have been talking about or even in cases when both are 15 and the boys STILL gets the rape charge. THAT is just stupid.

Are you saying you NEVER had concentual sex with anyone under 16? Or are you saying the rules didn't apply to you? (I am talking when you were that age of course before you get offended that I am implying it is still going on!)

by absolutely

about GWB = a tyrant.

You could sue me.

He might frame me & put me in Gitmo.

I'd rather defame Oz and have to pay a bunch of $$$$$$$$$$$$$. Get it? Ha, ha? Maybe not, but I still try.

by martini

In the old days there were three categories of devvelopmentally disabled (exceptional? mentally challenged?) persons, based on the severity of the handicap. If I recall correctly, they were, in descending order of severity, idiot, imbecile and moron.

By now we all know it is politically incorrect (and some believe it is wicked) to show any disrespect for any defined groups of people, with the possible exceptions of liberals and child molesters. Certainly we know one does not make fun of developmentally disabled persons, or discriminate against them in any way. In public schools they are in least restrictive environments, and are mainstreamed, and have Individualized Education Programs. On no account are they to be left behind, except when they miss the school bus, and then someone is supposed to go get them.

In fact, acting as if being identified as learning challenged is to be insulted reveals a negative attitude toward persons with that exceptionality.

When pointing out that someone is an idiot, why not play it safe, and add, "...not that I have anything against idiots myself: some of my best friends are idiots..."? Remember, idiots make up a substantial portion of our population, enough so that many representatives of the idiot sector gain elective office.

by richtrini

I think you've misunderstood what I wrote. First, this isn't a codified law. It was brought over with the English common law and further refined through the years.

Second, this "common law" says that you are under no OBLIGATION to aid another in need. If you do aid someone in need, and you do it negligently, than you have to face the consequences.

This is not a criminal case. I don't think any state will be crazy enough to prosecute someone criminally for coming to the aid of someone. This is civil. This is the person who you just helped suing you for helping and 1) screwing it up so that he got hurt even more due to your help or 2) he didn't want your help in the first place.

In this case it could be the parents of the kid being beat up. It's not the law that is the ass, it is the people.

by jarizonatech

Thanks for the post. I'm a registered Repubican and proud of it..... EXCECPT for bungling Bush. Who I did not vote for in the election.

by recce1

There was a case in NYC illustrating the dilemma. On the sidewalk, a man came across another pounding the daylights of a woman. Being a gentleman with courage, rare in the Big Apple, he told the other man to cease and desist. Of course the neanderthal told him to mind his own business and turnded back to hit the woman again, so the knight in shining armor decked the miscreant.

By that time NY's finest had arrived. It turned out that the woman was the wife of her abuser and declined to press charges against him out of fear of retaliation. Therefore as no crime had been committed that the police could see by her abuser, as far as they were concerned, our good hearted rescuer had simply walked up to an innocent man and assualted him for no reason. Guess who was arrested, went to court, and lost? Was it a potential murderer? Not on your life! Isn't justice dandy?

by sekerob

In order of the cases sighted:
1. The New Jersey Legislature link went dead, in fact the whole document directory structure went dead....one of the peers must have realised the sponsor of the bill was full if it.
2. Ashley Cole gay.....the computer is quicker in putting 2 and 2 together, but only as good as the fools programming it.
3. Catch 22....US law....refer back to point 1, there are many of them.

by jacksdaddy1

I wish to suggest that anyone making a serious threat of a frivolous lawsuit for being called an idiot is, by definition, an idiot. Courts have ruled however that vulgar epithets are not defamation, but protected free speech. Therefore to be on legal safe grounds call him an idiot M*****F***** or a stupid C***S******

by boxfiddler Hot topic

"Personally speaking, I'm getting sick and tired of people trying to make a new law to cover any little thing that bothers them; and people are obviously sue-happy."

I'd like to know where the idea that NO ONE (emphasis not yelling) should ever be offended came from. I'd also like to know where the idea that NO ONE (eny) should ever have to suffer the consequences of their bad decisions (who in 'h' drives around with a completely open cup of hot coffee in their lap for crying out loud?!) in life came from. I suspect these two things are related...

This discussion is closed to new replies.