Discussion Locked

Buying/Selling an iPod could get you busted

0 helpful
55 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Been reading up on article dealing with ipods and mp3's.

http://www.usatoday.com/tech/products/2006-01-23-ebay-ipods_x.htm
http://www.afterdawn.com/news/archive/7315.cfm

(just a few of the articles I found. I ignored blogs)

If you buy an ipod preloaded you can be charged with recieving stolen goods.

If you sell an ipod, you are suppose to either clear off all the music from the ipod, or make sure you don't have a copy saved on your computer.

If you ripped your own mp3's off of cd's, you are actually suppose to send the cd's with the ipod as you have given away your right to that music.

Where will the music industry realize threatening their clients is not good for business?

I heard this on the radio and it sounded so crazy, I just had to look it up. To my surprise it is all over the net.

What will be next?

And can you believe people are stupid enough to pay 99 cents for ONE song as a down load? duh!

I have my ipod shuffle, but only because it was a door prize at a voip seminar! I NEVER use it and find the samsung mp3 players I bought my boys for Christmas to be much better, and twice the storage for only $30 more AND have a display.

55 replies

by wwed

Either way I suppose this will carry over to all mp3
players and then any other storage media, loaded hard drives and more.
when will this corporate greed end?

by jdclyde

many of the players all require WinXP. XP allows them to lock down the media.

Also the reason I won't EVER buy an iRiver product again and question the intellegence of anyone that would.

by maxwell edison

Without "corporate greed" there would be no corporate profits. Without corporate profits, there would be no corporations. Without corporations, there would be no corporate employees. Without corporate employees, there would be no product, no payroll, no.......

by rob mekel

the bush, hunting deer, living in caves. lol :D

Think not, but there has to be a limit on the greed of some of these company's. Can be done by not buying any of their products. (lol, as if that ever will be done :D)

But then again is that the case now? Think not. As you buy music, ipod download, cd, dvd, etc, it doesn't give you the right to keep a copy and sell the original you bought.

Rob

by faradhi

I disagree that corporate [b]greed[/b] is a good thing. Greed, as defined by the Merriam-Webster dictionary, is [i][b]excessive or reprehensible[/b] acquisitiveness[/i].

There is corporate greed. It manifests itself in all sorts of ways. We hear all the time about corporate layoffs. The ones that happen when a company is not profitable I have no problem with. However, when I hear a company has layoffs because the [b]increase[/b] in profits are not what is expected, this becomes greed. These layoffs ultimately decrease the number employed workers and decrease the number of people buying non-necessities. Thereby, reducing the buying power of the population and hurting businesses.

Profitable corporations are a good thing (Which is what I think you intended). Greedy corporations are a bad thing that ultimately hurt the economy.

by absolutely

jdclyde: "Where will the music industry realize threatening their clients is not good for business?"

Absolutely: When threatening their clients stops being so good for business. Which means, when the federal government stops bending over for them with gibberish like the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, that contradicts fair use precedent so thoroughly that it amounts to an abolition of all private property rights to the affected forms of what used to be property.

by too old for it

I am about 6 months from having a non-fiction work published. I am in fear of finding vast quantities of it inserted into some college professors handouts (or handout that has to be purchased) under "Fair Use".

by absolutely

I understand your fear, but "Fair Use" allows copying for some well-defined purposes. It isn't fair to punish people who use technology legally because some use it illegally.

Back to digital copying, the RIAA's real complaint is Internet distribution, yet it has prosecuted end users instead of illegal distributors.

To compare to your fear of your non-fiction work being distributed illegally: would it be fair to punish the students who receive the copies [b]instead[/b] of the professors who copy and distribute them [b]knowing[/b] that their actions are illegal?

by maxwell edison

It's the consumer who wants to rip off somebody, not the music industry. If you don't want to pay for a product, you have a choice to either do without it, steal it, or get somebody else to buy it for you.

And it's not a difficult concept to understand.

If I buy a piece of music, regardless of the medium on which the music is delivered, that music is mine to enjoy, regardless of how many media forms I might elect to play it. I can copy a song from an old record album, for example, onto CD or tape or convert it to digital form for play on my ipod, or all of those options. But I can't give (or sell) one of those to another person without giving (or selling) all of them to that person. It's the music that's the product, not the medium on which it's delivered.

To think that if you buy a piece of music that it is then yours to distribute as you see fit, is the epitome of ignorance and being self-centered. If everybody did it all the time and in all cases, there would be no music industry to create the stuff to begin with. (Because only one song would be sold to only one person, who would then pyramid it to the rest of the world.) And who would create a piece of music to make a lousy 99 cents?

by jdclyde

There are many things about the "theft" of music.

First on the list, if you offer a quality product for a reasonable price, it wouldn't be worth the time to steal. CD's were SUPPOSE to drop in price when "the technology became mainstream" but it never did. (think 80's)

Second, there are many bands out there that got their start by giving their music away with instructions to make as many copies as they could (metallica).

Third, I USED to do the napster thing before the crack down. I would check out music, buy what I like and delete what I don't. After the crack down, I don't buy 1/8 the music I used to because I am not exposed to as much and I will not pay $18 to "check out" if I like a CD or not.

Does it ever create good will to attack your customer base? They have lost out on a LOT of sales from people like me. Others that they are stopping are the people that wouldn't buy anyways. (think people using pirated software on personal system. They wouldn't pay the $180 for XP, but it does keep them using it instead of Linux and anything that keeps them from using linux is good for MS.)

by maxwell edison

You can look for all the justification you want, but it won't fly.

You said, "..there are many bands out there that got their start by giving their music away with instructions to make as many copies as they could (metallica)."

So what? There are also many restaurants out there that got their start by giving their food away. That doesn't mean that all restaurants, including this one, should give away all their food all the time.

"Does it ever create good will to attack your customer base", you asked? What customer base? Are people who don't pay for a product considered customers? Moreover, if you shoplift from a store because ______________________ (fill in whatever justification you want), then the real customers are the ones who pay for it and/or the store will go out of business.

Nobody's forcing you to buy a product. If a product is offered for sale, and if you consider the terms of the sale unacceptable, don't buy it. If you want to use that as justification to steal it, I simply can't relate. And yes, it is as simple as that.

by nz_justice

You don't have to be ignorant or self-centered to steel and distribute music. You can download an album knowing that it is steeling and distribute it know that it is wrong to do so, and you can make a profit from doing this.

You can also be lazy and not bothered to remove all your original music from your mp3 player when you sell it on (I guess that can be a form of ignorance).

You can also delibritly target corporation's you hate and steel from them, again with out being self-centered or ignorant.

You could be a Hippy and believe that every thing should be shared (whats yours is mine and vice-versa). And simply be taken the "every thing should be shared" attitude.

Music is free, just listen to it on the radio.

;)

by maxwell edison

Yes, it is a capitalist's atitude -- as it should be.

Okay, self-centered, ignorant, mean, or dishonest if you do it.

And yes it is; music is free; just listen to it on the radio.

by mjwx

?If I buy a piece of music?

You don?t ?buy? a piece of music anymore. It?s more like you rent this music for an unspecified period of time. You don?t own the music you just own the right to play it, a right which can be taken away from you at any time. The piece of music is not yours to sell on despite the fact you paid for it, nor is it legal for you to have a backup copy in case the original becomes damaged. As I said this sounds like a rental agreement not a purchase which is why I and many others don?t want to ?buy? music.

?And who would create a piece of music to make a lousy 99 cents??

Someone who wanted to make music not money. But I suspect this point will be lost on you.

The artist (in this day and age I use this term loosely, very loosely) only receives 10% of the purchase price of the song/album, 20% goes to the writer. So if an artist lets take the Foo Fighters for example, who write and perform their own songs would only receive 30% of the purchase price at best under a standard contract. A great deal of the Foo?s money would come from touring which the record companies have less control over.

The Foo would probably not be under a standard contract as they have some measure of control over their own fate (in the industry) as they are an old and quiet popular band, but this is beside the point, they are an example of a band not a contract. For artists that cannot achieve fame on their own (Brittney Spears, Kanye West, 50 Cent and the list goes on). Without the recording industry to ?make? these people someone with actual talent might make it.

Now Max I want to single you out but think for a minute, how much money would you make if you could guess what would be popular? Now how much more money could you make if you could control what is popular? If I?ve thought of this it?s an absolute certainty that someone else has too, perhaps someone in a position to actually do it?

To everyone except max, you will have to forgive my anti-recording industry rant, but there are so few good acts these days (this goes for movies too).

by jdclyde

no, the music you purchase can NOT be taken away from you.

Yes, you CAN make backups for your own personal use, provided you don't distribute a copy of it to anyone else.

Never could stand the Foo. :p

As for contracts, many a bad breakup has been because of getting robbed in their contracts. got to break up and form under a new name, of course they can't play any of the old songs as they don't often don't own the righs to their own music.

by stargazerr

Listening to music, deleting what you dont want and paying for what you like is not stealing in any which way.

There has to be some way you can trial music so that you can buy what you want. Maybe allow podcasting or streaming from the website for a short while when the album launches.

We cannot be expected to go in and buy a CD just because 99% of the population is in love with that band. What if we are in the other 1% ?? Isnt it fair to give us a chance to be able to check out what we are buying. Recreation has to have some sort of a choice. It isnt a take it or leave it situation.

]:)

by maxwell edison

Let's take a Sentimental Journey down the Revisited musical Highway. If you bought a Doris Day record back in 1945, there was no way to duplicate that music. If you wanted to hear the music, you had to buy the record, and hope like hell you didn't drop it, or else that 78 RPM format would break into a hundred pieces. Fast forward a couple of decades, and you could have purchased that Bob Dylan album for your enjoyment at home, and you could have even recorded it onto a blank 8-Track tape so you could ALSO listen to it while crusing down Highway 61. But even then, it wasn't allowed to copy and sell, or copy and give away. Just because technology allows you to duplicate the sound, it doesn't give a person the right to distribute the product.

If a million people want the song, the artist and music producers should be entitled to a million sales. Not a million minus the one copy you gave away.

And today's CDs are no different than yesterday's albums or extended play records -- or a can of mixed nuts. I bought hundreds of record albums in the 1960s and 1970s, maybe because I liked one song. But I got the other dozen in the deal, regardless of if I wanted them and/or liked them or not. If you don't like the notion of buying an entire album (or CD) because of all those other songs, don't buy it. And if you throw away the almonds from a can of mixed nuts because you only like the pecans, it's your own danged fault. Buy the single, or the bag of pecans.

You said, "Recreation has to have some sort of a choice. It isnt a take it or leave it situation."

Take it or leave it IS the choice. If you don't like the choices, then don't make either one -- or better yet, compete with them.

by bad boys drive audi

I'm sorry, but I respectfully have to disagree with you. I've been in too many music shops that allow you to "preview" the music. It requires that you do you DD (due diligence) to locate those shops.

I'm even aware of a local chain that will open a new CD (if one isn't already opened), send you to a collection of CD players with earmuffs, and let you listen away until your heart's content. If you don't like the music, you simply tell them "no" on that one and move on. If you like it, you can buy it on the spot. It's as simple as that.

The fact is, if enough customers were to tell the RIAA that they want to see ubiquitous access to preview music, the RIAA would find a way to make it happen. Preview machines can be in every music store - it's just a matter of lobbying hard enough to make it happen. People should unite to create the environment in which they would like to live, and not complain about the one in which they currently live.

by jdclyde

that complaining about a current environment is the first step to change?

Get people to realize that they don't HAVE to put up with what is pushed at them. Then push for "what should be".

Maybe THEN all that crap "gangsta rap" will just go awayyyyyyyy!

by jdclyde

i don't download.

I just understand that they have lost a lot of my business because of this and will continue to lose a lot of my business.

by maxwell edison

Like you, if somebody doesn't like it, don't download and/or don't be a customer. If enough people did it, they'd change their approach.

And I can relate. Personally, I refuse to pay for TV. I don't have cable. And next year, it'll really piss me off because Monday Night Football moved to ESPN! How dare they do that! But I still won't pay.

by jdclyde

the only reason I still have cable is because the boys watch it. I do have it backed down to the lowest it can go though.

I have not turned on a TV (except for the super bowl) in over three months. What a waste of time!

by jdclyde

it is the same with software.

I am amazed, that people that would never walk into a store and steal a candy bar would not think twice about stealing an OS or application.

My point is that the music industry should ALLOW people to share as it exposes more people to more music. The best advertising is word of mouth.

As for music on the radio, just like going to TR, just because it doesn't cost YOU money, doesn't mean it doesn't cost something.

by mjwx

I covered this in another post but I will rehash.

"how much money would you make if you could guess what would be popular? Now how much more money could you make if you could control what is popular? If I?ve thought of this it?s an absolute certainty that someone else has too, perhaps someone in a position to actually do it?"

To allow people to choose what they listen to (and most people are sheep and will follow the flock) will ruin the marketing.

by jdclyde

they just don't want you too see how much crap is being pushed out by the marketing clowns?

Pop music and all the people that follow it are the bane to my existance! :p

by maxwell edison

I do "waste" some time in front of the ol' boob-tube. If I took that time plus the time I spend on TR ...... wait, I won't go there. I need an excuse for whatever eludes me.

by jdclyde

I can't speak for others, although I will anyways. :D

My complaint isn't about the legality or not, or looking to get something for nothing.

It is about a failed business model.

How much has been wasted in trying to digitally protect the music from duplication only to have the protection defeated by a marker?

Now with musicians starting to distribute direct and leaving the big companies out of the loop, they more than ever should be looking for ways to make happy customers, not scare away the ones that are left.

itunes and such are big business and I don't remember if it was amazon or Barns and Nobles, but they are getting into this as well.

You can spend your time and money trying to force compliance with the rules, of you can change the rules and make it so it isn't worth someones time to bother to steal the product. You get more people sampling more music, and if it is atractively marketed and priced right, people will go out and buy that product.

Yes, they legaly can nail you for theft. Will they really gain or lose by that effort?
(no, not talking about big pirating organizations)

by nz_justice

:p

If there was a emoticons face for giving someone the evils (which as I understand is a form of beat down) there would be one here -> .

(rules\laws\ethics\morals\etiquette are made to be broken.)

by jdclyde

you just can't help but knock them off!

The only reason I didn't post that same post is because you beat me to it.... :O

by bad boys drive audi

At first, it sounds outrageous because it's an "us" versus "them" deal, but really, what's changed? How is this any different than selling a CD that you purchased a year ago? Let me explain...

Let's assume that a year ago, you bought a music CD. Under the current law, you're able to legally copy that CD for backup purposes. However, if you decide to sell that CD to someone, you are legally bound to do one of the following:

a. Hand over the backup CD to the buyer.
b. Destroy the backup.

In the iPod scenario, if you sell an iPod with music, there isn't a difference - you must either forfeit the music altogether. By keeping a copy of the music and selling the other copy with the iPod, you are in effect saying, "I'm going to sell this CD that I purchased, but I'm going to keep the backup copy!" That's illegal under the current statutes, and the RIAA is perfectly justified in their effort to sue you.

I do believe that the scope needs to be narrowed a bit. Yes, if the seller of the iPod keeps a copy of the sold music, he/she is in clear violation of the law. The buyer, however, may or may not have knowledge of the unscrupulous acts of the seller, and it is questionable whether they should be liable for any "damages". If I were sued by the RIAA, I would certainly mount this issue as my defense because it's not like I was buying a hot watch off the streets - I legitimately paid for a product (the "iPod") from a reputable dealer (eBay). There wasn't any "mens rae", meaning that there wasn't any culpability, which is required by statute as an element of a crime. If I bought a car off of eBay, and it arrived at my house with a trunk full of heroin, should I be arrested and tried for drug smuggling? Certainly not!

I think that the people who are ensnared in this mess by the RIAA, simply because they purchased an iPod with music contained within (without their knowledge) should counter sue the RIAA. Having a few judgments go against them in that capacity will ultimately force them to re-evaluate their strategy; or at the very least, narrow their scope.

by jdclyde

but the average joe on the streets doesn't have the time or money to fight a big legal battle, and the music industry DOES. Money buys you justice.

It will be interesting to see how this all turns out.

by bad boys drive audi

You attach your counter suit to the original filing. Since you're already in court as a defendant, it will cost you very little to counter sue. You're likely to be able to retain a lawyer who is eager to go after the RIAA - for the publicity and possible payout.

by nz_justice

If you went on a trip to Bali and you went form Australia to Bali, and while your bag was in the baggage handling area of the the airport, someone put a large amount of weed in your bag, and then you arrive at Bali, and your bag gets checked and they find the large bag of weed, you get convicted and go away for 15 years, then when you appeal the decision with new evidence the court decides to put you away for 20 years.

So if you brought a car of eBay and it arrived with heroin in the trunk, you would get arrested and tried for drug smuggling. guilty until proven innocent.

by jdclyde

What is the world coming to? :O

Of all the TR members, I figured he would be here with some of his insights.....

Guess he only has time for the Yuks anymore. Too busy out snowboarding?

by jdclyde

is that profit is not a bad thing.

They want the employees to make a good living with benifits, but profit for the share holders that make it all possible is always looked on as evil. We hear about "record profits" all the time, but never have this put into perspective.

How many times have you heard people complain about how much B. Gates has, but never complain about how much M. Jordan has?

Mostly it is people being told they should be jealous of other people that have a lot while they have so little.

Where does the line need to be drawn? When people break the laws.

by maxwell edison

That's why I say it's a good thing. Different people will have a different benchmark to determine what may or may not be excessive. And I don't think we want some person (profit czar) or agency (department of corporate profit), government or private, to decide what that may be. Besides, we already have such a group to decide what may or may not be excessive; they're called the consumers.

If a widget (or CD), for example, was made available for sale at the price of $1,000 per unit, the consumer group would be telling the supplier of that product what's excessive or not by their decision to purchase it or not. If nobody buys it at $1,000, but people would flock to buy it at $10, then that sends such a message to the supplier. The law of supply and demand, combined with fair competition, will define what's excessive, especially with a totally unnecessary product like a widget (or CD).

Therefore, it's all a good thing. Especially considering it's better than any other possible alternative.

By the way, that certainly was a typical "Liberal Musing". Quick to point out the perceived problems in the normal, liberal, rhetorical manner, demonizing a group (corporations, in this case), but not one shred of a proposed solution or alternative.

(That last "by the way", by the way, could certainly be taken as a challenge to elaborate a bit, based on the additional comments I've made.)

And you are correct, I was using "greedy" and "profitable" as being synonymous, but for the reason I described.

Edited Addition:

Especially in the case of music, whether it be CDs, or downloaded music, or any other format, the sky's the limit, if you ask me. If those guys can make a gazillion dollars by selling the stuff, more power to em'. Nobody's forcing anyone to buy it; and a person dang sure doesn't need it. But regardless, it's not good enough justification to steal the product, just because "somebody" decides they're being "greedy".

by faradhi

I did not in anyway say all companies or even most companies are bad. I did not say all profits are bad. I stated a very specific example of what I believe to be greed.

Further, I would agree that there is no government solution nor did I propose one. I would agree with you that consumers should enforce their beliefs with their purchasing habits. This is why I don't own Nike clothing or do business with citigroup.

by maxwell edison

If you offer no "solution", then we can surmise that there's no "problem". And if there's no "problem", what was the point of your message?

You might say that you didn't "demonize" corporations, but you really did, at least to a very small degree. (But maybe that's just another one of those "greed" versus "excess profits" things.)

Moreover, since you preceded your message with the warning about a liberal rant, I mean a liberal muse, I took the liberty to post an opposing political view. I don't think it's deniable that liberals, in general, demonize big business, as well as scores of other "groups". That's how they advance their liberal agenda. And the tone of your message, regardless of the degree, was just another instance of that very thing.

P.S. As a disclaimer: Don't take anything I say personal and/or as a personal attack. It won't be. However, I take every opportunity to discredit the evils and destructiveness of liberalism and liberal thought, even if it's presented in a non-political context. Liberal thought, in my opinion, has infiltrated every aspect of our existence, and it's one of the most evil and destructive things ever inflicted upon our way of life in the United States. So if you choose to open the door, I'll do whatever I can to slam it shut and/or discredit whatever liberal nonsense is being spewed.

by mjwx

"no, the music you purchase can NOT be taken away from you."

Maybe, but not through lack of trying.

"Yes, you CAN make backups for your own personal use, provided you don't distribute a copy of it to anyone else."

This is exactly what DRM is trying to prevent. If everybody made backups the *IAA would loose a great deal of profit by people not buying their favourite album/movie 7 times. The RIAA have said that you don?t need backups as there are ?replacements available at affordable prices? (quote is straight off their web site www.riaa.com site was down when I was posting).

"Never could stand the Foo"

Theres no accounting for taste :)

Cheers
Mike

by mr l

Hallmarks of the neocon response to anything that can be labeled liberal. Extreme (...has infected every aspect of our existence), blame filled (...and it's one of the most evil {btw, talk about demonizing..sheeh} and destructive) and making demonstrably false comments regarding the liberal position paper or quote they are attacking (In no way shape or form did he demonize big business...but it suits your purpose to create a bias against him by associating his comments with that position).

Why is it, I wonder, that you can't simply engage...in a logical, constructive, and less vitriolic manner...in a debate or discussion around the issue at hand? I suppose, given your stated bias, that there should be only a single party (as divergent thought is anathema to the dedicated neocon), or...heck...since we are down to one party...how about no party, and a conservative monarch instead...ala...King George?

by maxwell edison

I demonize liberalism. I proudly admit it.

And I didn't "create a bias against him", per se, but rather he did it himself with the title of his message - Liberal Musings Alert.

Moreover, faradhi appears to be a smart and articulate guy. I've conversed with him on more than one occasion, and I'd love to engage him in some stimulating political discussion. He admits his bias, and I admit mine. Let the discussions begin!

You, on the other hand, have suddenly crawled out of some hole to spout off about a circumstance about which you know nothing. You've just identified yourself as a very foolish person.

By the way, please define a neocon for us.

by faradhi

I freely admit that (other than voting with my dollars) I have no solution to some businesses negatively affecting the economy with greed. That does not prohibit me from seeing a problem, pointing out the problem, and doing what I can until I find a better one or someone else presents one.

Businesses are not all good. Nor are they all bad. If I demonized anything it was a very specific business practice of some corporations not corporations themselves.

BTW, I don't take too much personally. I am a liberal in many ways, Just not a bleeding heart one. :)

by mjwx

There are good corporations and bad corporations. Good corporations use their money to enhance products, better operating procedures, increase their market share (using ethical means) or branch into new markets. Bad corporations sue their customers, try to maintain absolute control over the products they sell, drown out competition and collude to set high prices.

For example, AMD good, Microsoft bad, Nothing (before they joined Interscope) good, RIAA bad. Get the picture.

Max, I know you?re an ignorant and self centred person so much of the meaning of good and bad will go right over your head but please, try.

Mike

You can?t please everyone, so choose who you are going to offend first and work from there!

by absolutely

Acquisitiveness is excessive or reprehensible [b]if and only if[/b] it leads to theft or physical aggression. No person has the moral authority to tell another how much wealth they may desire, or [b]earn[/b], only that they must earn what they have.

The RIAA has the right to enforce their intellectual property rights. If you don't like it, you have the right to [b]ask nicely[/b] for permission to ignore the law as a personal favor. You also have the right to try to make better music and listen to that instead, if you believe you're able. You do not have the right to steal.

The superior ability of the producer of the goods you steal is not an excuse to steal, and the word "greed" is not a mystical incantation. It does not obscure the fact that your acquisitiveness motivates you to steal, while the victims' acquisitiveness led them to produce, which benefits you by definition of your desire to have what they produce.

Money is not the root of all evil. Incompetence and envy are the root of all evil.

by faradhi

I wouldn't place any bets on it. But who knows. I might just change your mind on a few things.

by gabrielbear

re stupid enough to pay 99 cents for ONE song as a down load? duh!
people pay $15 or so for a cd. when a union grocery store checkout poerson was making 68 cents an hour, she paid 49 cents for a single...on vinyl.
i'm totallly with u on the industry moguls being voracious monsters.
but power to the people imho means power to the artists.
and this is just the beginning.

by jdclyde

I can say for a FACT that vinyl was NOT $15 back when people were making 68 cents an hour.

Besides that one MAJOR blunder, the rest can stand on it's own.

Note, I am not old enough to tell you how much it cost, but I would bet in the 68 cent wge range more people were listening to 8tracks? :D

by jamesrl

He said CDs are $15 or download one tune off it for 99 cents, versus 49cents for a 45 RPM single in the old days.

I can rememebr buying singles off the charts for about $.75 cents in the mid seventies when I could make 3 or 4 bucks an hour picking strawberries/peaches/apples. When I was much younger I remember buying a grab bag of 10 45s of stale hits (no longer on the charts and not top bands) for $2.

I remember 8 Tracks and albums for $4.99.

James

This discussion is closed to new replies.