Question Locked

Can 2 Hard Drives be DeFragged...?

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

[i] The above topic is Mis-leading,
so here is what I really mean:[/i]

I have 2 separate Hard Drives, C & D.
I am running XP Pro.

[b] Can I goto MY COMPUTER/C/Properties/Tools/ErrorChecking for BOTH drives and ask for Error Check At Boot??

Will the OS get confused if it has to do Error Check for BOTH drives at Boot/Restart??

Finally, is Error Check the Same as SCANDISK? [/b]

Thank you very much.

5 replies

by older mycroft

I've never seen that as a User option within Windows - only when the System itself recommends it.

This is due to System files being in use while the system is running therefore they cannot be examined if they are active. Error checking at boot is recommended because the check will commence BEFORE the System files become active (before Windows has loaded).

However, if the system is recommending Error Checking at Boot for your D: drive, that tends to suggest to me that it is either because your D: drive is in fact a partition of the C: drive, OR because you may have your Pagefile mounted on the physical D: drive.

Either way - having only just (in another thread!) got rid of your PREFETCH files and disabled the formation of Prefetch Files for all but the Boot files in order to SPEED-UP your boot times, if YOU invoke an Error Check on Boot of BOTH hard drives, I'd go run a hot bath and have a long leisurely soak in it, because by the time you are swaddled in towels, you'll be able to sit down just as Windows begins to load. ;)

*Just noticed - the Title of your post is regarding degragging 2 drives but the body text is asking about Error Checks. :p

< * >

by rajsdoshi

Hello Old Mycroft,

I messed up. Here is what I meant, which is kind of similar to Jaky Howe's response.

I have an XP Pro PC with 2 Hard Drives, C & D.

I want to Error Check both Drives. When I go to C > PROPERTIES > TOOLS > ERROR CHECK it tells me that it can do this the next time the PC is started. So I said OK.

I also want to Error Check the D Drive.

Should I ReStart First, Let the PC Error Check C Drive first, then request a Error Check for D Drive, Restart, and wait for D Drive to be Error Checked,

OR is it OK to do the following at the same time:
go to C>PROPERTIES>TOOLS>ERROR CHECK select "Yes do Error Check at next Restart..."
and then
go to D>PROPERTIES>TOOLS>ERROR CHECK select "Yes do Error Check at next Restart..."
and then Re-Start ???

My question/confusion was: Will XP get confused with 2 Error Check Requests ???

Thank you!!

by rob miners

get confused at all. As I earlier said that when you go to D drive and select error checking it will do it then and there.

If you have a file a file open on D drive it will ask if you want to schedule it on stertup. Simple. ;)

by rob miners

When you click to set the primary drive C for an Error Check it will ask you if you want to do it when the system is restarted as it needs exclusive access to the drive. When you click the second drive D for an Error Check it will run for you straight away if you don't have it selected with something on it highlighted.

I don't see any sense in running them at the same time as it is easy enough to do the D drive on the fly. It will let you know if it needs exclusive access to be able to fix it. By all means run the Error Check on C drive occasionally.

Scandisk has a replacement it is known as chkdsk.

This discussion is closed to new replies.