Discussion Locked

Can you buy a judge?

0 helpful
48 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In Michigan it has that appearance.

Wayne Circuit Court Judge Susan D. Borman is the judge that is ruling over the case concerning the striking teachers in Detroit.
http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060905/UPDATE/609050387

There is clear law stating that it is illegal for the public school teachers to go on strike, yet Judge Borman has again delayed ordering the teachers to return to work.

Guess where a lot of the funding came from that got this judge elected to her post? You got it, unions, and specifically, DFT, the Detroit Federation of Teachers. Conflict of interests here anybody?

This judge is there to uphold the laws or strike them down, not ignore them as she chooses because it helps her politically.

Bought justice? You decide.

Oh, if you want to try to distract from the facts of the case by crying about how unfair it is that the poor teachers can't strike, then THAT law should be challenged and struck down if it is a violation of the teachers rights. No where is there room for ignoring laws when it is convenent. I hope she is brought up for review for her clear conflict and resulting handling of the case.

48 replies

by nicknielsen

Not in most of the South, they can't. We were individually contracted. Failure to show for work is a violation of the contract. Bye-bye baby! No problem finding replacements, especially in the district I in which I taught-not the highest-paid in the state, but an excellent reputation.

Now, do I want a teacher in the classroom who is more worried about the paycheck than the students? No. This may be a wash. BTW, what's the strike about? Pay? Benefits? Competency requirements?

by jdclyde

I didn't say the teachers don't have a legitamate gripe, but if they choose to disobay the law, they should not be an exception.

The detroit schools are hurting because people are leaving the districts in droves. The funding is based on enrollment. Because of funding down, they want to cut the pay and benifits of the teachers, who already make less than teachers in other parts of the state BEFORE they take the cuts.

The stupit thing all the way around is even more people are going to leave the district because of the strike, cutting funding more than ever.

This is a losing situation for everyone when they are on strike. The shortfall will be even greater if they don't get the schools going. right now they have other staff babysit the kids in the gyms and such doing nothing all day.

by tony hopkinson

They aren't cheap you know.

As for the teachers they were stupid to sign a contract that they couldn't strike, and total dumbasses to have a law passed saying the same.
However if they agreed to it, they should stick to it.
Whether they think about their paycheck I'm not bothered, being in charge of my offspring's development when they have n't got enough ethical fibre to be trusted is a way bigger problem.

by jdclyde

or public transit.

If you have made the choice to make a living off of working for the government, there are some things that you have to give up in exchange. this is one of the things.

So while they didn't support the creation of this law, they knew about it when they made that choice to work for the government.

by tony hopkinson

ever a good reason from being legally barred from withdrawing your labour.

As a good socialist though I think there are situations where communal responsibility should always override personal concerns. After all you can always change careers to something less critical.

Get a good few doing that and someone will have to get off their ass and address the problems instead of relying on a legislative whip to keep you in line.

by tig2

DON'T work for the government. They are simply prohibited from walking out. They do not belong to unions. They are prohibited based on "perceived need".

In addition, they are subject to government regulation and are required to carry insurance in order to maintain licensure. They can be sued by anyone at any time for anything- even issues the patient brings on themselves- and can be held liable for the actions of others beyond their control.

In the event of disaster, they must show up at their primary place of practise and may not leave until the emergency is over. They do not get paid for 24/7 coverage but must provide it. Doctors may bill for their time and expertise. Nurses may not. They may bill at an hourly rate within limits.

They can be sued for refusing to provide service but can be sued if they provide service.

I don't teach anymore. I am no longer a nurse. That is why.

It cost me more than I made to stay in practice. I paid for my malpractise insurance, I paid for my equipment, I paid for my uniforms. By the time I was finished paying, I had no income.

That's a profession designed to attract people, huh?

I NEVER worked as a nurse or teacher for the government. When I did work for the government, I was given full disclosure regarding the rules. I did not receive the same consideration while in nursing school.

While I know the situation is tough, I must say that I would not choose to teach in Detroit. Do your kids deserve less education because teachers are leaving in droves? NO. But Detroit has issues that need to be resolved in order to attract talent back to schools.

To your initial question- is there a conflict of interest? In my opinion, the judge should have recused herself in this. But forcing the teachers into the classroom at reduced pay and benefits isn't the answer either. Those teachers may just choose to pack it in. And the government can't force someone to continue a profession that they no longer wish to continue.

I know a lot of former teachers. I know a lot of former nurses. I know why they chose to pursue alternative professions.

Edit typo

by mjwx

But I can rent one.

But this doesnt sound like the judge has been bought. It?s more like the judge wants to make a name for themselves. A reputation for entering politics maybe.

by jdclyde

so I can't tell you more than what I have read in several articals from several sources.

They do all point at her knowing not to bite the hand that feeds her.

by maecuff

nearly ANYONE can be bought. I'm not saying that every person will break the law for money, go against their personal moral code, etc. But still, there is a dollar amount that (and I'm sure that amount is wildly different, depending on the person) will turn a person's head.

Personally? I wouldn't harm another human (physically or emotionally), destroy any property that couldn't be easily replaced, do anything that could cause my death or cause long term health issues, or commit a crime that could result in prison time for myself or another person..other than that, I have a price.

by maecuff

have to be one big a$$ piggy bank. I'll admit to having a price, but I am far from cheap.

by tony hopkinson

of those things if my principles required it.

I have no problem with harming someone who had harmed or intended harm to me and mine. I wouldn't say I'd be happy to face imprisonment as a consequence, but if it was choice between my kid getting hurt, or me doing jail.

by jdclyde

whatever it takes to keep the kids safe. whatever it takes.

push come to shove, how can anyone chose otherwise? thankfully if you are just protecting your family, there isn't imprisonment here.

it is when you are the aggressor that they put you away.

by onbliss

Once I was asked, what would be my price for eating meat as I am a lacto-ovo-vegetarian. At the moment, thinking I was some great guy standing behind his principle at any cost, I answered I would eat meat only to ward off any physical harm to my family members.

Later I realized that I could set a high dollar amount as the price, and use the dollars for my pet causes or charity. Would'nt that be smarter? But would I be sacrificing one set of principles for another set of principles or priorties.

It was personally revealing to me that price was'nt just monetary, it could be principles, interests or priorities.

by jdclyde

out weigh other priorites.

"compared to what" is always a good way to look at things.

Or if you prefer, lesser of two evils?

Or what has become so very common in the politics of the day, "at any cost" or the "ends justify the means". People talk themselves into doing lots of bad things if they can rationalize it away.

Sad.

by techexec2

So, who made contributions to the political campaigns of the legislators who voted for the no-strike law?

Just a little "devil's advocate" for you(1). It's all politics and they are ALL "bought" by something. All of them.

Having said that, I have respect for the law. If there is a no-strike law, the teachers should be fired, just like the striking air traffic controllers were fired in Reagan's day.

(1) I _hate_ it when people do that to me! :-).

by jdclyde

than the individuals, is the excuse behind the law as I understand it.

And no, I am not an expert on this or many other aspect of labor law.

I do know that it is the kids that get hurt over this, and this judge not enforcing the law is a disgrace. Challenge the law or follow it. Ignoring it is not an option.

by tig2

Those teachers simply quit? They have that option. Any or every one of them may decide that teaching in Detroit is no longer acceptable.

Then what?

I think that what the judge is trying to do is provide some breathing room- certainly they could fire each and every teacher that strikes. But isn't it better to find better solutions?

The problem would be better resolved by finding a way to get the teachers back in the classrooms. But some of those teachers are going to decide that the cut is not something that they can absorb and will therefore seek alternative employment. Detroit's issues are bigger than whether the teachers walked out. They speak more to whether or not they HAVE teachers going forward.

by rknrlkid

why have parents pulled their kids out and moved in droves?

In many cases, poor school systems are caused by something other than lack of money/resourses. Here in Oklahoma, the school district with the highest teacher pay and highest student-to-dollar spent ratio has the highest juvenile problems, teen pregnancy, etc etc. Simply money isn't the answer.

I am puzzled over one thing mentioned though. Why do parents tolerate their kids being herded up into gym to be babysat rather than being taught? I doubt the kids are learning anything that way.

by jdclyde

and are giving them a few days benifit of the doubt. (according to the reports)

Many of them have clearly said that if it goes on for more than a few days, they WILL be moving their children, and many already have.

Excess of money is NOT the issue here. these are some of the poorest schools in the state, and some of the lowest paid teachers as well.

How do you attract good teachers to that kind of work environment? How long till you get teacher burnout?

Don't have all the answers, and I am just learning some of the questions.

by jdclyde

I would say that the judge should order them back to work, but the school system should be FORCED to keep them at the same level as their last contract until an agreement can be reached.

I don't mean to come across as being against these teachers as they ARE getting a raw deal.

The kids are getting a worse deal.

The judge should not be allowed to pick and choose which laws she wants to enforce, based on who donates money to her. Buying justice always undermines ALL other legal efforts. If you don't enforce this law now, how can you justify enforcing the next law?

Who decides which laws will be enforced and when?

by tig2

The judge should have recused herself based on her funding. If her actions come into question, she is going to have a tough time validating her actions- the case should have been passed on to another judge.

That said, I wonder if she thinks she is forestalling other problems? I don't know.

I do agree that law should be enforced regardless. To do less makes the average guy ask himself what other laws are for sale.

by jdclyde

that I think it is criminal that the state hasn't taken over that school district. People on the board of ed with limo drivers that take them everywhere. A few years back, one even made the driver stay in the car, with it running, while she went into the mall to shop. She didn't want to come out to a cold car.

Sweetheart deals and kickbacks.

Embesslement in the multi millions.

A huge slap in the face to another school district was the administration asked for a pay reduction and freeze to balance the budget and the teachers stepped up and did it. The administration turned around and gave themselves a raise right after. Wow, for some reason, that didn't go over well.

Government takeover and a clean slate approach is the only hope that the Detroit school system has.

by maecuff

anything to protect my family. I stepped between two men fighting with each other in a parking lot because they were scaring my kid (this was years ago, when my older son was around 6 years old). I read them the riot act, told them to grow up and act like adults. Fortunately, they stopped. Looking back, I'm lucky I didn't get the snot pounded out of me. In situations like that, I react before I think. This drives my husband insane. He's absolutely sure I'm going to get him into a fight one day because I can't seem to keep my opinion to myself in some cases.

by jdclyde

in the reply to your other post. I don't doubt for a minute anyone that was a threat to your family would regret it.

by onbliss

Are'nt these two that rank high among the noble professions? By doctors I mean all medical professions. The other profession that might rank among those two would be serving in the military for one's country.

Society sometimes does not give due credit to these professionals. Just my opinion.

by onbliss

...but when that moment comes, it is tough to predict now, how you would react then. It might turn out that I might cop out and succumb to greed; whereas you might hold onto your principles and come out shinning. [b]You see, unless the software code is tested, we really can not say if it is good or bad code[/b] :-)

That is why we have Powerball for not having to work anymore :-) I have just bought once or twice Powerball tickets. Knowing me, and knowing how addictive it is to buy lottery tickets, and knowing how remote it is to even get one dollar out of the system; I rather put it in money market account :-)

Oh how many times I have gone through in my mind and with my wife what we could do with the lottery money.

edited: typo

by maecuff

have actually argued over what we would do with our lottery winnings (We don't even BUY tickets). I'd give a lot of it away and he would not. We finally had to agree that we would split our imaginary winnings down the middle and each could do with whatever they wanted with their half. Of course, once MY pretend money is gone, he'll have to share his. :)

by onbliss

...does not even want to win the lottery. She thinks too much money is a problem onto itself. Whereas I would'nt mind winning $100 million (before tax). I would be giving lot of my pretend wealth too :-)

by jdclyde

I thought I was the only loser to dream about how I would spend my winnings for a lottery I don't even play..... ;\

I do know that my good fortune would be my close friends good fortune, as well as college funds for nieces and nephews.

I would have to send GG a NEW laptop so she could stop having to nurse hers back to health all the time though! :x

You would not believe the house I would build right on the river. individual walk in closets the size of my current bedroom.

Oh and the game room would be an english pub! Stocked! B-)

by ontheropes

I buy 1 ticket every time I go into the party store. It seems like an appropriate place to get it. My chances of winning are infinitely better than JD?s, seeing as how he doesn?t BUY a ticket.

I used to pick my own numbers but now I just get an Easy Pick. I don?t check the numbers right away when they draw them either. I?ll usually wait for a really BAD day and then either check them all online or have them scan ?em at the store.

When I did pick numbers I used algorithms based upon the theory of probability that used to be available on the web for free. Maybe they still are somewhere. To give you an example, there are 21 algorithms?s at http://tinyurl.com/ofqo2 and some free ?tools.?

I?d split buying tickets with 3 Engineers I used to work, with in one of our Kentucky Division?s. That's why the algorithm's. It's scientific donchaknow. Using Excel I?d put together a list of every winning number combination for the Michigan Lotto since the game began and we?d play 10 sets of numbers, five for one drawing and five for the second drawing every week. Any winnings we?d get would go into buying more tickets so it didn?t cost as much to play. We?d hit ?something? often enough that between the four of us it probably cost only 10 to 15 a month. It rarely cost me a dime because they?d just fork over the small amount of cash for me doing all of the work. :) It was kind of hard to keep track of it but what the heck. They all got a copy of the tickets before the drawings after I?d scan them in and send a picture via email.

That?s so long ago it seems like it was in another lifetime. :D Possibly hitting ?the big one? made for good conversation over a few beers after work when I?d be down there.

If I were to win today with my little $1 ticket twice weekly my wife and I have talked about what we?d do if we hit something big, $50 million or more.

First, pay everything off. That?d take about $100 bucks. (?) Then we?d split the cost of building a humongous log home, right here. Each of my kids, including my son-in-law, would get a million and my wife could have everything that was left except for a million dollars that I could spend any which way I wanted to with no questions asked. I?d probably donate $5.00 ;-) :x in Tigger?s name to The Susan G. Komen Breast Cancer Foundation and blow the rest on some really good beer and maybe a boat... and a motorcycle... and a big dog and... :)

Seriously, :| thinking about what you WOULD do eases tension and stress somehow. In my opinion, there?s nothing wrong with building ?castles in the sky? as long as I don?t try to live there.

by tig2

Remember that I am walking the 2007 3 Day and have to raise a minimum of $2200! I will be happy to advise you in how to best direct your (pretend) wealth!

Kidding- but the opening was there, why not use it?
:)

by tony hopkinson

between my kid starving and ...

There are some tasks where the money would be a bonus, others where no amount of money would be enough. Leaves a large tempting grey area in the middle though, that range.

by tony hopkinson

In the UK, it's most definitely not.

Called reasonable force over here. Very ambiguous definition. The gooders have been having a field day for a while.

You see, you knew it was wrong, your 'victim' is a poor misunderstood person who was subjected to too much violence on tv.

Got to work on my liberal outlook, I must be confusing the people who've pigeon holed me.

by jdclyde

There used to be a standard that you had to try to retreat first (even in your home) and then had to pretty much already have that gun pressed against your temple before you could retaliate.

Recently in Michigan and many other states they fixed this. It is finally understood that you have a RIGHT to be safe and secure. Anyone is breaking into your home, this is a threat and can be dealt with.

Of course most homes this doesn't make a lot of difference to as the majority of households do NOT have loaded weapons just laying around for home defense. (no matter what you have heard) I recognise there is a higher chance that my boys of a friend could find and play with said weapon and shoot each other, than that someone would break in WHILE I am home AND I will be closer to that weapon than they are. They are all under lock and key.

I DO have several compound bows laying around the house though, as well as an old golf club in just about every room. It would not be a good idea to come in a window or my puppy will chew on your fingers! :D aw man. bad dog! Sitting here in the front room with my laptop and she started farting. BAD DOG! :0

by tony hopkinson

In the UK you can't assume that your assailant is carrying a weapon and therefore that the threat they pose is extreme and warrants a similar response from your self.

Once they shoot you or stab though, you are allowed to use more force.
If you are still capable of course.
You may not go down for it, but you will end up with a conviction and a record in most cases.

Got to be careful with the dog as well, it's classed as a weapon that they can execute.

by jdclyde

It used to be someone could break into your home, get bit by the dog, and after they sue you, you have to have your dog "put down". What stupidassclown could ever come up with such a stupid idea?

The criminals are finally not walking in with more rights then the civilians.

Of course, of that person has your TV and is running away, they are no longer a threat and force can not be used to stop them. got to catching them coming in, and then just the fact they broke into your home is enough of a threat that you can defend yourself and your home as you see fit. One iron upside the head anyone? :D

I hope someday crimials in your area will lose the RIGHT to do as they please with your home and your posessions.

by jdclyde

I think I would buy a Durango too. :D

And a Crossfire.

How many lottery winners die from drinking too much? A lot I would bet.

Would money ruin me? Lord, I hope so! I could use some spoiling right now! :D

They have a pool at work, but there were doing $5 a week, which is $20 a month. Just can't throw that much away every month right now.

They do say the quickest way to become a millionair with the lottery is to take that money and throw it in a bank account instead, and you are more likely to get anywhere than if you actually "play". I LOVE how the lottery isn't gambling. Oh, and how this originally got it's start to raise money for the schools. only about 30% actually goes to the schools and all they did was a nutshell scam and replaced existing funding with this rather than increase the amount of funding, so the schools get all the lottery money and are still broke. how nice. :|

by jdclyde

in my position you would agree. I live in an OLD house. How old? Don't know because the City doesn't have that on their records. :0 From the style and neighborhood, it is guessed at being built about 1900.

Looks big on the out side, but get inside and it is horrible. Not even a broom closet in the house. Not a cubboard in the bathroom, no pantry in the kitchen, and the two bedrooms (small) each have one small closet each.

lots of wasted space because of a bad floor plan, but compared to what I had moved out of, it SEEMED good at the time.

Can't ever keep the house clean because there isn't anywhere to put stuff away at.

Everyone deservers a nice roomy closet to go into, don't they? ;\

by onbliss

[i]In my opinion, there?s nothing wrong with building ?castles in the sky? as long as I don?t try to live there.[/i]

It gives a few moments of [b]bliss[/b].

I think it terms of circles/spheres. First my family, then extended family, then community, school/college, charity etc. Will take a world tour of some sort. Indulge in other learning and passionate activities. Wow........dreams.

by maecuff

a break.

yes. I have to agree. I live in an old house, too. When my older son moved back to Cincinnati with my parents, I moved my younger son to his old bedroom and turned his room into my own personal closet. And do you know what? It's still not big enough.

I can't WAIT to move from this stupid little town and from my wishy washy job and get into a house where every one has their own walk-in closets. :)

by tony hopkinson

priviledge.

We have that law for dogs, you have to put a beware of the dog sign up to warn burglars otherwise your 100 lb german shepherd with a bark that gets you into trouble with the local noise abatement society is a concealed weapon!

My dog doesn't do concealed, not even when he savaged my lawn mower and sweeping bush.

This discussion is closed to new replies.