Discussion Locked

Cat food and the economy

0 helpful
39 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

So I have been watching the pet food thing pretty closely. Menu Foods has a problem that they need to clear up. I think that I really need to know what has happened here- I live with three cats, I want to understand what in cat food can cause renal failure.

One of the very interesting bits to come to light here is that Menu Foods produces canned and pouched varieties of dog and cat food for a number of labels. Names like IAMS and Eukanuba and Science Diet. Very expensive cat chow. Dog chow too.

Menu foods also produces some of the mid range brands... like Purina.

AND they produce the low range- Walmart's "Special Kitty" and the like.

To me- an interested consumer, I have basically just learned that it is not important at all if I feed an expensive or less expensive food to my cats. There is zero value using a food that is vet recommended unless you vet the supplier.

There are a lot of people who were paying premium pet food prices that are grieving over the loss of their pet. There are others that aren't covered in the news that were paying what they could and trying desperately to keep their pet healthy and have now lost their pet.

I don't think highly of government regulation but is something else needed here? How about PEOPLE who depend on pet food to stay alive? That has been a known for awhile. Should the FDA have an input to the pet industry?

39 replies

by michael jay

is and does have input to the pet food industry.
http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2007-03-20-pet-food_N.htm

It is indeed tragic to pet owners, so far I have seen reports of 15 to 17 pets that have been killed by this problem.

And from those reports it seems that this is nothing more than a tragic accident that probably should not have happened. I do not think that more government input is needed, what is needed is better checking of content by the manufacturers of the food to insure that they do not harm pets with a product intended to keep them healthy.

My cats like Meow Mix, and that is not on the list. Thankfully..

But wait... there is more
http://www.fda.gov/opacom/7alerts.html

Kinda scary, but any time you mass produce anything there is the chance for mass contamination.

by maxwell edison

You asked, [i]"How about PEOPLE who depend on pet food to stay alive? That has been a known for awhile."[/i]

I disagree that people are ever forced to eat pet food. I've heard that general statement thrown around for a long time, but I've never actually heard of a REAL case of it happening. I doubt you have either. Personally speaking, I think it's a myth. Especially considering all the sources for food available to anyone who needs it, sources such as food stamps, food banks, private charities, meals on wheels, and such. It seems to be one of those claims without any examples, so I simply don't believe it.

Secondly, when asked what ONE food she would eat if she had to pick ONLY one because of being stranded on a deserted island or something, Marilyn Vos Savant said dog food because it had all the daily nutrients necessary to live a healthy life. She didn't know which she would prefer, however, dry or canned. So even if there are isolated cases of it happening, there's nothing wrong with it, and it's probably by choice -- a can of chunky Campbell's soup (a good meal in itself) isn't really much more than a can of Alpo.

Nonetheless, that's one of those claims that I take with the proverbial grain of salt.

You also asked, [i]"Should the FDA have an input to the pet industry?"[/i]

They already do.

by sleepin'dawg

I was in the supermarket the other day and as I was buying dog food, it croosed my mind that dog food or any pet food for that matter, was too expensive for anyone homeless or on welfare. To top it off, there are many more nutritious and cheaper options than putting pet food on your diet.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by locolobo

reminds me Circle K. I actually sold pet food to people who ate it. Did they need to? No way. Everyone I knew was an alcoholic who had enuff for a fifth but not enuff for a fifth and food. Back then a fifth of T-bird (really cheap wine) was about $2 and a small can of cat food was 25 cents.

by absolutely

[i]You also asked, "Should the FDA have an input to the pet industry?"

They already do.[/i]

But, should they? If so, how much & what kind? Is it useful to provide product-specific information in summary form, or simply to ensure that the [b]raw data[/b] is available to consumers, with each of us taking a bit more personal responsibility for evaluating that data? Would it be prohibitively difficult to research questions such as these on WebMD, if manufacturers were required to publish their ingredients & processes?

by tonythetiger

somewhat on supply and demand. Canned mackerel is cheaper than cat food around here, and the cat likes it better.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

You can't get food stamps if you don't have a valid mailing address... And PO Boxes don't come cheap.

In some areas soup kitchens are few and far between.

Some people can't get to food banks, or if they can they don't have a home or anyplace to cook anything.

I have known at least 2 people who have resorted to pet food to get by.

Poverty is a horrifying thing, and even more horrifying are the opinions of those who have never experienced it.

What about children who will stick anything in their mouths (my brother had a thing for dog food for several weeks when we were small)?

by maxwell edison

.....[i]known at least 2 people who have resorted to pet food to get by, [/i], then you should be ashamed of yourself for not giving them real food.

You also said, [i]"Poverty is a horrifying thing, and even more horrifying are the opinions of those who have never experienced it."[/i]

You presume to know what I may or may not have experienced in my life. You presume too much. I've experienced lots of things in my life -- and being without money is one of them. And I've actually given food to people -- lots of them. I've stocked people's kitchen cabinets. But I've never tried to force others to do it, nor have I judged those who don't. In your case, however, I'll make an exception. Shame on you, by your own admission, for standing by and watching them eat dog food.

by hal 9000

Several years ago there was a Spaghetti Restraint here called Boots or something similar I never actually went there but remember them quite well because all their glasses where in the shape of a Boot and they sold heaps of these.

As this was the place to go and was way above my willingness to pay the prices asked there I never went near the place but I think that the boss got a couple of glasses from someone who went there regularly.

But after they had been running for about 12 months the Health Department here sprung a surprise Inspection on them and found that the Delicious Meat Balls that every one was raving about where actually Tinned Dog Food and the place had an immediate closure order placed on it. Apparently according to the Health Department report that was presented in Parliament they visited this Restraint close to Christmas and found 350 opened and empty tins of a product called Lassie Meat Balls with Gravy which has since disappeared off the shelves as well.

Apparently this was the Sauce and Meatballs that where so well thought of by the paying public who paid outrageous prices to be feed dog food. :D

Col

by absolutely

It's possible that she was referring to people who eat cats!
:0
Well, Tig? What do you have to say for yourself?

PS If the most wonderful thing about Tiggers was that TiggerOne was the only one, what was the second-best thing?
:p

[edit: 'shocked' smily face requires '0', not the 'O', as displayed [b]in the TechRepublic guide to emoticons![/b]
http://articles.techrepublic.com.com/5100-22_11-5269527.html
Who is in charge here?
X-( ]

by tig2

I threw that out because I have known people who have resorted to eating pet food. And not the premium stuff either.

There was a time in my life when survival was not a guarantee and I didn't qualify for the programmes that Max mentioned. Something about being white and single. Oh, I was allowed $97 for food every month but only for a short period of time. And my available cash- not much- had to get me to MD appts and pay the co-pay for medication.

I was fortunate that I could find other ways. I knew people who were not so fortunate.

And as another poster mentioned, there were always the alkies- rather pay for booze than food.

And I have no idea if the name "TiggerOne" was available. I know that there is another TR member called "Tigger"- or was when I joined this last time. But that Tigger is obviously an imposter as I took the name Tigger right off my own resume.

by tig2

It is now assumed that this is a case of poison- rat poison to be specific.

Check the following links for additional information. (1)(2)

In the question of Whether the FDA should regulate such matters, my question stands. The fact that it DOES is not material. With that knowledge, the only alteration to the question is "should they actually be doing that job?" If you ask me, they are not doing it remotely well.

This issue is over pet food. Couple of months ago, it was over bagged spinach. Before that it was E.coli at a fast food retailer. Isn't this all the same basic question?

(1)http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=2975912&page=1
ABC on the causal (?) issue.

(2)http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601103&sid=aF8tMnC47qwI&refer=us
Menu foods increases recall.

Edited to insure links were added properly.

by michael jay

I found that rat poison was the culprit.
From what I read the rat poison was placed in the fields to protect the grain that was used in the food, apparently the rat poison got into the grain and was added to the food, scary, it could happen to human food.

On a what if, if I was in charge of the thing, the government should not be involved, the food makers should have many cats and dogs eating their food to insure that it is wholesome. Also the cats should have the rule of the field this would remove the need for rat poison as the cats could take care of the rat problem without any trouble at all.

by maxwell edison

You presume that involvement will result in no mistakes or oversights

Generally speaking, the FDA does a pretty good job ensuring that our food supply (human, canine, or feline) is relatively safe.

At worst, sixteen animals died because of this "mistake" of rat poison being introduced into the food. How many animals WERE NOT affected? Millions, I might suggest. What percentage of animals were affected? .000000001 perhaps?

If you expect perfection (out of anyone or anything), you'd better expect it of only yourself; in which case, there would be no government involvement.

Come on, Tig. This is a bunch of nothing.

by tonythetiger

the more interference (or the bigger the government), the easier it is for incompetents to hide among them, and the [b]more likely[/b] mistakes will be!

by maxwell edison

More were killed because of cars. (Or more were killed because they crossed the street without looking both ways.)

How does this kind of "non-event" make the news?

by hal 9000

And Bad News always sells advertising so it's a news worthy item.

2 A mistake was made and from what I've read here a very obvious mistake as any form of Poison isn't allowed to be applied to foodstuffs within a certain time frame of harvesting apparently in this case that didn't happen.

I seem to remember a move from a long time ago where Milk Cows where contaminated by a Heavy Metal Poison that built up in the tissues of the people who drank the milk and could not be removed unless of course you where a Lactating Female who could then poison their child.

This is fairly common with any Heavy Metal Poisoning but you might care to look up the facts I think that the movie was called [b]Bitter Harvest[/b] though I'm not 100% sure of that and I seem to remember that the farmers who destroyed their livestock which had been contaminated didn't receive any incentive to do so if anything they where actively encouraged to continue to supply milk known to be contaminated to the public.

Wasn't a recent event but probably happened about 20 to 30 years ago.

Col

by absolutely

Do you know something correlated more strongly to short life span than smoking, drinking, or obesity?

[down]

Poverty.

You know what makes people poor?

Governments that distribute wealth according to algorithms other than productivity, and interfere in business [i]as standard operating procedure[/i].

Sorry, Tig, I know you're concerned about your cats, and there is nothing wrong with that. But, before the next time you vote, please step back, and ask whether you really believe that corporations are motivated to put rat poison into your pet food, or whether that was much more likely the work of an aberrant employee. Whether unusually stupid or unusually malicious, this kind of thing is unusual. When it does occur, investigations can be conducted on ad-hoc bases. These rare events do not call for new government agencies. ABC News is not in business to protect your liberty, but to keep you alarmed, tuning in, worried about what goes bump in the night. It increases their Neilsen ratings, increasing the revenue they yield from cat food sponsors!

by tig2

I don't think that additional governmental control is the answer here. I ask the question to hear the feedback. I didn't press my own views.

I found it fascinating that having gone to the effort to find a good quality food for my indoor cats- one of which is a less active senior, that brands that have been touted for years as top quality premium are made by the same manufacturer as the Wal-Mart private label. That was a new level of transparency to me and I want to understand how the same food can have such a variation in retail value.

To my mind, Menu Foods has done the right thing from the beginning- they informed consumers, made an honest effort to pull the product, complied with everything that they have been asked to comply with and have resorted to the additional step of asking retailers to remove all of the food of the type that has the problem, regardless of manufacture date or location "just in case". The FDA didn't make a request that they do so, they chose to. Frankly, I think that they have handled themselves remarkably well since all this started and would do so with or without government.

by daveo2000

I know that you are very good at being insensitive but are you so thick that you didn't read the post that you just replied to?

It appears to me that Tig2 is saying the [b]she[/b] had to resort to such tactics at a low point of [b]her[/b] life. So are you asking her why she would let herself do it with insufficient money and social services to do otherwise?

So now that you are aware of that little possibility, would you like to go on to berate her on anything else?

by tig2

And at the time, I was pretty darned close to the same thing.

When you find out after the fact, about all you can do is damage control.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Unless I'm greatly mistaken the culprit is something used overseas as rat poison in grain fields that is not an approved substance in the US (unless you're talking chemo and that's another subject).

My cats had been puking for months before the story broke and only after they had their can for the week. Thank God they only got a half a can week! I stopped the cans a day or two before the story broke because of the puking - then of course pitched what was left after - and now they will only get a bit of canned tuna and/or chicken periodically. No more cans. But what am I to do about their dry food? Poor kitties! :(

Until US businesses are forced to closely examine foreign content in their product, and/or until some serious global regulation is enforced, we will be at the mercy of the toxins used on foreign soils.

Then there are the toxins allowed in the US, but that too is another story.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

"There was a time in my life when survival was not a guarantee and I didn't qualify for the programmes that Max mentioned."

If the address of the place you live isn't "techinically - legally" yours, you're SOL, too.

by juliannasong

and most cat food I tried tasted dreadful.
The cat thought so too ! So I've kept trying different brands until Ive found one that looks right, and that cat and I experience as tasting good. That's the one I buy. She eats it all up, and I'm sure I could use it for myself if I had to. When in doubt keep tasting.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

You presume that I didn't give them food just because I say I know of two who have eaten pet food. And I did not say that I stood by and watched them eat dog food. I simply stated that I know of people who have done so. I give money, time, and food to those who are less fortunate than myself on regular occassion.

Poverty goes far deeper than just not having money. I am quite weary of the people in this nation assuming that just because there are food stamps, people who need them get them, I am sick and tired of hearing peole say things like "I'm tired of being poor", when it's obvious that what they really mean is "I'm tired of not being able to buy what I want when I want to". Worldwide, around 150 million people starve to death every year and I know too many people who "don't believe it".

My apologies for having snapped a bit.

by hal 9000

Over here there have been numerous demands on different industries for money of their foodstuffs would be contaminated after one case of contamination was found. Their response is to contact the proper authorities and then Proceed with the Business as Usual approach and then they are not responsible for what happens.

But many years ago when I was between 15 and 17 I worked in a Woolworth's at the food counter and there we had no Pet Foods and where not allowed to sell it but we could sell Methylated Spirits to anyone who walked in off the street. They actually had some of that stuff chilled for the [b]Hot Days[/b] and knew exactly what it was being bought for. This was back in the days before they had the Blue Dye in it so it was just a clear liquid. The shop in question was actually proud of the level of service that they offered and where constantly selling more Metho than any Other of the shops in the same chain. As they say there are three rules in retail sales [b]Location, Location, Location.[/b]

Col

by daveo2000

I expect that the [b]process[/b] is the same for the various categories of cat foods (dried, moist, disgusting) and the real difference is probably in the list of ingredients. For instance, for a long time the Ford Pinto and the Mercury Bobcat went down the same production line but got different parts (I saw one with Bobcat trim on one side and Pinto trim on the other :) )

Maybe the same happens with animal food. They make a big batch of prime vendor food with prime ingredients followed by a big batch of cheap food with cheap ingredients, etc. This allows for the holy grail of "Economies of Scale" and avoids idle time between major runs of production. This, in turn, provides for continued employment for the manufacturing staff.

Electronics firms do this too. For instance, I am led to understand that there are really only about 4 manufacturers worldwide of optical drive guts. So, the super expensive DVD player and the mid-priced one may have the same engine... just one will have more bells, buzzers and whistles.

by tonythetiger

doesn't mean it's the same food.

The same company makes the Lincoln Continental as makes the Ford Focus ...

by absolutely

It's clear now that we are in agreement.

[i]
To my mind, Menu Foods has done the right thing from the beginning- they informed consumers, made an honest effort to pull the product, complied with everything that they have been asked to comply with and have resorted to the additional step of asking retailers to remove all of the food of the type that has the problem, regardless of manufacture date or location "just in case". The FDA didn't make a request that they do so, they chose to. Frankly, I think that they have handled themselves remarkably well since all this started and would do so with or without government.[/i]

As long is there is more profit in providing cat food than cat poison in cat food containers, the profit motive will provide the best incentive for all manugacturers to provide the best quality they're able. When killing consumers is profitable, [b]then[/b] greed will be the root of all evil.

by tig2

I tossed the question out because I am not altogether certain that we need governmental controls on cat food- I think that a company with integrity will act with integrity and I don't know that forced compliance does any good.

I am irritated to have a new view into the cat food industry as a whole- and with no blame to Menu Foods- and will be re-thinking my cat food choices in the future. The cat doesn't have a say in what she eats. She is wholly dependent on me to make good choices for her.

by tonythetiger

such things, you end up with some companies striving to meet minimum standards. Kinda reminds me of labor unions :)

by nicknielsen

When Diamond Pet foods here in SC had problems, they did the same thing Menu Foods did: informed consumers, made the effort to pull the product, and so on.

[RHETORICAL]When was the last time a people-food manufacturer did that without a lot of fuss and bother and "it wasn't me" first?[/RHETORICAL]

This discussion is closed to new replies.