Discussion Locked

Comparison of government spending on academics, athletics.

0 helpful
72 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
There has been a great deal of discussion in certain media in recent years of the United States 'falling behind' other industrial nations in education and economic production, with greatest concern in sectors dependent on advanced scientific and engineering knowledge. My casual observation is that none of these other countries emphasizes athletics as much as the United States, especially in schools. What does your state spend on college athletics? What about your kids' school district, if you have kids? What do you think of the idea that parents and school boards are the problem with American schools, and that you/they allocate too much money & attention to play and not enough to education?

72 replies

by santeewelding

You drag a hundred-dollar bill through a trailer park. Spend your not inconsiderable faculties on greater.

by tony hopkinson

to survive going through a trailer park dragging a $100 bill. Or you study for a bit and not do it in the first place. :D

by absolutely

Have you nothing now to say about [i]how[/i] it is spent? Why no comment on the original topic?

As you are British, frivolous spending in the United States might tend to help your country be more competitive globally, in the very industries whose foundation has been built on inventions of the United States. Silence from you on this exact question will appear, to me, to contradict your assertions that you favor socialism [i]for the sake of the good of people[/i].

by absolutely

It would appear you are familiar with the tone of Discussions on TechRepublic. However, I believe the question of resource allocation is worthy of serious consideration, in the very atmosphere that is the source of the problem. Come Monday, we'll see whether other members are actually willing and able to consider the question responsibly, of if in fact this is a case of casting pearls before swine.

by santeewelding

I reside in the selfsame park. I don't wake porcine, nor see other residents so. And I do not regard what you cast as a pearl. A grain, maybe, in the way of an irritant.

Your grain is guaranteed only to attract layer upon layer of contrapuntal belief. The deposition, for millennia past until now, has produced no pearl, just quarrel.

Spend your own resources, and not of the governmental kind, on the question. Lend your faculties to a far larger, total approach.

For instance, technical education is subsumed by education (madras?), in turn by duty to our young, thence to duty.

If duty, then what duty of the rest of us to any one of us, of any one to any one other, and the duty of any one to the rest?

If you presume all that to be already and Absolutely settled, admitting only of casual as opposed to causal insight, look to the child of your post. The category of one is violently disputed as to simply when it is conferred upon life as child.

And nevermind duty. The category of one itself is conjectural until you draw certain lines certainly. Excuse me: responsibly.

Until then.

by tony hopkinson

But this particular branch of the post went right over my head.
Is this some sort of literary reference or the written equivalent of talking with a mouth full of marbles?

by absolutely

And I disagree.

"I reside in the selfsame park. I don't wake porcine, nor see other residents so. And I do not regard what you cast as a pearl. A grain, maybe, in the way of an irritant.

Your grain is guaranteed only to attract layer upon layer of contrapuntal belief."

We'll see what we see. Others may be more willing than you to solve a problem that is rendering them and their children unemployable.

"The deposition, for millennia past until now, has produced no pearl, just quarrel."

Why do you suppose that is?

by santeewelding

And I agree. There is a problem. There are many problems. Among them is the problem of how we go about dealing with all problems. Do we prop this solution and that in place with wiki sticks? Or cut the great swath through all and start from scratch? Forces in the world would reduce all to scratch -- their belief, their version of scratch.

I hope it doesn't happen while you fiddle with sticks.

by absolutely

[i]Spend your own resources, and not of the governmental kind, on the question. Lend your faculties to a far larger, total approach.[/i]

My ideas are one of my resources. My right to free speech includes expressing them, and presenting those that I choose to share. You have no complaint.

[i]For instance, technical education is subsumed by education (madras?), in turn by duty to our young, thence to duty.

If duty, then what duty of the rest of us to any one of us, of any one to any one other, and the duty of any one to the rest?[/i]

That is part and parcel of my original question, which was posed less pretentiously than your retort. To wit:

[i]If you presume all that to be already and Absolutely settled, admitting only of casual as opposed to causal insight, look to the child of your post. The category of one is violently disputed as to simply when it is conferred upon life as child.[/i]

Your cowardice grows more despicable with every evasion.

by thechas

From what I have observed watching sports parents around here, the motivation behind high school sports is for Johnny to get a sports scholarship.

In far too many families sports is given too high of a priority over academics so that mom and dad might not have to pay for college.

That said, I have never understood the obsession with sports in the US. And, likely never will. I mean, realistically, what difference does it make in our lives which team wins any given game.

I'm even more confounded by the people who have no idea what is going on in the world of US football, but MUST watch the Superbowl so that they won't miss out on the commercials! Perhaps the marketers actually are running the country.

Anyhow, enough personal rants, back to your main question.

Around here, most of the local school sports programs are funded by pay for play. The school system only maintains the facilities.

Parents use the schools of choice program to send their sons to the school they think has the best coach / team for their best chance at a scholarship.

Academically, many schools are limited by the state controlled funding formula, and have a tough time with the 3 r's.

Too many students choose their courses based on the how easy it will be. Rather than by how much they could learn. I remember my daughter switching out of a science class based on the other students in that session. She was concerned that the teacher would have to spend so much time to get these students to understand the basic concepts that she was not going to learn enough.

At the college level, I would say that most of the money for sports is coming from alumni. Imagine what a change there would be in this country if college alumni invested in academic scholarship funding instead of sports.

I know, let's get some game show promoters to bring back the old college bowl shows.

On the pro sports level, I know that some state funds are going to Detroit to pay for the new stadiums. But, I believe the bulk of that funding comes from hotel / motel taxes. If the city of Detroit is even breaking even on what they spent to keep the Lions and Tigers, I would be surprised.

So, yes, I do think the people in the US place far too much emphasis on sports specifically, and on entertainment in general.

Just think what could be if we treated scientists like we do rock stars and sports heroes.

Chas

by Member 25348569

This pervades your entire culture.

Obviously, my insight is gleaned from TV programmes and some little reading that has touched on the subject but the pattern seems obvious.

Like everywhere else in the world, in US high schools there are students who are culturally and intellectually superior to their fellows. In most other places in they receive some form of recognition by their fellow students. Not so in the US where they are, generally, socially outcast. These students can have wit and sophistication beyond that of their peers but all prestige goes to jocks and cheerleaders and who possess the emotional capabilities and depth of a goldfish. The nerds in the US then come to believe that their introverted, closed life is the only life they can have and the cool, good-looking people look down upon them even if they can be bothered acknowledge their existence.

Jocks and nerds grow up and shape your political, social and educational landscape and the system perpetuates.

by tony hopkinson

I think our education establishments are misdirected as well. Ours isn't mis-spent on sport though. If you don't believe me check the medals totals for the last few games.

I could go chapter and verse on what's wrong with the UK education establishment, but I know next to nothing about yours, except for things like taking the oath of allegiance, sports scholarships, and a really crap history course.

The only part government should play in education is making sure as many as possible get as good as possible start in life through school. As far as sport goes, not every one can be a quarter back.

Don't go Maxwell on me, and treat me as though I was a democrat. I'm not. I'm not a Blairite either. In my experience, that last thing education needs is anyone's political dogma. So called socialists made a complete and utter arse of our system. Most of them wouldn't consider me a socialist, I know I don't consider them to be so, more like f'ing liberals.

by absolutely

[i]Don't go Maxwell on me, and treat me as though I was a democrat. I'm not.[/i]

Those aren't the very most exact instructions I've ever seen, but I'll try not to attribute my assumptions to your words, and hope that's close enough to what you mean.

By the way, though, you [i]have[/i] in the past asserted the right to spend my money, remember?

[i]As far as sport goes, not every one can be a quarter back.[/i]

Not everybody wants to be, either. Why should recreational activities receive tax money at all? How much should they receive, in comparison to the subjects that 99.9% of students will need to know to earn a livelihood?

by tony hopkinson

I could only do that if one of us changed nationality.

I see funding society as an obligation and a duty. Telling someone where their duty lies is a futile exercise, so we are left with force (on both sides) and an argument about the exact nature of the obligation.

As to sport in education. Playing sports does teach a lot, taught me I was crap at it. Team play, discipline, competition all good add ons for an education establishment. But only part of it.

It will play a much bigger part in some pupil's lives than others, but to sacrifice what a large percentage of pupils need , so you can hear your school's name in a association with a first round draft pick is at best myopic.

If the guild of mathematicians had the buying power of the NFL or some such, would we be sat here saying not everybody can be Einstein or Hawking. Quite possibly. Balance is what pupils need initially, until they get some idea of what path they want to take.

In the main I'm in total agreement with you. Any society that considers missing out on a potential Michael Jordan more important than missing out on a Richard Feynman is messed up. But that's my bias, perhaps it would be best if we missed neither.

For those holding the purse strings , Feynmans are much cheaper than Jordans as well.

by drowningnotwaving

[i]in comparison to the subjects that 99.9% of students will need to know to earn a livelihood[/i].

Without trivialising it, that is the entire problem, isn't it?

And also with respect to the fact we are in different countries, I acknowledge that this is an academic discussion (pardon the weak pun) rather than an attempt to say which would be right, wrong or indifferent.

Having laid that foundation, the fact is that you wouldn't want me determining that, nor me you.

And when the rationalist movement says we should fund maths / english / practical subjects, and the touchy-feely movement point out the importance of art to the growth of a child, well, all hell breaks loose!!

There are so many reasons why the teaching of sport, athletics and health are critical to the growth and development of a child that this would seemingly be a must-have in an education system (to me, of course).

Whether the extension of that process into the full-on NCAA-style approach you have in the USA is justified, well that's up to you.

And to add to that, my (limited) understanding of the literature and study in the field of younger person education is that there is a specific and objective need for recreational programmes to be interspersed with the academic. The success of the latter will be significantly reduced without the former.

My suggestion to your original discussion is that each is completely independent of the other. One should not be increased or decreased simply in proportion to the other.

An individual child's ability to cope with either should be measured, managed and maintained according to the needs of that child and the effort that their parents are prepared to put into the overall process. If their parents are not prepared to be a part of the process then they can't be too upset with the result.

by drowningnotwaving

Schools have the grounds, the auditorium, the tennis courts etc etc, depending upon their ground area (e.g. country schools often have huge football fields compared to city schools, obviously).

Very few public (funded) schools have expensive / specialist sports facilities like olympic length pools. They just utilise the local town's / suburb's facility.

But with extremely few exceptions of radically gifted young athletes who receive national or state grants to assist with expenses, everything for the average Billy or Maggie is payed for by the parents, or by fund-raising endeavours. Everything. Even school-colours uniforms.

Some sort of physical activity is compulsory to year 10 (average age 16). Given the challenges of obesity there is a lot of talk about the compulsory attendance being lengthened (more hours per week).

Sport, and international success thereof, plays a massive part in the psyche of New Zealand and Australia who are, in terms of population (or just about any measure you want to apply) disproportionately and extremely successful.

There are some schools that thrive on their sporting reputation and are overly successful in terms of generating potential professional sporting people. These tend to be dominated by the four professional football codes.

We also have specialist sporting high schools (in the public system), but we also have specialist artistic high schools, academic high schools, technical high schools etc.

The competition to be seen in the highest academic averages / grades is arguably (and especially in the last 10 years) significantly higher than being seen as the best breeder of front-row forwards.

It's been especially sensitive/in the news in the last two months as final results for school leavers, as well as university placements, have been published.

It would annecdotally appear that the US athletics programmes for high-schools thence college is a significantly (hugely) bigger machine than over here.

Sports scholarships do exist, but they are generally significantly less than the overall fees (more subsidies of expenses). There are exceptions but they are often for kids who are truly exceptional, and have generally represented / won at national and international levels.

There is a lot of private subsidy and black-market subsidy. It isn't unusual for a good footy playing kid to have bought himself a car for 1% or 2% the normal value. That's all okay.

In general, the education / literacy question comes up all the time, particularly around elections for all the obvious reasons.

And invariably trailer-trash-Johnny gets rolled out infront of the cameras showing how he can hotwire a car but not read the road signs.

But overall academically we rate right up there with the world, standards and literacy rates are getting better, we are not far away from full disclosure of results and relative standings on an individual level, school level and some say potentially even faculty-within-school level.

A series of literacy tests have been invoked at a number of times during a kid's schooling, and in general (as the saying goes) what you measure, you improve.

Indeed federal funding of the schools programmes have been specifically tied to the tests and the disclosures. That worked.

I don't want to comment specifically on the US situation but (if you accept my apology for the rant'n'rave) I thought my personal take on what happens over here may have slight interest to someone.

And I am sure other people from this part of the world will have very different takes on it according to their (or family or fiends) experiences.

Have not yet invented a hangover cure. That is sadly lacking in our science expertise. Or alcohol that doesn't give a hangover in the first place. But we do make mighty fine white and red wine. Does that count towards literacy?

by absolutely

I disagree. I say, we'll see on Monday whether members of TR (other than santeewelding who has already displayed his willingness to emote at the expense of his ability to reason) have the maturity to discuss a subject in need of serious attention.

by tony hopkinson

I learn something from you, what is anyone meant to pick up from his pseudo intellectual gnomic babble?

Rhetorical question, no answer necessary.

by karmashock

Sports get almumi excited, bring up school spirit, and get community support/involvement.

Furthermore, if your game is televised the school gets that money. Why do you think such schools are prepared to spend MILLIONS on hiring a good coach? Because they get MILLIONS more in grants, community involvement, and tv rights money.

Sports are not required for higher education but they do help fund schools. As such that football money comes right back into the school to fund expensive programs such as physics and engineering.

As to US schools falling behind, that can't be said of US higher education which still generally head and shoulders over almost anywhere else. If you disagree then examine where the discoveries are made... and where the various geniuses were educated. The US is doing very well in higher education.

Pre college public schools however aren't doing very well. But that's because excellence isn't demanded of students. It's a different educational culture and thus produces different results.

Point: If you want better public high schools then you've got to be prepared to fail and hold back anyone/everyone that doesn't meet the grade... and of course fire incompetent teachers. But between the teachers unions and the various groups that think it's "mean" to give kids that can't read failing grades - have fun with that. High school is thus what you make of it. If you don't care and screw around then public US high schools won't stop you. If you make an effort and put in the extra time then you can be anything.

by absolutely

"Actually, Universities MAKE money on sports."

Some. Others take a loss. Any way you describe it, money is being spent on recreation which necessarily means that it isn't being spent on study.

How much in your district?

by karmashock

Just because money is being spent on sports doesn't mean it isn't being spent on education. A good way to think about college sports is as an entertainment business. That is to say the university puts on a show. Putting on that show costs money in the same way that making a television show costs money or frankly anything else. But it is done for profit generally and increasingly schools show a profit from the enterprise.

True, not all schools do show a profit from their sports program. However, most of the schools that spend a LOT on their program do actually show a net profit. TV rights deals are extremely lucrative. What's more without these sports allumni tend to contribute less. As such you have to take into consideration the difference in allumni donations if you didn't give them something to cheer for every year.

Think of all the sweatshirts and baseball caps that universities sell with the university logo on them? You can't sell any where near as many of those without a sports program.

In short, sports is not education for the university... it's a side business.

by karmashock

Sports get almumi excited, bring up school spirit, and get community support/involvement.

Furthermore, if your game is televised the school gets that money. Why do you think such schools are prepared to spend MILLIONS on hiring a good coach? Because they get MILLIONS more in grants, community involvement, and tv rights money.

Sports are not required for higher education but they do help fund schools. As such that football money comes right back into the school to fund expensive programs such as physics and engineering.

As to US schools falling behind, that can't be said of US higher education which still generally head and shoulders over almost anywhere else. If you disagree then examine where the discoveries are made... and where the various geniuses were educated. The US is doing very well in higher education.

Pre college public schools however aren't doing very well. But that's because excellence isn't demanded of students. It's a different educational culture and thus produces different results.

Point: If you want better public high schools then you've got to be prepared to fail and hold back anyone/everyone that doesn't meet the grade... and of course fire incompetent teachers. But between the teachers unions and the various groups that think it's "mean" to give kids that can't read failing grades - have fun with that. High school is thus what you make of it. If you don't care and screw around then public US high schools won't stop you. If you make an effort and put in the extra time then you can be anything.

by w2ktechman

I remember a short time ago about a school district that started grading on a curve, which allowed more people to pass, even if they weren 't up to the national standards. I said WHAT??? What the hell is this?

Later there was a demonstration because the same people were upset because they didnt graduate because they couldnt even reach the lower standards, and they were complaining like little babies. These people do not deserve a diploma. Since when is it appropriate to continue lowering standards because some people cry like children?

But many of these same people like hanging out at 7-11 or other places, not studying at all.
I used to be one of them, but then I decided I had to do something with my life and I had to study like crazy. then soem more, then some more. Finally I received my GED, then more studying to become an IT person, then more to furthen my education. I do not feel sorry for the pathetic that just want to have fun and put nothing or very little forward and expect to be treated just as if they had.

by tig2

I have respected you since I first "met" you. You have just helped me to understand the underlying reason WHY.

People like yourself are proof that it is possible to succeed on the strength of your own intellect fueled by your willingness to do so.

Having been in a similar place myself, I can only applaud. And be grateful that there are still people like yourself out there.

Edit- typo. And smart enough to fix it...

by drowningnotwaving

In the USA you have seemingly had high user-pays-fees for college and university education for a long time.

This phenomenon is only relatively recent in Aust and NZ.

An interesting and immediate result has been the lowering of educational standards and many reported cases of academic "corruption", all in order to ensure that the fee-paying (and in particular the international fee-paying) student is encouraged and enabled to attend and pass.

Personally I'd be happy (in my part of the world, of course!) to reassign some of our taxes to ensuring university education stayed only in the hands of those that qualified and worked hard to get into (and then stay in) their elected course and university.

by tonythetiger

that a lot of the kids don't want to learn anything, but want the piece of paper that says they learned it.

by karmashock

I can't speak to other countries I have no knowledge of, but in the US uni standards have been climbing for years. I base this largely upon the required GPA and SAT scores required to just be considered by most of the universities. True, if you make a "donation" (bribe) of several million (sometimes much more depending on the specific uni) to many universities then they'll wave some of the entrance requirements. However, very very few people can/will do that and so it's not statistically significant.

As to people unqualified being barred from entry, this is a free country... and if some fool with more money then sense wants to waste their money failing out of a school they can't hope to succeed in then the university is typically happy to take that money.

These schools MUST charge for entry because economically it doesn't work out if they don't. The demand for educated people is sky high. That drives up demand at universities which is why they're all packed beyond maximum capacity (at least in california they are, I can't speak to other states). If you didn't charge for them and instead funded it entirely on tax dollars you wouldn't be able to fund enough capacity even if you raised taxes... you'd lose efficency I'd be impressed if you could fund even 60 percent of our current capacity with nothing but tax dollars.

It might lead to economic collapse. As to why the unis are so expensive it's because the professors are highly educated individuals in a climate where highly educated people are GOLD. As such if the unis don't offer a competitive salary they'll work for someone else. Of course various humanties professors might well not have a choice their specific knowledge being in less demand at the moment. But the science professors especially MUST be paid well or they'll walk.

So I guess what I'm saying is that the system is complicated but functioning well all things considered. The sports programs give the schools an extra shot of cash while boosting school spirit... and of course are a lot of fun to watch/go to... everyone wins.

Once you know what is going on and why it's hard to argue against it.

by drowningnotwaving

Given that historically the majority of funding of science has been military / weapons-based, perhaps there is an argument that we have it all a$$-about?

Maybe a bit less on weaponry and a bit more on music ...

by thechas

Yes, there was a time when research for the military and space programs paid for a lot of things in the US.

However, starting in the 1980's, the desires of the consumer sector speed ahead of the technology needs of even the space program.

When the first launches of the space shuttle took place, some consumer electronics had more computer power than the computers on the space shuttle.

A PS3 has more computer power than some super computers.

The military no longer has technologies that are not available to the general consumer. Their equipment might be more rugged. Tuned to a higher degree of accuracy, Even have some redundancy built in. But, it is nearly all based on technology that has been proven in consumer devices.

Right now, the biggest area of technology innovation for military electronics is a concept referred to as COTS. Or, Consumer Off The Shelf. The US military wants all of their electronics to be built with standard commercial parts.

A serious side effect of what has happened to the US electronics industry, and the COTS program is that all the parts for all the fancy electronics our military uses come from southeast Asia.

Doesn't that make you feel more secure.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.....because they see no benefits, apparently aren't capable of considering the benefits others might derive from being involved in organized sports. Moreover, benefit and value is measured in more ways than just dollars. I could articulate what I see those benefits to be, but it would still fall on "deaf eyes". (Previous comment in reply to other answers.)

To answer the gist of your question, however, you'd have to also consider and list what sports actually brings to a university that academics does not. One hundred thousand people might not pay ~$50 for a seat at a debate, but they would for one at a football game; and such a debate might not generate the millions in television revenue like a basketball game would. So any discussion about what collegiate sports "costs" would also have to include what it earns.

by thechas

Max,

I could accept and agree with the premise of your argument "IF" a respectable portion of what college sports brings in to a university ended up being spent on academics. At best, universities use the sports programs as part of a bait and switch campaign with the alumni. The shame is in how hard of a sell job needs to be done to get a donor to switch from funding an overstuffed athletic program to funding academics.

I would even go so far as to say that the glorification of sports in general, and football in particular is at the very root of what is ailing the US.

The pump up the team spirit, take one for the team, winner take all, no blood no foul mentalities have spread way too far into daily life. Be it road rage or the breadth of the current political divide the bad traits of human nature are growing from the fevered sports mentality.

One of my co-workers is by even a sports fan's standards a sports nut. Among other things he coached a youth league football team. He was livid this fall over how hard it was to get the kids to aggressively tackle and block the other team. Combine that attitude with the parents who push a kid that just wants to have fun because dad wants a sports scholarship, and you breed the aggressive resentful culture we are developing.

Overall, I fully agree with the core question at the start of this thread. The US is falling behind the rest of the world in science and technology because we are unwilling to invest enough money in academics, scholarships, and compensation.

Perhaps the real question should not be is too much money going into sports. But, why are we not investing enough money in academics, science and technology?

Chas

by maxwell edison

Is the US is falling behind the rest of the world in science and technology? Somewhat, but it's not as dire as it's made out to be.

Is it because we are unwilling to invest enough money in academics, scholarships, and compensation? Not even close.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"I could accept and agree with the premise of your argument 'IF' a respectable portion of what college sports brings in to a university ended up being spent on academics."[/i]

Before we can consider your suggestion, you have to define what you mean by "a respectable portion", and you have to compare it to the status quo. That is, what portion of college sports revenue IS ALREADY being spent on academics -- including on scholarships to students who otherwise wouldn't and/or couldn't attend college? I don't know the answer, but since you made the suggestion, I assume you have some sort of benchmark. I don't necessarily disagree with your suggestion, but I'm not sure it's not already being done.

Moreover, we have to consider the intangible value sports programs can bring to universities. The University of Michigan, for example, a college that's considered a perennial sports powerhouse, and one that attracts both talent and dollars to its sports programs, undoubtedly attracts all sorts of things that benefit only the academic functions as a result. People just want to be associated with that university because of the stature that is brought, in part, by the athletic programs, even though they have nothing to do with those programs. Someone (student, professor, contributor, etc.) might choose the U of M over Hillsdale, for example, just because of the name recognition. (Even though Hillsdale, arguably, might have a much better academic program.)

by maxwell edison

Total expenditures for education (including higher education) were about 7.9 percent of the gross domestic product in 2003?04. In 1993-94, the percentage of the GDP spent on education was about 7.1 percent. So spending on education has increased about 11 percent over the past 10 years -- more in terms of real dollars.

In 1959, when the USA was, perhaps, the world's leader in science and technology, education spending, as a percentage of GDP, was only 4.7 percent. It's been increasing every year, with the exception of a downturn in the 1970s and early 1980s.

As a percentage of GDP, only two nations spend more on lower education -- those technology and scientific powerhouses, Norway and Luxembourg. And the USA is ranked tenth in overall education spending.

I submit to you that your cause and effect are deriving an incorrect conclusion. There's no question that something "causes" a decline in educational output; however, decreased (or not enough) spending and/or collegiate sports programs is not the cause -- at least not directly. Perhaps those universities that you're concerned about should divert their efforts from social engineering to electrical, mechanical, and chemical engineering.

by absolutely

[i]I would even go so far as to say that the glorification of sports in general, and football in particular is at the very root of what is ailing the US.[/i]

I hadn't actually said that, but I can definitely agree with most of the remainder of your post. The obsession with violence in popular culture is a manifestation of the looter mentality, which completely ignores the source of production.

by absolutely

[i]One hundred thousand people might not pay ~$50 for a seat at a debate, but they would for one at a football game; and such a debate might not generate the millions in television revenue like a basketball game would.[/i]

On the other hand, countless billions of dollars are taken from citizens who earned it, without any such debate. Just a vote, nothing like the old town councils of New England, nor honest analysis of the real reasons for progressive taxation, what it can [i]reasonably[/i] be expected to accomplish, and for whom.

by absolutely

Maybe it's the rhetoric: some politician in New York was whining a couple weeks ago, on behalf of his constituents, that "schools were failing the students". When I was a student, it was [i]the schools[/i] which assigned grades, and the students who [i]received[/i] them. Now, there is a collective mentality of entitlement that prevents the paradigm of personal responsibility for one's own actions from even being publicly discussed. What a steaming pile of BS.

by maxwell edison

There's a cause and effect for everything. (In this case, it may or may not be "specifically" the schools.)

What "causes" some elementary school students to fail while others excel? Parents perhaps? (How about parents take responsibility for their kids?) Peer pressure, perhaps? (How about "choosing" a child's peers?) If you could "predict" which elementary student is most likely to fail based in his home-life, give that kid to someone like me (someone who thinks like me), and he/she will excel beyond anyone's most optimistic projections. It doesn't really have anything to do with the schools -- IF, that is, a parent can make a wise choice of schools, and IF that parent is a positive influence on that child. If a failing family keeps a failing kid in a failing school, how can you expect anything BUT failure? It doesn't matter if you spend $4,000 or $40,000 a year "educating" that kid, he's still gonna' fail. But, for some reason, people (like Chas) continue to suggest MORE FUNDING. That's what's really a pile of B.S.!

At the university level, as I suggested in my earlier message, I believe that the past several decades has seen more emphasis placed on academic subjects OTHER THAN science and technology. I've also seen reports that suggest many college students have to first go into remedial studies to "catch up" on what they didn't learn in high school. I believe that those two things, more than "sports", "causes" the outcome you asked about in your initial message.

There certainly is a "cause and effect"; the debate, I suppose, is accurately identifying what it is. In the case of your initial question, however, I do not believe the "effect" you asked about is "caused" by athletics and/or lack of funding. Not even close.

by drowningnotwaving

I didn't hear/see your politician's chat directly, but the things you are saying don't necesssarily correlate.

I could easily (and somewhat universally, according to some of the information on this thread), suggest that schools are failing the children.

Commenting upon the success or failure of a school, or sections of the schooling system, has no direct correlation upon the need to instill a sense of self-responsibility in the student. They are two separate discussions with a common thread.

{Parameters: I take your discussion (in this particular instance) to be about children - primary school, and the various types of high schools - so up to the age before they go to college or university.}

Examples - these are things that happen in Australia but as I said from some of the posts would evidently be occurring in a lot of places:

* Many schools, by refusing to adhere to strong principles of coursework, assignment, testing and grading, are "failing" our students when they refuse to properly grade them and tell the student they are failing a course! This is absolutely setting false expectations on how people will grade their performance in the real world. If you screw up there are consequences and your school life should be a part of teaching that lesson.

* Many schools, by providing an open curriculum with little (or in some cases no) base standards of any vocational skill whatsoever, are producing graduates who are incapable of effectively operating in a real world environment. Both from a point of the vocational skills (filling in a form, budgeting, whatever) and also from a point of the student not understanding that when they get into a real world environment there will be rules, regulations, procedures, pecking orders, sh'tty things that must be done etc etc. Schools that present an 'ideal' that the individual will be able to choose whatever it is that they wish to do at any point in time, and totally control the environment in which they do it, without having to work for it or up to it, are failing our kids.

* In Australia there is a sense in the education community that every child that wants a place in Universtiy should get a place. Just because. Bzzzzzzzzzzt. Wrong. You get a place if you are good enough. If you're not initially up to it then you work harder for it. You work in jobs that will make your entry easier at a later date. You take community courses to get better. So I could argue that many proponents of the "system" are failing our kids by not setting proper expectations nor showing them that initial failure is not necessarily a path of complete, future doom and gloom.

Does criticism of the school, or the school system, change in any way the need for kids to learn, practise and be encouraged to take responsibility? Not whatsoever.

I'd argue that without strong and immediate criticism of the school system there is a higher likelihood of less children learning to take responsibility for themselves. In which case we verry much have failed in our responsibilit

I could also argue that few things teach the need for work, responsibility, hard graft, that failing is part of learning, learn the basics before you learn the advanced (or any of a few hundred other cliches) - than sport.

by absolutely

I suggest that more local action, and lower expectations from the federal government are in order. They are pretty consistently disappointing, so let's revise our expectations to match, and get more involved in our own backyards.

by maxwell edison

(Disclaimer: These were cut and pasted from a variety of sources, most of which would be discredited by people who deny that these "cause" the "effect" in question; they can't debate the substance, so they discredit the source. Therefore, I provide no specific source. However, you'll never see these kinds of stories in the "main-stream" media. I wonder why? It's not because it's not true, so it must be ________ .)

And these "courses" are just the tip of the iceberg.

Students at Harvard University can take Feminist Biblical Interpretation, a class that will concentrate on "the significance of feminist Hermeneutics for contemporary theological reflection and education for ministry."

At Carnegie Mellon University, students will study Sex and Death. This course will address the question of "whether we need to liberate death now that (maybe) we have figured sex out." (Presumably it will answer the question "Is there sex after death?")

Brown University offers Black Lavender: A study of Black Gay and Lesbian Plays and Dramatic Construction in the American Theatre. The course is described as "an interdisciplinary approach to the study of plays that address the identities and issues of black gay men and lesbians."

Women's Studies students at Bowdoin can take Music and Gender. The main question addressed in this course: "Is Beethoven's ninth symphony a marvel of abstract architecture, culminating in a gender-free paean to human solidarity, or does it model the process of rape?" (Huh?)

The University of Texas offers Race and Sport in African American Life. The class will explore "how sports have been used to justify and promote antiquated, eugenic, and ultimately racist notions of blackness." (And forces hundreds of black athletes to bear the burden of multimillion-dollar salaries for playing baseball, football and basketball.)

At the University of Virginia, students can enroll in Marxism: What Is to be Learned From It? The description declares that Marx's work is the "standard against which all subsequent social thought must be judged" and that "it is worth devoting an entire semester to it." (And here we thought communism was dead and buried everywhere but in Cuba and China.)

Students of Latino-Latin American Studies at Syracuse University will study Gay and Lesbian Caribbean Literature. These students will read "Caribbean poetry and short stories in homosexual literature." (Probably while dancing the Limbo and singing calypso in falsetto voices.)

Georgetown students can enroll in The Bible and Horror. The description states that the Bible "can be a scary book" and that it "often reads more like horror than religious literature." The class will examine the question of "what might religion and horror (or the monstrous) have in common?" (And this is a school run by the allegedly scholarly Jesuit Order? No wonder Clinton studied there.)

Literature students at Cornell University can take Bodies Politic: Queer Theory and Literature of the Body. This course discusses such questions as "How do concepts of perversion and degeneration haunt the idea of the social body?" and "How are individual bodies stigmatized, encoded, and read within the social sphere?" (We give up. How?)

Middlebury College offers Images of Blackness and Whiteness in American Literature in which students will study how American authors in the 20th century "construct images of blackness and whiteness" and examine how "culturally coded images both shape and are shaped by American attitudes about racial identity."

Students at UCLA can enroll in Death, Suicide, and Trauma. Students will study "Definition and taxonomy of death; new permissiveness and taboos related to death; romanticization of death; role of individual in his own demise; modes of death; development of ideas of death through life ? partial death, megadeath; lethally psychological autopsy; death of institutions and cultures." (Well, is there sex after death?)

Bucknell University's sociology students will take Women and Social Inequality. They will explore "recent anthropological, historical, and sociological literature on gender inequality."

"Mail-Order Brides," "Adultery," "Cyberfeminism," "Homosexual Literature," and "Lesbian Pulp Fiction."

Topping this year's Dirty Dozen list is Occidental College in California with a course named after the male genital organ.

Rounding out the top three is a University of California-Los Angeles course called "Queer Musicology" and an Amherst College class called "Taking Marx Seriously."

And making YAF's dishonorable mention list is a course at UC-Berkeley called "Sex Change City: Theorizing History in Genderqueer San Francisco."

YAF spokesman Jason Mattera says what these schools view as avant-garde, breakthrough classes are supplanting traditional scholarship on Western civilization. "We have a soaring tuition problem in this country," he points out. "Tuition rates are soaring past inflation, and these classes gobble up time, money, and energy -- resources that could be used to offset the cost of tuition and teach students about American values, American civics, American history."

One particular school has been a perennial among the Dirty Dozen, Mattera points out. "Occidental College seems to make the list twice almost every year," he says. "They have a class called 'The Phallus,' and they offer another class called 'Blackness.'"

The latter course "elaborates on a 'new blackness,' 'critical blackness,' 'post-blackness,' and an 'unforgivable blackness,' which all combine to create a feminist 'new black man,'" the young conservatism advocate explains. "Now, I don't know what a feminist 'new black man' is," Mattera says, "but it doesn't sound like something that I'd ever want to be."

Other college classes making YAF's 2006-2007 Dirty Dozen list include Mount Holyoke College's "Whiteness: the Other Side of Racism"; the University of Washington's "Border Crossings, Borderlands: Transnational Feminist Perspectives on Immigration"; Swarthmore's "Nonviolent Responses to Terrorism"; and the University of Michigan's "Native American Feminisms."

Occidental College?s The Phallus covers a broad study on the relation ?between the phallus and the penis, the meaning of the phallus, phallologocentrism, the lesbian phallus, the Jewish phallus, the Latino phallus, and the relation of the phallus and fetishism.?

Queer Musicology at the University of California-Los Angeles explores how ?sexual difference and complex gender identities in music and among musicians have incited productive consternation? during the 1990s. Music under consideration includes works by Schubert and Holly Near, Britten and Cole Porter, and Pussy Tourette.

Amherst College in Massachusetts offers Taking Marx Seriously: ?Should Marx be given another chance?? Students in this class are asked to question if Marxism still has ?credibility,? while also inquiring if societies can gain new insights by ?returning to [Marx?s] texts.? Coming to Marx?s rescue, this course also states that Lenin, Stalin, and Pol Pot misapplied the concepts of Marxism.

Students enrolled in the University of Pennsylvania?s Adultery Novel read a series of 19th and 20th century works about ?adultery? and watch ?several adultery films.? Students apply ?various critical approaches in order to place adultery into its aesthetic, social and cultural context, including: sociological descriptions of modernity, Marxist examinations of family as a social and economic institution? and ?feminist work on the construction of gender.?

Occidental College?making the list twice for the second year in a row?offers Blackness, which elaborates on a ?new blackness,? ?critical blackness,? ?post-blackness,? and an ?unforgivable blackness,? which all combine to create a ?feminist New Black Man.?
Border Crossings, Borderlands: Transnational Feminist Perspectives on Immigration is University of Washington?s way of exploring the immigration debate. The class allegedly unearths what is ?highlighted and concealed in contemporary public debates about U.S. immigration? policy.
Whiteness:

The Other Side of Racism is Mount Holyoke College?s attempt to analyze race. The class seeks to spark thought on: ?What is whiteness?? ?How is it related to racism?? ?What are the legal frameworks of whiteness?? ?How is whiteness enacted in everyday practice?? And how does whiteness impact the ?lives of whites and people of color?

Native American Feminisms at the University of Michigan looks at the development of ?Native feminist thought? and its ?relationship both to Native land-based struggles and non-Native feminist movements.?

Johns Hopkins University offers Mail Order Brides: Understanding the Philippines in Southeast Asian Context, which is a supposedly deep look into Filipino kinship and gender.

Cornell University?s Cyberfeminism investigates ?the emergence of cyberfeminism in theory and art in the context of feminism/post feminism and the accelerated technological developments of the last thirty years of the twentieth century.?

Duke University?s American Dreams/American Realities course seeks to unearth ?such myths as ?rags to riches,? ?beacon to the world,? and the ?frontier,? in defining the American character.?

Swarthmore College?s Nonviolent Responses to Terrorism ?deconstruct[s] terrorism? and ?build[s] on promising nonviolent procedures to combat today?s terrorism.? The ?non-violent? struggle Blacks pursued in the 1960s is outlined as a mode for tackling today?s terrorism.

Dishonorable Mentions

UC-Berkeley?s Sex Change City: Theorizing History in Genderqueer San Francisco explores ?implications of U.S. imperialism and colonization for the construction of gender in 19th-century San Francisco?s multicultural, multiracial, and multiethnic? community. The course also covers ?contemporary transgender, queer, genderqueer, and post-queer cultural production and politics? and ?the regulation of gender-variant practices in public space by San Francisco?s Anglo-European elites.?

Cornell University?s Sex, Rugs, Salt, & Coal asks students to ponder the questions: Why are ?oriental? rugs collector?s items? How did we come to keep salt shakers on our dinner tables? When did coal start replacing wood as a fuel source?

Hollins University?s Drag: Theories of Transgenderism and Performance analyzes historical, theoretical, and autobiographical perspectives on drag, including transgenderism and performance in non-Western cultures.

University of Colorado-Boulder?s Introduction to Lesbian, Bisexual, and Gay Literature introduces some of the forms, concerns, and genres of contemporary lesbian, bisexual, and gay writing in English.

Swarthmore College?s Peace Study in Action partners students with a local ?peace? organization ?to study its mode of action and develop a document or brief that brings useful peace research to the service of the organization.?

Swarthmore College?s Renaissance Sexualities explores the homoerotic, chastity and friendship, marriage, adultery, and incest.
Oberlin College?s first-year seminar, She Works Hard for the Money: Women, Work and the Persistence of Inequality, ?tackles? price differences, occupational segregation, comparable worth, and other factors that supposedly uncover institutional discrimination against women.

Hollins University?s Lesbian Pulp Fiction examines ?a literary genre that critics once deemed ?trash? and moralists commonly found ?scandalous,? but that formed a crucial part in the burgeoning canon of queer literature.?

Yale University Sociology of Heterosexuality ? This course begins with the assumption that heterosexuality is socially produced and reproduced. Examination of heterosexuality as it is produced through a binary gender system; through structures such as law, religion, and psychiatry; through texts such as television, fiction, magazines, and movies; and through rituals such as weddings.

UC-Santa Barbara Feminist Theories of Science and Feminist Scientists ? Exploration of feminist analyses and critiques of science in social, historical, and political contexts. How does science construct gender? How and why are women excluded from scientific discourses and practices? How have women transformed science, and what is "feminist science?"

UCLA Cultural History of Rap ? Introduction to development of rap music and allied forms, with emphasis on musical and verbal qualities, philosophical and political ideologies, gender representation, and influences on cinema and popular culture.

Duke University Girl Culture ? Black-belted heroines, Powerpuff Girls, goddesses, teenage fairies, and witches dominate popular culture. All-female bands storm the charts and underground music scene. Riot grrls, FaT GiRLs, and Cybergrrls "don?t wanna assimilate," and their alternative zine cultures may be changing the world for real. This is a course about the exploding dimensions of girls? cultures. About girliness from the 19th century to now in the United States. About good girls and bad girls and how these labels relate to race, ethnicity, sexuality, and economic class. About femininity and power and whether we can have both. About dolls, dress-up, slumber parties, and makeovers and whether they always restrict girls and their bodies to predetermined gender roles or if they can provide spaces of freedom and experimentation. About girlhood as a possible utopian site for imagining altogether otherworlds and as a powerful political and cultural site for taking over this one. We will study theories of the female body as a place where definitions of femininity are established and questioned. We will read about body image, adolescent sexuality, advertising, and schools. And we will use feminist theory, philosophy, cultural studies, history, sociology, and psychology to study: fiction and non-fiction written by girls and for girls, zines, websites, visual art, mainstream and independent films, television series, and cartoons.

University of Michigan How to be Gay: Male Homosexuality and Initiation ? Just because you happen to be a gay man doesn?t mean that you don?t have to learn how to become one. ? This course will examine the general topic of the role that initiation plays in the formation of gay identity. We will approach it from three angles: (1) as a sub-cultural practice?subtle, complex, and difficult to theorize?which a small but significant body of work in queer studies has begun to explore; (2) as a theme in gay male writing; (3) as a class project, since the course itself will constitute an experiment in the very process of initiation that it hopes to understand.

Antioch College Cuba: An Experiment in Human Equality ? In January 1959, a revolutionary government came to power in Cuba. Launched by Fidel Castro, this revolution overthrew a three-decade tyrannical government. Since that time, Cuba has been a target, an icon, a set of images in the popular mind in the U.S. The experiment in human equality undertaken by Castro and generations of followers and the international response to this experiment form the basis for this introductory level course.

UC-Santa Cruz Music of the Grateful Dead ? In-depth exploration of the music of the Grateful Dead. Contextual study of the sociology and history of the late 1960s psychedelic movement supplies background for study of the music as the band evolved through time.

Middlebury College Reading Fairy Tales Today ? This class will take a closer look at the genre of the fairy tale and will examine the special fascination that fairy tales have exerted over a variety of cultures. A broad variety of approaches to reading texts (ranging from socio-historical approaches to feminism, psychoanalysis, Marxism and structuralism) will help us identify the "magic" elements in fairy tales. We will map the "landscape of fairy tales" beyond the rather restricted, traditional understanding evoked by the Brother Grimms? collection.

Vassar College Women and the Culture of Nature: Feminist Environmentalism ? This course is an introduction to feminist environmentalism as a political movement and an emerging critical field. We explore the ways women have shaped the meaning of nature as naturalists, gardeners, tourists, artists, scholars and activists. We also explore a range of feminist theoretical approaches to the environment and to environmental crisis, such as critical ecofeminism, feminist movements to end environmental racism, and Marxist-feminist critiques of capitalist development.

Oberlin College Education in the Black Community ? The philosophy of a Ghetto Scholar is the sole focus of this course. This highly creative and very original philosophy centers on a Ghetto Scholar?s use of education to pursue the concept of GGG (the greatest good, for the greatest number, for the greatest period). Students are required to think imaginatively, analytically, and independently as they examine critical issues facing black and other oppressed peoples. Education is essential to the attainment of a world that is liberated, peaceful, and humane.

Cornell University Democratizing Society: Participation, Action, and Research ? This course poses an alternative to distanced, "objectivist" social science by reviewing some of the many numerous approaches to socially engaged research. Among the approaches discussed are those centering on the pedagogy of liberation, feminism, the industrial democracy movement, and "Southern" participatory action research, action science, and participatory evaluation.

University of Pennsylvania Feminist Critique of Christianity ? An overview of the past decade of feminist scholarship about Christian theology and institutions. Biblical analysis, historical interpretation and alternative theologies will be considered, and the "post Christian" view presented. Authors read include Rosemary Radford Ruether, Phyliss Trible, and Mary Daly.

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
and on it goes......

by absolutely

irrelevant in discussion of how public money is spent.

As long as they are able to foot their bills let them study what they will.

by maxwell edison

Let's see, included on the list are, The University of Michigan, The University of Colorado, The University of Texas, The University of Virginia, UCLA, The University of Pennsylvania, UC-Santa Barbara, and UC-Santa Cruz -- all public universities. You "choose", however, to see only the private colleges -- and you suggest (by your lack of comment) that they don't have an effect the outcome you asked about in this thread. Besides, they DO receive federal dollars in the form of grants, loans, and GI Bill money, as well as from other sources. (Do an Internet search with the keywords [i] Duke University federal grant[/i] or [i]Harvard federal grant[/i] or any combination of those "private" schools that, as you suggested, are "privately" funded.)

I suspect the real reason you deny this reality is that it doesn't prove your premise that sports is to blame for the outcome you cited. These examples are all but a drop in the bucket of a culture that permeates our universities, both public and private -- all of which are "educating" the business, technology, scientific, and political leaders of tomorrow.

You're wrong in your "sports" suggestion, I've presented a viable argument against it, I've presented a valid alternative argument, but you deny this reality. I suppose this is yet another example of you starting with your desired end conclusion, and you working backwards finding reasons to support it and dismissing reasons that don't support it.

by dr dij

(except those who see govt control of our minds and govt control of our money as good)

is the libertarian solution

privatize schools, then parents have control over what and where money is spent on.

a good start would be vouchers. we don't have the govt build shoe factories because some can't afford shoes. Instead we give them money to buy the shoes

by absolutely

Coupled with our consumption in comparison to other nations, I contend that it is the most dire threat to the nation, by a landslide.

by mr.wiz

In many respects this is a losing battle. Where I live the University just hired a new head football coach to the tune of $4 million a year. Our states' K-12 schools are rated in the bottom 5 of 50 (somewhere between 45 & 49). Thank goodness for Mississippi!

by maxwell edison

.....the University of Alabama decided to pay its football coach $4 million a year, or are there other reasons?

by mr.wiz

They say that the coach's salary doesn't come from the state, only from sports activities. The state itself has one of the lowest funding rates in the country and it's difficult to get the lawmakers to put any more money into education. Too many vested interests that don't want any more taxes? Who knows? Anyway, it just shows that the priorities are a bit backward.

by maxwell edison

You are correct in stating that the coach's salary does not come from state tax dollars, but rather from the athletic department's revenue generated by concessions and ticket sales. Therefore, one could surmise, that those dollars would never find their way into the public coffers anyway. But what you are not considering is what such an arrangement might bring to the state, even though the state has no investment in such a return.

The University of Alabama, for example, has a vested interest in making its university as attractive as possible, not only to Alabama residents who might attend college elsewhere, but also to nonresidents who are considering spending their education dollars in that state. Upwards of twenty five percent of the university's students are nonresidents, and as such they're paying a higher nonresident tuition. They (and their families) spend money in the state, thereby generating tax revenues. If they could increase their nonresident enrollment by only one or two percent, that might mean millions of additional dollars for the state of Alabama that they otherwise would not have seen.

That football stadium holds about 90,000 people on a good day, many of whom come from outside the state; and the difference to the state of Alabama (in terms of revenue generated) between filling the stadium to capacity versus one that's only half-full can be measured in the millions of dollars per week. I might guess that the difference between 50,000 people and 90,000 people in those seats might easily exceed the $4 million paid to the coach -- each and every week of the football season.

You're looking at it the wrong way, as oftentimes many people do when the "appearance" of something might generate an emotional response instead of a realistic one.

While the state has absolutely no investment in the $4 million a year salary of that coach, his presence and talent could provide a return in the tens of millions to the state. What the state does with the money that otherwise wouldn't have been generated is up to your state legislature. Perhaps they can figure out a way to apply it to your education system in such a way to produce better results.

Nonetheless, they're in a position of having absolutely nothing to lose and everything to gain. What could possibly be wrong with that?

by mr.wiz

I honestly don't have a problem with the new coach. I understand that his presence will bring in a tremendous amount of revenue for the state.

Its just that its a distraction from the real issue of providing and paying for a quality K-12 educational system. That is the issue before the state legislators (or it should be).

Granted, it's much easier to get peoples attention with sports than it is with school. I know that the state has lost several large manufacturers because of the lack of a properly educated population. Education is also one of the best beginning steps in eradicating poverty.

by maxwell edison

Why don't your messages articulate the REAL benefit, and downplay the "distraction"? The "distraction" argument is simply not true. Why advance it?

http://www.tidesports.com/article/20070122/NEWS/701220331/1011

[i]"35,000 came out for the 2005 opening game ..... Will all previous records for A-Day attendance be shattered with a 92,000-plus turnout for a game that will, for the first time, unveil Nick Saban?s University of Alabama football team?"[/i]

That's a difference of 57,000 people -- FOR ONE GAME -- who otherwise would not have spent those dollars. How much of a windfall will the state realize for an investment of zero dollars? Whatever the answer is, that's a pretty damn good deal.

by maxwell edison

Not only will Nick Saban's presence and talent generate windfall profits for the state of Alabama, but he will also, personally, regularly visit those schools of which you speak, and do whatever he can to help motivate and encourage those kids to get their education. And a lot of them will listen. Moreover, look for new charities and causes that will be born from his efforts and contributions.

Why would I make such a bet? Because people like him always do things like that as a way of giving back to the community.

by Former member

fat enough as it is. Take sports out of schools and they will just get fatter.

by mr.wiz

Only time will tell the true impact of Nick Saban in Alabama. The other side of it is the legislators in Montgomery who wanted "hearings and investigations" over the hiring. Instead of focusing on the real problems of education. UA and Nick Saban aren't the cause of the education problems in Alabama, the voters and the legislators are. :)

by drowningnotwaving

most of the kids just want the degree. God, that's how I justified spending more time in the bar and the gym than on a computer. My average mark in the last semester was 52% over 7 subjects in a computing science degree (that's becuase I have a job offer letter in my pocket with IBM - didn't need to give a hoot. Good attitude? Probably not. Good fun? Best year of my life!).

I think that when campuses drop their academic standard to ensure that (particularly overseas) students keep on passing and keep on paying then we've missed the point of what the higher education system has as its objectives.

In our world the two repeated manifestations have been different marking standards and turning blind eyes to blatant copying.

I know a lot of people don't want their dollars spent (and also that this is different in different countries). But if you accept that there are SOME things that are worth spending tax dollars on, I consider higher education to be the fundamental "R&D" of society. Of all tax expenditure, I see nothing with as high a potential return and benefit to all of us in the future. I am happy to spend my tax money on it but I do demand that we see high standards maintained both in the entry standard to get in there and what is expected throughout the course to stay there.

But it's just a discussion, what we do over here means nothing in real terms to you over there and vice versa. I appreciate your comments.

by tonythetiger

that one goes to school to learn something that one did not already know. I refuse to pay good money to "learn" something I already know, just to get a paper.

by drowningnotwaving

I very recently saw a study (which I tried to find just now on the web to provide a reference) that said:

In western countries, somewhat less than 15% of graduates actually work in the field that they studied.

Does that mean we could cut our higher education budget by 85% and get the same result?

Nup.

When I hire I look for graduates but more so to see that they have the the get-up-and-go and the tenacity to see it through. I'm not usually that interested in the discipline of their degree. (I hire for marketing and sales positions not usually involved in technical positions).

That and the size of their breasts ARRGGGHHH NOOO never that.

by absolutely

Aren't federal grants to private colleges very specific, though? For example, Stanford's research into mapping a single species' genome might be funded by the federal government, but not an unconditional gift to the biology department. Maybe I'm wrong. If so, I concede that point.

Also, there were certainly [i]some[/i] public schools. Only the private ones were intended by my "irrelevant" comment, not the public ones.

[i]I suspect the real reason you deny this reality is that it doesn't prove your premise that sports is to blame for the outcome you cited. These examples are all but a drop in the bucket of a culture that permeates our universities, both public and private -- all of which are "educating" the business, technology, scientific, and political leaders of tomorrow.

You're wrong in your "sports" suggestion, I've presented a viable argument against it, I've presented a valid alternative argument, but you deny this reality. I suppose this is yet another example of you starting with your desired end conclusion, and you working backwards finding reasons to support it and dismissing reasons that don't support it.[/i]

My understanding of statistical analysis is enough to know what a difficult undertaking it would be to analyze spending ratios, academic performance, and enough other variables to substantially reduce the risk of misidentifying spurious correlation as causality. My [i]suggestion[/i], as you correctly call it, was just that, and based only on my observation, stated clearly enough from the outset, that in those industrial countries with better science & math students, sports are less central to the national culture.

This time, I just wanted to pose a question. You'll probably get me next time, though.

:p

by tonythetiger

[i]In western countries, somewhat less than 15% of graduates actually work in the field that they studied.[/i]

They take what they want, not necessarily what's in demand.

[i]When I hire I look for graduates but more so to see that they have the the get-up-and-go and the tenacity to see it through.[/i]

I fully agree with that. If you have work ethic, you'll get the rest! Unfortunately, that's not something that can be learned from a book.

by thechas

I would much rather attend a diversity training session than watch football, sports in general, or reality TV.

On my list of things that I "might" prefer watching football to:

I might prefer to watch football rather than:

Get a root canal.

Be a patient in a trauma ward.

Have major surgery.

Things that "ARE" more fun than watching football:

Having a colonoscopy.

8 hours of breaking rocks.

Watching paint dry.

Shoveling snow.

Installing Windows 98 on a 486.

Running laps.

Cleaning the basement and garage.

Chas

by absolutely

Nobody ever learned anything they didn't already know from a "sensitivity" class, nor has anybody been persuaded to start doing the right thing because of one. They are without doubt a waste of [i]everybody's[/i] time!

This discussion is closed to new replies.