Discussion Locked

Constitutional Rights vs Voice of the People

0 helpful
200 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

200 replies

by smartacew0lf

many strikes at the American people's liberty. Where it was that we had a choice in it I do not recall. I do recall our current president's promise to repeal it or at very least to pull it back some. More lies. His evident enthusiasm (judging by the amount of time it took him to affirm his position with actions rather than words) lends evidence he knew it to be a lie when broadcasting it in his pre-election speeches.

by hal 9000

Question:= How do you know when a Politician is telling a lie?

Answer:- You can see their lips moving.

Now be honest it doesn't matter who won what they honestly where never in a position to do anything at all. ;)

Col

by charliespencer

the jingoisticly named PATRIOT act was a knee-jerk over reaction by a Congress more concerned with appearing to make this country more secure than actually accomplishing doing so. Ditto its inflammatorily named 'Homeland' Security dept. offspring, a word that rings of the Soviet era or Nazi Germany. What was the matter with the word 'Domestic'?

End of rant. These are purely unsupportable personal opinions; there's almost no chance I'll alter them.

by ansugisalas

It is not illegal.
For reals.

However, since we don't need them, we have not bothered to make it easy or quick nor has there been a feeling that advertisements for guns is anything else than appalling.

Now, granted, you have a big crime problem, you have a horribly backfiring war on drugs and a horribly backfiring neglected public school system, and a horribly backfiring social inequality problem.
So, yeah, in some areas people might actually need handguns to protect themselves from Meth Zombies, and I think that's a valid concern.

What I have a problem with is the NRA stance that guns are somehow a necessary or sufficient criterion for personal safety. They are neither, they can be one way, but they are only a poor treatment for the symptom, and the whole debate is a distraction from the root causes.

Just fix the root causes already. Trash the prison industry, get rid of the drug war, splash out on public school reform (as you probably know, the world's best school system is 100,0% publicly funded).

by delbertpgh

SAKO. I owned two of them. They were beautifully styled, flawlessly engineered, and accurate. Astonishingly accurate. Could group five shots in less than an inch at 100 yards with Norma ammunition. Alas, I sold them to pay off two obstetricians. I own no guns now. When I take up target shooting again, some day, it'll be with a Finnish firearm.

by delbertpgh

The NRA talks about assault rifles as though they are useful for home defense. They talk about all guns as though their primary justification is defense of the home. They are dishonest.

If you're going to defend your home, you need something that is handy indoors. You need something reliable that won't malfunction, and something you can operate when you're scared to death. You don't want bullets that will travel through three walls and wound your neighbor, sleeping in the next house. You want a revolver, preferably a .38 special. That was the standard police equipment across America for 70 years, and it did very well. It has six rounds, and all you have to do is pull the trigger to get the next one, a feat probably within the remaining skills of a panic-stricken homeowner. There are no jams, no safety, and if there is a misfire, you just pull the trigger again. It takes a simple, deliberate action to fire, and accidental firings from dropping the weapon or picking it up wrong are impossible. You don't need 15 rounds, or magnum calibers, to do the job; even meth zombies tend to go down with the first hit. It's pretty easy to get off a second quickly, if your zombie needs an extra flourish.

Possibly, if you're defending a farm and you have to investigate something in the barn, a shotgun is desirable. But once you go through a doorway, the longer barrel can be grabbed; and once you're inside, walking through narrow spaces, the long arm becomes a problem to bring to action. The revolver is best, for the amateur without professional combat training.

AR-15s are useful for reliving your days as a young fella in the army, trying to recapture the spirit you had when you and all your friends weighed so much less. And, in case the U.N. black helicopters come swooping in stocked with European liberals who want to burn your bible and make you gay-marry your dog, why, that's when you'd want to grab your AR-15 and defend your way of life. Because assault-style weapons are military weapons, made for fighting military formations, not for target work or hunting or home defense. They're ideal for shooting National Guardsmen, and not much else.

The gun industry likes them because they are so much more profitable, per unit, than conventional rifles and shotguns. Crackpot gun lovers like them because they play into a military-style apocalypse vision, and crackpots love weird conspiracy-powered end-of-civilization set piece drama. And the NRA likes them for both of those reasons, for keeping the money flowing and the excitement high.

by nicknielsen

The vast majority of people I met in my 24 years in the USAF, from Kuwait to California, from Nairobi to Norway, only wanted to be seen–and treated–as people. Americans have chosen to focus on the myriad minor differences rather than that major similarity.

Why? The American political class thrives on conflict. The media thrives on conflict. The oligarchy considers conflict a great distractor from what they are trying to do for themselves (and to the country).

To feed that conflict, Americans are indoctrinated long and intensely in how different "they" are from "us". The media ignores the real issues and focuses on inconsequential crap. Churches contravene their chosen religious writings and preach hate. Hypocrisy abounds and is ignored. Ignorance becomes a way of life. And the media also serves as the positive feedback loop, to the point that most Americans never learn that the differences between "them" and "us" are more cosmetic than real.

I don't know what it will take to break out of the cycle, but I do know that when it happens, the results will be terrifying to those in power. (i.e., those with the money).

by maxwell edison

It presupposes there always is - and always should be - middle ground between differing opinions, different desired outcomes, different values, and so on.

The notion of compromise being applied to every disagreement [b]IS NOT[/b] the solution, it's the friggin' problem. It touches on what Ronald Reagan referred to when he suggested that government was not the solution, it was the problem.

We cannot possibly find compromise for all our differences; and American government [b]WAS NOT[/b] created to be the arbiter of compromise, but rather the protector of liberty. We should therefore find a way to accommodate the differences and live with them. And that, my friend, is an element of liberty, something I've noticed that only I will dare to advance in these threads.

I'm sick of the people beating the drums of compromise when the sound of liberty is much sweeter. And the only ones who find the sounds of liberty as sour notes, are the very ones who wish to impose their will on others - and both sides do it.

Start with the premise of liberty and accommodation - the lowest common denominator, if you will - work your way up from there, and the solution to almost any issue is obvious. Moreover, it's the foundation of our country. Try to build something onto a foundation that wasn't designed to support it, and it's sure to crumble.

Geesh!

by charliespencer

I disagree with your use of words and phrases like 'always', 'every disagreement', and other definitives. Indeed, in themselves they deny the possibility of compromise.

There are times when compromise is appropriate, and times when it is not. If both sides agree on 90% of an issue, I view accepting that much as more producting than both sides each repeatedly insisting on 100% of what they want and getting nothing over and over.

No, we can't find compromise on ALL our disagreements, and that isn't what government is for. But lately our elected representatives refuse to seek compromise even on those disagreements that are and should be part of their jobs.

"We should therefore find a way to accommodate the differences and live with them."

Liberty and compromise don't have to be in opposition. We've agreed that the liberty to yell 'Fire' ends in a crowded theater. Can I assume you agree that one person's liberty to swing his fists ends at the next person's nose? How is 'accomodating the differences' not compromising?

by maxwell edison

You start by saying, [i]"Where we disagree[/i]", and you then, pretty much, dismiss and/or disagree with everything I said.

Why don't you try something different? Try to point out where we do agree, and leave the disagreements for later.

by aidemzo_adanac

I think many, if not most Americans (and Canadians), actually feel more centered than they act. I'm sure that many people sit closer to the middle but speak further to the left or right in order to associate their beliefs with a like minded collective.

So the issue isn't actually both sides backing off and sacrificing their true beliefs in order to advance an agenda, I see it as two side realizing that they aren't so extremely different after all and agreeing to seek a common, middle ground where both are appeased.

The sense that it must be one way or another is where I see fault. I know that you don't always agree with the right or the left, though you clearly lean more toward the right, as do I. However, I have found that not all of your views are far right extremist views, and you support preservation of the country's natural beauty and wildlife, which is more left leaning than right.

Everyone sees common ground without sacrifice, that ground needs to be allowed a voice without condemning it due to not being a political extreme.

It's not compromise it is simply common ground that needs to be found.

Perhaps the US won't break out into war, but never say never; if we were that astute, the world would be a much better place.

One issue I see is that you fall back to the most basic, primitive foundations and want to build from there. While that would appear ideal, it is not realistic from my perspective.

It's the same sensibility as living off the grid and surviving on the fat of the land, a fresh start, per se'. Sure, it technically can be done, by individuals, but I don't see it not working as a collective. If so, who would implement it and under who's understanding of the true foundations of the nation; yes, of course that definition will differ greatly too.

We don't get many do overs in life, I think 200 years of national history and politics would not allow it in this case.

by aidemzo_adanac

Finding middle ground is not compromise. Many on the left and right share similar opinions...thus middle ground. When that middle ground is focused on, ignoring the two extremes to either side, effective action is generally found. When two side are s extremely opposed as America's left and right, there's no hope for ANY progress by ANY side as they will constantly work to revers the other when in power. It's like a tug o war where no side can hold the other long enough for the whistle to blow.

by charliespencer

"To feed that conflict, Americans are indoctrinated long and intensely in how different "they" are from "us"."

We don't have the Soviet Union available as a convenient national enemy any more. We also have new forms of media accessible around the clock that have to create and feed an audience or die. With no major external antagonists, the politicians, pundits, and single-issue supporters are left to create internal divisions, making canyons out of hairline cracks.

by ansugisalas

Clash of civilizations.
The question: Now that the Soviets are gone, how can we keep existing?

The answer: create a conflict with Islam.

by charliespencer

Iraq, Iran, and Al Qaeda did their best to offer conflict-seekers with a convenient target. I don't know if even their actions would have been sufficient if oil wasn't involved. Similar opportunities to compete with Islam exist outside the oil-producing regions, but they rarely get our attention.

by charliespencer

Then we agree on the following:

"... It touches on what Ronald Reagan referred to when he suggested that government was not the solution, it was the problem.

We cannot possibly find compromise for all our differences; and American government WAS NOT created to be the arbiter of compromise, but rather the protector of liberty. We should therefore find a way to accommodate the differences and live with them. And that, my friend, is an element of liberty, ...

the only ones who find the sounds of liberty as sour notes, are the very ones who wish to impose their will on others - and both sides do it.

Start with the premise of liberty and accommodation - the lowest common denominator, if you will - work your way up from there, and the solution to almost any issue is obvious. Moreover, it's the foundation of our country. Try to build something onto a foundation that wasn't designed to support it, and it's sure to crumble."

That looks like 70% or 80%, a good starting point to my mind.

by aidemzo_adanac

Finding middle ground? LOL.

It's interesting to read that you agree, there is no advantage to compromise when middle ground is not there to begin with. I think it results in a homogenized society too. Like dinner at Denny's, it's okay and most locations will serve the exact same dinner no matter where because they have set standards that everyone adheres to, whether in Alabama or Washington state. This works because the food, while okay, is also fairly tasteless. By 'manufacturing' bland food, it appeals to all pallets. If something is hot and spicey or tangy it usually doesn't stay on their menu for long, as with most fast food franchises too, stick to the formula.

That said, a common saying that drives me right around the twist is, 'Let's agree to disagree'.

I say NO, I DON'T F'ING AGREE AT ALL!! WHY AGREE TO DISAGREE?

You know very well we have sat in opposition too many times to recount, however that adds the spice to our discussions and makes them more interesting, to me anyway. I don't want someone to agree with me all the time, I don't want to talk with someone I agree with all the time. And yet, while we find we oppose each other's voice in many ways, we have also been able to find middle ground, without either of us compromising or changing our personal beliefs. To me, THAT is debate. We don't have to agree but if we can have healthy debate for long enough, we generally find we agree on just as much, if not more, than we disagree on. Now, music, that's a different story, I think we know we are both like minds in that respect. Even though I work in the metal scene, we share so much common ground that the extremes simply don't exist.

Make any sense?

by maxwell edison

I'll leave it at that, for now, but will be interested in seeing if any others follow your lead. (Maybe I'll later discuss the stuff you didn't include - but I have a few things I need to get done first.)

by charliespencer

The local sheriff was on a radio call-in program the other day. He said for home protection, he prefers a shotgun. Accuracy isn't an issue, and you don't worry as much about rounds going through the walls into the kids' bedrooms. He went with a revolver second, listing many of your reasons. He didn't see much value in rifles or semi-auto handguns for home defense.

I wouldn't go against too many National Guardsmen with an AR-15. We had full-auto M-16s, M-60s, SAWs, and M-203 grenade launchers, and I'm sure the hardware has only improved since I got out a decade ago. You'll have some short-term success, so as long as that's your only goal...

If I was into the end of the world conspiracy stuff, I'd be looking for whatever used the most common ammo. Without that, all you have is an expensive club, and a cumbersome one at that.

by charliespencer

The Centers for Disease Control used to track a variety of statistics regarding death by firearms. Several years ago Congress, under pressure from the usual suspects, forbade them from doing so. I believe allowing them to resume doing so is one of the proposals from VP Biden's study group.

by maxwell edison

I enjoyed it thoroughly. Thank you. I even agree with much of it. I would post a reply specific to your fine rant, but since it wasn't directed at me, I'll resist the urge. I'll wait for another one aimed at me. (I have a great idea for a new twist to the GW/CC thing. Perfect rant material.)

By the way (and you did touch on this), would you confirm (or deny if you disagree) for the other non-Americans who frequent these threads, that there are really two Americas. There's the one they see on their television or computer screens, and then there's the real one - you know, the one you've seen and experienced with your own eyes. I read them describe things and people that I've never seen or experienced.

I realize that I'm just an ignorant country bumpkin who just fell off a turnip truck in the middle of some survivorlists zone who stays glued to FOX News, but you'd think I would have seen at least a smidgen of what they describe, considering all my years here.

by maxwell edison

He's one of my mentors. I've never met the man, mind you, but he's a mentor nonetheless.

I find it interesting that you use a past conservative to discredit some of today's flavor of conservatives - and you're a guy who espouses existing democratic-socialist principles and policies in your own country, and call yourself a conservative.

No wonder people are so confused about titles, names, and descriptions that are being thrown around.

P.S. The Internet is a dangerous thing, in that it gives people like you a false sense of enlightenment; it makes you think you know what you're talking about, when, in fact, in many cases, you're completely clueless.

by aidemzo_adanac

Due an an inferiority complex, it is important to instill the same upon others? Much as someone that is insecure always points out flaws in everyone else.

Perhaps Americans just stand out from the crowd everywhere as being loud and obnoxious because they are trained to see others as inferior and thus have to be louder and prouder than others, to express superiority.

I've seen it many, many times where, Americans accused of being too loud and proud, will retort with 'you wouldn't understand, we feel that way because America IS the best and we have freedoms and rights that we have fought for".

This not only illustrates arrogance and utter ignorance but also implies that the other nation just wouldn't comprehend what it's like to be proud because they have nothing to be proud of.

If you visit the UK, the people are the exact opposite in that they are self deprecating and will laugh at themselves before others. Brits call it being humble, I see it as the same as being comfortable in your own skin. Britain has fought for it's own freedom and rights more times than the US too. People just don't seem to have a need to express superiority, but there is a very strong, quiet and inherent pride in all Brits.

by nicknielsen

[i]No wonder people are so confused about titles, names, and descriptions that are being thrown around. [/i]

That's because those titles, names, and descriptions don't have the same meanings they did 50 years ago. They don't even have the same meanings in California as they do in Iowa, Alabama, Canada, England, or Finland. And today, there are many with the arrogance to assume they are the arbiters of what does and does not fit in those labels and who is and isn't entitled.

"Conservative" is no longer a valid definition for the Republican Party, nor is it a valid definition for the political right. There is nothing conservative about destroying the environment in search of the almighty dollar. There is nothing conservative about dismissing scientific findings outright because you disagree with what they tell you. There is nothing conservative in forcing others to comply with your religious views. There is nothing conservative in condemning others because their opinions differ from yours.

The "conservatives" in today's Republican party are no less radical than any member of the Black Panthers or Weather Underground ever was. They say they are in favor of less intrusive government, fiscal responsibility, and the American worker, but when push comes to shove, it's just the opposite. They want government to regulate who people can love and women's health options. They won't raise taxes to help reduce the deficit, and refuse to consider cutting subsidies for the most profitable corporations in the world. Their anti-union stance and desire to cut social programs are the proof they don't give a flying shot at a rolling doughnut about the average American.

Today's Republican Party has become a perverted shadow of what it was 50 years ago, holding positions closer to those of the John Birch Society or Ku Klux Klan. Were Barry Goldwater alive today, I don't doubt he would repudiate the Republican Party's positions and platform in the harshest words possible.

For centuries, politicians have been considered as liars and hypocrites. Today's Republicans seem determined to become the poster children.

by smartacew0lf

Thank you sir! I agree with most of what you say here. And furthermore, you confirm my suspicions about when the major tide turned. All of that said, your problem is what you perceive the American people to be, due in most part because of what we continue to support within our politics. And this is the CRUX of the matter.

With a government hellbent on business as usual as you describe above, would YOU want to submit YOUR last ditch hope of ever recovering the dream it was designed to be? As for me, not no but HELL NO!

Before proceeding further, allow me to make one thing abundantly clear. There is not a single firearm nor bullet anywhere in or near my home. Hasn't been since before I went and was released from Federal Prison. Nothing to hide here. Just so everything is ON the table and no one gets surprised here, now you know. To many that will automatically mean that anything I have to say about this subject is of no merit. If that is you -meaning anyone reading this- then kiss my a$$ and move on back into your sandhole.

I lived the better portion of my life as an outlaw. So, I am a late bloomer into this subject. Yes, I too rode high on the heels of my forebears comfortable in the lifestyle they fought and died to preserve. Shame on me I know. All I can say is better late than never. No sooner than I took an interest, the landslide began.

The way I see it, our political system is broken. We have what is now either a neo-conservative party (meaning any and everything the term defines) and then on the other end we have a party that chooses to represent the opposite of any and everything the new Republican Party endorses. I'm sure anyone can see the epic failure in that picture. And to either of the two parties, you are either with us or against us. No middle ground. Common sense be damned!

In reality, it would seem that life as we know it has been sold out to the highest bidder by the clowns we have running things in Washington. Who was the highest bidder? Any guesses? You can bet it was one of several corporations. Indeed, a good portion of it was bartered to Halliburton, but it was no single entity. Corporate America seems to have won it's desires.

The fact is, "they" continue to parade a group of clowns before us to vote on, none of which seems to amount to a hill of beans in effecting change. Meanwhile, "they" (there's that word again. More on this later) continue to polarize and divide the American people by their ongoing agenda of making all of us believe you are one or the other. This is all BS and allows them to sink us deeper in the muck they are creating.

We and our way of life are in trouble here. The major trouble we have on the forefront has nothing to do with guns. It has everything to do with us still having them though. I do believe that when the guns owned by the people are removed from the equation, we will likely be doomed to the most oppressive government the world has ever known.

All in all I enjoyed your post Neil. Thank you. The only thing I took personally was the line about more spaces. Kindly note the addition of them. ;) As for the rest of your post, these are all valid points. I can not take them personally as though I were responsible first-hand for them. However, as an American Citizen, I must accept responsibility for them. To sum it up, it would seem that you are as aggravated with this countries' governmental policies as I am myself. When they come for everyones' firearms, I will be holed up with some good friends of mine (mostly members of the various constabulary offices within our government) who own plenty. Better to die standing on your feet than to live on your knees.

We all need your prayers. If you don't believe in God, we still need your good wishes for us. (Belief in God or not, I personally believe in their power as well.) You were with us pre-911. Please remain that way. We are trying to rein it all back in. Please do trust in us and support us through this. Because if we fail, the same will likely come to your shores sooner than later. We had no way of knowing your good will and support for us regarding 911 would be "prostituted" (is that even a word?) the way it was.

Good reading for anyone who desires to learn more of the way our political parties weild or misue their power and influence. Both of these are very timely with regard to this conversation.

Google the following terms. Good Riddance Attention Wh0re and then How Do You Kill Eleven Million People?

And finally, as promised, more on "they". I find my favorite definition for the term -and it most assuredly applies here- from within the old Sam Peckinpah movie, The Wild Bunch. The group had just robbed a train and were dividing the spoils when they realised they had been setup and ended up with a bunch of washers instead of coins. One asked at some point within the conversation, "Who the hell is 'they'?" The reply came from the least of their ranks thusly. "Who the hell is they? Why they's as plain as fancy they! Tied a tin can to your tail! Marched ya right in and right back out again, left you with a hand full of holes, a thumb up your a-- and a big grin to pass the time of day with! That's who they is!" Just a little sad humor there.

Again, thanks Neil. Now we're talking.

edited to provide a way to finish the google terms that wouldn't be censored. Now if you will excuse me, someone claiming to be ATF or something or other is at the door. ;)

by Member 25348569

I was careful to end my piece on a (relatively) conciliatory note, making the point completly that I hold the US government and their servants responsible for most of the more justifiable anti-American feeling that seems to abound at the moment. Hollywood must also shoulder some of the blame for their portrayal of your society.

But I love the country and the only reason that I'm not holidaying in the US these days is that I take my old mum and, at 88, she isn't up to much air travel these days so if we can't drive there, we don't go. One day I'll make it to Colorado! Steak is on the menu.

Jealousy coupled with ignorance accounts for a lot of less justifiable anti-American feeling too. There is plenty of ignorance in the UK these days.

Using the US as a scapegoat for the failings within their society is quite common and totally unjustifiable. Probably.

by ansugisalas

If a liberal policy turns out to cost-efficiently achieve a goal, it may very well become a conservative policy. If it works, that's more important than theory and dogma.
Conservativism is pragmatic, not idealistic.

by maxwell edison

You're an idiot - or a git, if you prefer. (Pragmatic, my a$$)

For those who haven't noticed, "pragmatic" is the new buzz-word for this disingenuous crowd.

by Member 25348569

The tone of your posts is what really confuses we Europeans. I have never, until now, ever contemplated "the best weapon for home protection". OK, I don't live in a particularly bad part of London but there are some pretty "iffy" areas a few miles away. I have decided to get myself a recording of a pump-action shotgun being cocked followed by a creepy satanic laugh. That should do it. But on the down-side, it won't work against zombies.

I do know some peope who tell me they have a baseball bat under the bed but all I can ask when they say that is "Why don't you have a cricket bat? What's wrong with an indigenous sport? It's not that you're ever going to have to use it." Although, if you do, a proper stroke with a cricket bat takes a lot more skill. Either are good against zombies.

I checked up and it seems that around 9% of Brits, most of whom are female, live alone or have been burgled before, "don't feel safe in their own home" and a quarter of householders keep a baseball bat, heavy flashlight or walking stick "just in case". Although most keep it by their front door which strikes me a a pretty dumb thing to do. It's reckoned that over 90% of baseball bat sales in the UK are for protection against intruders. Or zombies.

by slayer_

First you would have to head shot them hard enough to destroy their brains.
And that means you have to get close, and your probably going to get covered in blood, and then infected yourself.

by charliespencer

Personally, I don't own a firearm and can't see circumstances under which I would. I don't go places where I think one may be necessary, and I won't live where I think the possibility of my home being broken into is above average.

I've had one home broken into in 31 years, and no one was home at the time. I suspect most criminals target unoccupied homes; if I was in that line of work, I certainly would.

I have no objections to others owning a firearm for home defense. The sheriff's point was if that's your concern, get a weapon suited to the task. He thought an automatic rifle was a poor choice.

by aidemzo_adanac

cowboys and gun-toting clowns who defend the Constitution written for an 18th century society.

Clearly they generally are right wing but that still doesn't state my position or beliefs. I actually lean a lot farther right than you would think.

Point is, there are MANY right wing supporters who feel gun laws need to be refined and many right wing supporters who are not cowboys and gun-toting clowns who defend the Constitution written for an 18th century society.

I was speaking of a certain, very extreme segment of the right wing. I am also against left wing radicals who protest for the sake of protest without knowing the true objectives behind a given project.

Your conclusion is just an incorrect assumption. When I say "cowboys and gun-toting clowns who defend the Constitution written for an 18th century society", you automatically think I oppose Republicans, but that comment doesn't include most republicans at all.

by ansugisalas

when actual arguments run out... :p ;)
You didn't have to admit to losing, Max. You could've just pretended not to notice my post :^0

by Member 25348569

What did Iraq do to deserve what they got? Other than have the wrong dictator in the wrong place at the wrong time. Oh, and have some oil.

What did Iran do? There they were, minding their own business and the next thing they know is the CIA have executed their first successful regime-change (with help from the UK). The Iranians finally got rid of the Shah some twenty five years later, Why have they any reason to love the US and the UK? Why are they on your list? Oh, of course, they have oil.

Al Qaeda, at least the Osama bin Laden bit, was a CIA creation to fight the Russians in Afghanistan. Al Qaeda now is an loose-knit, very loose-knit, band of Islamists who know that calling themselelves 'Al Qaeda' is going to put the frighteners on the West.

Your government - and mine - require scapegoats to allow them to push this "War on Terror" crap through. The Middle Easter government just loved Al Qaeda because they used them, too, to crack down on demonstrations and swindle money out of the US. Mubarak and Gadhaffi? That was nice company for George W Bush. And GWB, of course, was a more successful recruiter for Islamic terrorism than it's possible to imagine.

by maxwell edison

You are a dishonest and disingenuous supporter of a socialist-democratic society, principles, and government which forces it on people. You can call yourself an avocado, for all I care, as rational for supporting it. You're fooling no one - except maybe yourself. And you're bringing your crap to my shores, pushing your values on America - the very thing America is being criticized for doing in other places. So add hypocrite to the things that describe you - and p****, of course.

by charliespencer

Iran's mistake was invading Kuwait, unfortunately drawing US attention via our 'friends' in Saudi Arabia.

Iraq's mistake wasn't overthrowing the Shah, but kidnapping US embassy personnel during the revolution.

For those looking for an excuse to demonize someone, those actions were sufficient. But yes, in both cases our government wouldn't have cared for very long if oil wasn't involved, especially after the hostages were released. I believe we wouldn't care about Israel if it wasn't in the middle of Oilvania. While we're at it, I've never understood why tiny harmless communist Cuba isn't considered an acceptable trade partner but huge China is. Surely it isn't just about the trade dollars, is it? Nah...

Way off-topic rant - I hold the Ayatollah Khomeini personally responsible for the rise of 24-hour news networks. When the US embassy personnel were being held, US television networks began running five-minute situation updates at 11:30, after the local news but before Carson and other late-night fare. These expanded to 30 minutes, and eventually begat 24-hour CNN. There wasn't enough 'news' to fill even the one network's round-the-clock schedule, much less all its imitators. End of rant.

by maxwell edison

That he ignored for himself, as he's slung mud throughout the discussion. But it's pointless arguing with him about it, because he'll simply deny it - even though it's there for all to see.

Mudslinging, you see, is a matter of interpretation. He didn't sling mud, he'll rebut; it was only a hand full of dirt, or a snowball, or......

Demeaning characterizations of others in his usual straw-man fashion is his way to hide his own mudslinging.

I've seen it for too long from him - and his denials that he does it.

Personally, I make no bones about mudslinging. It adds emphasis to the written word when voice inflections can't be used. People like a_a and Ansu do it in a sneaky and underhanded stealth mode. At least I own up to it and don't try to hide behind their word games.

by hal 9000

Why about 50% of US Voters simply do not vote.

They know no matter who they vote for they are going to get a Lieing Cheating Sod who is owned by the Political Party that they belong to.

Actually the real problem here isn't the Politicians but the Political Parties. Doesn't matter where you are the Party selects who is best for the Party not the Country. ;)

Col

by j-mart

With the amount of money required to run a political campaign, you need to be seriously rich to start with, or have connections with those that are.

by Member 25348569

The Iraq War was 2003. I fail to properly see the connection.

As for the hostage crisis, I draw your attention to my earlier point about the CIA's imposition of the Shah. We screwed their entire country, payback was to be expected. Then you tried an armed recue attempt...

I do find the US's attitude to Cuba truly outsiide of my ability to understand. You could have long since killed their regime off with kindness.

by charliespencer

I'm just speculating as to how Islam became the target du jour. If you have other theories, by all means, trot them out.

I understood why the Iranian people wanted to unload the Shah, but I don't think that excused violating the generally accepted principle of diplomatic immunity.

by av .

Ok, that means to me that you're on the left. Am I wrong in that assumption? I know you can't be with the party that has gun-toting clowns and cowboys or you wouldn't refer to them like that. I don't think you've referred to the far left radicals as the bleeding heart, Krill-eating, save the Whales crowd, so apparently they're ok to you, even though they are extreme too. They're just misguided. Aww.

Most Republicans, myself included, have a deep respect for the Constitution and will defend it. Its the framework on which this nation was built and is every bit as valid today as the day it was written. You may misunderstand the gun-toting clowns and cowboys, but they are up in arms that our second amendment right to own guns is being taken away. No one wants to see the horrendous crimes that have been committed with guns lately ever happen again, but the government's answer is to just ban assault weapons. Problem solved! That was done in the past and it didn't work and won't work now. Also, and this is why the gun-toting clowns and cowboys are so fired up, if the legislation passes, it will give the government more latitude to enact further laws to restrict legal gun ownership in this country. Its a gun grab by the government and thats why every gun store across the nation is packed with people buying guns and ammo.

Legal gun owners in this country shouldn't be persecuted for the crimes of disturbed people that walk among us. THEY are the real problem. Here's an example. http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/headlines/2013/01/halloween-inspired-texas-teen-to-kill-mom-and-sister/ A teen steals his grandfather's gun and gets inspired by the movie Halloween to kill his mom and sister. He did it because they were rude and he felt suffocated by them. He only used the gun because he didn't want them to feel any pain. He might have used something else maybe if he had no gun. Should we ban Halloween the movie and the gun to prevent that from happening in the future? Would that help? No.

We need to address the real problem and that's mental illness. We need to be talking about what we can do about those individuals instead of deciding which weapons we should ban. Every gun is an assault weapon in the wrong hands.

I know I got a little sidetracked, but I wanted to shed some light on why the gun-toting clowns and cowboys are so upset. The government is going to use these horrendous crimes to chip away at our second amendment rights in the name of public safety, but its a false sense of security for everyone because the real problem is mental illness.

AV

by Member 25348569

But what I'm saying is that they, Iraq, Iran and Al Qaeda are scapegoats in that they were or are not the threats that they have been described as. In much the same way that the US particularly and the West in general are scapegoats for some Islamic countries.

Whether this is a deliberate and cynical ploy by the politicians or stupidity on the part of the politicians , I don't know.

by j-mart

Maybe Ansu's society is working better than yours and has a more "conservative " and less radical approach to change. Why don't you look up the word "conservative" in a dictionary to see if you have your head around it's real meaning.

by charliespencer

"Whether this is a deliberate and cynical ploy by the politicians or stupidity on the part of the politicians , I don't know."

D. All of the above.

by Member 25348569

And your point, here? I'm assuming it's that communists are so implicitly bad that anything that they agree with is unhesitatingly wrong.

That was certainly the premise in the rubbish at the end of your link. Mao Tse Tung, for heavens's sake. He brought MaoTse Tung into the argument. Then, it got worse. Stalin. And then bloody Lenin! Shouldn't Godwin's Law apply to right-wing mouth-frothers? I think it should.

I loved the bit about the UK's "hunting ban". Context, please! The ban was on hunting foxes with dog packs. No guns here!

I loved the little sideways dig at the "journalist", with journalist in quotes. Hello! We can't have a communist journalist, eh? What sort of muppet wrote the piece? Googling him seems to suggest he's a conspiracy theory nut. That's well-supported by this piece of drivel!

I mean, "centralized monopoly of force which invariably turns tyrannical and deadly." We're doomed. We're all doomed.Well, we are over here as we don't have guns.

I usually follow any links that you post as, generally, you don't post links to total tosh. Don't make a habit of this!

By the way, what is it with the "Founding Fathers" and the reverence in which they seem to be held by you guys? So, it's really good for everyone to have guns but blacks have no rights?

by maxwell edison

..... that I just wanted to post that link.

Regarding your last question - reverence with our founders?

I'll answer your question (again), but why is it I have to answer the same kinds of questions over and over again. You guys don't seem to get a grasp of it.

It's not the people (founders); it's not the paper (constitution); it's the underlying principle - which means it's not really any given issue either, but rather the underlying principle which should act as a compass when considering issues.

Look at how dishonest ANSU is being up above about the definition of the word conservative - like I don't know the meaning of the word and its different variants and applications. He's hiding behind a word in an attempt to conceal his underlying principle. Likewise, people criticize [i]"the founders"[/i] and the [i]"constitution"[/i] as old white men and an out-dated piece of paper, all the while refusing to address the underlying principle, which is not outdated, and is inclusive to all men (gender neutral).

By the way, you knew that. So why did you have to ask?

On your pet peeve issue right now? And how I would reconcile our different outlooks and approaches?

Our federal government simply does not have the power to implement sweeping gun control laws. I would go on to explain myself, but I think I'll see what kind of criticism ..... I mean reply ..... that comment might generate.

by charliespencer

"It should come as no surprise that the Communist Party USA is on board with President Obamas plan to attack Americans right to keep and bear arms as a means to 'end gun violence.'"

I disagree with the article's title of 'gun grab', and I disagree that the proposed changes to gun regulations are an 'attack on rights to keep and bear arms'. These phrases tell me the article is not going to be impartial.

I don't buy into the 'slippery slope' theory that any regulation automatically leads to elimination. We had an ban on so-called assault weapons for a decade; it didn't lead to the elimination of other types of weapons.

I see nothing wrong with closing the 'gun show loophole'. Travelling retailers should be required to comply with the same laws as brick-and-mortar retailers.

I don't see anything wrong with state or national databases tracking serial numbers. We do the same with automobile VINs; that's hadn't led to government confiscation of cars, but does make it harder to sell stolen ones, return recovered stolen property to its owner, and identify vehicles used in crimes.

If that makes me a communist, fine with me. I wasn't aware that agreeing with someone on one principle automatically meant I agreed with them on all principles, but so be it, comrade. I guess I'm a lesbian too.

by aidemzo_adanac

From my view, whic seems to mirror your own, the entire premise of the first paragraph is convoluted and one sided. "Obama's plan to attack Americans right to keep and bear arms" sounds pretty biased in it's context. Is Obama REALLY out to "attack" people's rights? or does he propose that some changes need to be made for the nation and to safely progress?

"as a means to end gun violence" I could be wrong but I highly doubt he's said as much, at least not in that simple context. It is a means to help reduce unnecessary deaths and greater CONTROL will most likely validate the effort.

Once again, how many lives saved does it take to make it a valid solution?

It's a bit of a trick question really. IF the answer is 1, then clearly it shows a value toward human life. If you say 10 or 50 or 100, then one's humanity is questionable. The question is still very valid though, if one is to deny such actions as being valid, then they surely have a value placed on human life and HOW MUCH VALUE is the key question, which any 'freedom of gun ownership' supporter can not honestly answer.

The whole registry idea even upsets some. As Max said, not to point fingers but purely as example, he wouldn't feel comfortable with the serials of his guns being kept in a central registry by the government. It's completely understandable that one would feel almost violated and sharing similar information makes a person uneasy. I've felt the same way about other issues with government knowledge of my activities.

Nobody seems to mind them having a record of your vehicle registration though.

What's the difference with guns? They are just as lethal, if not more, than a car?

I understand there are over 5000 THOUSAND gun shows in the US each year! It's simply a staggering number, more than car shows, electronics shows, boat shows, home shows etc. and I mean a LOT more.

LOL, without even reading it, I had replied to the registration comment with the same view as yourself.

As for your newly found political status, I wouldn't worry about it. I'm tagged as a left wing, tree hugging , commie, socialist.

In reality I am none of the above though.

by nicknielsen

The persistent lie about Hitler taking away the guns (he didn't, it was the Weimar government's response to the requirements of the Treaty of Versailles).

by Member 25348569

I think we've established over the years that I really don't quite get it. Never have. Maybe you have to grow up with it to appreciate what it means. Maybe you have to have NOT grown up with and have grown up with a totally different system to get a different perspective. Let me try and explain what we have over here and then YOU may understand why I don't get it. Why we are SO different.

You have The Constitution. Capital 'T', capital 'C'. It's written on one document, codified, and amendable with great difficulty. Our constitution is uncodified, is contained in some documents such as the Magna Carta, the Bill of Rights the Act of Settlement, and the Act of Union but it is also, and mostly, contained in common law. It evolved haphazardly through conflicts between different power-groups over the last thousand years, Monarchy vs Barons, Monarchy vs Parliament, Parliament vs People giving rise to anything from minor constitutional changes through to major political upheaval and civil war. It eveolved through Case Law, Common Law and Acts of Parliament. It is now being further modified by interaction with the European Union via our signature on European Human rights legislation. The Human Rights Act enshrined the European Convention on Human Rights into UK law.

The reason we don't have a written constitution is because our country has been stable for a very long time when compared to most of the rest of the World. We remained free from the revolutionary fever that gave us the French Revolution and we weren't a new country like the US that required codification of citizens' rights as a necessary part of the process of independence. so we never bothered to write it down.

Your constitution tells you what your rights are, whereas our constitution is a little different in that we have the right to do anything EXCEPT that which is prohibited by law. The law, and therefore the constitution, in Britain doesn't tell us what rights we HAVE, it tells us what rights we DON'T have. To get to that point, by the way, you needed the 9th amendment.

We are a Constitutional Monarchy and Parliamentary Democracy. Parliament, using the power of the Crown, enacts law which no other body can challenge. Parliamentary sovereignty is commonly regarded as the defining principle of the British Constitution with the ultimate lawmaking power vested in a democratically elected Parliament to create or abolish any law.

It seems to work. We may get it all written down, one day. But, I suspect (and hope), not soon. And, if they do try and write it down, then it will probably be the wrong "they" and it will be wrong. And wrong forever. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. It gives us a constitution that, for the average Joe citizen (me), I have no real idea what my rights are but I haven't run up aginst anything obviously missing, yet. It's a constituution that is fluid and adaptable but because we have had it for a long time, it changes slowly and not in big jumps.

It is changing, though. We have had the introduction of codified rights of individuals for the the first time in the Human Rights Act 1998, and devolution to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. These recent constitutional reforms may have made the constitution less flexible in some respects as, certainly, devolution would seem difficult to reverse and that goes against the principle that no Parliament should pass a law that another Parliament cannot undo.

So. do I understand your adherence to a rigid document written some hundreds of years ago by men who had no idea how the world would be now? No, not really. But I have the same trouble understanding religions and for much the same reasons.

by maxwell edison

To think about it, there's only one reason I get involved in anything political in the first place.

I'd much rather just stroll along the yellow brick road of my life, being content in not knowing where it will lead and knowing it offers no guarantees; minding my own business, and taking care of my own business - and certainly not minding anyone else's business; not bothering anyone at all, not hurting anyone, and being willing to stop and help someone I see along my way; and so on.

But I'm always finding myself saying (or thinking) things like:

Leave me the f^%$& alone - mind your own business - I don't give a rat's ash about your stupid problem - I'm responsible for your what? - You've got to be f#$$^%& kidding me! - I said to MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS - Don't suck me into your stupid scheme - You believe what? - You believe who? - You've got to be f#$$^%& kidding me! - I said to MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS - and on it goes.......

Do you know what I mean, Neli?

by aidemzo_adanac

I really do, in fact I feel the same way quite often, when I do I find it best to give my head a shake and not care about people begging for help.

Much like yourself, I prefer to help people when I see a need to help them, not when I'm told to or asked to.

Before you bring it up, I don't get the same feeling from having welfare take my tax dollars to help others. I just don't and I know you see it as the same thing and perhaps I should too but I accept it as a necessary evil.

I really do relate to that mindset though, 'who am I to resolve your screw ups?'

Not a great example but playing on the same mindset, there's a guy at the track who ALWAYS asks you to buy him a pop when you turn up. As soon as you walk in the door its "Hey, see the Canucks game last night? Buy me a pop?"

Okay, in his defense he is a bit slow, actually he's quite slow, I'm not sure what actual mental issues he has but he's surely not on par with the rest of us.

I'm patient for that simple fact of course and I'll always buy him a pop because, well, because he's 'an old face at the track, in his mid 50's now and there are worse people I have to deal with.

It has gotten to the point now though where he EXPECTS you to buy him a pop.
HE -"It's Chinese New Year, you gonna buy me a pop for Chinese New Year?"
I - 'Sure man, I'll get you a pop when I buy my next beer.'
HE - "When are you getting your next beer?"
I - 'Not sure buddy, but I won't forget okay?'

At this point I haven't even checked in, bought a voucher, taken off my coat or found my seat at the bar.

I - order a beer and a pop. 'Hey buddy, here's that pop you wanted'
HE - 'Oh, okay, there's one muffin left, buy me a muffin?'

This is where I get ticked. The guy gets disability, welfare or whatever, he practically LIVES at the track (in fact he was all worked up last week because they decided to open an hour later in the morning) He used to have a menial job at some warehouse, flattening boxes or whatever, but he had a job, bottom line.
His sister, who nobody has met, is known to be rather wealthy and it seems that the track has become the place they tell him to hang out all day, like a care home.

So while I have NO PROBLEM buying a guy a pop, and in his case he does have some issues where he doesn't comprehend courtesy, it is STILL that sense that he is entitled to something and expects a handout that gets to me.

To be fair, I try not to encourage it but I do always by him a pop, as does everyone else he knows there. But I have also told him before that I'll buy him a pop if I feel like it and that it's not good to just walk around asking everyone for a pop.

It's getting to the point now though that I think, 'why does your family just expect you to come and beg here all day? If your family is wealthy, then why aren't THEY being responsible for your well being?'

I think they actually do give him a bit of money each day for food etc. but he'll just drop it on a horse and then ask someone to buy him food or drink. I don't see it as HIS fault but more so his family's fault. It's like they have just put him out to pasture, please forgive the pun.

I work all day and stop in for a beer and a bite after work, see a few old familiar faces and place a few bets while waiting out rush hour. Why is it MY issue to take care of him? If you don't 'help him out' then someone else will offer up handout and you get dirty looks for saying no to him or telling him to wait a while.

Then it's a matter of I'm an a$$hole for not cowtowing to his pleas, which is also encouraging it.

Note: This is also a guy who can drink gallon after gallon of pop. He'll take a large pop and drink it all without stopping for a breath.

Perhaps a poor example but it was just last night that I was thinking about it, 'why am I a bad guy for not offering a hand out EVERY TIME I SEE THE GUY?" And I see him several times a week.

Buying him a pop doesn't have any financial impact on me, if he is hungry and wants a muffin, NO PROBLEM! It's not the money, it's just the expectation that I have money and so I should be offering handouts every time.

Rant over, sorry, i tried to stay somewhat on track but it was a bug in my ear that I had to clear out.

by delbertpgh

Its very brevity makes it accomodating to a variety of historical eras. The secret to its usefulness is that legislators, courts, and the people have to accomodating of change. And they have been, for the most part. Americans start from a naive faith in the sweet nature of progress, and reshape their habits, institutions, and congressional interpretation to make the best out of whereever progress takes them.

There were some rascals in the early and mid 19th century who resisted progress, but we had a transformative little war and fixed them, more or less.

by Member 25348569

that gives you weirdies like the Second Amendment that is interpreted so many ways by so many different people. You have the Eigth Amendment and yet you have capital punishment, waterboarding, Gitmo and the largest prison population in the World. Certainly, it's flexible if the scope for (mis)interpretation is added in with Judicial Reviews to change the meaning every so often.

The Eighteenth and the Twenty-First were fun, eh? The Land Of The (Alcohol) Free.

Still, whatever suits you.

Lucky you could get your Civil Rights Act through without a Constitutional Amendment else they'd still be at the back of the bus.

by charliespencer

"Our federal government simply does not have the power to implement sweeping gun control laws."

We disagree on the word 'sweeping'. Would you say the federal government has any power to pass any gun control laws? Does any law on the subject automatically default to violating the 2nd amendment? For example, does federal registration of serial numbers violate the right to keep and bear? If so, how?

by maxwell edison

I wonder how some of the current laws have passed constitutional scrutiny (generally speaking, that is). Nonetheless, I think any federal gun law is treading on dangerous territory, in that it [i]arguably[/i] violates the second amendment.

[i]Arguably[/i] being the key component of my comment, with respective arguments taken to extremes on either side - and again, to say [i]"extremes"[/i] is even subjective.

By the way, I'm not sure how to respond to you (or anyone else, for that matter) when you nitpick on words. Gee, I used the word "sweeping". Maybe I could have pulled another word out of my ash (tray) that would have been more appropriate for more people. Sometimes things just come out without having been given a lot of thought. I wish people would nitpick less and seek overall understanding more; and I think the former prevents the latter - oftentimes done intentionally, but not always.

Does registering the serial numbers of my weapons to the federal government violate the text of the 2nd amendment? How in the hell do I know? How in the hell does anybody know? [i]Arguably[/i], both yes and no, depending on who you ask and what their desired end result is. And it's for that kind of reason I'd prefer to start with the premise and work up (something advocates of progressivism refuse to do (because they fear to do), by the way).

Do I want to give the serial numbers of my weapons to the federal government? Hell no. That's not the intent of the federal government in regards to any of the articles or amendments of the constitution - the rules under which government must operate.

by charliespencer

"That's not the intent of the federal government in regards to any of the articles or amendments of the constitution..."

"...promote the general welfare..."

by aidemzo_adanac

I think I follow Palmetto's lead on this and I also wonder how changing how guns are registered actually infringes on the right to bear arms.As far as I can tell, nobody has removed rights, they are just keeping a registry of who, what and when.

I light of the current out of control situation, is it really so impeding ?

Secondly, and I see both views to this again, why would registering your guns with the Federal government be an issue? Do you oppose having your licence plate number being held in a central database ? If not, is the difference simply the fact that you don't have a right to drive noted in the Constitution?

I know, 'they know enough about me already, too much in fact, why do they need to micromanage my affairs?

I completely agree with that view point too, in fact I simply didn't exist about 5 years ago, England thought I was Canadian, Canada thought I was British, income tax didn't know where I was etc. It felt pretty nice for a few years but I really don't care now and am tracked like a bear in the woods.

What is the actual issue with respect to the 2nd amendment though?
Is it a feeling that the loss of SOME rights will lead to the loss of others too?

Is it even an actual loss of rights? Control, not removal?

Is it that American rights get trampled on enough and people are just fed up now?

Is it that the information they want to collect is seen as useless and just a reason to collect personal data?

I just don't get how it's an issue or why people are so enraged over the whole matter. If it was me, I don't know how I would oppose it, not being American of course.

Living in Canada, I thought it was pretty easy to go and get a permit, I didn't find a mandatory wait time to be an inconvenience of any sort. As long as you are not a criminal or psycho, you can have a gun, that basis seems pretty fair and acceptable to me, in fact I'm glad someone IS keeping tabs on guns.

Perhaps this really is one of those things that, unless you are American, you just don't understand it.

or is it one of those things where, you FEEL, that unless someone is American they wouldn't understand freedoms and liberties?

How its even a topic of discussion that lasted more than 5 minutes baffles me.
To me its like saying "The number of deaths due to guns is going through the roof in our country. Let's put together a together registry and REALLY check people out before issuing a permit."

To me that would be,
'I second the motion',
'motion carried, next order of business...'

Seems like such a no brainer, I just don't get it.

I THINK what Americans see is:
'okay, I second the motion''motion carried'
'next order of business, taking guns away from women under 40'
'motion carried'
'next order of business, taking guns away from white msales living in populated aread'
'motion carried'
etc?

Is that the fear, one allowance will lead to others, give them an inch and they take a mile?

by aidemzo_adanac

If they start having a central registration database of your serial numbers, the next step is to remove your right to ignore posts.

by maxwell edison

I don't know how they've gotten away with it.

Neither does my buddy, James:

[i]With respect to the words general welfare, I have always regarded them as qualified by the detail of powers connected with them. To take them in a literal and unlimited sense would be a metamorphosis of the Constitution into a character which there is a host of proofs was not contemplated by its creators."

"If Congress can employ money indefinitely to the general welfare, and are the sole and supreme judges of the general welfare, they may take the care of religion into their own hands; they may appoint teachers in every State, county and parish and pay them out of their public treasury; they may take into their own hands the education of children, establishing in like manner schools throughout the Union; they may assume the provision of the poor; they may undertake the regulation of all roads other than post-roads; in short, every thing, from the highest object of state legislation down to the most minute object of police, would be thrown under the power of Congress.... Were the power of Congress to be established in the latitude contended for, it would subvert the very foundations, and transmute the very nature of the limited Government established by the people of America." [/i]

- James Madison (regarding the [i]general welfare[/i] clause)

by ansugisalas

It's not perhaps an "only in America thing", but generally the rest of the western world have more reasonable right wings (because they have actual conservatives).
The US only seems to have the Extreme Right and then a bunch of minarchists.

by Member 25348569

The PATRIOT Act managed to go through without a Constitutional Amendment and if ever there was a case of something actually making all those guns relevent, that was it. But the concept of the armed citizenry acting as a brake on government is so much bollux, anyway. The chances of enough of you agreeing what's wrong with your government and what should be done about it is zero. But, hey, it's your constitutional right to fail to think through the fine detail so you're damn well going to keep it.

The French Revolution gave us the Terror and then Napoleon. The Russian Revolution gave us Lenin and then Stalin. What makes you think a bunch of armed Libertarians arguing which of the sayings of Ayn Rand should be sanctified into law are going to last any longer than the Provisional Government in Russia?

by delbertpgh

Just noting that among the English speaking peoples, in every land, a proper respect for liberty, process, and free speech has its failing moments.

The Patriot Act's actual Orwellian name (it's so easy to forget) is "Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism"; the acronym is USA PATRIOT. The point of the whole name is to come up with that acronym, which actually means "any congressman who votes against this bill is against the USA and against patriotism and is a turd who should be wiped from the national butt in the 2002 mid-term elections." The secret code embedded therein may not be as obvious to people outside the USA as it was to us, here.

by ansugisalas

If they're really on to something, how come their arguments are backed by phony crap spouted by crackpots and freaks?

by ansugisalas

I remember wanting to applaud the few lawmakers that refused to vote for it.
Just one senator voted against it in 2001, Russ Feingold. Voted against it in 2006, too.
66 reps voted against it in 2001, just a handful of them Republicans.

by mjd420nova

Along with the rights to have and bear arms comes the responsibility to understand and maintain the weapon of choice. I found a gunsmith that installs the Smart technology in handguns. Now I can leave my weapon out and it will not fire for anyone but me. The same goes for my wifes piece. As yet I haven't looked at the manual for the multiuser program but it supposed to handle up to five users. It doesn't use a ring or bracelet but has two biometric pads on each side of the grip. The solution?? NO but it might insure my own piece won't be used against me. Slanted more towards law enforcement as the black market has become over run with the rings and bracelets crooks wear just in case. Pretending you need an assault rifle for anything other than hunting humans is a bit see through and a poor defense for logic. One doesn't drive a car without some real experience and guns should be the same way.. Remember, a crash in car can be tragic but an accident with a gun can be lethal.

by Member 25348569

It's pretty draconian in that the people who define "secret" are not always -seldom - justified in so doing. However, it has a long long way to go to catch up with the Patriot Act! Just a few pleasantries...

Third-party holders of your financial, library, travel, video rental, phone, medical and place of worship records can be searched without your knowledge or consent, providing the government says it's "trying to protect against terrorism".

Secret searches can be authorised by a secret court without accountability, so long as there is a putative "foreign intelligence" basis for the search.

An unknowing association with a "known" terrorist is a deportable offense.

It's even got us over here. If I do business with a UK subsidiary of a US-based cloud operator, even if I specify that English law applies and I mandate a UK-based data centre operating under EU data protection laws, the FBI can still get access to my data.

The point I was making -and still am - was that you have the Patriot Act DESPITE the rights that some (a lot) of Americans keep wittering on about in threads on gun laws and such. Yes, we have similar laws and government control and nanny state the EU is about as anti-democratic as it's possible to be but what we DON'T do is bang endlessly on about "Freedom" and "Inalienable Rights" and feel it our duty to export the ideal.

We just went about bitchslapping half of the World into the shape we wanted. Don't know why we gave it up. Everywhere has gone to the dogs, since and at least we were honest about our reasons for Empire.

by aidemzo_adanac

Well, yes. I sit much more to the right of centre than the left, if that's a better explanation. I have referred to the extreme left as tree hugging people who protest for the sake of protesting. But I feel a need to save the whales and out environment too. I'm not opposed to every building constructed because it displaces rats and birds but I am for responsibility. One of my hero's is the great David Suzuki, many see him as a tree hugging fish lover, which he is not. He's a US trained scientist and supports sustainability by educating public on the realities of our actions, not some radical, chain yourself to a tree in protest kind of guy.

Like i said, there are extremes on both sides, in the US the extremes are so pronounced that there is no middle ground to be shared and as a result either side meeting in the middle is seen as lowering their beliefs to compromise. I agree many left wing supporters are misguided and radical too. No need to say awww, I feel the same. But I don't see every effort to save wildlife or nature as being letfy, hippie sh*t. Just the same as I don't see every corporate maneuver as being healthy for us or the planet either.

There is no question in my min at all that most Republicans don't see the Constitution for what it is but what it represents, it's as valid as the first copy of the bible. Which, to me, makes no sense from either perspective.

I am all for defending your rights and not letting others impose on them, but we are talking common sense and human lives now. If your defense of your rights is jeopardizing others lives, there has to be middle ground found and some 'adjustment' made. As I have said though, there is no hope of common view or shared middle ground in a political system that forces people to go out of their way to be an absolute opposite in every possible way to each other.

[i]but they are up in arms that our second amendment right to own guns is being taken away.[/i]

ALL of my comments here have been focused on stricter laws to legally obtain guns, I have said NOTHING AT ALL about taking away the right to own one. If you are an upstanding, red blooded American citizen then your rights are not impacted in any way shape or form. You can still own a gun, go to gun shows, show your guns off, shoot things with them, make yourself feel safe in your own home, whatever it is you feel you need to do to feel safe again in your free and most desirable nation.

There is nothing in your Constitution that says you should be able to buy a gun without passing some checks first though. Right to bear arms does not stipulate a time frame. If you feel it does, then why is the current check okay and not proper checks and wait time to ensure that criminal charges aren't being processed in the system as you apply for ownership?

" Its a gun grab by the government and thats why every gun store across the nation is packed with people buying guns and ammo."

That's such a pathetic comment in every way. "quick, the government is taking away all of our guns and our rights!" I mean, seriously hilarious but rather sad at the same time. Only in America, I know, because Americans have freedoms nobody else would understand, freedoms to protect themselves from all the other free Americans trying to harm and steal from them.

Yes, and then there are the thousands of government conspiracies, all the UFO's the government secretly stores and those pesky aliens that work at area 51, the Chinese setting to take over the world etc.
Actually, shhh, there's a guy out front of our office wearing a black hat, I think he's in on it too!

Legal gun owners ar enot being persecuted, nor having thei rrights removed. Gun CONTROL is gun CONTROL, not gun REMOVAL. Even if the government wanted to, they can't remove guns from American hands, it is impossible and anyone advising the president or congress already knows that. I have only ever mentioned gun CONTROL laws are tightened. Just as they are in Canada where we also have plenty of guns, legally owned by people with rights and freedoms, or the UK, or Australia, or Germany etc.

Your absolutely ridiculous analogy using the movie Halloween is both far fetched and inapplicable to any comments I've made.

"We need to address the real problem and that's mental illness."

Very true, in fact you can add that to the list right after a longer waiting period before a gun permit is obtained, greater responsibility for ALL gun owners, an education for the rest etc.

There are many MANY people who go on killing sprees that show absolutely no signs of mental illness, either before or even AFTER the killing spree, this is why most take their own lives too, they completely understand what they have done and what the repercussions are.

I've studied criminal minds and criminal psychology at great length for many years, there is no 'formula' that you feel we need to identify and correct. Yes, there are those that are prone to end up that way, and many are left untreated and able to commit their crimes, but the vast majority are not diagnosed that way before or after their crime spree.

So while I agree that focusing on mental illness is needed, it's also a cop out for completely sane people to commit heinous crimes and plead insanity. To even suggest that greater background checks is not as effective as identifying the more than 3 million 'known' psychopaths in the US, perhaps those mental illness checks need to start at your front door. Should BOTH be focused on more? Yes, why not? Oh, right, because if you had to wait an extra two weeks to legally obtain YOUR gun it would be imposing on YOUR right to shoot something, right now.

by aidemzo_adanac

If I throw mud at both the right and the left, you only have an issue because I commented on the right?

IN actuality, I didn't sling mud at the right, I specifically focused on a portion of the right wing and even then specifically on a certain mentality of SOME of the right wing, as I described also. The fact that I say the same about the radical leftists is irrelevant though I suppose.

Why must you only see extreme right or left with no concept of what conservative thoughts are?

You hid ebehind your own word games, you are famed for it, cryptic enough that you can skew it either way dependin gon reponses. No Max, I don't think you are that dumb as to not know what you are doing. Your posts are so carefully planned and posted, it's not funny. I don't know anyone around here who puts as much thought into an evasive and protective post that implies yet doesn't assert as much as you do.

by aidemzo_adanac

You mean you want him to start by finding middle ground first in order to have a sensible discussion, which just may result in a more positive outcome? Isn't that compromising, in your eyes, though?

by charliespencer

"England thought I was Canadian, Canada thought I was British,..."

Are you sure it wasn't just that neither wanted you? :D

And yes, some people view gun registration as the first step down an increasingly steep slope that leads to restriction and inevitably prohibition.

by aidemzo_adanac

Surely if that was their aim, they'd just do it right off the bat. No need to piddle around. I think the US knows very well just how poorly their attempts at prohibition have been (drugs and booze? c'mon, there are more guns in the US than drugs, I'd think).

Why do so many Americans not trust the government and yet state it's the best place on the planet to live?
There's got to be SOME association there, one would think that feeling you live in the best nation would go hand in hand with feeling you had the best government too.

It seems that most people want to stop irresponsible use of guns, especially those who are properly trained and practice for sport. The bad ones always make it worse for the good ones. But those same people fear that the government will strip them of their rights. They want more control but don't want more control?!

Is it that people feel the PEOPLE committing crimes need to be corrected and not the laws themselves?

How can that possibly work? If we could determine people's mental weaknesses that closely, there would be no crime and no plea of insanity.

I just don't get it. It seems the focus is that if each side argues about ridiculous fallacies, then nothing gets done and everyone carries on as usual, except the problem continues to escalate.

For a nation full of forward thinking people, how do those, who are stuck in the dark ages and simply won't accept that change is needed, have such a voice?

Seriously, I just don't see how its even an issue of debate, especially one that constantly results in a stalemate. I might say Americans are gullible consumers or that they can be lead like sheep but seriously, this can't just be a matter of people's blind ignorance, or is it?

by charliespencer

I don't buy into that theory myself. I don't distrust our government as much as regard it as too incompetent to pull off something like total weapons ban. Even if such a proposed amendment would get through Congress, it would never get past the state legislatures. Anyway, the alcohol prohibition demonstrated that total bans are unenforceable.

by jamesrl

Long guns in Canada were required to be registered since 1993, but that part of the law was thrown out by the Conservative government last year. Handguns have been registered in Canada since the 1930s.

There have been restrictions on automatic weapons, clip sizes, regulations around safe storage etc. mandatory safety training, for decades.

So it is entirely possible to implement some controls, but not slide down some slippery slope into a ban.

by aidemzo_adanac

That;s the way I see it. Clearly many Americans fear that if they give an inch the government takes a mile. I know I have seen some changes and proposals here too that many, including myself, saw as a start with more to come. I can understand that mindset but it seems SO ingrained into so many US minds that one has to wonder if they trust government at all or if they feel its a crooked operation that needs to be either fixed by noncompliance or replaced entirely.

I think again the whole left vs right issue comes into play. the right will oppose Obama, no matter what, no matter how valid and no matter the reasons. He's left and must be opposed without consideration. If a right wing president were in office, I think it might play out similar though. Either he would be a visionary and everyone accepted change but it is more likely they'd see him a s flip-flopper or a democrat in a republican's clothing.

I know some actually feel that there should be no government at all, free reign for all etc. But I think that's seen as pretty radical by most.

I honestly don't see the US government trying to take it to great lengths, even if people agreed to more stringent checks and longer wait times. the ONLY benefit I see from that is reduced, random killing sprees and fewer guns landing in irresponsible hands.

Granted, it won't stop all gun violence nor is it be proposed to do so, but ANY life saved is still one life saved. As I said before, how many lives saved does it need to be deemed a worthy solution, 1, 15, 50?

The fear of a slippery slope is somewhat valid, if the government has been proven to do so in the past, but I honestly don't see it being taken to that extreme. Any elected leader in power at such a time would never see reelection, it just wouldn't make sense politically either.

I think it's the common fear, uncertainty and doubt.

Fear of change. Uncertainty on how it will take effect and who it will effect. Doubt toward the effectiveness of dramatic change or the seemingly inevitable slippery slope.

I don't see any of those reasons as a valid excuse to not save more lives; even if just a few, it's a valid change.

by ansugisalas

Ban person-to-person gun sales.
The thing to bear in mind here is this: The US has so many legal firearms, so many of which turn into illegal firearms, that people are smuggling them to Mexico!!!
Chew on that for a sec.
If people are smuggling something from a high-earning country, into a low-earning country, there's something not right.
The FBI is confident that theft, gun shows and person-to-person sales account for the bulk of the illegal weapons.
Considering that gun show salesmen are allowed to sell firearms without background checks for the same reasons private persons are, that's a two-fer.
As for theft: Put damn license plates on the weapons. Demand secure storage. Theft is hard to avoid, but it is possible to make people store the weapons so that they're hard to steal.

Illegal guns are a big problem, and there are insane amounts of them.

by hal 9000

The Local Police Station was broken into and the side arms stolen from the safe. Well actually the safe and half the wall where stolen and latter found but by that time the safe was empty and several Glocks where missing.

Unfortantly there is no easy way to prevent something like that from occurring though I am however still amazed that they got away with it as the Police Station was in a residential area with lots of people around and no one noticed some sort of truck backing up to the wall of the Police Station and tearing it out.

I would have imagined that the thieves made quite a lot of noise with the way they took the safe.

Though why the US Government can not use Computers to store the Records of Fire Arm Owners is beyond my understanding.

Col

by charliespencer

"Though why the US Government can not use Computers to store the Records of Fire Arm Owners is beyond my understanding."

Technically, it's not 'can not', but 'may not'.

by aidemzo_adanac

That one always makes me chuckle. Being Ron Obvious is often the best way to be unnoticed. People think that it MUST be legit, nobody would be THAT obvious when committing a crime!

When I worked in store security, many many moons ago, we did some video testing with old crimes to see how brazen thieves would actually be. Two guys walked into The Bay (Hudson's Bay Company, largest and oldest department store, ex trading post company in Canada). They went to the candy department and bought $1.50 worth of candy, which was put into a Bay bag, and casually munched away while strolling the store and checking out security. They walked up to a canoe in the sporting good department, taped the empty bag onto one of the seats and thanked security for holding the door as they walked out of the store with it.

They ended up getting arrested three days later, not because they were tracked down by great security and cameras but because they returned and tried to do the same thing to steal the paddles ! Clever to start but why not a different store for paddles?!?

Needless to say we all pee'd ourselves with laughter but it can happen to the best of us, even the police (not to suggest they are the best of us).

by aidemzo_adanac

"To date, the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) has prevented nearly 1.8 million criminals and other prohibited purchasers from buying guns. The law also has a deterrent effectprohibited purchasers are less likely to try to buy guns when they know comprehensive background check requirements are in place. "

"Unfortunately, current federal law requires criminal background checks only for guns sold through licensed firearm dealers, which account for just 60% of all gun sales in the United States. A loophole in the law allows individuals not engaged in the business of selling firearms to [b]sell guns without a licenseand without processing any paperwork.[/b] That means that [b]two out of every five guns sold in the United States change hands without a background check[/b]."

"Unfortunately, only six states (CA, CO, IL, NY, OR, RI) require universal background checks on all firearm sales at gun shows. Three more states (CT, MD, PA) require background checks on all handgun sales made at gun shows. Seven other states (HI, IA, MA, MI, NJ, NC, NE) require purchasers to obtain a permit and undergo a background check before buying a handgun. Florida allows its counties to regulate gun shows by requiring background checks on all firearms purchases at these events. 33 states have taken no action whatsoever to close the Gun Show Loophole."

There are over 5000 gun shows in the us each year, compared to how many car shows, boat shows, home shows?

It's so far out of control that no single measure will do much but every small step helps. Perhaps this is why so many Americans feel they will be stripped of rights and stripped of freedoms.

In the same sense, I was always told to pick my battles wisely. If the government were looking to restrict free speech, freedom of press or freedom of religion, I would strongly oppose THOSE right being taken away. But with something as stupid as gun ownership, I think Americans need to get a grip on what's actually important. Owning a gun is not important, it is a luxury. There are cases where it is very important but in such cases it is also legal and a matter of safety, security, police etc. For the average American to fight for gun freedom is simply insane to me. Nobody actually NEEDS a gun. Sport and hunting are fine examples of a DESIRE but not a need. Carrying a weapon for safety when in the wild is a NEED, even though just about any loud noise will work, except in the case of grizzlies. MOST wild animals flee at the sound of even distant human voices though.

This whole protection of your home, family and property is a crappo excuse to me though. Other country's with more stringent gun laws still have the odd home invasion but not to the point that most homeowners feel a NEED to protect themselves with a firearm. When I grew up, guns were simply for cowards. Anyone carrying a gun in the street or having one to protect their home would have been knocked out and laughed at for being such a pu$$y.

Back on topic, person to person gun sales are, for the most part, unregulated and often allow serious crimes to go forward. With 60% of US guns being obtained by any SCHMOE with a wallet, how is gun control such a confusing issue?

Put an end to it, it doesn't infringe on your freedoms to be checked out before being allowed to buy a gun.

IT's baffling how many Americans get so upset over something as gun registrations. As an upstanding citizen, how could such a system possibly be infringing on your rights?

by ansugisalas

from the US.
That shows the absolutely ridiculous amount of "illegal" weapons in the US.
"Illegal" because they're all legal weapons that just somehow changed to the wrong hands.

by hal 9000

But the only reason that it's like that is because someone or some group wants to prevent fast access to information and the most likely reason is that the Baddies want it that way.

Col

by nicknielsen

Preventing the government from using computers reinforces the "Government can't do anything right" refrain because people can point to the inefficiency of not using computers in today's world. The first argument then justifies arguments that there shouldn't be any expansion of what the government is already not doing correctly.

That the NRA not only fully supports, but [u]lobbied for[/u], the current woeful state of affairs at ATF is immaterial in their fallacious arguments.

by charliespencer

Because if they had the sense to change stores, they'd probably be smart enough to have real jobs and be able to afford to buy canoes and paddles instead of stealing them.

They probably figured that since it worked once, it would work every time. Never a good assumption when breaking the law.

by aidemzo_adanac

Actually two. Return to the crime scene and repeat the same crime. DOH! A lot more people would still be out there if they only had some common sense and didn't act on impulse.

by aidemzo_adanac

It's always a debate by "responsible gun owners" that they lock them up properly, don't store them with ammo, are properly 'trained' (by whom, we never know) etc.

But aren't many of the illegally obtained gun stolen, traded, bought etc from thee so called 'responsible gun owners?
Once a responsible gun owner has a gun stolen, they are no longer part of the 'responsible group'. This makes it convenient for their cause because it results in no 'responsible' gun owners having their firearms stolen. Clever indeed, if you are 4 years old.

I know, for sure, that any THING can be stolen. any PLACE can be broken into. It makes no difference how well secured or protected, if someone REALLY wants it or really wants in, they will achieve it. People lock their guns up, they are still stolen. People store ammo in a different place, it's readily acquired anyway. Fact of the matter is, despite the millions of "responsible gun owners" their guns are still stolen, their guns still end up killing people and the problem increases, regardless of their training, expertise and precautions. Clearly they operate on a false sense of security.

Mexicans want US guns because their own just blow up due to poor maintenance, being 100 years old etc. If tens of thousands of PEOPLE, many being women with children and belongings in tow, can infiltrate a border repeatedly, then how secure is the nation itself? Bottom line, it's not. Of course that's Canada's border issue or Mexico's border issue, but surely not US customs.

'America' doesn't look inward for resolutions (or anything else for that matter), only outward. This way people feel safe, though they are misguided into feeling that way. People feel secure, again misguidedly so and people stay in America (much to my enjoyment but also due to being misguided). If more Americans were actually aware that they are lied to daily and practically coerced into staying in America with propaganda based media, the army would dwindle and the government would have no wars to fight...crumbling America.

FEAR, UNCERTAINTY an DOUBT. The biggest killer of any corporate growth and exactly what keeps America functioning under it's tight government control.

This discussion is closed to new replies.