Discussion Locked

Crossing out parts of an application

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Tell us what you think about crossing out sections of an employment application, as featured in Monday's Career Advice e-newsletter. Have you ever selectively filled out an employment application? What information do you refuse to share before an interview?

11 replies

by discordian

when i receive an application to fill out after i have supplied a resume or prior/after an interview, i very rarely fill it out. when i receive these things the person giving it to me usually says "this is just a formality, everyone we hire has to fill one out". to this i say, "your executives and hr personell probably did not, besides, this is a sign that your organization is mired in senseless beauracracy and if this is any indication of what working in your organization is like then i want no part of it. if my first impression is like this, think of how you will tie my hands when i try to offer my skills to help you and you wrap me up in senseless procedures that do not apply to what i do.

i want to work someplace where things make sense and there are not stupid and inane rules that hamper productivity and ruin the creative thinking that usually makes great companies what they are. when companies fall prey to becoming beauractratic machines incapible of any thought process or reason then that company is on the wrong path and won't last long anyways. hardly worth my time at all!

by miket14437

What I would like to know is, how can you determine if they do a background check without your consent.

by t bowman

It's no real likely that they will do a background check w/o your permission.
Number 1, it is illegal.
Number 2, it would be easy to find out.
Simply contact your past managers, employers, references, land lords, etc. Use the pretext that they "may" be contacted and casually ask if they have already been contacted.

Old PI's never die... ;)

by michael - consultant

When presented with an application, I review the information carefully. Most applications are boiler plate and request things like your SS# and Birthdate. Both are not required for hiring a potential employee. Nor can they discriminate based on this information. I have seen more recently that they have the EEOC survey at the end and tell you that it is separated from the application during the interview process and the hiring managers won?t see the survey. (http://www.eeoc.gov/facts/qanda.html)

Salary ranges are another item that you see on applications. I usually will leave these blank as well, so they don?t have a chance to low-ball you when making an offer. Always put Negotiable on salary questions. That information is betweenyou and the hiring manager.

Always be polite about the forms and questionnaires you receive during an interview process. The best advice is know your rights before an offer is made and accepted.

If they do ask for your references and background check, remind them that you don?t want to waste the time of your references unless they are serious about making an offer. As for the background check, I always ask them that I would be happy to fill this out if an offer is pending. Be very simple and polite. Processing these forms both cost the potential employer time and money. Would you really like to work for a company that wastes time and money?

by phil_h

and never had any problems. WHen/if they hire you, they're gonna give you more disclosure forms anyway which you'll have to sign to get the job. Refuse those, and no job.

by tomsal

Back when I was still in High School I used to fill out applications aimlessly providing any information the form asked for.

Today, if you give me an application - I'll still answer about 95% of what's asked of me, but you only get EXACTLY the information that is deemed by *ME* as reasonable for YOU to have. You won't get my SSN number for example, I had one interviewer (mind you it was non-government work too) try and tell me that they require SSN for their records. I said well the federal government says I have the right to not include it on a public sector job application - so I'm not including it.

I do agree with what others say as well and I ALWAYS thought it was STUIPID that you need to fill out an application even if you hand in a resume.

So you spend all this time and put all this thought into creating a very informative, professional looking resume and then they still ask you to fill out an application.

(Funny I thought w/ modern technology the hope was to becomepaperless....lol)

by david o

A job application is a contract. The applicant supplies information about themselves. By signing the application you certify the truthfulness and permit the potential employer to verify the information supplied as well as any other activities thatthe application expressly states the applicant is giving permission to.

After the fact the applicant can plead ignorance and say that they didn't read the fine print. That should hold up in court, because a contract is not valid if both parties have not come to "a meeting of the minds". Why go through that? Cross out the items you do not want to agree to. Be sure to initial at each point where you have crossed items out. Then go ahead and sign it. Request a copy of the application while you're at it.
Keep in mind though that a potential employer (who probably has not read the fine print on the application by the way) may not want to be bothered with somone who crosses stuff out on an application.

by lwood

In today's market, not filling out their required information might be enough for your resume to be shown the waste basket. It is an employers market right now, and I wouldn't be picky over things that are pretty simple to obtain in the first place.If a private investigator wanted your ss# he/she would have it inside a few days-once this is obtained they can search for just about everything they want to know. Very little is private in the technology age.

by david o

As I suggested, a potential employer may not want to bother with an applicant that crosses out items on an application.
It's true that with your soc sec number it's easy to find out pretty well everything there is to know on paper about a person. Privacy is a very precious commodity these days.
The fact is that a potential employer may not perform a background check on an applicant without permission. Would you want to work for an employer that would violate your privacy?

This all comes down to trust. Trust can be earned. Before trust is earned it can be granted on faith. The opposite of trust is suspicion. Neither an applicant nor an employer wish to start from a point of suspicion. Both need to start with trust based on faith. So if you do cross stuff out on a form, you may wish to explain your position.

by webrambler

Although I agree with Nick that an application is not a binding agreement, I'm certain that crossing out a part of the application is a sure way to prevent you from getting the job. An application is a tool used by employers to screen out undesirabale candidates. If you cross out a portion of the application, you're telling an employer that you have something to hide. It's better to leave the sensitive portions blank. That way, if the employer is interested in your qualifications, you may at least be able to obtain an interview.

by prefbid ii

I haven't completely filled out an application since my time in the Army. If the information is already on my resume, I just write "see resume" on the form. I do fill out the name, DOB, address, phone section, but most of the rest is fair game forbeing ignored. I especially hate the salary history part. If they insist and I have an offer in hand, I'll tell them my final salary of my last job, but that is it. If it is pre-interview -- no numbers!

So far I have only had one form come back. They insisted on knowing where I went to High School. So I told them.

This discussion is closed to new replies.