.
By now, you should know me. I like to get the real scoop from the horse's mouth - in this case, Deputy Secretary Armitage's own mouth.
Here we go............
"The future of Iraq, and of the Middle East, matters to the whole world, and that?s why we welcome allies of all shapes and sizes to contribute to the outcome. America is being tested in Iraq, but we welcome this test, we?ll pass this test. And we certainly have no more cherished ally in this crucible than Australia."
Whatever the challenges still ahead, we?re going to stick with this mission until we?ve done what we came to do: give the Iraqi people a fair chance to build a new life, with a legitimate government. Iraq can be a genuine democracy, an Arab democracy that can serve as a model and inspiration for Arabs everywhere. President Reagan said that ?the future belongs to the free,? and he was right. President Bush believes that, Secretary Powell believes that, and I believe that Australians believe that, too.
And if we?re successful, all together, in bringing about Iraq?s emergence as a democracy, what a wonderful thing to bequeath to future generations. Then every Coalition soldier, diplomat, and politician from every country in the Coalition will be able to look in the mirror and say that I, we all, made a difference. And this goes for Australia and the diggers who served, and the people who supported them.
It is not foreign for Australians and Americans to be working together. We?ve been through a lot over the years. Two World Wars, Korea, Vietnam, Operation Earnest Will, the Cold War, the first Gulf War. So it?s no surprise to anyone that Australia is with us today in the Global War on Terrorism, in all its various aspects and theaters.
Some in Australia doubt the wisdom of so close an association with the United States. It?s not an entirely frivolous debate you?re having and it?s not a superficial political joust. Serious, sober-minded Australians have been pondering the matter and come out on various sides. Some question America?s judgment. Some question America?s competence. Some question both and more.
Well, in that you?re just like Americans. We ponder. We debate. We question ourselves ? not least over how Abu Ghraib could have happened, and what we need to do to make sure it never happens again. That?s what liberty under the rule of law is all about, and that?s what Americans enjoy about Australians. You?re strong-willed but good-humored. You?re used to telling the truth, and you expect to hear the truth. You?re suspicious of entrenched power and privilege, and you?re just a little on the irreverent side. Americans and Australians are far more alike than not.
We welcome debate, argument. That ultimately makes our partnership stronger and better. Prime Minister Howard said recently that Australia does not need to choose between its geography and its history. It can acknowledge and honor both. Rather the same can be said for America, so that?s an argument from Australia we like to hear, an argument we embrace.
What we don?t like to hear is the argument that Australia doesn?t really matter to the United States, that Australia is in a corner at the bottom of the world, that Americans don?t care about Australia?s opinion, this way or that.
Not so, mates. You do matter. Australia is a success story, and with success always comes commensurate responsibility. You can?t escape it. Like it or not, you are leaders in your part of the world, and we?re both Asian powers with a common stake in the future of an Asia that is prosperous, democratic, and increasingly at peace.
We?re destined for partnership, in Asia, in the Middle East, and in a whole host of challenges and opportunities that defy narrow geographic definition. We don?t have to agree with one another in all instances. But we need to agree that neither of us shall try to go it alone. Neither of us is safe hiding behind the protection afforded by great oceans. Our alliance is sacred, to be treasured. There?s no avoiding our partnership, so let?s try to make the best of it. And in that process, not just accept whatever fate offers - but take charge of our fates for the assurance of a better future for those who inherit our alliance. An alliance of equality ? not equality of population; not equality of military strength ? but equality of our affection for common ideals and values, and for the belief that we have something special to offer the world and a unique responsibility to do so. And this is why we so often end up in the same place at the same time ? in difficult, sometimes dangerous endeavors ? Values and Ideals.
- Richard L. Armitage, Deputy Secretary of State, June 11, 2004
Remarks to the Australian-American Leadership Dialogue
Oriental Mandarin Hotel
Washington, DC
June 11, 2004
The above excerpts were selectively cut and pasted. For the full text of the speech, see the following link:
http://www.state.gov/s/d/rm/33478.htm
-------------------- More --------------------
In an interview by Maxine McKew Of Australian Broadcasting Corporation's Lateline
Washington, DC
June 9, 2004
.
.
.
.
MS. MCKEW: Okay. Well, you know, certainly, in Australia, this is going to be quite a contentious point in the lead up to the election. Do you agree with President Bush, as he said last week, that the withdrawal of Australian troops, if a Latham government were to come in, would it represent a disaster?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Of course I agree with the President, but I would say, even since the day that he and Mr. Howard stood in the Rose Garden and the President, in answer to a direct question, gave a direct answer, as our President is one to do -- I would say, given the fact that we have a UN Security Council resolution, which puts the international community squarely on the side of Iraq, and, I think, clearly, makes the point that bygones are bygones, I think to walk away now would be almost unthinkable.
MS. MCKEW: In reply, of course, Mark Latham has said that the -- all of the policies, in relation to Iraq, have failed. He talks about the consequences. He said it's meant the diversion on resources from the fighting and the capture of bin Laden. He has pointed to the prisoner atrocities scandal, as providing great propaganda for a more vigorous recruitment campaign. What do you think of that?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I saw a rather interesting press release from the ALP. I think those were some of the points to which you refer. They also seem to think that Australia was made a target by having participated in the war in Iraq, and as I have said before, I was under the impression that Bali happened prior to the invasion of Iraq.
MS. MCKEW: You don't think we're a greater target then?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Pardon me?
MS. MCKEW: You don't think we're a greater target --
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I don't think you (inaudible) --
MS. MCKEW: -- as a result of Iraq?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I don't think you know where the Bali attack emanated from, and whether it was from Afghanistan or whether it was planned somewhere else. You can't pick and choose, I think, with a transnational threat like terror and just limit it to one corner of the earth like Afghanistan. And God knows, the people in Morocco, people in Turkey, people in Thailand, and the Philippines, in Uzbekistan, Spain, they certainly know that, and there are cells all around and we can't limit ourselves to prosecuting a global war on terror in one small corner of the earth.
MS. MCKEW: Mark Latham, of course, separates the alliance issue, or separates Iraq out from the alliances issue. He says it's -- the alliance is bigger than just this one thing. Is that a point that Washington would agree with or not?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Well, I think our alliance, having existed since 1951, is huge and much bigger than any individual issue. Having started down the path together and being within, at least, in reasonable sight of a goal, an Iraq which has a representative government, it would seem to me this is not the time to turn around.
I also noticed in this press release, to which I think you were referring, some of the comments Mr. Latham made about the alliance. I agree, alliance is, is bigger than a lot of things, but he also says it was apparently limited to strategic, whatever that means, and intelligence and cultural, and my own view is it's much more than that. It's about policy, politics and about the economy.
MS. MCKEW: So you're saying you can't separate it out.
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I have said it before. You can't pick and choose. You don't have to agree with us. And, by the way, we don't have to agree with Australia. We can have differences of opinion. We can disagree without being disagreeable, and we've done that in the past. But I don't think you can pick, like, an ala carte menu: I like the intelligence-sharing, but I don't have to talk about global policies; or I like a strategic relationship, but I don't want to be involved in it economically. The world doesn't work that way now.
MS. MCKEW: That would seem to suggest, with both sides locked into these kind of positions -- let's say President Bush is reelected, let's say Mark Latham becomes Prime Minister after the election -- that this could be, if not an alliance-buster, something that will certainly cause a lot of disharmony.
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Well, I can't speak for our Australian friends, but I can speak for Americans. And I can tell you whether Mr. Bush wins or Mr. Kerry wins, that our view of the alliance with Australia is going to be the same. It is not a partisan issue, and it won't be allowed to become a partisan issue. I can't speak for Australians. It takes two to have an alliance. And as much as we want it, and as much as we want to nurture it and have it grow and develop, we can't do it alone.
MS. MCKEW: Of course, the worst scenario would be for Australia to be, say, left out in the cold like New Zealand. Are you saying that's just not remotely possible?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I would have said --
MS. MCKEW: That you could work together with the future Latham government, if that happens?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: In 1981, I would have said it was virtually impossible to consider that we'd be in an AUS alliance and not in an (inaudible) alliance. So I can't see the future. I can only say that for our part we will always sit down and try to be the most reliable, forthright, and transparent partner that we possibly can, but I'll let Australians make their own decision on how they view the alliance and what affection they may hold it in.
MS. MCKEW: There is the question of how we speak as allies. And someone you know very well, Kim Beasley, has said in recent weeks that, in fact, post-Iraq, Australia needs to be the kind of ally that the U.S. needs, as opposed to the one it might want, but we need to find a way to engage in a very meaningful dialogue, even if that's a dissenting dialogue, on some of these big issues. Has he got something?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I don't know. I, for years, sat in on some of these dialogues with Kim and it seemed to me that's exactly the kind of ally we had in Australia. You know, it seems to me that Australians pride themselves in speaking straight, in speaking candidly and frankly. It's almost a national trait and a national treasure, and when Americans speak that way somehow this is not fair. It's not fair to anyone.
MS. MCKEW: Oh, c'mon.
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: We've had the most in-depth, sometimes neuralgic discussions with Australians over the years that one could possibly imagine. We are much better for it. I'll let, as I say, the Australians, successive Australian governments decide if they're better off for it.
MS. MCKEW: Let me ask you why -- let me tell you why I ask that question, and that is, there are a fair number of political junkies in Australia all wading through Bob Woodward's book, Plan of Attack. And what comes through is that, in fact, some of the dissent within the Administration was not necessarily heeded. I mean, one reading of the book would be the fact that you and Colin Powell were seen as voices in the wilderness.
Now, if that's a correct account, what chance* do allies, such as Australia, have of putting a dissenting view?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Nobody -- first of all, nobody forced Australia to participate with us. It's a coalition of the willing. First of all, we didn't drag Australia into this. John Howard made his decision based on what he felt was best for Australia. It wasn't because the Americans were pushing, pushing, pushing.
Regarding the question of what's accurate or not in the book, I think it's fair to say that President Bush is a guy who wants strong voices and strong opinions. This would be a hell of a government if all of us got up in the morning and thought the same thing about every issue. It would be kind of like a mom and dad getting up and always having similar views about how to raise their children without ever discussing them, without ever having differences of opinion. That is not the way the world works, and it's certainly not the way George Bush wants his government to work.
MS. MCKEW: So the book's slightly got it wrong?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: No, the book's a bestseller. That's all I'm saying. (Laughter.) You can decide for yourself whether they've got it right or wrong.
MS. MCKEW: Okay. Just a couple of other points. There has been talk recently between Senator Robert Hill and Donald Rumsfeld about a joint military facility in northern Australia. How do you envisage that?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: That's something that's more correctly addressed to our colleagues in Defense, but this is not something that just popped up. We've had discussions like this for some number of years. At one point in time, we were talking about the possibility of having carriers (inaudible). But the (inaudible) distance made it rather undesirable.
I can't speak to where these discussions are. I can just note that if found favor with the Australian Government and it was a fiscally responsible thing to do and it benefited both nations, then it's something that they should be considering. But I can't speak to just where those discussions are.
MS. MCKEW: Okay. Just one final issue, if I can, and one that's very, important to our region; that is North Korea. In the same week that we've seen this decision by the U.S. to pull some of its troops out of South Korea, equally Prime Minister Koizumi of Japan is saying that he feels Kim Jong-Il is sincere when he stresses the need to dismantle some of the nuclear programs. Do you accept his word*?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: We've had those discussions with Prime Minister Koizumi, and we'll see at the end of June when we have our meetings with North Koreans if the alleged words of Kim Jong-Il are translated into actions by his colleagues at the parts -- at the talks -- excuse me. I'm willing to certainly take the Prime Minister of Japan's words at face value and hope it's the case.
But we are, as we've discussed, we're moving a brigade from Korea because of our needs in Iraq. We have likewise, over the past several years, put in $13 billion of weapons improvements into (inaudible) to make sure that we can fulfill our responsibilities to another ally,
MS. MCKEW: Rich Armitage, for that, thank you very much, indeed.
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Thank you, Ms. McKew.
For the full interview, see the following link:
http://www.state.gov/s/d/rm/33460.htm
-------------------- More --------------------
Interview on Channel 9 Australia's 60 Minutes with Peter Harvey
Washington, DC
May 21, 2004
MR. HARVEY: Richard Armitage, thank you very much for joining us. Your time is very much appreciated. I guess we'll cut to the chase, right from the top.
Can you guarantee, Mr. Armitage, that the two Australians who have been held in Guantanamo Bay now for the best part of two years, haven't suffered any abuse, haven't been beaten up, as is being alleged?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Good evening, Mr. Harvey. I was approached by Michael Thawley, your excellent ambassador, and Ashton Calvert, on this very question yesterday. I am seeking answers and clarifications. I have not found that they were abused in any way, but I'm not running Guantanamo.
I will say, as I understand it, that the defense attorneys of these two people are involved in discussions with military officials here. And if there is any information they have, they ought to turn it over so we can investigate this and get to the bottom of it. I don't think there is any abuse at Guantanamo, but, as I say, I'm not running the prison.
MR. HARVEY: Well, I guess people didn't think there was any abuse in that prison in Baghdad either.
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Well, the ICRC did, didn't they? They reported on it.
MR. HARVEY: That's right, to your government and nothing happened.
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Oh, on the contrary, when Secretary Powell first met Mr. Kellenberger of the ICRC in January of this year, he said that some improvements had been made.
MR. HARVEY: The question of these two people, these two Australians at Guantanamo Bay, has gone right to prime ministerial level here, and the Prime Minister said he was going to raise it himself with U.S. authorities. You have heard, as you say, from our diplomatic people. But have you or anybody else heard from the Prime Minister or the Foreign Minister? Have they raised this directly with you?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: The Prime Minister raised it through his diplomatic representation, made it very clear, that if he wasn't satisfied with the answers, he would raise it during his visit here in the early part of June. Alexander Downer has done the same thing, exactly.
MR. HARVEY: You know, something that intrigues me about this whole issue of the last year or so, I mean, what on earth has gone wrong? The United States and Australia and the coalition went into Iraq with the best of intentions, with the best will in the world to show Iraq and the rest of the world just how decent and fine our system is. What's gone wrong? I mean, what's causing all of this trouble?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Well, it depends on which trouble you mean. If you're talking about the violence in Iraq, I think that's not totally unexpected. As your Prime Minister said in his excellent speech in Melbourne the other evening, if we have democracy come to Iraq, it's the end to everything these terrorists want.
If you're talking about Abu Ghraib and the abuse there, it doesn't intrigue me at all; it horrifies me. And it seemed to me that we had a command climate there that was conducive to this kind of bad behavior. And nobody was taking normal corrective actions, no one was exercising command, and I find that a horrifying specter and I couldn't be angrier about it, and I couldn't be sorrier about it.
MR. HARVEY: The United States military around the world, and especially the contact with the military, the U.S. military that Australians have had over the years, has been pretty fine and pretty decent. I mean, what's happened to that system where reservists can run around, beat people up, and take pictures of it? I mean, what sort of mindset operates there? Do you believe that these people were doing this on their own initiative?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: First of all, you, yourself, have some experience with U.S. forces, both in Vietnam and in the Gulf War, first Gulf War.
MR. HARVEY: That's right.
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: And you know this is not indicative of our armed forces. I don't know what went on at Abu Ghraib, but I can guarantee you that we're going to get to the bottom of it. And once we have gotten to the bottom of it, we'll punish those who are guilty and go as far up the chain as necessary to do so.
MR. HARVEY: All the way up to Donald Rumsfeld, if necessary?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Look, the Secretary of Defense finds this enormously agonizing. He's got a heavy heart about it, and he's as intent at getting to the bottom of it as anyone else.
MR. HARVEY: Okay. On a related issue, there is a lot of debate here about the Australian participation in the coalition of the willing. There is a lobby, a strong lobby saying that Australia should get out. Equally, there are a lot of people here who are saying that we have got to stay the course, that we mustn't cut and run. Would you like to see more Australian troops sent to Iraq? Would you like to see more of a contribution from Australia?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Look, Australians have never cut and run, in my knowledge, and certainly in my experience. And we're not asking for further troop contributions from Australia. Australia stood up when it mattered, did the dirty, hard and dangerous work. You still have soldiers in Iraq, and we couldn't be prouder than to stand alongside of them.
MR. HARVEY: Something I touched on earlier, the relationship between our two countries. I mean, Australia and Americans, as you know better than most people, have been long-time allies and long-time friends. There has always been a great depth of feeling. What's gone wrong? I mean, what's starting to burn the bridges? Or, more appropriately, do you think that bridges are being burned, largely, because of the revelations about the abuse of the prisoners?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: No, I don't think bridges are being burned. Look, we've -- if you look at our long history together, after the Vietnam war, there was a lot of introspection in Australia and in the United States. I can remember back in 1983, when the Labor Government came in, there were commentators on your side speculating the end of the alliance.
We weathered, then, the disappearance of New Zealand from our alliance. These are things we manage because our interest keep us together, and, I must say, I think our principles keep us together. The revelations at Abu Ghraib just sear us. They're a blot or a stain on our own honor, as our President has said, and we have to work our way through this in a uniquely American way.
We've got to investigate it. We've got to talk about it. We've got to find what went wrong, and we've got to punish those who are guilty; and then we have to take remedial action in our services to make sure it does not repeat itself. This is what democracies do.
MR. HARVEY: And you'll go right up the line with that?
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Absolutely. The President would have it no other way.
MR. HARVEY: Thank you. Richard Armitage, thank you very much for your time. It's much appreciated.
DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Thank you, Mr. Harvey.
MR. HARVEY: Thank you.
(The full interview IS posted above)
Source:
http://www.state.gov/s/d/rm/32708.htm
-------------------- More --------------------
Interview by Kerry O?Brien of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Washington, DC
March 17, 2004
http://www.state.gov/s/d/rm/30566.htm
-------------------- More --------------------
Hell, find more for yourself.
-------------------- More --------------------
Go ahead, Julian find the EXACT TEXT of what all the hub-bub is about. No, never mind. I did it for you. I posted the full text and the full context. I must ask, what the HELL is wrong with your media? The interview you posted to begin this discussion contains lies and misrepresentations. Did you bother to go find the full text and the full context? I didn't think so. Geesh, Julian, can't you ever look past the rhetoric and see things for what they really are??????
However, for the life of me, I can't find that China comment - except I did find it on a "blog" Web site, but not a direct quote, just an assertion - and that was from 1999! Can anyone else find it? I would love to see the full text and the full context of that. (Any bets that no one will be able to find it?)
-------------------- Okay, One More --------------------
QUESTION: In relation to Iraq, if a war does break, what sort of commitments does the United States want from Australia?
Armitage: We would like the commitment that Australia would act in her national interest. That's for Australians to determine. It's not for an American visitor to determine.
- Richard L. Armitage, Deputy Secretary of State, Commonwealth Parliamentary Offices, December 13, 2002
--------------------
I'm really beginning to wonder about the international media - especially in Australia. Moreover, I'm really beginning to wonder about the people who are duped into believing such nonsense.