Discussion Locked

Dear Mr Bush. Please mind your own goddamned business

0 helpful
70 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Two former Australian Prime Ministers, Liberal Prime Minister Malcolm Fraser and Labor Prime Minister Paul Keating, have harshly criticised certain members of the Bush administration, notably President Bush and more recently US Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage, for
trying to dictate Autralian foreign policy.

The transcript of an interview with Malcolm Fraser may be read in full at

http://abc.net.au/lateline

It is my considered opinion that, if the formerly happy alliance between the USA and Australia is damaged, it will not be by Mark Latham's Labor Government if he is elected, but by the Bush Administration.

Here is an excerpt from the interview with Malcolm Fraser. A number of other issues are discussed in the interview, which is too long to post in full here.

TONY JONES: Well, returning to our top story.
The US Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage may well be regretting he loosened his tongue.
He's been tagged a thug by one former prime minister, while another has urged him to butt out of Australian politics.
The crudeness of Armitage's public critique of the Labor Party so close to an election has drawn an angry response that's taken the gloss off the PM's attempt to win back the political high ground today with his headland speech Getting the Big Things Right - if one of those big things is Australia's relationship with the US.
The long-serving former Liberal prime minister Malcolm Fraser says the Government's still got work to do.
I spoke to Mr Fraser at his home on the Mornington Peninsula earlier this evening.
TONY JONES: Malcolm Fraser, thanks for joining us.
MALCOLM FRASER, FORMER PRIME MINISTER: Thank you.
TONY JONES: Richard Armitage has now made two forays into Australian politics in the last month.
Has he crossed the line between legitimate commentary and interference?
MALCOLM FRASER: I think Richard Armitage crossed the line quite a long while ago because it's not the first time he's done this.
It's worse because we're approaching an election but he has, on a number of occasions, said, for example, that if there is a war between China and America over Taiwan, Australia would have to do a good deal of the dirty work.
Now that's not his decision to make.
It's Australia's decision as, hopefully, an independent country.
And the intervention, not only of Richard Armitage but his bosses, in our political scene, I think, are quite unforgivable.
TONY JONES: What do you make of Mr Armitage's - sticking with him for a moment - his latest remarks which specifically target the Labor Party, suggesting its "rent down the middle" because of discussions he's apparently had behind the scenes.
He says he knows there are deep divisions in the Labor Party.
What do you make of that kind of commentary?
MALCOLM FRASER: Well, again, it is an intervention in Australian politics.
He's doing it for a very specific purpose - to try and achieve a specific outcome that the United States wants.
If it had been in older times, American officials would have been told to butt out.
If it had happened in Menzies's time or it had happened in my time, ambassadors or State Department officials would be told to keep well clear of Australian domestic politics.
TONY JONES: It's happening in John Howard's time.
Do you believe this PM, this Government, should do something now to halt these interventions?
MALCOLM FRASER: Well, if it were looking after their own interests I think they would, because I believe, from what I've heard people saying, that this is counter-productive from the Government's point of view.
People resent being told what to do by the United States.
Part of that resentment, I think, is a general belief that we have grown too close to the US in the years since the Cold War ended.
TONY JONES: Your views on this administration are pretty well known.
When President Bush first made his comments about Labor's policy a month ago you called that an abuse of power.
But if those concerns, expressed by Australians such as yourself, are getting back to Washington, they're clearly going unheeded.
Why do you think that is?
MALCOLM FRASER: This current American administration is one of a kind.
It is different from every other administration, Democrat or Republican, in the post-war years.
It doesn't really believe in a multilateral world.
It believes in unilateral decision making.
It believes in the United States going its own way as they believe best for the United States and I think they have become intolerant of other countries.
You might well ask why do they interfere in this way in relation to Australia when Canada, a very close neighbour, a defence partner, has, in many ways, been much more provocative.
Canada didn't participate in Vietnam, they didn't participate in Iraq and they have conducted policies in relation to Cuba which are diametrically opposed to the policies that the United States would like to see.
Now, why does America tolerate this with Canada when they behave so crudely in relation to Australia.
TONY JONES: Indeed.
Mr Fraser, I was in fact going to ask you that question because Canada, obviously, shares a border with the US.
It also shares a free trade agreement.
It also has a military alliance, through NATO, with the US - there are many similarities, as you have pointed out. Why do you believe Australia is treated differently to Canada?
MALCOLM FRASER: Canada have, in all the years since the war, made very significant efforts to differentiate itself from the US in certain important ways.
And I think the US, probably, has come to accept this.
But, in more recent times, we have got closer and closer to the US.
We appear to agree with nearly everything they say.
We appear to do everything they want us to do and that's not my idea of Australia.
I don't think that it's an idea of Australia that too many people would support.
TONY JONES: PM Howard appears to be saying the Iraq war case is somewhat unique.
He's strongly defended the President's right to make his position known to Australia on Australian troops and whether they should, or not, be withdrawn early - or before, as he puts it, their job is done.
He's making the case that this actually rises above domestic politics.
Can you make that case?
MALCOLM FRASER: I can't make any case, and I don't want to make any case, which gives the US some superior right to interfere in Australia's domestic affairs and in Australia's political arrangements.
It would be perfectly appropriate, or would have been appropriate, for the American ambassador to say to one of the political parties, without publicity, "We don't like this, for these reasons".
If that was done privately, quietly, without publicity there couldn't be any objection to it.
By publicly siding with one of the parties, with the Coalition against the Opposition, in this particular election, indicates an American attitude to Australia which I just don't like.
They either take us for granted or they regard us with a degree of contempt, because they don't have to behave, or they don't have to accept, the norms of diplomacy.
Take other examples.
The British have been able to get most of their people out of Guantanamo Bay.
The British have said that the justice system set up for the military tribunals is not appropriate, would not be acceptable for nationals of the United Kingdom.
Now, we go along and say, "What they're doing is fine."
Other people can have differences with the United States and be respected for it.
We seem not to have differences with the United States and if there is any sign of independence in Australia the United States wants to stomp on it.
I think it's time they're stopped...
TONY JONES: What are the implications of how you see this interference in an election year?
MALCOLM FRASER: I think the implications will, in the end, be counterproductive because I think a number of Australians will seriously resent this interference.
TONY JONES: You've just mentioned, a moment ago, Guantanamo Bay.
You, I gather, regard the military tribunals as unjust, because we now hear that another Australian citizen, Mr Habib, is to go before a military tribunal.
MALCOLM FRASER: I regard them as unjust as set up by President Bush, because there is no appeal to an independent court and the judge in the military tribunal is somebody chosen from the, as I understand it, from the panel who will make a decision in relation to the case.
So, in the context of Australian law, there isn't an independent president of the court as it were.
It hasn't been sufficiently noticed that the United States Supreme Court, a week or two ago, in a enormously important human rights decision, has said that the United States President has acted beyond his executive power and that people in Guantanamo Bay have the right to appeal to the American judicial system.
Now, this is an enormously important decision.
It means that a very largely Republican-appointed court has seriously reduced the power of a Republican president.

70 replies

by skipperusn

On the same foot Jul - Why don't you mind your own business about the USA - I read loads of your posts and anti-american messages - because you don't like out leader .... To F'en bad mate - Don't get me wrong - the vast majority of Aussie's are a great - but you have some like you that f'it up for the rest of them... If you want us to keep our noses out of your shit - keep yours out of ours ...

by jimhm

Hey - doesn't feel good when people want to tell you how to run your country - does it Jul... So Quit telling the USA how to elect our leaders..

Tit-for-Tat mate...

by oz_media

You see gentlemen, YOU have imposed on others for too long. NOW they are beginning to speak out against you. Other times it has been accepted because it was commonly seen as US nature and simply brushed off "oh it's those Americans again".

These days, your president has made US interests a global interest and people have simply had enough. The USA was always seen as a country that thinks highly of itself and was pusht and classless (no I am not slamming America just letting you know what the general feeling has been for MANY years now, many more than I've been around I'm sure). The people have always been accepted as kind and everything, it's just the air of arrogance that gets under people's skin. Pride is one thing, but as I've said before, poor winners are as bad as poor losers. For the time being you are a self proclaimed supre power, which I know everyone has had a shot at and it simply cannot be sustained forever as many people here will agree but it's almost as if you are TOO proud to be American. People wich you'd just keep America's business as America's business.

So what gives these people the right to speak out about it you ask?
The same right that you have to speak out about their political and even personal affairs. Nobody would disagree with MUCH of what you say about other countries, they also feel the same way. They also realize that EVERY country is completely screwed up in some way, just as everyone but the boss of the company has things they would improve or do differently if they ran it. This is human nature, we are all different and think differently but we try to accept each others faults and understand we are all different, it's not polite to make fun of peple at work, it's not nice to comment on someone's weight or height. Therefore people will not welcome the most 'arrogant' country in the world to try and dictate what they do or don't do right.

One of the most common things I have ever seen an Americn say here is that they have a right to defend themselves or even take premtive action if needed. I will agree whole heartedly and would expect the same from anyone, in fact I hate it when people won't speak out or stick up for themselves.

Any country's citizens would answer a call to arms, we don't need to hear it. Every country has political and legal flaws, we don't need to hear that.

The BIGGEST issue I've seen that people simply reject like a bad organ is that we all know we have flaws and much room for improvement, but if it comes your way, people are considered the enemy, anti-American, jealous or it simply gets rejected and an insult is thrown at them.

Why is it that every country COULD be improved if they listended to America yet you refuse even voilently when people comment on your country or political system?

Mind your own Goddamn business, keep your politics INSIDE your country, stop bad mouthing your enemies if they won't join your game and stop expecting the world to follow you, "one nation" and all that, it's not one world.

So settle down and live your own lives for a while, people may even respect you if they forget about you for a while. You come across like a needy girlfriend that calls you ten times a day and is constantly checking up on you.

by jardinier

Anyone of you who has followed my postings should know by now that the Liberal Party in Australia is actually the conservative party. The (small el) liberal party -- similar to but in no way identical to your Democrat Party is the Australian Labor Party.

I thought I should clarify this for anyone who may think I was posting the words of a "liberal" (usually equated on this website with Leftie or Commie) Prime Minister.

Malcolm Fraser was Prime Minister of the same party as John Howard. Unlike Howard, who is an unscrupulous, unrepentant liar (this relates to domestic issues of which you most likely may be unaware) Fraser was and is a man of integrity and principle.

By posting this interview I am NOT representing the opinion of some commie, leftie. Malcolm Fraser was a highly respected Prime Minister, and that is why I think his views on relations between America and Australia are relevant.

So in this instance it is not myself criticising the American administration, although I could find plenty of reasons to do so, but a highly respected former conservative Prime Minister.

And I DON'T believe that the majority of American peers have deserted these political discussions because they consider them pointless. They started to drop out when the war in Iraq turned sour.

However as I don't give a tinker's dam about the opinions of the few people who continue to haunt this site, I will continue to express views which are shared .... now wait for this ... by most of the people I speak to, and I live in one of the most conservative (Liberal) areas of Australia.

In fact I live in the safest Liberal seat in New South Wales, and the third safest Liberal seat in Australia.

So if you don't like my views, then you had better believe that they are shared by at least 50 per cent of Australians.

by stress junkie

I believe that jul646 has every right to say what he
thinks. Generally, any input is good input. Criticism
isn't anti-American; it's the foundation of our freedom.
I believe that people, like myself, who stand as
outspoken watchdogs on the government are like the
canary in the coal mine. Our criticism may not always
be valid. Nobody is correct all of the time. Some people
are rarely correct. Maybe jul646 and I in that group. I
don't know. But the freedom to criticise is an
absolutely required charateristic of a free society.
Hearing the opinions of people in other countries has
as much value as hearing the opinions of citizens. We
should want to know what our country looks like from
other view points.

As for the details of the original story I believe that
when foreign elected officials make harsh statements
of the United States they are really just posturing to
gain popularity in their own country. I'm more
interested in hearing the opinions of individuals in
other countries than in hearing what elected officials in
other countries say, particularly if they are
campaigning for re-election.

Lastly, if we can believe what we see on television then
I get the impression that Mr. Bush has been pretty
clumsy handling foreign affairs. This may be more
important in the upcoming election because two term
Presidents typically spend their second term focusing
on foreign affairs. It is possible that if Mr. Bush is
re-elected he may do much more damage in the next
four years in this area than he has done in the past 3.5
years.

by jimhm

Mine was meant as a play - if they get upset that our leaders are trying to tell them how they should live run their government. Then - they should do the same thing...

I believe in the freedom of speech - which has protected our freedoms - but when they bitch about our freedom of speech that has critized their government and the whole time they do the same thing about our government ... then I say - buck up Mate - its freedom of speech - if you don't like it being done to you - don't do it to others...

Like your dear sweet mum would say - Do unto others as you want done unto you....

by maxwell edison

.
First of all, no, you can't believe everything you see on television or read in the newspapers. In my opinion, in order to form an accurate view of events, you have to literally go out of your way to become well-informed, and you have to get your information from a variety of sources. A well-balanced view of the world will not present itself by simply watching the standard news programs on television or by reading your local newspaper.

In a different thread, someone suggested that American foreign policy was flawed. I agreed with that assertion, but qualified my agreement by suggesting that in the arena of foreign policy, it will ALWAYS be flawed to some degree by simply considering the dynamics of foreign policy. The USA is not the only country in the world, and events and circumstances are ever-changing. We take foreign policy steps and make some missteps; we get some things right, some wrong; and we are in a constant state of reevaluating policy decisions based on the changing world. This becomes obvious by considering the fact that with any foreign policy decision there are two (or more) players in the game, and we have less (or no) control over the other guy than we have over ourselves. Take Iraq, for example. Did the USA make some foreign policy missteps over the past twenty years? Of course we did, and you could point to Carter, Reagan, Bush, Clinton, and Bush. Take Iraq again, for example. Did the Iraqis make some foreign policy misstemps over the past twenty years? Again, of course they did. Apply the same to any two nations, and the same could be said.

Therefore, with any foreign policy failure, there are at least two (or more) parties that should share the burden of blame. If the Australians are having problems with their foreign policy issues, they should probably look at themselves just as much - if not more - than the USA.

But I forget, the USA is to blame for everything.

And as far as any Bush foreign policy missteps, and I'm sure that even the administration would admit that some have been made, there's no reason to automatically assume that improvements and changes couldn't be made. People learn from their experiences, and they move forward all the wiser, not unlike you and me when we make that occasional misstep. I'd challenge you to name one American administration (or any nation, for that matter), who didn't make some foreign policy misstep. Hind sight, as they say, is 20-20. Quite frankly, I feel much more comfortable placing my faith in people who have been in the thick of things, than I would with the guy on the sidelines simply criticizing everything under the sun for political expediency.

by nd_it

Just like MM. Don't even look for an political or idealistic answer, just looking for the right way to personally slam Bush. Not before anyone else jumps on me, I am not a huge Bush fan, but I don't like hate speech whether it comes from the left or right. I try to keep my mind focused on the idealogy of polictics. I agree with Max, every administration is not going to have a perfect foreign policy agenda. This world changes in minutes it seems like. Not only does our foreign policy change with a new administration, but it also changes when a leader from another country is elected as well.

by stress junkie

I intended my post to focus on the idea that we, as
Americans, should be interested in the opinions of
people outside the United States.

I agree about Bush being a known quantity who may
improve while the other candidates are untested, at
least as far as being President.

I agree about the credibility problem of television news.
I personally don't watch the big network news
programs. I get all of my world information from
Comedy Central's Daily Show with Jon Stewart.

I probably should have limited my post to the main
topic. I tend to mix side issues into my posts. Bad idea.
At least I didn't get overly hyperbolic in this thread. I
guess my medicine is starting to work. :-)

by garion11

What happened to this site? There used to be a LOT more pro-American people that supported America even during and after the war. Don't tell me Oz and his gang of wankers drove them away by their constant barrage of lies, misconceptions, stupidity, arrogance, short-sightedness and truth spinning. What a shame.

by pctech

Max,
I think you covered the topic quite well.Yes, mistakes will always be made and rarely are the mistakes onesided.
The only area that I can offer any opinion is on your statement concerning those that have been through the thick of it as opposed to those on the sidelines. I would not be as readily availble to believe that those that have experienced the thick of it to know how to handle future situations better than those on the sidelines. While hind sight is usually 20/20, this is not limited to those that have experienced the situation personally. Those on the sideline also are afforded the same 20/20 vision and with a greater perspective. While those in the "driver's seat" may adjust well and compensate for past errors, this should not be a foregone conclussion that they will. They are still limited by the narrowed view of a quarterback as opposed to the announcer overlooking the game. Does this imply that the announcer will play a better game? No, it implies that there are approaches they may take that have been overlooked by the quarterback. Joe Montana was arguably the best quarterback ever. He had an excellent ability to "read" the field. Even with this ability, he could not see all that the announcer sees. There is a major difference between sporting games outcomes, except to the true sports nuts, as opposed to world events and their effects. ....... no debate, just an opinion.

by jardinier

I am not sure if your statement:

"As for the details of the original story I believe that when foreign elected officials make harsh statements of the United States they are really just posturing to gain popularity in their own country."

is valid or relevant. Malcom Fraser has long ago retired from Parliament, and in fact Prime Minister John Howard (representing the same party as Fraser) usually scoffs at his views.

So any statements made by former Prime Minister Malcolm Fraser have nothing to do with one or other of the two major parties winning the election.

by maxwell edison

.
By now, you should know me. I like to get the real scoop from the horse's mouth - in this case, Deputy Secretary Armitage's own mouth.

Here we go............

"The future of Iraq, and of the Middle East, matters to the whole world, and that?s why we welcome allies of all shapes and sizes to contribute to the outcome. America is being tested in Iraq, but we welcome this test, we?ll pass this test. And we certainly have no more cherished ally in this crucible than Australia."

Whatever the challenges still ahead, we?re going to stick with this mission until we?ve done what we came to do: give the Iraqi people a fair chance to build a new life, with a legitimate government. Iraq can be a genuine democracy, an Arab democracy that can serve as a model and inspiration for Arabs everywhere. President Reagan said that ?the future belongs to the free,? and he was right. President Bush believes that, Secretary Powell believes that, and I believe that Australians believe that, too.

And if we?re successful, all together, in bringing about Iraq?s emergence as a democracy, what a wonderful thing to bequeath to future generations. Then every Coalition soldier, diplomat, and politician from every country in the Coalition will be able to look in the mirror and say that I, we all, made a difference. And this goes for Australia and the diggers who served, and the people who supported them.

It is not foreign for Australians and Americans to be working together. We?ve been through a lot over the years. Two World Wars, Korea, Vietnam, Operation Earnest Will, the Cold War, the first Gulf War. So it?s no surprise to anyone that Australia is with us today in the Global War on Terrorism, in all its various aspects and theaters.

Some in Australia doubt the wisdom of so close an association with the United States. It?s not an entirely frivolous debate you?re having and it?s not a superficial political joust. Serious, sober-minded Australians have been pondering the matter and come out on various sides. Some question America?s judgment. Some question America?s competence. Some question both and more.

Well, in that you?re just like Americans. We ponder. We debate. We question ourselves ? not least over how Abu Ghraib could have happened, and what we need to do to make sure it never happens again. That?s what liberty under the rule of law is all about, and that?s what Americans enjoy about Australians. You?re strong-willed but good-humored. You?re used to telling the truth, and you expect to hear the truth. You?re suspicious of entrenched power and privilege, and you?re just a little on the irreverent side. Americans and Australians are far more alike than not.

We welcome debate, argument. That ultimately makes our partnership stronger and better. Prime Minister Howard said recently that Australia does not need to choose between its geography and its history. It can acknowledge and honor both. Rather the same can be said for America, so that?s an argument from Australia we like to hear, an argument we embrace.

What we don?t like to hear is the argument that Australia doesn?t really matter to the United States, that Australia is in a corner at the bottom of the world, that Americans don?t care about Australia?s opinion, this way or that.

Not so, mates. You do matter. Australia is a success story, and with success always comes commensurate responsibility. You can?t escape it. Like it or not, you are leaders in your part of the world, and we?re both Asian powers with a common stake in the future of an Asia that is prosperous, democratic, and increasingly at peace.

We?re destined for partnership, in Asia, in the Middle East, and in a whole host of challenges and opportunities that defy narrow geographic definition. We don?t have to agree with one another in all instances. But we need to agree that neither of us shall try to go it alone. Neither of us is safe hiding behind the protection afforded by great oceans. Our alliance is sacred, to be treasured. There?s no avoiding our partnership, so let?s try to make the best of it. And in that process, not just accept whatever fate offers - but take charge of our fates for the assurance of a better future for those who inherit our alliance. An alliance of equality ? not equality of population; not equality of military strength ? but equality of our affection for common ideals and values, and for the belief that we have something special to offer the world and a unique responsibility to do so. And this is why we so often end up in the same place at the same time ? in difficult, sometimes dangerous endeavors ? Values and Ideals.

- Richard L. Armitage, Deputy Secretary of State, June 11, 2004

Remarks to the Australian-American Leadership Dialogue

Oriental Mandarin Hotel
Washington, DC
June 11, 2004

The above excerpts were selectively cut and pasted. For the full text of the speech, see the following link:

http://www.state.gov/s/d/rm/33478.htm

-------------------- More --------------------

In an interview by Maxine McKew Of Australian Broadcasting Corporation's Lateline

Washington, DC
June 9, 2004

.
.
.
.
MS. MCKEW: Okay. Well, you know, certainly, in Australia, this is going to be quite a contentious point in the lead up to the election. Do you agree with President Bush, as he said last week, that the withdrawal of Australian troops, if a Latham government were to come in, would it represent a disaster?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Of course I agree with the President, but I would say, even since the day that he and Mr. Howard stood in the Rose Garden and the President, in answer to a direct question, gave a direct answer, as our President is one to do -- I would say, given the fact that we have a UN Security Council resolution, which puts the international community squarely on the side of Iraq, and, I think, clearly, makes the point that bygones are bygones, I think to walk away now would be almost unthinkable.

MS. MCKEW: In reply, of course, Mark Latham has said that the -- all of the policies, in relation to Iraq, have failed. He talks about the consequences. He said it's meant the diversion on resources from the fighting and the capture of bin Laden. He has pointed to the prisoner atrocities scandal, as providing great propaganda for a more vigorous recruitment campaign. What do you think of that?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I saw a rather interesting press release from the ALP. I think those were some of the points to which you refer. They also seem to think that Australia was made a target by having participated in the war in Iraq, and as I have said before, I was under the impression that Bali happened prior to the invasion of Iraq.

MS. MCKEW: You don't think we're a greater target then?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Pardon me?

MS. MCKEW: You don't think we're a greater target --

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I don't think you (inaudible) --

MS. MCKEW: -- as a result of Iraq?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I don't think you know where the Bali attack emanated from, and whether it was from Afghanistan or whether it was planned somewhere else. You can't pick and choose, I think, with a transnational threat like terror and just limit it to one corner of the earth like Afghanistan. And God knows, the people in Morocco, people in Turkey, people in Thailand, and the Philippines, in Uzbekistan, Spain, they certainly know that, and there are cells all around and we can't limit ourselves to prosecuting a global war on terror in one small corner of the earth.

MS. MCKEW: Mark Latham, of course, separates the alliance issue, or separates Iraq out from the alliances issue. He says it's -- the alliance is bigger than just this one thing. Is that a point that Washington would agree with or not?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Well, I think our alliance, having existed since 1951, is huge and much bigger than any individual issue. Having started down the path together and being within, at least, in reasonable sight of a goal, an Iraq which has a representative government, it would seem to me this is not the time to turn around.

I also noticed in this press release, to which I think you were referring, some of the comments Mr. Latham made about the alliance. I agree, alliance is, is bigger than a lot of things, but he also says it was apparently limited to strategic, whatever that means, and intelligence and cultural, and my own view is it's much more than that. It's about policy, politics and about the economy.

MS. MCKEW: So you're saying you can't separate it out.

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I have said it before. You can't pick and choose. You don't have to agree with us. And, by the way, we don't have to agree with Australia. We can have differences of opinion. We can disagree without being disagreeable, and we've done that in the past. But I don't think you can pick, like, an ala carte menu: I like the intelligence-sharing, but I don't have to talk about global policies; or I like a strategic relationship, but I don't want to be involved in it economically. The world doesn't work that way now.

MS. MCKEW: That would seem to suggest, with both sides locked into these kind of positions -- let's say President Bush is reelected, let's say Mark Latham becomes Prime Minister after the election -- that this could be, if not an alliance-buster, something that will certainly cause a lot of disharmony.

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Well, I can't speak for our Australian friends, but I can speak for Americans. And I can tell you whether Mr. Bush wins or Mr. Kerry wins, that our view of the alliance with Australia is going to be the same. It is not a partisan issue, and it won't be allowed to become a partisan issue. I can't speak for Australians. It takes two to have an alliance. And as much as we want it, and as much as we want to nurture it and have it grow and develop, we can't do it alone.

MS. MCKEW: Of course, the worst scenario would be for Australia to be, say, left out in the cold like New Zealand. Are you saying that's just not remotely possible?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I would have said --

MS. MCKEW: That you could work together with the future Latham government, if that happens?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: In 1981, I would have said it was virtually impossible to consider that we'd be in an AUS alliance and not in an (inaudible) alliance. So I can't see the future. I can only say that for our part we will always sit down and try to be the most reliable, forthright, and transparent partner that we possibly can, but I'll let Australians make their own decision on how they view the alliance and what affection they may hold it in.

MS. MCKEW: There is the question of how we speak as allies. And someone you know very well, Kim Beasley, has said in recent weeks that, in fact, post-Iraq, Australia needs to be the kind of ally that the U.S. needs, as opposed to the one it might want, but we need to find a way to engage in a very meaningful dialogue, even if that's a dissenting dialogue, on some of these big issues. Has he got something?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: I don't know. I, for years, sat in on some of these dialogues with Kim and it seemed to me that's exactly the kind of ally we had in Australia. You know, it seems to me that Australians pride themselves in speaking straight, in speaking candidly and frankly. It's almost a national trait and a national treasure, and when Americans speak that way somehow this is not fair. It's not fair to anyone.

MS. MCKEW: Oh, c'mon.

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: We've had the most in-depth, sometimes neuralgic discussions with Australians over the years that one could possibly imagine. We are much better for it. I'll let, as I say, the Australians, successive Australian governments decide if they're better off for it.

MS. MCKEW: Let me ask you why -- let me tell you why I ask that question, and that is, there are a fair number of political junkies in Australia all wading through Bob Woodward's book, Plan of Attack. And what comes through is that, in fact, some of the dissent within the Administration was not necessarily heeded. I mean, one reading of the book would be the fact that you and Colin Powell were seen as voices in the wilderness.

Now, if that's a correct account, what chance* do allies, such as Australia, have of putting a dissenting view?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Nobody -- first of all, nobody forced Australia to participate with us. It's a coalition of the willing. First of all, we didn't drag Australia into this. John Howard made his decision based on what he felt was best for Australia. It wasn't because the Americans were pushing, pushing, pushing.

Regarding the question of what's accurate or not in the book, I think it's fair to say that President Bush is a guy who wants strong voices and strong opinions. This would be a hell of a government if all of us got up in the morning and thought the same thing about every issue. It would be kind of like a mom and dad getting up and always having similar views about how to raise their children without ever discussing them, without ever having differences of opinion. That is not the way the world works, and it's certainly not the way George Bush wants his government to work.

MS. MCKEW: So the book's slightly got it wrong?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: No, the book's a bestseller. That's all I'm saying. (Laughter.) You can decide for yourself whether they've got it right or wrong.

MS. MCKEW: Okay. Just a couple of other points. There has been talk recently between Senator Robert Hill and Donald Rumsfeld about a joint military facility in northern Australia. How do you envisage that?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: That's something that's more correctly addressed to our colleagues in Defense, but this is not something that just popped up. We've had discussions like this for some number of years. At one point in time, we were talking about the possibility of having carriers (inaudible). But the (inaudible) distance made it rather undesirable.

I can't speak to where these discussions are. I can just note that if found favor with the Australian Government and it was a fiscally responsible thing to do and it benefited both nations, then it's something that they should be considering. But I can't speak to just where those discussions are.

MS. MCKEW: Okay. Just one final issue, if I can, and one that's very, important to our region; that is North Korea. In the same week that we've seen this decision by the U.S. to pull some of its troops out of South Korea, equally Prime Minister Koizumi of Japan is saying that he feels Kim Jong-Il is sincere when he stresses the need to dismantle some of the nuclear programs. Do you accept his word*?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: We've had those discussions with Prime Minister Koizumi, and we'll see at the end of June when we have our meetings with North Koreans if the alleged words of Kim Jong-Il are translated into actions by his colleagues at the parts -- at the talks -- excuse me. I'm willing to certainly take the Prime Minister of Japan's words at face value and hope it's the case.

But we are, as we've discussed, we're moving a brigade from Korea because of our needs in Iraq. We have likewise, over the past several years, put in $13 billion of weapons improvements into (inaudible) to make sure that we can fulfill our responsibilities to another ally,

MS. MCKEW: Rich Armitage, for that, thank you very much, indeed.

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Thank you, Ms. McKew.

For the full interview, see the following link:

http://www.state.gov/s/d/rm/33460.htm

-------------------- More --------------------

Interview on Channel 9 Australia's 60 Minutes with Peter Harvey
Washington, DC
May 21, 2004

MR. HARVEY: Richard Armitage, thank you very much for joining us. Your time is very much appreciated. I guess we'll cut to the chase, right from the top.

Can you guarantee, Mr. Armitage, that the two Australians who have been held in Guantanamo Bay now for the best part of two years, haven't suffered any abuse, haven't been beaten up, as is being alleged?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Good evening, Mr. Harvey. I was approached by Michael Thawley, your excellent ambassador, and Ashton Calvert, on this very question yesterday. I am seeking answers and clarifications. I have not found that they were abused in any way, but I'm not running Guantanamo.

I will say, as I understand it, that the defense attorneys of these two people are involved in discussions with military officials here. And if there is any information they have, they ought to turn it over so we can investigate this and get to the bottom of it. I don't think there is any abuse at Guantanamo, but, as I say, I'm not running the prison.

MR. HARVEY: Well, I guess people didn't think there was any abuse in that prison in Baghdad either.

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Well, the ICRC did, didn't they? They reported on it.

MR. HARVEY: That's right, to your government and nothing happened.

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Oh, on the contrary, when Secretary Powell first met Mr. Kellenberger of the ICRC in January of this year, he said that some improvements had been made.

MR. HARVEY: The question of these two people, these two Australians at Guantanamo Bay, has gone right to prime ministerial level here, and the Prime Minister said he was going to raise it himself with U.S. authorities. You have heard, as you say, from our diplomatic people. But have you or anybody else heard from the Prime Minister or the Foreign Minister? Have they raised this directly with you?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: The Prime Minister raised it through his diplomatic representation, made it very clear, that if he wasn't satisfied with the answers, he would raise it during his visit here in the early part of June. Alexander Downer has done the same thing, exactly.

MR. HARVEY: You know, something that intrigues me about this whole issue of the last year or so, I mean, what on earth has gone wrong? The United States and Australia and the coalition went into Iraq with the best of intentions, with the best will in the world to show Iraq and the rest of the world just how decent and fine our system is. What's gone wrong? I mean, what's causing all of this trouble?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Well, it depends on which trouble you mean. If you're talking about the violence in Iraq, I think that's not totally unexpected. As your Prime Minister said in his excellent speech in Melbourne the other evening, if we have democracy come to Iraq, it's the end to everything these terrorists want.

If you're talking about Abu Ghraib and the abuse there, it doesn't intrigue me at all; it horrifies me. And it seemed to me that we had a command climate there that was conducive to this kind of bad behavior. And nobody was taking normal corrective actions, no one was exercising command, and I find that a horrifying specter and I couldn't be angrier about it, and I couldn't be sorrier about it.

MR. HARVEY: The United States military around the world, and especially the contact with the military, the U.S. military that Australians have had over the years, has been pretty fine and pretty decent. I mean, what's happened to that system where reservists can run around, beat people up, and take pictures of it? I mean, what sort of mindset operates there? Do you believe that these people were doing this on their own initiative?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: First of all, you, yourself, have some experience with U.S. forces, both in Vietnam and in the Gulf War, first Gulf War.

MR. HARVEY: That's right.

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: And you know this is not indicative of our armed forces. I don't know what went on at Abu Ghraib, but I can guarantee you that we're going to get to the bottom of it. And once we have gotten to the bottom of it, we'll punish those who are guilty and go as far up the chain as necessary to do so.

MR. HARVEY: All the way up to Donald Rumsfeld, if necessary?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Look, the Secretary of Defense finds this enormously agonizing. He's got a heavy heart about it, and he's as intent at getting to the bottom of it as anyone else.

MR. HARVEY: Okay. On a related issue, there is a lot of debate here about the Australian participation in the coalition of the willing. There is a lobby, a strong lobby saying that Australia should get out. Equally, there are a lot of people here who are saying that we have got to stay the course, that we mustn't cut and run. Would you like to see more Australian troops sent to Iraq? Would you like to see more of a contribution from Australia?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Look, Australians have never cut and run, in my knowledge, and certainly in my experience. And we're not asking for further troop contributions from Australia. Australia stood up when it mattered, did the dirty, hard and dangerous work. You still have soldiers in Iraq, and we couldn't be prouder than to stand alongside of them.

MR. HARVEY: Something I touched on earlier, the relationship between our two countries. I mean, Australia and Americans, as you know better than most people, have been long-time allies and long-time friends. There has always been a great depth of feeling. What's gone wrong? I mean, what's starting to burn the bridges? Or, more appropriately, do you think that bridges are being burned, largely, because of the revelations about the abuse of the prisoners?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: No, I don't think bridges are being burned. Look, we've -- if you look at our long history together, after the Vietnam war, there was a lot of introspection in Australia and in the United States. I can remember back in 1983, when the Labor Government came in, there were commentators on your side speculating the end of the alliance.

We weathered, then, the disappearance of New Zealand from our alliance. These are things we manage because our interest keep us together, and, I must say, I think our principles keep us together. The revelations at Abu Ghraib just sear us. They're a blot or a stain on our own honor, as our President has said, and we have to work our way through this in a uniquely American way.

We've got to investigate it. We've got to talk about it. We've got to find what went wrong, and we've got to punish those who are guilty; and then we have to take remedial action in our services to make sure it does not repeat itself. This is what democracies do.

MR. HARVEY: And you'll go right up the line with that?

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Absolutely. The President would have it no other way.

MR. HARVEY: Thank you. Richard Armitage, thank you very much for your time. It's much appreciated.

DEPUTY SECRETARY ARMITAGE: Thank you, Mr. Harvey.

MR. HARVEY: Thank you.

(The full interview IS posted above)

Source:

http://www.state.gov/s/d/rm/32708.htm

-------------------- More --------------------

Interview by Kerry O?Brien of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Washington, DC
March 17, 2004

http://www.state.gov/s/d/rm/30566.htm

-------------------- More --------------------

Hell, find more for yourself.

-------------------- More --------------------

Go ahead, Julian find the EXACT TEXT of what all the hub-bub is about. No, never mind. I did it for you. I posted the full text and the full context. I must ask, what the HELL is wrong with your media? The interview you posted to begin this discussion contains lies and misrepresentations. Did you bother to go find the full text and the full context? I didn't think so. Geesh, Julian, can't you ever look past the rhetoric and see things for what they really are??????

However, for the life of me, I can't find that China comment - except I did find it on a "blog" Web site, but not a direct quote, just an assertion - and that was from 1999! Can anyone else find it? I would love to see the full text and the full context of that. (Any bets that no one will be able to find it?)

-------------------- Okay, One More --------------------

QUESTION: In relation to Iraq, if a war does break, what sort of commitments does the United States want from Australia?

Armitage: We would like the commitment that Australia would act in her national interest. That's for Australians to determine. It's not for an American visitor to determine.

- Richard L. Armitage, Deputy Secretary of State, Commonwealth Parliamentary Offices, December 13, 2002

--------------------

I'm really beginning to wonder about the international media - especially in Australia. Moreover, I'm really beginning to wonder about the people who are duped into believing such nonsense.

by garion11

After reading Jules's post (if you wanna call it that, LIES and MISREPRESETATIONS is closer to the truth) and Max's the question I gotta ask is Are you kidding me?

You know I am thinking that US is hurt because there is no more USSR. Yeah they were truly evil when they were around, but other countries had a reason to support the US, now they think we are the next Soviet Union. They think we are out to conquer the world or something so they are scared (thats the only logical explanation for I can come up with). Wow, this makes me think that IF they were a hyper power, they would try to conquer the world. What an evil mentality and YOU ARE POINTING fingers?

by maxwell edison

.
If anything, Deputy Secretary of State, Richard L. Armitage's words about the Australians were kind, complimentary, and filled with admiration for them, both as people and their values.

I have a saying about people who take an ounce of truth and spin it into a pound of lies. In this case, however, there doesn't seem to be any truth to the story to begin with. How they came up with that conclusion based on the real words and sentiment that was uttered, I have no idea. I simply can't imagine.

I spent about two hours reading everything I could find even remotely related to him and Australia. The stuff I posted was consistent with everything he's ever said. Man, you say nice things about people, and they turn around and stab you in the back.

This is really beginning to be quite sad.

by maxwell edison

.
I get emails from some if them on occasion. There used to be quite a few, but they simply don't waste their time anymore. Actually, I wonder why I do.

by oz_media

It seems that Republicans just won't accept that Democrats have an opnion and are entitled to it. That people in other countries also have American politics as a part of their lives and don't like it.

In response to Garion, I remember a time when there was mainly Pro-Rpublican people here too, many who were opposed felt stifled by the one sided support, and many still do as said in peer mail I have received stating as such.

Perhaps it's just the turn of tides people didn't like, or else just like the rest of the world, they are simply tired of this whole GWB/Iraq thing, TV, Newspapers, Magazines, Radio, Billboards, and now even TR is inundated with this war.

I still wouldn't agree that this forum isn't balanced in it's support for GWB or against, I think it goes back and forth depending on interest and neither pro or against has 'outnumbered' the other.

by maxwell edison

.
The reason these discussions go nowhere, except to the point of exasperation and name-calling, is because you (and others) continue to lay claims that have either been previously dispelled or shown to be incorrect, or you won't apply the same sentiment to yourself.

Your first sentence is only one such case in point. You said, "It seems that Republicans just won't accept that Democrats have an opinion and are entitled to it."

You've probably repeated that sentiment dozens of times, in one way or the other.

What a silly thing to say. Of course Democrats have an opinion and are entitled to it. I don't think anyone would disagree with that. (Gee, I'll even go out on a limb, here, and presume to speak for all Republicans.) Now will you agree to accept my concession on that point and never repeat it again? Of course you won't. You will repeat it again, and again, and again, and again...........

Moreover, while you make such a ludicrous assertion on one hand, on the other, you won't show the same consideration to those who ALSO have an opinion and are entitled to it. Of course the Democrats have an opinion and are entitled to it. But ALSO, of course, other people have an opinion and are entitled to disagree.

And when you start a message in such a way, presumably building your argument on such a statement, the rest of your message is easily dismissed as pure nonsense, since that's the way you initially started it.

Do you not agree that that statement is absolutely ridiculous? Do you not agree that that statement is false? Will you further agree to never repeat it, since we now know it's not true?

(I could point out dozens of similar assertions that "should have been" put to rest, but they go on, and on, and on, and on............the same false assertion repeated over and over again.)

Hey, I say this in all seriousness and sincerity. It's things like this that lead me to believe that it's not possible to have a genuine discussion with you (and others), because you continue to make such false assertions.

Perhaps we should have a "point taken" data base that automatically filters out all the points you've made that have been successfully challenged and/or disproved, and should have been put to rest, and instead puts a bunch of ****** in its place. So the next time, for example, that you say "It seems that Republicans just won't accept that Democrats have an opinion and are entitled to it", or something similar, all that appears on the screen is *************************************************************************************************

by stress junkie

I think it's a simple case of human nature. The United
States is currently the only country capable of
providing leadership backed by strength. I think most
people in the world want that. But there is something
in human nature that causes people in a relationship
to squabble. You see in in husband/wife relationships,
sibling relationships, friends, teams of people in work,
all levels of human relationships. Also, as mentioned
previously, I don't take anything seriously that is said
by people running for political office in other countries.
Their comments are for the local audience to gain
votes.

by oz_media

I also understand human nature that makes people desire to have strength and leadership. IN MOST cases, almost all, this is a sign of insecurity. Just as kids are bullies because they are uinsecure, husband belittle and demean their wives or women in general in an attempt to demobstrate control and superiority. It's just another way of filling the the holes and fulfilling ones desires.

There are more than several 'types' of serial murderer that are known to have not achieved this personal fulfillment and lack self-confidence.

During the hippie years, this was known as 'finding yourself', people used LSD to look within themselves and start to feel more 'comfortable with themselves' as we say nowadays.

This is generally overcome as we mature yet there are always the guys who will play testoreone junkie forever without ever realizing they are themsevles quite insecure, often due to a lack of personal success.

I really don't think that is the issue with people's opinion of the US though. certainly there are some who just abhor power and success but in an adult population they are fewer and fewer.

Once a person has 'found themself' they will often see the very silly and negative attitudes of those that haven't and will become sick of the 'peacock', as it struts and flares its feathers, and begin to with that it would just get over itself.

You know when you are out and see some 40 year old guy (not old but grown up supposedly) who has the trophy wife, a strut in his step and thinks he's a 16 year old high school kid with the cheerleader? This guy still hasn't become comfotable with wo he is and is still insecure about where he is in life.

Then the more milder form we call mid-life crisis, the rush to gain all your youthful dreams that you couldn't get when you were 18.

Based on the above (sorry it is such a long post however condensed)you could actually say the exacy opposite has happened to create so much dislike toward US foreign policies.

Instead of people WANTING power, I think others are more secure in their countries and there place in the world, they don't WANT to be a super power and simply get sick of those who do and wish to flaunt it. It's not that they don't accept your differences, it's that they are tired of hearing about it and seeing the 'peacock' strut.

I live in Canadam a VERY neutral and non offensive country and the people here LIKE it that way, they don't want our leaders to have that much power as thay don't trust them with it. Should we face an attack or attempted invasion, then yes we with our allies support will create a substantial force and do all that we can to prevent it, nobody will stand by while another ally is attacked. Until then, we just want to let things be and live our lives, keep the politicians pushing paper in their offices.

So while I think your psychology is accurate, the application is not. Your statement also implies in itself (although I am sure not intentionally) that once again, Americans feel that the world is jealous of America, maybe the national bird and motto should be Proud as a Peacock, not just NBC's.

by maxwell edison

.
When the Australian Prime Minister, John Howard, was in Washington D.C recently, an Australian reporter (Note: Emphasis placed on the fact this was an Australian reporter), who was covering the Prime Minister's visit to the United States, asked President Bush to comment on Mark Latham's pledge to withdraw Australian troops from Iraq by Christmas if his Labor Party wins elections due for later this year.

Here is the full and unedited text of President Bush's answer:

"That would be disastrous. It would be a disastrous decision for the leader of a great country like Australia to say that 'we're pulling out'. Terrorists think that the Western world, the free world, is weak, that when times get tough, we will shirk our duty to those who long for freedom and we?ll leave. It would dispirit those who love freedom in Iraq. It would say that the Australian government doesn't see the hope of a free and democratic society leading to a peaceful world."

Hey, he was asked a question by an Australian, and he answered it frankly and honestly, just like an Australian would do himself AND expect from others.

Consider this, how could President Bush have better answered that question?

Consider this, was it a "set-up" question in search for a sensational headline to stir-up even more anti-Bush sentiment?

What were the following headlines? Here are just some of them:

--------------------

Bush accused of meddling in Aust politics

US told to 'butt out' of Aussie politics

Bush lashes Latham over Iraq

Australian opposition slams "thuggish and dumb" US criticism on Iraq

And my favorite from The Sydney Morning Herald:

Bush warns Latham on Iraq pullout

US President George Bush has delivered an unprecedented blow to the Labor Party, describing Mark Latham's policy of withdrawing Australian troops from Iraq as 'disastrous'

--------------------

And consider this, Mark Latham himself called President Bush "dangerous and incompetent" (gee, in our own election season), and has continually refused to back down from his comments. Current Australian Prime Minister John Howard (correctly) pointed out that "Mr. Latham's attack on Bush was hardly being diplomatic and gentle". Mr. Howard also (correctly) accused Mr. Latham of being "hypocritical and super-sensitive".

I smell a double-standard being applied here.

And I smell a question being asked in search for a controversy.

by maxwell edison

.
Of course, the infamous Sydney Morning Hearld had to editorialize that headline as well.

Bush rival joins Latham attack

http://fairuse.1accesshost.com/news1/smh2.htm

--------------------

Another interesting tidbit:

"It's OK for him to say George Bush is the most dangerous and incompetent president in living memory, but dear me, if anybody says anything nasty about his party from the American side, they're wrong, they're interfering, they should butt out. I mean, really, that is a double standard."

- Australian Prime Minister John Howard

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/common/story_page/0,5744,10093431%255E2702,00.html

--------------------

I think I'll send a big campaign donation to John Howard. (However, I would imagine that he couldn't accept $$ from an American.)

by garion11

Some of our more "enlightened" personalities on this forum can't see the SPIN and HALF TRUTHS? Or its possible that they are truth spinners themselves who choose not to see it. After all one crook doesn't see what the other crook is doing as wrong. I mean come on, look what Bush answered and look what the Austrlian newspapers reported, its hitting you right in the face with such false headlines. Any comments?

by maxwell edison

.
It's called starting from a predetermined and desired outcome, and working backwards to find justification to support it. It doesn't matter how much it has to be "streeeeeeeeeeeeeeetched" out of proportion, the important thing is proving (and I use that word lightly) the desired outcome, even if it means a trip into la-la land.

by jardinier

According to whose opinion? Why, Maxwell Edison's of course. I do not recall any other member of this website ever singling out the Sydney Morning Herald for special attention.

I suppose if it were the Melbourne Age (another Fairfax publication) that I had worked for, you would have found that paper especially disingenuous (a very derogatory term which I had never encountered in my life until you started using this word in your personal attacks on my character and integrity).

The Sydney Morning Herald was, is and always has been one of the most highly respected newspapers in Australia.

One of the things in my life for which I am most grateful is that I trained as a journalist on this newspaper in the early 60s, when grammar and syntax were considered almost as important as facts.

I am proud to have worked on that newspaper, as I am still proud to describe myself as a former Sydney Morning Herald journalist.

Perhaps you can point me to a mainstream American newspaper which you consider is less biased and disingenuous than the SMH.

And as for that question put to George Bush, it was obviously a setup. Rupert Murdoch owns The Australian, and in fact he founded that newspaper.
Murdoch wants Howard re-elected. Blind Freddie could see that the question was a setup.

And George Bush DID NOT have to answer the question in the way that he did. He merely had to say: "It is not appropriate for me to comment publicly on the foreign policy of another sovereign nation."

In a discussion which I started at the time, I seem to recall that, whatever peers may have thought about the meat of the comment, not one failed to agree that it was inappropriate for George Bush to answer the question as he did.

by garion11

And George Bush DID NOT have to answer the question in the way that he did. He merely had to say: "It is not appropriate for me to comment publicly on the foreign policy of another sovereign nation."

The issue wasn't that he didn't have to comment on it, but the SPIN your media put on his opinion. You took it to the next level to say THAT HE IS DICTATING AUSTRALIAN FOREIGN POLICY? WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!??????????

Another thing is, its the most innocent comment in the world unless you don't know English properly.

"That would be disastrous. It would be a disastrous decision for the leader of a great country like Australia to say that 'we're pulling out'. Terrorists think that the Western world, the free world, is weak, that when times get tough, we will shirk our duty to those who long for freedom and we?ll leave. It would dispirit those who love freedom in Iraq. It would say that the Australian government doesn't see the hope of a free and democratic society leading to a peaceful world."

Now tell me where in that quote does it say, AUSTRALIA SHOULD DO THIS...Australia shouldn't do this...meaning...Where did GWB DICTATE AUSTRALIAN foreign policy in that quote?? Unless you have a different meaning for dicate.

Which brings me to my second point, even IF GWB refused to answer that question...The headlines in Australia will explode with such ferocity...

"BUSH DICTATES AUSTRALIAN POLICY WITH HIS SILENCE"

"Bush and his silence...Australian government is on its toes"

"Bush tells a Kangaroo how to hop with his silence. How dare he?"

"Bush and his administration sent a message to Latham"

"Silence speaks louder than words"

"American arrogance is seen not heard"

What a spin!!! Yet the enlightened ones here are calling the American media biased??

by maxwell edison

.
......."It is not appropriate for me to comment publicly on the foreign policy of another sovereign nation."

by oz_media

"Just another left extremist hate speech
Just like MM. Don't even look for an political or idealistic answer, just looking for the right way to personally slam Bush."

This says it in a nutsehll. You see the right wing as correct and the left as extremists, yet in another country you must understand that this could be exactly opposite. Some countries will be happier and more productive as what you deem extremist left wingers and would see the right wing as the extremists. Like they say, "whatever floats your boat".

You have just shown that you will completely discount any opinion that doesn't favour your own, and unfortunately thst is a common statement from the US as seen through other eyes. As I've mentioned before, it seems you have a need for segregation through political view. If someone doesn't see and agree with how YOU think the country should be run, they are the enemy.

by garion11

Did you even read the posts by Max on EXACTLY what Armitage said? Other countries think the exact same way as well, its human nature if you will. But I dunno where you got the impression that leads to the quote "if someone doesn't see and agree with how YOU think the country should be run, they are the enemy"

You are very far from the truth, the post by Max and the respect he showed to Australian politics says a LOT. I think you are beginning to watch too much Al Jazeera, which leads me to believe you want to hear bad things about US. As far as being self proclaimed super power, its not true. How did you come up with that statement? Super power based on what? Wasn't Chirac the one that called US a hyperpower?

It makes me wonder where you get your crap from.

by oz_media

I get all these inflated egos of America from guys just like you. Now if you paid attention, you would notice exectly how your personality type is what causes other countries to see America the way they do and for why people such as yourself just don't understand why.

My post wasn't directed at you OR Max, yet somehow you feel an urge once again to make noise, sit down kid you don't make sense.

by nd_it

I think some American felt that way at some point after 9/11. I did take it personal and applauded Bush for his actions to go after the Taliban and put an ultimatium to other countries to say whether they are with us, or against us. I know just as much as the next, that Canada, Britain, France, Russia, etc are with us on the war on terror. I agree with you in the fact that we do feel the need to have a separation of political views, we have that in America, it's called political parties, it's what makes a democracy what it is. And I for one, don't oppose someone else for speaking out against the US, I don't think they are the enemy. It's the political hate speech that I don't care for.

by garion11

Who are you tell me to sit down anyway? Its because of people like you that Americans feel the "world" is being arrogant. But I guess you can only see the anti-American opinion or choose to.

by maxwell edison

.
I would assume that accepting money from foreigners is covered by Australian campaign laws, as it is in the USA, but the extent to which it may or may not be disallowed is unknown to me.

by maxwell edison

.
It is so obvious that Julian literally worked himself into a frenzy over a news story (Can we say "fabricated" news story?) that, at best, is a blatant attempt to mislead the public and sway public opinion. And considering what we now know, it's literally as obvious as the sun up in the sky.

I don't say this as a criticism of Julian, because, Lord knows, he's not alone. (And I say "worked himself into a frenzy" based on the title of his discussion - pretty strong words, to say the least.)

However, I'm at a loss for words. I really don't know what can be done about it.

by garion11

How many more quotes? How many more headlines? that were SPUN out of their intention to suit the predetermined media around the world? Can you even believe anything else for that matter? in any country? or its people?

No, there is nothing that can be done about it. I NEVER THOUGHT I'D SAY THIS...I wish the Soviet Union never collapsed and it was still around today. That collapse hurt the US's standing around the world. People had a clear understanding of what evil was, now obviously they don't.

by oz_media

When a kid in school says everyone is wrong because he really doesn't think he's skinny, he must then stop and think. HE thinks he is husky, yet the majority of people that can see him will say he is skinny.

SO who is right? Sure we can believe what we want, but when the majority of those that can see think otherwise it's time to consider their viewpoint as you may find yourself very alone otherwise.

by oz_media

Wel no I don't think it's a false assertion at all, it simply a viewpoint. There is no factual basis needed as it is purerly based on feeling and observation.

As far as parroting myself, I am also exasperated that it is neccessary but in most cases it is because even after I have contested a point someone will make a comment that shows they are not aware at all.

THis happens when people enter discussions that haven't shared views before, such as Garion, he made several counters to my points because he simply didn't know that I agree the war was neccessary but prematurely executed (which you already know). He was adamantly defending the need to defend the country and that Saddam was a nasty dictator. You know I have never contested this, he doesn't, therefore we riterate our feelings.

Really Max, with all 'due' respect, if discussions bore you, then you have the same right others do to simply not participate. Personally I find them a great excersise in understanding psychology as you know demographic maketing is a fascination of mine. It is actually very amusing for me to see the same questions and counter arguments all the time, as tiring as it is to reiterate myself.

As for whta you consider false, wellin the same sense, that's what YOU believe or understand to be false, not myself.

by maxwell edison

.
I find it very interesting that you won't concede such an obvious point. I suppose some people believe the sky is green, but to each his own.

In my opinion, however, it means that you either _______________ or ________________ . Personally, I suspect the latter. Either way, it does indeed speak volumes.

by maxwell edison

.
(The following is a cut and pasted quote):

"I would like to especially thank Garion11 and Maxwell Edison for their input to this most amusing discussion.

It is much, much funnier than The Three Stooges or the Marx Brothers.

Perhaps we should ask TR to start a new discussion category 'Humour', to accomodate certain individuals who make such absurd statements as to provide a source of amusement to the majority of peers who are sane and rational."

- jul646@aol.com, 07-08-04

---------- end of quote ----------

Now what was that you were saying, Julian, about "amusing", "absurd statements", and "sane and rational"?

(By the way, no one is funnier than the Three Stooges.)

by oz_media

To an American.

Monty Pythons is a far dryer yet much more cerebral form of humor, although many people out here "just don't get it." Therefore it is stupid, much the same as Garion has called anything he doesn't understand.

Stupid humor? Try Red Green (Canadian embarrassment) or Bob and Doug (which are now part of Canada's heritage).

Good humor? Monty Pythons, Fawlty Towers.

Easy humor? Stooges, Herbie the Love Bug, 90% of North American "comedy" movies, sit-coms et al. (requiring no thought process to understand and appeals to the masses).

Bigger audience means more money but humor is relative and can't be homogenized for a general/wide audience without losing substance.

by pctech

Max,

I wanted to post this at the end of our previous posts. "Max Thread Length Reached" was all I got, or something to that effect.

I made my last post to you after glimpsing your comments towards what I had thought would be a response from you concerning experience vs sideliners. In the first paragraph you were only questioning me about what Kerry was going to do different than Bush. What did that have to do with what I stated, I asked myself .... and you. The next thing to catch my eyes was the name Joe Montana and I said to myself, "Great! Now the man wants to debate Joe Montana!". This is when I made my mistake. The first one of my life! ( Shocking, I know, but, true. ) I made the mistake of immediately thinking you to be another partisan wimp that could not see beyond your thoughts towards what might lay beyond your thoughts. You know the rest from here.
I made the post and thought I may have been too critical. I needed to reread the posts and discover if I was justified in my statements or, if I had just become a jerk. ( I had never been a jerk before and had no desires to become one at that time. ) Well, I had become a jerk. Why did I not post a correction then? Simple. I came off like a jerk and I wished to afford you the opportunity to chastise me for my words. I certainly deserved to be chastised and yet you remained the gentleman between us. I bow to your superior character.
Your post concerning Joe Montana contained great points of interest and I certainly missed a great read by bypassing it the first time. My loss. I now wish to thank you for the time you took to add those lines to your post. I also wish to thank you for remaining the gentleman when you were not confronted by one. I offer to you my apologies for such rude behavior on my part.
Max, should you still be willing to debate me on the political issues, I would love for you to start the debate, at your leisure. Yes, I can debate either side of an issue and I can do so with passion. I am an Independant and for me to be true to this I MUST study both sides of an issue and decide for myself what are the long term effects of an issue as given by either side. What best represents the long term needs of our citizens as opposed to the short term needs of sellect groups of individuals. My strongest fights will always be for the preservation of our Constitution, as our forefathers gave it to us, and I see the extremists of both sides wishing to dismantle it and rebuild it to their own liking. Our forefathers gave us a Constitution that is solid and more than a mere guideline for us to follow. Our forefathers also had enough foresight to make it flexable through ammendments to it and strict guidelines as to how these ammendments could be done. I see the extremists wishing to bypass the ammendment process and add, or subtract, whatever they want at their own convenience. I will not stand silent and watch this take place. Yes Max, I can debate either side of an issue and with a great deal of passion. .... Shall we?

by garion11

Blah, blah, blahahahaha, blah, blah, blaaaaahhh!!!

Finger pointing, He said She said, lies, false accusations, truth spinning, stubborn refusal to see anyone else's point of view, thinking you know everything. Yeah, O mighty OZ, when do you start Kindergarten btw?

by oz_media

Show me where you have offered anything except comments that require such answers.

The ONE time you actually made a thoughful and somewhat educated post, I replied accordingly and gave you kudos for the thought you had put into it.

When you just spew completely inacurate and irrelevant crap, do you really think anyone will take time to provide a serious answer?

Crap in equals crap out.

So what part of the post didn't you like? Is it the fact that you show a typical (probably one of the most common) personality traits seen in mankind? Is it the fact that you still haven't grown up enough to realize it or is it the fact that you just don't want to deal with your own insecurities and would rather just push the blame on as someone elses inadequacies?

Either way, you'll get over it, perhaps, one day.

by oz_media

I se no point being made in which I would need to concede. You know this is the nature of TR that forces one to reiterate a point or particular stand 1000 times, not everyone is quite as knowledable and wise as yourself.

Here's a question Max?

I have yet to see you concede a single point, certainly when you realize you have made an error or simply realize you are wrong, you will say so, through gritted teeth and always with a disclaimer to explain how your brain let you down.

So what makes oyur participation on TR any different than mine, Garions, maecuff's, Jules, Colins or anyone else's comments.

WHat you see in others, others see in you.

Must it always be you looking at others and never you looking at yourself?

by oz_media

Would you not sell something to another person whether or not it was a good value for money?
If I walked up and offered to give you money whether it was neccessay or not, would you not take it either way?

I would take your last cent in a heartbeat, don't try to fool anyone that you wouldn't also.

by maxwell edison

.
Oz, I have yet to see you concede a single point. When you realize you have made an error or simply realize you are wrong, you will say never so. Must it always be you looking at others and never you looking at yourself?

by oz_media

Isn't that exactly what i just said in response to you saying i am a know it all?

Are you now simply going to retort with retort?

WHatever Max, as we have said befor yet you seem to forget ever so quickly is that much of what is said id personal opinion. How can I claim to be wrong in an opnion and why the hell should I.

You are REALLY starting to sound as stupid and tiring as your new buddy Garion.

Try using print and actually following the course of the thread and you will see just how stupid your last post was.

My God, do you have to be such an a**hole with every word you utter, you point your finger at others yet refuse to see that you are exactly what you call other people. If we are all the same, why is there a problem?

WHat a dummy you can be, do yu have such a short attention span that your only knowlegde is all linked on the internet or something?

Try not being such a robot and actually think for once.

I have admitted to mistakes as well as have been corrected on misinformation, I am human as you seem to think you are not. I will not, and can not accept being wrong in my personal opinion. If I change my opinion due toalternate information then that's one thing, what the hell do you want me to apologize for?!?

Are you really serious or are you simply lost in space or something??

by garion11

Yeah, I never actually sold anything that I felt wasn't worth someone's money. So I am not sure what you are talking about in that regard.

No I actually wouldn't take your money if you JUST GAVE IT to me. Even though you have this pre conceived notion that I would, (from your post, a very self centered thought process, again I don't think like you) I wouldn't take your money.

So...yeah...Why don't you comment on this obvious SPIN of the Australian media about Bush's comments? Why don't you admit that this isn't just a SPIN, its a downright LIE? Admit that your stupid comments about US media or what not is inappropriate because the media that you presumably watch is even more twisted and biased than the US channels. So all that finger pointing that you did is based on your stupidity, assumptions, downright lies, and YOU are everything you accuse the US to be, why don't you admit that? Even you can't lie to such an obvious PROOF that Max illustrated.

by oz_media

Even some of your American peers here have noticed that censorship toward the war is selectively favouring the good side of war. It should be up to the viewer to decide what they do and don't want to watch, read or see, not the government.

So NO, in NO way whatsoever will I contest that the Pentagon has laid down rules to be followed by reporters as to what is and isn't acceptable. These rules step way beyond the obvious humane conduct of showing caskets and not giving away classified information.

YOU are the only person I have ever encountered that would call the Pentagon a liar for saying it has rules against war reporting in America. Perhaps you should write your local congressman and have him explain that everyone knows that this is so and it is not just heresay or lies. THE PENTAGON CENSORS WAR REPORTING< THIS IS A WELL KNOWN FACT. Get it yet? Or are so really that stupid. It's not an issue of debate or merely my assumption, it just IS and everyone including you fellow Republican Americans knows it, except you.

by maxwell edison

.
Of course there's an echo. That was simply a direct cut and paste from your own message.

I just came to the conclusion that it's pointless to attempt to have a serious discussion with you, as you challenge absolutely everything I say. I think you just make sport of it.

So lighten up, and see a chuckle when it was intended.

by maxwell edison

.
The first one, of course, is to suggest that "Republicans" don't want to grant others' the right to voice their opinion. Even though I disputed that in very civil, thoughtful, and rational manner, you continue to lump all these people together and charge them with, what any reasonable thinking person would call, a silly assertion. To the contrary, there's nothing that most Republicans would welcome more than genuine debate and discussion on a variety of issues, but in a way that builds on a core set of values and principles instead of the tired old rhetoric that's so prevalent in all too many instances.

The second one is when you suggested that I was a non-thinking "robot". To that I would suggest that, in reality, the exact opposite is true. And to that I would also suggest that I am probably the most analytical, studious, and consistent person who posts anything in these threads. With the possible exception of TheChas and your fellow countryman, James, I can't recall anyone posting well thought-out and principle based messages such as the ones I have, at least not recently - as many such people simply don't contribute any longer. (I'm sure there are others, but I just can't think of them right now.) Isn't it interesting that you are the only one to make such a ludicrous assertion? (Well, Julian will agree with you, but only because it would suit his desired outcome of attacking me - even if it means taking a trip into la-la land.)

Instead, as usual, you resort to name-calling and disingenuousness. Instead you continue to play your tired old games. Instead you continue to drag any meaningful dialogue into the mud. Well, keep playing your games, Oz, and keep showing everyone else your true colors - colors I am all too familiar with.

Okay, go ahead with your usual blah blah blah nonsensical retort, but I'll probably choose not to reply - unless, of course, you show a glimmer of reason and civility.

by maxwell edison

.
I didn't merely suggest that John Kerry was just "the guy sitting on the sidelines", I said he was the guy sitting on the sidelines, "criticizing everything under the sun for political expediency". Correct me if I'm wrong, but I have yet to see any real suggestions from him (Kerry) that would change the course that we're already on. He's only said (and I'm paraphrasing - condensing) that Bush is not doing it right, never specific on what is wrong, and that he'll do it better, but no outline of what that is. John Kerry ALSO had the same assumptions (WMDs) as GWB. And John Kerry ALSO voted for the Iraq liberation - and he has not said that he would change his vote, even when pressed for an answer.

Now if Kerry believed - and clearly articulated - that he would go in a different direction entirely, and we had a choice of this plan or that plan, it would be another matter entirely, and I wouldn't have made such a statement. But he simply hasn't done that. I believe that all the criticism aimed at GWB, especially in this politically charged election season, is only political rhetoric - no more, no less. So in that respect, I feel much more comfortable with the guy who's had a specific plan, he's outlined the plan, he has a clear-cut goal in mind, he's done everything that he said he would do, and he's been moving forward towards the established goals.

On your other point (from the football analogy) Joe Montana was indeed a great quarterback. Some might argue, however, especially from my neck of the woods (Colorado), that John Elway would be at the top of the "best quarterbacks" list. And speaking of those two, I was in attendance at Mile High Stadium on a Monday Night in 1994 to witness, what many people have called, the best football game ever to be played, at least the best Monday night game ever played. John Elway's Denver Broncos were playing host to Joe Montana's Kansas City Chiefs (after his great San Francisco years). In the fourth quarter.....oh heck, here's a cut and pasted account:

MNF's Greatest Games: Kansas City-Denver 1994
By Mike Diegnan
ABC Sports Online

It was the ultimate battle between two of the game's all-time greats. NFL enthusiasts could debate for hours who was the better quarterback, John Elway or Joe Montana, and on the night of Oct. 17, 1994, they would have gotten their money's worth.

Montana, in the twilight of his career, headed to Kansas City in 1993 after losing his job in San Francisco to Steve Young. In his first season with the Chiefs, he guided them to an 11-5 record and a spot in the AFC championship game. In '94, the three-time Super Bowl MVP led K.C. to the playoffs again in what proved to be his final season.

Meanwhile, Elway entered their '94 meeting without a Super Bowl ring. Deep in the back of his mind, he could remember when Montana and Co. blew him out in Super Bowl XXIV. That night in the 55-10 rout, Montana threw five touchdown passes whereas Elway was picked off twice.

Both were up to the challenge for their final showdown on Monday Night Football.

The game went back-and-forth all night with neither team gaining a true advantage. It was tied 7-7 after one quarter, 14-14 at halftime and 21-21 as they entered the fourth quarter. Neither quarterback blinked.

"Those kind of battles you get in are the fun games for a quarterback," Montana recalls. "You're going against the guy that can, you know if you let him back on the field, he'll do the same thing back to you."

The game remained tied until Lin Elliott kicked a 19-yard field goal with 4:08 to go to give the Chiefs a 24-21 lead.

Elway, who had negotiated six Broncos comebacks against the Chiefs already in his career, had the Broncos in line for another one until Shannon Sharpe fumbled on the Chiefs' 40 with just 2:45 to go.

Inexplicably, Marcus Allen handed the ball back over to Denver on the very next play.

This time, no one could deny Elway. On a classic Elway drive, he led the Broncos 39 yards on six plays, finishing it off himself with a 4-yard touchdown run to give them a 28-24 lead with just 1:29 left.

But it was more than enough time for Montana.

Even though a sore shoulder forced him to miss significant practice time during the week, the 38-year-old was near flawless in his execution of the two-minute drill, completing 7-of-8 passes as he moved them 75 yards on nine plays.

The Broncos had been given Montana the underneath throws and he worked it precisely, going perfect on the final four plays, 11 yards to Kimble Anders, 12 yards to Derrick Walker, 19 yards to Tracy Greene and then a five-yarder to Willie Davis as Davis extended his arms at the goal line before reaching the pylon for a touchdown.

"He makes a great catch, squeezes it in the end zone, and, and it was right in front of my wife and daughter who happened to be on the field," recalls Montana, who finished the night 34-for-54 for 393 yards, 3 TDs and 1 INT. "She was working for one of the TV stations there, and I kind of knew in the back of my mind that it was closing in on the end of my career, and to be able to do that and have them there was pretty special."

And to make it even more special for Montana, it left just eight seconds on the clock, not even enough time for Captain Comeback to lead the Broncos one more time.

"That's how everybody feels with John," Montana says. "You can't afford to give a player that relishes being in that time of the game any time on the clock. And the best thing you can see is when it says zero, because then you know, even if he's got the ball in his hand, he can't do anything with it."

The same could be said if the ball was in Montana's hands. On that night, Denver was unable to.

The Kansas City Chiefs won the game, 31-28.

----------

And if you're interested/able to attend, another cut and pasted story:

Elway, Montana to face off in Invesco Field flag-football game
Legendary quarterbacks John Elway and Joe Montana will face off at Invesco Field at Mile High in August, but this time they'll be wearing flags instead of pads.

Elway and other former Denver Broncos stars will play Montana and a team of former NFL stars on Aug. 20 in a flag football game to commemorate Elway's induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Tickets for the event go on sale Saturday. (Two weeks ago)

Elway's formal induction will be Aug. 8 in Canton, Ohio.

The ex-Broncos signal caller was the winningest quarterback in NFL history with 148 victories in a 16-year career. He played in five Super Bowls, winning the last two.

Montana was inducted into the hall in 2000 after a career with the San Francisco 49ers and Kansas City Chiefs.

Dubbed "A Game of Fame," the Invesco Field event will be held at 7 p.m. Aug. 20. There will be a pre-game autograph session and a post-game concert featuring Diamond Rio.

Tickets ($35 plus service charges) go on sale at 10 a.m. Saturday through the Ticketmaster agency (www.ticketmaster.com) and outlets.

by pctech

Max,

Slow down a little, OK?
I was speaking in purely generic terms. I did not mention a country. I did not name an administration. I did not name a person, other than Joe Montana. I did not give any specific circumstances. My relpy was purely generic and was in response to my view that you think the experienced will do a better job in the future than those on the sideline. I only offered that the "sideline" has the same advantages of hindsight and with a greater perspective than those "on the field". ...... Why a 5000 word essay, in your response, to something I was not even discussing?
Do you, or do you not, think that those on the sideline might have the advantage of perspective that those on the field may not have? This, in reality, was all I asked. Actually, all I did was offer my opinion that those on the sidelines should not be ruled out from doing a better job and that those on the field may not adjust to changes they need to make. ... Do you wish to debate this?

by maxwell edison

.
Your generic point is taken, and I don?t disagree. And no, I don?t want to debate your generic point. The only exception I took, and clarification I wanted to make, is when the first half of my statement was separated from the second half, and I only wanted to emphasize that in my context, one couldn?t be separated from the other. And I didn?t take a 5000 word essay to say as much; I only used 250 words.

You did, however, give me an excuse to go off on that little light-hearted football tangent ? the greatest sport of all time. (Warning ? this is another tangent.) And I only used 1,006 words in that ? most of which weren?t even mine. I simply cut and pasted them from a couple of sports related Web sites.

Total words used in the whole message ? 1,256, not 5,000.

by pctech

Max,

What I wrote was generic, as you now admit.

Since I had said that I agree with what you were saying on the rest of your post ( what part of this was unclear to you? ) and wished to give my opinion on just the experience vs sideline abilities/inabilities, ( what part of this was unclear to you? ) then the rest of the post you made was a moot point to what my comments were about. I was not discussing anything other than what I said I differed from you, in opinion, concerning experience vs sideline ability/inabilities.

I did not read but for the first paragraph of what was your response to me. I scrolled through the rest and I was certain that it did not pertain to any statements that I had made. There is no difference as to if it was 5000 words or 5 words. What you posted as a reply was not relevant to what I said. Does this clarify anything for you?

Look, Max. Obviously I was wrong. You are not capable of debating political points and your interest seems to be announcing that you are a Bush cheerleader. OK, you are a Bush cheerleader. RAH! RAH! I hear such partisan rhetoric daily. I am weary of such partisan rhetoric. I offered you the opportunity to debate political points and all you wish to do is Bush rah, rahs. I NEVER offered to you any Kerry rah, rahs but, this does not seem to matter to a Bush cheerleader. I offered to you that I would take EITHER side of the issues. You wish to take the Bush cheerleading path to only start attacking me and not my counterpoints/points? ... How childish this makes you appear. This belittles the intelligence you have exhibited in other areas.

Max, I am still open to debate, EITHER side of the political points, once you have aquired the mental ability and stamina to do so. I do not wish to offend but, it has become obvious to me that you have not reached the level of intelligence to do so. In the mean time, I hope you look good in your cheerleader outfit and pom poms. Not that I would want to see this.

May I suggest a book for you to read, Max? I am not being sarcastic when I suggest to you to read Carl Sagan's book, "The Demon-Haunted World". Carl Sagan didn't have all of the answers and he admitted as much but, his book is a good read. The book suggests we take a scientific approach towards what is offered as evidence before us. This would include political statements and those who make political claims. Scrutinize the evidence, Max, and see how it tests out. ... What a nobel idea! This is all Carl Sagan suggested we do. Why did it take a true genius to offer such a simplistic idea????

OK, obviously this is the end of any debate between Max and I. Feel free to make your hisses and boos, or cheers and applaudes. Even though there is not much to go on, bring on the comments.

by maxwell edison

.
Geesh, what was that all about?

Why don't you read the entire flow of our dialogue again, but this time look at it from a perspective that's not so cynical. You may draw different conclusions.

As far as debate, instead of picking "any side", playing the devil's advocate, so to speak, I'd rather debate issues with someone who is as passionate about an issue as I am, but with a different position. It would be much more real and meaningful. But if you just want to argue for argument's sake, I suggest you make the offer to our Canadian friend, OzMedia. He's really quite good at it.

By the way, in case you're interested:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=155018&messageID=1622591

If you see "Bush cheerleading" there, try looking through different glasses.

(You're not going to become one of the insulters and name-callers, are you? We have enough of those around here.)

by oz_media

Sir, it is in your best interests to simply agree with Max. He is correct and everyone else seemsd to be wrong. If you can't admit that, you are one sided, disingenious and unable to agree that/debate why GWB is the best leader for America.

When will you learn?

by oz_media

WEBSTERS
Preposterous: Contrary to nature or reason, not adapted to the end; untterly and glaringly foolish, unreasonable absurd, perverted.

WORLD DICTIONARY: preposterous: completely devoid of wisdom or good sense, "the absurd excuse that the dog ate his homework", "that's a cockeyed idea", "ask a nonsensical question get a nosensical answer", "a contribution so small as to be laughable", "it's ludicrous to call a cottage a mansion", "a rpeposterous attempt to turn back the pages of history", "her conceited assumtion of unversal interest in her rather dull children was ridiculous"
SYNONYMS: derisory, laughable, nonsensical, liducrous, idiotic, absurd, cockeyed.

Well there you have it, PREPOSTEROUS.

"The reason these discussions go nowhere, except to the point of exasperation and name-calling, is because you (and others) continue to lay claims that have either been previously dispelled or shown to be incorrect, or you won't apply the same sentiment to yourself."

"Your first sentence is only one such case in point. You said, "It seems that Republicans just won't accept that Democrats have an opinion and are entitled to it."

So NO Max, these comments regarding left not accepting right and vica versa are not at all preposterous, in fact they are based solely on observation of how you act toward each other and a logical conclusion was reached based on the information shown in these forums.

You seem to see it as, the LETIES never admit that the right is correct. They will discount anything said by the right.

However, I see the EXACT same knee-jerk reaction to Left wing reports when viewed by right wing supporters. Commentrs are instantly discounted, MM ? Most won't even read his slanderous BS it is all leftie crap sligning and in no way cuold be correct.

this happens on BOTH sides, whether you feel you are above the rest or not, it is a fact, MOST staunch righties and lefties act this way, always have and always will.

It seems that in a religious discussion, people are VERY careful not to offend the other as it is religion and therefore differences are accepted (for the most part). Discounting someone's personal beliefs is VERY wrong, even if they go on about things you don't agree with or consider utter hogwash.

Discounting someone's personal beliefs in politics however is a different story. People's personal beliefs and feelings are simply considered wrong if they differ from another's views and beliefs. christians wouldn't give agnostics the time of day if religion was treated like politics, yet in religion we all accept and understand each others right to form an opinion. A political opinion is another thing though, if it differs from your own, it is absurd, PREPOSTEROUS ir just MORE LEFTIE/RIGHTIE RANTING!

Why is religion accepted when something so trivial as politics is set in stone, left or right pick a side and stick to it. Yet be careful not to pick the WRONG side.

Now THAT is "preposterous", disingenious, contrary to nature or reason, not adapted to the end, utterly and glaringly foolish, unreasonably absurd, perverted.

For you to consider anothers opinion of yourself as being preposterous is a preposterous statement in itself. How can you possibly understand how you are viewed through anothers eyes? To discount their observations is, yes Max, PREPOSTEROUS.

by jamesrl

I enjoyed reading the whole story.

I think its total silliness to say that no country can comment on the foreign policies of another. And even try to influence. As long as the influence is based on policy and logic and not based on intimidation or threat, then its fair game. Canada and the US try to influence each other constantly. Our ambassadors are lobbyists and public speakers. They give press conferences all the time, they meet both government and opposition politicians.

The job of a newspaper is not to be an unvarnished source of facts. The job of a newspaper is to sell newspapers. And they accomplish that with striking headlines and sensational stories. That requires a certain amount of spin, and usually the direction of that spin comes from the ownership. Left/right, it hardly matters. Just know that every paper has a bias and blindspots.

My favorite analogy about Canada and the US is that of brothers in law who happen to be neighbours. Sometimes familiarity breeds contempt. But at the end of the day, you are going to ask to borrow his truck, and he is going to ask to borrow some money.

James

by garion11

I stated in many previous posts that the media does control and police itself here. It will not, AGAIN I REPEAT WILL NOT show very graphic pictures unless it "has" to. But people who have access to the internet can find whatever information they need or want to see.

Now why don't you comment on the OBVIOUS LIES and SPIN the Australian media did on Bush's and Armitage's quotes/interview? Is Canada that way too? I bet it is and you are a fool for pointing fingers.

by oz_media

Well Garion, I will be very short because this discussion is dead. We need to let things sit and stilfe while we move on, the old days of 300 posts threads are gone.

As for the LIES and stuff about Asuatralia, well perhaps they are maybe the White House has edited or censored yet another document as they have been proven to do before when it is in their interests. But I would suspect neither is to BLAME.

This is reported conversation which as you know can be colored any way, whether the US or Australian side is right or wrong doesn't matter, they are both screwed up, and Australians will admit it.

My only stand has been that it is principally incorrect for one politician to comment either for or against another's political stand while a campaign race is on.

Secondly that it is often seen by others that GWB has more interest in their affairs than he should, which I agree with because I see and here more of him than our own PM.

If he kept Americas business inside America nobody would care, he is a political bully and is not liked by other governments.

So lets let this one die already, it is getting SO boring, redundant and droll.

by oz_media

Hokey site with awful webhosting. Just servers are full messages with an apology about getting more webspace from the webmaster.

Looks very educational though. :-P

This discussion is closed to new replies.