Discussion Locked

Dell......because all of the other four-letter words were taken.

0 helpful
70 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

One of my jobs in my company is to insure all of our wired and wireless hardware is up to par. In the last couple of months, our Dell hardware has been extremely undependable. We are using the Optiplex series.

This includes GX260, GX270, and the mini-PC SX270. Motherboard failure seems to be the leader, with hard drive failure in second, and CPU and board components in a tight third.

Dell will not send replacement components proactively, as we have to wait approx. one and a half weeks for each replacement part. They don't want to send parts unless a report is made of the failure first. I don't know about our other sites, but this is killing mine.

Has any of the other TR members experienced this kind of breakdown? Between all of our sites, I would say there is well over a hundred hardware failures. Dell also sent a notice that we will have to replace 152 hard drives because they are defective.

What manager in their right mind would continue to do business with a company like this? I thought Compaq was bad, but I think I would rather purchase from them as of now....

I would appreciate any feedback in regards to this issue. Thanks all.

70 replies

by bfilmfan

I've not had good experiences with Dell's in the past in the area of hardware reliability.

I've also seen issues where 2 models in the same serial number run would have totally different equipment on the motherboard.

For a commercial client, I can't advise them to use Dells if they have availability as a concern.

by jdclyde

The Company President has a Dell at home that has died a few times, but everytime I had the replacement part the next day.

This is a home system, not company purchased.

Replaced Hard Drive, Sound Card and Video Card.

This was three years ago.

A big change from what you are seeing now. That is what happens when they worry about making the stockholders happy before making the customer happy.

This was also before Akmed took over support as well.

What brand do people recommend now for people that want a computer that you don't want to be responsible for the rest of your life? That is why I don't make most people computers, because they seem to think that you will support this (for free) till the end of time.

by cp7212

Been there, done that with the build and support of PCs... But our company has a three-year lease program and we just started the new rollover. Then get a "memo" that basically states, "No. Wait. There are 152 hard drives that were bad, YOU replace them." Maybe Akmed is building them too....

by dr dij

do a search on yahoo (or google)
+dell +failure +"customer service"
(you could think up other combo's of words)
I get 169,000 hits for this combo

sample:
... THE worst customer service i have experienced in a loooong time ... Mini3Com: Msg: Failed Internal loopback Test. Failure: DELL i8600: motherboard failed; system won't power up
(from resellerratings.com)
and if you goto shopping.com dell consistently has lowest ratings (2.5*'s last time I looked) and a huge# of revu's, largely horror stories of lies (about delivery date, availability, changing prices, etc) - they are fun to read.

I was going to buy a PC from them but won't now. Appears their products are OK until they fail, and they appear to be doing alot of that.

by jck

They get:

1) a month of hardware support
2) all the warranty cards
3) a receipt to make copies of when they register the product (video card, hard drive,etc)
4) an initial bit of training to show them how to use basic things in windows
5) a smile

I don't make $100 on a $399 PC like Dell does...and, I don't sell annual support packages.

Support is a seperate component, in my opinion. As far as I can tell, Dell's has gone to the outhouse.

by eureeky

We purchased 16 Dell SX270's for our computer labs. Eight were installed at one site, eight at another. To date, all 8 at one of the sites have had the MOBOs fail. These PCs are out of warranty and Dell refused to sell us any replacement MOBOs. All 8 at the other site are still working fine. Personally, I thing there's about as much chance of this cluster of failure occuring naturally, as there is of monkeys banging randomly on typewriters and producing a Stephen King novel.

by caestelle

The last two companies that I have worked for used nothing but Dell's and the only models that we have experienced much trouble with are the small form factor ones and those issues seemed to be related to heat. When we have run into the occasional problem, our replacement parts usually arrive next day. We have premier support, so I am not sure if that has anything to do with how fast we get our parts. Anyway no real complaints here.

by justin maxwell

We have 135+ Dells GX260's,GX270,GX280 + Servers and have had no problems apart from a TFT panel go faulty when it came out of the box.

Phoning support is a nightmare I was once put through to India and bounce between 5 people for nearly 20 minutes. I now purchase 'Gold' support and on the 2 times I've needed support I got it!

It may cost extra but IMO its worth it!

by cp7212

I found out we have Gold Premier support, but Dell claims they never received our request for replacement parts, even though our rep called every day after the first three days - for a week and a half!

I can't wait until I get asked for opinions again about "how to improve IT". Two simple words (censored version here) No Dells!

by jessie

We're also using the Optiplex series of desktops at my company. Of the 300 Dell systems we've got, 100 of the hard drives are being recalled due to a "high incidence of failure." To their credit, Dell is sending out Dell certified reps to do the replacements so our tech dept doesn't have to do it all. Of course, the guy they sent out to our site had JUST passed his A+ and Dell certification tests, and this was his FIRST service call EVER.

After PAINFULLY watching this Dell rep replace one drive and WATCH it while it ghosted... I took it upon myself to show him how to multitask, and by the end of the day, he could do 4 systems at once. Apparently multitasking is something that comes with years of experience. :(

Personally, I'm liking the IBM line of desktops. They've got actual metal cases. Heavy sumbeaches, but one dropped about four feet to a concrete floor (after I spun the cart it was on, to turn it around) :( and aside from a dent in the case, it was apparently undamaged, worked absolutely perfectly!!

Of course, IBM has now sold their PC manufacturing biz to Japan.

by jessie

You are correct. It was Lenovo of China... I think I'd almost prefer they'd sold it to a Japanese company... maybe they'll be lots cheaper though...

by garion11

I bet that these were the ultra thin Maxtor drives, no?

I was one of those reps who replaced about 500 PCs with HD failures.

Trust me it is not just Dell, everyone that has used these drives has had issues with them.

by gil6002

Dell was the company that made that decision to use those Maxtors in the first place on their machines. Reason? To cut cost's and maximize profitability for their company. We all need to accept responsibility for our actions and Dell is responsible for this snafoo. Like with my company, I only want to put in the best parts and your right about Maxtor, I will never put another Maxtor on my customer machines. Installing the best parts will save my company money in the long run, So I only stick with Seagate, Western Digital or IBM, depends on the model of my Desktop or Laptops. I truely believe in customer satisfaction and dont want my customers to worry about broken down computers.

Gil
MCSE 98/2000/XP
Owner
LeShe` Computer Systems

by gunnar klevedal

We have been using Compaq Deskpro EN 733 for three years. They have worked fine, I am using one right now. We have even standardized on them. There have been a couple of HDD crashes (Fujitsu) but not many. Anyway we do not keep personal data files on the HDD. Of course these machines cannot be purchased today, but the product line Compaq EVO is good also.

by afram

My last employer had about 60 DELLs. Never had a problem with any of the Optiplex desktops (almost all were the GX260s).

The laptops were another story. Many of the Inspiron5000s had to have many replacement parts but the techs always made repairs on site by the next day. I'm not convinced the problems were with the DELLs either...the users treated their laptops like crap...dropped, waterlogged, etc.

Those Inspirons were replaced with Latitude 550 and 600 and they worked fine. Users were much more carefull with them.

by cp7212

The SX270's are the ones with the most issues. They are bracketed, so users are not the problem. Did you say waterlogged? That almost sounds like a pickle juice story I heard in school years ago..... ;)

by jdclyde

It got under the corner of his rocking chair.
Can you say Crunch?

Another sales rep has had TWO systems stolen from him, while no one else has had even one. It couldn't be him, right?

by afram

One or two were dropped in puddles and one unlucky guy spilled coffee all over his brand new laptop on his first day.

Most of the abuse came from rough handling. I noticed one laptop's harddrive was making a loud knocking noise and when I asked him about it, he said it was doing that ever since he knocked it off his desk a weeks before. Then I noticed the corner was smashed in. Not only did DELL replace the drive, they gave us a bigger one because they didn't have any of the original in stock.

by jdclyde

For anything that bad, check to see if there are any class actions against them.

Also, I would try for a voucher towards new purchases or even money back to cover the expense of YOU fixing their systems. Didn't they come with support? Even a HOME system would be repaired by THEIR techs doing warranty work.

Years ago I got money AND vouchers from Tochiba because they had sold laptops with KNOWN bad floppie controllers.

I ended up getting $1500 in cash and $1200 worth of vouchers as settelment. We only had five systems.

I would also look about getting out of lease of those into a different series? Something that will do something crazy, like maybe WORK?

Good luck with this!

Was Dell your push or someone elses?

This is why I only get IBM for business.

by cp7212

The only push Dell would get from me is right into the river. No, the upper mgmt. orders it and I fix it. IT situation normal. They're probably too busy on their yachts to look at the track records of our vendors.

You know, I never realized how hilarious Dilbert was until I actually started working in an IT environment...

I actually used to like Dell. I suppose when you get to # 1, there is nowhere to go but down. I am going to check into some support coming down here or some kickback. Thanks for the comments.

by lmayeda

I've purchased Dells exclusively for the past 5 year and have been happy with the Gold Tech Support. Recently 2 of the PC have demonstrated the issues (no video) that have gone through a couple permutations of replacement parts but I would still be willing to stay with Dell except for the Dell Financial "Services" (Dell Hell) which I am convinced is designed to prevent customers from 1) calling them (busy signals, misdirections, etc) and from reconciling accounts that rapidly pile up the late fees and finance charges because ....you can't call them (see #1). While we are a small shop of less than 100 PCs, on our next order we will be looking to purchase either IBMs, HPs or Gateways to avoid dealing with Dell Hell. It has literally taken me hours and passed through 5 people before I thought I finally reconciled out accounts to zero... then a statement later ... mysterious balances.

by garion11

I agree that the Dell no parts in stock policy is imo not very customer friendly. However there is a work around...You could buy extra Dell PCs, then swap them if and when there is a problem with the ones that are live, then call in the problem with the current PC and then replace the broken part. This way the user is not down and you are not in a rush to get the needed parts, etc. I don't know the exact terms of your contract, but I have seen many companies do this with Dell. I hope it works out for you.

by cp7212

Thanks, but I would prefer a computer company that gets a huge contract over all the rest in the business, not to lease defective workstations to begin with. Besides, we would have to buy a lot of PCs....we had eight motherboards go south yesterday alone.

I am just upset because I would not have expected this from Dell, who is supposed to be so great in the market.

by house

...the servers are excellent, but their workstations suck - IMO

Back in the day, we had some GX100s from Dell. These machines are actually still on the floor at my former position. They have been more than adequate for running a variety of apps over XP with sp1. All memory and processors within the boxes were consolidated into a standard of at least 256mb and 500mhz respectively. There were very few instances of the machines going down due to hardware failure, yet I see it all the time will "today's" Dell machines.

After acquiring some bad GX50's we moved to the IBM Thinkcenters for desktop workstations. While some ram was DOA, support was unbelievable, and all was solved within 2-3 days.

I'm still for IBM, even with the recent sale, but time will tell.

*

There must be something about 'karma' in this field. I have an eMachine (believe it or not) at home that has been running without fault for three years. I had bought it and killed the factory OS immediately. The hardware specs are a little weak, but if I wanted to upgrade, that's my prerogative.

by cp7212

Well, if it's karma, that explains it....it's my fault. ;) You wouldn't happen to have any of those GX100's up for fire sale, would you?

I hope Dell still stays on the up and up with their servers. We have those too and I do value what sleep I get. Thanks for the opinion.

by house

1) those boxes are ancient

2) I don't even work there anymore

3) All equipment that cannot be consolidated into the standards are donated to charity - "Computers for Schools"

* sorry mang - no-can-do

by garion11

been running for 7 years now. 1998 we bought it....and I am completely amazed at the thing. 7 years!! NOT ONE PART HAD TO BE REPLACED. In fact, I upgraded it by adding a burner and ram. It was a Seagate HD mind you.

by roger99a

I'm still waiting for my Dell sales rep to call me back after 3 weeks. I needed some upgrade parts for a Dell server. THREE WEEKS! I suppose he doesn't want to talk to me because I don't need 50 computers, but if spares are going to be that hard to get I don't want any Dells anyway. I did manage to get through Dell's phone Hell and bought the parts from a company selling parts for Dell, in Bangalore India. I guess that because it wasn't actually Dell I got the parts for good prices and rather quickly. I can't wait for that jacka$$ saleman to call back........

by danfan

I support about 30 GX260's and 270's. I have had one power supply and one HDD go bad (in about 2.5 years). Dell was out the next day to replace parts. We also have Gold Premium Support, so that probably helps. Phone support has been adequate to date as well.

by roger99a

I never said anything about service. As far as I can tell the service is still good. I'm mad because I couldn't get parts for an upgrade.

by jbrackmann

I made 7 calls in an effort to obtain parts for some latitude Laptops. I left five voice mails. Please keep in mind that my three year support agreement had expired. I was hacked to say the least. I did make contact twice, only to be given an alternate number. I then decided to call sales, and see if they could assist ion some way. I advised what I had been through, and that I would not call any other numbers and I expected them to get someone on the line that could take an order. This will not happen again.
I filed written complaint with Dell, no respones. Even though I do like their servers, we are done with Dell. Keep in mind, we are the customers. We do not have to tolerate this type of service, there are alternatives.

by betageek52

I have been of the mindset, for the past several years, that the best thing about Dell is Their ADVERTISING CAMPAIGNS.

by cp7212

I was told we have Premium Support, but turned down Dell techs coming out here. The reason? Mgmt. thinks it is faster for us to replace the parts ourselves. Like usual, the war on two fronts continues....

by cp7212

No kidding. Every time I put up a joke, I get reprimanded for some ridiculous reason. Now my partner, that would be cute if I didn't have to work with her, she puts up a joke and everybody falls all over it. I'm a man and I can't stand my fellow men sometimes....

The office is run by testosterone. That doesn't mean I couldn't start sending them anonymously by snail mail, though.

Let me find my one joke I got in trouble for...earned a trip to the main HQ for it, too.

by sean-leonard

First let me start by making it clear this is not directly pointed at any one person.

When you buy the cheapest or lowest end desktop you can find and put it in a busniess you are jusk asking for trouble. The dimension and low end optiplex are designed for home users not busniess applications.The lower pricetag means that you get the "overseas" tech support and the "do it your self replacements". I support over 50 desktops that are a combination of the Opti GX and the persision workstations as well as a few SX's . They all come with the gold support "English speaking techs and four hour parts replacements"and i have had no major problems the extra money spent on the gold support pays for itself on the first call to support. I dont have to deal with non english speaking morons that have no clue what they are talking about The part is sent out four hour and depending how busy I am the choise is mine to fix it or have a tech do it.

by duanedelima

But what about the basic ideaology that says... you sell a bad product and your reputation will be tarnished. In a global market like ours, where a single complaint can resonate throughout the entire IT community in minutes, would you really want to let a product out of your hands knowing it has the potential to damage your company's reputation? The truth is, money is making IT decisions more and more. Sean is right... you get what you pay for... and when you buy cheap systems, which obviously use cheap parts, you will get failures on your systems. If you want low availability systems with low dependency factors, go ahead... cut costs and buy cheap. But when your business depends on the uptime of your IT facilities, compare the costs of a high initial investment to the cost of the next few years of parts replacement and downtime.

by jck

In corporate America, they (execs) don't worry about ideology. The worry about:

1) bottom line
2) meeting market expectation
3) getting their bonuses

Managerial heads will roll before an executive will give up his $2.5M bonus to make sure his employees don't have to work their butts off maintaining sub-standard PCs. Their view is "choose the PC that fits within budget", but they allocate too little budget for good PCs and when they fail they blame the manager for not buying well.

Face it...the job market sucks, and therefore we computer folk have become complacent with being abused by management...and they realize it and take advantage...management is REALLY good at that in Corporate America. 7 years ago, tech jobs were booming and if your boss treated you bad you could walk across the street and get the same work for a bit more money. I know I did. in 1999, I left a programming job to make almost $10k more a year doing IT consulting. year and a half later (2001), I was laid off cause of the tech downturn after Y2K.

My Dell Optiplex GX280 is sluggish and it's a 3.4GHz I believe. My AMD AthlonXP-based machine at home with the same amount of RAM and a 2.2GHz processor works faster.

Therefore, I'll keep building my own machines.

I wish you IT guys luck. Supporting the PCs nowadays does bite.

by jbrackmann

I have tested a few DEll desktops against white boxes, some of which I had assembled. The white boxses fare far better in performance and reliability, as loing as quality componnents are used from reputable manufactures.
We will not but desktops from Dell.
I have no issues with some of the servers, both racks and towers, quality and reliabilty has been good.
I have thirty something laptops in the feild, some failures, allthough small number.
Ordering spare parts is a nightmare. This has really turnmed me off with Dell.
If you buy from Dell, you had better buy the on-sight support agreement, as you cannot get anything repaired once the warranty or support agrement expires at any cost.

by boneyfish

we've had Dell's for 7 years, minimal problems, I replaced 2 hard drives, and 3 monitors out of 30 units. So there, buy the good stuff, and shut your trap. Finally had to replace most of them last year, because they are now obsolete, and won't run newer software.

by rexworld

We've definitely had a drop in Dell quality with the PC's they've shipped us for desktop use. Not certain about servers, but for example three people near me had new Dell's that went bad within weeks of each other. Various quality problems--smoking power supply, blown motherboard, hard drive crash.

Luckily our contract includes next-day replacement, they got new parts out quickly and our tech guy was able to get everyone back up and running within a day or two.

by csrphd

I have about 100 optiplexes and up to this point, have had only three failures (knock on wood). Also I always have spares just in case. I noticed that their support has been horrible as of lately, one time I got transfer abot 6 times, I was just trying to get a quiote for a server, until I got upset and I told them I was going to start buying from IBM. Suprisinlgy next morning I had a voicemail from the sales representative, which agve a whole bunch of direct numbers of engineers and techs to call, when I needed them. I guess sometimes been angry is better.

by jdclyde

The packard bell of a few years gone back.

Man, those systems were terrible. If they were brought to me, I would charge them double up front because 1) they were going to be a pain to fix and 2) you saved on the front end by buying crap, so your going to pay the difference now.

How about Compaq? Now there was another can of worms that I didn't want to crawl into.

by cp7212

I almost forgot about those. Compaqs were running the close second. Actually, I think if I would not have had a Compaq, I would not be in IT. It was my first 586, with a Pentium 75. Ooooo, big processing power for those days. And as if the Compaq wasn't enough of a curse, Windows 95 was brand new. Compaq put 8 MB of RAM in, the minimum needed...big spenders...

Didn't know anybody that knew anything about PCs or Windows 95. Luckily, I stumbled onto a chat room full of techies on AOL (2.5). I thought it was easier to learn at $2.95/hr than pay $39 for each call to fix the stupid PC.

Man, do you remember when that was the gripe? Had to pay for tech support? I know Compaq started that crap. They implemented it just about when I bought it....lucky me.

by jdclyde

Remember those daze people?

Login, download a page and logoff.

Read page

Start over.

Oh when it went to a flat per month rate....

Used to work at the local college, so I would take a few buds into one of the labs after hours and install DOOM off the hidden directory on the server and frag till about 5am.

Can't believe I didn't get carple tunnel from that! My wrists would just KILL me after a night of gaming.

But think about it! You could get FOUR whole people into the SAME GAME!

Ah, a simpler time.

Good luck with management. Don't LET them beat you down.

I would STRONGLY recommend getting your resume out and trying to find something else. I have seem many people get turned into poor workers from being in a poor work environment.

by cp7212

So Now You Know...

Start with a cage containing five apes. In the cage, hang a banana on a string and put stairs under it. Before long, an ape will go to the
stairs and start to climb towards the banana. As soon as he touches the stairs, spray all of the apes with cold water.

After a while, another ape makes an attempt with the same result - all the apes are sprayed with cold water. Turn off the cold water. If, later, another ape tries to climb the stairs, the other apes will try to prevent it even though no water sprays them.

Now remove one ape from the cage and replace it with a new one. The new ape sees the banana and wants to climb the stairs. To his horror, all of the other apes attack him. After another attempt and attack, he knows that if he tries to climb the stairs, he will be assaulted.

Next, remove another of the original five apes and replace it with a new one. The newcomer goes to the stairs and is attacked. The previous
newcomer takes part in the punishment with enthusiasm.

Again, replace a third original ape with a new one. The new one makes it to the stairs and is attacked as well. Two of the four apes that
beat him have no idea why they weren't permitted to climb the stairs, or why they are participating in the beating of the newest ape.

After replacing the fourth and fifth original apes, all the apes which have been sprayed with cold water, have been replaced. Nevertheless,
no ape ever again approaches the stairs. Why not? "Because that's the way it's always been around here."

And that's how company policy begins...

Sorry about the formatting. I wanted to copy and paste it before a wandering snitch came in....

Oh, and thanks for the link, jd. I'm glad to see the industry does have some people with humor left...

by ildiko

Once upon a time (2000 January) I was so stupid to buy a Dell computer online with 3 years of guarantee. After 6 months I lost my motherboard and had to replace my hard drive. At this point I was covered by the guarantee. I cannot remember when I had to replace my keyboard and mouse but I clearly remember I still had a full year of guarantee when DELL refused to upgrade my computer. They explained that my model was so old that it was no way to upgrade. I was careful until this point not open myself the tower and risk to loose my guarantee. So, I opened the tower and looked inside. Every single component had a label on the bottom. The usual stuff like date of production, codes and there was a class info. The info was always SECOND CLASS: passed. Now, I haven't got a single bit of that original DELL computer that works. Not a CD player. I slowly had to replace everything. I can understand why DELL can sell so well.

by johnmcgrew

Have had only minor issues over the last few years; a bad fan here, a failed keyboard there. Every failed component was replaced within 24 hours.

I moved most clients over to Dell a few years ago when the Microns I was supporting started going to hell and dropping like flies. The problems with Dell described above are identical to the problems we were having with the Microns; mostly repeatedly failing motherboards & power supplies.

by rhayden

I support 2 customers both with identical top-of-the-line Dell PC's with dual serial ATA hard drives. After 6 months, one of the system's USB ports stopped working. Dell support insisted that an IDE hard drive and a fresh install of Windows XP be done to be certain that it was a motherboard failure - talk about ridiculous. We complied, got the replacement motherboard and are up and running again. Not impressed.

by mastertechphila

My company used to purchase Microns for about $1200 each with 17" LCD monitor. I convinced my supervisor to let me build them from scratch. Including my time, parts and shipping, the cost per computer with a 17" LCD was approximately $800. (And lowering) Any problems, I dealt directly with the manufacturer (ASUS, AMD, Seagate, Crucial, BenQ). All have a minimum of 2 years warranty. Replacement of parts was easy. Just call them, explain the problem, request an RMA.
To date, I have put together about 400 computers with about 0.1% failure rate. I will NEVER buy propietary computers again. Don't have to buy any special Dell this, HP that, IBM whatever, etc.
We can add on anything we need without the special propietary parts pricing.

by n3voc

I have had 7 out of 12 systems, all bought in the same order, all with Maxtor 40GB hard drives, all have the hard drives go bad. Dell refuses to replace the remaining 5 until they fail. They did offer to sell be 5 though!

by doc.two9

As the "Tech Man" at a small company I urged my boss to let me build the 3 computers that we needed after being told by Dell that:
1. The model and style we ordered was not available so at their discretion sent us what they had.
2. Way too many "TRUE HORROR" stories from friends, family, buisiness assocciates.

Maybe, if it is an option, go else where

by klibbey

How about 39 new Dell Optiplex pc's that intermittently burn up! Dell replaced multiple motherboards, CPU's, Ram, CD-RW drives, power supplies but denies that it is a "known issue" even though the Unisys rep said it was.

Also a new Dell Inspiron 700m with a bad USB port out of the box - 3 hours on the phone to get it resolved.

by k.h.

we've had the same experience, batch of brand new optiplex systems, out of the box, failing. Dell FINALLY sent replacements...but they insisted that we were the only customer reporting this problem...nice to know that some companies will lie to keep major contracts just to make money...especially after reading all the posts about the same experience...

by realsundancekid

My hospital bought 90 Dell OptiPlex SX-270s (along with 5 Dell PowerEdge servers) on the advice of a consultant who came to help us set up our network.

That was almost one year ago today. Since then, we have replaced the drives on 8 systems, the motherboard, RAM and hard drives on 2 systems, and two fans and one CD-ROM on the servers.

I had a sick feeling when we started having the problems, and then one day while getting specs for a desktop (non-network user) I felt that sick feeling grow when I noticed the SX270s were not even listed to be sold.

Before this, we had only non-networked desktops, mostly Dimensions, and to this day I have not had one iota of trouble out of any of them (about 25 PCs). I have a Dell Dimension at home, and any trouble out of it? Nope. Nada. Zip.

I read on the Dell support forum that the SX270s had the capacitors 'over-filled' at the factory, and this caused them to bulge and shortly after the bulging begins, the trouble begins.

I told the Dell service tech, with whom I have developed a close relationship over the past year that if the SX270s were the only experience I had ever had with a Dell, you couldn't pour one on me.

But, we have the Gold Support, and the tech and the replacement part arrives the next day for workstations and within four hours for the servers.

Still, it's a hassle to have to keep extra systems on hand so you can replace the workstations when they go bad. But being a hospital which also owns 3 physician clinics which are tied into our network with fiber, what other choice do we have?

All I can say is I am not buying any more of the small form factor systems - and that I am learning my lesson from this experience.

Don't even get me started on trying to talk to the yahoos at Dell, from sales to tech support. Over the past 5 years, we have purchased more than 120 systems from Dell, and to this day, when I place an order, the confirmation email comes with "No representative assigned - do not delete" on it.

Gateway is looking better and better to me. But I do believe it's related to the heat issue, and the Maxtor drives.

Last time my friend Kevin the Dell service tech came, he brought a 40 GB drive to replace the 20 GB bad drive in the SX270 - he said they are not getting anymore of the Maxtor drives.

Hope someone else can learn from this.

And while I'm here, let me say this, since I don't post often, if at all: TechREpublic ROCKS!

And Jeff Davis, well, he is one of the greats, IMO. I emailed him with a troublesome spreadsheet problem one day, and in just a little while he called me on the phone, and shortly sent a spreadsheet with the function that solved the whole issue.

OK, you guys be good to each other, and I'll go back to my lurking and learning here at TR.

Sundance

by hal 9000

Of preferred Drives. Since they have been taken over by Hitachi they are as bad if not worse than the Maxtor's.

I had a tech out from Canon the other day and he asked me what I thought of these drives apparently they have had nearly an 80% failure rate with the new Hitachi drives and these are not in little units that are easily drooped unless you are using a forklift these things are unmovable.

Col ]:)

by desmodeus

I've been working for my current employer for a little over 5 years. In that time I've seen hundreds of Compaq computers come through the door with hardware failure rates of about 1 in 50 to 1 in 100 which I consider pretty acceptable. In that time we've had 5 Dell laptops 3 of which experienced hardware problems either out of the box or within a few months. The reason in my opinion is poor quality parts whuich is of course how Dell keep their prices so low. My personal favourite though was when we bought a Dell laptop (can't remember the model now) with docking station only to discover that to use the docking station I needed to uninstall the PCMCIA network card and then install docking station drivers! Docking station drivers I hear you exclaim, but there's no such thing well that's what I thought until I discovered the horror that is Dell. Remember people you get what you pay for. Expensive doesn't guarantee quality but cheap pretty much guarantees lack of it.

by cp7212

Geez, that is going pretty far. Thanks for that info, I'll have to check on that for our next cycle.

by hal 9000

Pentium 200 or lower?

I haven't seen any docking station drivers for so long I thought that by now that had all been built in to the system.

Col

by jbaker

Where I work, we use Dell PCs. I only recently started working here, but they have a history with Dell, all the way back to Optiplex 110 and Dimension 410 machines. We have had no major failures (knock wood), and only one or two single instance failures. Each time Dell has overnighted the parts to us, and we have returned the bad part.

Currently most of our machines are Optiplex GX260s and GX270s.

Sounds like you need to do a site eval and figure out what is going on with your location. Do ALL of your machines have their own UPSs? How clean is your power? If you have dirty power, that could cause issues...

by jck

We recently bought an ATI-based OEM video card (9800XT Radeon) for a Dell GX260 Optiplex. ATI stated that it is compatible, and Dell had no issues on the site specific to the base card.

However when we plugged it in, the machine wouldn't work. Dell only published an issue under the All-in-Wonder version. So, I didn't find it when I searched.

Dell acknowledged there is some sort of hardware compatibility problem. They have no resolution for it either (as of Feb 2005).

I don't think Dell does nearly as much hardware compatibility testing (as near I can tell...Dell didn't have things like this happen 5 years ago with major manufacturer peripherals).

It's said...they too, like Gateway, have really gone downhill in that department.

Makin a buck is better than making new customers, I guess.

by jkaras

We have the gx260 and gx270 in our office. On the Gx270 we had failing Maxtor 60g HDD, loss of video due to swollen capacitors on the AGP port. I had mad issues with them admitting the issue despite proof on their message boards on their sites, past cases, and the ever popular 1st time a call rep took a call going through every call script to resolve the issue despite the troubleshooting steps already taken. As for the 260's we are having HDD failures and now power supply failures that are going in series. Our old GX110's were a workhorse that never failed, these new one blow. All my users constantly ask me whether they should buy a Dell and I tell them no, only to have them tell me the next week that they bought one? I put Dell now in par with E Machines, only more expensive, for a doorstop. I know it really isnt their fault because they contract out part manufacturers to build the parts to meet demand but man oh man they are making bad decisions on whom they trust for their reputation, in my opinion. Apparently the Dell dude is building pcs for them, lol.

Question, since ours have Asus boards that have issues I have been afraid to try their boards. I use Abit's and they are ok and tend to work unless you get a lemon but multiple companies are poping up making motherboards. There are so many that I cant tell who is bad or otherwise, any suggestions? Is Asus on the downturn? MSI? EPOC?

by peakester

I had a Dell Inspiron 5100 laptop go south. They replaced the M-board. It worked fair for a few months then went really south. Each subsequent event was after multiple, tedious, difficult, inefficient, support calls, often with hang-ups upon initial contact, getting in line again and never taking less than an hour and a half. Here is the series of events to date:

1. After multiple diagnostics re-format and re-installation of OS. They finally agreed to replace the RAM, HD, processor and M-board (again)on the Inspiron 5100. When I received the chassis back, they hadn't replaced the m-board as promised.
2. Was granted replacement computer (Inspiron 5160 refurbished). It arrived and the USB ports did not recognize any peripherals. I denied the supervisor's request to send it back for another M-board replacement and was granted another equipment exchange.
3. Computer # 3 arrived, an Inspiron 6000m (about 5 weeks after the initial problem was reported), and 2 of the 4 USB ports did not recognize any peripheral components. I was promised that I would recieve a call from a level 3 supervisor the next day and did not. Called back in and finally recieved a message back to contact an extension for the missing supervisor. That's where I stand tonight 4/21/05.

I am hoping that they will grant me a new equipment exchange instead of a refurbished. I will probably sell it immediately (if I ever get one that works) and purchase a different brand.

I've lost about 40 hours just waiting/talking to tech support not to mention the many hours I was not able to use the computer for my work. The details of frustration with Dell's outsourced personnel and their inability to understand the nuances of the U.S. and our language has also been very, very annoying. I have tried to be patient and benefit of the doubt but it is truly a horrible, helpless situation and an incredibly annoying process.

It has to have an adverse effect in the long run.

peakester

by gil6002

I still dont understand to this day why people and IT puchaser's continue to buy big named manufactures computers except just to waste their hard earned money. The U.S. Government continues to buy Dell's but continues to have major problems with them and then continues to buy them and other named brand manufactures, time after time. Michael Dell thanks you all for making him rich and so do the other CEO's. :-)

by rentas13

In our office we bought 14 SX270's in Sep 03, of which 12 have already failed, seven this year alone and 2 today! A total design failure!! Now we celebrate their failure days instead of our birthdays....

by cp7212

Just wait until you order replacement parts, come as refurbished, then fail again. Had four motherboards like that so far..... I told the powers that be to let me talk to the Dell reps, but they won't let me. ;)

by kanenas000

One of the best proverbs i ve heared was a Rusian one, translated to somth like this:
Always look twice before u jump over a clif. Dell like all systems of all companies nowadayz are made of mostly cheap hardware, becauz of the necesity of low cost production and competative pricez. Btw if u choose precision series youy can overcome your issue, but then the question is "is it really worth to spend so much money for a pc?", and trust me on that answering that one might cause a real headache. The diference is that Dell gives you a third option. Buy cheap and pay a litle more to get WARANTY for almost anything. no matter how dificult is the issue ,if u got a nice support pack,u call Dell tech support and u get fixed.So look twice when u buy a system ,look 1. the system and 2. waranty As a profesionall when i m asked to make a repair, i wish to spent as less time(or no time at all...) to get the job done.
Thats what dell does 4 me. Maybe their is an issue with Dell tech support at yourplace ,but thats an other issue i cant note cauz i dont know.

This discussion is closed to new replies.