45 replies
by jkameleon
Gates earned his wealth by stealing our time, and time is money.
In the times of Windows 3.x, he saved his time by dropping all the work on application programmers. Consequentially, "Hello world" in C was more than 270 lines long.
He saved his time by slipshod programming. Time & energy wasted on Dr Watsons, Blue Screens of Death, and countless other issues, went directly on Gates's bank account.
He was stealing everyone's time & energy by hyping and pushing bothched standards & concepts (MTS/COM+, Win Api, ...) down everybody's throat.
And finally, he was stealing everyone's time & energy by rocking the abovementioned "de facto proprietary industrial standards"
Personally, I'm not complaining, though. Stupidity of M$ users does not make my job harder. It keeps my job. With M$ around, I'll always have something to do.
Bill didn't acquire anything from the Japanese; he built his monster himself.
How exactly did Bill steal anything? No one has ever been forced to buy or use a Microsoft product.
Of course he has work done by application programmers. That's why he hired them.
How EXACTLY did your time on a Blue Screen go directly to Bill's bank account?
No one has been forced to use any MS application. They have become de facto standards because people wanted to use them. That desire was probably fueled more by the MS marketing department than by product features, but advertising isn't theft.
by jkameleon
> How exactly did Bill steal anything?
By holding de facto monopoly, and selling malfunctioning software.
> No one has ever been forced to buy or use a Microsoft product.
You are not forced to buy gasoline either.
> How EXACTLY did your time on a Blue Screen go directly to Bill's bank account?
Bill saved money by not doing things right. You bought the stuff thinking it works. Once you found out that it doesn't, it was too late.
by jck
Paul Allen was the "big cheese" until he developed multiple sclerosis, then had to let Bill "take the reigns".
If it weren't for that, Allen might be where Gates is now.
As for earning his money, Gates might have grown it since the 80s to where it is now. However, he got an interest-free $50,000 loan from his wealthy, prominent Seattle attorney father to buy the first software system they used to develop a product.
He definitely didn't earn everything himself in the conventional business manner. "Daddy" loans aren't a part of the business world. Nothing in business is free.
by jardinier
Well I know which one I would rather be, but what they had in common (IMHO) was that each seized on a concept whose time had come, and doggedly developed the concept by application and hard work.
Has Bill Gates been any more tricky than other successful entrepreneurs? I doubt it. When you compare him with the great commercial empire builders of the past, who were nothing short of ruthless, and with today's energy barons and media barons, I think he comes out as relatively squeaky clean.
If you follow the history of Apple, I think you will find that they have an ongoing death wish. If there is anything they can do to NOT increase their share of the market, then that is what they will do.
Every now and again, when it is pertinent to a discussion, I raise the matter of my cousin, Sir Gustav Nossal, whose time is devoted to chairing the Bill and Melinda Gates' program to immunize millions of children in poor countries.
Gus has met and spoken with Gates on a number of occasions and, working closely with him as he has done, he has a great respect for the man.
by maecuff
by jkaras
he still had to make the right business decisions at the right times including today that made him wealthy. Risk=wealth if you got the guts for it or you fail miserably. He made a smart calculated risk.
Advertizing has made fools out of everyone in the past and daily. I dont know of anyone who decides to never see a movie from a certain movie company after seeing a real turkey that was sold as the next great thing. Sooner or later another movie comes out that you say wow that was great. The point of the example is even if a certain company makes some junk, they make something pretty remarkable that most if not everyone loves or sees it value.
When I see people rant on this issue it is nothing more than player hating jealousy. Anyone that wouldnt trade their life for his is a liar.
If I invest in stocks and make money did I earn it? Yes, whether I chose them myself with my own intuition or employed a stock broker. So what is the difference if I hired people to do work vs. doing it myself?
A win is a win in my book. He who has the most toys wins, points, or what have you.
by jdmercha
Bill Gates certainly didn't inherit his money. Therefore, he must have earned it. And I believe he started Microsoft from scratch by buying DOS from Digital Research.
And if Hollywood is to be beleived; he actually licensed DOS to IBM before he purchased it.
by jamesrl
Of a documentary on the subject, it was more complicated. If my memory serves....
http://www.skrause.org/computers/dos_history.shtml
IBM was in negoitations with Digital Research. They started to work a deal, but for whatever reasons it stalled. IBM was also working with Microsoft to buy Basic(something Gates actually did have a great deal to do with programming wise).
Gates realized IBM was in a bad way without an OS, and went out and licensed Seattle Computing's DOS, and offered it to IBM.
Timing is everything....
I do recall some of MS's less than honorable business practises (Disk compression - anyone?). But as has been said other companies have also been guilty - anyone read up on Henry Ford?
James
How is holding a monopoly stealing? Just MS holds a defacto monopoly doesn't force you to use his software. He's not stealing, you're giving your money to him voluntarily.
No, you're not forced to buy gas either. What's your point? If you don't like buying gas, look at the alternatives. Get a vehicle that gets better mileage, like a motorcycle or a scooter. Get a bicycle and forget gas entirely. Move closer to work and walk. Millions of people in the US use public transportation and don't even own a car. By choosing to own a car, you choose to buy gas. By choosing to use an MS product, you choose to accept the failings. If you don't like MS products, look at the alternatives.
Anybody who buys any software product thinking it will work has never read a license agreement. NO software manufacturer has ever guaranteed that their products do a stinking thing. MS isn't the only company that turns out crapola software. If you don't like it, why are you using it? Load some open source stuff and modify it to suit your needs.
by jkameleon
> How is holding a monopoly stealing?
Is there a better word for it? Extorsion maybe?
> If you don't like MS products, look at the alternatives.
There has been a lot of ink spilled about this. There were even ideas about giving M$ natural monopoly status.
It's not just about like or not like, since viable alternatives like Linux are only beginning to appear.
Webster's on-line defines "extort" as "to obtain from a person by force, intimidation, or undue or illegal power." Which one of these did Gates use on you?
It also defines "monopoly" as "exclusive ownership through legal privilege, command of supply, or concerted action; exclusive possession or control; a commodity controlled by one party." The key words are "exclusive" and "one party". Microsoft has neither exclusive control of software nor are they the only party. MS is only big on the desktop and server market, and they aren't the only player. They don't run at all on the big iron where *nix and other OSs rule, and they don't count for publishing where Apple is the, uh, "big apple". They don't even have programs for many scientific, medical, statistical, engineering, CAD, or dozens of other applications.
If you're losing money to Bill, it's because YOU chose to use his products. You either chose to use them at home, or you chose to work where Microsoft products are the preferred programs. You have the option to use other products at home, and the option to work where they don't use MS. You just haven't chosen to exercise those options.
by master3bs
Gates was at the helm as Microsoft became the giant it is.
Under his leadership his company made software products that most people who run use computers want.
Did he use a loan? Did he but from other companies. Did his company sometimes use bloated code that could have been written better? Sure. It's called leadership and business sense.
Give me control of Microsoft 20 years ago with the same monetary advantages Gates had and I guarantee you we I wouldn't be typing this message on Windows. Gates did a better job than I could; and better than most of us could.
by m_a_r_k
Say what you want about ol' Billy boy but he is a shrewd businessman. He's a visionary, astute, hard-nosed and has had a lot of good luck. He also gives a ton of his dough to charity. So what if he got a loan to start his business? That's normal. Not many startup companies have enough cash to subsist with no income. The history of Microsoft makes for some interesting reading:
[i]In 1980, IBM approached Digital Research for a version of CP/M for its upcoming IBM PC. Legend has it that Dr. Gary Kildall (founder of Digital Research) snubbed the IBM representatives by going flying in his Pitts Special (an aerobatic biplane) for several hours. Although widespread, the story is generally not accepted to be true because it was Kildall's wife, Dorothy, who handled business negotiations, not Kildall himself. Another story has it that IBM representatives wanted Dorothy to sign their standard non-disclosure agreement, which Dorothy considered overly burdensome. Kildall associate Gordon Eubanks has said that the non-disclosure was signed, but that [b]Kildall was not enthusiastic about porting CP/M to the IBM PC's 8088 processor. IBM returned to talk to Microsoft and Bill Gates saw the business opportunity of a lifetime[/b]. He obtained rights to a cloned design of CP/M, QDOS, from Tim Paterson of Seattle Computer products, licensed it to IBM, and MS-DOS/PC-DOS was born. [/i][http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gary_Kildall]
See also:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_gates
by master3bs
by m_a_r_k
by antuck
That Kildall snubed IBM by flying his plane. Either way IBM went to Bill and he took it on. Making the billions he has now and good for him too. If it were a different name, I think people would bash that person also.
Really, shame on Apple for going proprietary. Otherwise there would be two big vendors. Or we would all be using Mac's.
by jamesrl
They licensed the proprietary ROMs to others and there were Mac Clones - this during the time Jobs was off creating neXt. But it was too late in the day, and when Jobs came back, he killed it - not a hard decision cause they were doing much anyway.
Apple was always open and helpful to third party peripheral vendors -video cards, monitors, printers etc.
I worked for a Fortune 100 company that had more Macs than PCs at one point. Other than some networking challenges, there was no role they didn't do as well at as PCs.
James
by intram
by m_a_r_k
.
How much does 5 trillion pennies weigh?
If you stacked 5 trillion pennies, how high up would it go?
If you saw 5 pennies on the sidewalk, would you stop and stoop over to pick them up? What about 5 trillion pennies?
How big a piggy bank would you need to hold 5 trillion pennies?
If you put 5 trillion pennies on a railroad track, would there be room for any trains to run over them?
How many penny rolls would you need to roll up 5 trillion pennies? (Answer: 100 billion penny rolls.)
How many Brink's armored trucks would be needed to transport 5 trillion pennies?
How much would your bank charge you if you deposited 5 trillion pennies?
How long would it take to count 5 trillion pennies?
A penny saved is a penny earned, or so said Benjamin Franklin. So 5 trillion pennies saved is 5 trillion pennies earned.
There ya' go. Of course Bill Gates earned them. After all, who can't believe Benjamin Franklin?
by bruddaj
by dc guy
Adam Smith's free market was supposed to consist of buyers and sellers of approximately equal power. He would barf at the concept of a corporation with more money and power than Kyrghyzstan "negotiating" in the marketplace with individuals and small businesses.
The flaw is the nature of the corporation in Western civilization. Corporations were created by governments to replace the vanishing aristocracy. They have wealth, power, and no accountability. You can't execute one or throw it in jail, and fining it does little good because it just passes the cost on to its customers. Just like the ancient aristocrats, the outrageous dealings that corporations get away with distract our attention from our governments, so they can get away with far more outrageous dealings.
Stock ownership? Uh--there are two time-honored ways for an entrepreneur with a bright idea to raise capital.
One is to simply borrow it. The people who provide it assume no risk beyond losing their money, even if the entrepreneur does something dastardly. But the entrepreneur has to put up his home and other personal possessions as collateral. If he loses his shirt because he markets a shoddy product or does not provide support to his customers or fouls the environment and is thrown in jail--he literally loses his shirt as well as the closet the shirt hangs in, the house in which the closet is located, and the cars parked in its garage. There is a good deal of accountability.
The other way is to form a partnership with other people who like the idea and are willing to collaborate. This is especially good if the enterprise might cost more to launch than the total value of the entrepreneur's assets. No one can lose more than the money they've invested--unless the partnership itself takes out a loan or commits a crime. But having several people who are all risking a good chunk of their fortunes encourages them to keep a watchful eye on the original entrepreneur to ensure that he markets an excellent product and provides excellent service. In most partnerships all partners have voting rights so the original entrepreneur can't even make such a bad decision without convincing the other partners that it's a wise one. And they are probably more savvy than his customers and will catch a bad idea before it self-destructs. Again, there is a lot of accountability.
The problem with selling stock is that accountability is lost. If the entrepreneur loses his shirt, the stockholders simply lose their investments and can't seize his house as collateral. If he attempts to do something dishonorable, the stockholders' interest is so diluted that they're probably not paying attention. Even if they are, it's difficult for them to organize and out-vote him.
So we end up with corporations run by people with no feeling of accountability. Not to the people who finance their ventures, not to their customers, not to their country or the human race, eventually not to their own consciences. (And I don't mean to put Bill Gates in these last categories. I don't think he is an evil man.)
But wait, it gets worse. Somewhere along the way some brilliant evil genius came up with the concept of the HOLDING COMPANY. A holding company doesn't do anything, doesn't produce anything, doesn't add any value to the economy. It buys enough stock to have a controlling interest in another corporation (usually that's a lot less than 51 percent) and then runs it. Oh yeah, and skims the profits. If this sounds bad, you won't like the fact that holding companies can OWN OTHER HOLDING COMPANIES. By the time you get to the top of the pyramid, you've got a guy (they're always men) who effectively owns two or three percent of Company XYZ's stock and has no idea what Company XYZ does. Company XYZ may have 50,000 employees and supply a vital product or service to a large community, may be the backbone of its entire economy. But if the guy at the top decides that it isn't making quite enough money and it's competing with another of his holdings anyway, he can LIQUIDATE it.
Like I said, Adam Smith would barf.
Bill Gates is only doing what the governments of the world enabled him to do when, a few hundred years ago, they got the bright idea of inventing corporations and giving them all the rights and none of the responsibilities of citizenship.
Corporations are the aristocracy of the Age of Democracy. Bill Gates is merely the biggest of the aristocrats.
Perhaps help is on the way. It's been suggested that a great many of the enterprises of the Information Age will simply not require the huge masses of capital the Industrial Era enterprises did. After all, they require no smokestacks, no railroad lines. The economic underpinnings of the large corporation may be crumbling. The influential business leaders of fifty years from now may be people earning one or two hundred thousand dollars in today's money, with a few loans to pay off that financed the enterprise and a fussy brother-in-law partner looking over their shoulder.
There may be no place for insanely wealthy, unaccountable aristocrats in the future. Now THAT is what I call a Paradigm Shift!
by m_a_r_k
DC you wrote a lot of stuff. It'll take me a week to read half of it so I'll only comment on the first few paragraphs.
1) What does it matter if Adam Smith would barf at the idea of huge companies? He didn't create rules that free enterprise should be governed by. Only theories about how it works. Smith lived in a different age. And his theories never were realistic. They were refuted almost immediately. Hell, he was an economist. He wasn't supposed to be realistic.
2) Corporations themselves aren't necessarily accountable. Sure you can fine them but that's all. The executives (and to a lesser extent, individual employees) are accountable. Commit fraud and you spend time in the court system. Same with bribery or any white-collar crime. Ever heard of Enron? Global Crossing? And many others from the recent past? Why do you think all public companies are required to have ethics policies?
by surflover
by gkrew
by alwinlim1
by jkameleon
by antuck
by jamesrl
When they switched from the 680X0 architecture to the PowerPC Chip (Made by IBM and Motorola) they allowed third parties to make Mac Clones.
Essentially they had licensed ROMs to plug into MBs of any third party designs. They were a little cheaper but not a huge amout - about 15-20% IIRC. They used the same buses - cards, keyboard bus etc.
Trouble was though they tried, they didn't offer either a huge price savings or anything novel or extreme high performance to make it worthwhile.
When Apple started to falter (again) and Next was clearly dying, they asked Jobs to come back, and he was very much against licensing.
The Next boxes by the way were pretty cool - bsd unix IIRC, with a cool interface, display postscript.
Another former Apple and Next guy tried to build a PC OS from the Next experience - BeOS - it was pretty neat and very good performance but never caught on.
James
by antuck
I remember hearing about those boxes now that you mentioned them. I was into the PC's at the time and didn't follow the Mac's so closely. I remember hearing about Jobs leaving Apple and coming back.
Interesting though, both Gates and Jobs started simularly, and one mans product took over. I say both have earned thier money. One just a little more money.
by m_a_r_k
[i]"That way they made all the money themselves and kept strict control over production."[/i]
And by doing so, they stifled innovation and kept prices high, both of which were huge disadvantages against the PC clones.
by jdgretz
Was that because of their proprietary nature, there just wasn't the kind of anyone-can-build-one competetion at the low end of the market place. What Apple hoped to accomplish was to stimulate that market by allowing a limited number of other companies to also build machines based on Apples patents. Power Computing, DayStar, and others got into the market but went for the high end rather than the low end. Being more nimble they started taking market share from Apple in the higher profit end of things. When Jobs came back, he essentially closed the clone market by refusing to license the later versions of the Apple ROMs. (Stories differ on wether he wanted higher licensing fees, etc.)
Basically, other people could do it better, faster, and cheaper so Apple used it's "monopoly" on it's ROM code and kept that 10% market share all to themselves.
jdg
p.s. Hmm, I wonder if Apple will ever quit shooting themselves in the foot?
p.p.s. What would you say if Microsoft redesigned their OS so that over the past 20 years or so they totally obsoleted all your software and hardware three or four times???
the money he paid the japanese guy with ?
He didn't win the lottery and he didn't inherit it off his dad, therefore he put some effort into gaining it.
Did he provide value for money, is another question, there again what is the value of money. If I'm prepared to pay Bill for something he's got, then the question of 'value' is mine, not his. Hence your question is utterly meaningless. Of course he earned it, he had something I wanted to buy. It was cheaper to purchase it, than to make it myself and stealing it would have left me vulnerable with no claim to ownership.
by bruddaj
by bruddaj
by s_k_k
by surflover
by m_a_r_k
by absolutely
by bennett6p6p
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Community archive posts
Sort by Trending