Question Locked

Did you know you can mark answers helpful?

0 helpful
35 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

One of the new features we added to Forums during the revamp was the ability to mark an answer "Helpful."

However, since the revamp, I haven't noticed many answers getting flagged as "Helpful."

Of course, this could be the age-old problem of people not giving feedback. However, I'm betting that we haven't done a very good job of letting you all know about it.

So, if you've asked a question recently, go to one of your answers and look at the top right of your post (in the little gray bar that says "Post 1 of X"). You should see a link that says "This answer helped."

If you click that link, that answer is flagged with a thumbs up icon so that others can quickly find the helpful answers.

35 replies

by smorty71

I am going to flag this one as helpful. Note the little icon.

by now left tr

has this post been within: TODAY in Forums for the past week? That is not TODAY.

Just a Point...

by smorty71

I just checked my calendar. We'll take it out tomorrow :)

Remember, wherever you go, there you are...

by now left tr

By that time it will be Today, again (check your Cal tomorrow). Tomorrow is a day to late and today is to soon. It has to stay forever.

Edit: Mark me a helpfull comment tomorrow if you like.

by gadgetgirl

and when you've been, you've gone.

Most insightful.

Most helpful.

This is starting to get to you, innit babz?!

Work in the Mental Health sector - could I interest you in a small padded room somewhere by any chance.....?? :p

GG

]:)

by smorty71

I asked that that promo stay up a few days so that you all would become aware of the "Helpful" answer feature (which obviously needs to be retooled since no one has noticed it).

It should be gone tomorrow.

by gadgetgirl

offer someone a nice padded room, and I STILL don't get a thumbs-up...

sheesh

wot's a girl gotta do around here??

:p

GG

by maecuff

I'm giving you a thumbs up RIGHT NOW. Can't see it though, can you? You'll just have to take my word for it..

by gadgetgirl

Thank you!

Been following you on the board when I was able while I was off - how you doing?

GG

by maecuff

I'm just completely bored with the whole thing. I'm back at my old job starting today, so no more manufacturing work. That's good, I have a lot to do, but I'll miss the weight loss that's been going along with the physical labor.

I'll be happy when I can drive into work instead of riding the prison bus everyday. And I'll be happy when the 10 hour days go back to 8 hour days.

All in all, everything is pretty much the same. At least no one in my department have been the victim of vandalism or worse. That's still going on quite a bit and I don't see it ending. As of now, neither side has blinked.

How are YOU doing? Better?

by computab

Yes, but why would they?
Why would anyone bother to help someone out now, there's no incentive. The system of awarding point for the usefulness of a reply has gone.

by tig2

The incentive was never the points- couldn't exchange them for a pony. The incentive has always been to try to help out another tech in the trenches and maybe learn something new while you were at it.

While many are still learning about all the new stuff on the site, I have had an answer "rated" under the new system. It was nice to see the flag at a glance and know that I may have provided helpful information.

by computab

I agree with you entirely, but will everyone else agree too?

by smorty71

there is no point in helping people just to be nice.

by hal 9000

That you are nearly as cynical as me don't you?

But I have to disagree with the above poster as I know that I never answered any question for Tech Points as they where pointless pardon the pun :(

I saw it more as a learning exercise that involved attempting to answer questions that most times where not asked correctly or at best badly so you where most of the time guessing on what the problem could be and then attempting to come up with a solution. That's far harder than just posting to a discussion and getting forgotten in the rush. If I managed to help someone out that was just a side benefit as I mainly saw it more as a [b]Learning Experience[/b] for me while attempting to answer some questions.

Incidentally I don't think that I've go a single thumbs up from anyone so maybe you haven't promoted this option as well as you could have because some one has started a new thread thanking me for the help that I gave to a question that they asked.

Now who do I talk top about that 666 out of the Top 100 Site Rating? :^0

As I haven't asked a question yet I'm not sure how it works but I'm fairly sure that you can't award yourself a [b]Thumbs Up[/b] to one of your questions like it appears that someone is doing here. :p

Actually the sites got much better as I no longer am showing 42 discussions started so I suppose I can start a [b]New Discussion Now[/b] as every time that I tried to previously the mouse used to kill the computer and prevent me restarting it till it had looked at every possibility of what that 42 actually meant. Provided I didn't try to start a new discussion I could play on the site but the moment that I clicked on Start a New Discussion every computer this end would go crazy and shut down. :D

I was planning on starting a new discussion about WGA breaking XP far too often but it's just too easy and sounds of MS bashing which I wasn't really interested in doing. :)

But I like the idea of the [b]Thumbs Up[/b] as it quickly shows anyone going through previous questions which answer helped and which ones didn't.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

After all what where the use of Tech points?

Or are you one of the ones who wants to say Mines bigger than yours?

I actually prefer the new system as it quickly shows anyone looking through previously asked questions which ones where of assistance and which ones where of no help.

Many of the people asking questions didn't know what to ask or what info to provide so it was a guessing game quite a lot of the time which was a real [b]Mental Challenge[/b] and if you got it right it was just so much the better.

Now when someone posts an solution to their question it's a quick find and extremely easy for any newcomers to see what helped and what didn't help. I personally lost count of the number of times that I gave a correct answer to a question only to see it rejected because the person hadn't described their problem correctly.

So I would ask what's the difference now to what the old system was? If you like to think of it this way every [b]Thumbs Up[/b] equals 150 tech points and instead of collecting Tech Points that had no value you can not collect a number of Thumbs Up and still be able to say I've got more than you.

Col

by computab

Yes, but why would they?
Why would anyone bother to help someone out now, there's no incentive. The system of awarding point for the usefulness of a reply has gone.

by onbliss

...I always thought it would be a nice feature if TR allowed members to Rate other members. It could be both positive and negative and does not have to be technical.

Would TR consider this sometime in the future?

Infact I once wrote a big post about this, and at the last minute discarded it, thinking it would be out of place. (or did I post it? )

by marketingtutor.

cynics like apotheon would get horendous feedback, even though his editorial advice is quite apt and accurate *most* times. ;-)

by tig2

I think that there could be some validity in Onblisses suggestion- it would certainly carry more value than the current system which I believe is based on how much you post.

I think that a system based on quality of input could be an interesting thing. Perhaps you are correct and the feedback would not be based on genuine evaluation... but only time would tell and frankly it would be fun to watch.

I wouldn't give Apotheon horrendous feedback- he's helped me out too often.

by smorty71

we felt that the only person who can really judge how helpful an answer is is the person who asked the question.

Often, questions are so specific (certain OS, specific driver, etc.) that it would be very hard for someone else to evaluate a submitted answer.

Plus, we also worry that some members might downgrade other people's answers based on non-technical reasons. A person who has reached out for help (and received it) is less likely to do that (we hope).

by onbliss

:-) Actually I was thinking solely about non-technical aspects for the erstwhile Miscellaneous section.

I have not looked at the tech points system much to offer any sort of comments. So to me what ever current system would do. I do not know how I got the 10k points in the first place.

People could have TechPoints as well as KarmaPoints :-)

by nicknielsen

Nobody likes a smart-4ss. :(

Back to the bottom it is... :_|

by bluron

right hand side of post. sorry but i get no such item. i do use the line that is below the download area that asks if this was useful to you or not. thanks for all the good info.
oops just noticed the thumbs up next to post, still no little gray box in upper right, must be a 20 watt day.

by smorty71

who asked the question.

It will show up in the gray bar that says "Post 2 of 25" at the top of each answer. It is a link that says "This answer helped."

Once you click that, the member's post gets a thumbs up icon next to their post, plus they get another helpful answer added to their total (which we are working on displaying on member signatures and in profile pages).

The helpful answer option can also be undone if you find that it wasn't actually helpful.

BTW, we are working on making this a more noticeable element of the page for those who ask questions.

by bluron

answer and it should get a big thumbs up. thanks for clearing the brain fog.

by zen37

I was not even aware of the different messages on the board were either discussions or questions. I hadn't noticed it. I thing you should either put the new questions or hot questions on a different window or change the icon between questions and discussions so we can better see the differences. If you do make different icons, make them bigger too.

Just a suggestion. :-D

by hal 9000

It's people like that who create numerous accounts who could do some real damage to existing members who they dislike or don't agree with that could cause all types of problems.

I wouldn't like to see Trolls like that create 100 new accounts just to bag someone and give them a bad name that isn't deserved.

Just my 2 cents worth though.

Col

by hal 9000

Whenever I post it appears as Yesterday on the forums so I never get to see today let alone tomorrow. :p

Col ]:)

by techexec2

In order to encourage marking answers as helpful, make it possible to do so in the "Explore this question" area for the question asker.

For the question asker, replace the column of "thumbs up" icons with a column of "thumbs up" AJAX links that toggle between helpful (bright) and not helpful (dimmed). Make room for a "thumbs up" in the title of this section by reducing "Print this Thread" to "Print" and/or "Subscribe to this Thread" to "Subscribe".

This discussion is closed to new replies.