Discussion Locked

Do Employer's Have Right to Keep HR File?

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Just a hypothetical that popped on my mind related to something that happened at my company. You know how every company keeps an HR folder on each employee? It has all their reviews, filled out job application, any HR benefit forms, company policies that the employee signed, etc...

I'm wondering, does the employer have the right to keep that file and all its contents after you leave the company -- whether your leaving is voluntary or involuntary?

I was just thinking shouldn't the employee have the right to say "and I want my personnel file" when leaving? I mean that's the employee's home address information, that's the employee's SSN number, that's the employee's healthcare information, etc.

I'm posing this question because there was a bit of a blow out about this here about three months ago, but it resurfaced this week. Our executive staff was EXTREMELY displeased when our HR manager "lapsed in duty" (their words) and allowed an employee who was terminated to take their file with them.

I mean the executives were VERY angry. You should of heard them.

19 replies

by trockii

The employee's HR file belongs to the company. I does have personal information that once the employee leaves the company can be blacked out and such, but the employee should NOT get their file. I understand why the executives were upset. They have every right to be. How can you give a recommendation for this employee if you have no performance reports to look back on?

by tomsal

I can see the point about the employer needing the records for recommendations. Two other follow-up thoughts I have..

1) Do employee's have the right to get a copy of their entire file?

2) Do employee's have the right to request the company black out personal information (like home address, SSN number, etc.) in front of them.

I don't like the idea that you should just leave it up to the company to "black out the information" -- I don't trust folks easily and I'm anal about someone holding my personal information particularly with the increasing ID theft stuff going on and who's to say an employer who is angry (related to your firing) has integrity and keep trusted to do the right thing with your personal information?

by bfilmfan

If someone releases your private information from a former employer without your consent, there are a number of federal and state laws to deal with them.

If you had insurance through them, they immediately run afoul of HIPAA. Penalties include civil and criminal penalties, which could include jail time.

And having consulted with several insurance clients, i can tell you that firms live in absolute terror of a HIPAA violation.

by trockii

If they release (whether theft or otherwise) any of your personal information that's grounds for a lawsuit. I think if an employee wants a copy of their file I say give it to them. Take out all sensitive information (performance feedbacks, etc) that could get the ex employee upset at a specific individual in the company. The company have to protect it's current employees. Bosses can't fear writing someone up and then the person fired finds out that's the reason they were terminated and "waits for them outside". It's a sensitive subject. I don't think you have the write to black out your address (it's in most phone books anyways). If you have any problems I am sure your HR person can answer these questions. I am just putting feet in the CEO's shoes. LOL it's nice to dream sometimes.

by oz_media

If your employer DID try to scam you and even social enginner you, ANY half assed flat-foot investigator is going to ask exactly who has such information before proceeding. THEY have all the information and would most definitely be first in line for investigation.

My question to you Tom, WHAT possible benefit could an employer gain by social engineering former staff members?

For that matter, they could burn your house down or cut your brake lines, but for WHAT and WHY?

I think there is just a wee tad too much paranoia about security and privacy lately, yes there are malicious people in the world, they exist everywhere and not just IT. Revengeful mailce has been around a lot longer than IT and people could have screwed you JUST as easy in other ways all your life. Now that computers are in the mix, people have a paranoia about personal information and even with past employers? You know that your personal information was just as accessible 20 years ago as it is today. Theives have been around since the dawn of time, there are MANY other ways to get such info without having a copy of your information or a computer.

by maxwell edison

.
You asked, "Does the employer have the right to keep that file and all its contents after you leave the company..."

Not only do they have a right to keep them, but they probably have an obligation to keep them. Especially in today's litigious society, an employer may have the future need to recreate past circumstances, possibly having to explain themselves for certain things, etc. -- at least for a certain amount of time. I think I'd be a little POed as well.

by oz_media

What if the employee sues on ground of wrongful dismissal three weeks after being let go?

the company NEEDS supporting documentation, past performance reviews etc.

I would say it should be allowed to ask for a COPY of the paperwork but that's about it.

When you start with a company you give them permission to have and hold such infromation on you with confidence that it will not be used inappropriately.

The company is responsible for anything that happens as a result of them having your records.

Would you let your business licence be revoked due to some retaliation on a former employee? What are they gonna do, clear out your bank account? That's traceable, instantly.

I think it sounds like a disgruntled person, it remonds me of Steve Martin in The Jerk when all he needed before he left was his Thermos....and the lamp....and the...

I have had employees return after three days after being fired to say that it was THEIR stapler they brought to work and they are here to collect it. People get possesive and petty in such situations.

by nd_it

Our department created and maintains the company evluation database. That information is vital to the compay if someone is claiming wrongful dismissal. We have had to go back into the database for HR in order to bring up past reviews and anything that was written in their record. I agree with OZ, they should be able ask for a copy, but that's it. How else is the company going to prove that you once were employed there?

by dc_guy

That's why they call them that. Check the contract you sign when you first join a company if you have any questions. I'm sure it specifies that all records the company compiles on you become their property forever.

But once again, this is a legal issue. If you have a legal question, you should ask an attorney, not a bunch of IT experts. ^_^

by salamander

There are any number of reasons why an employer needs to keep this information for reasonably benign purposes. Here are some hypotheticals, just off the top of my head...

-Your employer needs an address to send your last check to.
-If you elect to take COBRA to extend your benefits, they need to pass your information to the administrator.
-If you were involved in any accidents at work, they need to keep track of that for mandatory annual reporting to OSHA.
-Your employer needs this information to create and mail your W-2 to you, or else you can't do your taxes.
-If your new employer calls to verify your dates of employment or your primary responsibilities, they need to have some info to go on.
-I would think that a company would have to keep this info around for auditing purposes and staffing statistics.
-If you were involved in any incident, like the earlier poster mentioned, that has any possibility of becoming litigious, they need to keep that information.
-I imagine that they need to keep your dates of employment for the insurance company in case you had any recent claims.
-Any retirement benefit information needs to be tracked in case you cash out now or try to access it later. Social security, 401K, etc.
-If you have any leave accumulated that you want paid out at your separation, I would imagine that they need to keep track of that, too.
-If you file for unemployment after your separation, the unemployment office would be required to contact your employer to verify dates of employment, pay rate, SSN in order to cut you a check, etc. I would imagine that, if that information doesn't exist, that the benefits would not be as forthcoming.

I have never heard of anyone being able to take the sole originals of their information when they left. I understand the concern with identity theft, but this is one area of exposure that cannot really be erased in any practical way.

by trockii

All excellent points. I sure wouldn't want to miss my last paycheck because I blacked out my address and ssn.

by salamander

Thanks. I would be wanting that check, too... :)

I got curious and looked it up. Apparently, the US government requires your employer to keep certain information for up to four years. Other state laws may require employers to keep information longer, and I don't know what other countries might require.

http://www.hrtools.com/HREssentials/P05_1770.asp

by jkaras

the point is how do you prove it was them? It would be nearly impossible, but I do get the other points.

Usually the violent personel acts that way because of improper firing or walking the person without their dignity. There are cases where the person just has mental instability but these snaps are usually from a bad atmosphere or being wronged. Do I condone just snapping? Hell no, but treating people like banished servants opens themselves to possible attacks unfortunately.

by oz_media

It should not be acceptable for a company to retain ANY personl identification (SS#, bank account info etc.)after you leave. You performance record etc. should be irrellevant.

If you have a prospective employer call for a reference they could always say, 'we don't have any records of his performance here', might not be in your best interests. But WHY anyone would be so paranoid as to request the company's file on them is what baffles me. I simply don't see what security measure this is at all, the company can't rip off your bank account, that is WAY to traceable.

Many companies have clear policies about how long records are kept and for what purpose, if yours doesn't then perhaps suggest writing one.

I STILL don't see WHY anyone would want to recover an employers records. Personal information should be destroyed or deemed worthless by the company, after they have finished all your taxation and separation paperwork, it is no use to them and most definitely no use to YOU after you leave.

I think the person you are referring to was probably quite pissed off and simply wanted to be a knob. It has no relevance or meaning to it at all, just a petty little thing to be a prick about when leaving.

Sorry, I still don't see the horror behind it.

Now if an employee wants a record of his performance ratings and evaluations, this could and should be copied and provided upon request, then again, performance evaluations should always be given to the employee after the evaluation is conducted, then you just need to hang on to your paperwork.

Sounds petty and useless to me.

by john.a.wills

When I was a German civil servant I was given a copy of each performance review shortly after it was written, so I could sue the author and have the file corrected if it was inaccurate.

by hal 9000

I got the same thing as well as free access to any details on my file. I know of one worker who sued the department after a car crash and was sent back to work "With Her Physiological Condition Cured" only to have her shoulder collapse several years latter. Apparently the correct follow up was not done from a diagnostic point of view and her Government records where freely provided as evidence.

The work cover people had rushed her back to work without allowing the medical staff to do their job or maybe the medical staff just where not interested but either way they totally destroyed her chances of ever working again.

But I think this is only a "Government Thing" as I've never seen it happen in any other place of employment.

Col

by awfernald

All evidence of "who" you were and what you did while you were in that company is (or should be) included in your personnel record.

However, though this is information on you, it BELONGS to your company.

But, you have the legal right to have copies of everything that is contained in that personnel record. If you request the copies, and they refuse to provide them, I would contact a lawyer who should be able to get them for you relatively quickly with a single phone call.

by tomsal

That's why I like throwing questions out on TR, like this one -- I got a lot of good responses and information back. Thanks all.

I personally am not affected by this, I have no issues with my employer regarding keeping my file or not..I was exercising my curiousity based on what I've seen go down here with others. Then I was just trying to play a bit of Devil's Advocate -- which I do often.

Again thanks all.

by hal 9000

Over here a company is required to keep these records for 5 years just to comply with the TAX Department Rules. So they have to keep at the very least a copy of these records in a secure manner particuarly with the Privacy Laws that are now in effect.

But what I did find interesting was a US friend showed me just how easy it was to find out information on anyone you wanted to in the US it took him all of 5 minutes to bring up what over here would be considered as Private and Confidential information. Now I certainly do not claim to know much about US laws or other things that go on about this type of thing and maybe this person was even a bit more paranoid than most but he did move to French Polynesia to avoid this from happening but in all honestly I do not think his personal data is any more secure over there either.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.