Discussion Locked

Do the people you try to help in Q&A ever frustrate you?

0 helpful
85 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Just curious, thought I'd throw this out there. This morning this topic came to me after my answer was rejected to helping with a problem in the Q&A. Now, mind you I really fundamentally couldn't care less about the points or the % of rejected answers to accepted or any of that petty stuff...and this really doesn't bug me in a major, kind of in a "funny smirking kind of way" if that makes sense.

But the guy asks a question that's short on detail and it seemed direct enough. So I give him an answer I know for a FACT works to solve the issue as its pretty simple and I've solved the same issue myself with the same solution time and again.

It was rejected because of the poster's own lack of experience (and its scary that even in his peer listing he states he's "new at this" and he says he is managing a network that numbers in the THOUSANDS...SCARY!!). I'm hiding some details to prevent identifying the poster so he doesn't get embarrassed, but trust me anyone of you with experience would of known EXACTLY what I was referring to in the answer as its very common.

It was a simple problem the guy had to be honest.

Anyway...enough of that...have you ever been annoyed by folks who either never give details enough but then reject your well thought out and typed replies in return?

I guess a second thought on this is what business does someone who even admits he's a newbie have being in control of a multi-thousand node network?

85 replies

by amcol

When someone asks you for something, by virtue of the fact they've asked they're acknowledging your right to say "no".

In this case you offered your expert advice. It was an offer, not an imperative. You implicitly acknowledged the poster's right to reject your advice.

Which is exactly what happened.

What irritates you more...the fact that your advice was not taken, or that it was rejected for what you consider to be a poor reason?

Either way, what's the difference. You can't control other people, only yourself. Offer your advice, then walk away. You've done what you came to do. What happens after that is beyond your control, and the only part you CAN control is your own irritation.

This post is case in point. If you take my advice, good for you. If you don't...no skin off my nose.

by tomsal

I will take all replies to this thread with a small grain of salt because I know "asked for" replies to take it as "what you are whining that someone rejected your advice?" tone. That was not my motivation...it was bred out of pure curiousity (which I know I have a lot of)

by tradergeorge

The fact that you ask the question denotes that you have some sort of expectation surrounding what you thought should have been the outcome of posting a reply. This is kind of like giving a gift and then developing hard feelings when the recipient does not react as you expect or wish. If one's own self-esteem is to survive, one must give and receive feedback in a totally neutral manner, and with no investment in whether it is acted upon or not. Otherwise, you are left angry, or as in your case, wondering at the reaction. This is what Psychs call an emotional investment in and uncontrolled situation. Nothing positive can come of it.

by ozi eagle

Hi,

If the problem Tomsal answered is the one I am thinking of, I must admit that the comment with the rejection was downright rude and derogatory (I think that's how you spell it).
I felt rather peeved at the tone of the comment, even though I didn't post.
I feel that any offer of help, even if wrong, should be treated with respect, as the answerer is putting in effort to try and help.
I know that it often takes me a long time to rate an answer, but that is usually because its a long time till I get back to that computer.

by jdclyde

It amazes me how many of the Q&A's that have several well thought out replies, and the original poster can't even be bothered to acknowledge the replies.

Are they too lazy to follow up?
Are they too unknowledgeable to understand the answers and afraid to say so?
Are they too afraid to give out the points by accepting an answer that solved their problem?

I would say the solution would be if a poster would not be able to have more than two open Q&A's at a time. To post a new one, and old one needs to be processed and closed.

Not like I actually expect to see that happen.

As for a noob having this job. First, haven't you ever taken a job where you learned as you went along? Anytime a perspective employer askes if I can do something, the answer is yes. I just don't mention that I would have to figure it out first.

Second note. Bet you a nice shiny new quarter that it is a Windows network.

by tomsal

I can appreciate taking a job learning as you go along...but really you'd think you know SOME kind of information about the job you are taking. Like I said I'm not into defaming someone (unless they do the same to me or someone I care about first) but just know this guy seemed like he was learning networking 101. Learn as you go or not...no way in hell I'd hire someone for a large network and they don't even demonstrate basic skills even a small "minimum experience" net admin would know.

by jdclyde

I have seen many people get jobs like this because they are the son of someone higher up the food chain.

Often hired by people that look at what we do as "just pushing a lot of buttons" all day. How hard can that be?

by vltiii

My question is why are you concerned about how qualified he is to do his job? That's an issue between him and whomever hired him, wouldn't you agree. His employer made the decision to hire him and must deal with the consequences of that decision. By virtue of him posting the question indicates that he doesn't know something. If you really feel that he wasn't at networking 101 level, the perhaps the solution would have been to reword your response to a level that he could understand. I think some of the previous responses are right on the mark and everytime you respond you confirm it further, and that is, it's more about you than whatever the issue was.

by thechas

I decided a long time ago to just take comfort in those that I have helped and who appreciated the help I gave them.

As to how a person with no experience or knowledge becomes an admin, that's quite simple.
They were able to hire him for a LOT less than a skilled admin.

Chas

by hal 9000

Your scaring me all over again!

Yes I know you are right but you do not have to rub in in do you?

Actually since we are already on the subject just how is it that every question that I open I find you've been there already?

Col :D

by thechas

Colin,

After innumerable weeks of 6 and 7 10 and 12 hour days at work, my body finally succumbed to a bug of some sort.

I have been home ill all week with nothing better to do than answer questions and post to discussions.

Chas

by jaqui

creating a major security breach with thier lack of knowledge?
;-)
they gotta stop thinking in $ and start thinking in $$$

insecure, inproperly administred networks cost far, far more than the wages of a skilled admin.

by house

We see the same problems that you do in the TQ&A. However, we don't hesitate to post the link. It is a matter of site etiquette and not necessarily the ignorance of a topic.

I've seen quite a few questions where the user states that they are in charge of 1000+ nodes while exhibiting a lack of knowledge in any computing related function. I don't get it.

Chris

by sleepin'dawg

Especially after the person has hung a 'newbie' label on themselves. You gave him an answer but probably, due to his technical inexperience, you scared the crap out of him. He probably doesn't know how to test your solution without directly applying it and is afraid if something goes wrong you won't be there to wipe his nose and change his diapers in the event something goes wrong, such as a missed keystroke or a typing error. Some people require spoonfeeding and handholding for even the simplest procedures. He labels himself a 'newbie' and his fear and inexperience are crippling him but he does recognize his shortcomings and will insist in asking questions. He just doesn't have the intestinal fortitude or knowledge to be able to implement them in a safe manner. What is simple and clearcut to you, with your experience, is probably far beyond his abilities to comprehend.
The fact that someone would place a clown like this in just such a situation, speaks volumes of the organization which probably never checked out his resume or qualifications. Also, he might have been inflating his position to make himself appear more important than he, in truth, is. You're right! The mere idea of turning this clown loose on a multi-thousand node network makes me shudder but the key here is that very multi-thousand node network. There are some around, I guess but none comes to mind at the moment and again I think this guy is just blowing smoke up your kilt and trying to impress you. Multi-hundred, yes; multi-thousand, no. Pray to the network gods he isn't someone in any organization that you have to deal with or as the ancient Chinese curse goes, "May you live in interesting times." Cheers, Dawg

by hal 9000

That multi K networks do exist and they are mostly Government installations.
Now to have a newbie in charge of one of these would scare the pants off me.

Just imagine they implement a Windose patch over the entire network which causes it to crash. Exit several Government Departments for the LOOOOONG duration.

I know I'm cynical but after working Government jobs it is always the bad ones who get advanced the more that they screw up the more advancement and pay increases they get. On the good side they eventually get to such a high level that they can not do any real harm any more and just blow their budget out the Window.

It's what happens in the mean time that hurts!

Col

by bfilmfan

Yes, I've seen the Peter Principle in action more times than I care to think of in government consulting gigs.

The other place that I see it happening is in out-sourced deals. The technically compotent staff, finally being disgusted, leaves for better opportunities and you end up with the folks who couldn't go elsewhere running the operation.

I can think of at least 3 government agencies that were infamous for promoting indivuduals far beyond their levels of technical ability.

And the other glaring fact is that the majority of these individuals do not bother or care to learn the nuances of technology.

by vltiii

Having spent 24 years in the military and now working within the government as a contractor, I can truly agree with what you say. Rising to ones level of incompetence is in full effect. Office politics carry considerably more weight than actual abilities.

by gralfus

This is a long shot, but some people don't understand where points come from and are afraid if they award points that the few points they have will be vaporized. I was a bit skittish the first time I asked a question, because I didn't understand that I would get lots of points every time I awarded points. I thought I might have to buy them or something in order to be allowed to ask questions.

by jdclyde

The whole point system isn't layed out very well that someone can just go the the FAQ and get a clear understanding of how you get/give/receive points.

There would be a posting, how to do postings.

by gralfus

Thanks for yet another example of how to post a rude useless reply.
Newbies by definition often don't know how to navigate a site, or even how to find the "FAQ". TR's opening page has a zillion links and areas, so most folks just dive into the discussions or technical questions because they are searching for an answer, as opposed to being a forum addict.
If you don't have anything good to say, then don't say it.

by hal 9000

Much now mostly because Chas has already been there and answered correctly no matter what the poster wants to believe.

The other reason that I do not answer many questions now is that the lack of feed back in no way helps. I would like to see the person with a problem tell how the fix was found or what cure was implemented.

I know I'm greedy but after all it is only by mistakes that we learn and it's better if it is others mistakes so we can learn from them but most of the questions that I've looked in on have been closed with every answer rejected so there is nothing to learn from these. I'm the first to admit that I know bugger all and I want to learn far more than I already know but to me the TQ & A section just is not the way to go. I get better feedback from questions listed in the discussion threads and learn more from these.

Actually how about this? We all get together and revoke Chas's Q & A privileges for a short time so we can have a chance.

Col :D

by jaqui

to bad the entire q/a isn't a searchable browsable archive.

it would be a great resource for everyone.

by jardinier

I'll second that motion. (no hard feelings, Chas).

There are MANY questions that I could answer, but Chas is always there first, so I don't bother any more.

But thanks Chas for all the help you have given me over the years.

by thechas

Just goes to show how little of a life I have.

Actually, the first 3 days of this week were the first time in a long time that I had a chance to get first pick at a number of new questions.

After a typical workday, I am lucky to be on the site from 6PM to 10PM (Eastern Standard Time).

Although when I stop and think about it, evening here is close to morning for my friends down under. So I guess I do get at a lot of questions before you get a chance.

From my personal observations, the bulk of the questions are posted between 10 AM and 3 PM (EST)

All in all, I suppose I deserve the ribbing I get.

Chas

by hal 9000

But you still deserve a slap on the wrists for being the first poster constantly to every open question on the Q & A site. :D

Anyway I hope you get better soon so you can return to what you love doing! :D

Col

by willcomp

Charlie, sorry to hear about your bout with the bug. Get well soon.

But that explains why you've been so active in Q&A lately. I do read answers and usually go on to another question if I have nothing of value to add. Seldom have to add anything to yours, so I just try another one. Appears that our expertise is pretty much in the same areas anyway.

Dalton

by willcomp

I answer mainly hardware and OS questions, so many of questioners I deal with are inexperienced. Even taking that into account and trying to be both simple and thorough, I sometimes provide information they obviously don't understand.

While that is somewhat frustrating in itself, the more frustrating aspect is that we don't have an open dialog with questioners. Structure of TQ&A precludes a discussion type format (which may not be all bad seeing how off topic discussions can become). There is also no mechanism to require feedback from questioners, so in many cases we don't know what worked and what didn't and what was tried. There are changes in the mill by TR staff that may address some of our concerns.

In same vein as your incident, I recommended that a questioner check 5VDC power on LED on motherboard. After having response rejected, it was apparent he did't have a clue as to what I was referring to.

So this stuff happens. I'm not as stoic as Chas, but have had enough successes that failures aren't as difficult as they once were. Now when I get to 500K points, might be as forgiving as Chas is. Until then, some of the rude and crude people will get under my skin.

Dalton

by jardinier

I KNOW that I have offended a number of people just because I don't know how to manoeuvre around Technical Q & A.

I left questions open indefinitely because I didn't know any better, and I have closed questions incorrectly simply because I didn't understand the correct procedure.

So I apologise to anyone who can remember me making a faux pas in Technical Q & A, but after seriously offending a very helpful peer recently, I think I have finally got a handle on it.

Col makes reference to lack of feedback.

On a number of occasions I have received personal emails thanking me for the advice I gave.

As mentioned in another posting, the newbie (as I once was) does not understand that they will be awarded 1,000 tech points simply for asking a question and closing it.

by jaqui

on a few I have also received email through the message to peer system thanking me for help.
one even requested permission to continue asking me for help.
but no way to reply to them, as no contact info given.
~chuckle~

by hal 9000

Isn't it?

I find it even more frustrating than those who just reject every answer I'm willing to help them as required but am unable to contact them so they must get the impression that I do not care or can not be bothered answering them.

Perhaps that is one thing that should be looked into to improve the position.

Col

by jardinier

Use your email address as your TR alias, as I have done from the time I joined.

So these "Thank you" emails have come straight to my personal email address, which has enabled me to follow up if appropriate.

I seem to recall that Colin used his email address as his alias, until recently when he realised that he was on the point of going totally berserk like his current alias HAL 9000.

by hal 9000

I passed that point years ago when I chased an apprentice out of a building with a 24 inch number 1 Phillips screwdriver attempting to nail him to a wall with the screwdriver through his chest.

He messed up bad and I spent 3 days trying to discover what he had done wrong when I did I gave him the job of repairing what he had done wrong and he repeated the same mistake again destroying a lot of expensive hardware. He seemed to think that if you just pluged it in and ran it things would be OK instead of using a signal generator to test that he had the connection right.

I just stood there dumbfounded when the whole thing came to a grinding stop and then "He" walked in Grinning and Laughing at what he had just done. I snapped then and have never fully recovered I'm still upset that I never caught the little SOD!

Col

by bfilmfan

Sorry to hear of your illness and wish you a speedy recovery.

I recommend a daily dose of Geritol to all my fellow elderly conulstants. :)

And now, I am running and ducking for cover!

by hal 9000

Bottles of Scotch.

They probably will not do anything to help cure you but then again

WHO CARES?

Col

by thechas

At least I don't consider myself part of the Geritol generation just yet.

There have been several 3 day bugs going around this area.

After working most of the week between Christmas and New Years followed by 2 weeks straight, I think my body just decided it was time for a break.

Made it in to work today, and several other people were missing.

It's just that time of year.

Thank you for all the good wishes.

Chas

by husp1

I still consider myself a newbie and have found that the Q&A section a great help not just for myself bit as a reasorce to show others that I know what I'm talking about,(one head better then two)I have turned down jobs because of my lack of knowladge in certain areas but I do that because I am honest not greedy (barely understand networking cause its hard to learn on one computer lol. ) still to see that someone is placed in a position of running a multi K network without the proper skills scares the begeebers out of me. (probably why I still get those wonderful viri laden e-mails) but remember that I at least appreceate your help and knowladge!!!

by thechas

This kind of feedback is why I continue to check the site as often as I can and add my thoughts as I feel they are needed.

Believe it or not, when I first started looking over the Q&A section I thought I did not know enough to answer many questions.

I'm still most comfortable with hardware issues as that is where my formal training is.

Thanks again for the words of encouragement.

Chas

by hal 9000

You're just a Techie who knows virtually nothing.

Defiantly not Management Material but like all good techies you know what your limits are and adhere to them.

Always believe that there is far more to learn than the minuscule amount that you so far have been able to absorb and you really don't know a lot it's just that you've had more practice than some others.

Right?

Well that is the argument I use and I'm keeping it as it works for me to.

Col :D

by hal 9000

They already know that the more they screw up the better off they will be. So it would be in their best interests not to know anything about anything.

Now what was the name of the movie that was situated in a Vets Hospital where the research side got all the goodies and the medical staff where left with the mess to attempt to clean up. After the siege the guy in charge said to the director of the place

"It's a sad fact that the SHIT always rises to the top!"

Col

by admin

95% communication 5 % technology.

Don't accept a job unless the statement of work is well agreed upon with detailed common terms.

Working with people on different levels of experience and with different words goes with the terrority. You can both use the same words and still not be talking. In fact, you probably are to begin with.

If you limit your clientle to persons who are at the same place and language as you expect to starve.

If you include everyone in your clientle no matter what communication takes place upfront you will starve.

It's not an answer until you understand it.

Hope that is helpful. :>

by jaqui

if the contact peer / message was enabled then a quick reply could be sent, giving contact info if desired.

and I know what you mean with the reject every answer. makes me look at the questions the person has asked to see if they have that habit before answering another they post.

by hal 9000

Some people do not have their listing active. I suspose for privacy reasons or something. It is these people who I find problems with. They contact me through the Peer Listing and do not give a forwarding e-mail address.

Actually I got a derogatory one recently and I had absolutely no idea who it was from what it was about or whatever. Added to the mix was the fact that the person involved didn't use English as a first language so I was a bit mystified as to what I had done to warrant this. I never did find out what it was all about. I'm just left wondering who I've upset and what it was all about as I really have no idea and have not been able to find the person on any of my Discussion or Q & A threads.

Col

by jdclyde

There was nothing in my post that was rude, or could even be taken as offensive.

My valid point is that the point system isn't spelled out, say in a pdf you can download and read. You have to jump around on the FAQ page reading the different aspect of the points.

So I did have something good to say, and I did say it.

Not every post here is a personal attack directed at you. Were you just having a bad day? Maybe today will be better for you.

by cp7212

I just do it. I don't look for any kind of compensation...points, ego soothing, etc. I figure I gain a lot of knowledge, so I am willing to give some back.

I was in a group of online people way back when AOL was $2.95/hr and I always figured it was money well spent because I was learning.

I get to chat with some knowledgeable people here. I agree with most of the posts, you (as in the third person, not you personally) don't have to post anything if you don't want to.

Personally, I average about 30% of my answers acknowledged, points or no. I figure it won't matter next week, so why bother?

by jaqui

wired a tower for a wang system.
( 8 floors of highrise for this lawyers office )

sitting on the floor of the computer room, between mini-comp and wall to be specific, soldering serial connectors onto the cables for the terminals.

in walks system admin, proud of companies brand spanking new computer.
he sees smoke coming up from behind the system and screamed.

I just about pissed mysef laughing. would you forget that you have techs contracted to wire the building and get the system running?
he did.

by oz_media

Sorry but I can't say enough times just how 'unclever' it is to use an email address for an alias.

Recently a moving company did this, have you noticed just how many people have talked about adding it to every spam list they can find? If not just spamming from their server?

Also another reality that happens here is that Tech Republic articles get indexed by search engines. Someitme when you are searching you will run across a post fomr here. Sounds great but it has a really nasty effect.

Email spiders crawl the web all day and night collecting email addresses for spammers ot build their lists, any email address it finds listed it will add to the spam list. The spiders are set to penetrate several levels of pages if not all pages on the websites they find, seeking the contact pages, info addresses etc. from the site.

With a TR article this could be a goldmine!! Thousands of email addresses form ONE hit!! SO they sell it to other spammers and so on and so on, list generation is a massive industry in itself.

NOw lets say ONE person SOMEWHERE down the line gets hit with spam that also is a virus, they get their address book nailed and any private contact you've had with them is now sending that virus to you.

So from ONE email address, you can receive thousands of spam mail, and direct or indirect viruses.

All because your posting was found by a spider on the internet.....no thanks.

Not trying to take a piece out of you or anything, just trying to explain the horrors that many don't realize are there. :)

by husp1

glad to see that there is still so humor left in the world, guess we all will be learning new things untill the day we die. I just thank god that my brain hasn't turn to mush from some of the misinformed or useless trivia that floats in some of these posts.(LOL) god help me I just do this for fun not profit so I'll just keep plugin along and maybe one day be as compitent as some of you guys

by thechas

Might I suggest taking a deep look into questions that pique your interest.

For many a question, I delve into a hardware manufactures web site looking for detailed information.

From time to time, I even set up hardware just to verify what I think will happen in a specific situation.

If your goal is to learn, digging into a few problems that interest you is one of the best ways to speed up the process.

Chas

by husp1

I have experianced several different hardware and software issues by working on other "users" systems.(I service 50 systems for home users on a freelance basis.) but I haven't tried a self made setup like your suggesting, I'll give that a shot! Thanks!!!

by oz_media

"Bind us all together,
Ablaze with Hope and Free.
No storm or heavy weather,
Will rock the boat you?ll see."

We stick together as a community, those that don't don't gain the benefits of the community.

When cp7212 said

"I just do it. I don't look for any kind of compensation...points, ego soothing, etc. I figure I gain a lot of knowledge, so I am willing to give some back. "

I figured, well that's the whole point isn't it? And it's WHY people that DO share as a community get mad at those hwo don't. NO it's not for points, or even a pat on the back. It's because we are a community, one that I am happy to be a part of too.

Why should SOME of us gain knowledge and benefit from each others feedback and input, while others just come here to gain some knowledge, full stop.

It is aggravating sometimes, I will often do some research into a question that interests me, either because the poster is honest and really lost and needs some help or if it is someone I know would do the same for me, or I hope would.

I have spent several hours working out problems with people, even involving other peers by email and finding a solution for someone on TR. It's what makes it great. Then the person says NO that can't be it, when you know very well they haven't even tried but are just not hearing what they want to hear, admittedly being clueless about it to begin with. If they found something that worked and posted back I wouldn't mind, if they said, thanks but it was ....., that would be fine to.

Just 'unaccpetable', it's a bad word for turning down a post and they don't have a choice I know, but to not say anything, is rude and inconsiderate.

This is a legitimate complaint I think, yet I fear that there's nothing we can do about it and no way to stop it really. We cannot control some people's nature to be selfish or unthankful when a complete stranger lends a hand.

We soon know who they are though and they rarely get too much help after that.

We also know just how much each others help is appreciated and that's what keeps us here, a common goal of suporting our industry and the people within it.

Anyhow, enough of that. If they piss you off, post about them and humiliate them in any way possible, it always makes you feel better. Hunt them in other boards and post back with details so others can move to those boards and flame them as thankless morons who went elsewhere for help and ran away. Why I outta!!!

:)

by raticus

I have put a few questions on this site and also hate the simple "unacceptable" response. Often answers may not be helpfull, as I have tried them or somesuch but are still usefull to know. If that happens I want to keep the question open to get other replys. Also tis hard to rate own expertise. I dont get on very often as I share this puter and I am disabled attending alot of medical appointments. I do this to learn, hopefully get a job one day. Twod be nice to have an income. My appologies if I have offended any one, and my thanks for all the effort put in my dirrection. As far as the email comment, this is why I didnt put my email addy, cant stand spam.

by hal 9000

Now its back to 200,000 Hail Marys {or you could make that Bloody Marys} and a couple of million Our Fathers.

But after all those Bloody Marys I don't think you could get up from under the table to say "our Farthers!"

Col

by tomsal

"Kill for gain or shoot to maim,
we don't need a reason..
the golden goose is on the loose,
and never out of season..."

oh um sorry I guess I'm quoting the wrong song.

up the irons!!!

;)

by oz_media

I knew it would fall on many deaf ears, but there was one peer I figured would pick it up, which you did. Well done.

Most people would never give them any notice but observation doesn't only come from philosophers.

Two minutes to midnight came to mind too, but the part about killing the unborn in the womb probably wouldn't go down so well. :)

by vltiii

Nice well thought out post... until you started talking about flaming, hunting down and flaming more. I have a very hard time trying to figure out why mature adults would feel they have to result to attacks because someone else is either ignorant or just inconsiderate. Wouldn't it be much easier to just ignore them? Eventually, they'll just go away or modify their own behavior to conform to the majority.

by gaston nusimovich

TomSal is right to point out this situation.

Many a time you get unpolite answers from peers.

When you offer an answer to a problem, you are open to receive any reply, including rejections.

The point is not the rejection, even if it is unjustified, the point is the absence of good manners, the absence of etiquette.

The truth is we, as a group, should play some role in the enforcement of etiquette in the use of these resources. We are a virtual community and we should behave like a community.

by rapell

I agree, TomSal was right in pointing this out. What does it cost one to say, fine thank you, I tried your solution, but it didnt work in this case? Acknowledging could help the would be helper to wonder, why? then you could do a further T/S and find some vital info you weren't giving, but bashing a helping hand, yet the problem might be with the needy is just a sign of weakness!! We share alot, we learn alot at TR, that makes us partners in education, please lets appreciate that.

by danag429

Back in the Paleolithic era, I was Tech Support for a division of Vivendi Universal. The people who did not listen were the ones with the least knowledge.

One guy said, "I'm a mainframe programmer" and I got worried it would be another one of those people who think they know everything when they know nothing.

Then he said "I don't know much about these little computers, so you'll have to talk me through it". This was a very wise person, he listened, and even though he understood many technical ideas, he waited for my directions before pressing any buttone. He was a breath of fresh air!!

So when I want to moan and gripe, I just think of this guy and feel that the world is not completely stupid, just mostly stupid. Inspiration!

by ibm5081

Since problem statements are frequently less than comprehensive, vital information is usually absent.

I can provide one non-unique solution to a problem that I solved, whether it fits the poster's situation or not. I try not to see it as MY solution, only A solution (or approach). Disconnect the ego from the offered solution.

There are the posters who are pompous and those who are simply pitiful, along with the trolls. Many times it's better not to offer an answer at all.
My theory is that job descriptions and hiring practices do result in underqualified folks in responsible positions with big job titles due to the budget. This encourages management to title someone in excess of their skills and experience and leave them there.

by tomsal

"Disconnect the ego from the offered solution."

First, thanks for contributing. Personally I believe and others around have said things to make me think I'm right on this -- that I'm on the other side of the spectrum from someone who has a big ego.

In fact big ego's drive me insane.

The problem, and therefore the underlying frustration stems from wishing the poster who seek help had a better understanding of the solutions offered to them.

My frustration came because not of ego, but because I really wanted to help the guy out and I knew for FACT that my solution would have helped the guy? Why because of experience that's why.

I've been through what the poster was seeking help on. I know how to fix it.

Then when you get no feedback, like perhaps even "Please explain your solution to me because I don't understand you fully". That just got me thinking about what goes on in TQA.

by ladyjet

Tom: I've been involved with computers (1984) and the Internet since 1992. Over the years, I've run into people who have no "netiquette" (for the newbies, that's Internet Etiquette) whatsoever. The newer the person involved, the more rude they are even if they do admit to being "new to this" technology or IT. It's nothing but fear, or lack of self-esteeem and confidence. It's not right, but it happens all the time. It's also hard for some people to read the "emotions" of an email/response without the emoticons...even if they know the response is right.

Unfortunately, this is not exclusive to the computer industry, but to all industries (i.e., electronics, etc.). The schools they are getting their degrees at are not teaching them enough.
I've heard my husband, involved in the computer/electronics industry since 1976, mourn that when he interviews possible employees and asks questions that are very basic for the computer/electronics field, they don't know the answer. He wishes that 1) either the people new to the type of work they're looking for paid attention in class, or 2) the schools need to teach them in a way they can absorb the education. However, that's not the only problelm. People who've been involved in the industry for years looking for employment, don't have the basic answers either because they don't keep up education in their fields. In any job you have, you have a duty to yourself and your employer (that's regardless of loyalty to the company, BTW) to keep up on advancements in your field.

It wouldn't be so bad if they could say they just don't know or that they're willing to learn, but they get rude, sometimes downright nasty, especially when they're online. It's a response you get when they don't see you face-to-face. If that's the way they react online when they can't see a person, how do they act when they're face-to-face with someone, perhaps their boss or a co-worker?

People who deal with industry or even people on mailing lists need to consider using basic courtesy when dealing with others, be it online or face-to-face. There's no reason to be rude to anyone.

Jet Tenley

by blueknight

First off, I agree that the person posing the question has no business, as a confessed newbie, being responsible for thousands of nodes. My guess is that either he's related to the boss, or the boss is totally clueless as to what caliber of people are required to provide decent support.

I saw a similar posting in another forum where someone responded to a question, which was devoid of sufficient detail, and another jumped into the discourse saying that they'd never be caught dead running XYZ software because he had a PC with that very same software die and he had to reinstall everything on it... supposedly because of that one particular application.

Jumping to a conclusion that a piece of software is to be avoided at all costs just because a machine that had it installed died, just shows the lack of experience possessed by the respondent. I see this many times each week.

I don't mean to offend anyone, but it seems that the rude responses typically come from members of the "generation X" era. There are however, many others of the same age group that are very courteous and helpful, and in a number of cases I wish I had some of their knowledge on top of my own.

All that being said, I don't lose any sleep over the demeanor/attitude shown in forums by others.

As for the advice given, it's like an old preacher once said "be like a cow, eat the hay, and spit out the sticks."

Unfortunately, there are some out there who can't tell the difference between hay and sticks, which is scarey... but their inability will be exposed when whatever it is they're responsible for crashes.

by alanfinn

TomSal,

I understand well your flustration. I started applications programming in 1970 and progressed to systems (read modify the operating internals) programming in 1976. This was in mainframes. All the P.C. world has done is re-invent the wheel. For instance, "paging" (P.C.ers call it "swaping") has been around since 1974, "servers" now fill the role of mainframes/miniframes of the previous era as do LANs and WANs fill the role of 1970s peer-to-peer processing.

Since I made senior applications programmer in 1974, I've been pounded by "idiotic" questions. It only gets worse with experience. Calm down. Sometimes, the person doesn't realize how much he/she DOESN'T know. Other times, the applications (MS OFFICE, JAVA SCRIPT, XML, etc. ) programmers haven't the foggiest notion how the excuse for an operating system - WINDOWS - works, but they know-it-all because they are great in their little area of what I call end-user programming.

Just give it a sigh and think of when you thought you had all the answers and (in reality) didn't know a little knowledge is dangerous. Or, just save yourself the flustration and DON'T RESPOND.

by mgordon

"Have you ever been annoyed by folks who either never give details enough but then reject your well thought out and typed replies in return?"

Not really annoyed because I expect it. Here's what happens: The complainer is an ESFJ or ESTJ: impulsive, black-and-white thinker or feeler. Do it now and do it quick. Or to quote Yoda, "There is no try, there is only DO, or DO NOT."

The reality, as seen by the ultra rational types (INTP; google it) is that "reality" is arbitrary, capricious and defined -- meaning, the interet exists only because enough people agree that it should and agree on the protocols. But nothing forces any provider of hardware or software to conform completely to the protocols. There is no black and white and Yoda was mistaken -- there is no "DO" there is only "Try!" when it comes to a blended environment of Microsoft, Citrix, Cisco, Linux and heaven only knows what mix of cheap Linksys and Netgear switches and "routers".

An INTP person will always provide excruciating detail when requested for anything. Less than that is dishonest, prevaricating, etc. What the ESFJ/ESTJ sees is a morass of wishy-washy, prevaricating stuff that obscures the answer.

No easy solution exists. ESFJ/ESTJ types almost always gravitate toward command and control jobs; INTP's almost always gravitate to cubicles and network operations centers.

A suggestion: If the INTP can be taught to exercise his talent and apply optimization strategies (calculus-style optimization algorithms for instance), and then provide the MOST OPTIMUM and the LEAST optimum choices ONLY, to the ESTJ boss, everyone will be more happy. The fact that five hundred other choices exist is of no interest to the ESTJ and the INTP is not going to choose them either 'cause they are not optimum.

by todd

A lot of times I go to Q&A (I've never answered a question yet), and found that someone has already posted the correct response or the same response I was thinking. If someone reading it, doesn't feel it will work, then they are welcomed to continue trying what ever they think will work. Eventually they will either find an alternate solution or alternate line of work. The only reason I would get upset is if I actually did care about the points.

by tomsal

This isn't a self-esteem thing at all, perhaps I improperly explained it in my original post (which is very possible).

I'm a type of person who is not afraid to question things, is one who thinks about why this are, how things work, etc. In a nutshell the closest "lay term" I can think of for this is what folks call curiousity.

Frustration, yes -- because I like helping people solve issues and technical problems. When the solution doesn't get accepted that is known to be correct, its a shame because I know it could of helped.

There is nothing wrong with questioning WHY. The folks who are really warped are those that never question anything.

Thanks for your input.

by tradergeorge

I probably keyed in of your professed frustration when your solution is rejected. Being curious is one thing, and I don't think I said anything was wrong with questioning. I am just like you. I question everything.

That being said, when the outcome does not conform to your expectation, you become frustrated. That means that it is not about them, but in fact about you. Hence my reference to self-esteem.

by tomsal

Not a smack to do with self-esteem on this issue. We'll just have to agree to disagree.

by dmiles

I had to learn to not take it personal when someone post a question and wishes they knew enough to solve the problem.
There was once a post that involved a problem, concerning memory,after answering the question with a solution,he rejects my answer and then posts comments that he figured it out himself using the posted answer.For the small percentage that know it all and cannot acknowledge the help,I try to shrug off because there will be two that will appreciate the help,and let you know.
They Wish they could Think of Ways to be Important

by j.penney

Yeah, that sounds like the last 15 years.

With supposedly technical people I'm almost never surprised when they reject my suggestions - we're all a little egotistic and a bit insecure, right?

Don't want to admit we're wrong, even if we just did admit it.

It's sure weird.

And as far as a rookie running a big network - that's the manager's problem. Good for the rookie, fooling the idiot manager into giving him a good job with a fat salary!

JP

by tomsal

...being set up for complete failure...not all his fault (the manager needs to take responsibility too), but I don't know...is it really all roses fooling someone to hire you for a job of a magnitude you admit through a public forum essentially you don't know anything about doing?

Sure its great the first month or perhaps a few months - the guy's probably never personally seen bigger paychecks in his life or benefits package...but those that are truly unable to handle the workload and/or its related responsiblities -- will eventually get a HUGE wake up call. A shame in some respects really, because I'm sure this employee only wanted to into the industry and a fool manager gave him too much too soon.

Anyway..it all comes back around in the end.

by tomsal

Its a topic that came to mind for the purpose of discussion (this is called a Discussion board)..nothing more, nothing less.

Trust me, I haven't lost a second of sleep, expended a brain cell of worry on this situation...lol..

But I guess some folks don't appreciate those that question things or have curious minds...lol

by tomsal

Nope. But hey I like the fact that everyone voices their own opinions, that's what makes these things (forums) have a level of interest and hopefully serve some kind of purpose to solve an issue.

I understand that some folks will (and have pointed out) that it is read by them as a self-esteem issue on my part, and I feel if someone opens a thread for discussion, to a certain extend they need to be prepared for some responses. However, I will disagree with you (or anyone) who shares the opinion my motivation for these thread was due to a bruised ego, self-esteem or anything related to such things.

by vltiii

...and you would almost have to kill someone (and even then you might only get a letter of reprimand) to get fired. If one can't do... get a government job!

by house

...frustrates me. Whether or not it is here at TR, email, telephone, on-site...

The only real solution sometimes is to show up, solve the issue, and lock them down :)

by hal 9000

Even locking them down is no guarantee that the user will not stuff it up again. There is one big problem that I've yet to come to grips with and that is what takes up the space between the seat and keyboard, once you can overcome that problem its easy from that point on.

Col ]:)

by house

Maybe I could lock that down.

Tie it up and hang it from a bridge. It may work. :)

by hal 9000

That simple!

I have a friend who is a surgeon and every time I go down there I can guarantee that the last time that the AV was updated was the last time I went down there.

But it is tempting isn't it?

Col ]:)

by house

What is it about the medical field that promotes ignorance when it comes to data protection, security, and backup? My buddy just finished up a short term contract with a local hospital (my former position as well) where he had to install a Citrix client for remote data/utility access.

He told me that maybe only 5% of the machines that he came accross were actually secure and within a functional standard for the client's installation.

by hal 9000

But you know it has really got bad when you are taken into an Emergency Room and to get some form of treatment you have to fix the interface between the Windows workstations and the Unix mainframe with all the patient records on it.

I had to do that the last time I went to one of the local hospitals and then they carried on about me having access to a end users password. :D

Col ]:)

This discussion is closed to new replies.