Based on his article, Mr. Dray seems to have a cynical
perspective about voluntary contributions to the community and
society. Contributing to society is one of the most significant
items that make this world a better place to live.
It seems to me that Mr. Dray's objections to free tech support
stems from poor planning, communication, and implementation.
Let me address each one of Mr. Dray's points:
1: This can be resolved by managing expectations. Good
communication and setting expectations beforehand will
prevent this. If they ignore your agreements, you can always cut
them off by politely explaining to them that you no longer have
free time available to assist them.
2: This too is managing expectations and communications.
Simply explain before you provide support that since they are
not paying for it, it is at their own risk, and that you are not
guaranteeing the work as well as other things not related could
cause problems in the future. Getting a release in writing is
better.
3: Properly setting expectations beforehand and teaching the
person how to utilities available support resources as part of the
support can resolve this issue.
4: Setting expectations beforehand and managing them from the
beginning again resolves this problem. The shop could have
spelled out in a statement on the receipt for the item that
routine maintenance and training was not defined by the
support agreement.
5. Not your responsibility. Politely explain to the recipient that
your services had been sold without your permission or
agreement and that they should contact the seller for a refund.
This issue is between the seller and the buyer. Again, properly
setting expectations, that you are only helping the client, and
not all of their friends and acquaintances, can alleviate this.
6. The "invoice" is a good idea. Letting the client know
occasionally what support people are paid for your services also
helps. Letting them call for product or paid support other than
you occasionally, if you help them on a regular basis also helps
them appreciate you.
7: Some things are more valuable than money - like the hug
and smile on the face of a little child that had a deadline for
some schoolwork when their computer broke and you got it
going for them in time. Then again, what is wrong with a little
charity now and then? Sometimes expert services done right are
worth more to charities than money.
8: Unfortunate but life is not perfect. This might have been
prevented by knowing your client a bit more before
volunteering. An experience with a single "bad apple" like this is
not a referendum for a blanket statement that you should not
provide free tech support when it seems appropriate to you. Mr.
Dray admits that this only happened once in 15 years.
9: First of all, what was he doing fixing hardware on a good
dining room table or putting hardware on the seat of his car?
Workshops, workspaces, and car trunks are places for hardware.
Setting expectations that the client is responsible for any parts
beforehand, and agreeing on a limit or submitting an estimate
beforehand will alleviate this issue. If you or the client don't
have an appropriate workspace and tools to work on equipment
then there is some risk that both should be willing to accept.
Things happen.
10: Evaluating the situation and the environment beforehand, as
well as managing expectations before hand could have avoided
the example. If you are doing the work within a business not
owned by the client, and there are rules, you either must obtain
an agreement to bypass them or not violate them. Additionally,
attempting to work in a hostile environment is foolish.
In summary, most of Mr. Dray's objections to free tech support
can be alleviated by good communications with the client and
properly setting expectations, before work is started.
In the 30 years that I have been doing support, these issues have
rarely if ever come up for me, and if they have they have been
mostly resolved fairly and equitably. If my chance that haven't
been, I have learned from the situation for next time, and avoid
doing work for that client in any form.
On the other hand, volunteer support has enabled me to
network and meet people I would have never had the chance to
otherwise, created lifelong friends, and given me the
opportunity to explore new opportunities, and technologies that
I might not have had the chance, or only at great personal
expense.
This is not to say that free tech support is appropriate for all
who ask or desire it. Rather each situation needs to be evaluated
on its own merits. However to paint the picture that free support
is wrong and only list its possible negatives provides a very
warped perspective of the topic. I believe a better approach
would be an article listing things to watch out for and how to
protect yourself when providing free tech support.
I also feel it would help Mr. Dray to change his paradigm to one
less cynical. There is and old saying that states that if you look
for trouble hard enough and long enough you will most certainly
find it.