Discussion Locked

Dreaming Electric Sheep

0 helpful
419 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

419 replies

by westr

That has to be the best angle yet, that I've seen about this.

 

Patent Squatting.  Couldn't have put it any better.  The current patent law system was indeed meant to product the little guy developing in his garage, not developed to have a company sit on like what? 20,000+ patents, and waiting for this one type of situation that occured, so their gold digging fantasies would come true.  Other then what has happened in court(NTP's pay day), their business is nothing else, and nothing more.  Patent law needs to be revised for abuse like this not to occur.

 

This is exactly like cyber squatting a website, waiting for a big pay day.  Purely abuse of the "Patent Law" system.  Law needs to be revised.  Patent squatting companies shouldn't exist, immoral & unethical, and should be illegal.  It would be best for NTP to donate $300 million to the red cross, $300 million to unicef, and $11,999,999 million to cancer/aids foundations, and keep keep $1 dollar for themselves.

 

 

by twilsonva

While I agree that patents are useful and needed to protect the little guy, what I would like to see is a law stipulating that a patent infringement suit must be filed within a certain amount of time (say 1 year or even 6 months) after the infringement has been documanted. (i.e.) the patent holder cannot wait for the infringing companys technology to become the standard before going after them, thus enabling the patent holder to ask for more money later. By doing so you may reduce the financial incentive for "patent-squatting".  There should also be a time limit shorter than 10 years in which the person or company must either do something with that patent or lose the rights to that patent.

twilson

 

by jasonhiner

Windows wonk Ed Bott has a really nice run-down on how much easier it should be to upgrade versions in Windows Vista. According to Ed ... Windows Vista Home Basic, Windows Vista Home Premium, and Windows Vista Ultimate will all be included on the same Windows Vista installation discs. To upgrade, home users will now be able to simply go to the Windows Anytime Upgrade applet in the Control Panel, purchase the upgrade (from a choice of retail and OEM vendors), download a new license, and then pop in the original media and upgrade the version of Vista. Ed's description also includes a couple nice screenshots.

This is one of those features that makes me think, "Wow, why didn't someone think of this before?" Of course, in Windows XP, the only upgrade would have been from Home to Pro. With multiple versions of both Home and Pro in Vista, this type of thing is much more important. And yet, I still wonder whether all of these home versions will get confusing the average home user. I'd also like to see the potential to upgrade from Vista Home Basic to Vista Business -- that could still be important for SOHO users and remote workers.

by slumley

I don't know how a patent squatter could be defined in law. To say patent squatters shouldn't exist is certainly to take the bull by the horns - perhaps too blunt a policy to have a hope of succeeding.

There may be another path. I understand the breakthrough in negotiations took place when RIM agreed to pay regardless of the Patent Office's ultimate decision on NTP patent validity. RIM tried to wait NTP out, but ran out of time. So we have at least one future scenario where NTP's patents are declared invalid, but they get to keep the money - the legitimacy of which rests solely on the legitimacy of the patents. This is truly wrong.

I hope that if and when the Patent Office rules NTP's patents invalid, RIM can be offered or find a way to break their agreement because it produced a patently unfair outcome! (Please excuse the intentional pun.) That exercise would address some of the underlying issues with patent law.

by barbara5

I've shopped at the Palo Alto CA Frys for years.  As others have said, you need to watch for  returns showing up in new shrinkwrap.  My problem, however, is that I'm a 60+ female and Fry's employees will NOT listen to me.  Case in point: Last week I went to buy an ethernet PCMCIA card for my laptop and a 4-port KVM switchbox.  Two different employees insisted I really wanted a wireless card, and another insisted on giving me the wrong cables for the switchbox.   I finally found the correct card and cables myself - after wasting time trying to convince them I know what I want.  I'm constantly hearing "Who's going to be installing this hardware?" and "Are you sure that's what your boss/husband wants?"  Hey folks, I've been the family and business hardware guru for over 15 years!  And I know a lot of other women who have the same complaint about Frys.  And, to be fair, about most other techno-stores. 

by jddouble

I seriously doubt Microsoft could outweigh Google in terms of relevance of results, and speed, also, Google has a hugely extensive range of other services, such as Google Scholar. My verdict is that, within the near future at least, Microsoft's search engine will not 'trump' Google.

by jogr66

I guess my question that remains after this article and left out for who knows why would be: Will this start.com also be reporting searches to the Feds like MSN, Yahoo and AOL? I'm a MS fan, but lost trust in their search engines when all that government reporting stuff surfaced. Google has served a lot of us on a level that no one has touched. I won't fix something thats not broken. Unless MS comes up with a huge difference, www.google.com will stay on that search bar.

by jb_personal

I am amused at this posting. I am from India and until recently, Indian patent law required that the patent holder must "work the patent" (i.e. must put the idea into practice) if
he wanted protection for it. The rationale for this was that if society
is to expend common resources to protect innovation from an individual
or organisation, then the innovation in turn must benefit society by
being available in a practical manner.

In the face of very stiff lobbying from various countries including the
United States, India reluctantly amended the patent laws to accord
protection even if the patent is not "worked". This
will obviously encourage squatters to sit on patents without working
them, purely relying on the protection that law provides to them.

by bowenw9

While I'm happy to see that RIM's business will not be interrupted I am not at all happy that they had to pay what amounts to extortion. I hold the most scorn, comtempt and lothing for NTP, but right behind those swine comes the Judge. I understand the notion of "seperation of powers", but with the re-exam of the NTP patents underway why couldn't the judge just suspend the proceedings until the PTO had finished the re-exam?

If this case does not show to any sane person how disfunctional our present Patent system is, nothing will. But right now our patent law is being driven mostly by forces outside this country, namely the WTO and the UN. The multinationals want the patent system "rigged" in their favor (which it presently is), and this rigging plays right into the hands of the "patent squatters".

As to RIM getting their extortion payment returned if the PTO does invalidate the patents: my understanding is that a contract made under duress is on its face null and void. What else could this situation be called if not duress? What really makes me sick is that that a Federal Judge played the role of bully for NTP. Wonder if a criminal complaint could be lodged against the principals (and the sleezy lawyers) of NTP for extrortion and maybe RICO? Name the Judge as well.

Any comments?

by apotheon

Just ditch patent law entirely. It was well-intentioned when conceived, but it has for the most part been an unmitigated disaster. Just scrap it already.

It's so crazy it just might work.

by clockmendergb9

I agree with most every comment.
It was plain that the Judge had no interest in regards to the justice of the case.othewise he would have put it on hold pending patent review.
Yes RIM did try to slow the case down but it seems they had very good reason,
At the very least I think the Judge owes the world an explaination as to why he was in such a hurry to end this case.
Especially as it has or will have a great impact on companies in the future.
As for NTP,I have no comment worthy of print.
Clockmendergb

by jasonhiner

This week's TechRepublic poll asks whether IT pros are working more hours, less hours, or about the same number of hours as they were five years ago (you can log your response to the poll at the bottom of the TechRepublic front page, if you haven't already responded).

In my experience, a lot of IT pros seem to be working longer hours because their departments have been squeezed over the last several years due to cost-cutting. That has meant less staff members to do the same workload, and in other places the IT department's workload has grown without increasing the staff.

As a companion to this week's poll, we've also started a discussion thread for TechRepublic members to discuss their workload increase or decrease over the past five years. So far, the majority have said they are working more. One of my favorite responses among the current posts came from amcol, who said "You can put a smile on your face or a dollar in your wallet, and it's tough to do both at the same time. I'll take the smile."

So are you working more or less than five years ago? Join the discussion.

by jim.guy_at_jda.com

Who's the little guy?  NTP was co-founded by the late Thomas Campana Jr., an engineer who in 1990 created a system to send e-mails between computers and wireless devices. He is survived by his wife, who owns a large stake in NTP.   NTP did not start out as a "patent squater", but a small engineering group trying to do something new.   He's the little guy who built and demonstrated a wireless email system in 1990.  Did the US Patent office err in granting his patents?  I don't know.  But I'm glad his wife and family now has something to show for years of struggling.

See Newsweek article at http://www.businessweek.com/technology/content/dec2005/tc20051208_033879.htm?campaign_id=msnbc_blackberry

by jasonhiner

Over the years, we've had a lot of fun in the TechRepublic forums talking about the blunders and silly things that end users do and say. Now, we're turning the tables a bit and asking IT pros to tell about the worst blunder they have ever made in their IT work. This can include everything from config errors that took down critical systems to purchasing the wrong stuff.

I'll say this ... almost all of the bad blunders that I've ever made have come when I've tried to attack a problem too quickly, rather than thinking through all of the steps and potential outcomes before embarking on any potential fix. This has resulted in BSODs on Windows boxes, stopping network daemons on UNIX servers in the middle of a business day, and crashing a critical Exchange mail server. Ahhhh the memories.

Join the discussion and tell us your worst blunder.

by mr. hardware

Ahhhhh, as you say rushing it is ALWAYS the problem. Here's mine; this desktop had a blown HDD, it was due to upg the MB any way. So, new MB, new HDD, fire it up, windows loads corretly, everything else is well. When it come time to copy the old files to the new spare HDD . . . Wa? Windows doent see it. Tried reboot, checking boot.ini, everything you could think of. The moral . . . CHECK TO SEE IF YOU PLUGED THE POWER BACK TO THE HARDDRIVE, it will save you a hour-and-a-half! ;-)

by blueknight

I agree with the majority of comments posted on this case.  RIM should have held out until the final determination of the patent held by NTP.  "Taking one for the little guy" or however RIM's CEO put it was a mistake in my opinion.  Hopefully RIM will be able to get their extorted settlement money returned should the patent be overturned as expected.

I think the judge in the case was out of line in urging a quick settlement.  That is not his function.  If he had done any "homework" at all, and was truely familiar with the facts of the case, he should have granted a continuance until the ultimate determination of the patent in question.  Had that happened, RIM could stand tall and NTP would suffer the humiliation of defeat.  RIM still looks good because of its actions, but the fact that they settled gives some validity to NTP and any other patent-squatters out there, and that is just plain wrong.

I like the "must use" aspect of patent law in India as mentioned in one comment.  That just might make things work properly, though I haven't had time to fully think it out to its logical conclusion.  I suppose that there should be some sort of time period for the party who purchases a patent from the inventor to either use the patent by creating the product, or to sell it to another party who will do so within a reasonable period of time -- or it would revert back to the inventor maybe.  There needs to be an "incentive" of some sort there.  Another idea I like is a statute of limitations for cases such as this.

If NTP's claim is ultimately denied, I think they should be forced to refund the settlement with interest (and maybe even a penalty) to RIM.

by wayne m.

Microsoft May Have the Better Business Model

My concern with the longevity of Google would be based upon their business model rather than their technology. Google's business model is based on world-wide advertising subsidized searches. I think there are key inroads in having desktop, department-wide, and enterprise-wide search capabilities, which will not be able to be advertising subsidized.

As disk and server sizes grow, organizations will no longer be able to rely on hierarchical structure to store and find data. I doubt many organizations will be open to exposing coroporate data to an external service and will want a service that is internally installed, configured, and maintained. Microsoft already has the sales, supply, and support channels in place to market intelligent search engines within corporations. Though many people will still view Google as their first choice for Internet searches, I do not see that generating enthusiasm to use Google within the enterprise.

In the long run, I would see Microsoft better positioned to expand from Enterprise-level searches to Internet-wide searches than Google to move from Internet-wide to Enterprise-level.

by bfilmfan

Sorry Jason, but you're wrong on this one. If you can make money selling your patent to another company that just holds it and does nothing with it, that's the same as me buying a piece of real estate and not building a hosue on it. If you want to come on the property and build a house, you will have to pay me.

Once you start invalidating the concept that people have rights to their intellectual property, it's the start down a slope to the loss of rights to all property. You aren't using your propery to make enough tax dollars for the city, I will just take it and build something else there that will make the city more money. Oh wait, the Supreme Court has already allowed that one to happen...

by jasonhiner

Today Microsoft released some new screenshots of the revamped UI for Microsoft Office 2007. I've put together an image gallery of the new screenshots and included some other recent Office 2007 images to provide a fuller look at what to expect. As mentioned before, this will be the most drastically redesigned interface in the history of the product. It has the potential to cause a lot of confusion among end users (and cause headaches for IT support), but it sure looks cool and power users will probably love the power and flexibility of the new UI.

Office 2007 ui

by amberhaze

As the former owner of a software development company based out of Edmonton, I had a couple of experiences directly related to Patent law.  `Based on these experiences I would make the following comments.

1) I agree totally, completely abolish the current system and go to something more along the lines of what was described above as having used to be the case in India before the negative western influences changed things.

2) Under the current system, the average person can not afford to patent anything since the costs involved are prohibitive.

3) Even if you do patent something, you again need deep pockets in order to protect that patent since legal fees involved in persuing a violator are usually prohibative unless you have a lot of money behind you.

Between regulation, red tape, and the barriers created by an ineffective patent regime, the days of the "garage tinkerer" are just about dead with very few exceptions. 

by jasonhiner

After absorbing heavy losses in 2002 and 2003, IT employment in the U.S. started picking back up in 2004 and the trend accelerated in the second half of 2005 to the point that the numbers finally exceeded the highs from 2001, according to the January 2006 report from the National Association of Computer Consultant Businesses (NACCB).

Mark Roberts, CEO of NACCB, said, "In light of the downward pressure on IT employment following Y2K, the bursting of the Tech Bubble, the 9/11 terrorist attacks and the 2001 recession, I am heartened by the 2005 employment figures evidencing strong employment growth in IT"

The NACCB recorded IT employment at 3,527,100 in 2001. By 2002 that number had sunk to 3,339,500 and it didn't get much better in 2003. As the chart below shows, IT emploment got rolling again in 2004 and then in 2005 finally rebounded to the 2001 levels. 

 

And the NACCB's February 2006 numbers show that IT employment grew again in January, which has the trendline for 2006 looking strong.

by jasonhiner

One of the most popular articles zipping around the Internet last week and being posted across various social networking sites was the FORTUNE Magazine piece "Cubicles: The great mistake," which recounts the infamous history of the cubicle from its creation by Bob Probst, a researcher, in 1968 to its current loathing by many modern knowledge workers.

The most interesting thing about the article is the story of Probst. In all reality, we probably shouldn't blame him for the cubicle, because he later repented for his corporate sins. If Probst didn't design the cubicle for the suits at the time, they would have found someone else to do it. What Probst quickly realized once his original design got shrunk down to size, was that companies were simply looking to squeeze as many workers as possible into a small space that could be easily reconfigured at any time (although cubicle layouts are rarely ever reconfigured). Any naive notions of employee productivity and a pleasing work environment were trumped by the bottom line that cubicles save companies a LOT of money. (And that's why they probably won't go away any time soon either.)  

Interestingly, Probst's original design, called the "Action Office," was pretty altruistic. It was meant to give workers more counter space to spread out their work and be able to look at it holistically. It was also aimed at having different levels of counters, including some where employees could occasionally stand up and work to promote better blood flow and overall physical health. However, the cubicle was eventually shrunk down to size and deployed in large numbers throughout Corporate America. Probst later lamented the rapid spread of the cubicle, referring to it as "monolithic insanity."

Nevertheless, its spread continues. There will be over $3 billion worth of cubicles sold this year, continuing the reign of cubes as the leader of the office furniture market.

So what's the good and bad of cubes? Here's my quick rundown:

The GOOD:

  • Cheap
  • Inexpensive
  • Low cost
  • Did I mention that they cost less than offices?
  • They promote collaboration and interaction among teams
  • Managers can monitor workers more easily

The BAD:

  • Confidentially issues can come into play for sensitive documents and phone calls
  • Productivity can suffer when workers distract each other
  • Workers sometimes feel more paranoid and self-conscious

What do you think about cubicles? Does your organization use them? Do you think technology is easier or more difficult to support in cubicles? 

By the way, I wrote this from a temporary cubicle that I occupy when I travel to the CNET Networks office in Louisville.

by justin fielding

Yuck!  We don't have cubicles here in the UK (or not within any company I have worked for in the past)--we tend to favor a more 'open plan' office.

by gsg

Cubicles can be a good alternative in some cases.  For example, we were very limited in the amount of office space we had, and so, took over 1 large room to house 4 of us on one tem in 4 cubes.  They never bought the cubes, and moved others in on us, so we had 9 people housed in a space meant for 4 people.  It was all open desks.  Needless to say, I got my giant 21" monitors (pre-flat panel) on the desks, and set up my testing workstations around me, until I had built a fort.  I then booby-trapped the entrance to my fort with "Franken-PC", a cobbled together PC without a case.  They were scared of Franken-PC and left me alone.

They are bad when they are used as an excuse to save money.  When I have to be on an hour-long call, it's impossible to hold a handset that long while typing and taking notes.  Headsets don't work that well either.  I'm very thankful for my little 8x10 office complete with ceiling and closed door.

by wayne m.

Worst of Both Worlds

In my experience, cubicals do not provide more flexibility than drywall configurations and do not provide the communications of more open environments.

Cubicals still require power, telephone, and network connections which add greatly to the cost of establishing them and the current versions with built-in desk and storage space thwart user efforts to modify the configurations.  Cubicals do not tend to be any less permanent than drywall and I wonder whether it is really less expensive to buy the components than to put up (metal) studs and a wall.  One caveat, real walls require building permits and may require bringing an entire suite of office space up to current standards.

In terms of collaboration, cubicals inhibit communications almost as much as complete offices.  The communication level, for better or worse, is far below what occurs in an open lab or bull pen environment.

 

by dc guy

It's spelled "cubicle," as in "tiny cube," which is exactly what it means, more literally with every passing year. "Cubical" is a shape, like cylindrical, and it's only valid as an adjective. There, now that we've got that straightened out...

If corporations were really serious about saving money on office space, the answer is obvious: telecommuting. I can't remember the last time I did something at the office that I couldn't have done just as well, or better, at home. I'd estimate that 90 percent of the U.S. workforce is in the same position, and more like 99.9 percent of the people who read TR.

The cost of the real estate for these huge office buildings, the infrastructure, the utilities, the cafeteria, the parking, the insurance, the security, look at the fortune they could save. Just keep a small place for the computer hardware and save a fortune. They could equip each of our home offices with a webcam, a workstation, a second computer for video, and a third for a virtual whiteboard, and at a fraction of the cost of a cubicle we'd be perfectly equipped for even the most important meetings.

Who'd complain? No two-hour commutes, no million-dollar mortgage so you can live close to the office, no urban sprawl, no gridlock, no three SUVs in every garage, no $500 monthly gasoline budget.

Of course the dinosaur managers would complain. Their walnut-sized brains can't handle the concept of learning how to supervise people they can't physically spy on. Managing results instead of attendance, what a revolutionary idea.

Yes, a few of you really need to "go to work" to get your jobs done right. I did say that only 99.9 percent of us could telecommute. Some people need to get their hands on the hardware. And if you're a psychotherapist or a diplomat, you need to be able to read facial expressions and body language more accurately than you can do on video.

The rest of us can work at home in a cubicle-free environment.

And don't tell me that your subordinates would goof off. If you're a good manager you'll know. And don't tell me you'll goof off. How much time do you spend goofing off already?

by narg

It's all a matter of tastes...

Some prefer, even require privacy.  Other's don't, desiring open spaces in order to let ideas and interaction flow with others.  It's all just a matter of space, and not much else.  Whether your area is abundant in space, or highly limited is the real issue.  If you like walls, then a cubicle is not that bad of a proposition, as long as there is space enough there to allow for freedom of movement and area enough to expand on work if needed.  Same goes for open offices, if the desk area still rammed up together, then the workers will still have the same feeling of not enough space to get the job done and done well.

by it cowgirl

Yes we have cubicle land at every office in North America.

OK, I have no cubicle manners. My Team Lead and the rest of my team are "behind" my cubicle, therefore I am not facing them. So I just hollar over all the cubes to them when I am asking a quick question...or five.Or for running jokes and witty comments. I cannot hear well on the phone so it is turned up loud (on speaker) and I guess I speak really loud to the phone callers because of my hearing loss.

So it makes it difficult for everyone around me to work. But you would think that a team could be "housed" together better.

by apapaleo9

"Cubicals" may be perfectly OK. "Cubicles" as far as I can tell everywhere I have been or to colleagues here in the U.S. are a terrible blight upon the working landscape.

by jasonhiner

DC Guy and apapaleo:

You're absolutely right. It should be "cubicle" and not "cubical." How embarassing. The worst part is that I used "cubicle" throughout most of the post but threw out "cubical" a couple times at the end and of course used that mis-spelling in the title. It's fixed now.

Thanks, Jason

by computer geek

I've worked for a company where the cube was actually fairly nice.  Plenty of space, storage and room.  It was about 7x7.  I've since switched jobs and now have a confining 4x4, with little storage, countertop space and no privacy.  I can hear everyone else's conversations as well.  But what are you going to do?  The cubicle is here to stay since corporate America (and perhaps other countries) value the dollar more than people.  Anyone who wishes to challenge that I ask them when the last time at a Board of Director's meeting the shareholders asked the CEO/CIO "But are the workers happy?".

by jasonhiner

Computer Geek -- You're certainly right about the "Are the workers happy?" question. It doesn't get asked enough. I've worked in environments where moral was abysmal and in environments where everyone was pretty happy and excited, and there's no doubt that there was a lot more work getting done (and better work) in the latter.

This is one area where I think cost is calculated much too hastily. That doesn't mean that every office should get rid of cubes and go to offices or an open concept, but a lot more thinking should go into work environment beyond just the issue of building costs, because the environment has a major impact on productivity.

Jason

by jasonhiner

If you ask Microsoft executives why consumers or companies should upgrade to Windows Vista, the answer they've recently been talking about is "security." The head honcho of Windows, Jim Allchin, said, "Safety and security is the overriding feature that most people will want to have Windows Vista for."

Of course, the public perception of Windows security is still not very great among most IT pros and end users. But if we put that perception aside and take a look at Windows Vista, there are some impressive developments on the security front. In the testing that I've been doing with Vista over the past six months, it has become abundantly clear that Windows security has been re-engineered in Vista and several important security features have been added.

The two most prominent security additions are Network Access Protection (NAP) and User Account Protection (UAP). NAP will keep systems and devices with inferior security configurations from joining the network (and potentially infecting healthy machines) until they meet minimum security requirements. Until that time the machines are quarantined into a restricted VLAN.

UAP (which was originally called LUA - least-privileged user account) will finally allow administrators to stop giving end users local admin privileges on their PCs. With UAP, admins can grant privileges on a more granular level and so most activities can be performed with minimal privileges, thus limiting the access that rogue malware can perform in most cases.

In general, Vista is a lot more inflexible about letting programs launch in the background, perform covert system changes, and interact with system-changing operations. That provides a lot proactive protection against spyware, malware, adware, viruses, worms, and the like. Naturally, there's a trade-off in usability. For example, when launching many of the applets from the Control Panel users will now get the following message each time:

Vista dialog box

The user has to hit "Allow" in order to open this tool. When end users see messages like this (and they will likely end up seeing a lot of them), then they will probably ask their IT departments why they keep getting these messages. The IT department will respond that this is an important part of the increased security in Windows Vista. I think a lot of users will then ask, "Do I need this much security?"  

The answer is that they certainly do need this much security in order to pre-empt other potential security issues. Nevertheless, this much security comes with a price in usability. In fact, any time you increase security it almost always comes with a price in usability.

While most IT professionals will gladly welcome these major security improvements in Vista, they will also need to adequately prepare their staff and their end users for some necessary drawbacks in usability.

by apotheon

The problem is that you're not getting as much added security with Vista as Microsoft would have you think. Microsoft is addressing security issues in Windows the same way it always has: it adds security "features" rather than addressing an unsecured architecture. It's like slapping a bandaid on a plague sore. Sure, it covers up the sore, but it doesn't address the disease that caused it.

UAP is a prime example of the problem. Sure, more granular control over privileges helps a little. It doesn't help enough, though. What really needs to happen is not allowing a piecemeal approach to granting administrative privileges under specialized circumstances while denying them elsewhere — instead, Windows needs to truly learn from the unix example, and separate user functionality from administrative access entirely, so that the only tasks that require any kind of increased privileges at all are the tasks that only administrative users should be performing.

No user application should ever, under any circumstances, require the administrative user account to perform day to day tasks. Period. It's a lesson the Windows guys still haven't learned.

by narg

And I was concerned I was the only one who thought this was annoying.  I'd like to see an option during installation of whether to give the user little access or everything.  Haven't seen that yet, but doubt I will.

by sheng.long9

Read the top of that window, then rework it to get the truth...

[You need Windows' permission to use this program]

Windows XP Service Pack 2 had a similar, but lot less snazzy, window pop-up whenever you accessed the Internet with anything, except if it was Microsoft's own software.
This is even worse...
It's Windows saying "I'm sorry, but I'm so secure that I can't even let you check my desktop settings without warning you of a non-existent threat that my own software could be to me."

Probably, by RC1, Any time Microsoft certified applications are run, Vista will allow automatically if they have the correct CRC and source. Anything else will be warned, whether it be a new browser or that MMORPG that everyone is using...
Vista will need you to click that box so often you'll probably cancel it at just the wrong moment, and suddenly you've locked out a third-party application you didn't mean to...

by pompchas1

Insert comment text here
Why Upgrade to Windowa Vista. if your carefull with outside intrusion
as "email" have a respecetable firewall and untilities that can test
the worth of your hardware already and defend against outside interference. Why
not make vista an upgrade instead of a replacement for Window?? Is this
another way to create a market that is already sold on XP?

by forbes

When are they going to address the real issue that most of the various industries have developers that don't have time, nor do they want to devote the R & D money to implementing all of the new install pieces, and security rules to allow all of this stuff to be implemented.  With the public school I help support and with several of our vendors they don't have the developement staff nor do they want to increase it enough to make this a high priority.  The average management answer is enable the best security possible as long as all the applications needed to do day to day business works. We always fight with this.  Most shops don't have the resources to create special security for the various things so the go for the lowest common security setting that makes all the applications work and go for it. Usually the more you try to do custom security settings the more reliability issues you get into.  Making the OS more secure is a start, but it is a long way from getting the solution standard across the board.

by jasonhiner

How many of you have a color laser printer at work or a color inkjet at home, but rarely ever print anything in color? Yeah, me too. But last weekend I found a great use for a color printer when I discovered this optical illusion dragon. Check out this video clip to see what the illusion looks like, and then download a PDF dragon of your own to print and try out the illusion. Don't forget to close one eye and move slowly back and forth at first. Once you catch the illusion, you can move a little faster and try different angles. You'll look like a dork while you doing this, but I'm willing to bet that you'll be amazed at the coolness of this optical illusion. Have fun.

by jasonhiner

You're right! I never really thought about that, but the cut-out dragon is in blue and not green like the example. You could probably fiddle with the printer prefs if you wanted to print it in green, but that didn't really matter to me. I'm simply amazed by the illusion.

by diamond dan

This also works equally well with a black and white laser printer. The effect is an awesome one!

by moushie_23

I love the blue dragon!!! All my users were amazed at my illusionary dragon!

Thanks! It was much more fun than an hour of work

Heather

by darren

Awsome.....

This is brilliant....  Im now an hour behind repairing a computer but its still awesome :-)

Daz

by narg

People like cnassif who posted earlier crack me up.  Just because his karma can't handle Windows, he likens it to similarities on Ford vs. Chevy.  If you can't handle the OS, don't use it.  And don't complain abou it either.  I support many Windows machines _and_ many Apple machines.  Both are good.  Both are bad.  Both suffer tremendously from bad users, no matter what the issues and problems are.  Both abound with good when used properly and knowledably.  The latter of which is rare.

by jasonhiner

This past Monday, March 13, Microsoft's Greg Randall made a general post in The Official Microsoft Connections Blog about Windows Vista and its new features. In that post, Randall reiterated the party line that Vista would be released in the "second half of this year." However, the next day another member of the Microsoft Connections Blog posted "This is the year - the year that Microsoft releases the newest version of Windows. Yes, Vista will be released in November of this year."

That was a bit of a surprise. Nearly everyone expected that Vista would be released before the holidays. However, rumors and estimates have varied wildly from late summer to October for the official launch. With the product apparently progessing well based on the beta releases that I've seen, I'm a little surprised that Microsoft is waiting until November. Nevertheless, there you have it.

by jasonhiner

There was a very interesting opinion piece from Otto Stern in The Register last fall called "CEOs should follow NBA and make geeks wear real clothes" (referring to the new dress code in the National Basketball Association that was put in place at the time). The subtitle to Otto's piece was "Put your pants on, coders! Grow up!" That sums up the general tone and thesis of the article.

Otto also says, "For too many years, geeks have been abusing their roots as antisocial miscreants who could do things normal people couldn't do. Companies needed computer work done and would tolerate these freaks roaming around data centers. Do not poke the geek because he may ruin you if make him angry. Today, guys like Sun Microsystems CEO Scott McNealy and that loser Tim O'Reilly still embrace this mentality. They're businessmen of the highest caliber and run around in jeans and sweaters. This makes people way down on the totem pole think that sandals, torn jeans and KISS T-shirts will suffice as proper work attire."

Predictably, Otto's diatribe drew a lot of responses from IT professionals, and he printed many of them in a follow-up article 10 days later. One reader talked about an IT colleague who reflected poorly on himself and the company by wearing cargo pants and food-stained shirts to meetings with customers. Other readers ripped Otto as being over-the-top and way too straight-laced.

I think Otto made some important points, but the guy did go off the deep end a bit. In my last job, I worked at a health care practice in which I regularly met with business partners and was seen by customers (patients) in the hallways of the office. As a result, I was required to wear a shirt and tie every day. At that job I quickly realized that people take you a lot seriously when you are dressed in business attire. I work in a much more casual atmosphere now and so I haven't worn a tie in several years. But old habits die hard and so I still tend to wear khakis and collared shirts (business casual attire). I just think that if you want others to take you seriously then you have to take yourself seriously.

That being said, I don't think it's necessary for everyone in IT to wear business casual attire. For techies like software developers, who sit in their cubicles for most of the day, and held desk techs, who spend a lot of their time on the phone, there certainly isn't any benefit to the business to have them dress in business casual attire. And, in fact, a strict dress code could turn away some talented IT pros who don't want to work at a place where they have to spend money to buy extra clothes. However, for IT pros that interface with customers, for managers, and for consultants, I would highly recommend adopting business casual attire.

A new TechRepublic poll (which will run March 20-26) asks whether IT pros need to dress better and there's a companion discussion thread on this topic as well. Jump in the discussion and add your opinion.

by p_piluk

It depends on what your function is. If you are meeting clients then you must look respectable. If you are hidden all day writing code than you can be more casual. However, it is never acceptable to wear dirty, food stained clothes...Have some respect for yourself, if not for your colleagues.

by it cowgirl

I do not see much value in dressing in nice clothes, suit, or a skirt to crawl under the desk, carry and move dirty equipment, trace and run cables under the floor in the data center or a client's ceiling location, crawling around moving cabling from one 13 blade switch to a new 13 blade switch, or squat down to check power source connections on Network racks. Therefore, the type of job also dictates that it makes more sense to wear jeans and a casual shirt. I have specific work only clothes that get more beat up than any "play" clothes I wear. I have jeans and t-shirts over 15 years old not dirty or worn out. But my work clothes begin to wear and are stained from work and quick "shove food in your mouth 5 minute" lunch within two weeks. I need to replace thwm withing 3-6 months because I have worn holes and have rips from the work.  I would not mind if work paid a clothes allowance for replacing the business attire they make us wear to perform these jobs.

by alvarito_uy

Hi there! Ithink it's not necesary at all to wear ties, white skirts and all that stuff all the time; eventhough, by no means misalignment, dirt o ragged clothes should be acceptable too. If we all wear slightly casual, with clean and simple clothes, we will reflect simple, clean minds; sometimes, excessive clothing, expensive ties, and that kind of things (taken to extremes, of course) tend to show not-so-simple not-so-clear minds (if you need to 'produce' that much your clothing, you surely need to 'produce' that much your mind too: something to hide?);  At least, it's better to show us as normal people, take the other's one perspective and do what we know as good as we know it has to be done.... and that doesn't rely on clothes, but on your knowledge, intelligence and kindnes: dress just enough to show respect, and look as respetable as trustfull.And, if the meeting wooth it.. don't forget your (simple) tie.

Cheers, Alvin.

by alvarito_uy

Hi there! Ithink it's not necesary at all to wear ties, white skirts and all that stuff all the time; eventhough, by no means misalignment, dirt o ragged clothes should be acceptable too. If we all wear slightly casual, with clean and simple clothes, we will reflect simple, clean minds; sometimes, excessive clothing, expensive ties, and that kind of things (taken to extremes, of course) tend to show not-so-simple not-so-clear minds (if you need to 'produce' that much your clothing, you surely need to 'produce' that much your mind too: something to hide?);  At least, it's better to show us as normal people, take the other's one perspective and do what we know as good as we know it has to be done.... and that doesn't rely on clothes, but on your knowledge, intelligence and kindnes: dress just enough to show respect, and look as respetable as trustfull.And, if the meeting wooth it.. don't forget your (simple) tie.

Cheers, Alvin.

by wayne m.

I disagree with the asseretion that software developers and help desk techs do not need to interact with users.  This is what leads to the poor reputation and results provided by these groups.

User interaction is simply the most efficient and effective way for the software developer to gain understanding of the needs of the software to be built.  Software developers need to be prepared to meet with users at any time and not have to be hidden away behind closed doors.  It is this avoidance of direct communications that leads to major flaws in software and cries of arrogance by users.

Help desk staff have been put in a similar position by "centralization."  Rather than having the go-to guy sitting a few offices away, we have disembodied voices that can only be dragged out of the catacombs through continued pleading.  Is it any wonder that most users end up doing their own maintenance work and ignore the "advice" coming from faceless e-mails?

Software developers and help desk staff need high levels of user interaction to be effective and respected.  To do so, they must also dress the part.

by dc guy

Fashion is temporal, that's why we call it that. Intelligent, goal-oriented people should not be distracted by it. Office attire should not be dirty (you can rinse those lunch stains out pretty well in the bathroom while they're fresh), offensive (would you wear that t-shirt with the quotation from Eminem to meet your new boy/girlfriend's grandma), prurient (please let me just imagine what your anatomy looks like), or disrespectful (is this job interfering with your surfing lessons). Other than that, be comfortable and don't deliberately try to distract us with your clothes.

If your job involves face-to-face selling, other customer contact, or trying to influence people, well then you just have to play psychology, don't you? If you can convince them that your product is better because you wear a nicer suit, then wear the frelling suit and have a laugh over what an easy mark they are. If your boss will give you a promotion because you wear fewer earrings than anybody else who applied, just consider that one of life's really bizarre little tests and congratulate yourself for being clever and adaptable enough to pass it.

by jasonhiner

Wayne M -- You make some great points about software developers and help desk pros interacting with users, and I'm glad you brought this up. In the discussion thread on the site, JAMES.MACAULAY posted that end users are the customers for tech support. I think that's a great way to think about it for IT departments to truly view themselves like a service organization (rather than playing God, protecting their territory, or just trying to justify their existence -- those are the kinds of things that bad IT departments do). In that sense, it is certainly logical that just about everyone in IT should think about professionalism when it comes to how they dress.

Jason

by jasonhiner

DC Guy -- So are you arguing both sides? Or are you just agreeing with me? I think it might be the latter. I will say this: fashion is definitely temporal, but business attire -- button-up shirt, jacket, tie (sometimes), and slacks -- have remained the business standard for quite a long time and I don't see it changing anytime soon. The cut of the clothes and the colors will vary a bit over time, but I think one of the reasons that business attire has become a bit of a de facto uniform for conducting business is so that psychologically we know who is playing in the same game. Once we have that down, then we are free to ignore the particulars and pay attention to the stuff that really matters -- the work.

Jason

by jasonhiner

My colleague George Ou recently wrote that the U.S. banking system needs to abandon its Shared Public Key system (PIN numbers known by both the bank and its members) and adopt a Public Key Cryptography (PKC) system in its place. By using smart cards with PKC's combination of Public and Private Keys, George argues that banks could make security much stronger and easier to administer in case of theft (a bank could simply revoke the certificate on a stolen smart card to render it useless).

As George points out, Europe is quickly moving to smart cards (and Asia is on the way too). Is it time for the U.S. to follow? I think it will probably take strong demand from consumers or a crisis to light a fire under the banking industry. Maybe the recent theft of PIN numbers will be the catalyst, but I think it will still take an outcry from consumers. So if you want smart cards sooner than later, let your bank's customer service department know about it.

By the way, in his article George also mentions the possibility that smart cards could potentially become an all-in-one card with your ATM, credit card, and other access data all centralized in one uber-smart card. While I am fascinated by the ease of use that would create, I also must admit that I am scared to death of having all my private data and financial access info centralized, unless there was a strong biometric authentication component tied in as well. And even then, the paranoid side of me would have its hackles up. Am I too skeptical?

Read George's blog post and join the TechRepublic discussion on this issue.

by georgeou

I?m not suggesting that private data be put on to this card.  It just acts as a universal cryptographic token that allows access to multiple applications.  It is extremely strong authentication technology (the best) and it?s extremely manageable.  You wouldn?t put any secret information on here unless it was encrypted for your particular hospital or choice of hospitals and health organizations.

by jasonhiner

OK, I'm all for smart cards as a "universal cryptographic token." In fact, that's long overdue. I'm going to request a move to smart cards from the banks that I do business with. Actually, one of my cards (American Express Blue) already has a smart card chip built in, but it doesn't really do much yet.

by wayne m.

It was my understanding that the purpose of the PIN was to handle the case of a stolen card.  The problem arose, however, when the card no longer needed to be physically presented.  I see this would be true of smart cards as well.

As I rely on PIN number-free credit cards for most of my purchases, I guess I never really saw the value of the PIN number on debit cards.  I guess it mainly arose due to the transfer of risk from the card issuer (for credit cards) to the card holder (for debit cards).

I am not sure that the added expense of a smart card really provides benefit.  In fact, the "super card" proposed by Mr. Ou, would seem to open the door for electronically stealing information and probably provide a greater risk than he attempts to resolve.

by georgeou

The PIN on the ATM is not entered in to the ATM card itself, it?s given to the retailer who are often careless with it.  ATM cards can be replicated secretly either by any sloppy retailer or malicious fake ATM machine.  Smartcards cannot easily be replicated and the pin-on-pad is only done to activate the smartcard and never given to the retailer.

by georgeou

?I am not sure that the added expense of a smart card really provides benefit.  In fact, the "super card" proposed by Mr. Ou, would seem to open the door for electronically stealing information and probably provide a greater risk than he attempts to resolve.?

And here, I?m sorry to say that you?re just being plain ignorant of what a smartcard is or what I?m talking about.

by dasec

I fully support George Ou. Having used Public Key Technology since 1997 and Smart Cards since about 1998, it is the solution of the future for ATM's. The Bank that I am semi-retired from is migrating its ATM's from OS2 to Windows XP. With our own PKI and software to use public key certificates, we are perfectly positioned to roll out smart cards to our customers.  

by jasonhiner

Dasec -- Do you mind saying whether the bank you're talking about is based in the U.S.? If so, then I know whether to start getting my hopes up about whether smart cards are truly moving toward a reality on this side of the pond. :-)

Jason

by imcleod

The U.S currently have no mandate to migrate to smart cards (which Europe has). Most of the rest of the world is also committed. Those smart cards that are embedded in your U.S. issued card is nothing more than an empty marketing guesture.

An interesting aspect is Canada and Latin America are currently migrating to smart cards. This bring an interesting scenario to the U.S - fraud migration. For example, smart cards have reduced fraud in the UK by a massive percentage . It has been shown that upon adopting of this technology, criminals migrate across borders into coutnries that have not yet adopted smart cards. I expected this as the main reason that the U.S will eventally migrate. 

Smart cards have the benefit of storing multiple applications, such as a credit, debit, loyality points, etc

I like the idea of having a pin pad on the card but it will be expensive to implement and currently the technology may be too ackward for the end user & physical plastic.

by jasonhiner

imcleod -- That's very interesting (both encouraging and disturbing) that some criminals are migrating away from countries that have adopted smart cards. As you said, this will hopefully motivate U.S. banks to make the move to smart cards. I still think U.S. consumers should turn up the pressure on their banks. That can only help.

Jason

by jasonhiner

Photo Gallery of Dell Latitude X1

Latitude x1

The Job

I use laptops every day for both business and personal computing (usually separate laptops) and I regularly test various notebooks and mobile devices for TechRepublic to assess their business usefulness. The general requirements that I look for are speed (in its various forms), portability, and ease of use.

I have recently been testing the Dell Latitude X1 as a machine that a business user or knowledge worker would typically use for everyday tasks. I assumed use of Windows XP, Microsoft Office applications, a Web browser, business e-mail, and a line-of-business application or two. I also assumed occasional use of wireless networking.

The Tool

Introduced during the first half of 2005, the Latitude X1 is quite different from most of the other Dell laptops that you see running around ? both the consumer-oriented Inspiron line and the other products in the business-class Latitude line. That's because the little secret about the X1 is that it wasn't originally engineered by Dell. It is based on the Samsung Q30. Dell partnered with Samsung to offer a U.S.version of this sleek laptop at a very competitive price. As you can see in the picture below, the Latitude X1 has lot more style than most Dell laptops:

The Latitude X1 that I have been using has the following specs:

  • 2.5 lbs and 1 inch thick
  • 1.1 GHz Intel Pentium M (Centrino)
  • 512 MB of DDR2 SDRAM
  • 12.1 inch WXGA wide aspect display (1280x768 resolution)
  • Integrated video based on the Intel 915GM/GMS, 910GML Express Chipset (up to 128 MB of shared memory for video)
  • 60 GB Toshiba hard drive
  • Integrated Broadcom Xtreme 57xx Gigabit Ethernet port
  • Integrated Intel PRO Wireless 2200 B/G adapter
  • Integrated Conexant Modem
  • External CD-RW/DVD combo drive with D/Bay connector
  • 2 USB 2.0 ports (one intended for Dell D/Bay)
  • 1 Firewire/IEEE 1394 port
  • 1 Secure Digital (SD) memory card slot
  • 1 CompactFlash (CF) card slot
  • Integrated Dell Wireless 350 Bluetooth Module

The Right Tool for the Right Job?

I quickly took a liking to the X1. It is very intuitively designed and extremely usable for business tasks. There are no nagging features or components that are inconveniently or illogically placed, so it is really good at staying out of your way and letting you get your work done. It is highly portable but still powerful enough to quickly handle Web browsing, mail, and Microsoft Office. In fact, it was a lot faster than I expected for a 1.1 GHz notebook. I even did a little bit of work with photos and video files and didn't have any complaints about performance. This is clearly a well-engineered machine.

Naturally, it's not perfect. Its portability doesn't sacrifice much in power, but it does sacrifice battery life. This is not a laptop that you can use on battery all day. The standard battery will only give you about 3 hours of life. The optional extended battery doubles that to 6 hours. Also, when you go to battery power the vibrant display goes very dim. Another thing I didn't like was the touch pad. I'm not a big fan of touch pads anyway, but the one on the X1 is not very responsive. You have to really apply pressure to make it move. And there is no finger joystick mouse as an alternative. All in all, that didn't bother me too much because I typically use a wireless notebook mouse when I'm working on a laptop, but it may be important to some users. Nevertheless, for most business users and knowledge workers, I would highly recommend the Latitude X1. At a price tag between about $1300 and $2200 (depending on the current Dell discount), it is an outstanding bargain for a powerful and highly portable laptop, and is extremely competitive with other ultra-portable notebooks in its class.

There's one other thing about the X1 ? it has a lot more "Wow!" appeal than the average Dell laptop. While using the X1, I have had at least five or six people go, "Ooooohhh, what laptop is that?" I've never had the reaction to a Dell before. A couple more people approached me to ask the price of the X1 because they were in the market for a new laptop. They naturally asked whether I would recommend it, and after asking what they were looking for, in both cases I did end up recommending the X1.  

Here's my list of kudos and caveats to help you figure out if the X1 could make sense for you or your users:

Kudos

  • Extremely portable
  • Plenty of power for business tasks
  • Well-designed for usability
  • Solid graphics and display
  • Integrated Intel Wireless adapter with a strong antenna
  • Integrated Gigabit Ethernet
  • Integrated SD and CF card slots
  • Plenty of "Wow!" factor

Caveats

  • Short battery life
  • Unimpressive touch pad
  • No PC Card slot
  • Mediocre speaker quality
  • RAM is only expandable to 768 MB
  • External disc drive
  • Only two USB ports

Don't miss our photo gallery of the Dell Latitude X1.


Write your own review

If you've found the perfect tool for the job, we want to hear about it. Send us an e-mail describing the product and the job you're using it for. If we feature the product in The Right Tool for the Job? blog, you'll earn a little cash and be featured across the TechRepublic Web site and in our newsletters.

 

by stevef199

However , the Dell Precision laptop is the most powerful laptop. I typically use my laptop for demonstrations of development and GIS work, and typically have ArcGIS, SQL Server and Visual Studio.NET installed. Given the screen resolution, processing power, memory requirements and hard disk thoroughput (in that order) needed by my applications, the Dell Precision is the only laptop I can ever recommend for the power power-user.

by jasonhiner

stevef199 -- I haven't had any experiences with the Dell Precision notebooks, but I just looked up the Dell Precision M70 Mobile Workstation on Dell's site and it looks as powerful as you mentioned. Maybe that will be the next laptop that I review, with the power user in mind (CAD, engineering, advanced photo and video editing, etc.). Of course, I still stand by the X1 is a terrific solution for the average business user. Thanks again for the recommendation and look for some future coverage of the Precision.

Jason

by jasonhiner

On Friday, I posted that Windows Vista was unofficially set to ship in November. I was right. What I didn't realize was that businesses were the only ones that would be getting it in Q4.

At 5:30 PM EST this afternoon (March 21), Microsoft Windows chief Jim Allchin dropped a bomshell in a conference call with the press. He announced that Microsoft would release a wider public beta of Vista in Q2 (no surprise there), would release Vista to businesses with volume licensing contracts in November (yeah, okay), and would then release Vista to consumers in January 2007 (uh oh!).

To address the Vista delay, Allchin explained, "Product quality and a great out-of-box experience have been two of our key drivers for Windows Vista, and we are on track to deliver on both. But the industry requires greater lead time to deliver Windows Vista on new PCs during holiday. We must optimize for the industry, so we?ve decided to separate business and consumer availability."

I'm generally a Jim Allchin fan, but that statement rubbed me the wrong way. So all of the sudden Microsoft wants us to believe that "Oops, it takes a little longer for PC makers to prepare for a new OS than we realized." Give me a break. Microsoft has been delivering Windows operating systems for two decades. They know exactly how long it takes for computer manufacturers to prep a new OS. The truth is that Microsoft simply isn't going to have Vista ready to release by the deadlines that they needed to hit. So just come out and say it and save the PR department the valuable time they wasted on that lame spin.

I can handle the truth -- especially in this case because the truth is that Allchin is deadly serious about getting Vista right and not releasing it prematurely. Last year I heard live from Allchin's own lips that he unequivocally would NOT release Vista until it is ready (and have no doubt that Allchin is the one who makes the final call on that). The thing to realize is that Jim Allchin is retiring after Vista is released. This is his last hurrah and the final piece of his legacy in the software business. So, in that sense, he is a little more beholden to his customers than he is to his boss. No one wants Windows to overcome its reputation of being buggy and insecure more than Allchin and he knows that Vista offers a narrow window of opportunity for changing those perceptions.

"We could have just gone ahead [and released Vista this fall], but I didn't think it was the right thing to do," said Allchin, "We're setting stringent quality bars on what we do." 

He also added, "Product quality is the first priority. We won't compromise on that."

That's all he needed to say. Product quality comes before those juicy profits available in the fourth quarter. That's it.

OEMs and the partners in the Windows ecosystem will groan about it (their plans for a big fourth quarter just went down the drain), but I think IT pros and general users can forgive the delay if it means getting a truly finished product rather than a release candidate that users essentially pay to test for Microsoft.

I just don't want Microsoft blowing smoke at me about how "the industry requires greater lead time to deliver Windows Vista on new PCs during holiday." They've always known that, so to use it as an excuse for this delay is completely disingenuous.

by daheimbo

I perfectly agree with Jason- Microsoft should not, in the first instance say what they do not mean-their planning a bit up -the-spout!

Secondly, Bill Gates and company, to-date have never produced a fool-proof operating System- they are hoping to do so with Vista, I presume! If they do - it will be a miracle!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I guess they are looking at the profit from businesses- however, I suppose it is better to wait for something, that wll (we Hope!!) be a little more fine-tuned, than to get something that has not been- half-based. I personally, would be more surprised than ever, if Vista proves a little more fool-proof than OSs produced so far, including Xp!!

by tisha

Pfft...
Fool-proof operating System indeed!
Sure why not, let them live in the their own delusions.
Yet another way to feather MR. Gates nest and find a loop hole to stop support for windows XP.
What a joke!
Microsoft making life easier, "NOT"!

by jasonhiner

Hey, if you want a fool-proof operating system, go check out ... oh wait, there isn't one. :-)

Jason

by jasonhiner

As I wrote last month, I have become a Skype fan since I started experimenting with the popular VoIP app in January and I now regularly use it for some business calls and one-on-one video calls. The video quality is remarkable (and I've tested a lot of video conferencing software and hardware) and the sound quality is solid as well -- although it occasionally has some hiccups and it works best when the person on the other end has a headset. The Skype audio quality also sounds best on Skype-to-Skype calls. The SkypeIn and SkypeOut quality is where I have mostly run into robotic-sounding calls and general fluctuations in audio quality.

However, there is also one other thing that keeps me from using Skype more often -- dialing extensions and joining conference calls rarely ever work. The problem is that Skype does not properly emulate the DTMF tones of touch tone phones. When you dial a number on Skype you can switch over to Skype's dialpad and enter an extension number or a conference code. No problem there. But, in my experience, the systems on the other end rarely ever take the extension or conference code. Some say the Skype tones are too short and are not recognized, while others claim that Skype's tones produce echos that confuse touch tone systems. Skype employees claim that the problem is with SkypeOut termination providers. The bottom line is that at least 8 or 9 times out of 10, it doesn't work. As a result, I rarely even try anymore.

If Skype wants to get serious about serving business customers, then it needs to fix this problem ASAP. And make no mistake, businesses are important to Skype, which just opened its skype.biz site earlier this month after realizing that about one third of its users were business users. I've got a separate blog post coming up about Skype's business strategy. For now, Skype just needs to get this resolved if it wants to be a business-friendly service.

by jasonhiner

This doesn't come as a surprise since Windows Vista and Office 2007 have been expected to debut together, but Microsoft officially announced yesterday that the retail (and OEM) version of Microsoft Office 2007 will be delayed until January 2007 in order to sync up with the release of Windows Vista (on Tuesday Microsoft revealed that Vista would be pushed back to 2007). 

Yesterday Microsoft also announced some changes to the Windows team. The big move is that Steve Sinofsky (the captain of the Microsoft Office team, which has a much better track record for hitting product deadlines than the Windows team) will move over to the Windows group  and take over the team and future versions of Windows after Jim Allchin retires at the end of this year, upon delivering Vista.

Lots of people are piling on Microsoft for the delay of Vista, and rightfully so in some cases. However, I was a little shocked by the blatant giddiness demonstrated by Novell Marketing VP John Dragoon in a presentation in Salt Lake City in which he was demonstrating some features of Suse Linux 10. Dragoon, in an attempt to be witty, remarked, "Why, I feel bad for [Microsoft]... I don't know if you guys knew that [Vista] was originally expected to be ready by end of 2004. The last time I checked, it is 2006."

Dragoon's remarks might have even been funny if it weren't for the fact that Novell has made virtually no progress or innovations to improve Suse to the point that it can legitimately compete with Windows as a business desktop. I'm sure he's thrilled with the delay of Vista from 2004 to 2007 because it means his product is only about five years behind Vista, instead of eight. Of course, the bad news for Dragoon and Novell is that Red Hat hasn't announced any delays this week and so Suse is still a couple years behind the Linux market leader on the desktop. They should set their sights there first. Vista is still way out of their league.

by dhays

Insert comment text here "They should set their sites there first. Vista is still way out of their league. " sites is sights in this case.

by jasonhiner

dhays -- Thanks, I made the change. Spellchecker doesn't catch those kinds of mistakes. ;-)

Jason

by jasonhiner

We've just published a new gallery of Windows BSOD messages.
Looking at some of these screens brings back some painful memories for
me from across the years. One of them was a BSOD that popped up on an
Exchange server at my last job during my final week there. What a
nightmare. I ended up putting in long hours that week and had to do
some restores from backups. The mail system was down for a couple long
stretches that week. If I remember correctly, in the end it turned out
to be a conflict with the backup drive. Fun stuff.

Interestingly, I think I only ever experienced one or two BSODs with
Windows 2000 Professional (when I managed a network of those machines).
However, I've run into a lot more BSODs with Windows XP Pro, mostly
dealing with hardware conflicts and incompatibilities. Has anyone else
had the same experience? I've always assumed that those problems have
had to do with XP merging the code base of Windows NT and Windows 9x. I
assume 9x introduced some problems into the NT code base, which was
pretty solid prior to XP. Would you agree?

Take a look at the BSOD gallery and if it jogs your memory of any horror stories, please share them.

Windows BSOD gallery

BSODs

We also have an article called "Extract troubleshooting info from Windows XP BSOD error messages" that is worth reading (and you can download the article as a PDF). 

by apotheon

I've seen the same thing: Windows XP is not as stable as Windows 2000. In the course of my time here at TR, I've written up a couple of surveys of the architectural history of Windows that shed some light on the subject of why XP is not as stable as 2k.

by jasonhiner

Wayne M -- You and I are on the same page about the whole Google business model issue. Even with Google making a mint on paid search, I still question their long-term business model. On the other hand, I don't agree with you on the issue of enterprise search. Microsoft hasn't shone that they get it yet, and Google has actually produced some products, such as the Google Mini (offering impressive technology and a solid business play), which show that they could potentially corner the enterprise search market. If large organizations are eventually willing to pay for private internal search engines (as the number of internal electronic documents skyrocket) then Google might actually be able to develop a more diversified business model. In other words, I think enterprise search could actually help Google.

Jason

by jasonhiner

Check out this new gallery of photos that takes us through some landmark technologies in the history of computing. The first three photos in the gallery are very interesting. They showcase Google's first storage system, which was housed in a homemade case made out of Legos. Interestingly, the storage system is now an exhibit at Stanford University in William Gates Hall (yes, that William Gates).

Photos: A time capsule of computing

But wait ... there's more. Here are some more galleries of old school computers and devices:

by jasonhiner

One of the big debates raginig within many organizations right now is whether to centralize or decentralize IT. Some companies are consolidating services such as help desks into one location and then simply serving all other locations remotely. This can save costs and make efficient use of resources. Other companies are taking IT services (help desk, admins, and developers) and assigning them to business units, reporting to department managers/directors rather than IT managers and executives. This can make business units a lot happier and cause IT pros to be much less isolated.

As part of last week's discussion of IT department atmosphere, a thread emerged about centralization vs. decentralization. Join the discussion to add your perspective on the following questions:

-- When does decentralization make sense and when is centralization more appropriate?
-- What IT services are best decentralized?
-- Is your IT department more centralized or more decentralized and how well does the structure work?

by tony hopkinson

Raging now? You must be new to the profession.

The question of whether to centralise or decentralise is answered quite easily.
If you are centralised, decentralise and vice versa. Now you've decided to do it, come up with the reason. That's it. Not just in IT either, any support function.

Decentralise to be more reactive and customer focused. Centralise to integrate, standardise and reduce costs.

I've never detected any continuity in these decisions, I've been centralised and decentralised twice, the arguments for changing were valid.

As far as I can make out it's the management team, answering the question how can we improve. They go for we could be more customer focused or we could reduce costs and that depends on where their last focus was.

Personally I think it gives them something to do and a chance to make an impact. This success helps them in the game of musical chairs they play. I've never yet had a manager who's gone from one rationale to the other and back. After all that would mean the first change would have been a mistake and they would have been sacked or moved to special projects.


by wayne m.

Watching the Question of the Week Balloting with Surprise

I have to admit I am greatly surprise by the voting on Centralization vs. Decentralization with Centralization as a 2:1 favorite.  Being on the rabid fringe of Decentralists, I hope we can provoke some discussion as to why Centralization is favored.  I really, really just don't get it!

 

by jasonhiner

Pretty interesting. It won't happen like that (six sequential numbers starting with 1) again for another century. I'm not sure if I'll be awake to see it this time and I definitely won't be around to see it next time. :-) Oh well.

Does anyone know the mathematical odds of this -- six digits in a row in time? Actually, something similar happened at 2 seconds after 12:01 AM last year on March 4. It was 00:01:02 03/04/05 (in military time).

Anyway, I figured other number buffs like me might get a kick out of this.

by simon beck

Actually the next time it will happen is on the 4th may, over here in good ol' blighty. ;)

by charliespencer

As Mr. Beck noted, not everyone uses the MM/DD/YY format.  Some use DD/MM/YY (more logical, since the time element gets increasingly larger as you read from left to right).  Others use YY/MM/DD:HH:MM:SS.  This will never result in sequential numbers starting with '1'

"It was 00:01:02 03/04/05 (in military time)."

U.S. military doesn't write the month as numbers; we write the first three letters.

by jasonhiner

Last month I blogged about the fact that IT employment was surging in the U.S. during 2005 and more of the same was expected in 2006. It looks like Europe is experiencing a similar upsurge, according to a new Eurocom Worldwide report that surveyed nearly 300 executives in 20 European countries and was published in The Register. The Eurocom report found that almost two-thirds of tech companies in Europe plan to increase their staff in the next 12 months while only eight percent are planning staff reductions.

A few other interesting items from the report:

  • A third of the companies said that it was getting harder to recruit tech workers (because of growing demand)
  • Software engineers and project managers are most in demand
  • Like the U.S., Europe is aso seeing tech manufacturing jobs migrate to Asia

by dawgit

So true :-) sure, life is good in Europe. (I know :-) I'm here.!.)  But, just as in the US there are a few problems also. The main complaint I hear from employers (in fact, everyone) is the lack of qualified, skilled, trained, and educated people. In Europe, also like the US, it's close to a closed market in that with-out EU residence or citizenship, it's difficult to get the jobs that are in demand. But there are thousands of jobs to pick from, no doubt about it. Come on over. The food and Wine / Beer is good. And if you start to feel a little burn-out the Med. is only a few hours away. :-) -d

by jasonhiner

Count me among the most surprised individuals on the face of the earth over this development -- Apple has just released new software called "Boot Camp" that will allow Intel Macs to run Windows XP in a dual boot configuration. This is a common sense move for Apple. Maybe that's why it's so shocking to me.

Apple has rarely ever shown common sense when dealing with its relationship to Microsoft Windows. Usually, Apple allows its repugnance of Windows to get in the way of interoperability or platform-convergence opportunities such as this. As such, I give Apple credit for making a wise move here. This will likely make Apple's Intel Macs more appealing to many buyers -- including corporate ones -- and it will save some Mac users from having to buy a separate Windows machine if they need to run some Windows apps for business.

So how does it work? The best part is that this is not a virtualization environment but Windows XP can in fact run natively on the Apple hardware (man, it sounds really strange to say that). The Boot Camp technology will officially be released as part of Mac OS X 10.5 (Leopard) later this year. However, Apple has released a Public Beta of the Boot Camp software, which is available as an 83 MB download from the Apple Web site.

You'll need OS X Tiger 10.4.6 to run Boot Camp and a copy of the full version of Windows XP (Home or Pro) with Service Pack 2. The Boot Camp software burns a CD from OS X that contains the drivers (graphics, audio, networking, wireless, Bluetooth, and others) for Windows -- which greatly simplifies any installation -- and it sets up the partitioning of the hard drive for Windows, as shown in this screenshot (from the Apple site):

Apple boot camp 1

After rebooting, installing Windows XP, and rebooting again, the user will simply hold down the Option key and the following screen will pop up, allowing the user to choose between booting into Mac OS X or Windows XP:

Apple boot camp

From the looks of it, Apple has done this right. TechRepublic will attempt to test this in the coming weeks and report on how well it works in the real world.

The only other question I had was why Apple was suddenly having a change of heart about interoperability. Here is the answer that came from Apple's senior vice president of worldwide product marketing, Philip Schiller, "Apple has no desire or plan to sell or support Windows, but many customers have expressed their interest to run Windows on Apple's superior hardware, now that we use Intel processors. We think Boot Camp makes the Mac even more appealing to Windows users considering making the switch."

Wow, Apple is actually making some common sense moves to win back lost market share. Go figure.

by davemori

Hardware has been virutally identical , anyway, from a components standpoint (95%+ the same components as the PC counterparts) since the late 1990s.

If Apple did not do this, I imagine that V-Communications or somebody would have, and God knows what Windows stability and compatibility issues would have arisen with drivers, etc. that V Communications or otthers would not have had the engineering resources to handle on an ongoing basis.   Ends up being a Win-Win-Win (pardon the pun) for Microsoft and Apple and the customer who wants to do this.

Microsoft gets additional Windows licensing sales.  Apple sells its hardware and OS.  Customer gets native performance instead of emulated performance through something awkward like Virtual PC. 

 

by apotheon

Erik and Jorge are on the money, here. Market share is not only not the only measure of success: it's a completely artificial, pragmatically useless measure of success. It serves only to keep idiotic board members with no accounting skills happy, and to obscure the really valuable metrics for success (profitability, quality, innovation, and longevity).

MacOS is better than it ever was in the mythic halcyon days of yore. You pine for the misremembered glory years, and I'll enjoy the fact that MacOS is finally becoming a versatile, highly functional OS that doesn't place pretensions of artistry as far above technical relevance as it once did. Before the advent of MacOS X, I had zero interest in using the inscrutable damned things. Now, the only reason I don't already have one is the stupid single-button trackpad on the laptops.

Meanwhile, whole regional governments and corporations are fleeing Windows like their butts are on fire, but everyone's still prognosticating the death of Apple. To paraphrase Neal Stephenson's essay In the Beginning was the Command Line, the "going out of business" signs in Apple's windows have been there so long they're curling and turning yellow, but they're still doing a brisk business. Too bad technically superior competitors like Be, Inc. and NeXT actually did go out of business. At least Apple learned some lessons from both, and from the free unix community as well, so that it finally became a decent operating system rather than continuing to languish at the level of Windows quality.