Discussion Locked

E-mail retention policy - ethical dilemma

0 helpful
221 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

221 replies

by frodo3

Why shouldn't we save our e-mails, I have a couple of engineers that can go back 4-5 yrs and find the email to end an argument, usually shoving it right up the other guys Patoot!

by archiveitall

You may not be covered by SOX, but aren't you covered by the
Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)? Or what about state "open
records laws" -- requiring government agencies to produce
emails and other records when requested by citizens? (Also
sometimes called "sunshine laws.") All states may not have them
yet, but many do from what I've heard -- like CA, FL, NY. Does
anyone know who, exactly, is covered by FOIA? Is it only federal
gov't agencies, or also state and local? Regardless, with these
and scads of other e-records laws, it seems there are plenty of
reasons for government entities to have a system for archiving
and quick search/retrieval of their email. Like it or not, email
messages are definitely recognized by the regulatory bodies and
the courts as digital records. And your regular backups aren't
going to cut it for the fast response time required.

by mnlindo

There is an evolving compliance and legal liability environment that requires presentment of email documents during regulatory or legal discovery can lead to - and have resulted in fines in the million of dollars. Look at March 18, 2005 article "You've got (potential dangerous)Mail. Destroying documents is inappropriate and also illegal. Get articles on compliance, SEC regulations, etc. and educate your seniors.

by jclulow

When in doubt, don't... If the law is on your side then obey the law... your nitwit manager will be the loser. Go the company lawyer with the dilema, verify the legality of your position then gently remind your manager that the law requires xxxx then recommend a visit to the company lawyer, together, to verify the legal implications. If the nitwit continues to insist, escalate to the legislating body... as an IT person you have responsibilities beyond the department and the company... PERIOD.

by evil 9

Ultimately you need to remember several key points (many mentioned in preivous posts). First, and most important, YOU will answer for any law you break. The Nuremburg defense never works. An offshoot of this is that it is generally easier to find a new job as a previously fired employee than it is as an ex-con. Second, you're on your own. Don't trust anybody! You will be surprised how fast your "best" friend will turn on you to save his own bacon. Third, ONLY copy and keep records pertaining to orders or directives you have received from your higher-ups. Get everything in writing for two reasons: (1) clarity and (2) evidence. If you have to, be subtle (e.g. send an e-mail to the effect that "I'm sorry, sir, but I wasn't completely clear on exactly what you wanted done . . ."). Do not, under any circumstances, copy and save documentation which you have no right to privately posess, as that may put you in violation of privacy, disclosure, or other laws. Finally, if your instincts tell you this is as bad as it looks (i.e. your boss is wilfully violating the law), hire legal counsel.

by robdew

You're right, how dare ANYONE question management? They're management, they must know what's best for everyone and everything. I can't imagine management ever changing a policy just to benefit them or because they read about it in a magazine.

No one is suggesting that the CEO should ask the IT staff how long they think it will take, but being ignorant of realities creates a bad situation for everyone. Just because management "wants" something to happen faster than it can, doesn't mean it will.

BTW, don't you have a meeting to go to or a budget to slash?

by evil 9

Thankyou for shining your wisdom down upon us paranoid geeks. How foolish of us to think that management would ever do anything unethical or illegal. Of course, I've only been in the workforce a paltry quarter-century, however, in those twenty-odd years, there are three clear and distinct incidents where I was unambiguously ordered to violate laws or regulations for the sake of expedience or the bottom line. Only one of these happenned in an IT capacity, however, the fact remains that while the great majority of management is decent and ethical, there are self-serving, back-stabbing, corporate-ladder-climbers out there. (If you don't believe it, explain to me what happenned at Enron.) I was lucky, because the first time, I allowed myself to be lied to, and played along. Fortunately, my offense was non-felonious, and the worst result was a nominal fine and a temporary loss of income. Since then, I've wised-up. FACT: Most people are decent trusting and trustworthy individuals. Trust your instincts. If it does not affect you directly and personally, but it smells or feels wrong, start planning an escape route.

by Member 32650361

I work for a contractor who has oversite on government contracts. By regulation AND contract, the records on our projects need to be kept for several decades. When I raised the question, fur started to fly-- but the contractors are scrambling to catch up.

Bottom line-- you can't destroy the records, and the higher-ups who promulgated that policy are at legal risk if all copies are destroyed. (I wonder what they may be trying to hide?)

by ChrisP547

In the first post in the thread, BFilmFan cited the following:

You are required and compelled under the National Archives and Records Administration Act of 1984 (Pub. L. 98 - 497, 44 U.S.C. 101 note) to preserve certain documents, including email.

Also, IMHO, document everything, CYA, consult an attorney, do NOT have that attorney call the CEO as suggested elsewhere (definite CEM if he's innocent, and if not could get you fired at best, Pelican-Briefed at worst), and the post about the Archivist sounds like a definite avenue.

by ismd3

The company you work for does have a little discretion but not wide latitude. Create a memorandum for the record citing policy you might be aware of. Here is a start!

Policy. All Service employees and contractors are required by the Federal Records Act (44 U.S.C. 3301) to make and preserve records that document the organization, functions, policies, decisions, procedures, and essential transactions of the Service. You must properly store and preserve records, ensure they are available for retrieval, and schedule them for disposal in accordance with approved disposition schedules. This applies to all records--paper and electronic--including email messages and attached files.

Sec. 4 Definitions.

a. 44 U.S.C. 3301 defines records as all books, papers, maps, photographs, machine readable materials, or other documentary materials, regardless of physical form or characteristics that are:

(1) made or received by an agency of the United States Government under Federal law or in connection with the transaction of public business, and

(2) preserved or appropriate for preservation by that agency or its legitimate successors as evidence of the organization, functions, policies, decisions, procedures, operations, or other activities of the Government or because of the informational value of data in them.

by ismd3

c. Each employee must determine if an email message/attachment meets the definition of a record. Email documents are records when they are created or received in the transaction of agency business, are appropriate for preservation as evidence of the Service's or Department's functions and activities, or are valuable because of the information they contain. See 283 FW 2 (Records Disposition) for guidance on maintenance and disposal of records. If there is uncertainty about the status of a document, treat it as a record and consult with the records management officer for guidance. Examples of email records include, but are not limited to:

(1) Unique, valuable information developed in preparing reports, studies, and position papers that reflect actions taken while conducting agency business.

(2) Unique, valuable information on programs, policies, decisions, directions, and essential actions.

(3) Statement of policy or the rationale for decisions or actions.

(4) Documentation of conversations during which policy was formulated, decisions and commitments reached, or other activities were planned.

d. Email documents are temporary records or nonrecords when they provide no evidence of agency functions and activities or lack information of value. Examples include, but are not limited to:
(1) Copies of memorandums or text sent for information rather than action.

(2) Messages that have only temporary value, such as a meeting time change.

by mollenhourb9

Don't liken yourself to Ollie North. This isn't even close to the same thing.

The accounting department (Management and Budget, in government) typically controls retention policy, not IT. If you think you are truly running afoul of regulations in place in your branch of government (state, local or federal), then you should bring that to the attention of your superiors... politely.

If your DMB has changed their policy, then keep documentation of the decision and comply with it. You aren't going to jail (unless you are personally working to fund a covert war. You aren't, are you?).

Whatever you do, DON'T walk into your boss?s office and get melodramatic. It won't get you anywhere.

by mollenhourb9

BFilmFan will get you fired, whistle blower laws or not. Temperance my friend, temperance.

You can comply with the laws without getting all blustery, and raising a big stink at the first sign of this new directive (or is it new policy?).

Tread lightly, and carry the big stick of documenting your conversations. Keep in mind though, that all of your documentation can also be FOIA'd. Be careful what you write.

by compliance dude

If your company is under scrutiny from a regulatory body (Sarbanes Oxley, SEC, etc) someone will be going to jail when a regulator comes in and wants an audit.

You will be out of a job anyway...seems fishy

by sendbux

Anybody in Govt who makes an order like that, who's fairly elevated, knows it's illegal to destroy docs, including emails.

The boss is doing this because he believes he is protecting himself or someone or something by doing it, pure and simple. It is up to you to discover what that is, if you choose to accept the assignment.

This e-mail will now self-destruct.

by pricetech

I would archive them somewhere, then ask why I'm being told to destroy them. I would also remind my superiors that we could be out of compliance if I followed orders and destroyed them.

Whatever the outcome, I'd keep myself an "ace in the hole".

Joebewan

by n494f

Hmm..from IT audit perspective something is definitely fishy. More often than not, email correspondences are acceptable audit evidence. IF there is really no problem with the Exchange Server (capacity, et al.) and no logical good reason was provided, I'd say you better cover your @ss first. Make sure that whatever they ordered you to do is in writing/documented (emailed!). Print it out and keep a softcopy of it just to be sure that you are protected as well.

by Member 32314330

Doomed if you do and doomed if you don't. Think of the possible legal issues if you destroy the data. You may want to go outside your agency get the answers you need. I would say keep the data, in a hidden archive somewhere. CYOA, because there's a cover up in the making.

Peace and Good Luck

by theroyala9

You should never be placed in the position of
having access or control over the immediate
operations of business/government server
operation or data where you you do not have the
authority and precedence to obey the law and make
decisions for proper operation. Computers are
simple machines its only ever yes or no, 0 or 1.
It never gets any more complicated then that.

This discussion is closed to new replies.