Discussion Locked

eide hard drive manufactors,Best choice.

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

There are many varied options as to the best choice for a hard drive manufactor.
As a technician, I've have to replace a good number of hard drives. The drives i've replaced most would have to be Western Digital, more specifically the 1 and 2 gb drive models. Of course, now we have other options to consider such as bus tranfer rates and drive speeds. Todays drives are in and out of production so fast, even if you do find a good product line, availability can be sparse. What is the best choiceto recommend for a low-end pentium pc.

4 replies

by dtijen

I still recommend Western Digital. Their diagnostics and other utilites far surpass the others in my opinion. I find their 10 or 20gb 7200 RPM drives to be the best.

by gary_4_bush

Being a PC repair tech, I have also replaced several Western Digital hard drives.
I have also replaced a few Seagate HDs too.
It seems to me that the the most reliable hard drives that I have personally worked with have to be from Quantum. So far,I have replaced 0, yes 0, Quantums.

by thinkcomp

Considering that each technician will have
had different experiences, it is not
surprising that there is not much consensus
on an issue such as this one. I have replaced
Western Digital, Seagate, Maxtor, Quantum,
Conner, IBM, and many other hard drives in my
career. Of all of those brands, however, I
would recommend Western Digital for desktop
use, not because they never break, but
because technical support is actually
supportive if and when they sometimes do. For
servers, I would look at IBM or Seagate drives.

Aaron Greenspan
Think Computer Corporation

http://www.thinkcomputer.com

by btrik

One of the hats I wear is PC technician and I too have had many problems with Western Digital Hard Drives. If they are going to fail it is usually within the first six months from what I have experienced. The only thing good about them is the prefail warning...sometimes they will tell you if an imminent disk failure is detected either at POST or during an operating system session and recommend that you backup all data and replace the drive. I have had much better luck with Seagate, Fujitsu, and Maxtor, but this doesn't mean they can't fail just as easily. I think it comes down to Quality Control at the site where the drive was manufactured. Just an opinion.

This discussion is closed to new replies.