Discussion Locked

Embrace the strategic value of IT

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Do you agree with Ramon Padilla Jr. that governments are years behind private sector companies in terms of their strategic use of technology? How often do you deal with a non-IT professional making strategic technology decisions? Share your comments about leveraging IT's strategic value, as discussed in the Aug. 26 Government IT e-newsletter.

If you haven't subscribed to our free Government IT e-newsletter, sign up today!
http://nl.com.com/acct_mgmt.jsp?brand=techrepublic

8 replies

by john tieso

In many ways trying to evaluate Government use of technology in a strategic way vs. similar approaches in industry is like comparing apples and oranges. That's not to say the various government levels don't need to change some of their thinking and approaches.

Governments by nature are relatively static (Despite what they might advertise)and provides well-defined services, benefits, and resources to their citizenry. Once an agency finds an efficeint way to do that well, there is little impetus to make further change for an extended period.

Conversely, industry is in a constant state of cometitive flux that requires more frequent improvements to existing offerings, and infrastructure, and more immediate response to changing markets and customer requirements. Missing opportunities can be deadly.

by jyurow

Anyone who thinks that the making of critical IT decisions by non-IT is confined to government, hasn't been reading "Dilbert" or the e-mail postings from Computerworld's "Daily Shark" !

by lisav

Especially here in Hawaii where it's all about who you know. ie: "I have a cousin that can help us and he is really inexpensive" and they pay for what they get. It's amazing how many people will trust Computer Hobbiests to manage, make decisions and setup their networks.

by bigboss

I agree with the conclusion that it will be a long time before e-Gov will actually happen, but I disagree with the title "Governments must embrace the strategic value of IT". Government's main goal for existence is "governing", i.e. making rules for the society and making sure people are following those rules by making right rules, enforcing the rules, modifying the rules to match changing societal changes. Service to citizens, other than national defence, and enforcement, are just non-essential stuff they do. Therefore, benefit of IT in government's basic function is very limited - it takes ages for societal changes to become new laws or law amendments.

Therefore, IT community must be able to demonstrate IT's benefit before government will take IT seriously. Government won't fall because it does not use IT effectively. By the way, politics is very competitive, but, once elected, the "government" business has very little competition. Therefore, I expect to see more IT in politicians' election offices than in their government office.

As for "strategic decisions", one has to realize that "mail platforms, wireless technology, and operating systems" are not strategic for the real government business, especially for the "services" part of government such as water treatment plants, seweage treatment plants, street lighting, law enforcement, emergency medical services, fire fighting and prevention, national defence, etc. mail platforms, wireless technology, and operating systems are just enablers like electric power, office buildings, water supply, air, chemical supplies, etc. Fire fighting should not fail because their email system fails (think about a fire in the data center). So what you call strategic in on par with, say, the mobile drinking water truck for firefighter. They will be really miserable without it, but they will still get the job done.

Therefore, the IT community must, first, get the basic job done correctly. That is, making sure the mail platforms, wireless technology, and operating systems all run faultlessly every time it is needed (for governments, it is 366x24) and be able to respond to disasters (e.g. the east cost power failure) so quickly that it's like the dial tone telephone system (not the cell, mind you), before we can even discuss IT's "strategic importance" to business.

I can see how the network, the mail, the wireless network, e.g. to be 366x24. But I don't think the operating system, especially the desktop operating systems, will meet this challenge any time soon.

Well, there is a lot of work, and understanding to do. But it is all for the IT community, not the government to deliver.

As for the "progressiveness" of government, one has to realized that in the private enterprise, you can hope of increasing revenue through greater market share, or high customer demand, to hopefully generate higher income, to cover the investment. I have never seen citizens wanting to as for more fire fighting just because the fire fighters do it so well, or for more court appearance because they were treated so well while in custody and in court. The most usual way to have any financial return on investment is to cut cost. High proportion of government costs is in salary. Cost cutting means cutting staff. In some governments, staff cutting is not politically wise. That why in most cases, cost savings from IT in government are not realized.

by egschasteen

I would have to agree with Ramon on that issue based on my experience working with IT in the military. The military branch that I served in still operates largely in DOS! Only recently did some commands finally start switching over to a Windows based operating system. Before our command implemented Microsoft's Windows based operating system as our new computer intranet system, we had to deal continously deal with the DOS system crashing due to constant DATA overload from overusage. In addition, most military techs are rushed through intense training programs due to time constraints and military manpower demands, and are under trained when they go out and begin working on military computer systems. With the lack of training and the lack of abundant source of funding, the military personel are ill equiped to handle the maintenance of military computer systems. All this being said, despite the lack of proper resources and training, our military servicemen still find a way to adapt and overcome, and ultimately accomplish every task they are given.

by sshelby_hi

I work in a State agency where the decision about IT purchases and implementation is all based on how much extra money is available. During the last year new eauipment has been procured without any discussion with me, the computed data systems analyst. New computers were purchase and again replaced withing 6 months to give sertain people a newer machine. The latest twist is that a secretary, who was just promoted to that position from a clerk position has been given the task to design the specs for a web site. Of course I have not been asked to assist in this task. The problem of course starts at the administrator who does not have a clue,but knows how to spend money on new gadgets.

by adams1

I have just left a job because of that very same reason. You would think the people responsible for the IT department would base their decisions on a facts from the IT professionals within the department. I will never understand how a manager of an IT department can be expected to do their job when they are not educated in the technologies they are responsible for. The department i was in, was responsible for over 4500 computers and about 35-45 servers and only one network admin guy and 5 technicians. the network guy would not allow anyone to do "HIS" job, for fear of someone else taking over his position, and the IT head was none the wiser to how the network could be distributed to others in the department and free up the admin to do something really important like set up a SUS server for updates or something responsible like that. And then he would wonder why everyone was unhappy and nothing could get done. Because no one was allowed to! After months of working with this crap, I decided enough is enough. Time to move on to better and more profitable places. I believe leaving that kind of environment, was the best thing anyone interested in moving on with their career could do. Don't stay in a stagnant place like that. Move on. IT professionals should be the only ones to make decisions about the network, no doubt!

by road-dog

By and large, government offices are the model of waste and inefficiency. Just trying to access government programs is an exercise in futility more often than not. This is due to a culture who's first commandment is "thou shalt cover thine ass and protect thy Manager's fiefdom". Government attracts low performers and frustrates those who think fast and seek to excel.

New technology is a threat to those who are unable or unwilling to learn new things. Government is rife with folks who's highest priority is lasting to pension with the lowest expenditure of effort.

Until government takes on an enterpreneurial spirit, IT funding will be used to creep along on substandard platforms while gratifying egos by providing engineering class PC's to people who answer email and do basic word processing. I have seen LOTS of government employees using Ghz Pentium machines predominantly as terminal emulators.....

This discussion is closed to new replies.