I agree with the conclusion that it will be a long time before e-Gov will actually happen, but I disagree with the title "Governments must embrace the strategic value of IT". Government's main goal for existence is "governing", i.e. making rules for the society and making sure people are following those rules by making right rules, enforcing the rules, modifying the rules to match changing societal changes. Service to citizens, other than national defence, and enforcement, are just non-essential stuff they do. Therefore, benefit of IT in government's basic function is very limited - it takes ages for societal changes to become new laws or law amendments.
Therefore, IT community must be able to demonstrate IT's benefit before government will take IT seriously. Government won't fall because it does not use IT effectively. By the way, politics is very competitive, but, once elected, the "government" business has very little competition. Therefore, I expect to see more IT in politicians' election offices than in their government office.
As for "strategic decisions", one has to realize that "mail platforms, wireless technology, and operating systems" are not strategic for the real government business, especially for the "services" part of government such as water treatment plants, seweage treatment plants, street lighting, law enforcement, emergency medical services, fire fighting and prevention, national defence, etc. mail platforms, wireless technology, and operating systems are just enablers like electric power, office buildings, water supply, air, chemical supplies, etc. Fire fighting should not fail because their email system fails (think about a fire in the data center). So what you call strategic in on par with, say, the mobile drinking water truck for firefighter. They will be really miserable without it, but they will still get the job done.
Therefore, the IT community must, first, get the basic job done correctly. That is, making sure the mail platforms, wireless technology, and operating systems all run faultlessly every time it is needed (for governments, it is 366x24) and be able to respond to disasters (e.g. the east cost power failure) so quickly that it's like the dial tone telephone system (not the cell, mind you), before we can even discuss IT's "strategic importance" to business.
I can see how the network, the mail, the wireless network, e.g. to be 366x24. But I don't think the operating system, especially the desktop operating systems, will meet this challenge any time soon.
Well, there is a lot of work, and understanding to do. But it is all for the IT community, not the government to deliver.
As for the "progressiveness" of government, one has to realized that in the private enterprise, you can hope of increasing revenue through greater market share, or high customer demand, to hopefully generate higher income, to cover the investment. I have never seen citizens wanting to as for more fire fighting just because the fire fighters do it so well, or for more court appearance because they were treated so well while in custody and in court. The most usual way to have any financial return on investment is to cut cost. High proportion of government costs is in salary. Cost cutting means cutting staff. In some governments, staff cutting is not politically wise. That why in most cases, cost savings from IT in government are not realized.