Discussion Locked

Employers asking for job seekers Salary History

0 helpful
120 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

120 replies

by zeppo9191

Judging by your post, you're definitely NOT someone I (and I imagine most people) could tolerate as a supervisor. The act of your starting your post by being so horribly demeaning was my first clue, and it went downhill quickly from there.

Your statement that an interview process is 100% personal shows how little management training you've had. There are many, many PERSONAL questions you're not allowed, by law, to ask. Chief among them is religion, but there are several others. (During a phone interview, you're not allowed to ask about race, either, and even during a face to face, you can't ask about ethnicity.) The reason for these laws is to keep the interview and decision process business related, and not tainted by personal bigotries and/or opinions.

As for discovering lies in a resume/interview, there are other means to flush them out, without knowledge of their salary history. Even IF they disclose their salary history, how are you to know whether they lied about that? After all, it's not something their previous employers will release to you without some risk on their part.

I sincerely hope, for your sake, that your immediate supervisor can't identify you as the author of this post; or if you own your own business, that your customers can't, either.

by womble

Employers by law are restricted in the information they are able to provide to others. As you will not tell someone details like this, why should your employer. If they have not correctly identified that person, and guaranteed that the information will be held in confidence, they would be putting themselves at risk of litigation if they did tell and it was not a legitimate request.
In addition, this sort of information relies on a good relationship with your employer who is happy for you to pursue your career outside his organisation - how many people you know who would do this!
The most that I see employers willing to provide is a written statement of service and overall performance, with contact details for further information - never salary!

It is up to you to provide the information you wish them to have - you can decline to provide

by drowningnotwaving

Really, the only people who leave me and my company are unimaginative, two-faced, time-wasting, rumour-mongering folks.

Oh, like you.

Everyone else? Well, we work four and a half day weeks, we have a billiard table in the office, we're number one in our (albeit very small) niche, we have our children in the office with us during the day, and we have fun.

See, rather than 20% more money, or 40% or 60%, I'd take a pay cut to work in an environment that was a lot of fun.

But you sound like you'd have to look the word up.

So have no illusions pal, I doubt you'd get past our receptionist whose job it is to suss people out for their fun factor.

You're on the heap.

by jmgarvin

Not only have you managed to insult some very intelligent posters in a single thread, but you've also alienated yourself in a month!

Way to go!

by drowningnotwaving

Aw cmon JM laugh a bit out loud. They say it's very good for you.

Some people think these little fire-side chats are so serious ("but they mean so much to me !!!!" - but surely you realise they really are just the emotional equivalent of either a punching bag or a porn site or even both at the same time?

Is it really truly all that vital, for the health of everyone's anonymous & vicarious web conscience, that everyone else agrees or is nice and conciliatory in their manner?

Are our techni-fake emotions really so techni-fragile?

Is being 'nice and conciliatory' really the american way? I mean, I asked my good friend Condaleezza but she was neither here nor there about it. Donald and George were reaonably sure and, I have to say, pretty adamant about their take on the conundrum.

I mean, the Big New York F--K YOU, now that was good and balls-ey. Slightly hysterical in content but way-to-go buddy.

by tony hopkinson

I'd flip burgers, round up supermarket trolleys or empty trash bins, before I ever put myself in position where to get a job I had to jam my nose up someones arse.

No one has got anything worth me doing that and I'm more than good enough to find an opportunity somewhere doing something to earn a crust.

So if you are demanding servility as an acknowledgment of your superior position, you are s.o.l with me.

by tribeliker

Tell them you think it is too early to talk about $$ and you would like to know about the position

or ask them "Are you offering me a job?"

by sabol67

It has became the usual code of employers to know how well you are being taken care of by your former employer and why do you opt to leave. Im afraid if i frame the pay as big as i want,are they ready to pay ?.
The truth about this issue is if you desperately needed a job there is no crime in telling your employer the salary history because one wouldnt know if this is what will disqualify you in the interview.

by bfilmfan

I have always found that reply to be the correct answer. If they absolutely demand to know my past salary history, I reply, "I cannot do business with a firm that requests I perform an action which I know to be unethical and can lead to legal action against myself. Thank you for your time." I then get up and leave.

It isn't worth the worry and the stress to deal with organizations that are willing to play fast and loose with the rules of behavior ala Enron, Tyco, etc.

by technowiz

Always an important question that the HR throws to anyone whom they interview. People who have stuck to the process and have justified it, do u mean to say the knowledge is quantifiable and intelligence can be put in a numerical form. In such a knowledge driven global economy , the company trimuphs with its innovation and identifying the pulse what is required rather then what can be manufactured or delivered by them examples Microsoft , Google and mostly all IT companies have succeeded by creating a new segment or being early entrants. I have seen ppl been given even 100% increase in first promotion and few who have recd. no promotions for quite some time , so how valid and justified HR was in selecting such ppl who they have selected and have been nothing more then liabilities or no value addition to the employer. The changein job scenario has been faster then the decision taken within the closed doors of top management. Not everyday is a sunday, so the whole illusion of past history being a template for current and future prospect is a total misnomer , it kind be indicative but not a necessity and requirement. Such a policy is decremental for company itself, since long term prospects seems grim.

by gsg

I worked for a corporate head hunter. When the applicants put this information in their resume or letters, we always edited the information to read something along the lines as "Appropriate for position, experience, and local market." You never leave anything blank on an application. Fill it with something. Also, it's not appropriate as the employer to automatically reject someone who made more in the previous job. For example, where I live a house that costs $100,000 would cost $800,000 in certain markets in the east or on the west coast. If someone is coming from that market, with it's higher cost of living, they could take a 50% pay cut in my area and be much better off. If the employer insists on knowing the exact number, I stand up, shake the interviewer's hand, and thank them for the interview, but that I don't think that their company meets my requirements. Remember, the interview is not just for them to decide if they want you, it's also for you to decide if you really want them.

by sschafir

I work in a very fun loving place where we have a fun on a daily basis. In any case, I might take a slight decrease in pay to work in a more fun place but not that much. You are much less in need of money (or so it seems) than the rest of us.

by larrybell_20009

They check the Credit history because the thought is that if you are behind on credit payments, you might be tempted to steal from the company to pay the creditors.

It was either me or my wife that had the credit check done on them prior to employment, and I think it must have been my wife that found out that was the reason.

It is like when you go to rent an apartment or apply for mortgage. They usually will run credit check on you to see your ability to pay rent on time or at all. An employer wouldn't want to hire someone who might be tempted to steal from them.

by fe

We know that we are not always competitive in salary. We will ask about salary history, or desired salary range early on in the interview process to keep from wasting candidate's time where we are too far apart. We will talk about the salary range, but that can be deceptive. In the case of a very highly qualified candidate, we will exceed the published range. We will not, however tell a candidate that for obvious reasons.

Making the recruiting/interview process adversarial from either side will almost ensure a poor start to an employee/employer relationship.

by davidclark9

From the get-go every employer-candidate relationship is a contest. You don't know each other. Much is at stake. Do they want you? Do you want them? There's always some bullsh*t,always has been,always will be. Few of us are as we see ourselves and we always try to place the best appearance foward. Unfortuantely we live in a time and place where business has become more and more explotative,even mercenary. Get more for less.
My mother in law doesn't understand why people today don't " get a job and stay with it." Can't tell you what I told her - I'd be banned.

by tony hopkinson

I'd be stupid to believe you wouldn't I. You might be a paragon of virtue, most other employers are not.

Suggest you work on them first. :D

by _itpro_oc

in a perfect world, everyone's credit history would be prefect and spotless clean. In which case noone would have a problem disclosing that information. But when things happen and unexpected emergencies ariase and you are unable to coupe with what's come up,
it would be a shame if something as personal as hard financial times would prevent me or anyone else from landing a new position 2-3 years from now. A little upsetting to tell you the truth. I can personally speak from experiance and say that I've been in that situation with my current employer of 9 yrs and have not once thought about doing anything that would cost me my job, just because I couldn't pay my bills. What does upset me is being over worked and under paid. And to think someone could deny me a position for that reason makes it that much more harder to accept. Having a wife and 5 year old daughter to think about, doing anything to jepordize that would be foolish on my part. But my point is credit history should not make or break the deal.

As for the salary history disclosure, I see both sides of the coin but agree that it too shouldn't determine the pay for the job you are applying for.

My 2 cent, which btw are my first in a discussion.

This discussion is closed to new replies.