Discussion Locked

Employment : Checks, checks and more checks, invasions?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

It seems that more and more companies are starting to do employee checks for the heck of it, when it really doesn't hold any bearing on a person's ability to do the job.

For example, more and more US companies are buying out locals in BC and moving their former US headquarters up to Canada. Due to health care costs and other corporate benefits.

As a result, I know someone who has worked for a company for 7 years now, and is being told he has to pass drug testing. This person is a recreational 'smoker' but not a crackhead, methamphetamine dealer or anything hard core.

The fact that he has done his job, worked his way up the ladder and received recognition for his efforts for 17 years shows that obviously his recreational smoking is not an issue that effects his performance at work.

With this US company taking over, he COULD stand to lose his job, though we have laws that allow for a time period to pass after being told you will be tested so you can clean out your system. He can cleanse his system for a few weeks and they can test him in 3 months so he'll be fine. They can't just randomly test after that time. Laws for existing companies changing such policies and a company hiring based on certain criteria are quite different.

Another issue that some Canadian companies are adopting, due to US relationships, is to do credit checks. Just in case the person is hard up for money and it causes their work to suffer.

In BOTH such cases, these 'issues' of drugs at work or money problems have ALWAYS been a concern for an employer. However until recent years, it was something the employer addressed on an individual basis as it was noticed and not something that was a prerequisite to employment.

SOME people can have recreational drug habits after hours that never effect their work. Just like drinkers, some can drink at night and make it to work no problem, others (often those who rarely drink) are not productive and the drinking effects their work.

So while I agree that it can LEAD to problems for SOME people, it shouldn't be a basis of selection in a new employee.

Same goes for financial troubles, some people are always barely staying afloat, and can manage that just fine without it effecting their work. Others will be useless with worry if they are a week late on a phone bill.

So how can they justify testing every EXISTING employee, especially those with a track record that stands the test?

I a lot of cases, Canadian companies that adopt US laws, from such resources as internet forums, what other companies are telling them to do etc. don't stand up in court anyway. But even knowing that, they will not change such policies to adhere to Canadian laws, they just take the chance that they won't get sued.

I was offered a position with a company a few months back, which I turned down due to them having a US based contract that does not adhere to Canadian non-compete laws. I explained that I could get the contract revised by a corporate attorney [u]at no cost to them[/u], to be within BC employment guidelines and that the protection they sought was already afforded to them without the need for the contract. Being lackey's to a US manufacturer, they refused to make changes and I didn't take the position, which in hindsight was not such a great deal anyway. Since when can't a contract be amended to fall within legal guidelines? What kid of a misguided world are we living in?

I suppose I'll also hear about liberal weenies changing the world (unless substantiated) and that horrible Obama taking away people's rights, but that's not the focus I'm seeking. I am looking for more thoughtful opinions on WHY companies all of a sudden feel that they don't need lawyers, just forms others use from the internet and why they wouldn't check with local provincial laws before operating a business.

Are companies just becoming less and less qualified? Young guns at the helm who can play a great game of WOW but don't have a clue how to run a business?

3 replies

by mjd420nova

Drug testing has been a corporate policy but left up to the managers discretion. A new manager that came in in'94 made everyone take immediate drug tests without any advance notice and as a result he lost half his work force. Within a year the location closed and the corporate decision was made to exit that market segment. What a waste, no one exhibited any problems and the business was making exceptional profits before the purge. The firings affected department managers, supervisors, field reps, salesmen and receptionists. No one was given a chance to attend diversion classes or rehab, just shown the door. Todays policy is to test new hires and leave the rest alone unless there are problems. The state has a big part in testing anyone involved in an accident and on the job injuries result in a test during treatment and the company refuses to pay for any treatment in the event anyones under the influence or a positve test result. I understand the companies need to protect itself but abandonment seems to be the rule. With the economy being very shaky, it appears that the businesses are forsaking their support of the employees instead of providing the services needed to enhance the workers wellbeing and support for their employer.

by deadly ernest

giving someone a chance to talk.

A few years back a fellow I know was in an accident, no one seriously hurt, but mandatory blood tests for all. He wasn't the cause of the accident. The blood test revealed certain drugs in his system; so the police police called on him at work and took him in for questioning as they were considering laying charges for driving under the influence - it was a listed drug.

He gets back from work four hours later to find the big boss had seen his departure, made enquiries and he's now sacked for violation of company policy on the use of drugs. He goes to speak to the boss and is refused a chance to speak on his own behalf.

As instructed he clears out his office under supervision, then goes and talks to a lawyer. They write to the big boss and get a letter refusing to enter into any discussion on the matter as his decision is final.

He tries to get a job at other companies in the industry to find the rumour mill has been in full swing at the CEO level and he can't get employed, yet a week early several of the same companies had been wooing him. he finally gets a job with one of the smaller companies at a much reduced salary (all the company could afford) after the boss there allowed him to state his case.

Next move is filing for damages for ten million dollars against the boss and the company, separate law suits.

The cases go to court, the one against the boss first. The guy wins two and half million, two from the company, and half a million from the boss. The company settled out of court after seeing the private one lost, and they pay all legal fees.

What the boss would have learned if he acted fairly:

1. The drug detected is taken on prescription by his doctor. The company policy is against non-prescription drugs.

2. The police did not lay charges after talking to his doctor and getting a written report on the fact the identified drug is prescribed to manage pain caused by his advanced cancer. Other drugs are also taken to control the side affects that restrict the right to drive. No case to answer is the statement from the public prosecutor when presented with the facts.

Which just shows people need to think when applying any policy.

by oz_media

But they don't. I find, especially here, a lot of companies are owned or operated through US corporations these days. They simply use the same documents here as they do there, without any consideration for our own provincial laws, which are similar but do differ in the employees favour quite a bit.

How do you think Americans would react if their employer asked them to sign a contract that obeyed Canadian law but not a state law that offered you greater freedoms for employment?

Such as a non-compete: TECHNICALLY, a company cannot restrict your ability to work within a field of a specific expertise. In my case, sales in any given industry requires a lot of experience and very specific product knowledge. So signing a non-compete means I have to seek out an industry/prduct I know nothing about and then learn it and the market well enough to sell it effectively, which is why I now have a pretty diverse knowledge of quite a few industries. Of course industry blobking reduces my contract options or salary level due to lack of specific experience.

On the other hand, ANYONE working for ANY company in BC, cannot take knowledge acquired at one company, such as trade secrets, pricing etc. and use it to benefit another company, beyond overall industry knowledge. So even without a contract, the company can still come after me for sharing comapny secrets with competitors.

In short, they just don't NEED a non-competition agreement, and the ones they offer from US companies, are an unfair restriction on my ability to practice fair trade.

When yuo DO sign a non-compete, it has to detail specifically, within a reasonable radius of their terrirory where you canno work, it cannot be unrreasonable and must be an area the company already sells to, they can't block their potential territory. But the US contracts that are commonly handed out up here, often say you can't work with ANY company directly or indirectly associated and they offer up ridiculous areaa or restriction.

A company only conducting local BC business wanted to restrict me from trade within 200 'miles' of their territory (a dead giveaway as contracts in Canada state kms not miles). 200 miles from Eastern BC, reaches into Alberta and would restrict even Calgary and Edmonton! It's ridiculous, but instead of getting it legally revised and amicable, they wanted to stick to it. So I didn't sign it and stayed put.

This discussion is closed to new replies.