Discussion Locked

Encounter with Islam -- European Union

0 helpful
36 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Encounter with Islam
The nexus has given rise to incidents of terrorism, complications in integrating the

European Union and a rethinking of foreign policy.
By Diane Wolff

February 13, 2005

The Europeans have discovered they, too, have a terrorism problem, which is exacerbated by demographics and geography.

Europe is having a new encounter with Islam, in domestic politics and foreign affairs. However, it's not the first; the two have had 13 centuries of ups and downs.

The new European-Islamic nexus has given rise to incidents of terrorism, a shift of some traditional European political parties to the right, complications in integrating the European Union and a re-thinking of foreign policy.

Immediately after Sept. 11, 2001, Europe stood shoulder to shoulder with America.

Time and political differences, including but not limited to disagreement about the war in Iraq, have led to frosty relations between Washington and much of Europe.

The realization is dawning on the members of the European Union that their initial notion that terrorism was only America's problem is wrong. In fact, there now may be more reason for concern in Paris than Philadelphia, Amsterdam than Albany and Bonn than Boston.

Timothy Savage, division chief of the Office of European Analysis at the U.S. State Department, explains the situation well.

"The Islamic challenge that Europe faces today is twofold. Internally, Europe must integrate a ghettoized but rapidly growing Muslim minority that many Europeans view as encroaching on the collective identity and public values of European society. Externally, Europe needs to devise a viable approach to the primarily Muslim-populated volatile states stretching from Casablanca to the Caucasus," he wrote last summer.

After Sept. 11, the thinking on the Continent was that Europeans were tolerant and progressive and Americans were unenlightened. We went after the radicals. They opened their arms to their Mediterranean neighbors. They concluded that we were wrong and they were right.

Europe's attitude changed with the Madrid train bombings March 11 that killed 191 people. It was a devastating wake-up call for Europe, a different kind of terrorism than the homegrown Irish Republican Army or Basque separatist movement.

It is beginning to dawn on the Continent that things could get much worse. In preparation for President Bush's visit later this month, security police have been rounding up terror suspects by means the American Civil Liberties Union would take to court.

French law permits detention for three years of people suspected of terror. Britain has proposed placing electronic-surveillance monitors on suspected terrorists to keep track of their whereabouts. This is Britain's way of avoiding the U.S. practice of detention.

Below the surface, there are less immediate, but much more serious, concerns.

More than 23 million Muslims live in Europe, 5 percent of the population. If Turkey joins the European Union, that figure will increase to 90 million, or 15 percent of the total. As EU citizens, they could reside anywhere in Europe, work and cross borders without passports.

This comes as many EU nations have decided that to balance America's status as the lone superpower, they want to carve out their own foreign and security policies. This has led to disputes with Washington about Iraq, how to deal with the emerging possibility of a nuclear threat in Iran, the Kyoto Treaty on global warming and myriad other issues.

But, when it comes to the war on terror, the EU attitude may have more to do with Europe's growing Muslim minorities than with the United States.

In the quarter-century before George W. Bush became president, many European nations increasing found themselves at odds with the U.S. policy on the Middle East, especially in the Israeli-Palestinian dispute. The EU tilt toward the Palestinians in that confrontation and a generally more sympathetic view of Arab causes is at least partially a result of immigration from Europe's former colonies.

Efforts to assimilate the newcomers, the vast majority of whom are Muslim, into European life has been aimed at building interfaith societies. Yet, there is a segment of the immigrants who are resistant to the secular nature of 21st-century Europe.

They think that once Islam has conquered a territory, as it conquered Spain, Portugal, Italy and parts of France in the Middle Ages, it will remain Muslim.

Europe has done a poor job of integrating its Muslim immigrants. The Madrid bombings, numerous examples of street violence and recruitment efforts by al-Qaeda on the Continent suggest that militant Islam has become a problem.

In Europe, for the most part, immigrant Muslims are marginalized in terms of jobs and housing. This has created zones of violence and street crime, with disaffected young males forming a population ripe for recruitment into militant Islamic mosques. European governments have been attempting, in concert with their Islamic communities, to develop European Muslim clerics who forswear the al-Qaeda approach as a way of eliminating the influence of radical Muslim imams from the Middle East and North Africa.

The French government recently deported an Algerian-born imam because he claimed that the Quran authorizes wife-beating. The French decided that his interpretation was incompatible with a secular, tolerant society.

Europe's Muslim minority is diverse, but it has doubled in size in the past three decades. Its members initially came come from North Africa, Turkey, Pakistan, India and Bangladesh. They have been joined by more-recent immigrants from across the Muslim world.

In addition, there is a whole generation of European-born Muslims who are different from their parents and grandparents in that they do not have a strong relationship with their ancestral countries.

Very few European nations gather data on the number of Muslims within their borders. Some bar questions on religion in census forms. As a result, a policy meant to promote tolerance and multicultural values has created an invisible Muslim minority.

It is clear that most of the 900,000 immigrants who enter Europe annually are Muslim. About half the Muslims living in Europe were born there. The Muslim birth rate is three times that of non-Muslims.

By 2015, Europe's Muslim population is projected to double, and much of it will be made up of those younger than 25. Meanwhile, the overall European population is projected to drop by more than 100 million.

European welfare states created at the end of World War II will require higher taxes or more and younger workers to support the aging population. Obviously, one place to find the workers is the Muslim world.

For now, conditions in the Muslim world create the influx of immigration.

In the future, perhaps the need for workers will shift what is now an option to a necessity.

Here is the unanswered question: Has Europe reached the point where its foreign policy has caused itself a security problem? The answer may be yes.

As a recent PBS Frontline, Al-Qaeda's New Front, suggests, Europe may become a staging area for jihadist attacks against the United States.

Militant Islamist elements have been using Europe as a logistics center, a place for acquiring passports and funding, a place to conduct planning. (They have also used Southeast Asia as a logistical center.)

As the Spanish security services' recent disruption of a second Madrid railroad plot suggests, al-Qaeda's strategy may have shifted to plotting attacks on European soil.

Iran's potential nuclear capability, if it is allowed to become operational, may pose a threat to Europe. Iran denies it is trying to develop a bomb, but the United States and European powers think otherwise. The questions are, how advanced is the Iranian nuclear program and how best to stop its development?

Certainly, geography would make any Iranian nuclear program, at least initially, much more threatening to Europe as a potential target than to the United States.

As controversy builds within the EU and the EU security services step up their counterterror measures, will Europe stop sitting out the war on terror and pretending in its public pronouncements that militant Islam is a purely American problem?

On Feb. 4, in an interview on Tucker Carlson's show Unfiltered on PBS, the French ambassador to the United States, John-David Levitte, indicated that his government understood the internal threat and saw a reason to help stabilize Iraq.

"Iraq today is a kind of magnet for jihadists from all over the Arab world but also from France. Last week only we destroyed a network recruiting in the mosques young Muslim French citizens to go to Iraq to be trained and come back to France. And this is happening also in Saudi Arabia and Yemen and so on. These are the negative consequences we were anticipating. But that's done. Now let's make Iraq a success story together."

In France, the controversy over the wearing of the Muslim head scarf in public schools has given rise to a national debate with heated arguments on both sides.

Secular nationalists oppose the wearing of any religious items; multiculturalists support the wearing of head scarves.

The Netherlands has long had a reputation for tolerance, but in the wake of the murder of filmmaker Theo van Gogh, on Nov. 2, Dutch citizens are suspected in at least 20 arson attacks on mosques and churches.

Van Gogh's film Submission dealt with the status of women in the Muslim world. A five-page letter pinned to van Gogh's body called for Muslims to rise up against the "infidel enemies" in the West.

Al-Qaeda's recruitment of European Muslims is nothing new. During the jihad of the 1980s against the Soviets in Afghanistan, as long as the jihadists were going elsewhere to fight and not causing any mayhem on English soil, they were left alone by British authorities.

Many English citizens and recent immigrants of Pakistani origin were involved in the traffic of men, goods and money to the aid of Afghanistan. That may be why the British have a particularly high concentration of radical imams.

They also have a concentration of traditional and nontraditional Arab media. London has been called, by various wags in the press, the capital of the Middle East. Because Western democracies guarantee a free press, Britain has not cracked down on the Web broadcasts of militant anti-Western imams.

On British jihadist Web sites, al-Qaeda recruits the young by using the medium of the young, MTV-type rap videos with a variation on their American counterparts, Arabic music overlaying the drum tracks. Crudely produced, a combination of animation intercut with footage of perceived atrocities against Muslims, these Web videos have the beat and swagger to appeal to the young in the music-video format.

Jihadist fighters, wearing the traditional headdress and hiding the face except for the eyes, brandish AK-47 rifles. The animated figure executes kung fu moves. The lyrics are anti-American and glorify jihad, martyrdom and suicide bombing.

Recruitment continues in British prisons. This was where the so-called shoe bomber, Richard Reid, who tried to blow up a trans-Atlantic flight with explosives in his sneaker, was brought into the jihadist community.

Some in Europe see America's war on terror as detrimental to Europe's relationship with its Muslim minority. European opinion has become divided on the question.

European liberals support the integration of Islam into Europe; some on the right have begun to fear it.

The opposition to Turkey's entry into the EU is based on the fear that Muslims do not want to be part of Europe but to dominate it.

The Strength of Reason, a book by journalist Oriana Fallaci, accuses Europe of selling out for the short-sighted commercial aims of developing profitable commercial relations with the Arab world.

She also accuses the papacy of failing to check the advance of Muslim values in Europe.

"Europe becomes more and more a province of Islam, a colony of Islam. And Italy is an outpost of that province, a stronghold of that colony," she writes. "In each of our cities lies a second city: a Muslim city, a city run by the Quran. A stage in the Islamic expansionism."

Will European tolerance give way to more-stringent anti-terror measures? Signs are appearing that this is already the case.

Savage, the State Department official, says that "European counterterrorism officials estimate that 1 to 2 percent of the Continent's Muslims -- between 250,00 and 500,000 people -- are involved in some type of extremist activity."

"The September 11 hijackers," said Savage, "were not simply based in Europe; they were Arabs whose outlook had been radically transformed by their experiences in Europe."

Since Sept. 11, 2001, European countries have arrested 20 times more terrorism suspects than the United States, according to the Foreign Policy Research Institute.

Bernard Lewis, a noted expert on Islam, commented in a recent interview that by the end of the 21st century, Muslims will be the majority in Europe. Europe will have completed its transformation into Eurabia.

Diane Wolff is an author and journalist. She can be reached at dianepwolff@comcast.net.

36 replies

by garion11

What happened? You afraid of offending someone if you state the obvious.

But by all means, keep denying yourselves that the problem doesn't exist and continue to look the other way. After all it is your country no?

by tony hopkinson

I was simply born here, that gives me some rights including a vote and an opinion.
Everywhere I've gone in the EU, I've had to use my passport.
Big problem with Turkey is they don't recognise greek cyprus. I could go on, there is a serious slant to this article. A specific point is being made Islam is bad, they are taking over, blah blah. Heard it all before, Jews, Irish, Asians, Chinese. Nationalistic/religious biased drivel at best.
I don't deny there are problems with integration in our multi-cultural society, I fail to see how this sort of misleading rubbish addresses the issue.

by hargerd

Agreed Tony, very thinly......

Also Garion11, Europe happens to be a continent, not a country

by montgomery gator

Not that I think Garion is being bigoted by posting this, but if the post is bigoted, then this would me more properly be classified as "Religious Intolerance", since nothing about race is mentioned, just religion (Islam). Get your polictically correct labeling correct next time! :-)

by dc_guy

The whole point of forums like this is (among others) to be a DIGEST of what's going on out there. Not to reprint articles in their entirety. You're supposed to spend a bit of your time editing and condensing this into something that we can read in a minute or two. Instead, you got lazy and cut and pasted the whole thing, so that EVERYONE who's interested has to spend THEIR time reading the unexpurgated version. That's not a good trade. I doubt that many members will have the patience to finish it, especially since it makes the same point over and over and over.

by jdclyde

A short and sweet, and then provide the link for anyone who is interested in checking the source or would like more information.

I made it about 3/4. Then it started sounding like Charlie Browns teacher. waa waaa waa, waaa wa wa waaa.

by garion11

Ritalin if you prefer the artificial route or excercise if you prefer the natural route should take care of your problem.

by liame

I dont have ADD, funnily enough.

What I would have preferred to have read were your thoughts on the article and a link to the original so I could refer to it if needed.

Just a suggestion.

by sleepin'dawg

It is easy to call it racist but it won't make you any less of a target for these animals. Do try not to be at ground zero when the next Muslim suicide bomber strolls by.

Dawg

by hargerd

And nice to site back and ignore it.......
...when its not happening to you. (pre 9/11) Try telling that to the victim's from Manchester (1992,1996) and Omagh (1998) terorist attacks (to name but a few).

Oh!....wait a minate....that's not the same...is it?!

1T

by sleepin'dawg

Which pretty much stays between Brits and the IRA. Visit Ulster and see Christianity in practice. Lovely, fu*king lovely. Nice of you guys to keep it confined to yourselves. :(

by tony hopkinson

All followers of islam are terrorist animals, that's what this article wants to put across.
You really on board with that ?

by jdclyde

To say "militant" muslums, not anyone who is islamic. Or did you only get out of it what you wanted to?

While the article did go on and on, if you have something specific in the article that was WRONG that you care to refute, please do. Until then, sitting around and calling the poster names and throwing poo poo's around isn't adding any validity to your abjection.

Pick a point that is wrong and then disprove it. Simple.

by garion11

I love this race card BS. Read the damn article...it clearly distinguishes from extremist Muslims and moderates. The undeniable truth (which a majority of YOU are not acknowledging) is that the current Muslim extremists outnumber and are growing the moderates.

by sleepin'dawg

The Muslim community are well aware of the fundamentalist fanatics amongst themselves. If they do not step forward and identify these animals then it must mean that they are sympathetic to their cause and are condoning their actions. Sure there are risks but if you look to Ireland there are many instances where both Catholics and Protestants have stepped forward to identify and condemn the more violent members of their societies. As it now stands; you trust a Muslim at your peril.

Dawg

by tony hopkinson

about Islam. Lots of numbers. Quotes from people with other agendas, others out of context.
FYI I did not call any poster a racist, I assumed that the article had been cut from elsewhere and I described it has racist.
Did you mean objection, or was that some sort of unconscious criticism ? LOL

It is a list of facts and opinions, most with a specific slant.

Did you pick up the sense of us being overrun at any point. I got the impression I should be concerned, but I aren't. Terrorism is threatening obviously, but islam is not.

For instance travel across the EU without a passport. You can't easily leave the UK without a passport, though in theory you could. In practice, you'd be having an extensive chat with customs and would miss your flight. On the mainland you can cross borders without a passport this is because europe is open. You wouldn't fences off states in america would you to keep control of mexican immigrants if they suddenly became catholic extremists would you.
So given that, what was the point of the statement.? We are not safe perhaps ?

There's lots of others of this nature in there.

My absolute favourite is the idea that Europe's just discovered it has a problem with terrorists. That was so wrong it's almost hilarious. Americans have just discovered terrorism, Europe unfortunately has known about it for centuries.

Next on the list was the quotes from that Italian idiot who thought the Pope should step in. I can only presume she's a devout catholic. Because the last time we let them fella's dictate policy we were at war for about 600 years in one part of europe or another. You boys fancy rowing across and helping us out again ? Shouldn't last more than five or six years, could call it WWIII, once you do.

as for the militant bit
A quick word count
Islam 16
Muslim 33
militant 5 (all with islam or muslim)
terror 15
So their religion was mentioned twice as much as the bad guys we all want to get rid of.

The biggest point about the document however is what solutions does accepting it's premise dictate. Big walls, immigration bans, persecution of minorities, restriction of the press, government interference with short term commercial ventures, great a cold war in fortress europe.

The bit about the UK knowingly letting terrorists operate from our country with impunity was extremely annoyinhg by the way. I haven't seen any documentary evidence of this assertion, so I can only say I don't believe it. Somebody give me something real to go on and I'll be as livid as you like, not against the terrorists though, against the governmment. That in my eyes would be unforgivable, because or our experience with terrorism.

by sleepin'dawg

Give or take a few years. They can deny it all they want but that is fact and to shut your eyes and ears to it is extremely foolish.

On the one hand the Qu'ran says that Jews and Christians are people of the book and should be respected. On the other it states quite specifically that infidels and unbelievers are to be converted or if not, as it so quaintly phrases it they must be,"Delivered up to the sword." Now do you really want to bet your arse that the muslim you are dealing with is one of the enlightened ones who will respect your life as a person of the book or one of the brain washed fundamentalists who chooses to forget that and wishes to take his shortcut to Paradise by dying while blowing you away. What do you do if your a Buddhist, Confuscian, Taoist or Shintoist??? Kiss your butt goodbye??? Wasn't that as*hole with the explosive shoes a Brit and don't you have quite a few Islamic nut jobs wandering around advocating death to unbelievers. Are you an ostrich with your head in the sand or for that matter up your butt. I watched a few interviews on BBC television showing those people and they aren't fooling around. Worse they weren't Arabs but white and were native born Brits. Then your high level security lets one of them scramble onto a plane and people sat by watching while he tried to ignite his shoes. Somebody even loaned him matches before the penny dropped and they figured out he might be up to no good. Duh!!!

Don't give me any crap about UK passport control. I'm in and out of there several times a year and I can't remember the last time anyone asked me for my passport, coming or going. The Germans and French on the other hand, do check. For a country that has supposedly joined the US in the fight against terrorism you guys are making a rather poor job of it.

Dawg :(

by tony hopkinson

Fifty trips in and out of an airport , that can land a hundred seater, checked everytime. Schipol at the other end checked there as well in and out. That's over a two year period before and after 9/11. The only difference was I had to keep my steel comb at home and use a plastic one.

Exactly people of the book are not heathens and infidels in one interpretation, they are in another. Why is this strange, how many different versions of christianity are there.
Not an argument it's a justification for a belief.

I aren't going to get into an argument which countries security systems are best. Our success rate isn't that good is it ?

Yes we do have one or two of those nutjobs, we watch them very carefully. They aren't terrorists, are they, too visible. They incite racial and religious hatred for their own misguided purposes. Occasionally you might get real terrorist turn up, then you can follow the bleeder and spot his cell. Charging in and planting a combat boot in their slats might be satisfying, but it's a short term gain.

What do you mean supposedly fighting, where are a lot of our trrops now, where were they before that, and before that, and before that, and before that. Fighting terrorists is where they were. Apart from a little bash in the Falklands, we've been doing little else since WWII.
Oh I forgot some of those actions were against freedom fighters were they.

by sleepin'dawg

When I talked about the guy with the explosives in his shoes he was Brit muslim convert and he was onboard a British plane and he endeavoured to blow himself up on an approach to a US airport. The explosives were in his shoes and he spent 15-20 minutes trying to light the fuse before anybody thought of stopping him. Back in the 60s I did some TDY at Sterling Lines up in Hereford. I wasn't overly impressed then and I'm not too impressed now. That Falkland business took much longer than it should have and even then they almost screwed the pooch. Yup Schipol will check your passport but Gatwick and Heathrow haven't checked mine since about 1999. Sorry to say but I don't think your people could organize a decent drunk if they were in a brewery.

by Member 25348569

which kept it going. Still, post 911, funding has dried up so now the IRA rob banks.

An interesting fact. In the late 19th century, Belfast's Catholic Bishop petitioned the corporation for part of the City Cemetery to be Catholic. The request was conceded but only after it was agreed to build an underground wall to keep the Protestant and Catholic dead demonstratively separate.

(shudder)

by hargerd

Sorry Garrion, Long day, didn't read properly.
I still believe that it was a very slanted article, also I don?t remember the US complaining about the mujahideen when they were fighting (read: helping) against the Soviet's

Just wanted to clear the Europe issue up

Thanks

by garion11

I completely agree US wasn't complaining when the Mujahadeen were fighting a foreign invasion with our support. But that is how the game is played at the level of international politics. Sometimes the only choices one has is a bad guy and a worse guy. Sort of like when the allies in WWII "allied" themselves with Stalin to defeat an even worse guy: Hitler.

by sleepin'dawg

"He may be a son of of a bitch but at least he's our son of a bitch." I forget who he was referring to at the time but it seems the sentiment endures in the name of expediency.

Dawg

by fonken monken uk

and little else - its hardly an unbiased, objective article by any stretch of the imagination, and if you cannot see it as propaganda, turn around and question those who taught you the English language.

Perhaps after watching so many IRA members being released then interviewd and witnessing the gash they spew out, I find it easier to spot such crap.

I can safely assume Diane Wolff is not a UK based journalist and author?
Check out this quote - does it feel familiar?:

"Of course the people don't want war. But after all, it's the leaders of the country who determine the policy, and it's always a simple matter to drag the people along whether it's a democracy, a fascist dictatorship, or a parliament, or a communist dictatorship. Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is easy. All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked, and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism, and exposing the country to greater danger."

Familar? Thank Herman Georring for that. Quoted from the Neuremberg Trials.

by jessie

In case you didn't realize it... there are extremists in EVERY religion... nutjobs... and we don't always know who they are! They SEEM harmless enough... until you LIVE with one of them... or they attack you...

Being a muslim, does not make you an extremist any more than being Catholic makes you a member of the IRA. It's all an individual thing... about the individuals and their ability to make up their own minds. The Quran, the Torah, and the Old Testament all pretty much say the same things. Where what they say leads you... is up to you and what you believe.

I know a LOT of Muslims who are very nice, kind, gentle people who think the suicide bombers and the terrorists are a bunch of whack-jobs.

[i]you trust a Muslim at your peril[/i]?!?!?!

Go back to sleepin' dawg.

by garion11

The point of this whole post is to illustrate that the "bunch of whack-jobs" are seriously outnumbering the "very nice, kind, gentle people".

by jdclyde

you may hurt someones feelings if you point that out.

Not suppose to hurt peoples feelings.

This is like the crap last summer in Florida where the muslum woman went to court because she didn't want to put her pic on her drivers license because of her religious beliefs. Fine, go back and use the license you had back in the middle East. Opps, I forgot. She wasn't allowed to have ANY license back in the middle east. And the courts actually WASTED OUR tax dollars listening to this crap. If you don't want a picture on your license then don't get a license. Give her a bus pass.

by sleepin'dawg

Pick up a copy of the Qu'ran. There are many translations but they all say essentially the same thing, unbelievers who won't convert to Islam, should be killed or words to that effect.
Show me another religion in our cockeyed world that brain washes its children (10-18yrs old and sometimes younger) into strapping on a load of explosives and sacrificing themselves so that they can kill non-muslims. The 911 whackos sacrificed themselves believing that death while killing unbelievers would gain them instant guaranteed entrance to Paradise and most of them were university educated. When I was on UN peace keeping duties back in the early sixties I was shot by a 14 year old who was convinced he was serving Allah. Under the circumstances I didn't have much of a chance to convince him that my duty was one of peace and that I was there to protect him and his people. I still resent the people that made his death necessary.
You may know some nice, kind, gentle muslims but unfortuneately I know far too many who are not and lately their numbers have been growing to the point that they are beginning to outnumber the peaceful variety. Read the bios of the 911 killers. Those were just the tip of the iceberg or in their case, sand dune. :(
I've known this stuff since the sixties and I'm used to people thinking I'm alarmist(perhaps even racist) but each and every day I open the paper to a new Islamic attrocity and its no longer confined to the middle east. You'll pardon my not taking your advice and would suggest that maybe you should wake up and become a little more aware of the potential risks these people are bringing to our shores.

Dawg :(

This discussion is closed to new replies.