Discussion Locked

essay for school paper.. please look over and critique it

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

now, if you decide you want to help me and review it, and add comments or whatnot, please use the highlighter tool in word for me, so i can see the changes. You can ftp it up as a word file to ftp://user:user@69.169.149.34 your help is dire!!

Jeremy

[start/]
Have you ever struggled with a computer or ever had complications while using one? Imagine running many buildings of computer were problems arise by the minute and need to be delt with in a timely manner. Yes, New Hartford School is the places were this all happens, but not the only place, because there is also the other 3 schools that the Technology department manages. The main office is just in the high school, and most everything can be done right from there. The Network Administrator Mr. Rankins and Network Specialist/Engineer Jason Tallman have a very demanding job. Not only are they both responsible for keeping the network active, but they are responsible for all of the information that is communicated throughout the network. Mr. Rankins is primarily responsible for the implementation of new software and the network integrity. He also works on a computer called the AS-400 which is a mini-mainframe computer. This is mainly used by the office personnel of each building. This one computer holds all the student related data, such as grades, attendance, student schedules and student information. Mr. Rankins is one of two people responsible for the up-keep of that computer/server. This AS400 is also used by the business department. They play a vital role in the business of the school district and Mr. Rankins makes sure that there business is not interrupted and flows smoothly. Mr. Rankins started off as a AS400 RPG programmer for a company called PartLow-west company. As that company grew, Mr. Rankins became involved in networking. Mr. Rankins stated ?networking was not my path chosen but it was different. It allowed me to expand upon what I do.? Eventually the company that he worked for started closing doors, and soon Mr. Rankins was looking for another job. At that time he spotted an ad in the newspaper for a opening in the New Hartford Central School District for the job of Network Administrator. It was a big change but he stated ?there are a good variety of people and problems?. Now Mr. Rankins does this on a daily basis. He monitors network activity, monitors server?s, fixes hardware, experiments with new software, troubleshoots problems, and manages personnel like student techs and Jason Tallman and all of this is done in a timely manor. Some of the things Mr. Rankins likes about is and the occasional thank you from the people he gets to help each day. Also, Mr. Rankins states ?I enjoy the new cutting edge technology that we incorporate into the district?. As many will tell you, Mr. Rankins has a great sense of humor and is a very nice person to deal with.

Another key person in the networking business is Jason Tallman. Jason Tallman started with his networking interests when he was in the sixth grade, he states ?My first run in with computer networking happened around the sixth grade. I setup a small home network so that my brothers and I could play various computer games against each other. I can still remember running the wires through the heating vents in my house. These days you don?t need to do that with the advances in wireless technology?. Jason loves what he does and he believes he came into this field/job at the right time. With the upcoming budget Jason is pushing for two major changes. One, increased security for the overall network and the second is consolidation of services within the network. The consolidation of the services will allow for better overall network manageability and cost effectiveness. In addition to just knowing a great deal about networking, Jason has is CCNA ?Cisco Certified Network Associate?, he also has his certifications in ?Cisco Voice over IP? and ?Apple AppleCare Printers, Desktop and laptop?. Now a CCNA, he states that you have the basic knowledge and skills to operate and maintain a hydrogenise network using Cisco routing equipment. Such equipment that you are tested on to get your CCNA is switches, routers, hubs, and the inns and outs of networking with Cisco hardware and there operating system known as the Cisco IOS or ?internetworking operating system?. Now a brief explanation of a switch would be this, a switch is able to know were the computer wants to send its data, so the switch has a table of all the other computer connected to it, and sends it to the appropriate place. The VOIP portion is voice over IP, so that lets you turn a think such as the school network into a very powerful phone system using special VOIP Cisco routing and switching equipment. These systems are versatile because they can also be implemented through the existing POTS or ?Plane Old Telephone System?. Jason also states ?If I was to ever do a complete field change it would have to be to Formula One driving. Although with the role that technology plays in that industry I guess I would still be working with computers in some fashion. Jason?s favorite part about the school network is its vast potential and the untapped capabilities that are still waiting to be utilized.

[/end]

13 replies

by hal 9000

As you have given a lot of detail that may be enough for someone unscrupulous to hack the system.

I've just skimmed the paper and saw many passable entry points I think it may be a wise decision to cut back on the details and think more on the actual ways to correct problems as they arise, or better still work out a way to correct problems before the more common ones arise.

Col

by amcol

You need to delete this posting immediately.

Assuming you're a student who's considering a career in IT, you also need to take a course in computer security. Quickly.

Not to mention a course in English. Communication is a key skill for an IT career, and your writing skills need significant improvement.

by tomsal

The others before me said it all already.

This posting should be deleted.

by jamesrl

But if want one big hint, from someone who has been paid to write, your paragraphs are too long. Break up the story into smaller parts. You can't communicate the technical side of your story until you master basic grammer, spelling and composition rules.

James

by 5jgibbs

well.. sorry.. i am not giving anything away.. i have a learning disability and i have made great strides in written communications, i have never written an article like this so that?s why it may be messy at first.. tis only a draft. second.. this has been cleared with the IT department, we are using un-routable ip's so we should be fine. ++ most students have no idea how to use the computers, and we constantly monitor them anyway.. i am a student tech..

my grammar may be off.. but i think i got the basic point across.. i am still working on it though.. .. sorry if this is not the "homework thread" but im not exactly a magician with words, i understand communication is key in IT but i am much better speaking it then writing it. if you would help it would be great.. but if you still think this may be a hazard.. i will remove it. thanks

Jeremy

by jamesrl

Yes I mispelled grammar. Don't deny it.

But I was posting on a newsgroup. No one was marking me. I am sure everyone understood what I meant.

It is a different story when you are posting an essay which will be marked.

I have said in newsgroups as far back as ten years ago that a spelling flame is a lame flame. But I am practising what I preach. When I submitted articles to my editor, I printed them out, went over them with a red pen, and did what I anticipated my editor would do.

I used spell checkers, grammar checkers and readability indexes.

I am betting you didn't hate doing that, but enjoyed it. Did you contribute anything that might help the original poster?

James

by jamesrl

or take it down.

I will suggest you read it over, and say it, rather than just read it. At the major points where you stop to take a breath, think about making it a new paragraph.

I would suggest you look for some structure. Here is a high level suggestion.

First Paragraph - Introduction - What theory are you going to explore, what story are you going to tell. Introduce the subject matter and the background.

2nd, 3rd etc. Draw a list of points you want to make. Make each point a separate paragraph. Order the points so that similar points follow each other. Then order the groups so that the stronger paragraphs come towards the last(unless you are writing for a magazined or newspaper).

Last Paragraph. Summarise your points and draw a conclusion - what did you learn.

Hope that helps.

James

by ippirate

Jeremy,

You appear to have made an honest effort at your first draft. Trying not to make this sound to harsh, it also would appear that you wrote this entirely from the hip, possibly with some notes but definitely no framing/planning.

Now, with the negative out of the way, lets debug.

1. Determine who your audience is.
2. What is your message to them.
3. What is their current level of interest/understanding of the subject?

After you have answered these questions, move on to your information. Draw out a rough framework of what you are attempting to convey.

Outline ?
Subject,
Key Statements
Introduction
Main Point
Supporting Information/arguments
Second Point
Supporting Information/arguments
Third, Fourth, etc.
Supporting Information/arguments
Summation
Close

In this exercise you are only attempting to build the framework, keep statements brief and in a outline/bullet fashion. Maintain your outline frame as it will make it a lot easier to build the paragraphs later.

Also, As you build your frame, check your points and information for relevance to the subject. Remember to consider only the information that you present directly, that is all your readers will have and if it doesn?t make sense to you then it won?t make sense to them.

Don?t worry about the paper yet. Frame it and then we can move on.

Some closing notes. First, there are some elements that you may want to consider removing from your post. The biggest being the IP and FTP data.

Lastly, this is a peer forum and you are asking for critique. You need to remember that. If someone criticizes your work, you asked for it, as in the case of James. Most everyone on here is intelligent enough and been where you are. Take it in stride, learn from their input and use it all to grow. These guys might know a thing or two, even about network security. If you don't agree with that, I'd have to wonder why you are asking input on your paper here. Teachability is the key to whatever you do, especially in IT.

Like I said before, it looks like you are giving this an honest try but you?ve got some work to do to clean it up. Work on the information above and get the foundation laid first.

by hal 9000

My only comment is largely dependent on who this is written for as others have covered the basics quite well when it comes to the actual construction of the paper and some of the more important Security Issues.

This is just a personal thing on my part I would keep real people out of the paper unless it is being written for them to read. To me it is just not great reading for a Technical Paper it is looking more like building up individuals to some power that Be rather than a straight Technical Paper. Anyone in IT knows that you never work alone even if you are the only IT person in the place it is always a TEAM EFFORT and it doesn't matter if there is 1 person there or 10,000 they all contribute to the overall success or otherwise of the program/project or whatever you want to call it. Actually the small IT staff have a much harder job as they have to integrate a solution to either a want or problem into the system while working with others to get the best results. After all it is no good having a really secure system if the students can not gain access.

No matter who you are what your position is you are always part of a team so singling individuals out isn't good for morale.

Just out of curiosity what level is this actually aimed at?

Col

by cp7212

Don't take it too seriously. When I first posted on this site, I got ripped to shreds, also. Believe it or not, sometimes when it seems people are being rude, they are trying to help in their own way. And sometimes, they are just being rude.

I got busted on for paragraph breaks, content, and "the proper place for my posts". I wouldn't worry about it much.....

At least you are paying attention to schoolwork, which is more than I can say for a lot of younger people I know. Keep striving to be better and it will pay off in the future. Good luck.

by 5jgibbs

thanks for all the help, after many edits and changes and things of that nature.. i am done.. i will post the final copy tomarrow.. the one thats being printed in our paper... thanks

jeremy

by sleepin'dawg

You have included far too much about personalities and not enough on the technical aspects. You may be hoping to score brownie points with your instructors but as a tech article this weakens your approach. You also present too many security vulnerabilities to let this go out as is, Clean this up. Yes you may have a learning disability but out in the real world nobody is going to care about that. The question will be; can you do the job and blowing sunshine up your administrator's kilt won't cut it in the end. Ippirate has laid it out very conciseley and that is the type of approcach you should be taking. Your spelling and grammar do need work but a good starting point would be to realize you shouldn't use i when I is required. a minor point to be sure but you'd be slammed and flamed if this went out as is. You also might want to be a bit more forthcoming with footnotes and crediting your sources. These indicate your level of study and research and will be more appreciated by your teachers as being indicative of the efforts you have taken in creating the paper

This discussion is closed to new replies.