Discussion Locked

Ethical Dilemma RE:Kiddie Porn

0 helpful
104 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

104 replies

by macghee

It's on his computer.
He got it from somewhere and kept it.
It's highly illegal.
Children are hurt in making it.

This is called a "no brainer." You report him.
Period.

by absolutely

The question "am I absolutely sure without a shadow of a doubt that this customer is guilty of receiving this smut for his own enjoyment?" is the one that a jury member is instructed to ask itself [b]in a murder case[/b]. When the death penalty is not at stake, the standard is "reasonable doubt", not "a shadow of a doubt", and that is only [b]in trial, for the jury[/b]. When considering whether to report a crime, the standard for investigation is "reasonable suspicion".

The presence of child pornography -- the tech's own independent judgement of the images -- means that this tech has [b]definitely[/b] observed what [b]to him[b] is the product of a crime, on a client's computer. The only uncertain fact of this crime is how the evidence got to that computer, and thus [b]who[/b] is guilty. Unless the images are of individuals who are over 18 but appear younger, sex crimes against children have been committed and must legally be reported.

There are legitimate causes for hesitation and uncertainty, ethically, if this tech really believes his client's story, but legally and professionally the prudent thing to do is report the evidence to the police. As long as you believe in the justice system, doing what is legal is also ethical.

by macghee

I got curious as to just what the US law said on the subject. Do I did a Dogpile search and that led me to a US DOJ search. I found an interesting document at http://www.usdoj.gov/criminal/cybercrime/append.pdf which had the following in it:
"Congress has also required ISPs that become aware of an apparent violation of any federal child exploitation statute to report that information to a designated law enforcement agency. See 42 U.S.C. ? 13032; see also 28 C.F.R. ? 81.1 et seq. (requiring ISPs to report such violations to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, which in turn forwards complaints to designated federal law enforcement agencies)."

If any out there are practicing attorneys in any of the United States, its territories or possesions, an authoritative post would be appreciated, to clear the air in regard to the legal requirements under Federal and State law.

The moral and ethical requirement is much clearer: such things must be reported.

by protiusx

Without question you should report the incident to your local authorities. Remember for evil to flourish requires only that good do nothing. For the sake of our children and our society and our souls we must fight this satanic perversion.

This discussion is closed to new replies.