Discussion Locked

Ethnic Discrimination in Consulting Job in NYC

0 helpful
115 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

115 replies

by alma.sandoval

Although I agree that companies should not discriminate, I disagree that a language requirement be considered discriminatory. Have you ever called for tech support for your software or home computer and gotten someone who isn't fluent in English? As part of my undergraduate computer science studies we were required to take a Finance class. The class was taught by a gentleman who had a very strong accent and did not have a full understanding of the English language. It wasn't until after mid-terms that the class finally understood that he was not scaring numbers - he was squaring them. Without speaking the NATIVE language of the company and understanding the company culture - I would say... save YOURSELF the heart ache and move on...

by alma.sandoval

As a Hispanic single mom working in IT, I feel your pain. But don't despair; much of life is what you make of it. You sound like a very well educated well versed individual with allot to offer. You will succeed just being who you are.

I do agree with what you say about the US: It seems that in other countries they are willing to embrace multi-culture more than the US. I have been discriminated in the past. Gratefully so... It has taught me to go where people accept me for my technical skill, not discriminate against me for my ethnic background. By being in a business that embraces other cultures helps them stay in the forefront in the international market which in turn keeps our stock prices high.

Many of the job posting in our international locations requires that you speak other languages. I often look thru those ads and wonder what it would be like to live on foreign soil. Sounds like a great opportunity to me. Knowing a foreign language will only make my travels that much easier and my dreams that much more attainable.

So, maybe the originator of this blog should learn Chinese. It would only open up more doors of opportunity and adventure. I don't know... maybe he has just lost his childhood sense of adventure. Please don't loose yours.

by gardoglee

Some people expect the world to accomodate them, while some other people figure out how to get along in the world by accomodating it. You've got the right idea. Go where they value what you bring along, while you try to develop new skills to bring more value to the table.

by techrep

ALL interaction of people is between (2) people. The bottom line is the person who is filling the position was not convinced by YOU to give to YOU the job. You failed. Move along now.

(poster above me, probably should avoid the use of broad philosophical generalizations to solve personal inter-human matters)

by waltjohnson35

For two years while I was at IBM I was in a teaching unit whose students were all Chinese. On my three trips to China Mandarin was definitely a plus. With a sixteen week course at Berlitz, I was hardly fluent and I suffered because of it.

Better that you know out front that you would probably fail without the Mandarin background.

Stop complaining about one job where you don't qualify. There will be many areas where you don't qualify. At least in this one you know before you apply.

Get a life. If you think you have one, expand it.

WJ

BTW: I am an ethnic minority now retiring after earning my living in various areas of computing and IT since December 1962.

by techrep

There is no such thing as need its a non-word describing a non-real concept. All things are desire. The asian people were the first to figure this out. Why didn't it stick to YOU?

Person desires to work at Company X. Company X does not desire person to work there. Move along.

by portable123

You can take this several ways. This thread seems to take the negative. You could also say this may be a high profile position and they want to be sure that the contractor has no problem communicating with upper management. Secondly, I have yet to see a job description where NOTHING is negotiable. And finally, while it is unusual, would you be suprised at a French company asking for a contractor who also spoke French? I think that would be tossed off as "ok...". I used to speak Mandarin (Uncle Sam trained me back in 1970) and it is not that hard to pick up if you're trying, I found it easier than Spanish or Russian.

by Former member

There have been a few people who have suggested that at some point Chinese and English languages will 'merge' and a new 'world-standard' language will evolve. An interesting idea at any rate...

by x-marcap

There was the Esperanto experiment many years ago. The Language "Standard" from the 1800s.

People like their own heritage.

by Former member

You are describing a simple human behavior. An experiment was done to demonstrate this, many years ago. Volunteers were asked to test another individual (who they couldn't see). When the person incorrectly answered a question, the volunteer would adminster an electric shock to the individual each incorrect answer, or failure to answer resulted in an increasingly higher voltage shock (the individual, was of course an actor, and was not really being shocked). Sadly, the majority of volunteers would 'shock' the individual to apparent unconsciousness or death, under the reassuring direction of the observer who was a knowledgeable, college Professor. An authority figure they trusted.

It is not a military problem, it is a general people problem.

by x-marcap

I have found the best instruction for languages is at the Presidio. I went through classes in French,Spanish,Mandarin,Wu,and Greek there.

by x-marcap

and you think in it. You spend all your time 8-10 hr/day speaking the language. Only Hello was spoken in English...

by Former member

I remember through most of my elementary school years hearing how the US was on the verge of switching to the metric system. There was a real push to teach it to us so we'd be prepared for it. 25 plus odd years later, and I can't see that much progress has been made...

by techrep

Being in IT one of the things we can have a lot of influence on is date formats:

06-06-06 - What day/month/year is that? Easy

07-06-05 - And this one? Impossible without a code-book for THAT organisation, or a study of 'nearby' data

2006-07-05 - Metric date. Smart. Also sorts properly in tables and file/folder trees.

In my consultations, if the specs do not specify a date format, I provide YYYY-MM-DD by default. If they contain something else, I argue for YYYY-MM-DD. If I lose that argument, I store data in YYYY-MM-DD and any non-user facing views where harmless, I still show YYYY-MM-DD.

As a craftsperson/professional I live in the reality while always pushing against the worst parts of reality, while propping up the good parts of reality. I make that call, then act. We can ALL do that. We are all part of one complex organism. ALL pressure causes change.

by sctang73

I am of Chinese descent and was born in the USA. My grasp of the english language is better than many other native born Americans, Asian or not. As for my grasp of the Chinese language - let's just say I know enought Chinese to order Chinese. Thus, I would fall under your category - not qualified for this position. Here are my thoughts on why you should open your mind and not feel offended...

I worked for a Japanese bank's IT department. MANY users traveled between the US and Japan, thus had laptops that dual booted between MS Windows US English and MS Windows Japanese. English was obviously their second language. Had I been able to at least speak some Japanese, I could have been more efficient in providing support for these users. Clearly, I was at a disadvantage.

Is it illegal for aJapanses bank to do business in the US? NO.

Was it my fault I could not speak/ read/ write Japanese? NO.

However, if I did nothing to adapt to my environment, it definitely would have been my fault!

Bottom line is that this potential employer have something that you're looking for - a job. As a candidate, you have to do what it takes to convince the potential employer that you're the best candidate. If the position offered is not appealing or isn't a good fit, then move on. You're not getting any more qualified for this particular position by complaining about it.

BTW - this isn't discrimination. The glass ceiling in white corporate america is a different story. That ceiling even holds caucasian women back...

This discussion is closed to new replies.