Discussion Locked

Eugenics: Are we ready for our genetic future?

0 helpful
89 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have just finished watching a rather disturbing documentary on TV. Some of you may have seen it too, so you'll know why I call it disturbing. It was the final episode of 'DNA', entitled 'The Future', from the good old Beeb in the UK.

Dr James 'Jim' Watson, co-discoverer of the double helix and the genetic bases of our existence seems to be using his name to promote some rather controversial issues.

When DNA was discovered nearly fifty years ago it was considered 'significant', except nobody really knew which direction it was going to take now that we were aware what it was that made us the way we are.

Then came Dolly the sheep, and cloning became feasible, at least in animals. This has been followed by many other experiments in this rather contentious field, bringing it to the point where the cloning of humans may be just around the corner.

Behind the scenes of all this cutting-edge genetic research I discovered tonight, was the shadow of Dr Watson, still working in the field for which he became famous after securing the Nobel Prize back in 1962.

It was Watson who lobbied the US Congress for the money to begin work on 'gene mapping', which, as we now know, ended in the discovery of the complete human genome. I'm pretty sure it was his name that secured the millions -- sorry, billions -- required to undertake this massive project.

As with the discovery of DNA back in the fifties and wondering where it would go from there, so too we now observe this new achievement and wonder the same thing. Or do we?

Dr Watson, apparently, had but one idea about the human genome once it was perfected, and that was eugenics. Now eugenics may make some of you very apprehensive, as it should do if your only knowledge of it comes from the Nazi atrocities used in WWII.

But before jumping to any false conclusions, let's be fair and say that eugenics was also dabbled in a good half century before that by Dr Davenport, who even wrote a book on the subject. His aim was to rid the world of 'feeble-mindedness' by not allowing persons with this affliction to breed.

Now, while we may laugh at this rather quaint attempt to tamper with something that was very little understood at the time, it does raise the prospect -- as Dr Watson very clearly sees right now -- of being able to eradicate many inherited genetic defects so that they will be no more.

To cite one or two examples: haemophilia, cystic fibrosis, breast cancer, depression and some other mental illnesses, all of which are inherited, can be painful, frequently lead to a miserable existence and quite often, an early death; these, and hundreds of other instances, could safely be eradicated from our genetic 'code' and allow previously afflicted families to have happy, healthy children instead.

But would it stop there? Could it stop there? Inherited characteristics are one thing, but what about when things just plain 'go wrong', where there's no family history, and yet an 'imperfect' baby results simply because a gene didn't copy properly or an entire group of genes 'malfunctioned'?

Tests already exist for such 'accidents' as Downe's Syndrome babies, where a genetic mutation results from a slip-up in the copying. The mother can decide to have an abortion if the test proves positive, rather than bring into the world a child not considered to be 'standard'.

But how about conditions such as depression or even schizophrenia, now believed to run in families and therefore have a genetic connection? As the program pointed out, this particular condition was often associated with great creativity, so how would we ever know that we were not aborting a Van Gogh or a Beethoven or even an Einstein?

Worse, if we could actually remove the 'offensive' gene, or group of genes, before procreation, how many unborn artists [of all persuasions] would never see the light of day?

Dr Watson asked his audience 'If we don't play God, who will?', referring, of course, to the future use the human genome project could be put to. Well yes, who will?

Playing God depends so much on who's doing the playing. An ethical doctor, any human being, would no doubt jump at the chance to rid the world of the suffering caused by many inherited genetic defects. There's already enough suffering of other kinds to add unnecessarily to it, so in this respect, eugenics would be very desirable, very beneficial.

But where to draw the line? It would only take another Hitler to turn eugenics into an evil and terrifying program, such as it was seventy years ago. Even a less ethical doctor whose values were perhaps more materialistic, could easily be turned from doing good to doing evil.

Where DO we draw the line? Do we even go down this road at all? Have we already gone too far to turn back? How do we regulate this vast, new field to prevent the Hitlers of history from getting their hands on anything as sensitive as this?

It IS our future. But is our future about to lead us wildly astray?

Gret Racine

89 replies

by black panther

I supposed you can look at this a few different ways. Well I did anyway. Right or wrong here are my observations:-

If you believe in God then you may have concerns with the tampering of the human genetic code.

If you don't believe in God then you most likely will not care and agree to try and improve/perfect the human race ( as by the definition of what improvement or pefection my mean to you in todays society ).

ie Hitler saw it as blonde haired and blue eyed.

Ayran

The most interesting part to me was that Dr Watson still could not find any DNA responsible for mental illness. ( a shame considering his own son suffers from it ).

Now this lead "me" to think about the relationship between the human mind and the genetic code.

Is the genetic code linked in any way to the human mind or is it only responsible for our physical attributes.

And if it is not repsonsible for our human mind - the question is what is?

Also interesting the similarities between the genetic code of humans and mice - %99.9 compatible. :)

by bob in calgary

I personally do not want the human race to be "perfect" It is everyones individuality and flaws that make people what they are. if that includes genetic errors then that is the way life works. we shouldn't tamper with it. and no i don't believe in god.
There will be people that support eugenics and try to build a master race again and there will need to be controls put in place, somehow, to prevent that line of research.

by levannah44

I don't believe in God either, Bob, and nor does Dr Watson, by the sound of it.

However, genetic errors which cause suffering and which could be eradicated I do believe in getting rid of. Who wants others to suffer needlessly?

But you've hit the nail on the head by pointing out the negative effects of eugenics, such as was tried with Hitler's so-called 'master race'. That's exactly what we've got to try and avoid. There's got to be legislation in place before everything gets out of hand.

I unequivocally condemn any kind of research in eugenics along the lines of a master race or anything like it, but I do support it when it comes to easing the unnecessary suffering so many families face because of inherited genetic defects.

That research warrants support and lots of government money.

by absolutely

If we had individual rights, we could just extend those to include our DNA. If we re-enact our US Constitution, we would have individual rights to apply to our property and our own genetic material. If we really had rights, no mad scientist could impose a personal idea of a "master race" on the vast variety of individuals who comprise the present race.

by hal 9000

For a very long time now. We selectively breed Food Stocks and plants if just for their flowers.

We subjectively breed animals for better muscle content and less fat. Or show animals for better looks and closer to the stated "Perfection" of the breed.

Humans have been selectively breed for centuries the Nazi Party only took it a little further and where far more open about their ideals but the process continues today with selectively choosing partners for people 'Commonly know as "Arranged Marriage!"'

If it where to help prevent deformities and wasting diseases like MS I'm all for it.

Col ]:)

by levannah44

I'm glad you watched the program too, Panther, as it makes it far easier to understand!

Looking at Watson himself, I'd say he definitely doesn't believe in God, considering his quote during the show, but it could also explain his stance on eugenics as a whole, and explicitly his interest in turning the genome project into one about eugenics.

I was also interested when the program mentioned his son, Watson mumbled that it was genetic! However, I thought the program did say they'd found a gene (or group of them) responsible for mental illness, or at least for depression. Maybe I mis-heard that bit. Just as well I taped it; I'll have to take another look.

Yes, I have a feeling there could be a connection between the genetic code and our minds. Didn't Watson say something about a gene for intelligence, or am I just imagining that?

Anyway, intelligence, if such was indeed said, is not physical, and yet we have it, so there must be some genes that are responsible for those kinds of things in us.

And let's face it, if the genetic code was only responsible for our physical attributes, we may as well just be animals. So I think there has to be a connection between the physical and the non-physical, Panther.

Now, with the whole genome project finally finished, all that's left is for the single gene/s for everything about us to be tracked down, one by one! Another fifty years' worth of work!

And yes, that mouse bit was rather fascinating, wasn't it? I'd better be careful, or Col will have the White Mice after us, all, er, 42 of 'em!

by black panther

Please have another listen and confirm the mental illness part. ( i could have heard wrong ) :)

...Although Fragile X Syndrome is caused by a mutation in the x gene FMR1, and downs Syndrome by an excess of chromosome 21.

The interesting part is that even if you do start off with a "good" set of genes what's to stop a mutation afterwards!

maybe as they mentioned we will plug into "self correcting gene software stations" when required!

hope there are no 'bugs' in the software or power outages :)

by hal 9000

The White Mice are our creators as stated in the Christian and Jewish Religious Books.

It goes something like this "The Gods made man in his image" That could equally apply to Genetic Image as well as the often misunderstood Physical Image. Now if we share 99.9% of the Genetic Material with the White Mice who can honestly say that we are not made in their image? :^O

I've got to pick up another Mercedes from Sydney and currently I'm wondering if it's worth the drive or just to pay to get it brought up but I can send some of my "White Mice" down to have a talk with you although they may be a tad upset that they have to fly as cargo and not passengers. Although I think that I can talk them into it as it works out far cheaper as cargo and they wouldn't want to eat or drink airline food. :p

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

White Mice where our creators and they would want us to improve the race so that we could answer their question faster. :D

Now we all know that the answer to the meaning of Life the Universe and everything is 42 but no one has actually thought about the question they have just left it all vague.

So maybe the bible is right when it says that God Created Man In His Image just only in his genetic image and not in the physical image.

Col ]:)

by bob in calgary

OK not trying to sound like a cold hearted a$$

there will always be genetic errors it is a factor of the natural reproductive cycle and with todays environment thrown in for good measure. once we have identified all the genetic patterns and combinations that can cause defects what comes next? a list of eligable partners you are allowed to mate with?

I just see it as tampering with life to a level that would eventually wipe out the individuality that makes us human. people born with genetic defects are part of life and the natural lifecycle.

by absolutely

"people born with genetic defects are part of life and the natural lifecycle" to somebody born with Down's Syndrome.

by black panther

If you found out before the birth of your child by DNA testing that it had Downs Syndrome?

ie Would you want the test to be done in the first place?

If so and it was positive would you then abort?

by levannah44

Well, according to Dr Watson, it won't be necessary, Absolutely. Downe's will have been 'bred out', so to speak, and will no longer exist.

by levannah44

Panther, you've been reading far too much science fiction!

On the other hand, what was once science fiction has often become today's solid science . . . !

And yet, look at what terrorism alone is doing to our once vaunted 'liberties' and rights? Isn't that perhaps the first small step in that direction, the 'thin edge of the wedge', little as we may recognise it now?

As I keep saying, it's a very murky issue that will need to have the legislation well in place almost before the discovery's made! Yes, it's that bad.

How else can we control it if not like that?

by dr dij

If you can genetically design your own baby, why worry about your partner's DNA?

Eric Idle did a hilarious skit on this in 70's on sat nite live. This couple came into his shop to 'order' their baby. He was in a lab coat. They went over a 'shopping list' of features. (things like # fingers, etc.)

He asked them if they wanted any options such as 'hatched back' - I guess a hatched pattern on their back.. They kept ordering the 'perfectly normal' options and he went into a rage at the end, yelling at how he had spent 20 years researching how to get 'hatched skin' and they order a blatheringly normal baby... Then restarted the check list, (presumably to pick some of the more exotic options).

by levannah44

And I totally understand where you're coming from, Bob. That was even one of the arguments used on the program I watched! Where does our genetic diversity go if we alter it out of all recognition?

Which is why I say that if EVER anything is attempted in the direction of at least eliminating those genes which cause harmful genetic diseases, those which really make for a lot of suffering, then the law and legislation for all this will have to be right up there on top of things, so that nothing, NOTHING can be attempted that shouldn't be.

I know, it's a very fine line we draw between our genetic diversity + suffering, and genetic alteration + 'playing God' + peace of mind for all those previously affected.

It's one of those very grey areas which can only be solved ethically if the law keeps pace with it. Without it, you'll have all the little Hitlers in the world wanting to turn eugenics into the evil it once became, and we don't want that.

Bob, I don't know the answer. I wish I did. But thanks for your input, anyway.

by jellimonsta

Even though I am one of those 'Bible thumping' types, the jury is still very much out for me on the whole thing. While I do not put my faith in the abilities of man, there are some incredibly bright people on this planet and some amazing works can be performed.

While I do like the idea of minimizing the impact of genetic problems and other inherited diseases, even today ?selective birth? is performed. Wherein, if a successful pregnancy does not meet a certain ?spec? (i.e. gender, physical/ mental or even number), it is terminated. Maybe it is just us ?weird Pro-Life Christian types? that see a problem with this, but I know I do.

I guess I am just perfectly happy being perfectly imperfect! :)

So what's all this about Eubonics? ;)

by black panther

Even if it were possible to be by our own 'definition' physical perfect we would never be 'mentally' perfect as who decides what the criteria is? :)

by hal 9000

Anyone with an IQ lower than 210. :D

That would immediately get rid of all the Politicians, the Lawyers and Accountants. Without those people life would be all Milk and Honey. ;)

Col ]:)

by black panther

Theres something I still don't understand....

..a patterned DNA code of 4 for humans that determines our make-up, whether physical, mental or both.

A code that provides information about our makeup.

When you look at the DNA pattern it reminds me of machine code, and that in turn presupposes ( a programmer )?

is DNA a third or 4th Generation lanquage?

A language such as C is considered a third-generation language. The code must pass through two additional generations before the computer will execute it. The first-generation language is machine code -- 0011010001. The second-generation language is assembly code -- MOV D1,0xDEADBEEF. The third generation is the C code -- double d = 3735928559.

In the process of protein synthesis, DNA is transcribed to RNA, and RNA is translated into a sequence of amino acids. The amino acids are the first generation. The RNA is the second generation, and the DNA is the third generation.

All life forms are in fact programs in execution, but there are no programmers around to fix bugs. Evolution serves as quality assurance. It's hard to imagine how this situation works. It's as if a software company fired all its programmers after the first version? :)

by jellimonsta

Maybe they retired? :)

We do after all have 'artificial intelligence', or is that 'superficial intelligence'? :)

by Member 25348569

Why are you trying to find some "meaning". The four-base code is the four-base code because it's the simplest that works. Three bases code for each amino acid in any protein and the fourth base is needed because three isn't divisible by two.

This didn't need an "architect" or some sort of "cosmic programmer". Any more complicated would have been unnecessary and anything less wouldn't have worked!

There have been untold "bugs" in evolution but the program is self-learning. If you make a mistalke then you will probably die! Simple! Simple! Simple!

Stop trying to justify whatever it is you're frightened of! Accept what is.

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaagh!

by black panther

What makes you accept some things in science yet question others?

I wish I could put an end to all this and just say.... "everything is just that way and thats the way it is"

But I don't know how to - maybe a pill or bullet might help :)

You know Neil I can sense your frustration at my posts and I'll tell you, times your level by 100 and you may be close to my own level.

I apologise for asking what others have already asked in the multitude of posts on TR and I know you could easily ignore my posts ( but I'm glad you havn't ).

Without you, Absolutely. Dr Diji and Gret - I wouldn't have learned anything so - thank-you.

I'll tell you what I can do though...put me and you and others out of our misery on TR and I'll stick just to Q&A.

I'll go elsewhere with the other questions or keep the questions to myself.

Just say the word and I'm gone. I've been thinking of it anyway :)

by levannah44

A nice analogy, Panther. However, the way I see it is there's no 'outside influence' doing anything, it's all part of the code.

I guess that for the real answer, we'll just have to wait until the entire genome has been interpreted.

A long wait, I'm afriad!

by absolutely

...either fix the scratch, pick up the needle and play a different track, or just discard this broken record?

by john.a.wills

The physiologist J. B. S. Haldane wrote, in one of the Possible Worlds essays, that contraception ought to be freely available because only the nasty, selfish people would use it and that way we would have fewer nasty, selfish people in coming generations. The eugenics societies between the Wars had the same idea, encouraging contraception among Negroes, on the supposition that Negroes were nasty.

by levannah44

It's to be hoped we've come a long way since such dark ideas abounded, John. And that we've also learnt through our mistakes.

A wish maybe? Well, they're allowed!

On the other hand, maybe if such a 'eugenics program' had been initiated in such a fashion, we wouldn't be facing things like the aids pandemic, for instance . . .

by john.a.wills

The American Eugenics Society and another society, whose name I forget, did start preaching contraception for the lower orders, and got many campaigns under way. Later the two societies merged to form what is now the Planned Parenthood Federation of America. I leave othes to judge the extent to which the principles and practices have changed.

by firstpeter

We automatically assume that these "problems" are actually bad things and not opportunities for us to grow. We tend to assume that if we have pain that we need to get rid of it. Standard human response. Standard human response is also a very short-sighted response. We (all us homo-sapiens in general) will trade an hour of pleasure/relief now for a year of pain later. And we'll do it GLADLY in many cases - a pretty clear testament to our really screwed up nature.

Some of the most caring people I know are people who have worked with kids and adults with disabilities. If those kids/adults weren't around, would that person have the same caring, selfless attitude that they have now? Are we really willing to risk turning our world into a world of people who don't care and who aren't selfless because they never had the opportunity to be such?

Short-term happiness ("Nobody has to have a thorn in their side if they don't want it...") for long-term pain ("...and as a result we never learn.").

Beyond that, however, is the definition of what's bad. Is Downs' Syndrome bad? Some would certainly say "yes", but I'm willing to bet if you asked folks who have lived with children/siblings that have DS you'd get a completely different perspective. It's different, it's a challenge, but it's not "bad". And if it's not bad...why again are we trying to "cure" it?

Short-term happiness ("We saved him from living a life where kids made fun of him...") for long-term pain ("..but we never got to experience his smile, his warmth, his love, and he never got to experience a sunset, the soft purr of a kitten, the loving hug of his mother.").

Why don't you ask someone who has a genetic disorder whether or not they'd rather have lived their life or never have been born at all. I'm sure some would choose the latter, but this route would say it's okay to kill a child before he/she is born simply because we think they would look back on their life in 5, 10, 20, 30 years and say they wish they'd never been born.

Short-term happiness ("I think they would have been sad to have to live with a dialysis machine their whole life...") for long-term pain ("...but I will never know, and I see so many children in the same situation smiling big and loving life.").

Even worse - is it REALLY okay to kill a child before he/she is born simply because WE don't want to deal with something? Is murder for MY convenience really okay?

Short-term happiness ("I can continue to go on five vacations a year and eat out every night because I don't have to pay for daycare, school supplies, or their medical treatment for their disease...") for long-term pain ("...but I have just killed my daughter, a unique girl I will never get the opportunity to know and love, before I ever even got to see her or hold her tiny hand.").

I will fall on my hands and knees and weep the day this becomes the road we take.

by levannah44

When I watched this program the first time round, I felt exactly the same. I was torn in half about it; on the one hand, do we get rid of those [inherited] genes which cause pain and suffering in our children in exchange for healthy, happy ones instead?

Or do we stick with the status quo and continue to bring sick children into the world who, no matter how much we love them, will suffer unnecessary pain throughout what could be only a short life?

I'm still in two minds. The program disturbed me greatly, and while I can see the good that could come of it, there's still too much that we could lose if we went down that path.

The trouble is, have we already started on it without even realising? Is it already too late to turn back?

by absolutely

What do you think would be lost? You present the choice between happy, healthy children, or the status quo that includes many unhappy, chronically unhealthy ones, and I wonder how you can be uncertain which option you prefer. If a parents' genetic preference is achieved by screening before conception, would that alleviate your worry? To me, that would be ideal, and I perceive no drawbacks.

by firstpeter

The real question I see in your last post is what is really "unnecessary pain"? If I drink too much and end up with a hangover, I have pain. Is that really unnecessary pain? Or do I actually LEARN something from it and not go on a drinking binge next weekend?

If we see a child who stutters, is that "unnecessary pain"? Or is that really an opportunity for the child (and perhaps others around him) to learn how to persevere despite the problems he faces?

If a child is diagnosed with ADHD, is that "unnecessary pain" because he can't concentrate on one thing and is bouncing off the walls? Or is it really an opportunity for him to learn to control himself or for others to learn to "let loose" from time to time? (Check out Matt Moran's stories of life with an ADHD child - they're very enlightening!)

When we see a child that's confined to a wheelchair because she suffers from a rare genetic disorder, is that "unnecessary pain" because she can't run and play with other children? Or is that an opportunity for her (and those around her) to learn that there's more to life than what your physical body can do?

When a boy has cerebral palsy is that "unnecessary pain"? Or is that an opportunity for ALL of us to learn that there are things in life that we can't control, and we need to learn to quit fighting things beyond our scope of influence and learn to instead enjoy life for what we DO have?

When a child is born with brittle bones and only lives for a week, is that "unnecessary pain" because the child has such a short life, filled with pain? Or is that a wake-up call for all of us to realize that life is precious and that any one of us can be called away instantly so we should enjoy those around us while we have them?

Who makes those decisions? Why are they qualified, when they're just as falliable as we are (probably even more so if they believe they're qualified to make such decisions...)?

by hal 9000

Firstly are DS suffers capable of giving an unbiased answer?

As they have never know any difference what is it that they expect from life?

Is pain a good thing yes provided it is used as something to warn of injury and the like but severe cronic pain that requires daily intake of drugs to make the person able to get through the day is a somewhat acceptable manner to them isn't a good thing.

The definition of a Drug Addict is someone who has a physical need for a substance. Now that substance can be Heroin, Cocaine or Insulin, of one of the medical Opiates used for pain minimization as they never remove the pain just minimize it to an acceptable level.

Why is it that I can break a bone and not feel it or even worse am unable to answer a simple question like how bad is the pain? I've lived with constant pain since 1976 and I no longer remember what it is like without pain. I only have two levels bearable and unbearable this 1 to 10 rubbish means nothing at all to me and I'm a difficult patient because I can not answer the questions in a manner that is expected by the Doctors/Nurses.

If given the opportunity today I would chose never to have been born but since I'm stuck with the results of a Genetic defect I'm waiting for Stem Cell Therapy to come along and I'll be one of the first rushing in for treatment.

So get your facts right you can not ask a blind person from birth do they feel adversely affected by their disability as they can not answer differently as they have never experienced anything else. Any question is answered against what the individual has previously experienced and come to expect as Normal so to a person Blind from Birth you are the 'Freak!" Not them and the same applies to others it is only the people who have experienced what is considered as Normal by the masses and then suffer who can answer the question properly and honestly and I'll tell you now that no one in this position will ever tell you that they are happier now than what they where previously.

Granted I'm one of the lucky ones as I have a decent education to fall back on and I can do light duties like IT related stuff but I sure as hell can no longer pursue my preferred sports or hobbies as I am incapable of performing these now. And while I may chose to do somethings that I know will cause me pain it is my way of not allowing my disability to get on top of me and dictate how I live so I'm constantly doing things that result in me needing a few days to recover from.

Now for the big question would you be happy to live like this and be willing to suffer the pain for days where it hurts to even breath just for a bit of fun for an hour or so? Also to go along with that you are unable to sleep for any length of time as it is far too painful to even attempt so you are restricted to at best 4 hours sleep at any one time.

Col ]:)

by levannah44

I don't remember the program focussing on genetic defects per se, only on INHERITED genetic defects/diseases, Col. Maybe I missed something!

At the moment, or at least, according to the program, we can only eliminate KNOWN genes, or will be able to once the human genome is deciphered in its entirety.

Abnormalities, defects or accidents which happen AFTER conception but in utero with no known previous family history, i.e. such as Downs syndrome, can't yet be genetically traced, or not in an inherited capacity, that is. Whether they'll be able to do this once the human genome is fully decoded remains to be seen.

We can only wait and see.

G

by firstpeter

Out of curiosity, is happiness really relative?

That's an honest question. I notice that some of your answers revolve around someone not knowing what life without "x" is, whether x is Downs Syndrome, blindness, etc. I'm curious as to whether happiness is really relative, and if it is whether that actually matters.

The question at hand isn't whether someone with DS would be happier without it - the question is whether someone with DS would rather have DS and be alive or simply not be alive at all. In my mind whether that person is as happy as, say, I am has no relevance whatsoever, and in fact can't even be measured.

In terms of my question about short-term thinking, very few of us think "hmmmm...if I drink fifteen shots of tequila I will probably end up in the hospital with permanent liver damage from blood poisoning. I'm doing it!" We don't really think that rationally - we're thinking about the short-term effects and how cute that lady at the table across from us is after a couple of shots. We aren't thinking of the brain cells we lose, the additional work our handy liver is doing, or any of the things that happen down the road. The general contention is "I'll deal with it later".

Don't get me wrong - I'm not trying to imply we're all like that. I know several folks that have a great long-term outlook. I'd argue they don't have a lot of fun in the here and now, but hey - I lack that long term vision myself, so they probably argue I won't have a lot of fun in the later. That's how it goes. My only point in that was that we assume that by "controlling" who is born and who isn't based on some set of human-derived criteria we're playing with fire and setting ourselves up for some potential serious pain later on. But hey - "we'll deal with that later."

by levannah44

This is a test that came along years after my son was born, so I don't know at what stage of a pregnancy it gets done, Panther.

Needless to say, I think that would have a very great bearing on my final decision. If it was during the first trimester, I'd definitely say yes.

However, once into the second trimester, I'd be wavering a bit, and by the third trimester, it would be a definite no.

On the other hand, the test may not be able to be carried out successfully until the foetus reaches a certain stage, say well into the second or even third trimester, which would make the mother's decision very, very difficult.

I can't explain it to you properly, but before the 'bulge' begins to show, most women are just a bit blase about the whole business of pregnancy. There's nothing to really 'show' for it!

Then, of course, by the second trimester when the baby actually begins to move, everything changes. Suddenly this 'thing' has become a real person, a very small one to be sure, but nevertheless, a person.

So if the test can only be carried out in the later stages, then I'd in all probability say no, but yes to an earlier stage.

Then you've got to remember other factors. How will this child effect other siblings in the family? Will the family be able to afford the extra cost of care such a special child will require without depriving the other children?

All these have to be taken into consideration as well, Panther, not just the stage when the test is administered.

So sometimes, in spite of everything else, a mother may honestly have to make the decision to abort, whatever stage she's at. If she knows that the family won't adequately be able to afford the extra care needed for this child, or she thinks the interaction with the rest of the family will harm them in some way, or indeed anything else, then she must make the decision to abort no matter what.

As I said, it's a grey area that legislation MUST be on top of, from go to whoa, and I don't really have any answers.

Does anyone?

by levannah44

I intend to look at the tape again, Panther. In fact, as soon as I see the DVD, I think I'll get that instead. It's well worth having, I think.

by absolutely

If the human genome is truly completely mapped, then it ought to be possible to identify the genes for it before conception. I'll wait and see if Neil will support or refute this, but either way I can imagine no reason why it [b]couldn't[/b] become possible. And as long as the individual prospective parents have the right to screen their own genetic material according to their own standards, nobody who exists is harmed, and some eggs and sperm are passed in favor of combinations that produce more able offspring. Who has an issue with that?

I swear, some people (not you, levannah!) will turn the question of one's favorite flavor of ice cream into an abortion debate!

by dmambo

When my wife was pregnant with #2, she had an amnioscentisis (sp?) because an ultrasound raised some questions. We waited 3 weeks before we had an answer and just could not make the decision whether we would abort if the test came back positive. We never had to face the choice as the test came back negative and the kid was born healthy. The thing I learned during those trying weeks was that this choice is not one that the government should dictate. The main question running thru my mind at the time was how would this affect the lives of our other child and our future chidren. I have seen the impact that it had on other families, and I was not sure I had the strength to endure that.

by firstpeter

If only the choice were really that clear and there were no other consequences...if only...if only...if only...

by dr dij

Rosalind Franklin really discovered DNA

http://www.historycooperative.org/journals/ht/36.1/rapoport.html

Her boss Wilkins invited Crick and Watson into her lab to look at her papers. There was a great special on this on PBS. Sadly, they didn't even attribute her in their original publication.

Anyway, back to genetics. in the 'sci-fi-as-reality dept', Andromeda paints an interesting world where you can genetically improve yourself (Nietschians). They of course, use that advantage to dominate others.

On EFC (see efc.com) the taelons helped us build a DNA scrubber (similar in expense to a brand new wafer fab, about $2billion) with lots of wild odd alien looking machines, but simply put, they took your cells and cleaned out toxins, cleaned up the DNA and put them back. Essentially, a DNA scrubber. Maybe fixing defects. Nice peaceful use, fairly non-controversial. Maybe they could enlarge the telomeres at same time so you could live longer.

They did this on Andromeda also when what's-his-name changed his DNA to that of Drago, the founder so he could claim to be their savior reborn. (sorry about the what's-his-name, can't always remember movie stars, my gf gets on me about that, and why I remember Angelina Jolie? ;)

Better get going her, will eating rice and beans for a few weeks, as I'm saving to get my cat and dog cloned. (Not!!)

Better than freeze - dried, the alternative to taxidermy?

-see geneticsavingandclone.com

It could be OK if all we do are fix major problems via genetic defects we can map, that people have. If we reduce variability, we reduce chances of our survival.

by levannah44

I know about Rosalind Franklin. Apparently the reason she couldn't be credited was because they don't give Nobels posthumously.

Whether that's true or not, I think she should still have got more of a guernsey for what she contributed. I agree with you, Dij.

by levannah44

I don' think it would be the government who'd be making the final choices, Mambo, and I hope it never sounded as if that's what was meant.

It would ultimately ALWAYS be the mother's choice [well, the father too, maybe!] whether she went ahead with an abortion or not.

However, the issue pointed out by the program was that no choice would ever be necessary in the future because all these 'bad' genes would have been bred out. In that respect, yes, the government would be the one making the choice and it would be a very final choice too.

After that, if for some reason we then decided we wanted those genes back in the genome, I've no idea how you'd do that once they'd been 'bred out'.

Finito, perhaps?

by levannah44

Never thought of that, Absolutely, but it sure makes a lot of sense.

If we must move down this path, then it sounds just about the right way to do it, I think!

Good one!

by levannah44

We laughed at it then, Dij, but we won't be laughing so hard when the time comes that we're left holding the baby ourselves -- literally, I mean.

Anyway, they're already 'choosing' in China. Because of the Chinese one baby policy, if a woman discovers she's having a girl, she often asks for an abortion.

Were you aware that, instead of the normal ratio of 106/100 boys to girls in most other countries, China has already skewed the figure to 120/100 and rising!

In a generation or two, where are all the girls going to be for this army of young men to marry? There won't be any because they'll have been aborted!

by levannah44

According to Dr Watson, WE make those decisions, WE play God.

After all, you can always control your hangover by not drinking, as you suggest, Peter. A child born with a genetic disability doesn't have that option.

by firstpeter

And in my mind that's exactly where Dr. Watson has gone astray - by trying to justify playing with something we have no business playing with (because of who "we" are).

My example of a hangover was simply to illustrate that pain has a purpose. We may not like it, but it does.

Admittedly I can't wait until the world is completely pain-less, but I can assure you we, as humans, will NOT be the ones to make that happen.

by levannah44

That sounds like a bit of a conundrum, Peter! If we aren't to be the ones to create a pain-free world/society, then just who did you have in mind, and furthermore, how is/will it be done?

G

by Member 25348569

People are looking to germ-line gene therapy to "straighten out" faulty genes to allow for the production of health children. I?m not so sure that it?s the way to go. It will probably require dangerous and unethical experiments on human beings. It is currently illegal in the UK. The goal of eradicating a genetic disease could better and more cheaply be achieved by the means of therapeutic abortion of affected embryos or foetuses.

In the UK, embryo screening using pre-implantation genetic diagnosis is already used to enable parents with a family history of serious conditions, such as Cystic Fibrosis and Huntington?s disease, to avoid passing the faulty gene which leads to their condition on to their children. Last week the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority increased the conditions by adding inherited breast cancer, inherited ovarian cancer and hereditary colon cancer.

In PIGD, the fertilized embryo is grown to the 8-cell stage and one cell is then removed and tested for the faulty gene and the embryo - on the basis of the results - is implanted or destroyed. That's (relatively) simple and will result in the eradication of these diseases without costly and dangerous germ-line gene therapy.

So, for the wonderful goal of eradicating Cystic fibrosis, do we:

Dismiss the views of those who think that termination of pregnancy under any circumstances would be wrong. (YES! It?s not their lives!) ? or - Go down a dangerous and possibly unnecessary road of germ-line therapy.

Obviously, the second path will be taken as it?s a) Glamourous and b) likely to be expensive and so make lots of money.

Down?s though, that?s another matter. I can?t see how it can be eradicated without the current method of screening and therapeutic abortion unless [b]every[/b] embryo is tested per-implantation simply because no-one knows the cause of Down?s.

It?s caused by extra genetic material from the 21st chromosome. Individuals with Down?s Syndrome also have all the other genes given to them by their parents giving a combination of features typical of Down?s on top of the individual features from their parents. The extra 21st chromosome causes an extra dose of some proteins and these cause the typical features of Down?s.

During the formation of the egg, a woman's pair of chromosomes normally split so that only one chromosome is in each egg. In Trisomy 21 Down?s ? found in nearly all of people with Downs?s - the twenty-first chromosome pair does not split and a double-dose goes to the egg. The above also applies to sperm but it is estimated that over 95% of the extra chromosome is of maternal origin.

There is no association between Down?s Syndrome and any given culture, ethnic group, socioeconomic status or geographic region. The only relationship found is the age of the mother. The odds of having a child with Down?s Syndrome at age 35 are approximately 1 in 350. Under age 25, the odds are about 1 in 1400 and at age 40 the odds are about 1 in 100. The chances of a parent of a child with Trisomy 21 having another child with Down?s Syndrome is approximately 1 in 100. If the child has a translocation ? a much rarer cause of Down?s then the recurrence risk can be as high as 100%. The chance of a woman with Down?s Syndrome having a baby with Down?s Syndrome is theoretically 50%.

Sorry, I went off on one. What was the question again? Oh, yes. I think what my ramblings above are trying to say is that, for me, I can?t see any way to "eradicate" Down?s Syndrome genetically without screening and abortion as there is no way to unobtrusively test the egg?s fitness. I don't usually argue with Nobel Laureates but I can't see that Down's was a good example for Dr W.

Neil

by hal 9000

My first reaction was if carried out this would be the last generation of Politician's who are self serving and out for perceived self power. :D

Bring it on the sooner we get rid of people like Abbot & Costello and lay Little Johny Rotten in the ground not necessarily dead the better off we will be. :^O

Col ]:)

by levannah44

Well, for starters, none of the above mentioned would survive in Dr Watson's 'brave new world of eugenics', Col, because they've too many defectic genes.

Come to think of it, pollies are one of the groups for which 42 ISN'T the answer, huh?

G

by hal 9000

Arguing that 42 actually meant nothing at all and was just something to confuse us all with while they went about promising the world prior to an erection and then reneging claiming that what they promised to deliver was not a "Core Promise" and what it was that they where actually doing would benefit us far more. :D

At one place that I went I was asked the Question "How do you know when a Politician is lying to you?" I replied "That's easy you can see their lips moving!" To which I was told {WRONG} if they have a heartbeat and are breathing they are lying to you! ;)

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

And many do get Aborted and many do not and it is not confined to Down Syndrome but a whole range of defects.

Now on the positive side why should the Government be placed in a position to support these people who once their "Loving Parents" die become a drain on society?

Is this an acceptable out come?

Where the places that where previously used to house these people acceptable?

Do we currently have an acceptable provision for these people?

The answer to all of the above is quite defiantly NO!

So who should be responsible for these people and why?

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Got this off my desk calender last week. :^O

Computer Industry Acronym

Microsoft

Most Intelligent Customers Realize Our Software Only Fools Teenagers.

It would have to be a solid Open Source product to be trusted. :p

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

That is self inflicted pain which you deserve.

But what is unacceptable is you deciding on how others live and what they should be expected to live with.

I'll just address your last question as I'll get carried away with tearing apart both you and your opinions with the others

"When a child is born with brittle bones and only lives for a week, is that "unnecessary pain" because the child has such a short life, filled with pain? Or is that a wake-up call for all of us to realize that life is precious and that any one of us can be called away instantly so we should enjoy those around us while we have them?"

Yes it is unnecessary pain for both the baby and parents who hopefully want the child and don't wish to see it suffer.

What makes the Human Animal so special if we allowed something like this to happen to a animal under our care we would be quite rightly charged with Cruelty to the Animal but for some reason you seem to think that it is not only acceptable but good to happen to a human!

Why they is it that we treat our Cats & Dogs better than we are allowed to treat ourselves? If I breed a sickly puppy or one that contracted an infection at a very young age I wouldn't hesitate to have it put down as that is the Humane thing to do but at the same time very intrusive and expensive Medical Procedures are undertaken to keep a dying person alive for a few more hours/Days/Weeks/Months no if these people chose this and pay for it well that their choice but why should we as a society be expected to pay for it if they chose to try to live longer.

Far more importantly what gives anyone the right to force their opinions onto another who is incapable of defending them self against this action?

Col ]:)

by firstpeter

First note - my point about a hangover was simply illustrative that pain can have a good side to it. I am in complete agreement that _I_ caused that pain where a child doesn't have that same level of control (they have no level of control).

In terms of your sentence: "I'll just address your last question as I'll get carried away with tearing apart both you and your opinions with the others."

I would hope we can keep a civilized discussion on this one as opposed to attempting to assasinate the character of good people (after all we're not American liberals here... *grin* - couldn't resist!). I'm not attempting to impose my views on anyone else, just trying to present the other side of the coin that I believe gets missed FAR too many times in discussions like this. If I have failed in that and am attacking a person or their opinion please let me know - I'll correct it immediately.

On that note, though, I see tremendous value in life, and I struggle to see how your last paragraph doesn't completely reinforce what I'm trying to point out. Perhaps I've read it wrong, but I read that I should absolutely not be able to simply abort a pregnancy because my child has some disease that currently can't be cured.

I won't get off on the topic of abortion in general (you can imagine where I stand on that topic), but this is really no different. This discussion centers around aborting the child because we think they'd rather never live at all than live with a disease. If the argument is that we really don't know what the child would want (and it's pretty obvious that we don't)...shouldn't we be erring on the side of caution and allowing the child to live?

It seems to me that anything else would be what you're noting in the last paragraph - imposing our will on someone who can't defend themselves. Am I missing the point there?

by hal 9000

But just your statements. Actually reading the above brought to mind a Little 5 -6 year old girl that I ran across when I worked Medical she had been burnt and had been in hospital for several months and just before an operation had run away because she didn't want to go through the pain again. At the time her arm was attached to her stomach and this operation was to cut that join and free up the arm again but because the skin had shrunk she was going to be having a lot of pain until things settled down again.

The poor kid must have been in agony when she ran away to get away from the tender clutches of the "Caring Profession" but she preferred that pain to what she knew she was going to be going through latter that day. I found her in my server room hiding in a dark corner crying and asking why if her parents really loved her they would put her through these operations and associated pain.

I couldn't report her hiding place but I did call in and tell them not to panic and I just sat there talking to her for about 1 hour until she decided that she had better go back and face the music and pain so I took her back and felt so low for doing this. I went up and visited her the next day and she was in tears with the pain and she was only being given aspirin for the pain as anything stronger would have adversely affected her. It's one of the few times I've been temped to alter Medical Records to help the poor kid.

But what did get me in this particular case was that everyone was doing the best thing for this Child but no one was listening to her wishes and even though they where simple childish wishes they should have been given some weight she just didn't want to hurt anymore so their way to cure the problem was inflict more pain upon her. I still speak to this woman today some 25 years latter and she insists that I was the only one who took the time to listen to her while she was in the hospital and made her life there bearable. The doctors and Nurses just ignored her and only spoke to her parents and her parents told her that it had to be done.

Today she'll admit that it was a necessary treatment but that she always felt like a caged rabbit while in there and she insists that if it wasn't for my visits she would never have got through the ordeal.

Col ]:)

by levannah44

Plants, animals and food don't seem to raise the ire so much, Col, as humans do.

And of course, most people I've ever spoken to have only heard of eugenics via the Lebensraum program of the Nazis back in the '30s and '40s.

And that, of course, was bad eugenics, or rather, eugenics used for the wrong reasons. It's probably made a lot of people very scared to even consider what can be achieved with good eugenics, as in preventing deformities and genetically inherited diseases.

But then, how do you prevent those with a less than altruistic intent from doing the opposite?

by hal 9000

Keep the Politicians away from the decision making process, they get their bureaucrats involved and nothing good comes from it ever!

The second step would be to leave it to Medical Ethics Boards to decide what is acceptable and what isn't acceptable. I for one consider Therapeutic Cloning a good idea.

But I don't like the idea of cloning just for the sake of cloning for the few rich who can afford it so they effectively live forever. If that was to happen we would have the same Politicians and Business people at the head of the different organizations all the time and that isn't a nice thought. Then there are the legal issues like is a Clone responsible for the actions of the original owner DNA that was used to make it?

In every currently recorded case where Eugenics have been used for nonproductive purposes it has been the Political people involved in perverting its uses. Hitler made it the "Ideal" to have the Ariana Race as the only "Pure" race that should exist not a Scientist.

Just think on this for a second as it really doesn't warrant any more time wasted on the idea if somehow the DNA of what the Christians call Jesus Christ was to be cloned from the foreskin that was removed by Jewish tradition would that Clone be considered as being Christ Incarnate? Being the cynic that I am I believe that there are many Christians who would blindly follow that person to whatever end that he wanted. Then there would be another group who considered him the Antichrist and that would leave the rest of us shaking our heads in disbelief and laughing.

But it could quite easily start off another religious war in the Christian Sects and take us back to the really Dark Ages.

PS Enjoy the photos of the GM food that I've sent you. :p

Col ]:)

by levannah44

Once again, Col, I agree with what you're saying. The pollies would need to butt out, and the Ethical c'tees be the ones to pull all the strings, but then, how do we have legislation passed without pollies? I still think all this will need proper legislation, and if it can be done without pollies, then I'm all for it.

Therapeutic cloning, I'm guessing, is where a body is in anyway injured, due to accident, disease or other ways, we should permit cloning to fix it.

In other words, someone loses a leg due to say, gangrene due to disease. Okay, grow a new leg, or, more properly, clone a new leg. Yes, I agree with that. And so on and so forth for any other instance where the body 'perfect' has, in some way, become 'imperfect'.

But it still always comes back to the proper legislation to guard against misuse of any of these future methods/techniques, and unfortunately, legislation always = pollies. How are we to get around that?

Perhaps it's just as well that the Jesus clone idea is hypothetical! I'd hate to see the results otherwise!!

We could laugh heartily, but what about everyone else?

G

by levannah44

Actually, I happen to agree with you, Neil. I think perhaps Dr Watson forgot for a moment that DS is NOT an hereditary genetical defect, just a genetical defect.

While the test is still available for DS for those parents who wish to take advantage of it, I think the only solution to the problem is to research the reason Down's happens the way it does, when it does.

Obviously there's got to be some connection with the mother's age, as it does seem to hit mums who conceive at an increasingly older age. If I were a medical researcher, I think that's where I'd start, and try and discover what it is about older mums that causes the 21st chromosome NOT to split.

As for some of the other true genetically inherited conditions, like cystic fibrosis or haemophilia, they ARE the kinds of things that could be treated with eugenics.

They are distressing for both the parents and the child, and in the case of the latter, so I understand, extremely painful as well. Not only that, quite frequently they result in short lives as well. Not a happy picture.

However, having said that, I still think it should be a matter of choice by the parents, not a blanket eradication of the gene across the board whether people like it or not. That's dictatorship.

Maybe some parents don't want the gene removed, for whatever reason/s, and they should be allowed the freedom to choose. Whether it's done via an eight-cell embryo or later through abortion, for those parents who choose this way, remains to be seen.

Provided freedom of choice is retained, I don't have too much of a problem with Dr Watson.

G

by hal 9000

Some women may wish to keep the Hairdressers to fan the flames of their own vanity. :)

After all what sensible person picks a fight with someone that is holding a sharp implement in their hands at the time? ;)

I know I'm regularly Blackmailed by a surgeon who stands over me with a scalpel saying that he's so worried about his work computers that his hand might shake and he cuts something important to me off. :D

While I'm no expert I would imagine that a pair of Hairdresser Scissors sticking out of one of your ears or neck would at the very least be a painful experience if not deadly. :^O

The worst that a Polly, Lawyer or Accountant could give you is a paper cut which while painful for a short period of time is not life threating at all. :)

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Mice have been tested for this.

If they where to get their hands on one of the original White Mice who used their genetic material to make the Biological Computer to answer the Ultimate Question of Life, The Universe and Everything they just might have 21 pair and not the 20 that have been left over for the Garden Variety White Mice that where left here to keep tabs on the computations. :D

After all if the White Mice who are the Creators where involved it only stands to reason that they would have left poor or not as well developed copies of themselves to supervise the experiment and report back on the progress. If they had of left a few of their original party the possibility exists that those few may of withheld the answer for their own gain. :p

So it makes perfect sense that they also made copies of themselves but to a lower standard so as not to find themselves in a position of having the answer but not being able to access it. :^O

They could also be missing a "Pair" by design so that they lack a bladder and are therefore easier to track down when the answer is reached. After all a urine trail is easy to follow even for the poorly developed Human Olfactory Senses. :)

Col ]:)

by levannah44

Sorry Neil! Must've had one of those 'senior's moments' I've been having lately!!

Or admit that I just can't count. Damn it!

G

by hal 9000

Spina Biffida at S3 level {the spelling is most likely wrong but I'm way to lazy to actually dig out my medical records and look it up} which I suffer from. While not as bad as it could be it is none the less a painful experience that only came to light after an industrial accident in the late 70's.

You have to love the "Caring Profession" as at the time I was told that I was Bulging and just being lazy until something as simple a as Plain X-Ray was performed. Now that is hardly a massively invasive or high tech diagnostic tool to use but for 6 months I was being what a Lazy SOD I was not wanting to return to work when actually I wanted to get back to work ASAP as I was finding it as boring as Hell sitting at Home not to mention the drop in income that went along with it. Now if I didn't have that Spinal Defect when the accident happened it would have been a simple cure maybe a few weeks off with people who actually wanted to help me get better and then back to work without the massive drop in income and the needless insurance forms to fill in. Of course when it was diagnosed the Insurance was wiped as I had not informed them of the Heredity Defect which I didn't know about previously.

Needless to say if I had of known what was wrong prior to that I would not have had any children either as what I live with every day I would not wish on anyone.

It is now possible with nothing more complex that an Ultra Sound scan to pick this up and while I'm still walking around as I refuse to allow the surgeons to operate on me as I'll most likely be worse off I could be doing so much more with my life that what I currently am. :D

Actually for a change I was an innocent Bystander in that accident which is fairly strange as I used to test drive Race Cars and have a few horrendous crashes which I always walked away from unscathed but being around while they unloaded a shipping container is extremely dangerous so I suffered the consequences. :(

Col ]:)

by levannah44

Col, correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think SB is hereditary. It's one of those things -- like Downs -- that 'goes wrong' internally after conception and before birth, but has nothing to do with 'inheritance'.

Unless you know of anyone else in your family with this condition, i.e. either of your parents, your grandparents, aunts, uncles, brothers, sisters -- close rellies and all that, who may have had it too.

When my niece's son (great nephew?) was born with it, there was no other indication of this condition in either family that could be traced, which is why I think it's one of those genetic 'accidents' that happen in utero out of the blue.

And of course, this is where cloning would come into its own, I believe. Nothing to do with wanting to live 'forever', but simply fixing up parts in us that had somehow gone 'wrong'.

G

by hal 9000

You get different answers. However I've always been told it is Heredity although lately there has been some research that makes it more likely if the potential mother doesn't consume enough of some foods. Although this has only come to light in the last 10 -15 years. But in my case it is defiantly a Heredity thing as several of my Brothers have the same thing although they didn't know it until after I was diagnosed with it. They just thought that sore backs ran in the family which they do on my fathers side.

Perhaps the next time one of the Right to Lifers comes around trying to pervert me I can use this as an excuse to Sue my Mother as she didn't do the right thing while pregnant with me. It's all her fault. :D

That should go down well shouldn't it?

Col ]:)

by levannah44

Freudian slip in para one, Col?? I never laughed so much!

G

PS: But yes, I agree with the rest.

by hal 9000

It just shows how much respect I have for Pollies doesn't it? :p

Actually I love using Carl Jung's quote "Life is a Sexually Transmitted Disease with an Extremely Bad Prognosis!" That one is always good for a laugh when you get a bunch of shrinks around as they try to disprove it and then start to tear the person who is responsible for it to bits until I mention Jung's name then they are left wondering how to proceed. :D

Col ]:)

by levannah44

I must admit I was in two minds over it, Col. With you, one never knows half the time if you're being deadly serious or killing yourself laughing.

I'm glad it's the latter this time; I love a good laugh!

by hal 9000

I was asked to run a proposed Cyclotron at Lucas Heights which we needed 20 + years ago now. So I read the safety procedures that would be involved and as they where all written by Bureaucrats who knew nothing at all about the technology I could have created a very nice Fission Reaction without breaking a single safety rule and wiped out Sydney or at the very least the best part of it anyway.

Involving Pollies means involving Bureaucrats to advise the Pollies and that is alway a recipe for disaster as in the Public Service there is an old Maxim never make a decision that you can kick upstairs to be made. Never make any controversial decision at all refer it to a committee. And when you are walking around always carry a sheet of paper and look busy even if you are only caring a bit of toilet paper. :^O

Therapeutic Cloning is growing vital organs from Stem Cell research so that there are no problems with rejection and the like. So if you need a Heart Lung Transplant all you need do is grow some new ones from the patients DNA and a spare unfertilized Ova left over from IVF.

Actually look at the Pigs Breakfast that IVF created and even now we are still undergoing problems that have been brought about by the Bureaucrats who thought that they knew best. Once you have some Law in place it is very hard to get it changed or revoked no matter what. Unless of course some senior Bureaucrat needs the process that they have outlawed so then it might get pushed through as a 1 off experiment.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

But also with the non life threating problems who should take the responsibility when these children's parents die?

I used to work Medical It and then when that got unbearable I moved to a specialist center for Cerebral Palsy and while those kids appeared more than happy they where going to out live their parents who where going to be their primary care givers and then they would lack the necessary support system that they required. And generally it was left to the Government which means you and me to foot the bill for their care.

Now is this right?

Or more to the point is it right that some Bureaucrat is given power over these people to only allow them to do what they consider is in their best interests?

One couple that I know with CP are now married living independently but on a Government handout and a little outside work to supplement their Government income. Both where forcibly sterilized when they hit their early teens as it was then the "Policy" which I also find offensive.

All I can say is that it should be an individual decision that is left to the individuals concerned but I've seen both sides of the coin and I really don't like either of them. Or in one case recently where 2 babies suffered the same injury at birth by the same Doctor because one family was wealthy with several houses and the other was working class who spent their limited money wisely and always bought what they thought was the best. Now when this ended up in court the exact same injury one family got Millions for the injury and the other family only got $500,000.00 because they didn't have to modify 3 houses and add lifts to the multi story dwellings. I also find this more than offensive the same injury should elect the same compensation after all why should one family who is capable of caring the financial burden be rewarded for the injury and the other one who is struggling be devalued for the exact same injury?

If it was my decision I would have awarded the greater amount to the working class family as they where the ones who where suffering more than the other family who had full time care hired for the child had altered the houses for ease of access and generally speaking where no where near as affected as the other family who where doing it tough because the wife had to stop working to care for the child.

But even that would be discrimination wouldn't it?

Col ]:)

by levannah44

Would you believe, Jaqui, that that little piece of media garbage actually made it to our news broadcasts down here in Aussie?

I couldn't believe my eyes or ears when I heard it; I thought 'Someone's making this up!'

Then I remembered about the 'war on terrorism' and what it's done to the world. At least, I'm trying to be charitable and put such idiocy down to things like that.

But I do agree with you; the gene pool needs a terrific stirring. Maybe Dr Watson will get his way after all.

by firstpeter

Don't get me started on doctors and listening...and I say that in all sincerity because I could very well drown the TR system with my ranting on that particular topic. That's a great story - most people would normally assume IT people don't really care (a horribly wrong characterization, but I've run across it too many times to call it the exception).

Let me clarify my point because I'm not sure I did a sufficient job before - I'm not against healing (that's a very noble thing as long as we're not killing to heal), but against determining whether we choose to let a child live or abort them based on whether they test positive for a disease/condition/etc.

Whether we claim it's for the sake of the child or for our convenience the end result is the same - we're killing a child. The difference here is at least there is some rationalization that perhaps the child wouldn't want to live that way -- if we're being honest about it (vs. the real issue being _I_ don't want to deal with having a child with x disease...which gets right back to abortion for convenience).

And this is where I'm stuck. I have an issue with killing the child...period. Never giving them a chance to live. It really gets back to the old values debate of "life vs. quality of life" - you can't even start to have the latter without the former. But to me that's even a rough argument because how do you define the quality of life?

And, most importantly, since happiness should NOT be judged relative to someone else, we have no idea if that child would be unhappy until they're born. But we remove that altogether if we accept that we, as parents, should be able to abort a child based on the results of a test saying "we don't think they'd want to live with Downs Syndrome." The issue isn't really that, although that's an easier one for us to deal with so we adopt it. The REAL question that people need to answer is would they rather live with DS or not live at all?

That's the best we can get - we will never know the child's wishes if we never give them the chance to live.

Obviously this doesn't address the issue of at what point you give credence to what they say (that it's out of reason and not simply emotion or throwing a fit), but that's really a different subject but one you hit on here that's very important.

by hal 9000

The issue here is with Eugenics there would never need to be an abortion as these genetic traits would be eventually removed from the Gene Pool as they would be all checked to prior to implantation into a Womb. It would all be IVF and the resulting Embryo tested at the 8 cell stage.

With potential Politician's I would insist that they be tested at the 1 cell stage and allow that cell to be destroyed. ;)

So if a 7 cell embryo is thrown out because of genetic defects which happens now I really do not see much of a problem with it as the IVF factory would be sued for not doing their job properly.

Different matter if there was mandatory Amino done to every pregnant female and then Government appointed Medical People got to make the decision as to what was allowed to go to term or be aborted. I trust Doctors about as far as I cam move a hospital building to drop on them and Government Bureaucrats even less. :)

As the old saying goes I wouldn't waste the time to Urinate on them if they where on fire but I might consider drinking several gallons of Turps and then urinating on them as they burnt. :D

At least Doctors are sort of necessary but the Bureaucrats are a waste of time and effort as I just hate them. I still remember one Doctor asking quite Sarcastically why it was that I thought I had hurt myself when I attended a Emergency Clinic after being knocked off a Motorcycle and I just took off my shirt and pointed to a large protrusion out of one side of my back that wasn't there previously and said that wasn't there before and I can not raise my left arm up without pain.

Or the doctor who insisted that I only had an upset stomach when I attended a Hospital so he pumped in 1 pint of Saline and sent me home so I called my local GP who immediately ordered an emergency Ultra Sound and then I was rushed back to the same hospital with an infected Gall Bladder about to burst apparently being 18 hours latter the same Doctor was on duty and after my wife had finished with him he disappeared never to be seen again. :^O

And they are only some the of good experiences that I've had with Medical Doctors the bad ones if I where to waste the time to try to list them would require several days to type in and most likely kill this workstation the Internet and TR's servers as I uploaded the message. :D

Col ]:)

by levannah44

I had a little think about this one, Col, because I know for certain SB isn't hereditary in our family. However, there's a lot to be said for the food connection. Too much, too little or just plain wrong!

A few years ago -- I'm just assuming you were born in the late fifties or early sixties, Col (geez, aren't I kind??) -- we simply had no idea of what some foods did to us, especially for pregnant women.

And then you've got to remember that funny little whatsit -- I've forgotten the proper name -- when expectant women have these weird cravings. Well, they could be for foods that are absolutely NOT ON for women in that condition, except back then, no-one would really have known.

After all, time was when it was thought that Downs might be hereditary too. Now it's been pinned (mostly) on older women getting pregnant for the first time and something goes wrong with the chromosomes and an extra one turns up.

It's no-one's fault unless you like to point to the age of the mother. But then, a lot of women, especially these days, put off having kids for as long as possible so they can party while they're young and leave the responsibilities of parenthood until they're older.

Where do you draw the line? For that matter, how do you draw it? No woman is ever going to be told when she can have her kids, believe me! Not even by her partner! Even in China, with its strict one child policy, it's still left up to the woman (and her partner) to decide WHEN they want to have that one child.

So we're left with a bit of a prickly problem. If any of these defects/deformities are or can be put down to say, a woman's age or what she's eating at that age, there's no way you can tell a woman straight out to have her kids early to avoid these malformations. It just doesn't work like that.

In a way, it's a bit like smoking. We all know the risks of either direct or passive smoking, but it's up to an individual whether they actually quit or not.

Same goes for women having kids. They know the risks age and/or certain foods can have now, but you can't stop them getting pregnant after forty, or not eating what could be dangerous foods in their condition.

Women still smoke, drink, take drugs and drink gallons of coffee when they're pregnant; I guess it's the old attitude of 'it can't happen to me' (or my baby, in this case) but it still goes on.

The answer's education, lots of it. Except even that doesn't necessarily work. Maybe there's no answer. Maybe we'll just go on being our stupid selves, waiting for elective cloning to come on the market and fix the defect then.

Humans can be so blinkered sometimes!

Gret

by hal 9000

I wouldn't dare as my life wouldn't be worth living she would probably trash my house that I let her live in. :^O

But it is a sign of the times the way some people think that they should behave and how they can if not force someone into doing something hold them legally responsible for the results. I think it's stupid unless there was direct negligence involved which in this case there wasn't.

You where nearly right with the late 50 's though only a couple of years late there but I'm turning 21 this year and I'm sticking to that story. :D

Actually My mother was 26 when I was born and then 18 months latter she had another son who died in the late 80's and then 11 years latter when Dad was 64 she had a girl who is perfectly healthy it's sickening really even her 3 kids now are all healthy and other than one of them asking for "Boiled Baby" for tea one night when I was over there they seem normal. I thought it was funny as the youngest was only about 3 months old but she took a very dim view of the whole request. :D

Col ]:)

by robpellucid

Back in Mary Shelley's day the newest science that brought fear into the hearts of many was surgery. She illustrated her deapest nightmare in her book Frankenstein. It was feared that surgery would bring a spare parts market where someone would be kidnapped and dissected for their spare parts. This may exist today somewhere, but this practice in minimal. Surgery for the masses is a reality and saves millions of lifes. The genome project will bring us closer as we find out how muc alike we all are. I'm sure that if a child had the choice of a healthy body and mind they would always choose it over the havoc caused bt a defective gene. The person with this freedom of choice is the mother and she does not need any guilt heaped upon her by outsiders. Ultimately no other person has the right to force a choice on another. If you ever come to that day when you must choose, I hope you will have that freedom.

by sleepin'dawg

http://www7.nationalgeographic.com/ngm/0507/index.html

Who is to say where this will take us but the one thing certain, is that if it can be done, someone is going to do it. We can only hope that they are ethical people. An international standard of ethics should be put in place and enforced. The world cannot afford anymore Mengeles. Just because something can be done doesn't mean it should be done. My hope is that if people can come to an agreement on a standard of ethics, it will be derived from scientists and not theologians.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by levannah44

Sorry to have been so long answering, Dawg. Just away investigating some other threads!

Yes, I agree with you, there should be such an ethical body, a world body. And guess what, if we try to get that, everyone will be quarrelling as to who and what the makeup should be, etc.

Just now as the world appears to be dissolving into separate, highly nationalistic factions, such a body would actually require something like a world government. And that's another, quite separate nightmare.

We've already seen how ineffectual the UN (pseudo world government) has been in some of the recent world crises -- no disrespect to them, but they're constantly fighting red tape, vetos and heaven alone knows what else; how much more a 'world government'?

'I wish,' I guess, although somehow, if it comes down to it, it must be the scientists and researchers who have the first, second and third say this time round, not the pollies or the theologians.

Is this some kind of Utopia or Arcadia we're talking about? I like to think it may be the real world we live in, but I'm a cynic from way back!

I guess all we can do is hope -- and wait!

G

This discussion is closed to new replies.