Eugenics: Are we ready for our genetic future?
I have just finished watching a rather disturbing documentary on TV. Some of you may have seen it too, so you'll know why I call it disturbing. It was the final episode of 'DNA', entitled 'The Future', from the good old Beeb in the UK.
Dr James 'Jim' Watson, co-discoverer of the double helix and the genetic bases of our existence seems to be using his name to promote some rather controversial issues.
When DNA was discovered nearly fifty years ago it was considered 'significant', except nobody really knew which direction it was going to take now that we were aware what it was that made us the way we are.
Then came Dolly the sheep, and cloning became feasible, at least in animals. This has been followed by many other experiments in this rather contentious field, bringing it to the point where the cloning of humans may be just around the corner.
Behind the scenes of all this cutting-edge genetic research I discovered tonight, was the shadow of Dr Watson, still working in the field for which he became famous after securing the Nobel Prize back in 1962.
It was Watson who lobbied the US Congress for the money to begin work on 'gene mapping', which, as we now know, ended in the discovery of the complete human genome. I'm pretty sure it was his name that secured the millions -- sorry, billions -- required to undertake this massive project.
As with the discovery of DNA back in the fifties and wondering where it would go from there, so too we now observe this new achievement and wonder the same thing. Or do we?
Dr Watson, apparently, had but one idea about the human genome once it was perfected, and that was eugenics. Now eugenics may make some of you very apprehensive, as it should do if your only knowledge of it comes from the Nazi atrocities used in WWII.
But before jumping to any false conclusions, let's be fair and say that eugenics was also dabbled in a good half century before that by Dr Davenport, who even wrote a book on the subject. His aim was to rid the world of 'feeble-mindedness' by not allowing persons with this affliction to breed.
Now, while we may laugh at this rather quaint attempt to tamper with something that was very little understood at the time, it does raise the prospect -- as Dr Watson very clearly sees right now -- of being able to eradicate many inherited genetic defects so that they will be no more.
To cite one or two examples: haemophilia, cystic fibrosis, breast cancer, depression and some other mental illnesses, all of which are inherited, can be painful, frequently lead to a miserable existence and quite often, an early death; these, and hundreds of other instances, could safely be eradicated from our genetic 'code' and allow previously afflicted families to have happy, healthy children instead.
But would it stop there? Could it stop there? Inherited characteristics are one thing, but what about when things just plain 'go wrong', where there's no family history, and yet an 'imperfect' baby results simply because a gene didn't copy properly or an entire group of genes 'malfunctioned'?
Tests already exist for such 'accidents' as Downe's Syndrome babies, where a genetic mutation results from a slip-up in the copying. The mother can decide to have an abortion if the test proves positive, rather than bring into the world a child not considered to be 'standard'.
But how about conditions such as depression or even schizophrenia, now believed to run in families and therefore have a genetic connection? As the program pointed out, this particular condition was often associated with great creativity, so how would we ever know that we were not aborting a Van Gogh or a Beethoven or even an Einstein?
Worse, if we could actually remove the 'offensive' gene, or group of genes, before procreation, how many unborn artists [of all persuasions] would never see the light of day?
Dr Watson asked his audience 'If we don't play God, who will?', referring, of course, to the future use the human genome project could be put to. Well yes, who will?
Playing God depends so much on who's doing the playing. An ethical doctor, any human being, would no doubt jump at the chance to rid the world of the suffering caused by many inherited genetic defects. There's already enough suffering of other kinds to add unnecessarily to it, so in this respect, eugenics would be very desirable, very beneficial.
But where to draw the line? It would only take another Hitler to turn eugenics into an evil and terrifying program, such as it was seventy years ago. Even a less ethical doctor whose values were perhaps more materialistic, could easily be turned from doing good to doing evil.
Where DO we draw the line? Do we even go down this road at all? Have we already gone too far to turn back? How do we regulate this vast, new field to prevent the Hitlers of history from getting their hands on anything as sensitive as this?
It IS our future. But is our future about to lead us wildly astray?
Gret Racine