Discussion Locked

Ever wonder what determines "top 100 Members"?

0 helpful
120 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Ever wonder what determines "top 100 Members"?
I did the other day when someone told me I was at the Number One slot. Down to Number Three by the time I looked, and the Number one member was someone I had never even heard of before?
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5247-6257-0.html?id=792047

So I go to look at who the "Top Member" is and just what the top member is up to.

Never posted in a discussion?
Never posted in a TQ&A?

How is this the Numero Uno Member?

Oh, because he linked to a bunch of short external blogs?

Well, Ok, lets see what he has to say in the external blogs. Shoot, they are all between three to five lines long, and none of them are in English. To make matters worse, he looks like one of those "MAC" guys? Oh the humanity...... :D

Well, anyways, Congrats [b]ernestoe[/b] of Miami Florida on obtaining the Number One member rating for TR! Somehow I had expected something different from the #1. Ah well. B-)

120 replies

by dr dij

maybe you could creep him out by putting him on your contact list, so he knows you're a stalker.

If he annoys you, the new law lets you put him in jail. I'm sure Max would spring for baloney sandwiches and a cot in a tent in AZ desert for him for the rest of his life.

I noticed that some question askers would give ridiculous amounts of points with made up questions to become '#1'. Oh well, does it really matter? Their bogusness will show up somehow. I'm sure my karma will run over their dogma someday..

Did you know why the average driver in Miami is looking distracted at a stoplight?
his pitbull just knocked his cocaine onto his sub-machine gun :)

by jdclyde

it was because they forgot they were driving? :D

florida = OLD :^O

I actually did had him as a contact to see what he had to say as "#1" before I realized all he was doing was pulling in external one liners that I couldn't even read.

I just thought it was interesting on just what it is that determines your "ranking". It seems it is weighted in favor of blogging, as that must be where they want people to focus?

Giving away points, that is like in the old daze when I used to work in a gas station. Some stations had started putting in those air pumps that you had to pump quarters into for them to run.

People would come in and ask "Do you have free air"?

My relpy was always "Sure! Breath all you want!" :D

Your Karma doesn't seem to be holding it's own though. For your karma to raise you up the ranking, does that mean someone elses karma has to fade or yours just wins out?

Either way, #76 is respectable.... (cough cough, choke choke, snicker snicker....) :D

by dr dij

Wow, didn't even realize they had such a thing, had to search for it. Well.. I go for quality over quantity, but..

my website at one point was #542,376 most linked to or visited site (forget which). I better not give you the site, don't want the rankings to go up :)

I am however on top (no pun intended) with my gal, am #1. All I need.. (not meant to rub in your divorce ..)

by stargazerr

slipping down the top 100 .. The sales guys are being more annoying than usual...

But I ahve never really found out what makes the top 100 ... There was a time when I had no idea who the top 6 guys were .. except you when you were at #3 ...

What do you think will be more effective to get a better standing?? My Tank or my swiss account?? ;)

]:)

by mickster269

All the bribes I have been sending to "The Trivia Geek" via paypal didn't give me a better standing???

Next thing you are gonna tell me is that he really DOESN'T have $17 million in an off-shore account that he quietly wants moved to the USA, and all those checks I have been cashing for him are bogus.

Rats.

by jdclyde

out of Smorty!

How else can he finance his play room and all the toys in it? :O

I still want to try the "hack your couch"! :D

by jdclyde

but I don't have a good answer for you.

I don't even look at it, and had even forgot it even existed until someone told me congrats for being #1, so I had to go out and see what they were talking about.

I then figured this MIGHT be a good source for finding new information by watching the top members and was just surprised to see what the current #1 had to say and how they got that way.

I then found that looking at this list will NOT lead me to better information.

Thought it WAS interesting though, which is why I posted. Is that an acceptable answer?

I don't worry about site rankings or the tech points as I see that neither have any value.

by master3bs

I like getting tech points, because some day I will probably have some questions I need answered. Actually, I've asked two questions and without answering others my tech points bank would be going dry.

by m_a_r_k

The index is called Site Activity Rating. The score depends on what they call "activity". I used to think it was simply discussion postings. Since you brought this up about ol' Ernestoe, it looks like it has to be measured by something else. Maybe it's just the number of times you access any TR web page. Do we have any volunteers to sit at home one day and click Refresh over and over and over again to see if your Site Activity Rating shoots to #1?

Hmm...I wonder if all those double posts counted towards our Activity Rating? No wonder I went from #30 to #15 in a matter of days.

by master3bs

I've gone up and down the activity scale since my time here; and I've seen it affected by discussions, blogs, and tech answers. I believe (but haven't tested) that it is also effected by posting comments on other people's blogs as well.

Its pretty much any kind of activity that leaves a trace here.

by wojnar

Which, of course would be you ! And then you get to pick number 2 right ?????

Oh, you don't pick number 2 ?

Well it still looks good on the resume to have been a number 1 ranked member.

Congrats on the bronze !

by jdclyde

that make me look big! :D (how is THAT for an acceptance speech?) ;\

Thought provoking? Glad you think so. :D

Others just call it "argumenative"! :O

by faradhi

I think if I said the sky is blue, you would say that is just a lie propagated by the liberal media and that president bush is going to make it green.

by dr dij

This guy is #1 and has no postings, no Q&A, etc.

Seems he has the 'Fonz' touch. Must be because he is a Mac person.

They don't have to worry about if we're supporting a bunch of welfare cheats. (I think they do worry about war in Iraq occasionally)

They just 'create' or dance in jet black clothes in silloutte to iPod tunes all day.

Plus he speaks Spanish. He's opening up TR to the Latino community. Can you say 'Senorita caliente'?

:)

by wojnar

you are now officially listed as number 2 ! (I will wait for the applause to die down)

Are there any Chads out there who are still dangling ? The supreme court is next !

by jardinier

was to reach 20+ K tech points (some answers, mostly legitimate questions) so that the little box beside my name in discussions would say 20K.

Alas I have achieved my goal but still I am only accredited (in the little box) with 10 K. Now where's the justice in that?

by jdclyde

don't confuse me being argumenative with you being wrong! :O

What do you have against green anyways? You some kind of commie? :D

by jdclyde

I think because Mac "users" have been discriminated against because of their lack of technical knowledge, that they get a weighted average to compensate for said lack of tech knowledge! :D

I think they also get bonus points because MACs are just so dang cute! If they ever have a good sale at Toys-R-Us, I just may have to get myself one!

"Speedy likes my seester".
"Speedy likes EeeeVERYBODYS seester"!

by jaqui

not to me. I can't stand the look of them.

why can't they come with a nice rectangular case that will easily fit into a cupboard instead of these space wasting curved cases?

most workstation desks have a cupboard that will hold any case, but a mac.

by jdclyde

I had to find SOMETHING nice to say about them and that was all I could come up with! :D

We could talk about what a value they are, but that would blow what little credibility I have left! :O

Cute. Poorly thought out maybe, but I will have to stay with cute until I can come up with anything else nice to say. ;\

by dr dij

There's now a company (adamo or something?) that makes a PC size and look of mini-mac.

My brother has a mac square thing in translucent and blue case, along with a huge mac mon, also translucent plexi and blue. Looks very cool.

Like something the Taelons from EFC went 'poof' and materialized with nanobots and a transdimensional gate.

And he has it out on a back porch work area (enclosed) with lots of windoze. Surprised it hasn't "walked off" yet but they live in a real mellow area.

by jardinier

A couple of years ago when I was heavily into learning about computers in general, I acquired various models of Macs just to learn about them.

When the iMac was first released I was very scornful. I likened it to either a children's toy or something that had fallen out of a UFO.

I soon satisfied myself that Macs are LESS user friendly than Windows.

But which is my favourite computer now? Yep, my iMac because it is space efficient and contains computer and monitor in a single easily portable unit with a built-in carrying handle.

I only use the thing to play Scrabble on because for some unknown reason Scrabble was released (by Hasbro) for Macs a long time before they released a Windows version.

by jdclyde

they have this new invention called a "laptop", and it fits on your lap. It even has a monitor built in for a single easily protable unit. most even come with a CASE which has a "handle"!

I know this must all come as quite a shock, but all those "new fangled" toys change all the time! :D

by jaqui

would point out that they do have good quality hardware.

just real badly designed cases.

I'll leave the corruption of the os that requires a complete port of a unix app to get it to run on a mac alone.

by shellbot

JD, I am thoroughly shocked at your flippant remark. *Cute*
Kittens, baby bunnies, little girls with ribbons in thier hair..now thats cute..

Macs are not. They are colorful because graphic artists use them (admittedly they are powerful for graphics) and they want pretty colors and stuff..

i think if i go any further i may be labeled annoying and then i'll be sued and my life will be over..*sigh*
so i will leave it at that, and please JD, next time consider the rest of us when passing judgement items such as Macs.

*won't somebody think of the children*

by dmambo

Aussies should be penalized points as an affirmative action step to help out those of us who are "challenged" by being too close to the late end of the International Date Line. It's not our fault that we can't post until after they get a crack at the discussions. I mean I'll post this around 8:00AM EST, but it'll already be tomorrow there, so they will have had 12 to 16 hours to reply before I even hit the submit button. People in the warm climates, especially the south and southwest US, should be penalized because they can type faster when they're not shivering.

Men should be awarded bonus points to make up for the handicap of not being as smart as women. Parents should have added points for not being as smart as their kids. I base these two on what evidence I'm able to gather at home.

People who visit TR while primarily at work should be awarded bonuses for the stress of looking busy madly working at their keyboards, while in reality getting farther and farther behind in their work.

I'm sure there are other handicaps to overcome, but these are the major ones. I'll leave it to others to develop the working formulas.

by jdclyde

If I walk with a limp?

Now the people that need to be penalized are the people in the Pacific time zone that STEAL other peoples last/first post of the year!

No whips though, because this is suppose to be a punishment, not a reward! :O

I know. Jaqui will have to wear all WHITE for a week! What is that? oh, never mind. ACLU on the phone saying that is classified as "cruel to an unusual person". :^O I tried to explain that Canucks aren't classified as "persons" so it was alright, but the didn't buy it! :(

There has to be a way!

by dmambo

If you walk with a limp what? It doesn't matter what's limp, that would only give you more time for posting, so that costs you points.

by maxwell edison

.
It's terrible when those Aussies are already in tomorrow while I'm stuck in today, and my to-do list puts me in yesterday.

I once had one of my comments answered by Colin before I even posted the silly thing! Now tell me, is that fair?

by nz_justice

quite a few bouns points, my work is really pilling up and all I seem to be able to do is waste time at the TR (helps my site rating).

by jdclyde

is why your only 10th.

Time at TR is INVESTED, not wasted! 10 lashings for member #10!

( Hee hee, he said mamber....)

by jdclyde

Jay likes CASH! Cold Cash = favorable rankings.

I must have been late on my last payment! ;\

by Jay Garmon

The more evil, the higher the ranking.

Seriously, we're working (I know you get tired of hearing this; we get tired of saying it) on an improved recognition system. We stole the old one from Gamespot, and it proved inadequate. We'll probably steal the new one from Xbox Live. We'll keep you updated on the reverse engineering...er, development efforts.

by jamesrl

Posters who support their friends at Tech Republic with technical info.....

But seriously....I don't start a lot of discussions, but those that do - extra recognition.

James

by jdclyde

not serious ideas!

Well, now that you opened that can of worms, I think people that[b] answer TQ&A's [/b]should be rated the highest.

Second would be people that start discussions that go over 30 posts from at least 5 people. (to head off someone just starting 50 discussions, all liked to external blogs, four lines each! : ) )

Active bloggers of VALUE should be third.

Then the people that post in discussions would be fourth.

I would not put value on people that POST TQ&A's as they are asking for something, not giving something.

by jdclyde

about blogs being weighted higher? The only thing I could see.

Well, that or you really are performing affirmative action for MAC users out of sympathy? :D

I know it is off-character, but I will be serious for a minute here. I don't care that I wasn't number one, I was just bummed that for a minute I thought I had found a new way to get good information as the sites "number one" poster would HAVE to have something good to say? Imagine my surprise when I saw what I saw. Link-o-rama to all external two sentence blogs is our number one member. Can you say "disappointment"? I did.

by shellbot

ya know the music that plays when Darth Vader is in the scene ?
thats been in my head ALL FRIGGIN DAY

i think its actually given me a headache.. :(

by jaqui

then Oz and I should be swapping number one and two positions in the list..

by jdclyde

how else would you explain not knowing how to post a link? :O (oh my.....)

Now THAT is comedy! That is just PERFECT! What a wonderful start to my day to see that!

As for Shell, hey I was just TRYING to be NICE! ;\

The more accurate words are all on the banned list of TR and my entire post would be #### ## ###### #!

Besides, everyone has fun with the M$ bashing and I thought that the MAC guys might be feeling left out as they are NEVER found in the war of the desktop discussions, even though they have been sitting in their trendy corners with overpriced boxes on their trendy desks, drinking their trendy overpriced coffee and bagles! :^O

Life is good.

Now if mjwx would repost a link that works AND change "his"(?) name to something I can pronounce (even if it isn't as "trendy")! B-)

It is good to be me!

by jdclyde

I call MAC's "cute" and I get ridiculed after decades of them making many mistakes over and over.

YOU start up on Florida which has only done ONE thing poorly and that is just fine and dandy?

Where is the justice in the world?

I have to go post 20 one word blogs to go boost my rating now..... ;\

by shellbot

that JD secretly likes Macs.
:)

I know I'm very bad to stir up trouble like this, but out of boredom i have no other choice!

*is it blue or green?*

by jdclyde

A wee bit of trouble ye be a stur'en is ye? :D

Off to the basement then! A flogging is in order! ]:)

(nice to see you out again Shell! :x )

by jdclyde

recompiles the list in "off hours" accourding to EST? :D

Never paid attention to that one before, so not sure how often it does change.

It also appears that while annoying, my posts aren't evil enough to put me over the top!

by jaqui

to those asking?

no, give value, when they actually rate and close a question, awarding points in the process.

for every question not closed they lose points..on a daily basis..say 100 points for every day the question is open... with the points going to whoever correctly answered the question.

by jdclyde

I stand corrected!

Forgot to reward people considerate enough to close them, and penalize the baustards that are too self centered to be BOTHERED to do so.

I like the idea of a top 10 WORST members showing up for people with the worst records of not closing and rating questions! THAT is a list we could get use out of!

by jardinier

all those in favour raise your hands? Motion carried.

I used to answer some questions but gave up because TheChas always got in first. These days it is mostly Hal.

However here is my personal record of questions answered.

Number of answers given: 27
Number of answers accepted: 7 (25%)
Number of answers rejected: 2 (7%)
Number of answers not rated: 18 (66%)

Need I say more?

by cactus pete

Are you following this line in the discussion? Can we get some statistics about the average percentages of the answers rated, not rated, etc? And while you're at it, through in the medians. I'm always fascinated by the differences (or not) between the two.

by jdclyde

for how often I am told I am full of sh!t, being number two has a poetic justice to it! :D

by jdclyde

I was trying to see it better yesterday, but had forgotten my glasses and things were a little out of focus!

Very nice detail.

Is it a self portrate for a model or not based on anyone you know?

Oh, and thanks to that pic, I don't have that "limp" problem anymore! ]:)

by jaqui

"Vicky" a 100% cg person.

Daz3D's "Millenium Woman" figure.
for Poser [ Digital Barbie Dolls ]

She actually made the image to resemble me facially and overall size. [ if I had a bust like that I would be playing with myself ]:) ]

My wife modelled and textured the dress herself, creating the mesh and textures for it.
the belt and jewellry are part of a set from another modeller.

by jdclyde

should have been a little COLDER in the room when the dress was modelled! ]:)

The arm band is sweet!

So when you go in drag, that is what you look like? :O

by maecuff

You do realize that..well, never mind. It's too much to try and understand. You aren't limp. The picture looks mostly female, but it's based on Jaqui..so...the perfect person for you would be half and half??

There are things about you we wouldn't understand, things we couldn't understand, things we shouldn't understand.. (having a PeeWee's Big Adventure flashback..)

by jdclyde

it is too depressing to think that we have 100 scumbags as members. X-(

Funny. Got myself and "earwig" going in my head today, Nymphetamine, by Cradle of Filth. Too funny! Putting on some "Fates Warning" to replace it.

by shellbot

you know how that kinda talk effects me ;)

by the way, i picture you with a green one !

ha ha :)

Ya, i been workin like the proverbial dog..so thought i'd come up for air. Hopefully i am back on the TR scene now as i am adopting a "you don't pay me near enough cash to have me working that hard" attitude form today onwards! -

by jdclyde

traffic generation.

I would think someone that draws in a lot of readers should also get a "leg up". It is becoming clear that there are many people that come and read but don't feel they have something to add so they don't. Or at least not until something comes along and pulls them off the fence.

Traffic generation for blogs and discussions would be a cool thing to see. HOT discussions are ones that get read a lot and are a big draw as well as the onces with lots of postings.

by jdclyde

you have to go home and watch the first Star Wars movie tonight! Love that show. None of the others caught the same "magic" as that one.

The funny thing about mine is 98% of the members here would have never even heard of it! It has replaced the one I had last week by Korn, "love song". Cool songs!

Baa baa baa, baa ba baa ba ba baa
"I thought I recognised your stentch when I was brought on board."

by stargazerr

And flapped their hands over their ears before it managed to reach their brain ....

There we go ... Damn, It works through the eyes too ...

]:)

by jaqui

8) <- stunned look emoticon

I refuse to answer that question....

on the grounds of you may get all hot 'n bothered. ]:)

by jdclyde

HEY! I didn't know it was a dude until AFTER!

I didn't look to see if there was an adams apple!

That is false advertising!

(and after finding out that "dude looks like a lady", peewee and limp are both words that fit!)

Because NO! I am NOT looking for someone that can "give as good as they take"! :O Exit only! I LIKE GIRLS!!!!

Can't we go back to picking on Lobo instead?

by jdclyde

I posted a blog about posting a blog. :D

It is a crazy thing, aye?

Didn't realize this was the list you had meant before. I had completely forgotten there WAS such a list until you said it and I went back and looked again. So You were correct, and I stand corrected.

by wojnar

from this thread ! Nothing like stirring the pot to get recognized. (and he CLAIMS he doesn't care) It has all been a big conspiracy to get JD back as number one. He lured us with his tales of seeming improprienty and used us to lauch his star back into the spotlight. (Yes, tongue planted firmly in cheek - don't want the newly all-powerful JD angry with me)

I think I will write about that in my next Polish blog entry ....

As Monty Python put it - "Burn the witch !, Burn the Witch".

by nz_justice

I can't believe it, I've been answering peoples questions trying to help them out in the tech Q & A, starting random threads in the discussion areas (only two so far) and adding my two cents to some threads, and for what, (sarcasm after this point) I?m number 13 oooooohhhhh wow and all I had to do to be number one was post some stinking external blogs. blah I say, I say BLAH.

by jdclyde

oooo, better you than me! Well chicken spawn, I wouldn't step on any cracks or walk under a ladder until your ranking changes one way or the other.

And remember, if a black cat crosses your path it is bad luck and if a black dog crosses your path it is dumb luck! :D

by m_a_r_k

I've never even heard of you, Mr. NZ_Justice! You've only been a member since December. Hey that rhymes! A member since December... And you've made only FOURTEEN posts!!! By the way, don't stop to look over your shoulder because I'm breathing down your neck at #14.

by nz_justice

apparently the secret (but don't tell anyone) is to post blogs from external sites that are in foreign languages to your work space. but you didn't here this from me ;)

by stargazerr

There had to be a trick ... And here I am ... breaking my back to get to #1 ... and when I had nearly made it (got to #6) ... Viruses attack and my computer is snatched away from me ... I am forced to stay in bed, looking longingly at my desk ... Trying to reach out but always managing to miss the desk by an inch ....

Aah .. woe is me ... People who use tricks to get to #1 ... X-( ... Off with their heads ...

]:)

by jaqui

I think I got to #4 once, then I realised that I was getting more emails from TR peers asking questions that were never posted on tr and wanting me to answer them.
so now I'm happy when I'm below the top 10, far less aggravation.

by jaqui

yup, run away from TR for a week, I'll drop down to around 20 then. ]:)

unfortunately, I'll not be able to do that for at least another week, I might actually get up to number 6 or so by then.

by m_a_r_k

I've been trying to drop back down to around #30. I've been stuck in the teens for a while. Why am I so high? It's not because I'm posting blogs from external sites that are in a foreign language. The only foreign languages I know are C++ and C#. And a little bit of Spanish.

by nz_justice

C is spanish for yes. yes? and your 15 at the time I posted this. If you know what objects, and methods are. then you can probably speak, Vb, Python, Java and any other 3GL

by nz_justice

Generating site activity since December 2005. Actual I only started using TR because I had to register to buy books.

by jamesrl

Yes occasionally I get a pleasant note from one of my peers here.

But often I get a) SPAM, b) requests for such detailled and information that it should be billable or c) stupid comments.

I have yet to get a picture of any of my peers, unlike some of my peers. Let me be clear, my curiousity only really extends to the fairer sex.

James

by jdclyde

to be you! :D

Sure, I get an occasional spam (see scumbag post) and even a few "do my work for me" mails. But most is from my adoring fans! :^O

And James, Pics? A few, and ALL of the VERY fair sex! Woo woo! B-)

It is great being me! ;\

by jdclyde

Number of answers given: 64
Number of answers accepted: 16 (25%)
Number of answers rejected: 12 (18%)
Number of answers not rated: 36 (56%)

Note about the "rejected". The majority are from being a smarts$$ to people that were under chastisement for poor posting, or a complete disregard for closing Q&A's.
A few examples:
http://tinyurl.com/do8xu
http://tinyurl.com/a2t4u

Cool that the accept percentage is the same. :D